 ׺ 2-2551
ԭĳѧо
ԭ
ԭںš199803
ԭҳš114
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš199804
    ͳйִʱ
    Τƶ
    ǿ
߼顿ǿ  ϵѧѧϵڣʿ
ҪѧۼΤԴͳйΪʲôδܷչִʱĽʱǿΤйȱʱ徫Ĺ۵㣬
ΤԴͳйεƶȷΪΤѧ˵ռҪĵλΤƴͳйƶǵ͵ļҲơһ棬
Ȩרϡڣһ棬ȱЧĹͳһĹƶȣҿʮޡҼ޷Ϊ
÷չṩԤڵġȶĹ谭ƶھڳ֡
    
            һ
    ۼͳйΪʲôδִܲʱ徭ʱǳ֤νΤ⣺½ʱ徫ȣй
ͳȱԻǱܣȱʵĶȱ½ֽ̺徫һ仰ȱʱ徫
    ȷΤҪ⡣ǣڶսԺرΤѧУƺΤйʱΨһ
״ɭ˹ΤĽйأҲսѧǿΪƶȲйءɭ˹ڷΤ
ڽ̵ıȽоʱǿΤڼֵȡۡйʱ巢չԣɭ˹ָΤ۵Ҫ۵棺һй
ʷչĳЩ׶ΣƶԼŷʱ֮ǰȣǲʱ֮չڶЩ
Σ˼롢˼룬Լ˼ľʱķչ(Stephen Molloy,1980,p.381)עɭ˹Ľͼ
йоеӰ죬μStephen Molloy 1980ԭġɭ˹ŵĺǣأǾ谭йԷʱ
塣ɭ˹Ľں̶ܴϹΤѧĵ򡣲ֵɭ˹ĽͣΤйؾִϵ۾г˥
Ӱ죬Ϊѧעģִʱʷȴδõ㹻ӡڵΤѧ(Br-yan S.Tur
ner)ԹΤġ½۳Ϊֹġ⣬ʷѧṹȴδϵͳ۹(Bryan S.Tu
rner,1992,p.25)
    ֻӾΤѧ˵йĻȦڸΪͻйͳ˼άʽдعνġĻʶ
ĻıΪıĻ(Lin Yu-sheng,1979,pp.2627)йѧΤھ۸߶ӡǸп
޷ʱֻǸ̸ٽ˶ʱ壬ѧһ㹫ڳĳַʽͻ򲵳ΤҾĹ
㡣ȽϣΤʱδڴͳйչδܵ㹻ӡ
    ȻǿΤĻ۲ûеΤ˼ϵԣڽ̡ĻҪġնԹΪĻ
⡣ȻΤһԪ۵ľߡΤϵУĻҪ֮һ籾Ͽ˹(Reinhard Bendix)ԣ
ΤѧϵУϵصĲ棺ȨֵУֵȻҪ
ֵΡƶ֮䲢ֱӵľϵ뾭÷չĹϵʱֱӵģʱǼӵġ
    ΪʹѧΤڴͳйִʱһȽƽ⣬ͼΤΡƶִʱ
ϵһԱש񣬴ٽѧΤѧ˵Լйʷо
            Τִʱ弰Դһ
    ڿΤΪʲôйδܷչִʱƶȷ֮ǰȱΤʱĸԼʱԴһ
ΤڱȽڽойھѧ˵ѹΪ֪ǽص㹴Τʱƶ뾭õķۡ
    ˷۵֮⣬ΤҪ¿ɷΪ֡һΤڹŴ;ʷԼ¹ũҵЩΤ
ǰһ羭ͨʷΤѧ˵СΨ塱ɫŨĲ֣ڶΤıȽڽڷڽض
ʱ巢չӰķƩ磬Τġ̡൱ƪڷͳйڻʱ巢չأ
ᡷϵͳΤۣǰеҪ˸ϵı˵ΤЩһͬĻǾǡ
ʱԴ(origin)(effects)⡣
    ΤʱĲʿġó׹˾ʷ1889꣩ⲿּǿִʱ徭õϸ
˾ԴԼضɻĹϵΤ濼ˡʱ塱ֶؾʽķ⣺һݷ
ʱó׹˾ҵͥͬķ룻ڶڷʽ棬̽˵ʱľ⣺־
еԼغ߶ó׹˾Ӱ۵ǣ塱ִʱĳЩǰȡЩǰԴ
־(Dirk Kasler,1979,pp.2425)
    ˵ΤĲʿԷѧҵݷʱҵĹϵĻĩĽʦʸġŵ˥
ԭȫӾʷӽֹ̽Ŵʷеش⣬۹ԭⲿֵ֮ἰҪΤ
ڹ˥ԭķ൱Ψ塱ġдŵصǳغūҪū
ڡūͶ᲻ɻȱĻŴֲ԰֮ūִҪú̿һһܶںʹӦ
ūгһгūӪάֵĲɻȱǰ
    ۹˥ǡǡūԴĿݽߡ۹ʢ˥ת۵ٱɽ֮ս¹˵ȴܡⳡս۵Ҫڣ
ʵ۴Ӵ˷ԺŬֹͣšɴūгԴԴϵӦҲֹͣˡѡ࣬1
997,pp.126KaslerԣΤⲿѧڣΤͼӹŴṹ仯ĽǶȽ൱ӵʷת͹
̣۹˥䡣ڷУ÷չûҪܵͻǿ(Dirk Kasler,1979,p.35)ԺΤ
ˡŵũҵ״ע189718981909ֲͬ汾ÿζµڵУΤϵͳ
ʱ⡣ⲿУΤ˹Ŵʱ徭(capitalist economy)⡣Ϊһ⣬Τʱ
Խ綨ʱ(capital)ζҵĲƸˣʱ徭õĻҵݴˣΤһʱеĹ
㣬Ŵʱ徭áֻҪǷֲƲǽĶұгд´ҵôǾ
ʱ塣һ۵Ļôʮʱ幹ŴʱڣңʵϣЩʱڣǳ֮Ϊƽ
ʱڡܹŴʱ岻ȫִͬʱ壬ȷʵ๲֮ͬ(John Lover,1991,pp.182204)ⲿĽ۲
֣Τִʱγɵԭ1)ġʤš2)ضͬķ֮չΤ˵ִʱ壬
ҵʱ壬չĶڣĻһ׷ƶȣЩƶɹҵдģǲڹŴĳ(po-lis)(Disk
 Kasler,1979,p.40)
    Τִʱƶȷһһ羭ͨʷиһĸⲿУΤִʱ
Դ˼Ϊ꾡ĸִʱĸΤϮĽ˵ָʱһ൱ձ󡣡
ҵӦ༯ҪĹҵʱڡʱ徭ڹŴͶֹȻʱ
ִʱи
    һΤʱǡʱʽЩʱ¼֣
    һΪ˰˰ĿġйӡȵйʱʱҵڶͶóйصʱ壬Ҽû
һʷʱȫûọ́˵Ľ֮Ϊɳ֮Ĵʱ塣Щʽʱ嶼ͬսƷ˰ְȨ
̰ٷĸԼɺʵҪйءЩʱڱ϶ΪľĿĶ֯ģΪгᣬ
һֲʵʱûЩ취֮ǷչͶ֯ĺƶȵġΤҦ룬1981,p.283
    ʹڹŴͳֹΪ˾ĿĶ֯ʱҵЩҵҲֻǸġֲġĿǣһ־
Ӧǰʱ巽ʽ֯ģһ춨ֹҵׯ԰ʽϡһ㣬Τڡڽѧѡĵи
ĲעΤġڽѧѡδòӢ硣ۡɭ˹ΪӢģΪ½ʱ
Ӣ뱾ġԡάٵȸɭ˹Ӣ뱾ġ½ʱ徫񡷰ˡۡ֡Τ
ʱ塱Ϊ綨ΪýıȡΪ༴ڣʽϣƽĻΪΤָ
ԣʱԼʱҵǾ൱Իʱģھжϵж
ڵġйӡȡͱסڹŴкԼڽһֱšΤά룬1987,p.9
    ִʱ塱ڣǽ𾭼ûѭʱԭ򣬸ҵʱ巽ʽ֯Ӫõ
ʱ巽ʽӪΤĻ˵ǵճҪʱ巽ʽӦġ죬ĹӦѾʱ巽ʽ֯
ͻĳ̶ȣʽһȡƶȵıԤ֮УʱſԳ͵ʱʱΤ
Ҧ룬1981,pp.233234ֻ֡ճҪʱ巽ʽӦġƶȲſԱʱƶȡƶȡ
ңʹҲʮԺʼΪ޿ɱķġʮǰʱֻסʱʹ
ʵĻӾȫȡҲشı仯ΤΪִʱĳҪһϵȾЩ
ҵռֶΣгɣԵļԤķɣͶҵΤҦ룬1981,p.234Щ
УΤΪǿԵķԵĿƲƹңΪʹжյԤڵĺĻǰᡣΤд
    ʱʽĹҵ֯ҪãͱԤжϺ͹ϣǰʱ޵ڷƹҺֱ˹
ͼسУ߱ʼҵġαĹͬļӶ⣬Ĳ鷳ΤҦ
1981,p.235
            ⽨ơҲִʱ
    ΤڲִʱԴʱҪйȽϷڱȽУΤйĸйἰڽ
ŷڽǡôԣԱǿңıȽ塣йڽ̵ڽѧ޸࣬
ΪĲ֡йķУйƶȵķռͻλ
    Τйƶȵ۵۱֧ķࡣĪķɭһΤѧϵΪĲ֣Īķɭ
ֱ룬1989,p.1עĪķɭ(Wolfgang J.Mommsen)֧ͣΤѧμֱ뱾Τ˵
жķָ࣬͵֧䣺Լ֧䡢ͳʽ֧뿨˹ʽ֧䣨Īķɭֱ룬1989,pp.25-26
֧ʽУ˹ʽһֶݵġȶ֧ʽһʱȨʽȻл(routinized)תΪͳȨ
תΪԵ뷨ƵȨΩˣΤڽʷѧķУʵֻƶʽһǴͳġҳƵ
ȣǷ⽨ҲƣһִԵ뷨ƶȡ
    Τڴͳ֧֧ķϿȫ̬ģȴΤʷѧĻʵڽʾͳ֧֧ת
͵ĿΩˣ(Guenther Roth)ΤġᡷڱǾ̬ѧȴһѧҵʷ
¹ոҪչ·Ķطʽ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,pp.xxxiv-xxxv)ΤͳƶȸΪ
ƶȡ֧ʽͳεĻǸ˵Ĺ˳Ȩʹ߲ǹеġϼǸ˵ġˡ
ְԱҪǹǸ˵ӡְԱ˵Ĺϵȡڸ˵ҳϣǹ˽ְ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus
 Wittich,eds.,1978,p.227)ҳҪʽһǼҲ(patrimonialism)Ƿ⽨(Reinhard Bendix,1977,p.360)ǰ
ǼҳƵĵʽǼҳƵıԵʽǰʷ͵ĴͳһԺйߵĴ͵ŷҪָ
⽨ҲΤﶼ󣬶ڿϵ̬˵Τķ⽨˼еķ⽨
ͬ⽨˼ѧ˵ζһʽҪ漰ýṹ(Gianfranco Poggi,1991,p.80)ΤΪ⽨ƶһ
Ҫʷƶȡ⽨Ҫʽһֻڲأ⽨ƣһֻٺ»(Max Weber,Roth & Clasu Wittich,eds.,vo
l.1,1978,p.255)͵⽨Ҳкܴͻرڣ⽨µȨǻԼģרϵġΤд
ϵĽṹ봿Ҳ¿ɲȨԼϵȨλĲȶγɶԱȡݷ⽨ƶǼҲƶȵһֱԵʽ
ڹ淶ġ̶⳼Ĺϵͥڷڲʱ׼ʱݱΪԼضȨΪ
ҵһҲ´ֽײʿʱͬᵼԼҳϵķ⽨ϵЧҵδӼЧжڴ
һϵȨεĹʼ֣ǡƴʹϵҵչһ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,vol.2,
1978,p.1070)
    ⽨⳼ԼԹϵŷʷչоش塣ԼԹϵ⳼ķӲͬڵ͵ļҲµ
ӡ⳼ķӳ˸˻ķ⣬ӡһй൱ϸķ䡱⽨֧Ͱֲͬں
һǼϸĸЧңһȴԼʽ涨ȨΡӶϵȨεķǸ˻Լռ
Ϯơ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1074)ΪҪǣ⽨ƶµԼȨϸƣ
ϵԼ⳼κʱأӶֹ⳼ݡ⣬רϵǿڷ⳼ĳ⳼ضȨ
ֻܻڹЧӵԼһֶ˫Լ涨ġ֮⳼ĵԼ⳼ʵ
Ͼĳһضͳߵĸ߶ȸ˻ϵϵ⽨ƶ·չ߷(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol
.2,pp.1074--1075)ڷ⽨֧ԼأΤƷ⽨ƶΪƻƶȣƳַչ˵ķ⽨ƶ˵ϵͳ
Ȩƶȡ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1078)ַȨƶشַȨƶаԼ۵
ѿѾ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1082)Τ֮Էǿ⽨֧
ԼأĿָһ⽨֧ԡһ棬дͳƶȵȨǸ˻ģһ棬
ĳԻȨȨԼԼ
    ⽨֧ȽϣҲǼҳƵĵʽĻǹٷ񣬶Ǹ˵ĿģǶԳ淶ķӣһϸ
Чҡ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1007)Ҳ֧Եص㣺һǴͳ壬ڶר
־ҲȨֻܴͳԼ˴ͳ֮⣬κηɡ淶ԼԼļҳ֧ʽûκηɵơ(Max 
Weber,Roth and Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1009)ΤۼҲ֧ʱйΪҲƵĵ͡ΤΪйͳһ
ǰƶȻڷ⽨ƶȣַ⽨ٺ»ƵĽ(Max Weber,Roth and Claus Wittich,eds.,vol.1,1978,p.259)ͳһ֮
ϳƣƶٺ»Ĺ̶ȼȻ󣬡ơȷٺ»ƶȡζŷ⽨ȫϳΤ츻룬1995,
pp.46--47עĳע⣬Ը뱾йӴȷ˵͵ļҲƵĹƶȡ
    ҲƵȨרԡΤʮڴͳй뼯Ȩĳ̶ʮ޵ġΤ츻룬199
5,p.59ȱһԻĹƶȣȱ㹻Ĳһ׾ȷͳһĹΤ츻룬1995,p.
61ȨЧʹΧֻ´ﵽؼȻΤǿϣͳ߾оԵġκԼȨʵʦ
ߵͳߵļ˾ְ֮һһʥɶҡĴͳĹһоɵרʴȵĹ桱Τ
츻룬1995,p.120
    ŷ⽨ƶֵйҲµרȨʱ徭ڸԵش塣ʱ徭õķչҪ
ҪƶǡγĿԤԡΤд
    ʽĹҵҵҪԴгΪĿ꣬׼ȷԵͶ֯ʱܼǹ̶ʱܼˡ
ҵʱԡԡ͹Եķ򣬱ԻԤԲ򣬱ȱչ
ҵҵĿԤԱϡЩڶͻ̶ȲߵļҲƹΪ΢ִƶ´ﵽ㡣Թҵϰ
Ϊڽ̵˹̡˹߼˳൱ִҵңڽ̾˹̹ҽṹƶ
˾ƶ(Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,vol.2,1978,p.1095)
    ΤΪͳйļҲƵĹƶ޷ṩʱ巢չҪַйȨרԣҵ
ҵͶʾмðرĲȷԡƸ۵ԴȪǽ桱ȨеӶᡣֻйԱ
ѸٷĻᡣ䷢ԨԴǶԳ˰İǳΪȡͳԱйٷж֧ķã߲ͳ
Ա㷺ʩȨרȨ(Max Weber,Roth &Claus W-ittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1094)ڴͳйͳһֶص
ʱ塪Ӷʱ塱еģҪԵľûǡӶʱ壬Ų
ۣرصĻۡΤ츻룬1995,p.104Ҳƹʹͳ߿ɲȨΪ۲ƸԳ
ЩͳĻ͵ȨδϸƵĵ򣬼ҲΪͳߡ͢ԱҡܶĹ١˰չ١Ӱ̷Լ䵱˰ũ
ߵĴ˼ڼṩⷢƵɡͳߵĶءûճشµĲƸݻ١(Max Weber,Roth
 &Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1099)ȨڲƸĻзžãйܳٵͶΪùλ
ͶʡΤڡ̡ˡǵһӣݺصĹ˰ˡͷһ20٣ڶ
񡯣ΪСΤ츻룬1995,p.103ƣӲȡҲһͶΪ
Τͳйƶȵʱ徭÷չӰġΤķйڴսʱڼѳʱ徭
óɷ֡ͳйڲʱ巢չأƽˮػõԼѡְҵɵȡͳ
᲻ʱ巢չشأرͳһ֮ļҲƶȳΪʱ巢չϰͳһȵ´ڴ
սġɹľȷʱ塱˥䣬ѹˡгҪɽΪȡʱ塱Τ
룬1995,p.102ΩˣΤŷĸ̾йʽĹϽ£ִϵĹҵʱǲܲ*Τ
룬1995,p.123
    ֮Ҳƶʱ徭÷չӰ죬ŷ⽨ƶʱ徭õӰԡһǿһŤִʱ
塱⽨ƶȶʱ徭õĸӰҪ侭ýṹΪصķͨǲת벻ɷָģʳΪԵġӰ
Ҫɷ֡⽨ƶȡϸ񻮷ֵȨְԾȶЧԸ˲ƸķȶЧ
⽨ƶȡ൱ԡۡȨԡ͹ۡΪ(Rechtsstaat)ڷ⽨ƶвɳ
ɵġÿ侭Դƶȣڷ⽨ƶ£ȷʵԼϵȨЩȨһϵҵĻ
ڴˣΤ϶˵֮ҳʽҲƶ±仯޳ĸ˶裬⽨ƶµȨʽΪʱӮṩ˽Ϊȶ֧֡(
Max Weber,Roth & Claus Wittich,eds.,1978,vol.2,p.1099)
            ġԪṹִʱ
    ΤۼͳйҲƶʱ徭÷չĸӰʱǿҲȨרԣǿҲ֧Ȩ
ȫԡȨȫųκƶɵĻᡣΤڷִʱ巢չƶԭʱǿ
ȨĶԪԡֶԪ档һȨԵĶĽ̻ɮ¼ţڶҵм񣻵
Ƿַ⽨µĵȼƶȡΤͳйƶȱĶɷ֡УΤΪǿеá
жִʱӰΤѧ˵ռҪλϿ˹ע⵽ΤʱԴѧ˵ʱڿ½
áʵϣΤೡϸǿеáΤע⵽ŷĳб½̸ĸԼĸִ͡ҵִ
ƶȣִƶȡΤȨĻôһµƶȴӴͳļҲ⽨ͳµĽ(Bendix,1977,pp.76-
-79)
    ڷͳйʱΤΪƶȲԣͳйӰʱ巢չأ˼Ҳ֧⣬Ҫľȱĳ
СΤдȫͬǣйԼжĳУȱϵԡйĳУȷǹϣȵصĳǰ(Polis)
ҲûġзΪǾԼȨġΤ츻룬1995,p.21ȻΤע⵽й
ҲҵֹҵġΤ츻룬1995,p.19йо߱еǣΤǿйĳ
ȱڹȨµĳег¢ϡйõзɱϵġΡȴ仹Ҫ١Τ츻룬1995,p.19,pp.
21--22ѧڷйȱеԭʱ֤ΤԼĽͣйĳ֮ѻõɣ
ԭŦδϾΤ츻룬1995,p.20ũǨе塢ڵĹ籣ǧ˿Ƶ
ϵȻϸΤ۾ͻ֣ᷢȱҲƹҵܲɷ֡еνԣӸ˵
䷨ƻص졣õ״ֻ⳼֮Լϵһʽûз⽨ķȨûз⽨֧
չʾ̶ֹġƻ򣬳еȨǲġйзչϰǼҲƹҡ棬
һҲƹڹϷչһֶԹҵĳݣϢκڹҵƶȽṹĳ֡ƶȲ棬йĹ֯
ʵƶȻչҲƵĹơһͳĹƶֹеķչ(Wolfgang Schluchter,1989,p.108)
    ΤԳеҲһЩּ򵥻أ岻ɵ͹Τڳеʵһֹƶת͵Τʮ
Ϥ˼һ۵㣬ķչھƶڲʽѿѿķչ׳ȻҪϲ㽨ı
ҪԸķʽٳƶת͡Τڳеͼչʾµƶȷʽܷھƶɲһ̶ȵķչⱾһδ֪
⡣ŷ⽨ƶܹ̲֮ƶȵĲ뷢չŷ⽨ƶȵйϵһƶȱǼҳƵıԵʽ
Ȩ뷨ƻĳ˵һɶԪƶȵĿԡˣŷ⽨ڲһҳȫͬ
ʵƶȣƶȡзչ׳ճΪִʱƶȻŷȣйļҲǵ͵ȫƶȣ
ˡˣйͳƶ޷ʵƶȣҲ˵µƶʽ޷ھƶڲȻγɡ׳
            塢ִƶʱ
    ΤǿйͳȨԡרԣǿȨȫԤƣδ񵱴ѧ߿κط(K.Witt-f
ogel,1957)áר塯ĸйΡע츻̡뱾УʱΤԭеSelbstherrschaftΪ
רƶȡ츻룬1995,p.54ݷ̨뱾Ϊơ򡰶Ρݷ룬1997,p.93룬198
9,p.106Ƹ׵ר塱Ӧ"despotism"Ӧӹϣר(despotism)ѧ˵һ
ָĳЩƶȣͳרϡ⡢ȫ桢ܷԼȨϵ˹Լκطԡר
ƶȵĵ͡ΤйƶȵԶκط򵥻ΤΪйȨСȫ桱
ơǡǡ෴Τؿͳйεһۣһ棬ʵʦǵ۹ˡ֮£Ī
֮ĪʽƶȵİŶԣʵ۵ȨȫġϵġȨ⴦κθ塣һ棬ͳ
йδͳһЧĹƶȡȨᡢ͸ᡢ൱ԵطĿһֱǴͳйεͻ
⡣
    ǽΤĹ۲뵱ĳЩѧҵۿϵͻῴΤ۲塣Ӣѧɡ(Michael Ma
nn)Լ(John A.Hall)Τ۲쵽ϵıʹ֮ۻɡ۹ȨʱĹ
ȨһǹҵרȨ(despotic power)ҾӢڲŽлƶȻּۻ۵ǰж
Χ(range)ǹҵĻȨ(infrastructural pow-er)ʵ͸ᣬͳεЧ᳹ξߵ
(capacity)Ȩǿ״ɡʷԼʵеĹ˷࣬ɳͣһȨͣ
ŷ͵ķ⽨ңǿרȨȨͣл۹۹ȴͳ۹רȨǿȨͣ
ĹƹңġȨǿͣļȨҼڴ(Michael Mann,1988,pp.5--9)ɡķ౻Լ(John A.Ha
ll)ͳĵ۹ƶȣرйĴͳƶȡԴͳ۹Ȩ
    Щͳ۹ǿǵǿ󣬻ǿǵǣ߶ʵĴڡ۹ۣ
ìܣǵǿ󡪡ǵĺΰַǵרϡǶ˵ڱǵԡǿǡǡڲӳ
ԡЩ۹͸ı䲢Ա(John A.Hall,1988,pp.2021)
    ԼйΪִͳ۹ĵ͡һƪΪ᣺Ƚӽµġ漣УйΪָй
ȨȨʿײͬʱ棬ǡǡйδܷչִõĸԭ֮һ(John A.H
all,1988,pp.21--24)
    ɡԼۿʵֻǽΤķѡΤԴͳйεķѾļݡ
ڡ̡УΤ൱ƪͳйȱִƶȵ⡣дڷԱ֮󡢽ͨͳϽ
ȨйǷǳ޵ġΤ츻룬1995,p.59״ҪԭǡǡȨ޹󡣻ʵۡߵͬʱ
Ҳߵļ˾ʵʦȵְܣְֵ̻ܡʵְӦйԱְֱǰ
󡱣ǣֻһԱ³ʿһôʹԱҲʵܺáΤݷ룬1995,p.71,100
ķʽйĴҪӴĹŶ顣Ȼʵǡǡ෴ͳйεһ缲ǹ㡣Ҫԭ
ȱЧĹƶȡΤĹ۵㣬йһֱδܽЧͳһ˰ƶȡȻΤע⵽й˰
Խ˰ȡۣΪͳҪԨԴΤ츻룬1995,p.66˰ʵ˰ңŻҾõķչҲ
лҾ˰Ҫ˰˰˰˰˰ķʽ
    ˵й˰ƶȾ൱ͳһԡڣйصĹƶȣͳһԵ˰ƶֻǱ¶ѡй
ƶȵĸ׶ǹнٺ㡣ʽϣ֧нĹʵϵõнٺֻһС֣˵΢һС
޷нٺҲ޷нٺ֧ڵǣֻһ⽨Լľ˰֧
ѣʣԼĽǣͳйγĳֶصƶȡýϤݵĻһֲɵ
ȡ涨ʡ˰ʡҲմ˰涨˰Τ츻룬1995,p.70עѧ߻Ҳ
ΪͳйҪ׶֮һȱЧ˰ƶȡμ1977£Ͻõ뱻ٺ»
ʵ˽벢𡱡ˣһŬͼԼϽӦϽɵľ˰ʵϣΤע⵽
ʡеĳЩض˰񡯣˰ˣ뷽跨лߡӻʽӦľ˰ǣ
һרҹƣٷƵ˰ʵʵ˰գ߼ı14Τ츻룬1995,pp.70--73Τָй
ĵⲢûӢתɡ̶˰ڱϡ൱⽨ȻʽµĹ̶Τ츻룬
1995,p.70,73ֲƶʹй뼯Ȩƶͽݵġ塱ǲϵķʹͳϽԻԼͳһ
ľ޷ʵ֣Τ츻룬1995,p.75δܽͳһĹƶȣͳһĹƶȱȱҪĲԴ޷
ֱӵĺǣ޷ṩҪĹƷر޷ϸ˵ĲȨũͻ
    ΤڴͳйũȨص㡣ǿйȨδЧµйũһεʵ塣
ڵ۹޷ᷨ족ũ롰Ϊṩ˾ҪǣЩλṩ
Ʒһ棬вŸũһ棬ΪҪǣĹϽ޷ַӱƲ
ǱҪƲĹܡĳ̶ֳϿ˵ǡҵҵġ˳Ϊʵġũ񣬾ܵƦåרİڲ
Τע⵽ȱǿƱϲȨйũڹ֯޲Ŀ֮¡Τ츻룬1995,pp
.113--114
    ǽΤйεۼԹɣͻ֣ᷢΤԴͳйεĻǣһ棬뼯ȨƵޣ޷
͸Ա᣻һ棬뼯ȨȨǿһ̶ȣֹκΤĽģһ
棬йȨôȫ桢ڣطʵϵķȨܹĳԼɼԹ̶ôйԴս
ڵʱȫܷĳе壬ȡýϴķչһ棬й뼯Ȩȫԡרԡ
䣬ͬʱܹչЧʵġܹƲ͸ĹƶȣôйķչͻȫȻͬ·һ·ᵼºֽ
Τûչ֤ʯĸƺ԰˽߼ΤʯĸʮӣΪⳡĸйʷ
ڽԻƶȵҪŬĸʵǽԻĹƶȣӶһ֧Ӵġмɵġѵصġֱ
ʵ֧ĹҾӡΤ츻룬1995,p.92ΤƸĸΪ塱ġĸԳɹйΪǿ
ȨǿӦĹҡΤƺĹ۵㣬ǿȨǿƶȻͬչʱģ
ʽڴٽԻִ÷չ棬ϾȴͳйʽƶȸΪЧ
            йҲγԭ
    Ϊʲôͳйάֶص֧䷽ʽΤڲͬĳͼԴȻΤκ϶һ
ߡΪйļҲĳֱȻġоĸԴҲΪйҲ֧γɼȷʵĳЩضԭ
    ˼徭һΤע⵽йũҵһֹũҵˮҪͿܴٽһ뼯ȨƶȡΤ൱
϶˵ҲԴڶԳ˺ӵĿ䣬Ҳ˵Դڽ̡Τ츻룬1995,p.64ΤΪ
ˮũҵĴǶҪ֮һǶҳֹŽ׼Ҫԭд
    ڰǡӡȺйĻݽУǾйؼԵ⡣ˮ˹Ž׼Ĵڡ׼ǿԼ
ԵĹżŵְܵȨҲͨ¢Ȩʽķ޾֯֯Ļǰһ
£ʼҵĹٺ;ʼնԭǲڵģΤ1981,p.272
    ΤˮǿԶδﵽѧκطĳ̶ȣͼڹũҵ붫ר֮佨һֱϵΤһ
ߣ۾þߡˮ⣬ΤΪͳйƶҲڼҲƵĳά֡й㲻ׯ԰ơȱׯ԰
ȣйûŷ޷⽨ֵطȺ(Max Weber,Roth and Claus Wittich,eds.,vol.2,1978,p.1050)йļҲƲžи
ȵһ(Max Weber,Roth and Claus Wittich,eds.,vol.2,1978,pp.1090--1091)
    ƶϵͳйľƶֲͬͬҲ൱̶ȵƶ塣Τἰƶȴʱ𣬱
װʿɵġζţͳʿ⡣ڴͳ൱װʿ塣־ƶȶԷ⽨
ȵԼеĳ뷢չҪ塣ȣйӻһְ֧ҵӣʿԴļʿװͳṩ
ľֻͳߵĹߣκԼͳߵãBendix,1977,p.78Τ츻룬1995,pp.91--92ʽ
ƶƶһϵΤڡ羭ͨʷд
    й⽨ƶڼԪǰ;Ѿϳ˽漴춨ʼʣسĵһʵۣȨںͷ⽨Ӳͬ
Ϯϣ־׼ɵĸ˰ʱйĲйεıҡ˰Һ͡ƹҡ
֮䣬Ҳ˵һ˰֧ľӺ͹нٺΪ˰ԴһΪ۵ԴʹĳЩ
ض׼ʵԹҵҪΤ1981,pp.8182
    ͳйĳںƽҲڼҲƵά֡ƽĻȻҲơǣһҲƲ֮󣬳ںƽĻܻ
ĸĶΤΪŷ޽ƶȴ롰ȱһƽͳһ۹йءйսʱڣȨľʹʹ
ľ뾭Իǣڸսʱڵĺ˻ڵ۹֮ͲڡΤ츻룬1995,p.65
Τսִʱ뷢չõǿԶδɣصĳ̶ȡΤרɣصĹ۵㣬ΪӦðսá
ӦеĵλսڲԻĴ߻ãֲΪãΤ1981,pp.261--262
    ҲӦἰҴͳάϵҲͳεҪ塣ΤûȷҲƶ֮ϵǣΤ
ǿҴͳάּҲ֧Ҫ塣Τѧ˵ķһĻ⣬޷չֻۡǿ
һ㣬Ҵͳ⡣ΤΪѧ˵ȱԽֵͳʥԡйʷĸҲεĳ
Ʃʯ䷨ͳ֮ǿʧܡ
            ߡ
    ΤйƶԼĻġԨԴȿΤойĳԲ޹ϵΤйо
ȽڽоҪɲ֡ȽоĶǶйڽȫΪͻԡΤ
ڡڽѧѡĵȷойӡȵĶǣͼԼҪڽ뾭ĹϵԼǸ
ײ֮Ĺϵг׵̽ӶҳķչбȽϵҪ㡱Τά룬1987,p.16
    ˣЩоĲڼԸĻ㵽ķǴǳȫ෴ÿһĻУǵоĶ
ǿĻĻЩءЩı޶ֻЩһ۵ĻƺľҪԵ⣨Τ
ά룬1987,p.16עиĶĵڶԭ漰ΤϵĵĿɿԡΤ֪ԷĻ
ƶȵķʵȱʧԼרŵĺѧҡӡѧҡѧһ򰣼ѧңϵļ÷޷
רȡд
    Զ׼һ˱ֻףұú͹۸ֱ׻ôͲòʹԼһ
רȴ޷ⲿר׼ȷжϡһλ߱ȡǫѷ̬ȣĿǰֵܹĵһϣ
ףģִġҪȻٵÿойϸȱ£Ȼ͸ӦǫѷعԼ
ļֵˡЩԭʹǵоɾһʱʣЩ޵ĲָˣΤά룬1987,p.17
    ˵ΤڼʮǰʶԼĻķϷȱĻôʷоһչĽ죬ǿ
ѵָΤйоϸڵĻ򲢷ϸڵĴƩ磬ΤĻľʱѧķչر
ζѧԽֵķչһ֪磬ΤڴͳйȱʽķҲ²⣬Τйʿ
ײķеķвٿȶ֮˵Τйо۶ϣǶԻҳһЩ෴֤ΪҪ
ǣΤйķһ־̬ķƺйǧƶĻûзκαǨʵϣǺָƵ
ƶƶȱкܶ಻ͬЩͬ൱ҪġȻΤйоļֵȫݽʷϸۡΤ
ἰϸڵ׼ȷԲΪһֱȽоԽ޴ңרǲɱģ¶ôķ顱
ϣĽǣĻרǡں۵ҲԴ󡱣Τά룬1987,p.16Ӧ˵ʹԽ
ۣΤȻվסţһ㲻ܲ˳Ծ먱(C.K.Yang)Τ̡Ӣ뱾ĵݺ
ѧоɹΤйķйָۡܵϵƣΤչʾ˲ĶʵĶ
ΤйĻȱԭһ۶ΪΤԵֻ̾омͷԲſ
Ĺ۲죬رǶһδ̤йص˸ˡ(Max Weber,1964,p.xxxix)
    ΪҪǣΤйоĹײȫϵ׼ȷԼжϣҪϵ׼ȷԼжϡΤҪ
ӽۿܡЩӽԼۿΪойĴͳĻƶṩϣΪоһ
㡣ԱעĴͳйƶһۣΤķʹһµĽǶȡΪµĽǶٰ
1)ͳйĹϾȨҵͳ߻ʵʦȨ⴦κθ塣ϣʵ۵
ȨרϵġרƵġܷƶԼġƶ޷Ϊ÷չṩԤڵġȶĹ2)ȨԼר
Աȵǣͳ͸ԼǼ޵ġڳȱͳһЧĹƶȣͳһЧĹȨ
γɣڹƶ֮ȱԻӾ硣ȱͳһԵĹȨ޷ṩִʱ徭÷չҪͳһЧĹ
Ʒ
    йѧ߶Τйоɹ˫Եġһ棬ǵȻʷоĳɹΤѧ˵еһ񾡹ʮּ
ޣԶǽɵģһ棬ӦеղչΤйоķӽǡʷоĳģʽ
ݣܷʶһʷоͱȻ漰ĳۿӽǡȣϵȡ᱾ܵĳۿܵӰ
죻ΣʷĽ벻ĳۿܵĵִʷоܵ۵ľ޴Ӱ졣ΤΪѧĴʼˣרд
йѧ˵²ɺӡеѧ߽ΤйΪһԹԹĴ߿Ʊΰ
ʦ˵ԹģΤѧ˵мֵ(Stephen Molloy,1980,vol.31,No.3,p.377.)Τйƶȵķ
֪ǷЩԹĵۡ
    ֿδעͣ
        ԭ¼
α༭޺
οס
    1ѡ࣬1997뾭ߣΤѡһţѧ硣
    21997йʷ(byR.Huang,Ta-xiation and Governmental Finance inSixteenth-Century Ming China,Camb
ridge University,Press,1974)
    3Τ1981羭ͨʷҦ룬Ϻĳ硣
    41987½ʱ徫񡷣ά룬ꡣ
    51989Τѡֱ֧͡룬̨Զҵɷ޹˾
    61989йڽ̡̣룬̨Զ档
    71995̡츻룬硣
    81997̡ݷ룬ӡݡ
    9Bryan S.Turner,1992,Max Weber:from History to Modern-ity,London:Routledge.
    10Dirk Kaslet,1979,Max Weber:An Introduction toHisL-ife and Work,theUniversity of Chicago Press.
    11Gianfranco Poggi,1991,"Max Weber's conceptual portr-ait offeudalism",inPeter Hamilton ed.,MaxWeber:Critical Ass-essment
s 2,London:Routledge,vol..
    12John A.Hall.1988,"StateandSocieties:theMiracle in Comparative Perspective",Jean Baechler et al ed.,Europeand the Rise o
f Capitalism,Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
    13John Lover,1991,"Max Weber andthe TheoryofAncient Capitalism",inPeterHamilton,ed.,MedWeber:Critical Assessme-nts 2,Lond
on:Routledge,vol..
    14Kar Wittlogel,1957,Oriental Despotism:A Comparative Study of Total Power,New Haven,Yale University,Press.
    15Lin Yu-sheng,1997,The CrisisofChineseConsciousn-ess,the Universityof Wisconsin Press.
    16Max Weber,1964,The Religion of China,translated by Hans H.Gerth,New York:Free Press.
    171978,Economy andSociety,GuentherRoth andClaus Wittich,eds.,University of Calitornia Press,vol.1.,and vol.2.
    18MichaelMann,1988,StatesWarandCapitalism,Oxford:Blackwell.
    19Reinhard Bendix,1977,Max Weber:An Intellectual Port-rait,University ofCalifornia Press.
    20Stephen Molloy,1980,"Max Weber and the religions of China:any way out ofthe maze?"British Journal of Sociology,vol.31,N
o.3.
    21Wolfgang schluchter,1989,Rationalism,Religion,and D-omination,Univ rsityof Califirnia Press.
    
    
    
 
