 ׺ 2-840
ԭĳйѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200102
ԭҳš166177
  šD7
  
ӡںš200106
    尲ȫȨơϵݱ
    ѧ
߼顿ѧã1968ѧʿϺֶĸ뷢չоԺооԱ
Ҫʷÿϵ仯ʱڷս£尲ȫ˼ͻȨƵӰͻ
µϵȶԺȨ˼˹̨սԺһ¶Ϲ˵
ȨƶõҲڼǿ20͵ĹηչʷǼ尲ȫȨϵ桢໥໥ӰĹ
˽ͷ֮Ĺϵʶϵķչݱ䡣
  ʡ/尲ȫ/Ȩ
    
    20ͳ尲ȫ۵õʵȨڹеìܺͳͻһֱڣʸַתʱڸԵر
ͻ͵Ϊѷʼ尲ȫĳͼԱȾϵ尲ȫ¶壬˵ĽԾϵԷֹսΪ
ģڶսıȴ¶尲ȫܱ֤Ұȫ㣨עInis Claude,Power and International Relations,New Y
ork,Random House,1962,p.111.սڼ䣬Ȩ״̬Ϲ尲ȫʽϹΪƶʵ˵
ϵڹʹϵоλսĽϹںսеʤ尲ȫϵĸ˴⣬֮
ıֿʼ˶ɥʧġ尲ȫȨ֮ĳͻԶûнⳡͻһڵʷ̡
    尲ȫϵȨϵ֮ͬ
    Ϊȫʶϵ֮ĹϵжϹʰȫϵķչƣбҪŪ֮ʲôͬͲ֮ͬ
    һάҰȫϵڵĸԴĿ
    ȨǴͳʵѧɵĺ֮һͳʵΪȨǹжߵֱӺռĿ꣬Ҳ
ҲΪȨƶġ˹Ħ(Hans Morgenthau)ΪμǿȨΪ˼жġעĦ
ۡ뱾Ϻĳ1995棬4ҳǡɹֹ֮κһǿвҵĶ
ɹ֮ȵʵ״̬ͬƽ˵ĳеֵƽһעĦݺۡ
265ҳ
    ĦȨǹҶΪľأȨֶΣĿģˣĵֻԼȨǿھУҶ
ΪߺĿľƽȨάֹϵȶ͹İȫĦͬǣʵۼҿ˼
(Kenneth Waltz)ȨһпʹõֶΣȨ̫̫СзգĵǰȫȨ״̬µĹ
ιϵҲ⡣
    ˼Ϊ۴˼ϵĻң˷ֻҪķʶơȣϵͳв
ϵͳйҶ͹ΪǲȷġڶƲǸԾάһƽ״̬һȻ״̬ƲƳġ
ۻشһ⣬ǶԹĳ¼Ľ͡ģȨϵ£ĵĲȨ
ǰȫһҵ쵼ƶ߷ǳҪע˼ȣۡ뱾й񹫰ѧ1
992棬2ҳȴӾ໥Ͱȫṹ˵Ʊȶ༫ƸԽԡΪߣĦ
˶Թ׷ĿֲͬǵĹͬǣ֮Ա˴˵Ƕɵģұʱע⡰ʵв򡰿ܵв
иֶӦвѳΪĻʽ໥ϵڽ״̬Ϊѭɲ˴˵ӡܾ
䱾ԶԣǲԸ໥ɺ͵жԡҲÿǷԣϽǵΪ˾ơ
ע˼ȣۡ3ҳ֡ȫȨƲĸԴͽ
    80˹ٷҡ(Stephen M.Walt)һչ˳ͬƽȨľƸѾ͵ľ۴һЩµ
ӷҽ˵ĸԴָ֣Ѱ˹Ϊƽ⡰ȨΪƽ⡰вˣвۡ(balance 
of threat theory)ȡȨۡ˵עStephen M.Walt,The Origins of Alliances,Ithaca,Cornell University Pres
s,1987صĹ۵뻪Щƣܻûнȫƽ⡰вҲȷѡƽвǡȫ
ҪȻ˵Ŀһµġ
    սҪԴҰȫĳͻνʶ̬ͻ˵Ȩ˵վǹҰȫͻĲֻͬͶѡ70
ڹͬĹҰȫҪϵʵвʵսԺĻ˲ƻǶ༫ƣҰȫǵ
һλġ
    尲ȫͬˡԼеһ仰ǡԼΪٽʺ֤ʵĺƽ밲ȫеս񡱡Ϲ
¿żɽָҲ֮սάֹʺƽ밲ȫϹľģעй
ڹԼԷȱࡶִʹϵʷѡϲᣬѧ1987棬55-61ҳйϹ
ݵࡶϹ̡ѧԺ1993棬¼һˣǲҪʣΪ
ĹҰȫĸּ֧尲ȫ֯أΪάԱİȫܵõ֧أ
    ھƲܱ֤Ұȫвǽȫϣڼ尲ȫϵڼ尲ȫϵУԽҰȫǷ
ϹߵλʵǣҪĶԱӰ졢𺦱ξúͰȫ棬пܼĳʱά
ͬȫжһƴﵽпΣĳ̶ʱͳѡСˣǿ
ҲĪ⡣עۣۡϺ1995棬393-394ҳʵϣȨƻǼ尲ȫ
ΪһϵһߣĿһµģάҰȫԱȫȨƺͼ尲ȫĹͬ㡣
    Ȩϵ뼯尲ȫϵԷĻΪģ
    ʵ߿ȨƼȶϵ״ֹսЧֶΣһ֡ʵʴڵ״̬ɹ֮ǿȨ
ƽȵʵ̬עĦݺۡ223ҳһȻγɵḶ́ǰһǹᴦ
״̬ǹɲͬȨɵϵ״̬ڲһȶԣʹϵںƽ״̬һ
ĳһⲿһϵֻҪ˱仯¾ʧϵʾؽԭȷ¾ơעĦ
ݺۡ223ҳϵһӾƵǾٵƵĲѭḶ́ҲһȶٵȶĹ̡
̺״̬£κȨҶ⣬ǲʲôֶΡﵽʲôĿģҲԶѲġȦҪôֱӶԿ
ľƣҪô뾺͵ľƣעʵ۵㣬¿ԽִʹϵʷΪͬľƺͷǾƽ׶Ρһ׶Σ
1648˹طԼսٵ1815άҲϵһơǾơƵḶ́ڶ׶ΣάҲϵĽ191
4-1945սıٵŶϵγɣһơǾơƵḶ́սڼ伴ʹžƣҲ
Ϊݺʹģܿͱսƣڵ׶УսĽ½͵ϵ׽壬ת䲢ͨ
սʵֵģͨƽת䡣ĿǰµľǷѾѧкܴ顣
    ȨƲͬ尲ȫϵͼı״̬尲ȫȨڵΣԼβпս
Ƴġ尲ȫΪȨǹҼάƽһȻϵٲȷġϣϵҪĽǾӺ⽻
ǶߵĳԹߡ֮£尲ȫϵǴģҪһΪάƽ֯ҼĹ֯ע
Gabriel L.Negretto,"Kant and Illusion of Collective Security",Journal of International Affairs,Vol.46,No.2,Winter1993,p.513.
˺Ϲڱսʹ࣬Ծƴʧ½ġʱǵδкܴھϵ
СͬõӣǴǿȨʵȫĹߡСҵİȫʱܵʱҪܵµвǵ
ȫڴСƺʵ尲ȫڣСҴȨƵΣվнųΪ˸ıΡ
桱һҪСһ֤СҺǿͬȵĻȨǵĹҰȫںʹ
İȫͬҪĵλ͵Ϊ尲ȫһ֯ϵ(an organized system)ϵγĶԱȣעInis C
laude,Power and International Relations,p.113.˵ϵԶԷγɵĻô尲ȫΪƲ

    ϵе⼰Բ
    ʵСһȨҹɵģһЩ㹻ǿвĹңƺͼ尲ȫϵһЩ
ҵĲ⡣ǰǿԹĲΣǿԹߺͼĲΡ͵ָǰʵǡ˭̫ǿˡ(
Who is too strong)ʵǡ˭ˡ(Who commitsaggression)˵ľʵεĹϵ⣨עInis Claude,Powe
r and International Relations,p.124.ȨϵµġȫԴڶԹʵĲΣϹԸ˵ĳ
ҪΪڼ尲ȫϵ¹ỳ˵Ķͼ
    ŷйΪҡƽгҪĿꡣйʵĲǿйв֮ۡ磬
ǵйǿսİȨλʶ̬Ҷйͼδʵ֣תйΪһΡ
ҵ߸ֲڶйʵĲΣԼйδĻɡйĲǾϵ¹֮໥̬ȵ
һ־֡
    ȻϵҲעԹߺͼĲΡ磬ABԿCΪǱCΪCǿ󣬿
ǵвABǿǿεģΪ໥ֶ֧Էߺͼ磬ս¶尲ȫͬ˾й
ͼձձߺͼ໥ģйʵʾɡ
    ʵʣھϵ£һ߻ͼĲλΣԼĶֻѰԵġ
    Ϊ˰ȫΪȨƽ⡰Ȩƽ⡰вҪҲȡֶһģǾǲȡƽ⡱ߡֻ
ˣάֹϵ״ҰȫвǿԼͰȫС
    尲ȫͬ尲ȫγǻڶԹߺͼĲΣǹ˻Ϲδĳһ׳󿴳Ƕһ
в尲ȫв涨ǸӦǿӦΩֳԱȡԵߡϹΪ
ΪΣյĹң˵ǿĹңʺ˵ȹȴΣյĹңΪΪЩҾжԺŵ
ͼߡ90ĺս޿ɱ粵֤֮һ˵Ϲĳ̶ֳܵĳЩĲݡʵȹʵӢȹ
ȻᲢۣһֱܵϹĹעؼڶԹҵߺͼʶͬ˵ȹĶߺͼĲ
尲ȫ֯ԳԱ̬ȵһֱ֡
    ڹʺƽ밲ȫԼϹ¶Ĺ涨ҪԱеսعʹ֮涨ع
ԺƽʽˣΪָȷķ򲢹涨ĿΪ˶ߡĳԱͼѾȡ
ߵ£尲ȫ֯ȡӦΡƲõǿֶθıߡ
    80սڼ䣬ϹΪı໥ӺͶԿߣֹսͽս˺ܴŬϹ
ͻȺͨ˶飬19877°һͨĵ598žʹͣսش塣19908¡19912ºΣͺ
սڼ䣬ϹΪı˵߲ȡѸ١ʱĴʩȺͨ12飬аʹǿ
ıߵ678ž顣սϹľֶθıһߵһͷ
    Ȼ˻ʣսϹ˵Ʋôʩּȫ˾ڵĴģɱĺ˲жϼǿ
Ʋ÷ΧⲻҪ״ݻ˵ľʵ𣿼ȻѾıԿصߣΪʲôҪȡһ
ʩľʵأЩ˼尲ȫҪǲòǾأںΣͺսУΪ׵
ϹŲȡжµ⣺ζԴսгֵϹἰᱻܿյжǷԽ˰
ȨķΧδü尲ȫعȨĹϵ⣿ȵȡЩڼ尲ȫϵ³ֵġ֮
ںսг䵱ȷ桱ҪǵںưԽԶƵĺ˿˺ʯԴڿסǵ
ںսԵλܵϾսƽ⣬ӾõĶ档尲ȫг־ʱ
ڽ˹Ҳս£һһʵ⿴Ǽ尲ȫȱݣȴǾƴĻˡڼ
ȫϵ£ڲλһʵ˵ʵɳذʵҲԵ˻˹Ѻù
Եġ
    Ȩǿƽʵߣ尲ȫǿıߵߡߵĶԲȻͬĿһµģν;ͬ顱

    ģȨϵ뼯尲ȫϵ
    ھϵ£ΪάԵİȫ໥໥ԿۼĦƷΪҪʽһֱӶԿָͣ
ֱӶԿΪֱӶԿ뷴ֶԿԾƵص㡣һǾԾƣָԵ
ᴦƽ״̬Ȼ״̬ȶĶȻܹõά֣עڶԿԾƺ;ԾƵɲμĦ
ݺۡ228-234ҳ
    ƱĹȶйعҵĹϵͨ롱Ǿ״̬ĳ֡״̬ǼȶģʱбƵĿܡ
һ־ƣƽһ˶пĳһʱڵĳһʹΣաʵʣֱӶԿԾƺ;Ծǿ໥ת
ģ໥͸ġ״̬ʱABϵ񻯣CҲ⣬ڶCΪȴ״ĳһ
ƷձֻսǰԳʵֳͳΣ˹¹1938̲µ֫ݿ˹工ˣ60Խϣ1979ְ
ֱӶԿԾʱȱΪԾƣߺܿݱǰߡƵΣԻϱΪйعҵĹҰȫΣԺ
ԣǾϵȱݡ
    ϵͼ尲ȫϵʶͬκεսκιҶΣյ𣿡κιάϴ
Źͬ沢Ҫȫ𣿡ھϵУĵֻԼİȫǷܵ𺦣ʳͻԼԵк
ֹ֧ʳͻǴٽͼǿԼȫλһֶΣ²ؼ򡰸߸߹𡱡尲ȫϵͬΪ
Ұȫ໥ģÿһӦ뵽κһķսȥȫǵһλġΪֻԼİȫΣʱһż
뷴ߵУ尲ȫΪκһ˵κεԶвİȫ
    ھϵ£ȨҶǷ֧ܺӦѡɣڼ尲ȫϵ£Ӧȫ̷սӦޱ֧սܺ
ߡԼϹ¶涨սߵİ취ʹʩҲ۹˺ϹеЩʵЧ
˵˼尲ȫǺԵġЭԵģڱϵǲͬġ
    ȻǲܺӾϵаҼ䰲ȫأ尲ȫϵдڹҼͻʵߺ߶
ʺǿܵģҴڹεʵУǶԹǷڿչֲͬʵΪڹ
״̬£ʺȻǿܵģֺʵ֡ά֡ʵעDavid Baldwin,"Neoliberalism,Neor
ealism and World Politics"and Robert O.Keohane,"Institutional Theory and the Realist Challenge After the Cold War"in David Ba
ldvin ed.,Neorealism and Neoliberalism:the Contemporary Debates,New York,Columbia University Press,pp.4-5.ƶ(
Neoliberal-institutionalism)߷ֿһ棬ͬʵ߹Ĺϵ˹ʺĹ۵㣻һ
Ϊʻ(international institution)״̬й֮ͬĺãʻԴٽҼĽ
ʹǡѰĺԵսԡ(tit for tat strategies)ʺʵ֣ʻԴٽΪҪע
Joseph Grieco,"Understanding the Problems of International Cooperation:the Limits of Neoliberal Institutional and the Futur
e of Realist Theory"in David Baldwin,ed.,Neorealism and Neoliberalism:the ContemporaryDebates,pp.302-303.ɲRobert Keoha
ne & Lisa Martin,"The Promise of Institutionalists Theory";Charles A.Kupchan andClifford A.Kupchan,"The Promise of Collective
 Security";John Ruggie,"The False Promise of Realism",International Security,Vol.20,No.1,Summer 1995,pp.39-51,52-61,62-70

    壩˵Ķʹõֶ
    Ȩϵͼ尲ȫϵڱʽͶҲűʵ
    ھϵУڹҰȫľԺͶԿԣʹϵ˳ͻͶһҳֶαҰȫ⣬˵Ҳ
ձ顣Ϊ˶ԿһһҼţˣ˵Ķţһ׷۹ĿͺԱĶ
һ˵ĵ۹Ǿϵĸ֡עĦݺۡ247-248ҳ
    ȻǶġһҵİȫвСʧʱΪԼ㹻ʵԱٸİȫвʱ
ԭ˶뵽һȥһҪҪʵߣǸԭ⣬ǸȨ⡣һΪԼǿ
ԮΪĸܳõĺôͻرˡעĦݺۡ239ҳ
־ʱԣһ˵ڣ˾ͻ塣ںܶ£˵ĽսĽ19ĩһ
սڼ䣬֮Ľ⽻޳Щ˲ڡս󣬴󲿷սɢʹ
ʱҴҲѲ˽ˡ1902ǩӢͬŴ˥20ӢաĹԼᡣڶսǰ
һսǰ˵ƣսڼԽĶԿϵҲ⡣Ϊ̫ƽƹ塱Ⱥ
֯ˡƹͬԼȫԼȫԼͬԼǼԼȣ̫ƽ
ͬϵŷޣԱԼԿƽΪ׵ĻԼҡǣչϵĻԼսĽЩͬ˲ǽ
ʵ綫ŷԼʶǰвʧΣҳԼڲĻɢǿʹԼ
նޱ˳ʷ̨ܹҪôʷ˱仯Ҫôҵ˴ڵɡµĶֺ͵ˡ
    սӰµںƽսġз족棬սķʧһ˫нǿȫУҲԼӾΣ
УȶϵҲƻʹϵ״
    ھϵһּΪձ֮һصǣԵĶģйͬΣպ͵˽ʹڵ
ǰûĿĽΪǲڵģҲǲܳ־õġӸ˵ϵеͼ(externally-orientedgroupin
gs)֯ԱȡһжĿǶԸĹһҼšעInis Claude,Power and International Relations,p.145.
ԡⲿĵ˻˭ڽ˹ҿԶ׼ģʽս֮ǰҡղ˲κε
ˡ䲻ãҪƭϵУαָΪ硱Ҫôǡ硱Ҫôǡҵ
硱
    ϵĽ˹۽Ȼ෴尲ȫϵΪҲ˻˶Կһ尲ȫйҷйҡ
͵˵˵ġԡǼ尲ȫһҪص㣨עInis Claude,Swords into Plowshares:The Problems and Progress of
 International Organization,New York,Random House,1971,p.160.尲ȫҲһȫˣϵж
ȷ໥Կڱܴһʶ壬ͺ׽ϵȣ尲ȫһȫ(global)ձ
(universal)ˣǽйҰڵĹҼšڹҼˣǾϵµˡ尲ȫǡ˾
ϵеľصģʽǡйұǽǷֳɵжԵļŵϵעInis Claude,Power and I
nternational Relations,p.145.尲ȫ(inneroriented)ĹҼšϵСࡱ磬尲ȫֻСһ
磬йң粻Ƿֳź(we-group and they-group)вԡеһ
ҪҹͬԸעInis Claude,Power and International Relations,p.114.尲ȫĵ˼Ȳ̶Ҳ
ȷģԣ˿ڲκһҡ
    ˵üԵĹĻģսƶ(institutionalist)ʵҲйҵۡǰΪ
尲ȫһֶԸߵĸЧĹƽԴٽҼ籱Լս𵽵Ķв
֯ƽĵעRobert Keohane & Lisa Martin,"The Promise of Institutionalists Theory";Charles Kupcha
n and Clifford Kupchan,"The Promise of Collective Security";John Ruggie,"The False Promise of Realism"ʵ˵
ƶûŪʻ˵е⣬Ϊƶ̸ǡͻ(inner-directed insti
tutions)ֻּڡͽԱڲĳͻʹٽ໥ĺͨӰڲԱĹΪƽġԱ
Խ࣬ƽǰԽã尲ȫһͻĺӡȻƶûпһ֡͡Ĺʻ(out-dire
cted institutions)˲ǹעڳԱάƽҲǴΥ״̬Ϊ塢ǿƻҪܵĿⲿһ
ҼˡһʵΪԼսڼò֤ƶߵĹ۵㣬ʵϣƶĻ½
ʵ۵㡱עJohn J.Mearsheimer,"Back to The Future:Instability in Europe After the Cold War","The False Promise of In
ternational Institutions",International Security,Vol.19,No.3,Winter 1994/1995,pp.5-49."A Realist Reply",International Securit
y,Vol.20,No.1,Summer 1995,pp.82-93.Ҫжʲôڼ尲ȫʲôھϵһ
ģҪŪǵıʽԶ󣬲ȻͻὫ˿Ǽ尲ȫΪ˴άֹʺƽĹ⻷ܼʮ
ѧԽԽʣսһЩ˽ǻһ𣬽һЩ˫߻ߵľ뼯尲ȫϵ
    ⣬ϵͼ尲ȫϵһͬص㣺߶ǽʹþΪﵽĿĵֶΡΪάƽ֤Ա
Ȩַ尲ȫƵļƻȡʵжֹΪھֶεѡϣ⽻
Ʋ⣬ľ´ֶΡʵϵһ尲ȫϵЩѡֶǲѶΪ֮ġս֮ͨ
ﵽԼĿġѵѡھϵ£ʹþֶǺƽ£Ϊ߾װǿ
ԱսձΪǿʵﵽĿġ尲ȫ߾ƵļﵽܵߵĿģͬǣ
岻ǱΪǿԱľʵǾۼĹңԱԽ࣬Խǿйҵľ֮ʹ
һҡ
    尲ȫϵǶȨϵĲͷչ
    ͨ۹ʹϵʷչ̣ʣȨǹʹϵıʽ䲻ܱ֤ʺƽͷֹս
Ѻƽϣڼ尲ȫϣŬ̽ü尲ȫİ취ΪֶΡȻ尲ȫȨƶڡȨȻ
άֺƽ밲ȫҪʽڼ尲ȫϵбֳ
    ȣ尲ȫϵȨϵ෽涼ͬ⣬ʽƵġǼ尲ȫ;ƵĹͬ˵ԭ
ƵģΪ˷ֹԻάҰȫͬǣ˵ʽԭġһһһŶԿһţתΪȫһ
ȫ˶ԸڲκһңĦָܴϽԭΪѱ˵ļ尲ȫԭȡʵϣ
尲ȫδȡơȷе˵尲ȫκǱߵȫ˵ʽ¿϶˾ԭһ˽
ԶʤһߡעĦݺۡ253ҳ͵Ȼϸ˾뼯尲ȫΪ尲ȫעĺ
ȨһģǹȨ⣬ֻ尲ȫϵڹȨĹϱȾƼЩ˵ߵĻһµ
עInis Claude,Power and International Relationsϵʶͻڹ󣬲ֻͨ
ֹֹܷͻ
    Ϲ50ǿع۲쵽֯ķչ߹һϹƶǿܲûԤĵ·Ϲת
˵״һӦǡ尲ȫΪ尲ȫٶɴССɣ֮໥ж˵
Ȩƽ⻷ֹܹδֻ߲У˾жױʵʵ尲ȫζ
Źһ֡ȫһľ棬󽵵߳ɹĿԡȻս尲ȫǵϣһưˮҼ
ŵķչȡ˼尲ȫϵͬڱΪװƽֲƽ⡢սͺĸֲ̬ͬ໥šνġ˹ҡֻ
ܺϣԹۡϵƽġ״ȨĻһһ򱻿Ǽ尲ȫĻǰע
¶ࡤױ˹ֶȨ塪ʹϵѧۡ뱾ĳ1990棬361-362ҳ
    ΣڹʵУǳ֣尲ȫųȨصӰ죬ڼʱʱ̿¾Ƶӡĳ
Ͻ˵ԺϹİǴƵľ廯Ľṹ10ɵԺ4Ϊ¹ӳ
ŷЭľʹҪע¶ࡤױ˹ֶȨ塪ʹϵѧۡ352ҳ
ڸһִͳΡϹһΡͬڰĹ˵ʱʥͬˡ
¹˵ĺģʥͬеʥͬˡעĦݺۡ577590ҳ
    ڼ尲ȫϵУԴƻƽΪ޼ƿʩε״ءڴȷĴ
԰ʱ¶һȫԹ֯ԴʩƲһ㡣ҪһֻȨϵԾ·ʽƲһ
бҪһȫԵսҪԾ÷ʽƲһֿܻЩӦƲõĹɾѣƲɵʧ
ӰҵͶʴ̵޶ڣôЩƲñЧƱشۿۡ󣬽ͷ϶ԴƲãԺ
κʵԵӰ߽𵽴ʹ˳֯á30һЩ˳ʵ֤
    Ϲ尲ȫϵУȨ¹УִľƹϵĦСĳЩ֧
Ź̨Ĵ˹ϵΥʷƻĳ״ĻǱضдںҪʹµ7µļлִ
ʩЧȡڰ᳣¹ֱĶᡣԣں̶ܴµ7ȡõִļл󲿷ֱ273ȡ
עĦݺۡ383-385ҳ
    ڼ尲ȫϵУΪĲþֶҲȨϵСձйڰǣ¹ڰ
ݿ˹工˺ͲԼڷԺжеܣսڼܾڲʹ
һǧɣӶҲ֤ʵʵߵĹ۵㣬ŻֻǼ尲ȫϵµһ־Ʊ֡
    Ƽ尲ȫϵʱǲҪǾϵã򣬾ͻԼ尲ȫûάЧøеʧǷ
ϾƵĴڣϵǿ͹۴ڵģһֱԼż尲ȫЧá
    尲ȫϵǶԾϵĲͷչ尲ȫųƵá˹ݿ(Spykman)ΪһȨҿ
ÿҶԼӵзȨϵָˣһϵʹ尲ȫϵҲΪ
ȫϵǶԾϵġĽȡϵ(Wright)Ľǣ尲ȫԭƲǶģǶĲ
Ϊٽ尲ȫ֯ķչǾȻмƻķչעInis Claude,Power and International Relations,p
p.130-133
    ϹμҽԼǼ尲ȫϵĽߡȻǲûʶԼƾϵΪ丶ʵŬһ
ܵ尲ȫ˼Ӱ죬ŷκεطÿҵйںƽбͬΣһ
棬ڶԸɴֵ֧ս˱ᣬЧļ尲ȫϣð尲ȫķաϽ
ֱ⽫ϹƳɼ尲ȫϵַƣϹµ˸˰ʣȻļǿʵ
вƽĹҵĿơڰУҪصǴĹǶԴĹǶһдһԭ
²Ϊ尲ȫʹκδԸĹܶƵġ
    ϹĴ߳ϣԸɴֵ֧ĿвбҪԾϵΪͰšµ51涨ڰȡ
Ҫ취άֹʺƽȫǰ²ΪֹʹȻȨΪϵ˷ʡ尲ȫ
ȡƲ˵Ĺ֯άƽҶϿпޡľǰʹһһı仯ǹ֯
ĳֳΪϵ仯չڶһ˵ϵϹĴںܵԿ϶ϹȾϵ
Ⲣ˵δܵϵӰ죬ϹܾϵӰԵĺ͸Եġ尲ȫϵڵȨ־Ϲչʵʣ
ҪҶһϵӰǾԵġעInis Claude,Power and International Relations,pp.281-282.
    ෽棬Ϲھϵ书ܵķӣ
    һϹΪٽϵھ׵ĺƽṩ˻ͷ
    ڶϹǵֹԵҪڴģɱĿֲƽʹڡܾˡսǰֵ÷ǳ
ϹһҪܾǼǿǿԻĶЧʹΣմȶ״̬Ҫȡȫ渺̬ȣϵеľ
ΪһķΧڡ
    ھϵȶ£ϹøΪҪԴϹڶ鳤ˡԤ⽻
ͻΣзԽԽҪάֺƽãȲҪߣʵԻ˭ߣҲҪƴ
Χִֹ֧ͻĽһԼ֮ĴϵĶ񻯡ǶϹϣʹþ
ƴΪͨҶƳͻƾƾȶʹϵΪҵϹǱڵ
ײʵ˼尲ȫǰٽȶ˾ϵʹϵøӰȫ
    ģϹıͳԽϵֶΡ尲ȫȫͬݱ䣬ǡҪԽϵΣ
ǡΪɿϵ췢չԤʩһյǰıһи߶ȵǱĶԪᣨעInis 
Claude,Power and International Relations,pp.284-285.ȻǸȨϵ
    ûжԾϵУûм尲ȫ۵γɺʵ尲ȫһֽϵǶԾϵĲͷչ
    尲ȫȨƲĹϵ
    20͵Ĺϵһġϵϵ18ͺ19ɵһĹʾɵʱȽϣǼ尲ȫȨ
ϵʱ
    սʵƶϵάƽ໥йսǰΪ尲ȫĵԭ
ΥȨƵ߼עJohn Mearsheimer,"The False Promise of International Institutions"ƶָ
޵ķʸڶԡˡ⼯尲ȫٽƽġΪ״̬µľ˵尲ȫ
Ϊֿṩ˸ΪЧƽ⣬ʹγһΪĹʻʹҼľԵĿԸСڼ尲ȫϵ£
ȶûҪսǺĲȨϵ£ȶԾƶΪؼǣڡжһ
й¡ƶȻƽ⣬ȻڡΪսĹ޹µġƽάֺƽ尲ȫȾƸЧҲϣ
尲ȫǷֹս鵤ҩյĴ𰸣עCharles Kupchan and Clifford Kupchan,"The Promise of Collective Security",pp.52
-53.Լ׶˹Ĭ(John Mearsheimer)Լ尲ȫĸʶ壬Ϊݹ½ƽ͸ݡжһĹ
Ļڼ尲ȫķΧ˽ЭԼΪ尲ȫ롣ȻǴģԭǻ˼尲ȫƵ
    ѧɶ尲ȫȨеĹǿϵ֮߼еߵĸ˭Ҳ˵
˭ʵʵѧɻƶѧɶ̸尲ȫ֮໥ϵ⣬ǣֲԸһ㡣ƶ
߽尲ȫһľơһйµƶȻľơһ֡ȫһľƣⱾͳ˾ϵĴڡߣ
ʵȻšΪսġ޹¡ϵ尲ȫϵ;ϵǲɵġ
    尲ȫһֻ룬ΪһֱáȻǲģΪ尲ȫҲһֱáڼ尲ȫ
ϵ;ϵϷìܺͳͻĹУκһϵθֵı仯ռϷʧȥáϵһ
ֱڹͬã淢չ
    һЩѧ߶Լ尲ȫγɵǰ;мġΪս伣ǶϹִӴת
صᡣ2060Ȩôʼ½ͷӳơϵΪģʽ
¹弫ȨṹչԿһµЭϵͽڴһ»Ͼļ尲ȫ
𽥸༫Ȩƣ簲ᣩõĻָǼ尲ȫĸƣעμ¶ࡤױ˹ֶȨ塪ʹ
ϵѧۡ364ҳҲеѧΪ尲ȫǽȨƵ֮ϵģξõ໥ʹҼ䲻⿼ûֱ
ľвֺܷȾԼ档ھϵ£ǺһڼϽ綨Լ棬Ӷٽ
Ҽ尲ȫЧעμCharles A.Kupchan and Clifford A.Kupchan,"The Promise of Collective Sec
urity",pp.52-61
    尲ȫ֯žϵ´εһķչչŴĦͻĲ˥ˡϹõطӳһ
ʵϵеĴΪȫҵӵȨĺϻߣЭƺֻҪȨ֮Ż
ע¶ࡤױ˹ֶȨ塪ʹϵѧۡ373ҳɴ˿尲ȫԴͷԾƵĳɹԶ
һƼϽ໥ĳ̶ȲϼϵУ尲ȫϵϵϳͻͬʱڹģΧҪ
Եȷ潫չ
 
