 ׺ 3-988
ԭĳ羭Ρ
ԭ
ԭںš200105
ԭҳš5660
  šD7
  
ӡںš200108
    еľƲ߻߶ԶսľƲ̸
    
߼顿ִѧʷϵʱࣺ130012
ҪƲ(economic sanctions)Ϊһ򼸸ΪͨʵʩƲöﵽĿҪֶΣ
ߺ;ߵսθгµغͷչƣֶΣǾƲߣΪ
ΪʵĿҪѡ񣬶ڴͳκ;ֶΡǣӶľƲߵʹμ
ѧ߶һߵЧԲɡƲ߻߶Զͼͨս󾭼ƲʷĴԻعˣԴΪ
Ʋߵúսչһߵʷˡ
  ʡ/Ʋ/Ʋ
    
    һ սľƲ
    սսἫظı˹е⽻֡ΧڵʱĶʶ̬صԼ֮
ڹ⽻л˸ΪҪĵλսսỹζķɢͶ˹֮תͻرй
ձӢ͵¹֮ƽ⣬ͬʱȫ򻯵룬֯(non-government organizations)ڹθе
Ҳվ
    սʱڣɵΪ׵ӪΪ׵Ʋ÷ĳһΪȡƲõʱ򣬱Ʋ÷ת޻˵
ƲΣеԣǿԵӪ£ȻԸ⿴ġսսᣬĳ̶ֳΪ
Ϊ׵ҵľƲжṩˡõĹʻҲ˵ǿԲ˼ⲿָǰĸ棬ضЩ
Ϊ谭ƽͰȫġҡ(rogue states)оƲá
    ˣƲΪһ⽻ֶʹõƵҲΪӡս10ڣܹ50ƲðУ
36ҺʵʩģʵʩľƲðռ˽1/3μAЩƲðУЩʷϼ̳
ģΪԹŰͺʵľƲãЩųֵģ1998ӡȡͻ˹̹ԺҶӡ
ʵʩľƲá
    ӱABԿ۹20͹еľƲð90Ʋǰ෽淢ı仯
    һƲʵʴﵽû˵ĳɹʳ͡˵2090ȡµľƲжκʱ
ڶҪƵǹʾо(Institute for International Economics)ͨ90Ʋðо֣ƲΪһ⽻
ֶԵò԰ӱAԵؿƣ2070֮ǰƲжܹȡһĳɹȻ2070
90֮䣬ƲжĳɹʽΪ20%澭Ʋõ˥Ϊ2070֮ǰ澭Ʋ
ĳɹʸߴ60%֮࣬207090֮䵥澭ƲóɹʽΪ10%ңμAʾооԱΪĿǰ
̬90Ʋõĳɹ7090ֻ½Ŀܡֵ̲طһЩҡľƲ
Ҳ֤ߵĴ2000619ʽ˽ֶԳʵʩ˳50ľƲõйشʩǳֵ֤
עſԳʵľƲá»绪ʢ2000619ר硣
    AƲΪ⽻߹ߵúͳЧ(Use and Effectiveness of Economic Sanctions as a Foreign Policy Tool)
    ͼ{ͼ}
    עͣ(a)ĳɹһ
    ԴGary Clyde Hufbauer,Jeffrey J.Schott,and Kimberly Ann Elliott,Economic Sanctions Reconsidered,3rd ed.,revised,W
ashington:Institute for International Economics.
    ڶ2090ľƲõĿӵֲ˵ϷԵĸı䡣7080˹һֱң
ƲõҪĿ꣬սǰƲϷԵؼ٣μBҲһ淴ӳǰ˥
⣬90޵ΪƲõġҪѡ񡱣޵ġƲô󻧡¢ϵλμBĳ̶ֳϣ
ƷӳһЩҵġ̣ľƲѹ£ͷ޵ˡרͳΡͻȨ͹֣
ŷ޹ңͳη޵ǰֳңעŷսʱΪ׵ľƲøеЦҲȡ̶ͬȵ
ƣǴͳΧɧңҲظıҼɾƲõĴ󳱡
    ϹľƲжƵӡעսϹƲģDavid Cortright,George A.Lopez,"The Sanctions
 DecadeAssessing UN Strategies in the 1990s",Lynne Rienner Publishers,Boulder,Colorado,2000.ϹʵʩƲж
սܹ2Σս10ھʹ11֮ࣨμB 1990֮ǰϹȫ»(United Nations Security Cou
ncil)ȡǿƲж޵ǣRhodesiaΪǰϷһȨȫ澭ƲúͶϷǵˡ
֮ϹƲжƵӣֱˡǰ˹ǡءǡȡ׶ȫͬ
¬˸̶ֲͬȵǿƲá
    B19701998ƲðƲ÷뱻Ʋ÷(Senders and Targets in Sanctions Cases Initiated,19701998)
    ͼ{ͼ}
    עͣ(a)ЩƲ÷ҪƲռλĹҡϹʵʩƲжִУ(b)2060Ϲ
޵ǣRhodesiaΪǰϷһȨʵȫ澭ƲúͶϷǵˣ(c)а2090
ԳʵʩƲвȨԼկɫʵʩƲãûвȡʵж
    ԴGary Clyde Hufbauer,Jeffrey J.Schott,and Kimberly Ann Elliott,Economic Sanctions Reconsidered,3rd ed.,revised,W
ashington:Institute for International Economics.
    ӱսĹʾƲ˷ܴܲһȫںĳ̶ֳҲȽط
ӳսʾƲõĻơ
    Ʋߵ
    ƲΪһ⽻ֶΣƲúͷǾƲ(non-economic sanction)СƲͨǶһʵʩƲ
ΪҪһַʽעG.C.Hufbauer,J.J.Schott,K.A.Elliott,Economic Sanctions Reconsidered:History and Current Policy,Seco
nd Edition,Institute for International Economics,Washington,1990,p.2.
    ƲΪﵽ⽻Ŀߣ봫ͳľ½Ⱦи˵һ̶ϣΪƲõʵʩṩ
Ʋ÷۵ǿ侭Ʋߵԣ⽻ж֮ĸҡһսǶⳡսѾ
еսһЩ쵼ҲҲսֶζԸЩҡŲȡĹͬƲжУǰ
ͳѷ(Woodrow Wilson)ͼʹþƲöעйѷͳľƲ˼룬οG.C.Hufbauer,J.J.Schott
,K.A.Elliott,Economic Sanctions Reconsidered:History and Current Policy,Second Edition,Institute for International Economics,
Washington,1990,p.9.ΪսӰ˫ģɾ޴ľʧһʹϳصľø͵Ǵ
⵽ԷȺں͵ֵļҶԿҹȺںһЩ漯ҲȺ𷴶һΣվٴ롣֮ƲòҪ
ôľӡɾ޴ԱҪصľôۣҲƲһֲҪͶʶﵽ⽻Ŀ
ʽעDonald L.Losman,Economic Sanctions:AnEmerging Business Menace,A Speech in"The 39th Annual Meeting of NABE
,"New Orleans,September 1417,1997.Ȼֻ봫ͳľֶȽϣֻܴ֤Ŀȡԡʵϣ
ΪƲø˾޴ľôۺۡ͡
    ƲսƵʹ˳Ӧ˹аȫ˼άת䡣ԾΪʶ̬Ϊ֧սսᣬ͹˾
ȫ;ڹǹ⽻еҪԡսʾ໥ϵʷչչһЩҵľ÷չ
һЩչйңҺʾϵ̶ȲϼԹ֮ó׹ϵڡڡͶʡԮ
ʴȵȣΪʵֹͱϹҰȫҪںˣֶսڹȥӵеĵλƲ
ĿʹԷҪûıڱΪвǿáעѧ񣺡սеľƲߡ
ء羭Ρ19947ڣ46ҳ
    ôβ̶ȵ߾ƲߵЧأдڼؼԵԼأƲ÷ܹܺõشЩԼأ
ӵƲõԺʵ侭ƲõļȶĿꡣ֮Ʋ÷ܴݻٶԷľƲߣƻٵ޶ȡ
    һƲ÷Ӧת޾ƲӦƲõӦת޾ƲɵӰĻԡȡĸأ(1)
ó׹ϵ̶ȣƲ÷Ʋ÷ó̶Խ󣬾ƲɵӰԽ(2)ƷѰҵףƲ÷ʵʩֹ
Ʋ÷ĳƷʱƲ÷ܹ׵ΪȡøƷĽȨƷ˵ľƲþԵúܴ(3)Ѱ
ƷڷףƲ÷ƱƲ÷ĳƷƷй壬˵ʯ͡޵ľʱ
Ʋ÷ܺ׵ҵƷĵΪ壬ҲƲõʵЧ(4)ƲùõĳʾоFr
ed C.BergsternʿΪֻеƲ÷ɵľʧ÷ֵ5%㾭ƲЧעFred C.Bergster
n,Do Economic Sanctions Work?,March 11,1999,http://www.icrier.res.in/public/bergsten.html.۹2090ľƲ
ںܶ±Ʋ÷ھƲɵÿʧһ㲻ֵ(GDP)2%ֻڼٵ³5%עFred C.B
ergstern,Do Economic Sanctions Work?,March 11,1999,http://www.icrier,res.in/public/bergsten.html.
    ƲõĹԡͻȻľƲÿڶڸ׼ıƲùϴ̶ȵʧʾооԱKimberly An
n ElliottʿΪƲߵĹ(decisive)ѸʹӰ󻯵ĹؼءעKimberly Ann Elliott,Evidence on
 the Costs and Benefits of Economic Sanctions,A Speech Before the Subcommittee on Trade of the House Committee on Ways and Me
ans,October 23,1997.19985ӡȡͻ˹̹ٳûг̨ķɶӡ͵һٶƲã
ֱ718ԺƲõϸڣԺƲ÷еĲѧDevesh KapurΪ˵ľٴʵ
ƻƲõЧԡעSee Devesh Kapur,The Domestic Consequences of India's Nuclear Tests,paper delivered to"South Asia
's Nuclear Dilemmas"conference,Center for International Affairs,Harvard University,Cambridge,MA,February 1999.
    ƲõĶ֧֡ƲߵĹԺѸܵصӰ죬ڹڿܻӰ쵽漯ţǿ˾ĺ
棻ڹ⣬⵽ͻĹΪķԡȡĵ澭ƲѾʹ˾޴ĴۣˣƲĿ
ҲûдﵽܶѧߺμҶԵ澭ƲÿʼɲʵоƲõĶ֧֡ʾоThea Le
eʿΪѡĻе˶ΪƲñȵƲøΪȡȡöߵ֧Ǳ֤ƲЧԵĹؼ
Ӧʹÿһְ취ͨó֯Ϲ˵֧ƲжעThea Lee,Assistant Director for Internati
onalEconomics,Public Policy Department,AFL-CIO,A Speech before the Senate Task Force on Economic Sanctions,September 8,1998.
    ƲߵġΡ
    90Ʋõļ˾޴ĶԿԷӦⲻҹ㷺Ϲó׻֮䡣ӹĹ۵
ΪʵʩľƲصǶ뱻ƲùóĵΪ˾޴ľʧ͵1
996ֶǩġնķ˹ٷ(Helms-Burton Act)һصǶԵΪƲãӶ
60ԹŰ͵ĵ澭Ʋ󵽹ˣһ⵽ŷˡձ漯ŵһ·ԣΪ
ֱӺԵش˳ó֯(World Trade Organization)óԭ
    ϹƲж޴Ĵۺ˵ߵĺʹһ⵽ԽԽҺķϹ˵ĳǿ
Ʋãʹ˼ľǸŮͯΪʹעĽ㡣
    ȻϹʵʩƲõԸġôǲ˵ƲΪһֹ㷺Ӧõ⽻ֶ
ʷߡأ׻߶ԶأŶЩɻҪԾƲ١Ρԭε̽
    һȫ򻯵ͼɵȫ򾭼һ廯ǾƲЧĴ߻(catalyzer)ֹΪѧ
ƲЧ˥˼롣У³˹Э⽻о(Foreign Policy StudiesBrookings Institution)Richard N.
Haassʿһɵ׿Խгֵر˼롣Ϊϣȫ򻯵ĸ̶ȺͷΧĳ̶ֳ
ҵļԣԾƲõЧԲ൱Ӱ졣ڱƲùӵиǱڵĹӦ̺гֻȡƲ
ʵʹƲÿܷЧעRichard N.Haass,ed.,Economic Sanctions and American Diplomacy(New York:Council on Foreign
 Relations),1998,pp.56.Ʋ÷ͨĳƷĳڶԱƲ÷ʵʩƲãбƲ÷ѰƷ׳̶Ⱦ;
ƲõЧȫɵ羭һ廯ǿ˱Ʋ÷Ӧת޾ƲΣĵԣȡƷӦԴͳƷг
ʷԵȻ־ƲǺʵġͬʱȫ򻯵ķչӾ˹Ϊ֮óĦͶΪ
ͰȫҪѡˣΪƲ÷ҵŹͬĿĻʵֶƲá磬ƲжϹ
еģȴδõһЩʱҵ֧֣ЩԣΪ˵ĽŹϵ
ԼʽƷͶŵˣһ淶ΧԣľƲжǹԮġ
    Ʋ÷ľ޴µĹ漯ŵķǾƲЧ谭(internal encumbrance)
ΪͨԹȥƲõо֤˾˺ũ˳صʧ1995Ʋľôۣڷ
ʹﵽ1520Ԫɹ20ʧҵעGary Clyde Hufbauer,Kimberly Ann Elliott,Tess Cyrus,and Elizabeth Ann Winston
,US Economic Sanctions:Their Impact on Trade,Jobs,and Wages,Institute for International Economics Working Paper,April 1997.
ͬʱƲõĳ̶ҲԵӰųڵ1995ΪľƲжڳڵĳ½
    򾭼ƲֱʧǾ޴ģֵһС֡ԣǽֵھƲΪ
ʵ⽻Ŀġ۹ߡǣ˵ĴԺͳڵģΪƲõƵӦʹΪó
ζȲɣһΪľƲжܲصʧһʹóĵΪڹгѰ
Ϊŵĺ飻һ棬ڵľƲƶ˱Ʋ÷ܹҵƷۺͽгҡԸ
㡱ǿȻľƲ˵ΪĴ
    Ʋ÷Ĳʧµ˵ǴǾƲ÷Ҫԭ֮һ˵Ǵ𲻽ԹᣬҺ̶ܴ
ڲȡʵȨ˶ս󣬱Ʋ÷Ӧת޾ƲΣ˺̶ܴȵߣ
ΣǾ޴ģǶͯŮ˵Ļ⡣磬ھƲ˵µص˵ѣ
ҪƲõĺߡ
    ġƲ롰Ϊ֮̽һƽ㡪Ӵսԡ
    ƲߵġΡ͡ܡʹᡢν硢̽ѧ翪ʼԾƲãǵ澭Ʋãȫλ
ӣƲ롰Ϊ֮̽һԸҡЧƽ㡪Ӵսԡ(engagement strategies)
    ϹҲʼʵһ֡Ʋá(smart sanction)ʵʻǡӴսԡ20004ŦԼٿΪ
ΪġЧϹƲáToward Smarter,More Effective United Nations Sanctions)Ϲȫ»Ʋֻᡣ
    ̽Ϊٵ澭ƲӰӦʵظı侭Ʋߣ1997꿪ʼǹͬŬԽ
澭ƲΪĿUSA-EngageƶӴսԡ˾޴ĹסעUSAEngage,a coalition representing American
 business and agriculture,is one such powerful group.See their website at:http://www.usaengage.org/.ѧ磬³˹
Э⽻оǡӴսԡҪߣоRichard N.HaassʿоԱMeghan L.O'SullivanŮʿڡս
̽ҪĹס
    ͨԾƲߵĶ෽λҪڹоƲΪһ⽻ֶλ߶Զֻ˵ͳƲ˼ά
ȻڵĻƲûҪٶȷõĻôֻиĸеľƲߣӴսԡѾΪһĳԡǣά
ƽȨĽǶƲõı׼ӳ棬ȻƲõȨôǴͳľƲ
߻д̽ġӴսԡӳԶ䡰ƽʷıȻ
 
