 ׺ 6-1267
ԭĳŷ
ԭ
ԭںš199905
ԭҳš1425
  šD7
  
ӡںš199912
    еۣͬչ
    
߼顿1968ꡪ  ѧʹϵѧԺʿо
    ͨѶַ100871  ѧʹϵѧԺ97
Ҫͬǹεĺ֮һͳʵߵͬΪԾʵ塣ʮ
ͬоȡõҪչҪʵͬУԳɹСͬۡвۡԼԵϵ
ͬģʽоȡ봫ͳȣЩ۾иǿϵͳԺʵ֤ԡ
    µĹʵƶͽҲʼͬоǷֱƶȲ͹淶ͬͬˣΪͬ
оṩµӽǡƶͽͬۿֲʵĳЩ㣬µۺȻҪʵͬΪ

  ʡ/ͬ/ͬ
    
    ţD80  ױʶ룺A  ±ţ10049789199905001425
    ͬˣAllianceǹѧоĺ֮һע롰ͬˡͬĻСˡһʣΪͳһһʹáͬ
һʡԶϵ֮뷴˵Ķᴩ˹Ҽϵʷͬ˽Ľϵһ
˥Ľ״ֳԸʷʱڹʸֵӱֱӺԶӰ졣
    Ϊͬεϵڽܣɴ˽Ϊ롢綨ϵͳоѶȡʮһ״
˺̶ܴȵĸơڵѧۡʵϵУں˹Ħŵ¡ֶ˹Arnold WolfersͿ
˼ֶȵѧйͬĻϣѧΧͬ˵Դࡢṹܵһϵչҵۣ½Ƴһ
µоɹסʩε£Glenn H.SnyderġۣͬעGlenn H.Snyder, "The    Security   Dilemma  inAllianc
e Politics",World Politics,Vol.34,No.3,  July  1984, pp.461495.˹ٷҡֶأStephen M.Walt ġвۡbalan
ce-of-threat theoryͶԡƺ⡱balancing 롰ʹ桱bandwagoningͬ͵ıȽϷͽܿˡʩε£Th
omas J. Christensen & Jack Snyder һսǰ˩һͣchain-gangingͬ˺ͶսǰжΡͣbuck-   passin
g ֵͬϵȶͬģʽоȣעThomas J. Christensen and Jack Snyder,"Chain Gangs and  PassedBucks: Pred
icting   Alliance   Patterns    in   Multipolarity",International Organization,Vol.44,No.2( Spring 1990), pp. 137-168."chain-
ganging"һʱڹδʹãݰҿڼǶͬ˵ʶ
    սµʵһ̼ѧͬϵ۴¡µĹսԻ£սʱγɵĸͬˣ
ͻĵԼݺֽɫȻ쵼˺רѧߵĹעһԣʵ߶ͬ˵˴౧
ۺͻ̬ȣп˼ֶȵĹ۵ľߴԡۼսԼǰ;ʱ˵ʷǵ֪Ӯսʤ
ͬ˺ܿ壬ԽǾԵʤԽˡԼĽ壩ûռʱ򣬵Ѿ԰ˡע  Kenne
th  N.   Waltz,"The Emerging Structure of InternationalPolitics",in    Michael    E. Brown et al.(eds.),The Perils ofAnarchy:
 Contemporary   Realism  and  International   Security(Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press,1995),pp.73-74.Ȼ ٵĿǰΪֹ
ʵķչƺֶȵ˵Ԥкܴ롣սıԼûֵʧޣȴ˲òǿĵ·
ǵơ19964£ ˡȫϹͬԡٶ塣19979£ Ƴµġ
ָ롱ͬ˵õ˽һǿսͬʵֵַ֮أϣ  ʵ
ͬܵɣ   ƶ壨liberalinstitutionalismͽ壨constructivismͬʾڵļֵ
    ʵͬעȨϵͳṹͬƶͬǿΪһƶȣinstitution ͬ˽䱾
е   ͬӹ淶norm     ͬidentityĻĽǶʶͬˡǶսͬʵĽΪͬ
оṩµӽǣͬʱҲһ̶ֲʵͬ۵ĳЩȱݡ
    ڹеͬҪʵ۵Уע˹ٵǵойͳ417 ͬ˵Ĺѧ
⣬о󲿷ʵķ롣μOle R.  Holsti  etal.,Unity and Disintegration in International Alliances  ( NewYor
k:John Wiley & Sons,1973),pp.249-283.Ա߽ܵصҲڴˡ
            һͬ˵Ķ
    ͬ˵ĺƺ˽֪ҪҵһΪձܵĶȴ¡ڴ˽ܼѧ羭áȽдԵĶ
塣
    ŵ¡ֶ˹ΪͬˡһʱʾȨ֮Ĺ໥оԮĳŵֳŵЩɢ
ЭͬһǩֳŵľЭұʽŵһ빲ͬĵսעSee Arnold Wolfers,"Alliances,"in
 David L. Sills(ed.),International Encyclopedia of  SocialSciences(New York:Macmillan,1968),pp.268-269. סʩεͬ
ȷΪΪάԱİȫȨƶɵĹʹãʹãʽĹϣassociations
ضңЩǷѱȷȷϡ עGle   nn H. Snyder,"Alliance Theory:A Neorealist First Cut, "Journal of In
ternational Affairs,Vol.44,No.1(Spring 1990),p.104.
    ֮£˹ٷҡֶضͬ˵Ľ綨ҪһЩͬȨ֮ڰȫʽʽ
İšǰ߲ͬǣֶؽʽİȫҲͬ˵һʽ֮޽ʽԼЭǽͬ˵ıҪ
ֶڽԭʱ˵ڵҶԸ˹޽ʽԼ罫оʽͬ˽ɥʧһ
ֵоңϸʽͷʽͬ˻ܻʹ;磬ɫ֮䲢ʽͬԼû˻
Ǳ˴֮ĳŵ1971ꡰհѺúԼǩʵͰŹϵӾı־˫˴˳ŵǿϵ֤
עWalt,The Origins of Alliances,p.12. ֶصĹ۵Ӧ˵һ޲ء˹ŵ£Robert Osgood ԣͬ˵
ȫʵʺʽľºЭԼб¶ʵʺڻ֤еõһ      עRobertOsgood,Alli
ances and American  Foreign  Policy( Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press,1968),p.18.ǣûл֤޷ȷһ
˵Ļ״һûʽЭ£ʲôһǷѾأͬ˶еһ⡣Ϊˣסʩε½
ٶͬ˽нһķ࣬Աʹͬ˶עSnyder,"Alliance Theory:A Neorealist First Cut,"p.105.
    ܴһЩ磬ͬ˵ĶϾǹ֮ͬӶࡣڣȣͬ˵Ȩңʽ
֯Σͬ˵ĺǳԱڰȫ;ڵĺŵͨʹԱض¸ʹûʹ
ʹͬбЩҼľ֯ŷˣҲбЩҼ֯ӢٴΣͬͨĳһĳЩض
ʹͬȻбЩձԵļ尲ȫ֯ϹȡЩʶʹǶͬ˵ںһʶ
            ͳʵͬ˼
    ѧΪһŶѧƵһδսոս֮ڵʱ˼սΧѧʢеĻ£ͬ˱
ǿս֮һ⵽㷺ָ𡣵ͬڶսȡʤӵľ޴ãͬ˵תķ档ս
ѧλʵ۶ͬоʮӡһЩͳʵҪĦֶ˹˹ȶ
ͬרмֵ˼롣
    Ħ侭ҼΡԼͬ˵ʵһУͬ˵һʽ˿죨ע˹ĦҼ
뱾й񹫰ѧ1990棬 235 250 ҳHans J. Morgenthau, "Alliances  in  Theory  and  Practice, "in Arn
old Wolfers ed.,Alliance Policy in the Cold War( Baltimore,MD:The Johns Hopkins Press,1959),pp.184-212.Ϊ ͬ
ܲɷ֡һһһͬһ֮ͬʷҪıʽڶϵУྺA
BΪȷԵȨλ3 ѡһԼȨҵȨԼȨϣ
ֹҵȨӵֵȨϡһѡʱоڶ͵ѡʱִͬ
һǷȡ߲ͬһԭ⣬Ȩ֮ƣexpediencyͨ޽ԼʹҼȴĹͬԼӦ߼ʵ
ʩȷܷͬάϵȡ˹ĻǷһ¡Ħ5ֲͬı׼ͬ˽˷࣬ ԮʷʵӦ
˵ע˹Ħǰ飬235237ҳѧְͬ˵Ĺ̬ƺƶȻĳ̶Ƚͬ˷Ϊͬˣı
״ͬˣͷͬˣά״ͬˣԼƶȻͬ˺ͷƶȻͬˣעSee Wolfers,"Alliances," p.270;and Osgood,o
p.cit.p.18,25.
    ͬ˵Ĺܺã˹ŵΪһԷΪ4 ųķ棬Ȩӡڲİȫ˹ԼԼ
Ӱ졣еһͬԶ׼ĹܣڶܶСҪʱᳬһΪͬ˶Ȩȶ
ܴӰ죻ܵͻԽڵһͬ˿ԼͿ˹жرǷֹ˹ȡ𺦱˴Ͱȫ
жάֹͬ㷺ϵġͬʱҲ״ﵽĹܣսӢĹͬӹֹܣֹ
ʽǼ尲ȫעSee Osgood,ibid.,pp.21- 22.ֶ˹ѵָκͬ˶һԵĺ£ĳЩ
£ͬ˶ԹԿһֺķѶһֲ䣬κνṩԮĳŵвȷԡ˴ĺôǣһ
Ҫһָ˹ľԮڳͻ֮ǰ壻֮ҪڣһһͻԮ
ʹϸشӱùӦýⳡͻעWolfers,"Alliances,"p.269.
    ͬ뼯尲ȫĹϵǴͳʵͬ۹ĵһҪ⡣ⷽΪٵĴŻҪֶ˹ֶ˹
Ȼͬ˺ͼ尲ȫĳЩй֮ͬԱŵҪԮܹԱܹĹҲָԮǿ
Ե߾ͼжʽȴȻͬ ֮໥ֻһ˵ɺϡ עArnol
d   Wolfers,  Discord   and   Collaboration:  Essays   onInternational Politics(Baltimore:The  Johns Hopkins Press), pp.182-1
83.ͬ˺ͼ尲ȫĲ֮ͬڣ ǰԳԱĳһ֣ܳ⽻ĿǣֵֿܲδͬЭУ
ҳԱ֮ڵԵ綨ҪΣգӶܹڳͻ֮ǰƶսԲӦľ׼֮£尲ȫ
κεص㷴κΪĹңʹʱһò뱾ֱӵĶЯֺ߿һɿ˹עIbid.
,pp.183-189.ֶ˹ΪʵУ û׼ĹսԣϣձԵĹ
֯˫ԮЭ뷨ֻһֻþעArnold Wolfers,"Alliances,"p.270.
    ⣬ͳʵ߻ͬʶ̬ĹϵͬͲ˵ĹϵͬߵӰ졢Сʹͬսϴ
Ĳ֣̽   ˲мֵ⣨עSeeLiska,op.cit.,pp.61-69,202-254,pp.269-284;Wolfers, Discord andCol
laboration,pp.217-229;and Robert  L.   Rothstein, Alliancesand Small Powers(New York:Columbia University Press,1968).
    ܵ˵ͳʵ߶ͬ˵۴Ǵ۳еġ˹ԣͬԸĳ˻ĳµģ֧ĳ
˻ĳֻǴġĦҲΪͬ˱ȻڶϵһעLiska,p. 12;  Morgenthau,"A
lliances in Theory and Practice,"p.185.ͳʵ߶ͬ˵һȽϽǿͬһֶζһĿģ
õãҲ𲻺õãԲáͳʵ߹ͬ˵۵ֱ쿴ԲʧΪ֪Ƽǵͬ
оܻľԣرǡٶԸһԵļṩϵͳԵ֤עWalt,   The    Origins    ofAllianc
es,p.7.ǵͬ˼ΪԺͬо춨˻
            ʵͬ
    νʵָ70Կ˼ֶΪĹѧ߶ԴͳʵԽṹµʵ
˼ҪֶȵġۡһС봫ͳʵȣʵ屣ʵΣRealpolitik Ҫݣ
شȣͳʵΪҾҪϵıȨȨΪĿıֶΪ
ҵĿǰȫȨֻǴﵽĿֶ֮һΣҲǸΪҪһ㣬ǰߴӸ˺͹ҵΪ໥ĺѰ
ԭҪ֮ͨĲκΪ֮ͨ໥γһֽṹҵΪֽṹ
Ӱ졣ϵеĹңΪͺҪӹڲԣλͣҲҪӽṹܹͣȫذ
չϵڵı仯עμ˼ֶȣۡİԡ
    ֶȲδͬϵͳĽṹۡϵͶ༫ϵķԼһЩͬصȴѧߵ
оԼӰϡЩѧаǰͬоʮֻԾĸסʩε¡˹ٷҡֶءͽܿˡʩεµˣ
ڽʮнͬоһ롣
        1.סʩεºͬ͡
    סʩε¶ͬ۵Ҫԡͬо  ڷͬ˳Ա֮Ĺϵʱ  ˶¶ķM
ichael MandelbaumڷԹεӰʱʹõġ    abandonment͡ǣentrapment ע  
 Michael     Mandelbaum,The Nuclear Revolution:International Politics   Before   and    After Hiroshima(New York:Cambridge Un
iversity  Press,1981),chap.6.ʽжֶ˵˹Լйˡڶ༫ϵͬ˴Ǿ
ȹ̵ģԱԼ˹ĵҲǴڵġǣζ˹ϽһͻЩ汾ȴֻܹ
ֹʩεָκν˵ĹҶɱҪڱ͡ǣ֮Ȩ⡣˹ļֵⱻ
ǣһ롰ġĹһױ˹Ͻһϣ߲Ȼսȥ෴һܡǣ
˹ĹҪð˹ķա֮Ȩ⣿㹹ˡͬĵһ㺬塣ͬĵڶ
㺬ǣһΪⱻѡǿͬˣǱпֵĵ⣬ӶӾžƣͷԸΥһѡͬ
ֿܴʹЩĿĶֵôߡͬ˲˹֮ĲģͬʱҲֹ֮ĲģҪ£ע Gl
enn H. Snyder,"The Security Dilemma in AlliancePolitics,"pp. 466-467 and p.494.
    סʩε»ȽͶ༫״̬¡ͬĲ졣ָϵ£˹ķҪȶ༫ϵСö
ԡͬôأڴйĹϵʱ˹֮ԷжìܵߣôĻ֮
ʩε۷80ŷ˹֮г̵ΣΪֻҪϵĽṹ仯Լ
Եı仯עIbid.,pp. 483 489  and  pp.494495.ӸסʩεµпǿҵظֶܵȵӰ졣
        2.ֶصġвۡ
    ڡۡһУֶСʹ桱ΪģʽоעֶȽһ鹦˹ٷҡ
Stephen Van Evera μKenneth  Waltz, Theory  ofInternational Politics(Reading,Mass.:Addison Wesley, 1979) , p.12
6.¶ʩΤգRandall SchwellerĿ֤ʹá  ʹ һͬΪѧأ   QuincyWrig
htǰֶ˹ҲʹùʡֶȰѡʹ桱ƺһֽģʽʹָ뵽ǿһ
ƺָһˡֶΪڸ׷Ŀǰȫάڹϵеĵλ޶ȵԼȨ
໥ƺǿʹǹϵиΪɵؽѡĻǻӿһΪǽǿ
һŶǲвעֶȣۡ뱾152153ҳ
    ֶؽֶĻ۵㣬ƺǱȿʹһΪͬʱҲֶȵз⡣ֶȶ
ϵֲǿֶָս֮ڸ涼Ҫǿ󣬡ֻƽȨǱӦڵ
ȥ˲ŶԡעWalt,Origins of  Alliances,  p.275.ʵˣ бҪԴǰΧչͬ
ۼ
    ֶΪͬоУȨһҪأΨһء֮Խˣȷе˵ǶԡвһַӦ
šвˡȨ⡱͡ʹ桱ںҲ˱仯ֶصĶ壬⡱ָвĹһ
ҽʩвĹҡʹ桱ָвĹһвԵĹҽˡһǷвԣ
Ҫ4ۺϹԵڽԡ ԼͼעIbid.,pp.2128,and p.32.ʵϣ ҽԶԸ
вĹ۵ֶ֮ǰѧ μWolfers,Discord and Collaboration,p.183;Rothstein,op.cit.,p.53,pp.58-59;and Ho
lsti et al.,op.cit.,p.88֮ϵͳ ۻĹȴֶɵġҲ˵вɿ͹ԵԵͼ
ؽ϶γɵġ
    ֶؼ̶гڹͬ˵5裺1ҽԶԿв⣩2вˣʹ棩3
ӵйͬʶ̬Ĺҽˣ4 ṩԮĹҽˣ5 ͬЩɹض͸εĹҽ
ˣעIbid.,chapter 2,pp.17-49. Ϊ˶ЩЧԺҪԼֶض19551979жͬݱ
ϵͳ죬óۣȣвǽ˵ҪԭΣвҵĽΪͨƺǿʹ
ʶ̬Ԯ͸ͬγɹ൱ޣעIbid.,pp.263-269.ֶص۱Ϊв
ۡ
    ֶر˵ģвۡǶԴͳ۵һָĽעIbid.,p.263.ԽΪʲôһȥ˶
ǿĹңȨʹΪΣյĹңҿԽΪʲôһȥ˷һһǿġΪ
вԵĹҡͬʱڸ۽ϵͳʵ֤Ļ֮ϣнǿ˵עֶڡͬ˵Դһйж
36ͬ˵ֶ⼸Ľ˿죬һӡ֤ۡμStephen  M.   Walt, "Testing Theori
es of Alliance Formation:The  Case  of  Southwest  Asia," International Organization,Vol.43,No.2(Spring 1988),pp. 275-316;Wal
t,"Alliances,Threats,and U.S. Grand Strategy: A  Replyto  Kaufman and Labs,"Security Studies,Vol.1,No.3(Spring 1992),pp.448-4
82.ˣֶص۲ûߡ
    еѧָƺ⡪ʹַںܶ⣬ҵĽѡʵϲֹ֣⽻ʷвƺЭһ
ӣעGlenn H. Snyder,"Alliances,Balances,and  Stability,"p.128.еѧΪֶص۵͹˹ͬ˾
ãЩسӰѡһ͵ͬˣעⷽ׿ɲοʩΤейע͡See Randall  L.Schwel
ler, "Bandwagoning  for  Profit: Bring  the  Revisionist State Back In,"in Michael E. Brown et al.(eds.),op.cit.,p.251,fn.9 a
nd fn.10.еѧ˵ʵʹֶصȫû漰ƶȶͬ˵Ӱ죨עRobert   O.    Keohane,"Allian
ces,Threats,and the Uses of Neorealism, "InternationalSecurity,Vol.13,No.1(Summer 1988),pp.174175.
    ΪֹжԡвۡУ ¶ ʩΤգRandall SchwellerΪġʩΤտ 
ֶػֶȶһǾǰƺͿʹ濴ΪȫĿʹ໥Ϊֶؽѿʹ
ڹȻвʩӹһӦֻЩ漰شвͬˣȻصóƺ
ͬռĽۡʵϣͬ˲ǶвķӦͬʱҲǶԻķӦҳвʱܻῴʹ棬Ϊ
󱾹ءؿʹ档ֶصУʹΪĻһвʩӹͬѡض
ˡʵϣʹΪֶܱػֶҪöࣨעSchweller,"Bandwagoning for Profit,"pp.251252,p.256 a
nd p.270.ֵעǣʩΤղûжԿʹ͵ͬ˱ƺ͵ͬ˸ձ顣ʩΤսһҿԷΪά״
ңrevisionistࡣ ά״һ˵ƺѰȫϣԼĲƸȨ
ڷս߿ʹ棬뵽ǿԹһȥȡ档ʵ߶ԹҵĲͬ󲻼ֻ֣ǿȫ Ӷ
һ֡ά״ƫthe  status-  quobias  ƫǵ¡вۡԭעIbid., p. 262. 
ʩΤնԡά״ƫ μRandall  L. Schweller, "Neorealism's  Status- Quo  Bias:  What Security   Dilemm
a? "in  Benjamin  Frankel( ed. )  ,  Realism:Restatements   and Renewal (London:Frank Cass,1996),pp.90-121.
        3. ˩һchain- ganging ͡жΡbuck-passing
    ֤ϵȶ༫ϵȶʱֶᵽڶ༫ϵУҺ׷ִ󣬴Ӷ¾ϵֲȶһִ
Ϊ˹ԾƵάֱز٣ӶذԼ벻ƺ˹˩һΪģʽ˵һսı
һִǣжΣָеǿȨķգս֮ǰˣעWaltz,   Theory    of    InternationalPolit
ics,p.67 and pp.165169.
    ֶȲûнһ͵ʲôԭʽȻ෴ѣһҪǲԶġҪ͡Ԥ
ƶĳضµͬսԣͱΣоһָܷѧ߿ͽܿˡʩε
ⷽоܵѧĹע
    ͽܿˡʩε½ֶᵽֱΪ˩һ͡жΡעChristensen  and  Snyder,
"Chain Gangs and Passed Bucks,"pp.140-141. Ϊ˶Խͣǽ޲ءά˹Robert Jervis ȫۣע
Robert  Jervis, "Cooperation  under  the  Security   Dilemma,"World Politics,Vol.30,No.2,pp.167-214.еһǽṹ
˹ڽսԺͷսЧԵĹ뵽ֶȵĽṹ۵УԼۿܡǵҪ۵ǣڶ༫
£쵼ΪԵľսԸΪЧôҼɽͬˣ˩һͳͻѸĿԾʹ󣻷
֮쵼ΪΪЧǱͼڶԿսߵĴת޵ϣжΡۡ͡
ۡγҪȡϵͳĹϵԼʷϵĽѵرϴδսĽѵ˵һԾϵͳƽ
ǿ߸ùΪȡսʤľ飬ôڡۡγɣһԽϴ󣬻߸ùΪ
ȡսʤľ飬ôۡγɵĿԾͱȽϴעChristensen  and  Snyder, "  Chain  Gangs  andPassed Bucks,"p
p.144147.
    Ϊ۵֤ͽܿˡʩε·ֱһսͶսǰ¡ӢĹ쵼˵ĽͬսԽ
˿졣սԽͷЧԵĲͬδս֮ǰͬսԺͬģʽĽȻͬ1914꣬
ΪȡսپʤǿܵġΪ˱־ƽⲢӰսսΪǱȽɽܵͬ˲һʼ
ȫԸͶս⵼һսǰ˩һ͵ͬģʽ30ڵ෴ھ19141918Ѫȵĺ
ǵսս֮󣬸쵼ţѶġΪͻʼϹۣĺս߾ƣʱٳʰо
Ϊϲߡֹ˶սǰɴ¹ĴʳԱֳٶۡ໥жεԺעIbid.,pp.147167.
    ͽܿˡʩε¶ƻϵȶͬģʽоֲֶ۵Ĳ㣬һḻʵͬۡ봫
ͳʵͬȣʵͬϵͳԡʵ֤Իȷ涼ȡԵĽչ
            ġʵͬ۵뷴
    뵱ǰʵ塢ͽ3 ַʽ״Ӧעڹʵ塢ͽ
3 ַʽıȽϣ μStephen  M.     Walt,  "International Relations:One World,Many Theories,"Foreign Policy(Spring 1998),p
p.29-46. ʵͬ۵ҲҪƶͽ档սʵʵ֮ͬĲ࣬Ϊ
ƶͽͬʵ۵ĴͳؽṩһõĻᡣΧƱԼڻԼɢв
ǵûû෴ȴʮֻԾһʵͬԽ͵ƶߺͽ߷ͬϵĿ
    ƶΪʵֻͬעͬȨвսԼϵͳṹ֮ĹϵȴٰͬΪһƶ
оԼ߶ƶȻͬѾʷֻһֽԼͬкܴ𣨱ԼġƶȻҪӵʽĹŻ
ûӵһ׸ӵľ߳ͶĹܣͬ۱뿼ƶزܶԵǰԼ״ŷĽͣ  עKeoha
ne,"Alliances,Threats,and the Use of Neorealism, "p.  174;and Robert B. McCalla,"NATO's Persistence after the Cold  War,"Inte
rnational Organization,Vol.50,No.3,(Summer 1996),pp. 445475.
    ƶ߿ƶȻ֮ͬҪΪƶȻ¼ͬ˵ĴҪӰ졣ȣƶȻһ
ҵǰ;ͬ˽ľӢʿӢʿɵԱԭвɥʧͬ˴ĲӰ졣ΣҲǸΪҪ
һ㣬ЩûγһӦĹ淶͹ܵͬȣ߶ƶȻͬ˶ڻ仯ӦԸǿҲǿƶȻ
ͬ˳Ա֮Ľ׳ɱٽԱĺӶʵ档ڽµƶͨҪĳɱԳԱ
ȶԭеĳɹƶȼԸáԭеƶȹܹܶµƶµĹôƶȱάȥ
    ͬϣ߹ĵǹ淶ͬĻȷͬγɹáͷڹеӰ죬
ĴɽأAlexander Wendt ٹһͨ׶ӣӢӵ500öʲô 
ֻӵ5 öҲԲעAlexander    Wendt,"Constructing International Politics,"International  Security,Vol.
20,No.1(Summer 1995),p.73.Ϊ ֲֻͬǲģȷвѡһЩ˵Ĺؼ
ӹ淶͹ͬĽǶȼԿ죨ע  Michael   N.Barnett,"Identity and Alliances in the Middle East, "in  PeterJ. Katz
enstein (ed.),The  Culture  of  National  Security( NewYork:Columbia University Press,1996),p.401.
    ʵͬУֶصġвۡˡͼض𽨹ߵرעΪ
ǰʵֶۣͬصһǣͼʲôأвĹγɵأ
ֶزûиһĻش𣬶ǽҪ⣨עTed  Hopf, "The  Promise  of  Constructivism  in Inte
rnational Relation Theory,"International Security,Vol. 23,No.1(summer 1998),pp.186187;and Barnett,ibid.,pp.403404.
ѧֶָصڹʶ̬в÷⡣ǰʶ̬һӰв綨ļֵ
ϵĻôֶصĽ۱ҪһãΪʶ̬ŽͰȫ֮Ȩʱɱ㲢ǵʶ
̬ϲõġ    ע Peter     J.    Katzenstein,"Introduction:Alternative Perspectives on  National  Security,"in Katzenst
ein(ed.),op.cit.,p.28.
    ǽЩոһѧɣԸΪеʵ֤Եͬо  ˹ Thomas    Risse-
  Kappen ԱԼķбȽдԵһעThomasRisse- Kappen,"Collective Identity in a  Democratic  Community:T
he  Case of NATO,"in Peter J. Katzenstein(ed.),op. cit. , pp.355-399.У ѽӰġ
ƽۡƶۺͽ߽ԱԼĲͷչڹ͡˼·ǣ1 ֮伫ٷ
սΪǶѶԷǺƽҡ֮԰ѶԷΪƽΪھ߹һ淶2 ͬ
ԭЩ֮γ˾йֵͬĶԪȫͬ塣3 ӶԷΪƽҺͱֳĹͬʶʹпܿ˷
ЩаʺϰγͬĹƶȡ4 ƶжԸ໥üԹЩ淶Ӧ÷ӳеֵ
ۣڸڵľ߹淶5 Щ淶һǿΪĹͬʶͼͬԼչʷΪ
ɽṩһעšսĽζ淶ļǿֵ֮ͬİȫ
ϵֻƶȻʽȥעIbid.,p.371 and p.397.
    ƶͽ󲿷ʵ߲ȡյ̬ȣעʵߣԼ׶˹ĬֱԲ
ָƶȺٶԹΪʲôԵӰ죬ȱʵ֤ҲԤδμJohn J.  Mearsheimer,  
 "The   False   Promise   of   International    Institution,"International Security,Vol.19,No.3 (Winter 1994-95 ) , p. 47;and
 "A Realist Reply,"International Security, Vol.  20, No. 1(summer 1995),pp.9192.ֶسϡƶȻͬ͡ػͬ
˵άֲһӰ죬ͬʱָ߶ȵƶȻһЧʣһڸ⣬ʹͬ˲֪ȻԼְ
ѳɹʵȫơתӳԶ·δߵͨʷЩּҼͻĻƣ硰ŷ
ЭϹȶδֹȨεĻع顣ƿڽ񡢹ʿֲһЩС⣬
ǲ߱ҪȡжֻԱ漰شȫʱرǵĳЩؼԱԸȡжʱƻܷ
þͺܳˡ⣬ԼĿǰڴȫϱֳԱ40ĽֺضĹʽṹ
Ĳľ´зرҪáûЩڵġȫơǷܼưȫ˻
ɣעStephen  M.   Walt, "Why   Alliances Endure or Collapse,"Survival,Vol.39,No.1(Spring 1997),pp. 166-167.
    ͬ͹ͬʶֶΪĳЩҼ乲ͬʶȷʵڴϵҪСöࡣ
ʹŷһ廯̶ߵĵҲûж֤ݱԸιͬҳȡ˱˼롣Ȼ
Ȼͻʱ໥ǿһͻ쵼˽ȿǱ档ߣȻһڴڵͬ˻
Ա֮һֹͬʶֹͬʶҲܻӻͬ˵Ľ壬ƶһͬ͹ͬʶҲǻĲҵ
仯ֹͬʶ͹еͬͬûǿʹ淢ͻʱԲȡжĳ̶ȣעIbid.,pp.169
170.еѧߴӷ۵ĽǶȶԽߵͬоѡĸɣѡԼ֤ͬ۱
⣺۲ܽΪʲôϣôɵĹҲڱԼУעMichael     C.   Desch, "CultureClash:Assessi
ng the Importance of Ideas in   Security  Studies,"International Security,Vol.23,No.1(Summer 1998),p.165.
              
    ͬǳӡͬǹεһӰ۾ʵ˵Ǿ˵ˡ
    ڶԹеͬоһԵĿ֮󣬿ԿʵͬоȻλͳʵ
ͬǿͬĹϵһʵһеʷк̵˼Ϊͬо춨ۻ
ǵͬ˵ʱĿ飬ֱʾʵ߶Դͳʵͬ۽˲ٸ죬봫ͳ
ѧȣǸרעͬоĳ棬ͨһЩµĸͱչֹͬ˵רۣpartial theoriesЩ
ϵͳԡʵ֤ǿӲͬķǶͬ˵ʶƶͽߴƶȲ͹淶ͬͬˣǵ
۵һ̶ֲʵͬ۵ĳЩȱݡҪϵۡкۺϣȡ̣ܸõؽͱ仯硣
ۺҪаԵ۾ͬ۵Ĺͷչ̣Ǿ۵Ľ÷ΧĿǰܹṩһ
ֻʵۡ
    ͬ˽ۺһѵ顣֮߳Ϊƽıϡͬĵ䷶ָ֮Ӿ˽žƣӦöս
Ϊ˱ͬ˲⣬ǿһʵͬϵļʶҲǱҪģ1κͬ˶бף2ͬǹ
һ׶ԭעWolfers,"Alliances,"p.270.3ֻͬһֹߣνû4ͬ˵ҪӾ
һŶۡһԿ϶һսʱ˽ѡ񣬶ͬڻֹԷȷʵԷӹؼ
ãעMorgenthau,"Alliances in Theory and  Practice,"p.212;and Wolfers,ibid.
    ոڣ19990817
α༭
    
    
    
 
