 ׺ 1-869
ԭĳϾѧ
ԭںš199901
ԭҳš1018
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš199905
    ȡһ
    ۵ηչо֮
    
߼顿ѧϵ  Ϻ  200433
ҪԵηչоٵԴѧƵʷݱ̣ͨѧɡִչǨͷ
ѧɡۡɡȽԼĿǰĻоĸͼǶ̽Ѱηչо˥ĸԴ
Խ顣һΪѧƼֵȡ򣬱ͨԡֵ롱ֵܡֵع顱ΪбҪѧĸ߶Ϊ
ηչоѧļֵȡΪʵʵΪ۵ʵηչоȷһµѧĿꡣ
    
    ηչоʷѾа͡ڴڼ䣬ѧɲţ䶰ֳһɷٵľȻ
ȴеηչ⵽ĻɣƣηչоڴοѧһϢˣԼ
John R.Freeman˹Dudley Seers˶»Michael EdwardsάأDavid E. Apte
r޲ءϺRobert A.Packenham ηչоѧ߶ΪηչоֻʵһЩġӦõ֧
ۡΪ⵱ηչо֮ҪԴѧƵʷݱ̡ʵϣηչоΧƷ۽
һϷͬȡķֱַֻֻԴڶִоСۡĲͬ˼Լһϵо
Ͷתơһγѧɣżֵʵ룬ѧһַѧɣֵܼ
            ֵ룺ִչͱǨо
    ηչоѧżֵʵ룬оѧԣԴִչǨһоʷʷ
ԭִۼҶִΪŷͱƶȺͼֵʮԺŷĴ̣ʮ
ʮĴ̡עɣִѧٿȫ顷6ŦԼ1965꣬324ҳִ
̿ȫ紫Ḷ́ʵǰִ򵥵ΪУֹ۵ʮһֱռ
ͳελҲɱؿʼ50ִоĵηչۡʱηչڰηչ̽綨Ϊ
ʽķչչ뾭÷չĽйأصġִΡⷽĵ͡Ϊηչ
Ȼ漰ƶжϵļֵۣضʽӦκŬ׷Ŀꡣ
    ȻҲִ۵ıйϵʮѧ߿ʼԵķչΪȫ仯ʮʷѧ
ýѰᷢչɣֱʮԺֹҵۺͷչۣЩȻĽͣǶע
ھ÷棬ִҵ򾭼ĹԽԽʶǸεı仯ʱһոµĸ
ΪȻ1951꣬ĻǨ־༭еѧϣˡִһʣ˵ũҵҵת䡣
עĻǨ־ϵѧоᾭίԱѧѧɡĴ죬ࡣ
λ˵ʱйƶ;÷չƽԼߡ1958꣬ͳšִ
ǴͳִתĹ̡˺ִоʼʽ֡ڵִ֮Գαʶ̬
ʮޡ޺޳һǿҵ˶˳˵Ķҷ׷׵ڹзá
ƶĶսΪµĶߣҪ˹ҵķչǰоΪƶ
ṩۺʵݡӦ˶ִȻȻʶ̬ӡǲֵ
    ǲã־ƫӸͬڲĻͳļֵ⵽ԽԽбȽ粼˺й
  עйCyril  E.  Black:  The   Dynamics   of Modernization,New York:Harper Row,1996˱ࣺ Ƚִ
Ϻĳ磬1996Щƶִۼ¼ȥۺ͹۵㣬˶ѧƣѧѧѧ
ӲͬǶȶִԺʹͳԺĸв͡Щ͹ǿִеĹԣѺ;ԵؿִԺʹͳ֮
ĹϵȻûаִĽۡע˱ִࣺϺĳ磬1996717ҳ ԲΪ
ѧΪ߲ǾԶų⣬ִǴͳƶȺͼֵڹ϶ִԵҪ󲻶ӦḶ́˰ִ
۵صתԷչйұִԺʹͳԻϵо
    Ϊʱִо˷ǳҪת۵㣬ĸۺһ𣬵ηչоִож
ֵжϡһΪƶȺͼֵӦΪȫ͵ЧµİֻհȫƶȺ͹
ʵִĹ۵㱻ԷչйڲصĹעӣִ̬оʼִ̬ϵ
оʹչĸ͹ֳˣչйصִжϣBreakdown of Modernizationǣȱ
αϵľҺѣͳִ۶ԴѾ޷ṩĽͣģѧ˼ʹ
ηչоĴ󲿷ѧͼѼֵж϶ԿѧоӰ죬ʼֻʵжϵĺûҲ˵ϵӦó
ʲôչ
    ɵºͿƶġչеΡת۵ı־Ȼһηչоѧ
Ϊͳһ۵뾭оϲͨϵͳĶȽձԡע˹̹˹ȱࣺ
ѧֲᾫѡ¾ӡݣ 1996꣬149ҳԺо˺ܴӰ졣ɵáġ롰ġ򡰷չ
ġִʹͳᣬ֡һĻ϶ǻϵģѴͳִĳɷֽһһڡ˫
Ĺ۵㡣 עAlmond,  Gabriel   and   James   S.  Coleman:The politics of the  Developing  Areas, Princeron  UniversityP
ress, 1960.P2324 ⲿͼһֽбȽо͵ĸͷ룬ơĻṹܺữȣӶԹ
ģṹĻȻͬϵ֮кȽоȱעζ̬չľԱ󰢶ɵºC ķС
ġȽѧչоһֲ     עAlmond, Gabeiel  and  G. Bingham  Powell: Comparative Politics: A D
evelopmental Approach,Boston:Little Brown, 1966.P13߻ȡ޶䡢źͷӦȷ롣
    1965Ѷ͢ڡΡ־Ϸˡηչ˥ܡһģʽִηչΪߵͬ
̫ηչܹӦõġʱͿռ䡱ƱػС侭ں˵ĵ󣬼˥˵⡣ע
huntington,Samuel P.   political  Development  and  PolititcalDecay,World Politics,17(1965):P389393 ڵʱоηչ
ѧ߿ִо޷ϸظõϵı׼Թϣǰҡ۹ִҵ͹ƶȽбȽоǰ
˵ִҾҪչĿ꣬ζںܶ෽õĴͳᣬȴǲģӦ죬ںܶǳҪ
棬ȱݵġִоչоʹοѧҿþµ塣⽨רơ͵۹ơ
ɹƵƣͳΪ͵ˣݴ˷⽨רơ͵۹ƾͲǲģɹ򲻼һ
ǳġĹ۵Ϊͬϵ֮䣬ڡһϵڡ塱ֻǴſáԵ
Ĳ졣Եֵжϵоȡ ڰɵºCķСġȽѧϵ̺ߡһ
͵֡עİɵ¡СȽѧϵ̺ߡϺĳ磬1987
    ʵϣһʱִִ֧չоѧ߶ΪΪҪоֵоҪǿһۿ
ܣһ׸롢ͷȣʶеõַչϵⷽ棬ѧ߶ȡ˲Сĳɾ͡ᵽ
İɵºCķСġȽѧϵ ̺ߡһΪṹֻϵĻ׻ǳַչ
ϵҪָꡣ³Lucian PyeΪƽȡƶȺͽṹķֻǷչҪءעPye, Lucien: Aspects  of
Political  Development,Boston:Little Brown,1966,P4548 簣ɭ˹صķ˵Ĭɭ巽˵ȡעȻ
ʵ϶ͬһ⣬ηչЩɷ֮ʲôϵ༴ηչоһһһϸ
    ǣԴѧƺȻ⣬Ϊչоδȫֵжϣ簢ɵ˵ηͼرܶ
ϵ⣬ⳣ˵ġĳһλĳЩһλһЩ⣬Ȿζļֵѡ񡣡
עɵ¡СȽѧϵ̺ߡϺĳ磬1987ڣ27ҳȷʵԸֳַչ͵
ܹмֵжϵģֵβ롢ƽȺ׻ǳַϵԴˣѧҺѲ
Ψһŵ壬Ѱֻǡĳһࡱ壬ڼֵáƽ͵ͬȵġˣ·չ
ѧ߱ȻżֵʵȻеƿŵơ
    Ѷ͢1971귢ġ±仯ı仯ִչΡһУصηչԵĸĿԵĸ
ΪηչоʵȻĿԵģԵģȻŰƶȿļֵжϡоչ
ѧǸ˵ĸо˵ιЩҿмֵģһĿ꣬ҲֵоҪ⡣ˣ͢
һܽԵĽۣηչʵֻ־ѧǵİãһڷĹߡעѶ͢٣±
ı仯ִչߡϺĳ磬1987꣬27ҳǣŰоתʮĩͳֵġǨ
оΪܱηչоĶԺĿԵ⡣οѧΪѧңŬȥ¼αǨԭʼʵ
ķ̣ʱãδ仯ȡһһһЩڷû򻵵Ŀ귢չı仯ϸ
áα仯ۿܿоκηչˮƽеα仯ִ޹أвֱӵϵغ͹
ϵĺġעѶ͢٣±仯ı仯ִչΡȽִ˱࣬Ϻĳ磬1996
6667ҳ79ҳѧҾͿûκоչйҴαǨʵˡ
    ˣηչоƺѧˣҲǡǡΪηչԭĿоչйҵηչ⣬
⣬չйṩηչ߽顣ʷսԺޡޡ޵ֳط׷װֳͳΣ
ȡ˶Ĺʵλ˵ĶҲž÷չ񣬶һ쳣صηչ񣬶йطչ֪ʶ
ž޴ͬʱעЩչйҷչѧ߿ʼ˶ǷչоһִƶΪ
ΪչйҵηչıߣӭηչоΪٵĽ׶ΡȻչйҵηչȴԶηչоɹ
ƶȲĩЩѿȶĿ궼ĩʵ֣һֱڶͻ֮Сβȶ÷չ
ȱλͱϣһֱھƶͼĥʵ޴ķѧ߶Լеηչ۵Ļ
ͷ˼ʵϣηչоŬ۵ĿһԸȴߵһˣͼֵжϡηչ
оҲʧȥʵĶӶ˥Ӹ˵󲢲ǵĿѧοѧҲڶȻѧ
ļֵĿѧ£ֵʵϾ͵˸ηչоĻʹηչоΪޱ֮ľԴ֮ˮ
            ֵܣ۵˥
    ηչоѧΪֵо˥ʱһѧڼֵϽȻͬѧɷչ
ԼѧɣϵۣΪ70۶ηչо˾޴Ӱ졣ȫʽҵ
͹ҿչйηչĿꡣ۵ĳ֣ʵͼشηչоеһؼ⣬
һۣڶ̶Ͽչڷᣬ˵ǷܹѷչйҵĹȥڵ״̬ͨ򵥵ġʷ
λơΪ൱ڷһ׶ʶȻ۵ĻشǷ񶨵ģ̬ʮּ
    ͬǶִо۵ķʡͱųʶ̬أоѧǿ˼ԸЩ
ΪҲǴӡʷۡ򡰷ǵʷۣʷۣתԻעμ޴Ұִ۵ķ⡷
5£1984 ꣨תࡶִʷ̽֡Ϻĳ磬1993꣬137 ҳѧȣ
۲ǴӾѧѧѧȶѧƽǶȶηչгҪþѧηչʶǿ
Һͷչй֮ľùϵԷչйηչֱӰ졣ڿʵȻǺġȣ۶ԡ
뷢չйĲࡱһͳ壬ע뷢չйĲࡱԮ197451ա
ϹԡһΡΪֹһ趨ֻһַչģʽֻһͨձ鸣ĵ·趨Ҫļ
ֵǰᣬҵзչˮƽӦ̬ӦչйΪģʽΪһĿԽܡĳϣ
ĿҲǲʵʵġӶɡĵ˵ľѧ۳ۼΪܰѵ翴ֻһ֡
״̬÷ҵľ⡢˵ΣȻᳫ̵ؾܾκԮѵʶԮ
ãǵʹչйܹܺõطչҪʹǵķչ֤ԷΪĹʾϵ֤
ǰշҵķչҪ־õزȶĹʷֹˣԮʹʹٶȼӿ죬ҲŤԮģʽ
Ӿ侭ʧ⣬ʹùԵԼԴѰԼķչ·ڿ˾۸ָΪ
ڷչйڷչսԺصĸáͬΪҶڷչйҵḣҲǱ״
ġ
    ͼִ֤˳УٷչйǺͷ֮Ĳ࣬ҪԮ˾
ţʵϲҪչйҸķչҪǸ⡰ȲǷչҲִֻ֮
һϷԵײײУƵǸʮֳصĴۡΪչйҹԮͶ
ԼΪչĿȻе¾ԪԵļӾ磬ҽʹչйľֵϵ
£չйϾͲطչеԽԽáԴˣۺ˴չйҵ
ʾþ֮쿴ɲǼ֮Ĳ졣Щܾס֮Ϊкھ
˵ܿʲô۸񣬶ûжϵٴȷ˵¾ɲͬܣһǲҪƽȵľ˫
ͬһܵܣһǸһһˣǰͷܣĲ޷ˡΪʹһ˷
һȡ׷֮УھܾעAԷչ1976 ꣨ת
ࡶִʷ̽֡Ϻĳ磬1993꣬137ҳ
    ӦóϣΪչоҪסӴˣѧҲܺѧѧѧҲӱܾѧ
ѧˡҲʹչоһעⷢҵԮóסͶԼ˾Ρ;úһ濪ʼھ
֮漰ľ÷⡣ǣҲصȱݣΪ˥Ҫԭͼڷչоа
ۣѧƼֵȻļֵжԴС󡱵ʶ̬ӡҳʶ̬ƫ
Ӧ˵ͼͬǲȡġϿͷǶġͻ״̬ĺͽ
ġǲûнγɸȻϵͳؼоûиչһȷĶ塣۱׼ȱʧͻң
۶ʵȷƬķʱ򻹿Լ⡢зչйʵϣ
©ٳʹۿۡѧ߶19461973Ԯµξýп죬۵Ԥì
ԽǿľϿǽռƶǽΪƽ෴иȶܷ塣ҳ
˺ܶ⣬忴Ǵڿֹ۵ķչ״̬һ80õӡ֤ҵרη׷׿̨ƶ
Խͬʱ෢չй綫СȶѸٷչˡЩǡǡҵͶʣ˾
ҡ۵ȱݺʵìܣܿͼŬηչֵܼжϵԸʹ۵80˥ȥ
ɥʧӰ
            Ļع飺ֵȡδȥ
    ۵ս˥䣬չйηչľֲɹʹηչо80ʼ淶оع飬ʼעе
ֵءһعľ־ѧĻˡ
    ͢ҪڡչĿ꡷һдԵչĿԼ˵֮صˡڷչĻ
⡱עѶ͢٣չĿ꡷1987꣨תࡶִʷ̽֡Ϻĳ磬1993
꣬350357ҳָĻһ״ġ۸ӵĸĳһοѧеʣ෶
Ի󱸸residual categoryʹȽס һʱǾͻעйѧ
ϷĻΪ䡱ָʲôӡ ǡޡںͽķչԼȡõĳɾ͵Ĳ죬Դڶ
ǡ޼ֵĲ죬ôоصӦ÷ĻıȽϷϡĻԷչľ޴ӰҪоηչѧ߶Ļ
ϵͳġġȽϵġо͢оٳҪľŸĻȺÿһĻȺǷصξ÷չ
ﵽĿģʽһ⡣ΪĸӦñ任չģʽʺϸĻִģʽٴǿִ
ڽһ˵ĻԽͲͬչģʽشϵӱϿ͢ٵĻ۾ζǴܵ
˺ݱȻĻģδͳͬȵҪԣҪǣоֻǽ֪͡
ʵģΪչйκڸĻϷչִƶṩ߽顣1993һ緶Χ졢й
Ҳй㷺Ӧġĳͻб˺͢һı⡣ע Huntington, Samuel P:"The Clash of Civization?"ForeignAff
airs,72(1993):2249 ĳͻһĵһϵͳȫرȽϷĻڸչ͹еıʽݡص㡢
ãĻӰδξҪ֮һĵѧֵǲݷϵģóĽȴ˺ܴ
顣ΪδͻʵϽ˹һ֮ͬĳͻ
    ΪֹתĻоηչʵѾٹעչˡԺ͢Ϊ׵ͻȻڴˡ1996
ˡĳͻؽһ飬ڡ⽻ơǶصģձġŽ
еĻͳԿִķԹŷˡעHuntington,Samuel P:The  West: Unique, not  Universal,
Foreign Affairs,November/December 1996.ɴ˿ɼ˵͢ٹ׻ߣ²Ϊ˵ηչо
۵̶ҲΪ
    ͻ۵ȱǺԵġȣȫ׿Ļγɵʷ󡢾ԵĻֺӡ
о⵽ŷ˼άƵעάƣ¿ѧѧ磬1987꣬134135ҳ
й¡³˺ȣĻˡ㽭1986꣬67ҳR.G.£ʷĹйѧ
1986꣬8990ҳȡΣͻƵǽϸġۡhypothetical corollary֮ϵġ͢
ʷԼõĶȻԳġĻһ䶯ŵĻʵ̣ʷԼļ򼸸
صܷ嶨ġκձ棬Ȼǳͻġעܺ롢͢ٵġĳͻ
ؽŷޡ19975ڣ8081ҳ ͬʱͷĻʷҲ˵֮ںϺԻǱ֮
ҡͻĸԴȪͻ۵ҲܿⲢҪҪľڣʵϰһ
ѹ۵ηչ۵Ӱں̶ܴΪսʱҺͷչй֮ĳͻṩΪ
ݡνѧƼֵĻع顱ηչоηأ
            
    Ҫ⵱ηչо֮Դ˼
        һѧΪһѧƶԡ
    ѧ˵ʷϣһֱŽȻͬںһɣһǹ淶ѧΪµжϲǿܵģʵ
ҲǱҪģʿµġѧǾԵӡʵ֤ѧȻѧΪģϮѧѧ˼룬
ΪʵͼֵǽȻͬģ˹Τĵ͡ηչоڿʼʱʵͼѧͳһ
ٵĸԴǡǡֳԵʧܣѧƼֵȡķֻ޷˥
    οѧΪѧڱǷܹСֵжϡһ⣬ѧһֱѡӿѧĽǶ˵οѧĿʵ
Եز󣬰һֿ͹۴ΪѧңΪΪǷԵģеж϶Եģ
ѧоҪǲܵġˣΪѧοѧңҲӦоֵ⡣Ȼı
Ȼ漰ֵ֡жϡ漰ԡԼһϵлͻĵҪˣΪоεοѧңòоЩ
Ҫֽɫìܹηչоֵȡֻڻʱʷ۵ķʡѧ
оơʾƵķ硱仯Լսʱȣڻ˹ؼãʹֻγɡ5060ڣ
ηչоοѧҾŷ룬ϣͨоչйʵηչо
ԭ򡣵չйҷչ˳״ʹǲþͿʼһֵжϡ60кں70ѧ߾跨Ѽֵжϣϣ
ֻоչйҵαǨʵֻǻرѡֵѧɣƺŬηչоļֵжϣ
ֵļֵжϱȱݣչйҵĽһķչʵ񶨣Ҳʧȥ˻ĺ͢ٵȶĻоӣȻ
ʹηչоʼӷĻֵӣȻΪģҵۺʵĽš
    ѧǲӦҲֵȡģͻɥʧΪѧƵΪû֤һ㣬ηչо
ҪľΪηչоѰѧΪηչоṩļֵͷۣʹηչʵ֤оϵ
ʵʵļִֵƫļֵȡȻ跴ʡͷѧľԭ
ֵĸֹ۵ʵϾֵձ͵ձԣضʵҲǿԻɵġΪ
ԭڽʵҲҪġͻصִѧıԴζҪ
м˵ϣͨƷͨǿȨУܹڷչйʵƶȡηչ
ʷԴ֤Խּ˵ķչԽпܵ¼˵ʧͽѧӦÿΪηչо
лۻʹ֮߳ҮԷ͵ĽֻĻĽ۱磬Ϊڼȷ
Խ۵Ψַԡɡ۵ǰṩ˽һķչռ䣬עϣ롤Үˣԭ
1997꣬Ͼ38ҳṩһӽǡ
        ڶηչΪʵԡ
    ηչӸϽ۵ͬʱҲʵΪǾԵġִһ
ȫϺʷ߼Ḷ́γΡáʷĻڽ̵صۺúͻЭ
ģʽȻǽɡȻչγɵģʽͬᾭñѿäĿظһձ
ʱʵͱԤˡͬķչ߼ȻͬĿꡣսȻչйھͬ羭
ϵΡʷĻľ޴죬·չйҵִߵȫͬʷĵ·
·ϣΪִδʵǲɱġΪαȻѸľ÷չϵìܡ
ηչоǡǡ߼ķѺͳͻһԸͼĿǿڷչйҶһɡʵ֤ʵ
ΪԨԴ
    ηչоӦһҪĽ׶ΡµηչоؼǻشִҪʲôλʲôβܴ
ִӦشض£ͨĵϵͳЭγϵӶƽ彡
չͬʱʵķչһ㣬ڵչйҡҶǺġ˵ȷһµѧĿܹʹηչ
ĻôҲһֵóԵ˼·
α༭
    
    
    
 
