 ׺ 4-436
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš200102
ԭҳš135145
  šD7
  
ӡںš200110
    ϵԡءεۡ
    
߼顿ࣺ⽻ѧԺڡʿ
    
    ȥʮὨʹϵѸٷչѧɽһѧɵҪѧߣε
ۡȫὨʹϵۣΪһѧҪרעAlexander Wendt,Social Theory of International Po
litics(Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1999)ɽأεۡ룩Ϻ磬2000
档ⲿжԹʹϵ漰Ҫ˸ɣ׵ǹϵԡ
    һ
    ȶԾʵһشǰѹʹϵĵһƶشתƵϵԡʵΪʹϵʵ
ΪȨ䶯˵ıԣĦʵԭַӳΪʹϵһƶĹ۵㡣ע˹Ħ
ݺۣǿȨƽ¬룩Ϻĳ磬1995棬3-14ҳڵһﲢûȫԵ
أڡۡһпʼϵṹΪεΨһΣѹϵΪʹϵԭ򡣣ע
μKenneth Waltz,Man,the State,and War(New York:Columbia University Press,1959);Kenneth Waltz,Theory of International Poli
tics(New York:McGraw-Hill,1979).壨ʵ壩ʹϵѧ뻪ȹ۵һµġ
ͽά˹ΪǹʹϵĸʵָҴõ״̬֮УΪûȨƶȨ
׷󡣡עRobert Art and Robert Jervis,International Politics(Boston:Little,Brown,1986),2nd ed.,p.7;Kenneth A.Oye,Coope
ration under Anarchy(Princeton:Princeton University Press,1986),p.1.תHelen Milner,"Anarchy in International Relation
s Theory,"in David Baldwined.,Neorelaism and Neoliberalism:The Contemporary Debate(New York:Columbia University Press,1993),p
p.144-145.ŷġȨ֮ΪоƶȡΪ˹εĻϵҪءעK
robert Keohane,International Institutions and State Power(Boulder:Westview,1989),p.1.
    ѧɶԲɵؽ˵ڹʹϵоиٹ̵ĵλҲֳһļ塣
䱾壬ǹεĻʵȻʵǿ͹۴ڵĶҲ;в˵־ΪתƵԡֻҪ
ϵڣԾϵǷ壬ԳΪеһҪٶȻǼٶɼ
ΪĶȻǵһҪļٶˣйʹϵоٶʼʵԿʼ
ΪľԿʼΪչĺѧ塣κ͹ѧĻҲ
ٶֽġԾ;˶ԹζĹܡ
    ԵĻûмеȨȨȻԾ״̬壬ںΪ״̬״̬
Թϵʵ꾡˳֮ΪᡱעHedley Bull,The Anarchic Society(New York:Col
umbia University Press,1977).ԣʹϵѧձܵĶԼȱȨȻ˵ġȱȫ
ϵȨͻŷ˵ġȱһͬעWaltz,Theory of International Politics,p.88;Keohane
,International Institutions and State Power,p.1.ʵ˵ֹʹϵĻ塣һϵ
ʹùϵȻϵ£ϵλƵĵλͬȵȨ֮ûһȨ
ζȨɢûһȨܹϸԱİȫˣϵԱֻԼԼͲƲȨע
Waltz,Theory of International Politics,pp.91-93.ڶϵʹùұȻѰȨΡϵ
ϵ°ȫٰȫӦԷֻвȨεߣֹȨͻ
ָ˹֮ľͳͻעJoseph M.Grieco,"Anarchy and the Limits of Cooperation:A Realist 
Critique of the Newest Liberal Institutionalism,"in Baldwin ed.,Neorealism and Neoliberalism,p.116.
    ԣʵʹϵۼٶϵԵĻԵĴڣϵȻϵϵֱȻ
ȨΣǾ¾͹սⱻΪԵΨһ߼ȻȨͬ
ѹϵԺΪۼٶоصڹƶԵĸӰ档עRobert Axelrod 
and Robert Keohane,"Achieving Cooperation under Anarchy:Strategy and Cooperation,"in Oye ed.,Cooperation under Anarchy,pp.226
-254;Robert Keohane,After Hegemony:Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy(Princeton:Princeton University Pres
s,1984);Keohane,International Institutions and State Power.ڹƶȺ⣬μճӣȫ򹫹ʺ
һƶȵķϺ磬2000棬23-31291-297ҳƺȷʵΪϵĹԣΪΪ
ĹΪĸԭҲͳΪʹϵĵһƶΪһйʹϵо㡣
    
    ΪϵĻ͵һƶƺûܵɡ2080Ҫʹϵϵ
о󲿷ΪġǣǹϵͿ͹ԵǷȷʵ棿һҪ
ע1992ҪɣڡεۡһнһĹ۵㡣μAlexander Wendt
,"Anarchy is what states makes of it:The social construction of power politics,"International Organization,Vol.46,1992,pp.391
-425.߼ģȨ״̬ıȻôԵľ߼Ҳ棬
ΪʹϵһƶҲͳǣƵ߼ϱȻԵʵʡݺöۡ
    ԣҪӸϷΪεһƶ۵㣬Ҫ֤ԺȨβΪˣ
ǣԺȨεĲʹǹϵԱĻ̺ʵµģûֱӵϵûйֱӵʵ
ûйʽṹûν߼ԺȨǹ֮以Ĳԡƶأ
ڵ߼ͱȻĽעأεۡ24-25,313-318ҳ
    ǷȻԡ
    ʵΪȫΪĵһǡ״̬£ûһȨ֤ΪİȫΪֻб
ȫԣԱȻϵصĲǣʹ״̬£ʹΪĵһȫϵҲǱȻ
ʡϵ״̬ʱֿܵϵԣ(1)ϵԱ໥֮ǵˣôΪƱصҰȫ
Ҫķʽ֤Լİȫ״̬£ϵԡ(2)ϵеĳԱ໥֮ѣΪûбҪ
ԼİȫܵвΪ໥֮䲻γɰȫвҼʹܵϵΪвҲ໥άȫ״̬£
ϵԣԡݴˣϵǷԲǷ״̬ϵԱ֮ݹϵעأ
εۡ191-193318-328ҳ
    ݹϵеģΪ֮ԻʵȷġδıΪ岻ܻΪˣҲܻΪѡ
ֻͨ໥Ӵ໥жſȷԷǵѡʵ˻壬༴γɹҺߵĹй
壬彨ΪݣҲΪǺϵ档Ϊ忼ȫʱӰ쵽ֿǵ
֪ͬͬѣͬǵˡԵ׾ʲô߼ϵȨ䵽ʲô壬ȡ֪
ͬĲ졣໥֮ǷͬϵԵİȫϵһͲģϵȻϵ֮
ͬϵһ尲ȫϵһҵİȫԼ飬޹ءں̶ܴҲһ
ϵǣ֮ͬǾͰȫΪԼ飬ԼڣϵȻԣ

    ϵԳϵ֮У¿ԲҲԲ˵ĸԭ
ԣϵԱ֮Ļ֪ͬ塣ʹ߼֤Ե⡣
    ǷȻȨΡ
    ȨʵԹʹϵһֻ⣬ϵṹʹֲ֮ɱİȫϵ
ûһȨܹ֤ҵİȫֻͨȨΪݵĶߡǽṹѡϵ
ıȻעͬϣ328-332ҳһ۵㣬ָȨὨԱȻĽκδٳ
ụȨҲ⡣Ϊ˵ԲܱȻȨΣʹ˵һļٶٶҺ
Ϊ壬ûԤȵĻ飬ôڵһʱһҪеԷвԼһ߷Ķź
вԵģҾաͺ͸һ̣źҲΪв֮󣬲ŻвС߷źѺ
ģҾ֪̰ͬźҲΪѺõģǾͲΪ໥вǷв˫ڻ֪ͨʶ
ġҲ˵ûлʵҲûвͱвʶٳΪȡжҲͲڡ˫ԶԷڻ
еźŹͬ⣬γɻ֪ʶֻ֪ʶɻΪǿȶγɹṹֹṹж
塣עأεۡ337-338412-422ҳ
    ݴˣϵܳΪѣҲܳΪˣؼȡڹҲȡжͶж⡣һ
źűһΪвԵطͬвźţȫвŻȫŵȷȨβſԳΪҶߵ
ʯһźűһΪѺãͬѺõĻرźţ򲻻ְȫвͰȫ˫γɰȫͬ
ԣṹڱȡڽ̡˵ȫϵеģǱΪĻʵġҴڰȫ
֮УΪ֮ʵ˰ȫıǵʵͿԸı䵼°ȫĹ֪ͬʶͻ塣ˣȨ
ὨΪڻΪнġȨǹҽģġ
    ԿϵûڵʹΪȻ⡣ȨαȻǰȷϵȻ
Ͱȫָһ⡣ʵϣϵԵ°ȫԵȨεҲ֤
    ֤ԵҲ֤ǹʹϵһƶ⣬ʵ綨ΪΨһ߼ľԹҲ
ͲܹΪΨһ߼״̬ûʲô߼ԣһжҪȡڹ֮乲еĹṹ״̬ǹ
͵ġעأεۡİ򡷣41ҳһ֤شѾʹϵϵ
ĸ˵ɣϵġӲˡɡע˹ѧо췽ۡ룩
ĳ磬1986棬һµڡһɡ
    
    ȻϵʺȨεγȡڹΪĻʵôûеһԣҲûеһ߼ΪĻ
ʵͶ߼ĻעضԹϵĻμεۡ¡һ´
ϲ˹ϵĻ͡ں߼γɣǸľڡ
    ͵ĹϵĻ˹ĻĻͿĻνĻǡṲ֪ʶ༴֮乲
໥֪ʶעͬϣ180ҳ֪ʶֻ᷶ڴڣҲֻϲڹʹϵ淶ƶ
Ļıʽǹ֮Ļʵ͵ġϵĻĹж֮ĽɫṹġɫṹָΪ
λáעͬϣ325ҳϵпԴֽɫṹˡֺѣͬɫṹͬϵĻ
˽ɫṹ˹ĻֽɫṹĻѽɫṹĻͬĻвͬ߼
    ˹Ļɵ˵Ľɫṹȷģĺǵ(enmity)໥֮ǵˣΪԭǲΪ
ΪڵȨҿʹñ֮໥ɫǵˣֳµΪȡ(1)ͼݻ١𣬻
Է(2)ʱ̰ѶԷͼǣκ¼ϵһ(3)ʵΪҪأȸݵ˵ľʵԤ
˵жΪҾʵ໥ϵľأ·ʽΪΨһԾվȨֶΣչΪȫı
֤(4)սͻʹñֱԷ򱻶Է𡣣עأεۡ328-335ҳԣ
˹Ļ߼ǡ˷ˡս״̬ȫԼľʵ໥֮İȫȫǸ߶ȾϷ
ȫϵĻ˹Ȼ״̬
    ڶ͵ĻģʽĻĻɾֵĽɫṹģĺǾ(rivalry)͵ű
Ĳͬ˫໥ͲƲȨֳȨƶȱֲֳصвͼͳκ
Է֮λǾֳ֣µΪȡ(1)໥ȨȻ֮ľִ漰
䶯ȨΪһƶǵõձϺصġ(2)Ӿ档Ϊⲻ⣬Ϊ
Ӿ棬δЧӦ(3)ʵؼȻµĳͻʹùǾѾԵ
Ҫ(4)ܵơһսֻƱʹó̶ȣԷΪĿġעͬϣ350-354ҳ
Ļ߼ǡ桱ԣ֮Ĺϵ໥ɱ¾Ϊ1648ĹϵĻĻȨ
Ļı־ӡǣҵĵʱ߼ΪˣȱĹϵϵԼ
˵ǻ˹ϵעͬϣ357ҳ
    ĻģʽǿĻĻѵĽɫṹȷģꡣڿĻУ֮໥Ϊѣ
Ϊ֮ѭ򣬼Ǳͻ綨˿ĻйҵĻΪȡ򣺷ǱζŲʹս
սвʽζһܵвʱһ԰ⲻ˵֮ûͻ֮䲻ʹñ
ͻ⡣עأεۡ370-372ҳĻ߼ǡһΪңΪһˡһϵ
ԱܵвַʱϵԱʹûֱҲᾡһҵľʵвҵֶ
һΪϵгԱĹͬƸǼ尲ȫȫͬϵųȫϵ棬γһļݺ͸
ȵͬϵУڼ֮У˺ҲΪһ塣עͬϣ373-380ҳ
    ΪеĹϵĻϵԹϵĻֽ̬ȣΪϵ𲽳Ź淶໥Ѻõ
Ļչ
    
    ͨ߼֤ǹʹϵһƶ۵㣬ԺȨûбȻϵ֤
ΪʹϵĵһƶصĻϣһĻĸֹϵĻģʽָĻǹҽ
ġ
    ĻأضԹʹϵ۷չһҪס֮ԺȨεԭ
ϵУΪۼٶΪ屾ֻܴԻлõΪΪȻ״̬йеԡȨ
Զʵ͵ģʵĽȴﻯԣΪȻĶشὨĽǶ
ԣﻯнѳĻ⡣Ҳǿ˴ʵġܶԵжߣ̽ж߳еĿ
ͼֵṹЩжߵʵܶʹṹΪԽṹҲʹøıṹΪܡ
    ĻĻعζ˵Ļع飬ζ˵ܶԵļŴʵк͸촫ͳԣ
˵ĴԴӸϲͬȻĶԺ͸ԡĻⲻ˵˵治˵ͨԼͼ
ʽġҲˡעأεۡ272ҳ֮Ļ˹ᡣǰ
ΪȻԶԴԺȨΪԵıȻôǾԶʵ綨߼ͻѭ
Ȩֹκ֮Ч鶼ҪΪʵǷȱκιʹϵⶼҪ͸˹ĻӾ۲죬
¼Ҫ׼κιҶҪȰΪˡʵԵĽⲻǡҲӦ͹
ǰʵΪϵبŲĿ͹ʵԴͲҲܽʾԡ
ϵĻǹж߽ģжҪܶáʵ۵ɫʣǣȫûйڹ
ϵ룬Ǿ޷ʹǵܶԳŬҲֻƾʵԿƹʹϵˣʹԶǻ
ս˼ά֮С
    عԵ߼Ͻܵġۣ״̬ʺΪĻʵ͵ģΪˣز
۶ϣ״̬ǹ͵ġǣͬһۣӦÿĻģʽԴͬĸʵ
ͺʹڡǣڹʹϵʷУ֣ȨΪʵϵƺӳԼ
17֮ǰǻ˹Ļռλ磬17Ļռλ磬ܻᳯſĻռ
λ緢չʷϴ󲿷ʱǻ˹Ļ⣬ʹĻʱڣսƺΥ
ĻĹսУ֮ϣԷҲƵʹñʹڽ졢ʹǳĻ
ǵĻ֮ȻƵء䡱˹Ļ״̬ҲΪˣʵŰ綨ľ״̬
Ϊϵе߼Ҳɵؽ߼Ȼ˵Ļ룬ûеһ߼
˹Ļ״̬ƵֵʵϾһ⣺Ϊʲôڹϵл˹Ļƺ׵͡ԺȨθױ
ܣûȷĽͣҲȱⷽľоǽĻһȱʧ
 
