 ׺ 2-2658
ԭĳѧ
ԭںš199504
ԭҳš084-087,101
  šK1
  ʷѧ
    ׿
ӡںš199509
    Ԫۣʷѧٵ
    йʷѧĻعǰհ
    
    ԪۣPluralistic Eclecticismǵѧ˼ռλıۺͷԭڱϣǿκ
ɽǶػżȻһ໥Ӱ໥öγɵģͬϣɲͬĽûκһ
õأҲͲоĳֻ򲻳ֵȻԵĹɡɴ˾ڷϣǿܶо
ȻԵķ̽ȻԵĹɣֻܶĳʵ֤Թɣĳ
ĿԵģʽơ
    ӿѧѧݱĹ켣ԪǶԣʢеĻе۵淴ֻеȷϣɹ۲쵽
ȻԹɵġܶԣȻһЩͬֻҪһΣ㹻Ƶ£ͻٶȳ֡
˵ȫͷĶһ𣬡ȫʵ֣ض֮J.S.Mill,A SYSTEM OF LOGIC,1851,P31634
5֮ǻеģΪһѡ򡱺͡Ĺϵĳֽѡĸػ֮Ĺϵ
ĳֽǴٳĸƽеػȫĻеܺͣûпĳ֮ԳֳĳֽǸ
Լ˶ԾģǲԭβǸػӰ죬ʹòӦĸı䡣ڶ
ԣ㹻Ƶ£ͱضͬĽʹͬʱСơsimilarityͬ͡identity˫غ
parallelismһʴ岻ͬĴʣǵȼ۵ʹáʵϾǼٶֻҪʮƵͿԤϱȻ
ͬĽȻٶǺѳġΪκƵԭƳ̶ٸҲȫͬģԭƣ
͸ͬڣ͵ʷ£Ǻע⵽ɹ۵©߼ʹע⵽ҲΪ޹ؽҪʱ
ȻѧԺѧţѧΪǵһ׶ֹɹ۲ìܣ˵һµġֹɹ۽ʱٵĿ
ѧͼʵ⣬һҲѡʱʷ̣ʱƲɵȫƽμҺ˼Ǵ
ѾȡõֳɾΪݣȷȫʷȻԵķǰصʷѧҲԣĻ
ؽȫȡʤȷʵҲ֮ʿֲͬļ⣬ڴӢǿЩ鶼Ϊѵֻ֮е
ɹڵʱǶɧġ
    ˣͣ˾޴仯ѧˡȷϵΪⲻ׼ԭ϶һ΢ӵλúͶ
λ붯أͬʱȷֵһȷһĲȷ̶ǿȷԵľѧ
ս۷֣˶ٶȽӽڹʱҲ仯תΪԾѧ趨Ҳһս
ŴѧݻѧȵѧƣҲ˴Ī⡢԰յԿѧгֵƣѧѧҿW.V.Qu
ineڡӢѧѧѧϷ£ԣһжǲ϶ġһж޸ġW.V.Quine."THE SCOPE AND LANGUAGE OF SC
IENCE",British Journal for the Philosophy of Science,VIIIMay,1957͵ʷ̣Ҳһϵеľޱ䡣οǰ
ҵսֳϵ߽͵һϵҵĳ֣༫ֵγɡһж룱͵ľ
ӢԤԵ֡ȻơྶͥӢʷѧҰտڡ䶯еʷһдڣǳһֲ
ĸ飬ΪǸеһʱżʱǰľΪɿָϡתԡѧ
ֲᡷڣҳ磱棩ʷ£ԽԽ仯ԡżȻԺͷǾۣ
ԡȻԺ;ۡʢеĻеԵɹɥʧ˴Ȩ
    оʷʷѧ۵ѧϣPeter D.McClellandеģʽȱʱ߼԰Ϊ
ʽ
    Always,if (C[,1],,C[,n]),then E,ceteris paribus
    ߱Ϊ
    Necessarily,if (C[,1],,C[,n]),then E,ceteris paribus
    ߼ĺǣԭãۣݣãۣݣãۣݣֱãۣݣ£
ceteris paribusǣ˵Ȼֽšģʽ߼ʽܵġζţо߰жϵ
Ч֪ģ趨ģΧ֮ڣδ֪δ趨ceteris paribusΧҼٶǲġʵϣѧ
еԭȫԵںģʽǵʽУҪһϵҪ趨ǲģ
ͲáǸϵceteris paribusģʽǸʵʲֵģڵĿѧҲ벻ǣ
ϿȱݵġָнӣȷϣǷĳֹãۣݣãۣݣ
žͱȻţãۣݣãۣݣ֡ǣǲһʾǺԵĶͬһ
ҲҪԽ⡣Peter D.McClelland,CAUSAL EXPLANLATION AND MODEL BUILDING IN HISTORY,ECONOMICS AND
 NEW ECONOMIC HISTORY,Cornell University Press,1975,P.4546δ˵̫ˡʵǸʾСᡱģֻδ
֪δ趨ܵı仯ͱ仯ԭ׷Ѱ⡣ЩҲִѧٵĲȷ⣬޷Щ⣬ֻð
ᡱ
    Ͽģʽȱݣǽд
        Probably,if (C[,1],,C[,n]),then E京ǣ֣ãۣݣãۣݣͿ֣ܳš˵һ޸ĵ
ؼ֮㣬ǿֹԤͽͶǿ϶ɵġֻҪѧҺʷѧҵͽЩɣǾͲ
ﵽԿ϶ɵMcClellandͬ飬ڣҳ
    ϵ˼ҪǿȻѧܵóȫȷɵĽۣʷѧ;ѧЩѧ͸
ˡһеоֻܵóȻԡԵĽۣиߵҪҲǵѧΪʢеѧ˼ı
ǰĿ仰һжǲ϶ġһж޸ġԪ۾ѧ˼Ĳ
    ʵϣϱģʽоѾŶԪ۵ݡʽеģãۣݣãۣݣͣŵϵ
京ǣκһŶɣãۣݵãۣݵĶشٳɵģЩû֣֮ƽеã˭˭
ϵprobablyʾЩصϼ仯Ǳòȷаյģɴ˾ֻǻȻԡԵġ
    ͵ĶԪķǾȡˣ͵ĻеۣԲȷԡԡȻԵǿ˺߶
ȷԺͱȻԵ׷󡣴ӻ͵ķǾ۵ĶԪ۽֮͵Ļеۣһֳʵǫ̬ȡ
ҪʶԼ֪ʶ޶ȣҪ̲Է⣬Ҫʱ׼޸ԼĽۡڷֹʹٽѧչġǣ
˾ͷ˶ȷԺͱȻԵ׷رΪ͵Ļе۵ʧܾͷ񶨶Կѧľ۵̽Ͳܲ˵Ǵһ˵
һ˵
    Ǿ忴Ԫ۵ʷѧķչ
    ¹ѧҡʷѧҺ;ѧΤŶԪۣΪڽ̡áΡĻµȵضʷ
Ҫãܵǿĳһյľá漰̽Ϊʲôûвʱ
ԴڶĽ͡磬ΪһҪԭûвŴγУɶԭɵ
磬ûŷ͵ֳзΪһӵԼƶȺȨĹͬ壻Ҳû
־סڳвӵԼװľ˽ײ㡱ϵƶо׷ϵεҪϰһϣ
ǿѾָΪʲôʱδܵõչԭЩԭ򼸺ԹҵĽṹеϮԴһר
ͳҵĲɶҡʥͳЩ谭˹ҵʱķչҵʱķչµıûк
ɿִйӡȡ˹̹һطˡȨ֮ͨϣһԭ
ƶźƶͲöɵķչһԭ򲢲йʱķչʱǿصۺã˵
ڹŴֱԵ۹ҲͺͽòΪʱͨй۹һڵ۹ͳһ
Ϊʱеξʧˡй۹ҲûкϵӵֳعϵŴͺͽͬڹЩ
ʱйķչŵزڴ½ҵĵѾйһ
;صɵġʱǿĳһأرĻأҪأ˵Ĺҵʱ
ǰصȷط췽棬йȴܵ谭ⲻΪûʽϵı˾ƶԼ˰Ȩ
ƶȣҲΪûоϵĻֲй˾ей˵̬ȷ˺ʱķչ̬
ڹŽײԼЩ뵱ٵ˵رǿҡΤʵžĻ۵ģΪԻ½ʱ徫ڴ
ʱķչ˾áر𷴶Ψʷ۵Ĵھʶԭ˵ʱ徫
ϣʱ֮ǰͳˡڣ꣬ǾͶӢصΪ׷ϸ˱Թʵǣʱ
ڡڹϲݣչԶʵϲɴʲΪĿĶģӢֳ
СʲߡֹҵߺԸũİɴʿѧԺҵΪ˸ڽĿĶġϣΨĹ
ȷʵǰϵߵˡǣҪ˵ΤǾĻߣҲгֵɷ磬˵ҪעӦ
ȥڵĶԵԴȷ˵ÿһͼ˵ʱϾеĸҪԣر
ԾԿǡͬʱ෴ĹϵҲԿǵΪȻúķչֵںļͷɣ
ͬʱҲЩĳʵʺӪ˵ϰЩʱľΪķչͬʱҲ
صڲֵĺڽ̵ԼΪȥʼǶΪӰҪĹ֮һ
ʷŲΤļڣҳ꣱棩
    Τṩ˶Ԫ۵һʵ漰ڶصһΪÿػأһ
ŤһףÿһڶڷӰ죬ͬʱҲʩӰ졣ֺڽӰǡҪġ
ءСҪԡϵĻǡġ˵ʡǡԵģöԡѧ֪ʶڼ
Ӧþرáķɽṹͺṹ϶о޴Ҫԡǡزٵġȵȡ֮ÿһ
صҪ˵ˣǲǶ˵أӦóϣʷĳЩϣرھĻط棬ΤһЩ˵ȷ
֮ǣԶ޾ݵĿźȱʶҲټرǣһָΨʷ۰Ѵʶûϲ㽨
ϵߵˡȻϸ۾ݣͲѷ֣ԼѸ֮໥ϵŪһ顣ҪǶȥʷ
չĹɡǿͼѶԪ۵һܵԿףȥÿһ໥ûϵȴһҲûд򿪡
ԪһܶܵԿס
    ΤΪֶԪۣǹǰЩ꣬ʮ֮±ѧ磬
һġΤȡֻȥˣһСʹ޵ġ
󡱵۶ϲˡʷʷѧ˽й١
    ǣԪ۲ûšΤȡȥȻѧ˼ռλ
    ǼΨʷָʷоΪΪָϣǲܴӷ߽˷ʷ¼ʷ˶Ĺ켣
ȥ˳ӦĹɣԽٵĴȥµʷ·оʷĿڡԪ۵Σڣ
ǱĿóв塣ÿߵرģѱĽ·ڣٽάȵĴʱͻ֡
    磬̽й⽨ΪʲôйʱѿΪʲôɳʱǻ뵽⽨רȨһũ
ߺͺһҪԭ⵱ȻǶԵġǣǵ̽־ͣһ϶ȥһ׷ѰרȨΪʲôܹʵ
ߣŷڽķ⽨רȨΪʲôʵߣͿǻ뵽ƺ
ʹʱ۵һ̶ȾòתΪǲҵʱңҲһҪԭ򡣿ǣͺʢе
Ϊʲôٽ˷⽨ƶȵ˥ʱũʽӪķչأҲ뵽⽨ͳν׼ƶܷӹҵ
ãһҪԭ򡣿ŷͳԭҲڴ⽨УΪʲôγɹҵأǻ뵽Ʒ
õķչ赼СũȻóһҪԭ򡣿ǣʱƷòѾڶСũУΪʲôûдٽʱ
巢չأΪʲôƷõķչڴٽŷ⽨ũūƽͬʱڶŷȴٽũūƵٰǿأиٹ
ҲһҪԭ򡣿ǣŷͣѧǵĽ̵ǧ򻧵ʥͽ£Ҳǳ
˵Ϊʲô½Τ˵ʱ徫ʢҳķأ˿ڡ
ȵԭǶ뵽׷ѰȥͷЩԭ߾ã߷Щԭ򱳺иԭ
    뻥ཻѽѷֵʱΨʷһҪ׷Ѱָԭ򱳺ĸԭһֱҪ׷Ѱ
ԭǷ񷢻ûôСǸռԭǾΪ˵ʵ״ռԭֻ
ܱԪ۵ܴﵽ˷롢ģѱʷнʾڹɵĿġȻ̽Ϊ
˵ʵ״ʱƱҪȥ̽Ѱ־áΡĻϰסȻȵȶֶضǵ
ʵԼãѲǹȥЩصãǰǾ۽ԹͶߵʵֱ
ӵӰϣȥЩõʺʹСҲǡعǶʷõʺʹСԪ
۵
          ߣ׿  ʦѧʷϵڡʿʦ
                                              α༭
    
    
    
 
