 ׺ 3-2367
ԭĳʷ
ԭ
ԭںš199704
ԭҳš82-90
  šK1
  ʷѧ
    
ӡںš199710
    δͳͳһʷѧʷ
    
    ǰҶʷѧȺ֡ʷѧprogressive history͡ͳһʷѧconsensus historyǰԲ
˹ȶµȣCharles Beardۢ٣ΪҪߣ衰塱ĸ˶֮磬ʷΪһжἯš׼
ʶֹ̬ìܶʷǿĸﴫͳʷеλһͳĻʷáͳһѧ
ڣͣﵽȫʢʱʱڣȻơ򡰽ʷѧǿ󹥻Ρ
ͳȫµ뷴ʡ֪ʶ磬رʷѧشӰ졣
    ͵ǰҶȫԣȷһ޴Ķʱ˼䣬ھ˽ġ塱ĸ˶лʱ
ġʵʩһȸǡԼ̧ͷ
    ͬʱҲ˾Ҷһսı繲˶ķչ˹һʱⱡ𡢶սսᡢй
ʤսıսƵγɣȵȡ
    һϵش¼Ľ£ڱأ֪ʶҲһµ˼뾳ۣռϷ
壨McCarthyismĳֱ־Ķ㡣˼ı໥һµʷʱڡһʱ䣬ӳ
׷꣬ƤءΤˣPeter Viereckġ̸塷ConservatismRevisitedһĳ淢
Ҫźš˺¿ˣRussell Kirkġ黳the Conservafive Mind¹˹ءοAugust Heckscher
ġһģʽA Pattern for Politicsȵȣ
    ʷѧΪ֪ʶһԱʱ˵ĻɫͳһʷѧThe Consensus Schoolɴ˲ǹͬ򡰽ʷѧ
ϳͻìʷǿгһ¡ʷͳеλǵĽͣʷԡһ
͡ԡContinuityΪص㣬ʷĿϣǿŽճΪһĹֵۣͬΪ
䡰ԡͬ͡һԡԭϣͼսʱɻ󼰽ƫִͨԼͳʶӦʱ
֡
    ʵͳһʷɾǸ߶ͳһΪԵɡս̬ƵӰ죬һɡȡͳеı
򡣴Ե˹͡Daniel BoorstinͿֶ١أClinton RossiterΪվڡҡһ棬ף
ĳɹһ¡˹ΪRichard Hofstadterǰ̽ȫһ£ͳе
ͬһԡ͡ԡͬеĳЩԭֵۡǣǱš侲վڡ󡱵ķ棬
δͳɫʾԣΪһʧܵĴͳΪأȱԡԺӦԡ
            ͵ԡ
    ֶ١غ͵˹͡ǿ˵һֱĳָ߶ȵһԡ崫ͳ⴫ͳʷ
ͬʱֲڹͬϰ߼ഫƶС
    Ϊֳʱ𣬱ֲϣΪЩֳѻɣûҪΪ֮ս
£ܷѷԡǵʧȥʣΪʱڱ֧Ŀ겻ǡ̡
ЩȷΪʽɲֵ뷱١ۢ٣ؽһʷʼճűı֣
䴫ͳ弰ɼƣ·һֱǱصģ塢ơ廯ļ塢ϵ
ԸԺ׼ṹԼĴͳ塣ĶԣһĳǱ˲ھü
ϼˣεǱ֮
    ͳһѧɣرǡҡۣǶʵĹ涨Ϊܷƶ֮ǰڱһ
ƽȵв׼ᣬڼֻܷܶѷ֮䲻κԵѺۣܷѷһɣȷǼַǷߣ
ֻͼȥļֵ۶ѣսǰϱ˫𲢷ƲμսҲ߱
ʣΪϱ˫δκ˲õ⣬ǲڴͳķ֮ƶȵĻ֮Уǡǡ
ʷԡ
    ͳһɡֱǵ˹͡δͳġԡuniquenessڡε
һУָǲеŵ㣬½ʷǰĻһĲظ
ʷϡĵʷصһֻ᲻Դļٶ֮СƶȲʲô˵Ĵ죬
ΪȻطͳɳֲϵʹͳлСۢ٣
    ܽͳļҪŵ㡱һʷԵİʱطչԼƶȣ
ʷص㣬עء塱ѧԵ˼Ҳûѧżĳݣ׷ʵ塣ڵ㣬˽һĲ
ΪȱѧܽĸԭڣΪʵѴһ֡ۡ衱givennessĹ
Ϊļֵ۶ͨͬʽˡ衱ۢڣ
    衱ֱ֡ȣһ˽˹ȥļֵڹĵ֮ʾ
Ϊȱۣ㹻Խպ⡣ΣڰʱļֵΪΪ
ƶղġֹΪʽ̺š˼άʽ⡰˼άʽʵϷһ֡
ۡĹܡ˴δ֡˼άʽ͸˵ܽ֡۵ĹܡʼմڵġһΪ
۴δչԼһ⾭¡ߣʷԼͬһԣhomogeneity֡ԡ
ʹ˺ѵͬʱԤƶõĳʼѱҵߡ衱ˣʵľܹṩ
Լһּʵۡ
    Ŷ֮λͳһʷδͳĶڣһֳʱһƽȵв
Ϊ᣻ڶڲżľáγͻβ߱ҵĸʣռλĴͳ
ŷ޵ķ⽨Ӱ죬Ҳ˶ѧʶ̬Ƴ磬ӶԷʷؾġ˼άʽʱ
˵طչԼƶȵʵ弰壨instrumenfalism֮һͬŷ޹ңͬڶҵġһ޶
ĹңһֵҼĹҡ
            źġԡеӰ
    ǰͳһʷѧɡһ飬Ӫзֻһʷҡ󡱵Ѱδͳġһ
ԡʱڴ˴ͳ֮⣬̵侲С롰ȣǣԼڴ˴ͳ֮ж
²ġԽڴ˴ͳ֮ϣʾźġ̾Ϣ
    ͳһɡͳһʷѧɡķ¡˹أRichard Hofstadterһλ·˹ȣ
Louis Hartz
    ˹λʷҡۢ٣ʷصڣ㷺ѧѧѧѧƵۡ
Ӧʷѧоԡʷѧľþۣʹ˼롱Ϊʷоص㣬Դ˽ʾʷеġԡԡ
    ܷӳ˹Ҫ۵ǡδͳ䴴ߡ͡ĸʱӲ֡˹ǰ
ͼʶ̬аΪһĺġΪһİȫ˶ĳЩĹͬ⣬磺˽в
ʥԣ˽вƲɴúͶȨᡱļֵ漰ȷȻݽۢڣĿȷģȥ
δͳȫ½ͣǿһͳǸֲڡĹͬΧ
    ˹صҪǡ塱ʷѧҡǰʷ򵥿̻ΪìܡֻḶ́Ƕ
ʷеθĸ˶ʷġͳһгԡĵͱ֡ڷһͳһԡͬʱͻ䱣صʡ
ȱݺ;ԣƻáָ崫ͳʵϲһֳɹʶ̬δȡκξнԵĳɾ
֮һͳģڶ෽ȱݡı顢ؾɡ󿴵ģϣع鵽ǿ̰͸ֵ۵ʶ
̬ϡ
    ڡĸʱһУ˹ؽһḻδͳСпԣĩͣ
θĸ˶ƽ˶˶͡ƽ塱롰塱³ΪһϵĴͳ
Уԡƽ塱ȫķ
    ˹һλθʹеʷѧңں̶ܴΪʵͽдΪΧڶдԼĻ˵
Ӧʵ½͵ҪΪ֣ƽ塱ľ񲻵ڣڽʱм
شӰ졣Ϊƽ塱˼һֱǰΪط塢յġѡɡ̬Լ
ɲ֡ۢ٣ʵϣĿǶС
    ķƽ塪崫ͳĵͱǣũҵֵ۵ִż֣Ըҵ͸˻ļᶨԼɴ
ԸԶһеĿⱣۢڣݻ˹ؽʾƽ塱ĻȣĶԺͼԡ
ڸӵĹڼʱ²ũҵе鷳򵥵عڡġءƽ岻塢弰ط
Ĵӻ⡣ΣĻԣΪͼָҵ弰ũҵƷ֮ǰռͳελ״ۣۢ
    ˹ɴ˹ɳƽ塱ʶļ棺һյġƽʱطܰũҵ԰ڶ
ȻĺгشﲩӦȻءܷ٣Ȼض̰ƻһг
ԣͳΪ漯ţߣ߰¢ϹͷǮ˹·ͷԽ
ǮΪ׶֮Уģʷġıۣϵϣ漯ǱΪ飬ԽǮ
ԸϰգһǷ̫壬̫˳Ϊʽ𻷡Ĵʡۢܣ
    ıۡĺģԴһǿҵġ⡱֢⡱֢ٲڡ³ɭ塱˹
Ϊ⡱Ȼ˵顣ڶԳޣصļ򡪡ɼκ
ԶİˡֻҪԳУʹҲ⡣⡱Զޡ㷺ıǡǡӳ
һʵ³ɭƽ壬ƽȻεǰ½塣
    ³ɭ塱ͳͻص㣬йر塰Խơ˵һͳĺĽһ½̣Yankee
protestantͳ֮ϣһ½̴ͳӳУԷʽ֡ۼƽ弰ʱ˹
ǿأԺҵлԼ˿ɷֵı񡱣ۢݣݲĻ
ڽ̺ʹͳٲͬԣɹ黯ߡǣһ½̴ͳıĻŷ޴ͳĻ˼ͻ
ǰ߼Լδͳв׼ʽӦ־áı˽Ͷ빫ѭԭ
ķɣӶȻڸҪ֮ϣں̶ְܴڴٽĵ»Ըұϵ
вͬĻͳġǣرھԳΪĵʱƻһ½̴ͳǣƽ
رǽ˶͵ر˵ʱᡰ⡱⡱⡱Ȼּͬ⡱ɫ
    ·סͬ˹һվڡ󡱵ϣδͳĶ롰һԡڡ崫ͳУ
ҲΪһͬŷ޵ģ޷⽨ͳĹҡֶصʷ㸳Ȼ崫ͳҲʷĶ
ԡΪǷ⽨ص֮һȱĸͳҲûĴͳۢ٣
    Ȼָ֡Ȼ塱ɵΣָȻ塱һ˼άܡthe frame 
of mindϵʱƺΪһ֡Ȼ󡣹ָ״ֲ
    ȣѧ˵ΪȻ˼ƳﵽΪԵĳ̶ȣ˸û
塱ΪùȵĻ˵ʷϴδйʲô˶Ҳδйһġ
ӵеĲһʽ塯ֵĹϣֻһİߡۢڣ
    ָΪһָɵĹձʵ塱ͳǿ֮ڡ
塱ɱвۣۢ
    ΪٵⲢǶͳεΣգΪ˶Դͬкã
顱Σ֮ڣΪĻ˲ġ˼רơtyranny of opinion
            źġԡ⽻Ӱ
    صġⲿദԼڴ˹жͳĸӰ죬Ҳǡͳһʷҹע⡣
    ˹䡶˼е塷ѶϵҪӰķ
ָӢΪ繱˴ģԴĸѰѸٺҵĽȴ³ɭAngloSaxon dogma
Ϊ۹ʱҪɷݡΪԺļʮ䣬³ɭ壬Ǻսģֻƽ
۹ռͳελ۸ݡۢܣ
    ΪԼս˹ѧɵĽ־³ɭѧɵγɡĵĹ۵ǰ³ɭۡ
ΪӢƶȣرӢ飨town meeting׷ݵն˲ԭʼƶȡʷһΪ
ڡĿࡢ𷢱۵ġ壬ͬĳڶԡӢԽԡ͡³ɭ׿Խ
˹رᵽ˹ΪڸױǷѧԺͶʱѱŵĹ
    ˹ͬʱἰҹĴԽԡλʦԼ˹ˣJohn Fiskeϣǡ˹ʣJosiah StrongĹ
á
    ˹Ϊڣ֮ͣǷŵıУ³ɭھƽоصķ
ָȻľüս棬йóףԼƺȨıҪڱռϷ磬³ɭҲ
߸Ľڡ
    ³ɭеĺƽǿӢͬˡղķ˹˹ĪJames k,HosmerˡӢֵꡱΪ
Ӧ˹ˡӡ˺й˵ս
    ˹ذһڶһǶԱ˥ĵǣǶԡƻӵĿ־塣˹ָڣ
䣬ձĿ־ﵽ塣ܿˡ׶ض򵽰³ɭٵǱвձ˵֯ͳβܼ
ԦסӴй˿ڵľ޴ǰǲġ
    ˹ػѷġ塱⽻ߡΪˡ崫ͳõڹ͹ߵʤڽ
һսıҪԣѷ֮ΪһʹȫĶӶĸ桰ھܳߵľϡѷ
ǲֻڱԼΪ繫θС;ethosĸ£˵ĳڴУŶ
Ĺ㷺ΣΪԼƶȶһۢ٣
    ·סȴһǶָ⽻ϵ㡣̸塱⽻ϵıʱΪ򡣵һֱ֣Ϊ
ƽȡ壬һϵŲһǿҵɾ壨liberal absolutism˼֮Ľʱ֡
˼άܡframe of mindԶֽһⲿΪڹĴԻڹ
ͨԡ⡱ɿЪ˹ķһֱֵĸԴǡ硱ŷޡĹԭһּǿ
֮ϣ˲ľ硣
    塱ĵڶֱڽ룲ͺͻָΪ塱ľԵ»򣬵Ӵʱ
塱ʱá塱ȡƺһֱּҡڲҪôԶⲿ磻Ҫô硱ȥӵ
磬һ־Ե±ҪôӡⲿǰˣҪôȥǣ߲ܹ
    ۼսʱڵĶչϵʱָΪǰĶں̶ܴʶ̬ľġ˼άܡṩ
صĹԷ⡣ȻΪһǱˮСȻһֲױͺ
ۡۢ٣
    ΪĿǰҪشⲻǡʷǷΪṩĳЩԡڡĶǡʷǷΪṩ
ȷĶۢڣݹ˵ǲ֪ʷΪṩˡ֮ĺ׼ǻ֪ǣǶ
ˣǵ塣
    ̬ԭڣΪ֢ȱľ״˼˵˼άʽ
һϵо巽棬彻еѡ˺ŷ޵ġ⡱޵ĸ̵ᶷ͸
ϤڰѷȨġԴԣԵǰ磬ҪһµġʶΡһֶԷԵ
ĳԽڴ˹УӦͬʱǿԼʶͶԱ˵⡣ۣۢ
    ڱβǿ⣺һƽȡܹͬҲʷͻ͵ƽȡ
Ƿ˽Լ
    ʵʹġͳһʷҲ˹͡δͳʱҲָȱݣر򽻵ʱľޡ
˹ָ͡ƶŵıͽΪβܴһ֡ѧĵʷʹǶĮģʹ޷
ʽ֮ܶʹ֮òһۡ
ڡʡһУǿ»۵㣬ȰģǲӦҪ˽ġѧΪ
ûκѧɹ
    ر𾯸˵ԡѧһ緶ΧľǽڲλۢܣΪ
ŷ޵ѧӶʹǲڣҲϲۡʷԵʶΪ
δõĲͱҲףΪƶ޷ֲطˣڵǰ綷Уǲָ
ۣӦͼͨƶȵֲѶŷӹ֮½ų
    ͳһʷѧǱʮƼΡáĻ䶯ʷѧķӳʷѧʷڲչǶ
ʷѧֱս
    Խ۹ͳһʷѧȻԵȱݡӵۼᡰӢǵ˼뼰Ϊǿĵһԡ
ԡгһԣˡŮų⣬Ĩɱʷеìܡ磬˾ĻеҪӰ
졣ѹԣ⵽ʷѧľ޴
    ǡͳһʷѧرĹײĨɱȣѡ˼봫ͳʷоʹʷͱӷḻ͸ӣ
ˡ塱ʷѧֻǿصļ򵥻ΣΪҪǣĻͳĳЩΪԽʱ޵ľ
᳤ܽ磺³ɭۡ塱壩͡塱໥ת߶ȡ»
ı壻ѧ۵ȱʵ壻ⲿȱ˽⣻ֵձԹ˵ķԵ塣Щ
ǰпϷȻֵõ͵ζ
            ۱߳䣬ΪĴѧʷϵʿ
                                            α༭٣
    ٣  ˹ȶµҪԾ۹ܷAnEconomic Interpretation of the Constitution of the Uni
ted States,1913ȶ£Mary Beard𡷣The Rise ofAmerican Civilization,1927
    ٣  ޸˹˹˹ʷеġһԡ롮ԡJ.Rogers Hollingsnorth,Consensus and Continuit
y in Recent American Historical Writingsڣҳءϴ󼾿ڣڣ档
    ٣  ˹͡εʡDaniel Boorstin,The Genius of American PoliticsŴѧ磱
ڣҳ
    ڣ  ˹͡εʡڣҳ
    ٣  ˹صҪ˼е塷Social Darwinism in American Thought(1944)
    δͳ䴴ߡThe American Political Tradition andthe Men Who Made it)(1948)
    ĸʱӲ֡˹The Age of Reform:from Bryan to F.D.R)(1955)
    ڣ  ˹أδͳ䴴ߡڣҳ
    ٣  ˹أĸʱӲ֡˹ڣҳ
    ڣ  ˹أĸʱӲ֡˹ڣҳ
    ۣ  ˹أĸʱӲ֡˹ڣҳ
    ܣ  ˹أĸʱӲ֡˹ڣҳ
    ݣ  ϵָԶŷŷĶˡˡˡ̫ˡϣˡ˵ȵȡڸϽ
ˡ
    ٣  ·סȣ崫ͳڣҳ
    ڣ  ·סȣ崫ͳڣҳ
    ۣ  ·סȣ崫ͳڣҳ
    ܣ  ˹أ˼е塷Richard Hofstadter,Social Darvinism in American ThoughtŦԼ
޶棬ڣҳ
    ٣  ˹أĸʱڣҳ
    ٣  ȣ崫ͳڣҳ
    ڣ  ȣ崫ͳڣҳ
    ۣ  ȣ崫ͳڣҳ
    ܣ  ˹͡εʡڣҳ
    
    
    
 
