 ׺ 1-968
ԭĳȻ֤ͨѶ
ԭ
ԭںš199702
ԭҳš24-30
  šB2
  ѧѧ
ӡںš199706
    ѧѧƼ  һֿѧѧ
    ˼塱ڿѧЧӦĹ۵
ڡոڣ1996319
    
߼顿1959Ŵѧѧϵڣѧʿʱࣺ361005
ժ Ҫ ⡿˼塱ڿѧЧӦرǷ˸ѧɹڵѧһ¿ʽĹ۵㡣
ָܡ˼塱۴ֲ㣬ǽ̽˵ѧ֮໥ϵ⣬һֶص
ѧѧۣȫʶѧεĹϵַӿѧãһĲοֵ
  ʡ˼  ѧ  ЧӦ
    
    ѧ֮ĹϵǿѧЧӦǿѧ۵һҪ档ڹ⣬ΧƿѧεĹϵ
γһѧƣѧѧ˼塱رǷ˸ѧɽע⵽⣬оѧ
ЧӦ棬һضӰĹ۵㣬Ŀѧȡ˴ͳοֲֶζһµͳλʽǽ
˼塱رǷ˸ѧɵⷽ۵㡣
    ¬ڡʷͽ׼ʶһѾ漰ѧЧӦ⡣ΪѧʶĹӦȻʱֻƶ
ѧĽӦʱתΪʲ׼˼[]ִѧԽչԽӣķȻԽã
ԽԶԽΪƬġյġ޹صĶҲһרŻƻ󡱣ʵ˺Ƭʹ
λɢ[]¬ʵϰѿѧﻯʽУΪʲ׼һ潫ѧͿȻ
ߣһֽǱ˶ͳεЧֶΣѧʲ׼İףʱᣬѧԽչܰѹȾ
Խѧʱì컯һ¬Ȼע⵽ʲ׼ѧͳιߵʵ
˿ѧͳ֮Ĺϵ⡣
    ˸ѧ¬˼봫ͳԿѧͳ֮Ĺϵȫоѧ۵һ⡣˺
ĬͰŵڡɵı֤һΪſѧĽ˶ȻĿǿˣֿ˶˵ͳΪ
۵ģѧ˿ȻĹߣ˶ͳεֶΡǿڵᣬͳεԭѷ˱仯ԭ
ҰͳλһָͳΣѧֶΣͳν׼־ڻΪһἰѾΪµ
ʽ˺ĬͰŵĻ۶ǡĻԭͳεĻԭΪԹ߲ȻԼĽ
ЧʵΪԻ׼Ȿ˶Ȼͳոʱڿʼڿѧͳεֱᣬ
ſѧķչԽԽӡȷ¶˵ūۺͿǿɻݵĶѧ
˶˵ͳ˶Ȼͳκ˶˵ͳγ˵ͳν²֮ԵĺԱͳεĺԡ
    ͬʱڵرǡִĳЩں˹ΤеĹҵʱ塷ȵˡ
췴ȶ漰⡣ȷڵ﹤ҵᣬѧΪһµĿʽ⣬ҶԴϸķ
֤ѷ﹤ҵᶨΪװáΪڼͽṹõͳƶȡΪѧѾ
׼ĿнѳΪͳεƣļѾչľṹΪ֯ͳԭ򡣷˵ĹͲݸȾ
ϵͳⲻڼӦõľĿϣڼԴϣڻоˮƽϣˡԶļԵĳһ
صͳʽȻԿƺͶԹ̵ĹſƣͨϣͨƫЧѹƣʵϲ⵽Ե
ҸʶĻھáκĻϷĹƺͽ˼
    ڡִĳЩںһУ˼ͼαͳιߵģִҵ֯
ҪЧʺͼЧķӵġڡ˹ΤеĹҵʱ塷һͨΤʱ塢Ժͳ֮ϵ˼
ļһͳֶΣԾͳκԵĹ۵㡣˵ӦöҼǣȻ˵
ͳΡмƻġѧġɿġصĿơͳεĿĺ沢ǡ󡯻ڵǿڼģǽ뼼
һʷһṢ́̇һͳͶ˺鶼šһͳΡĿġǡʵʵġ
ΧڼԵʽ[]Եģͳһضԡ[]
    ڡȵˡرǵԺ͵һ£ǡƵʽУר⡣Ϊڷ﹤ҵ
ᣬչϵͳһЩȨʽЩʽϵͳܻ򲵵ΪūۺͿƶ
п顣[]ڹҵᣬͷļֶβΪηֿĴܺͣΪؾЩֶ
ʹúͷЩֶεĲϵͳתļֶβҪְҵܡ̬ȣҾŸ˵Ҫ־򡣼
ġĴͳѲӦӦ޷ֿˣڱһȨߣһϵͳѾ
˼ͽṹתΪ磬﹤ҵһ磬һصĹ滮ܳ˵жĻĻ
̬ڼнУĻκ;ܺΪһڵϵͳһϵͳͬųеǱڵȶ
ᣬͬʱѼӦͳεĿУԱͳεԡߵ׼˫ػϣ
﹤ҵüǿֲֶ[]
    ˶ԣڷ﹤ҵᣬƵʽµǼʽ[]죬ȨͻرΪԻ
͹һ֯Ĳݣ﹤ҵͷչеĹҵֻеܹɹضԱ֯ùҵеļ
ѧͻеʱάֲԼͳΣ[]µĿʽǣʹÿѧֶΣ˵ϵͳ
Ĳݻƣγɶ˵ıܵһ֡ѹ֡Ҳ˵ѡΡ˼ʹϵĻǵ˽
еȷȫġҵѧĲݻƣӶϵеƶСˡĺԡƽ
ƽȡĲɡ״ΪƵʽҲζż컯˵еļ̱Ӧ
ʹ˳ԽȻʹĽṹķ淢չʹ˴ǿӸĸֹŹֵҪнųʹ˷
ԺʹԣⱾǷ﹤ҵĿ꣬Եյ㡣Ȼʵȴ෴ռϷ磬ֶΰľúҪǿ
ӸɺͶʱ䣬ǿӸʵĺ;Ļ˵ᡢ˼˼άʽ˼ȨߡƵʽͷ﹤ҵ
컯ҪԴ
    ڡ췴һУ漰һ⡣һĹʽʱķһʽ
Ƹֵū۵չ[]ΪӹϿ֯򡢹
һ͸˵Ͷʱ䡢Ͼʱ䣬ҰѲڹ̵칤ˣ󵽹֪ʶӺͰײ㣻Ͽ
ܵԽԽרҵѧʵľμҺͽǵĿƣˡꡪ˻ϵв
ļְܣкǶ˹ˣԣڼεĻ󣬳ֳһʵȫūۣ
ϵɥʧ[]
    ˹ڿѧЧӦĿ˺Ĭ˵Ĺ۵һеġͬѧͳιߡڡΪ
ʶ̬ļͿѧһУ˿Ƽͳκ⣬رΤġ۵˵ڿѧʹʱ
ͳκĹ۵㡣˵ʹӺߵķΧΣʹͶҵǹԵĻ
򡣡[]Τֺ˵ͳÿѧĳɹ֯һЩֶΡµѡ񣬴ﵽġĿĻ
ѧ뵽֯Уıɵƶȣʹʱǣ˹ΤĹ۵㣬䲻ͬΤԡ
ЧķΪע⵽ѧ˺Ŀá˵Τ˵ֺǺԵʵ֣
˵úԵʵûйϵƶȵһرʽ[]һ˸ѧɴʱ˶Ȼ
ͳκ˶˵ͳ໥ϵŵͳΪĹ۵㣬˹ΪֺĿĻʵֿƣȿȻֿ
ؼǿѧĽʹ˵ͳΡ˵ϣҲʹ˵Ĳɱ÷ǳ֤ʹ˲
ΪģܾԼɼȲΪģҲΪεġ˵ǱΪӼƵġ[]Ȼ
˵ܿءԷӼƵʽ֣ôܿءɾͱáˡˣóۣĺԲȡͳ
ĺԣǱֺԣſѧĲϽͳһļȨᡱ[]
    һЩġ˼塱ɼҲۼѧͳιϵ⡣磬̬ѧ˼塱Ҫס
˹ڡȻͳΡһоͼ̳кͷ˷˸ѧɵĵѧһ¿ʽͳʽĹ۵㣬ǡ
ȻĹϣִʷ֮һȻͿ֮Ĳɷָϵ[]ΪȻ
ļǿת˶˵ͳΣ෴ӾͳΡͳεϵƣѧΪȻĹαɿ
˵ֶεġΪؼн黷ǼüȻͶȻԴз䣬˵ճӰ죬
ʹѧĺ͸֮С˹Ϊ໥ϵһǡʵֱϵؾ
ͨչʵֵĿƣͻ֮һְѿȻͿϵֶΡǡڣ
ͼ˵ͻʽģƻ˵ΪȵȡеӦԤʾźԱΣ[]
ͨȻͳζΪЧ˶˵Ŀṩ͹ߵĹ۵㣬˹Ϊ˵ͶͰǿֱڿⲿ
Ȼﵽĳ̶ȡľһǹҵĵ͹ϵͳͶӶ˶İĿ̶ܳȡ[]
ߣڷɹԴǿͻͬʱڶȻļƶǿĳͻ׷µļ
֮ͳΡˣͳΣƣ໥ٽġ
    ôǾӦο˼塱رǷ˸ѧɹڿѧ֮ϵǿѧΪһͳλ
ƵʽĹ۵أ
    Է˸ѧΪġ˼ߡ˵ѧشιܣѽ㼯ЧӦ棻ע⵽ʱ
Ƶ̬ʽϵı仯ؽ¶ʲ׼ÿѧάԼͳεʵо˿ѧԵʱΡ
úĻɵ컯ָʱͳηʽͬʱͳηʽĳЩص㣬رͳÿѧ
ΪԼͳεĺԱ绤һ㣬ָڵͳβα;ֶΣҪѧֶΣǽݣر
ǡݡơ֧˵Ǳʶʶ[]ʵ˵ʱпѧṦЧӦľԣͼ
ָ־ԵĸԴѧΪʽԡԴ
    ǽ˼塱رǷ˸ѧɵĿѧͳЧӦĹ۵ڽִо죬ͿԷ
غ͸֮ʮߡʮŽִѧĽһֶڿѧֹĿ˶
ӢΨۣԼʵ֤壬ٵѧ˼ֿȻѧرѧΪѧʽƼΪ
֮⣬ѧԺͽλһ壻ѧΪƼʹȻƶ֪֮нѳҿ
ĸɡǣԴʮͿʼſѧʱãѧṦܺЧӦ汩¶ѧ
Ȼ˹ҵߺĸƣȴʹΪū³ͻս̬ʧ⣬һﻯ磬
ȴʧȥЩһЩѧر˱˼ĴԿѧԻе̬ȡΪִѧ
˱徫ǲݵģѧַĻ򣬸ڽִֵĸϡѧȻ
ʵĸ߶ȴͬʱ˾Ŀʧ䡣ˣǶԿѧ뱯۵̬ȡ磬ʩΪܿѧķչʹ
ƻ֪ʶȷٽȴʹܻеͶʹ࣬Կǿû䣻ѧʦŷ
޿ƼΣ˵ΪִƼķչע׷ӾҪ˵ľ飬˵ļֵɥʧӶ¡ŷ
ԱΣʦ¸ʹ˱Ϊϵͳеġıв˵ıʣΣǰ
;ˡ
    ˼塱رǷ˸ѧڴʱĳЩ泬ԽֹͱĹ۵㡣ǲڶִѧ
ṦܺЧӦо٣̬ƻвµɥԵĶȣǺʶЩ󣩣Ҳû
ڶԿѧǴ𣬶ǸһȥھЩԴӿѧʱĹϵȥ£ӿѧ
˼ĸã־쵽ѧѱͳν׼Ϊͳι߼õľ棻ӶԻ򹤾ԵۣԵ
ȥھԭԵĹ߻˵αͳεĺԡεĺԣѿƼԵ컯ͬͳϵ
    źǣ˼塱رǷ˸ѧɲûгԽԶ¼Ҳ޵ġδѶԿѧеľɳ
ӸΥ˼ڿѧһָĹ۵㡣ǽѧʱϵ죬һ̶
ϽӴѧЧӦضƶйأʱԿѧɵΣڿѧѧ
ԭʣѧ˵컯ū۵ĳʱ䡢ʷԴʹ֮ΪƶȺͽ׼ļȨߡƬؿ
˿ѧʱƶµĳЩǱڵ򣬶óһձĽۣڷ﹤ҵᣬѧȡ˺ϷͳελΪһ
Ŀʽѧ˷Ķū۵ĹߡˣöԿѧȡʱξƶȵС
    ˸ѧɹڿѧЧӦǿѧΪһµĿʽĹ۵Υ˼Ŀѧ۵ġ˼ѿѧ
ƶǰľΪѧǡһ˵Ĺ˵ıʵ顱ʷܸˡϵĸ
ѧǿ˵͸ȻΪӱȻı֤ͬҲΪᴴҪʻ
ѧһͳ˵켺һΰĸͽ˼徭ҰѿѧṦܺЧӦ
̬ᾭƶϵ졣ΪϵʶԿѧṦܺЧӦоԵӰ졣Է˸
ѧΪġ˼塱ѧͳεĹߣӿѧǱڷԻƳʱһìܺ컯
ͬ˼ѿѧͳι߿ʱеΪѧ컯ѧʹõʱ巽ʽֲ
ѧͳûбȻϵѧܹ̹ʱ䣬ٹ˵ͶƸȷ˶ȻĿƵȵȡ
£ѧΪͶġʱĶ[]ѧʹñȻʹͶӽţʹ޲׼
ޱϣʹ˸Ȼ֧ū۵ȡʱпѧĸìܡ컯˼д
ʱÿһ񶼰Լķ档ǿмͶʹͶгЧȻȴ˼͹ȵ
ƣ͡¡ĲƸԴȪƶĸԴʤƺԵµİܻΪۻġȻȴƺ
Ϊ˵ūΪūѧĴԷ·Ҳֻ֪ĺڰҫǵһзֺͽƺʹ
˵Ϊ޶۵ִҵѧִƶ˥ֶ֮Կʱϵ֮
ֶԿԶ׼ġɱӹʵ[]˼԰ʱ컯ìܶԿڿѧ
˼ֿ϶ѧʱ巢չеá˼ҩָӡˢʱͷչܸˡΪ
ʱУѧִ˫ְܣһ棬ʱʵרƺͽĹߣһ棬ķչ
ΪƶȴӶͶƶȴҪ[]˼Ĺ۵㣬ʱ巢չĲͬ׶Σѧ
εĹϵʺͬո˼ʱʱڵĽ׶ΣѧΪʱеһʲ׼ۺ
ʵһڽѧȨͷ⽨Ȩʱʱѧεĳͻϴε״̬ĩ
ͳʱ¢ʱĹɣͳĿѧεĹϵģʽ˱仯ѧνӽ淢
ͻһʱҼǿ˶ԿѧչӦõĸԤ׷׽ҵĿйЭЩй֯ʱϵ
һһлɲ֣ǿƼɹ汻ӦھĿģҪ˿ƼһҪƶҪʱΪ
šӶȨ׷װѿѧ߾ҪƼɹ͸Ľװǿѧ
ӶȻֶΣʣֵҲ汻ڿᣬ˼ūۣȻ֮ϵȫ컯
ʹѧεǵʱпѧ޴õһԭ
    ƶ£ѧεĹϵҲеģѧͬҪְܡǣֹϵµʡƶ
ʹпѧķӦãʹ֮Ϊ񣬳ַǱܣʹ೹װȻūۣʹ˵
ȫ淢չ׵ĽźɡУѧĻĿΪˣпȷһ͵ĿѧεĹ
ϵһ棬ѧҪְܣǹɹһ߿ѧһҪ˵ǹҹƶִе
һҪأѧֱͨӻӵ;͸ι֮УΪιıҪɷ֣ᴩι̵ʼգѧ
ٽᾭõķչұĻ裬ǵľҪΪͶʵȫߣΪ˵ȫ淢չ
ҪǣѧνһҪûпѧԼտƼ֪ʶȺڣǲ
ġ⣬ΪƼ֪ʶĴߺʹߣƼ֪ʶҲξιԽԽҪáһ棬
ζԿѧķչӦòشӰ죬ͻһǹҸضʱڵΡáºĻȷҪƶʵʩƼ
չսԼһϵпƼߣȷ򣬸ĸйơƼתΪĻƣָҵĿƼչӦáȻ
£ѧε͹ϵԼѧЧӦ÷ӲԷγģҪͨǳڻ̽ܽ
ᣬѧȻбӦаĿĵĿԣҪƶȵԽϼƣ
ƶȵĲƣѧĻЧӦõԽԽֵķӡ
    ֮ѧεĹϵԿѧһͳˡڲͬƶ£ֹϵʺݣ׼ʵʺĿǲͬġ
ӽʼͬĽ׼ڲͬҪɣʵϵġʶ̬ϵĵȣĿѧķչӱͿʼѧΪ
ҪѧεϵǿѧԴﵽĿģʵָͼԽԽоصĵλرǶս
¿ƼչѧᾭüеӰӾ޴ѧġλεġѧΪ
һҪ⡣ڿѧεĹϵУأһǿѧεĹϵǿѧεĹϵڵһ
ҵǿ̨ĵλں̶ܴȡĿƼչˮƽЧÿƼɹˣչѧ
һᾭáĻսԣҲһΡսԡɴ˹֮оѧεĹϵ⣬壬
Ҿشʵ塣˼塱رǷ˸ѧɽעⲢо⣬һЩļֵ۵⣬
һáǣǵϲǿȡģǲûпͬƶȣͬһƶȵĲͬ׶ΣУѧ
εĹϵвͬʺݣûпѧһΰĸѧһͳοƹߣ˿ѧ
ǱЧӦ˼壬뷴Կѧı֮С
α༭
οס
    [][]  ¬棺ʷͽ׼ʶ磬棬ڣҳ
    [][]  ˹ΤеĹҵʱ塷ءִ˵ļϺ꣬
棬ڣҳ
    [][]  οȵˡϺĳ磬棬ԣڣҳ
    [][]  ȵˡϺĳ磱棬ڣҳ
    [][]  HMarcusc,Counterrevolution and Revolt,Boston,1972,PP.4,14.
    [][][][]  JHabermas,Toward a Rational Society,Boston,1971,PP.81,82,84,84-85.
    [][][]  ס˹ȻĿơ磬棬ڣҳԣڣҳ
    []  һ̸ѧ̬ڣڣڣҳ
    []  ˼ȻͿѧӦá磬棬ڣҳ
    []  ˼˹ȫڣڣҳ
    []  ˼˹ȫڣڣҳ
    
    
    
 
