 ׺ 2-3873
ԭĳѧѧ
ԭںš199501
ԭҳš004019
  šK5
  ʷ
    
ӡںš199504
    ǿ͵ı
    ִֶ̽еʷ
    
    Ҫ  ĴӶĽǶȣ̽˽һִִ󳱵̡һޱ
ڶսΪֽ߻Ϊ׶ΣĸںɸΪĸݱʽսǰձʱ幤ҵġɹӦ
ۡսǵ˹ҵشĳ֣Ӧ϶صʱǾءгҡĻͳִ
ȵĻϵۺϷ̽йصҺ͵ִµʷ顣
    ؼ  ִ  ø  ˹ҵش  չ͹  Ļ
        һԶʷתӦʶ
    ʮ͵ʷڷһתۣǾǵڶսγɵ뾭øֵľ޴仯ϵĴ仯ս
նŶƱƣת༫֣ϵĴ仯սΪĵʱϵ
ڽ壬γŷޱĵڶ˹ҵ
    ǣֳơ̫ƽޡPacific  AsiaӵϽָŷǴ½̫ƽ󰶵ıԵͰԵش޴½Ĵ½
뵺뺣Ķָй½ձеʰ뵺̨嵺ȣĶǰǼϰ뵺Ⱥ֮
ɰǼӡȰ뵺ҲڡͶǵԣҪй½ձʡй̨塢ۡ
ΧڣǺĻȦӰĵ
    ǵŵңɧԻƺӣΪγɵĻsinitic  civilizationũ
ơƶȡȵȣǺ͵кһȵλһֱֵʮʮͣŷҵʱ
ǵıԵ֮ǰʮͺŷҵʹ뷢شת·Ӵ½תԶʹ
ΪִոµҵŷǴ½𣬶λŷǴ½˵ĻĹŵũҵת
Ǳȫż̨ıԵձ⣩ҲʷĴת䡣ʷתڣΪı֯
ʷѧѶǽ綨Ϊϸʽʵͣ͡ר塢ձūơҲƵȵĴۣ
Ƶʷۣ˹ΤıȽʷѧ۵ķ£ۣݣγɶͣԵʷۡ
    ǣһ˵УǵľޱʹʱֿʼתָձսܹλԾΪ羭ô
ծȨǡСֳʱڶԾ˹ҵУйӡǲһΪ幤ҵ
гתȡóľ޴ɾͣ˹ҲѸıֳò׷١С׼ҵ̡֮Щ
Һ͵Բͬʽִķչ󳱣ǵľԶԶҹҵʱʷ¼Ŀġ
漣
    ǷľޱԹѧµսʮɵۡʮִۻʮļ
ۣܶʵĽ͡ʮڶǾ÷չᷢչıȽоΪѧ߹ע¿⡣ۣ
    ҪԶǽʶӦ˵ڶǾ÷չĵоȡúܴչսɵչ
شȱݣһǵù۵㣬˺ִǷǾھأһʷ۵ܱӵԵƾʷϵ
ԴһλձѧָбҪִǵı仯ֶ̽ǽʷĿܣбҪµĶǵĽִʷṹ
ԴʷϰִǷǳҪġֻۣʷ״۵ĽĽǶִ
ʷ̣ſܻйضǵʷ뷢չƵȷͼ
        ִеֻݱʽ
    Ǵ½ܱߵĶϺγɵĶϵ磬ŷΧϵЩƣΧӹΪ
ǵ˿ڡʱĻĽṩӶγɶľһĻǰִʱڣǵĹŵ
й½ΪĶ򶫱붫ǳչģйΪĵģʽũ̵ũдӡˢĻ
ֱͶ䵽йܱߵԭʼԭʼγл۹ΪĵġԳóΪĶϵۣ
֮ΪǡĻȦҲɳ֮ΪǡȦ򡰾硱ԱȵкԣйΪĻȦʤΪȦ
ġʷϵйεϾս۹ƶξ˥ֽһ޸ˣԳڱֶȶ֣
ԵγɢĴϵкĸִͬԿ϶˵ŷǴ½˵ĸʷչӺ
ѾֵԳϵĶ籣ԼĶչһֱʮҶʷȦǾ޽еġ
    ʮͣóףҵ̣ƼΪִγɲչΪһϵũҵ
ΪĶũ̽ϣ˹Ϊİ綼˥䡣Զóףг˹ҵߴǰִ
Ȼƽ⣬磬һסת˶֮Уģִ˶
ʷӷɢԵũҵһȫԵĹҵת䡣ڽУһŷ뱱ΪĶ½ġ
гΪִܵϵγˡ޴˵
    κָӵгõĶװáŷ޵ķչķչ޷г÷չгòԼ򣬰
ԽԽˣԽԽԶó򣬶Щó׼һڴһԵ硣ۣ
    ۲ǵĴڽִ֮ܽСʷоԹеġʮ
ǰǷչоʮǾޱԾ͸עˡʮǶʷת۵㡣
ȣӢռ¼£꣩ףۣ꣩꣩һȫµı˶ǵĽ̡ǵһ廯
ơһѻƬսձ˶ϵڶѻƬսԽϡկ˶ϵһս̨塢Ҳ
̱룻л۹漴壬ǵԵľء
    ʮʱͻ룬ʹǱΪĵµϵǶǲűޱĴ󳱣ʼ˴Ӵ
ͳũҵӦִҵµᾭƻתĹ̡Ұһת̷ֽΪ˥ܻԵԵ
ִĸ̡ۣԷì˶ڶǸϿΪֲͬĻݽ͡
    ձͣصûоڲ˥ֻܲܵ΢İԵͨĸĸֱӽ빤ҵһѸΪ
ģʱġ
    ͣصڲ˥ܻԵ֯ȫΪֳأֳ͵ĻͨĶ˶Ȼת
ִչԼɫĹҵ·
    йͣصǾڲ˥ܻ۹壬Եĳ̶Ȳڶأ̣ͨҵһ
ĵ·
    ֮⣬һЩλ̨ͣ塢Խϡ̩ǵȡֻеһ֣ձͣǱȽƽȵĽʽ
ƽڶֶǼƽȵĶʽƽձҲ򷢶սʧܶĴۡ¼۶ֳʱ廯
׶ΣڳִⰸŷԴִһ㶼ûгֹڲ˥ܻͱԵĲҲǳ⣩ǵ
бԵִִ۲Եֳ壬ƹͳһģʽǼȺ
ʷ뱾ʵʵġ
        ձǰִɹӦ
    ʮͺڵͣҵŷ뱱½չǳ֮Ϊִڶ˳ڣͬʱҲֳ˶
δڡ°ҶֳµĹҵ빤ҵȫչǳΪִ˳ǵı
ԵرΪ׶Ρ׶μһϵиԲͬ
    ڵһ׶Уձ⣬ǶԵͰԵԨձй֮γԵķձѸʵִ
ҵת䣬ӶǵıԵһԾΪǵµ۹ģл۹ұѸٽ壬Ӱӡġ쳯Ϊİֳ
йִıȽоһֱǹѧעһش⣬ձġɹΪоĽ㡣ָȥ
оǲִķʽ롰ͳһִֿܡѧǶԴͳձ봫ͳŷȽϣ磺ձĻ
ŷĵȼƣձĴŷķ⽨ׯ԰ƣձʿĻĻĹĻĻ⻹гӼ̳
ϮȼƵȷ棬ҵ֮ӿ˼˹Τע⵽ձͳᾭýṹеĳЩ
⽨ƵۣЩŷΪϵıȽоԶձִйһ˵Ľͣȴ
˵ΪʲôձһĶʱھѸʵһɵת䣬һԾΪʱ幤ҵǿ׻˵
ϡձһͻӡձҲΨһķңΨһƽȵֳ̬
ķҡ˵ձΪִгֵġһۣ
    ܽձġأȷձṹĳЩص㣬رձڵ´ʱڳֵȶƷ
ƣ˵˵ʱձڲȷвͬҵġԡԶԶģָձڡԡǾʮ
˹ҵ򶫷ֳƽԶλʮͰʮǰֳ񻯵ĵڷޡǺͶǲֵ
ֻܵ˳ǰײձץסʮļ϶ˡǿ·ߣʵǽȨ˶˶ϣм
͵ִйҲЧձά±䷨Ȩṹ˥ܣʹҪһССġִҲٲά裬
ʮʱۣձδµͳһ֮ʱͰСԭȺͼ꣨
꣩Զ̨壻ξ꣨꣩ʽĲƽԼǿڳʣ߽йڶǵĳϵζʮ꣨
꣩ĵһսձ˵۹Ϸйļȷ棬Ǵ𲽵̨볯ʵִ˶ƻй
ʮꡰǿ˶ҵӪȫɹձִֶʽִǶһ޶ġʮ
ѧоձΪִĳɹġģʱԼֻͬӾ÷չǶۣݣձִеķ
صãƬĹ۵ƺкӰ죬ȫִΣǳ
    ձʱıȫִΪġ˵ķЧӢ³ʿģʽʵձЧӢ
ģʽֻһǡձʱǺƾܽϵձʽʱ塣ڲṹԣ⽨ʱȨ
ͻͳ˧ȨĶרʡεľ岻ͬ壬ִŷչ͹ңdevelopmental  state
ⲿԣձ죬йŷѹȵķڣʱŷԣձԴԵȶǵ
γɵġۣһλձѧָձνǡǡǡνǡǡǡۣ
˵йִ˶άЧձ䷨ʧԺߵִͨĶص·ôձάһֱߵ
ִͨĶص·ձִĸƽҺ͵ִΪ۵ġǵԴг
֧ձ¶۹ձԴ˺ͶʷɵϾƣǵʱκҶġ
    ִĳɹ徫ϵĳɹҶ˽ʱĴֲ͹ʱų⣬÷
Դƶձʱķչ»ĹҵϵѸٸıձĹʵλձһûת
ãȨѹȨ˵Ȩ˶;ϡְӵִձһȨ巢չһתĹ
У׷ֵ۵˼ҸͼҲȨĳ߱ΪȨĴ֣Ϊձ׾ѣΪձڼս
еʤжݺᡣʮͺڶǸձ𣬶Чձάģʽʵһ룬һģʽҲ
ǲӦЧġ
    ִۣձִĳɫȹ֮ձĻĿԣѧϰȡĻֽԡǿ
ļֵۺ͵ľΪĻ׼ڽ죬Ӧڶִʶϣձִȫʷӣ
ۡ¹ۡڰǰڣӢķйձִ˶ĻͻıȽоһġ
ƪһЩ̼⣬ֵ˼Ϊձʽִͳν׼뼯ȨĿ֮£
ϸġԵġȶġЧʵִָ
    ձִûкشĲ֮ձ쵼ڽʱʵһٵת䣬֮еԶҲֻܿ
ĳЩࡣǴĻҪԼŲǿʳĿƣСرձͳĴɷ֣ʹ֮
ĴȾΪزúսִǿӲʹͳĻвٶԭʼԣŻɽΣ
աۣ
    ƪעԤձִаصΣȻɽһըٶǸִ
ҲըձִĳɹձѧҲָʱᳫձϣܾľʣҴ
ѡ̵ۣʷѵֵ̽֡
    άڡǿ·½еġòҵִֻʽִΣʿִںˡͳ
ִڴתеĻãִҪӵö࣬иĶɫδٽͳִ֮Ի
֮ĶԻӦܽһҪ顣
    ձά϶µִձĵѣbreakdownڴ϶µľ
ֻп¶ϵĸĸԤеڶִǵڶսԺձߵĵ·йǿ˶ʧԺ
ִΣǣһһ¶ϵķִͨ̽ĵ·ձֻսйִ
ѣҲйִģʽתⶼֵ̽⡣
    ձʱڶǵҲʹսǰĶǳ͵ʱصһձֳسʡ̨塢ʡ
ȴֵȫĻֳʱ廯һӢйɵһֳذֳʱ廯Щ
Եڶսʱķչĳϵǵξѧеһµ⣬дڽһо
ۣ
        ġսǷչصı֤ϵ
    ˵սǰִֻձһȡóɹľ飬вȫĳɹôսִȫһ־棺һʱ
ھһϵйҺ͵ƶϹҵĵ·ȣй½ڣ񾭼ûָת빤ҵļƻýʱ
ձ򡰺ս衱սؽ׶Σʮʽ밲ÿʼ¡ɡ̨塢Ϻ¼¡
ͳƶǡСʮȺͬʱáɡ̩ǡӡᡢɱͳƶĹľøҪһЩ
Ҳٸֻӡ֧ڷǾõԭͣͣԽϵʮҲַչͷ죬ڶǱԵѾγһ
˹ҵشŷޱĹҵһҵ˿࣬гû羭̫
ƽƶǶִȡõĵһɹչǺܲƽġ
    ǵΪѧоһ⡣ΪֹǹھøĸоͼʷչĽǶȣ
ĽǶȣƶսǵ̵ִصĹϵۺϷ
    ӽعʷսʱ˵𣬾һڹȥδʶڶսǶǽڱһ
ˮ롣ȣձڡսʷĴʧȫı˶ؽⲿձҲؽΣ
ձŷֳ۹߽µİȨռ䣬һԾΪ̫ƽ޵סٴΣŶγɵնĸ֣ҲʹսǴ
ӪԵεǰڣγֶģʽսսԽսǿԮΪսڶǵ߳Ͼṩ
ΪҪĻս󻷾ֵش仯Щ仯ǣʱһηչΣ֮һ
޸սǰ޴ľñߣΪ׵µĹʻƣʮʮ羭ôڿҮ򳤲
ھ׶ΣʱֿǰľþڶڣṩµĹгµ
ҵر΢ӼͽͨͨѸ˹ҵṹıԼִ֪ʶĴֳ߽
ͨԮʽƶǷҺ͵ľµĹʷֹΪҹͬȡ¾սԣҵķչپ
ȫ򻯡ȵȡЩ仯ս緢չսǰͬһµļִ󳱡˵µʱ

    ǣΪµʱԶѸϸٷչĵ·ǾͰѸӵʷóɻһĸʽˡ˼˵
ΪƵ飬ڲͬʷг־ȫͬĽЩչеÿһֱоȻٰǼԱ
ϣǾͻҵԿףۣ
    йͬʱܷ׽һԳãȫȡǷӦ仯Чؼõ
ơǰĿתսڶǸڲͻᷢѰϾǵʱûϣĵ֮һȣй
½⣬ǸձȻԴƶǺӡзḻʯԴ˿ڸ߳ܺͿռʮ޵ĵ
սƻԱȽϵľָ½ڷҡΣ̨塢ʡԽϡ¼µȶֳ峷˺Ȩؽת
Ƶּ⣬ûе⡣ٴΣҲΪϾģնɵķѾ³ͻʱձռ
֮£ʰ뵺ӡ֧뵺ս̨庣Ͽ¶šΪЩ桢ʶ̬໥ԿҡΣ
Եĵ֮һ¸ء̨ľ֧һÿռֵϣռԤģҡֻձ
ø¿֧ܵ͡ЩȣûڶǻܿѺΪܳɹ
ҡ˵֡漣ˡ
    սǳֵʷ漣ڣһ濴ϣĵ˷ѹأЧʱ޵Դȡ
¼ĸԼĳɹ·ڶǸ͵ʷʵľ޴죬ķչģʽģʽתͬá
һԿ״һķȥ̽͵չİءҲһЩͬԵľ̽Ҫִ̽ķǾ
⡣Ϊⷢչѧͷչѧ̸̫١
    ˹ΤоʱԴʱ˹ڡ½ļ˵һֱִֽܴۡ̽ʱҲ
ˡ⡣һں滹ҪָۡƶǾ÷Ծһֶصľؼʶ
ʶִûеġǵ岻ͬʮʲ׼гֵ塣ڷֳ
Ļϲģδսֳض˶ǿ徫γȡ뾭˫
⾫ǻʶָγɵķ澳ͷܽʶձṫ˾Ĵҵ֮һʢѷдձ
Ϊšǽµĵزÿ춼Ҫ𶯡ˮǵĵϼʲôԭҲûУ˾ס͸ֵزķ֮һ
ˣ˵еһжǱġۣ˵֮ضȡʶܲǿӦ
ھǵִҪ֧һλѧָҲΪ־ĻԼһ
дͷԣǲ޻޹ûеŬҲʹöǹҽ޵Դѵã˳ɳ
ͷչġ漣ۣʷǣձСй̽ԼʺϹ»ʺϹ·ӣǿ
ˣǿԼѻеĲ̽磬ǸսڶǲáҵսԣƱת
ϷչսԡձǡСǴתΪ򣬲Ĵ裬ʮԮȡԼѰҵ
·ˡũԹǿ̸߽Ϸչĳɹ顣ۣ۴תóתõͶ
չҵڳսʱй½˵Ĳ´ġ¼µչӢʿԶԺϾ
𲽵ġй̽Լɫ巢չģʽҲӰ֮̽ҵġ
    ڶִбֵӦھձսǰսˡսڣձɥʧΪӦ
һΣȡˡصʽȶ֮Ѹٴͳƾгùɣڱȷ´֮Сķ
롣ʮʵóɻʱɻѸʵ˾ɡʮġɳʯΣٴθձԳصĴ
ձּʱҵṹͶ͹ϵԴģչ²ҵ͵ҵ跨ձƷĹʾ
ʮó˳ձҪó׻ìܼӾ磬ʮһٽҵṹĸ߼תȫ򻯡
ľսԡ粻£ֿʼ;÷ת䡣ձþڲҵ˷һѹص
ǰٷչġңľҲĪˡ
    ɴ˶һҪʷ顣սʾû£츳ԴķᱡҵĴСλãʱرԮ
٣Ǿ񾭼ٶȲҪԭ򣬹ؼھи߶ȵʶĵƣڲ׽һ
أ䲻ΪأЧܵؼá֮ʹзḻԴõҲʹӦٵĹΣ
õʱ
    ͼ  {ͼ}
    Ĺģ뾭
    ԴеȷչΪҪݡйΪʣ̨һΪʣڶΪ
ʡ
        塢ǡչ͹ҡҪ
    Ŀġ漣ĳгƵΰɹƻƵĳ¹ŵ侭ѧͼչ۶ܺ
ý͵⡣
    Ĺŵ徭ѧ÷չҪгɵתͨһֻ֡Ϳ԰ѹ븻ԣ֮
ǰ۽Ĺ۵෴Ϊ÷չҪҼƻתͨһֻü֡ѾԤķչĿꡣ
ҹ˼ʱڣΪֻüָ֡һУץǰεƵ塣
    ǵ¾ѾƬĹ۵㡣ɾѧڴɵĵλԼ˷չйҳɹ
飬ȴʹеרԼĹ۵㣬˱¹۹õ⡣ۣ
    ɹľǾԵг۵ԵĹߵĽϡⷽ棬ձȻ˹עķΪձǶ
ӽƵг͹ҡڶսԺձսǰרƹұйشĸ졣ձ
ڶһҪΪձĹұǾʹˡձǶ൳ƣһֱ
ľ档һϱսĳȶھϣɢ˾ɲƷǿ˾õɻʽɣ
һ־ձɫļƻгáⲢȫսƶȴ£Ϯսǰͳƾõŷ硣ݺѧֶףKarel  G
van  WolferenձȨṹжԣձȨɢһЩԵļСͨıƽ
йΣιšϵĳЩҵҼŵĽϣһṹǡձơǿĳɷۣ֡ѧ
ڡͨʡձ漣һУձõ˶ʵ֤Եоۣݾܻۣձһʱ巢չ͹
capitalist  developmental  stateɹҵƶʱ巢չǿ϶ɵġձĹԱʽϸߣԾù
ְҲǿԤѡԵĸԤƶгƶȵơձȷĹҵķչսĿ꣬
ֱʺĽùϵ£սеƵĹҵսĿսǰľŵսĿȡøɹ

    гΪ˹ҵҺ͵Ϯսǰֳƻսľƶǽһָ߶ȼȨ
ȨԾáΡȫĸԤùƼձƶȡµηչ۰಻ͬ
ƵгõȨΪȨȨauthoritarian  regimeۣݵΪɸȫʵзεľ

    ǵƻΪ͹ңһ·չ͹ҡǵ׿гЧĸĳɹ
ʵȫԵгչͶ⿪ŵĸĸȡõġⷽ棬йӼƻгùɵ¾ΪעĿйΪ
ũҵ൱ձ붫˹ҵܺ͵ģ˿൱ǵܺ͵ģйִͨҵļǿ
ġڣʤͷУڼƻȡ˹ҵĳɾͣõĸҪǿͶȡõġ
꿪ʼĸĸ·ߴһԵıĸȴũ忪ʼƶũҵĴţȻչ򣬴쾭ʹ
ýṹԪгƹɡӣ꣭ʮУֵȫˮƽ
۳أֽйũҵƷλΣ־ӵڣλΪλúӵڣλԭӣλԭ
ӵڣλԭӣλˮࡢ޻ţⶼһλֻռ磷ĸռ磲˿ڣͬһʱ
ʹũ˿ƶйΪ̽Լִ·ٵսڽҲȻǼ޵ġ
    ֮ڶǣйһֱձ͵ִңƲͬĹͬǺ۾ȶٳһ
ֶиΪҷչҪĿֲġֶʽġչ͹ҡִҵķȣнϸ̶߳ȵ
Ȩʣͬڴͳľʽ뼯ȨңӦÿǴӴͳȨִתһֹʽִеҪ
ǱַչеĽϸ̶߳ȵȶǿھƶάȨĹҵƻȡ徭ߣʵʩ
ߣǿƵ͹ߵ˽ͻ֤ṫƽ븣ٽϣȵȡЩʩڸ߶ȵᶯԱƽٹҵ
չ˵Ĺƽɷܴﵽġݺľ飬ʮǡϧκδ۵
ʮλڡһʮΪƽֽһΪΪʵۣ

    ע⵽άϸƶ跽棬ҲشáΪ԰С¼ⷽʹ
мֵľ顣¼ࡢʵͶƣ࣬ûصȶ⣬ûдģǷ۶ĺ˽
ᵳֵ⡣Щǿ뾭÷ֵͬÿҫִɾ͡
    ʶҵҪԣҪĲ֧֣ҲҪи߶θУ˲뱸쵼ӣӾִ
ѧר֪ʶΪҵҴһĻضĳŵⷽҲкҪľ顣ִۣ۶Էչ
йӦעȨʵȨʵ۵ġʮΪƽȶĿ
ԵĹ۵ռϷ磬ִķչΪǺгĺֱʽġʮϾʵһ˵սʵ
չˮƽβȶĹϵƸ빫ƽĹϵһһ߹ϵѶ͢ΪصĲȶ״̬еȷչˮƽ
ġȶĸԭͬھСۣǶԺг۵һҪ
    ִȨ˶ķչƵģȨܵƣȨ֧Ȩǵִ
ͬŹȨ˶˶չġȨһȨ֮ϣӦȨ˶սǰִʱڵĵ
׼ظĸ˶򵹣˵ҵ빤ҵʲ׼ҵķֳɳġһʷγɵĽṹصʹй͵Ƿ
ҶûгֹᣬЩηչҲհģʽִ˳һͺڹҵŷ޾Ĺ
ҵķչ˳ҲˡڶǣԭеνṹӡĹʱʱγɶصΣýṹ뻥ϵ
׷Ǹش۵ġȨˮƽƣѪ̩ƣ̬ƻȾȡҲҪע⵽
ٶȵ׷ᵼʧҲƻͬݳǰ׷ҲӰ쾭Ŀ꣬ɴ
ҡֲͬʷ鶼ֵüȡġ
    ִõĲҽṹ뷢չģʽҲؽӦת䣬ֻܼǿõԣӶɸ
ִչͽһйӼƻгõģʽתشڴˡȨṹҲ
ӦתһͺھģʽתڶǵʹԾؽӦԵƸĸֻҪг÷
׼׳µؾͻ𽥳ɳҪĸ̨ⷽĸĸǳٳٲġﱣһ
нϳĻʡѡٵľ飬ڽϸȥԺŽȡϿϵĿţĶԪԭȨ
еνṹʼȨɢķתۣݺھʮҲͨѡٷʽͳͷηӪ˽׵
˶ʵС¾ߡȵȡⶼֵעĶ򡣴⣬žõʻԤĳ̶Ҳ
        ǷչеĴͳĻ
    ͳĻڶִĽʲôãҲоеһעĿ¿⡣
    ԡġй˼һֱǷͳ˹Τ½ıȽѧо
巢չļ˵ڹѧӰ졣ۣݵǣӰĶǵʱ塣˰־
жɫʱΪʱ塱ѾӰĶĻΪĻNeoconfucian cultureۣ
йض̵ִо˾ȡ֮⣬Ļȡ
    ѧǣݽкŴݽǷҲĻŴأҿеġִ
Ϊֹֹηչ߳ʮͺڵʮϰҶǵһθ߳ŷʮкڵͳǵ
θ߳ŷ󵽶ŷֵڻĻȦȦ°Ҷֵĵθ߳ԵĴ
ɢȴԶƵϵĶǣڽӽǵҲڽܹͳεǵ˵
ִɢĻȦ֮ĳֹϵǵܱǵ˹ǵķ̡ӡȽ̵׽ִܶ
󳱡ʷϣʮĻطرڶγɵĻ˾ȦƺҲһ֤Щںķ
ҴҵǿأҪǿ̿͵ʣСӪңȡҵ¸Ļᡣǵľ󶼳񵱵صӡ˻
һǶȱͬʱ徭вͬӦ
    ĶǾȦϿȷҲһĻȦĻȦڵĸ͵Ļȷڲ̶ͬлͳĻ
Ŵ˿˵ͬһĻȦĻȦǽųֵһʡΪӦΪ̻ĻȦȷһ
Щ̲ͬڶڽ̣׻ѧάȨѧ˵Ҳ淶ʽȵȡʵ
ںй̣һЩĶԽйķΧǵҵͳ߹ٷȻҲʽ
ȥѧǡ̻ĹҲǡĹ̡⴫ڹıĻϣγձѧѧԽ
ѧ뱾Ļйѧķ档ֻгʱйѧΪϣ̶Ϊ̣γͳѧơ
ѧйĴͳũҵϴĵطӰСӰ죨йͱҲعݿ
̻ڶǵı뺣Ұ½򾭳Ұ
    Ļһڲϱ仯뷢չел壬һ̬ľܰɾ̬̬ڶĻ
ӴĹУ嶼ռϷ粢ͬҵԺƼתֱ£Ӧҵִ
սһб塣ѧڶǸĹͬˡڽ춫ǵУĻغȻְһֽɫ
ΪִأȷһȤ⡣Ҫ⣬ġʱ²ĻԱȵķ޼
µġҪŪѧڶִʧԭ֮ڡͳѧִ֮˼άʽγɵһ
ѭءīسɹĴͳҪǴͳѧƶȻγȨṹ໥ֵ֧ĹѧƶȡΤоȴ
Ȳ֣Ǵ˼ֵġǽѧоеı֮ڣҪ֪Ϊѧ֧ŵľƶȵȫ壬սǸ
͵·չѧ˼ڶκεΪ˼룬˼ڶԪݣ飬˿лͽ
ռͽıռձͽ˿ڱظߴ̨ۣĸŽУͽռ
ͽռۣѧĳּԣ˼ĶԪһµ󡣿ǾƶȽ岻׵ĵط
ͳѧҲͱִ࣬ĸӰҲϴֻھƶȽȽϳ׵ĵطͳѧаʵԵĶ
ſܱųƳ³£áҲֻǴͳѧı֣ʽµľ
    ĻһͳĸκһĻһӵĻ塣ĻҲˡȰоӢĻ֣
Ļ֡ĻֿɷΪС񣨶УĻũĻЩﻹеײĻ̽Ļ뾭
Ĺϵʱӹ׻ҡ׻ҡĹ۵㣬оС׷ʵũʵ澫ͶǾûĸԴ
ΪлĻȦĻȦеĹϵȷӳһЩͻԿͣڼ󣬴ϰףʵ壬
ʵ壬ﻥȵȡЩȷǵľΪֱӰ졣ǷЩĻأ֮Ϊӹ
׻ĻأƺЩǣǿᡣЩǶŵũҵ᳤γɵһֻϰ߻ΪģʽԼ׳ɵļ
ֵۣӦΪǡԡ¡ı֣СϵؾԡǨǡԡһۣ롰
ĵ¡һҵ²ܻȺšЩڶġԡ򡰹ԡĶ֮ĻΪϰΪ
ĻΪлĻͳܴš
    ˵ԶʷչشӰĻڶǵʵչвᷢӰ졣ֻӰһʷת
ڵ£µƶȿܣҪгãڣ˼Ҳѷشת£䵽ʵ֮еġ
ЩӰ죬Ҫӳ¼棺
    ҵġ˼תΪһֹҵķչ塣˼Ļǣٵõ
ҵ˼Ļǣӡõûзչʶġ񡱵ͱ׼ǡ񲻼
Ȩβͬ޵Ȩ壬ĳָҳƵŴ򡣡ľںתΪзչսԣγ
϶µŽĽȡ񣬻γһɹҵڵĹ˽ǲͬƶȵĶʽչ͹Ҷеص㣬֮г
õĹҾиߵھܳת͵ľ޴ѹ
    ҵļ屾λ˼ھִתΪƶʱ巢չʱԸΪ
гƣʷγɵĹŵʱ塣Ϊʱ徫־½֡Ϊ
˽ʱ쾭塣ԼΪλձǣʱ巢չγСͼҵʽҵġι
ʶתġҸʶͬƶʱĿٷչǵּŶʱ֮ĸʱ
ԵġΡɫʡʹϵгŵ㣬ѧֶ߰ʽʱΪһʱ塣ձγΪһֹ˾ʱ
壬ԡ󷨱ƣӶơʹơҵƣһʱڲΪձҵҪ
áۣ
    ǣҲӦÿִ÷չĲһ棺Ӱ˿ڵͣ𱰵Գַ
ҵһϰʽչӴģת򡰷ʽҲȻڳеصִ֯ܡۣ
    ӽȵĽ˼תΪԴĴҵĽռ˵Ļ뼼ʶϸߡ
緢չйⷽھ޴ࡣ˹ҵһͬȻԴƶԴḻӽռΪ
չõһҪֶΡⷽ棬ձʱԸʶս̨塢¼ҲĪǡһҪ
ǽչٶȳٶȡݣͳƣĽռGNPģңңձΪ
ΪһЩҵͣε˿ڽУıԣ̨塢ձ
Ӣۣڶᣬһõ𴫳УӳĸԶŮѧҵ˲ŮĽҲ
Ӱֵõѧһ飬ĸǣ϶Ůѧϰɼǳ⡱йձĸǳƹ۵
ģһȽϵ׶԰׶Σ̨ͯѧɼû𣻵Сѧ̨ѧѧɼ
ѧ꼶ߵĲ󡣣ۣݶǵѧձȡѧϰɼҲ֪ġȻ
Ļرǿѧڸ߿Ƽͬӽ翪ţͶ
Ƚشáе緢չ棺Ͷܽƽʱһ꣬GDPͻӣʹGDPߣ
ӿ˼ĲáĽʹִĲ࣬Ҫȡ漰֪ʶʵ崫һ˿
˿ܽԽ࣬¼֪ʶԽסۣҲһҪĻѧԭɡ
    תĻصĹתȻֹЩϼͻ֮㡣
    ִĶԣҪӦִĹҵͿƼתУǵĴͳĻ棬γɶԪĻ
ֳִͳĻȫģµʷ¿ܷӳصӦھγһ
ʽִڽ춫Ƿչʾһص㣬Ǿķչָ꣨˿ڵԤͳʶΪָ
ԶԶھ÷չָꡣϹΪ÷չָλйľ÷չָӵڣλ
ķչָȴڵڣλ¼¡۵ȵָ궼Ѵﵽҵˮƽۣݽѧ綼
ע⵽ǾøеĻءеѧΪڶִаݵĽɫ½ŷ
Ҫ󡣣ۣݽʶ֮ʿӦй붫Ƿչ¾ѧϰЩʲô⣬ִҵĲ̬չ
ġⷽ棬ѧԴеķḻ̲أƳ³£϶δĺгչµĹס
        ߡǵķչǰ
    Ķʷ˴ʢ䣬ִӳʢ۹̣ǴӴͳũҵִҵĴ
ת䡣ǵִʷͻصǣһ˼͵ĴѹΪʱеļת䡣һʷԵ
ƻì˶ԴͳıڴͳĸϽеġͳִԵĻϵгɹľ飬ҲʧܵĽѵ
ͨ·ִҵͽִģʱ巽ʽĶģʽҲ巽ʽĶģʽʷγɵģ
ʷĺԡÿģʽ㶼ʵܵģʽת䡣ִĵ·ǶģִĴ
ͬģûκ赲ġͬ;һ¶ǡϵǡǶѧʷչľٸǧ
Թ⾰£֮ߡ
    죬ǵľγһ˵ľȦ򾭼ãĻȦ˵ĹҵشȻγһݼչСձս
ǰʵ˳ҵսĹҵˮƽʮѸȽִڸԺ׶Σڶôȡ
Ϊ򾭼õġСʮԾ뷢İ빤ҵңҵĳ׶κеȷйѳ
ԼĶľ޴ҵϵµķʽʵغĹҵȡҶеȷĹҵС̩
ʹԼķչսصӳƷתͶܼҵΪĳҵ׶ΡǰһչݼΪձΪ׵ġ
ΡУձСڹҵûгֹ¸֣Եʱ¹ʷֹ˵
羭ϵľͶֹĸ֣ҵũҵڷش仯ŷ塢γɶ־ø֡
θĻ֮仯
    巢չǰΣһϵȫչ⡣йء̫ƽ󾭼ȦǾȦһĹ
ۣݵԤʵԽȡءϵĹҵĹʱȫϵ
ϵڵڶսѷ仯ĵҵṹ߿Ƽչʱ۷ʽı仯ȵȡЩ仯
ͶܼͲҵԵתƣʹ緢չйпͶƷչԼ幤ҵѪ̩ƶȲ
չڵ;ãȡþõĸ˹ҵڸı䡰ġ롰ԵľɵĹʷֹҲڸıԵ
ĹʷֹǵݼչоǰҵˮƽִˮƽȻγɵġۣ
    ͼ  {ͼ}
    Ǹ͵ķչˮƽȽ
                ҵˮƽ
    Դۣܿڣڣ꣹£գ
    ˾Ƚ
    ˹ҵγһ׷Ҹϵĸ֡ݼʽ׷ϵ¸üĶ໥ϵγɻĿ
ԾȦһ棬ŸúͼʵͶܼͲҵƵҲ໥ľӾ磬ʹǱɹʾ
óͻӾսδķչǰΣȡԤıǷչĵ·ƽ̹ġ͵
ʷʾǣֻŬչһ໥¸֣ſʹսĶתΪƽ빲ͬٵ¶ǡۣ

    ע
    ۣݿκط򣺡ר塷뱾йƳ磬ꡣ
    ۣ˹Τ̡뱾磬ꡣ
    ۣݲThe  East  Asian  Miraclea  Word  Bank  Policy  Research  ReportNew  York
    ۣдܣʷٹɡ뱾ΪǾõķչгӡݣ꣬ڣ
ҳ
    ۣݲΣ⨩־йιꡣ
    ۣݷѶϡ޴͵úʱ塷뱾꣬ڶڣҳ

    ִۣۣйִ̡ѧ磬꣬ڣҳ
    ۣݸһ˹Τйձִѧо꣬ڣڡ
    ۣ˹ŵ˹ȫѣʷ̡뱾ӡݣ꣬ڣ¡
    ۣݲִۣйִ̡ѧ磬꣬ڣҳ
    ۣʯһɣǷִġձģʽۡĳ졷񵺶ɱࣺձִξ졷
ꡣ
    ۣԶɽïձִʷ뱾ӡݣ꣬ڣڣҳ
    ۣˮҰͼġ֤ۡĻִѧۻᡷ꣬
    ۣHu  ShihThe  Modernization  of  China  and  JapanA  Comparative  Study  in  Cultural  ConflictThe  Cul
tural  Approach  to  Historyedby  Caroline  FWareNew  Yorkp
    ۣɭͨ򣺡Ļձִ桷ѧ־İ棩ڣڡ
    ۣݹ⣬ɲο¹ѧڶϣ˹ҵҺ͵۹Ӱӭͷϵʵ
ࡶִʷõ̽֡Ϻĳ磬꣩ձѧдڡǾõķչ
гһĵ¡ʷṹ̽֡УҲ⡣
    ۣ˼¡־༭š˼˹ȫİ棬ڣڣҳ
    ۣʢѷ򣺡ձ졷꣬ڣҳ
    ۣݸThomas  Gold˹Էչ۵ս»ͱࡶͶȷչ뷢չ̨ͼ鹫˾
꣬ڣҳ
    ۣκࣺйʽʱ壭̨г֮·̨֣꣬ڣҳ
    ۣݣۣݡ緢չ桷İ棬ڣҳҳڣҳ
    ۣKarel  Gvan  WolferenThe  Japan  ProblemForeign  Affairsno
    ۣݲĬ˹Լѷͨʡձ漣뱾й뵳У磬ꡣ
    ۣݲPeter  LBergerEast  Asian  CaptalismA  Second  CaseThe  Capitalist  RevolutionFifty  Propositi
on  about  ProsperityEquility  and  LibertyGordon  WhiteedDevelopmental  Sates  in  East  Asia

    ۣݣۣݣۣݣۣα壺õ𡷣뱾ӡݣڣҳڣ
ҳڣҳڣҳ
    ۣѶ͢٣չĿ꡷ִʷࣩ̽֡ѧ磬
ڣҳ
    ۣݽҫ̨ĸоѧĻе̽ʮһۣ͡ꣶ¡
    ۣݲκ࣬ǰ飻Herman  KahnThe  Historcal  and  World  Context  of  East  Asian  Development
    ۣ԰̨ڽ̵ִơĻͼ񡷣£̨ʳĻ˾꣬ڣҳ
    ۣݲйļԸ񡷣԰ࡶй˵Ը񡷣̨оԺѧо
ꡣ
    ۣݲPetet  LBergerǰ飻Ĭ˹Լѷǰ顣
    ۣΤ̨ͨ徭áʮһۣ͡ڣڡ
    ۣݻƹ˼붫ִ̨ͼ鹫˾꣬ڣҳ
    ۣݱޡϣδѣΪ׼뱾»磬꣬ڣҳ¼ķ
չָ
    ۣHerman  KahnThe  Historical  and  World  Contextof  East  Asian  DevelopmentAsian  Security  in  the  
sProblems  and  Politicies  for  a  Time  of  Transitionedby  Richard  HSolomon
    ۣݲΣȴ֮ǾȦĻйձΪġоѧ
ڣڣۣ̫ƽʱ̫ƽѧڣڡ
    ۣݲAlein  LipietzTowards  Global  FordismMarx  or  RostowSerie  des  Tires  a  PartNoPari
sImperialism  or  the  Beast  of  the  ApocalypseibidNo
    ִۣʷʮǰѧڣڡ
      ѧʷϵڡʿʦ    α༭    ף
    ѧִо
    ֿδעͣ
    ԭûȥ쯼ӱǼһټӱ
    
    
    
 
