 ׺ 3-3261
ԭĳʷ
ԭ
ԭںš199701
ԭҳš46-54
  šK5
  ʷ
ӡںš199705
    Ƶйʷ켰
    
߼顿߹йѧԺʷооԱ100006
    
    ڶս󣬴Ӷ³ŵԼѷͳִڼ䣬һȡˡƲ(containment and isolation)й
19663830ռ䣬ԺϵίԱᣨƲԺίᣩϯJص쵼£Ⱥ9Ļ飬
սеĶԻ߽֤14˵֤йרҷͱɵˡ̨̨ͱ
Щý֤˱ʵתƵ(containment without isolation)йµ˼ͽ
֤ġľ֤ıݡ켰һ
            һٿԻ֤ʷ
    1965꿪ʼΡԺԽ߾˶֤ᡣ1964Լѷͳִ̨Խս
ڲսɺڵǿҲ¡19663ԺίеĶԻ֤ᣬһϵ֤еһ
    J֤֯ĿʲôΪʲôҪ֯Խ֤ͬʱר֯Ի֤أԻߺͶ
Խ֮ʲôϵսʲôϵأ
    ֤ĿģøԼĻ˵ǡΪӰԼѷԻߵƶͬʱڣԱҲԼ
[1]Ȼ֤ĿԵģֹսı[2]սԺͳȨԽԽĳЩ泬Խˡܷ涨
ġȨԭȻܷͳȨΧĽһЩǺ첻ģȻʮ͸ӵ
ҵһȨνġѾ½ͳԽԽߣʹ쵼Ȩ[3
]ʷѧսͳȨʹǿԹ֮ԡĳƺš֤֯Ҳӳһֲ
ͳ⽻еȨԽԽ󣬸ѹӦȷƶ⽻ߵȨ޲ͳ⽻Ȩ⣬
1949ŵȻйȶƬģ󵼵á֤˲й֤ͨһ
㣬ǡǡ˸صġڼԱʶԻߡ
    һϵԽ֤Уר֯й֤ΪԽսԽ漰йĹϵ⡣仰˵
Խչ޵սйģҪй
    ڶսֳֳԿľ棬ҲնսԻսһսԿƶģ
˼ԴڶյĶߡìʻ֮ǰְй˹ͬһԡ1950곯ս
ͬŷһΪսҪսйҲӽ֮УΪţйʵϾǶ
[4]ɭִʱ˹1952ڹ͵ѡ˵ҪԶĺӣŬΧйʹ1
9549º12£ȺӢ̩ɱĴǡͻ˹̹ǩˡǼԼ̨
ǩˡͬԼӶõضййκ͵й⣬ھ϶йʵнˣ1950
122գйһлʵ֤ư취[5]ڴ518ղϹᡰͨйʵн˵
顱[6]̨ϣ㡰һһ̨ϹĦ⡱Ҫν̨δλ⡱[7]1950
920գйطϹ֮⽻ʷԼйϵʷר£ȻѰƲ
߲ľʱԼݣǹϲл񹲺͹һһ̨ԻָйϹĺϷϯλ
й֯ʴ֮ͥ⣻ϰΧй϶йʵнˣ㹹һߵںһɶ³ͳ
ʱƶɭϺԼѷλͳִڶơ
    Խϵսʵйġ쵼УйԽϱĻ֧ߣԽϹ쵼ͬй쵼
֮ϵܡΪ˷ֹڶţڷ˳Խ֮ȻսʱĶ߳ǻڹ
ƶġǻֹĿǣ֮ʶ̬أԼѷͳԽϲšΪΪԽϵĽ
˶ǶййʵϾǶ֮йĶƹսһɷָɲ֡ں¹͵ָ
³ŶйľΣԼѷǸܴԽϳģֻʹսԽԽԽ
    Խսڡѧ缰ŽǿҵĲԽսĺԽԽߡԽս鲻
ԽϵĶȫ⽻ߵǰᡣ[8]ˣԺίԱ᲻ԽսԽ߾֤ᣬҰ
Խ߽صй״Σ1949빫֤֮С
            Ƶйĳ̨
    μӲԺίй֤˹14λǸױǴѧѧڱɡѧоη塢
ѧμʷѧڱʩߴġѧоĸԼMHֵ±ˡ۵½ս׼Ѷ
˼ѧѧĦ١Hִ֡ѧѧɽ󡤰˹̹Ρʢٴѧʹϵѧڹ޵¡
١ױǴѧѧɵ¡ǡԺǰԱԵ¡ʢٴѧǺоΡ̩աҮ³ѧѧ
Ĵ֥Ӹѧμʷѧں˹JĦԼݴѧУѧ޲ء˹ŵЩгԵ¡
̩ӵʱеĶԻߡȡκζԻ⣬11˷̶ֱͬȵĶԻ
ߣƲйߣ֮ԡƵйߡ
    ֤ϵһ֤ǱɣҲˡƵй뷨֤˵йȨһ
ּʧ󡣡ȥԤ⣬δǽòһʵ[9]δʮУζԴй
ٵֵĶ֮һ[10]ΪԹйȫ̬ȶҪлĸı䡣ڹȥ17䣬
һ߿õּڶƲйߡ[11]Ϊơĳ̶ֳǳɹģǡ
ǵġ͡ɹġ[12]ָǹҸıԹй̬ȲҲһƵߵʱˡ
Խ϶[13]һµߣɲľݣӦڸŬĽ
ǲӦԴ½йеó׽ˣӦֻսƷнˣ[14]ΪĿǰн˵ҪԡԵģΪû
κҪó׹ʵֽˣұԴձ¹Ӣط򵽱ǾܾЩƷ[15]Ӧ
˿ó׽ϹӦŬܸййעָ񵳣ϯλ᰸[16]ǵĿ
ս⽻ϵܻҪʱ䡭[17]
    ǵڶ֤ġڷͬⱫӦȡԻߵĽ顣ΪӦԻ߷
һ¹۵㡪ǲйʹ[18]йӦñйʻ֮Уþ飬Ӧרҵĺ͹
ԹЭ֮УڲƹĹ֮Уұڰڵͬÿ˵óףս֮ģ֮
[19]ҲͬⱫɹϹɴ½й̨顣ָϹͶƱʱӦȡһ̬ȣҲӦ
ݱ[20]
    ֵ±֤ʱ˵ǵǰԴ½й˵߲ûﵽκҪĿġ[21]ڶйʩѹƶûʲôá
[22]Ϊڿйͽľùϵǻḻջġ[23]
    ʩߴ֤ҲͬߣͬйͬʱҲͬйóףսģ[24]
    Ϊѧרҵİ˹̹֤طйó߲йľ÷չ״ָȨᡰ̨
۲ʵʵĻôӦýʵйһȥһʱڵʵ壬һһ־
[25]Ϊ1950йʼһ֡ûиı䡱ߣʵеġó׿ơֹּ֧ͶйһĿ
ġ[26]ʹͬ˹ֿʹͬǷĦͼʹִͬһµʱʹǵ޷ͬй
пܵĵнƵó׽ȴͬйó׽[27]
    ڷֱ֧ɺͷӦıԻߵ顣Ϊûй裬ƺͲþ⼰޵ȶ
޷ʵ֡[28]˵Ϊͬй⽻ϵǺ¡[29]޵Ļû
Ǻй˵ĶԻǲܽġҪֶԻΪɳȣעָʹ̸УǽҪ̸
ĵط[30]
    ֤ʱͬ⽻ϳй飬ΪڹȥѾзȵرºˡⷽһܺõļ
һνᵽɶԻյĿƺͶεĿơΪǵȷҪԷעָйЩӳ
[31]
    Ħ֤֤ʱ˵Ȼйģȫһʧܡͽй⽻κó׹ϵԣ
ܵ˹й[32]Ϊй߲ǾоԵģйϵ棬оԵǡơ
⡣4050ŷ޶оϵĶǳɹģһֱͼͨйܱߵľҪйܻ
ȡóɹΪйʵһǸԵĴ󡣡[33]ΪйǰҪвĻϵģв
ҪĻûҪھ϶й[34]
    ˹ŵڷҲͬƲйָͨжƵһߣӹεʵǲ
ʵҴӶйұӰ쿴ҲǺܲġܸ˿ѾڶԻĹۣ1959
һЩѧߡѧҡߺһЩȥйεȣⷽҲж顣[35]
    ϵķԽڹȥʮеĶԻߡ֮⣬Щ֤˴йרңз塢ֵ±ˡ
˼̩աԵ¡Ĵ˶һй֤ڼ䣬ӦԺίҪǶӲͬǶȺͲ̶ͬȣԼ
רйʷйʷ״й⽻ߡйϯλìܡйáʷϵĽӴԻߵ
ʷʵԽսйϵ˽ͺͷʹĹԱиǰȽ˽⡣
            ֤ķ
    ʱ9֤еͬʱŽҲճæµױǹ㲥˾ĵ̨ת֤ʵ[36]ȫٵı
֤˱ŽıУɷ¼ࣺ
    1.ķ
    (1)ͳ
    ѷͳ322վеļдϾͼߵʻش˵ǶЩ֤ܹעȫԱͲԱ
ЩͬίԱٿ֤ᡣΪЩڡרҡʹԼ˵Ĺ۵Ǽ¡[37]ЩȻ
ûʵģٿԷӳԼѷǲòע⵽֤ģý֤˵һˡ
    ʢʱ414տ˴紫һϢԼѷͳѶԹϰ˹˺߹˵Զ
֤ܻڴٽй㷺ۣʹйʱΪ»˵Լѷίе۶Ի
һǸ˵ġȻҲĶԻϵκشı佫ΡԱĳͻԿԼѷûΪıδ
ĶԻó׼ݵʱĹҰȫίԱԱղķ˹С˹ԼѷͳԸֵ֤Ĺע֤
ۣ̬ȱøˡ[38]
    320ջشױǹ㲥˾ʱ˹ָơ̫ƽĺƽصġעҲ
̫ƽ󡣡ơָ˹ŵԡڡҪй[39]
    Կͳ͹֮䣬ϻ̬Ȳ̫һ¡
    (2)
    оΡԱ֤ᣬµ飬ɺͷġƶй顣磬
˹ݵĹ͵Ա³˹֤ڼıйߡ³˹˵һΪͼйв
ͨģ֡оڻʢ١ǿӦ¿йó[40]
    ŦԼʱ311տķ˵Ϊƽա¡ָݵԱǿӲ
ԱĹ¹۹ߵĿʾӭ֤ܿʹйһǰ޷漰ⲻǲ˼ˡ
    Աз֤Ҳڡ磺ݼ˱صԱԼѷʲ³6ڹΪɫйԺ⼯š
ݡﱫɡĦνġɫйԺ⼯š[41]ĳԱǰѡƵйΪüϲĿ
šԸıԻߣΪĿǰıǵĶԻߣԼ˹еĵλһʹƽӺս[42]
    2.ķӳ
    ͬһ֤ķӳҲһ
    (1)֧̬ȣ
    ŦԼѧʷչѧάЪϰдŦԼʱ˵ͳݲء˱֤õġ
һʵܵġɸлͳʹ۵뱱ƽĹϵһרϷ⣬Ҫǣ
ɺ͸ͳһͲԱйͨί֤һֳβǺʾ塣½βʱ
˵ϣͳܹشԼѷͳ͹˹ˣȡʹ뿪⽻ЩйͨĽ顣[43]
    ֤һʱ321գܿԤ⸻ֵ֤ܻܿᷢչΪȫԶߡһ
Զ³ͳСս(coldwarice box)ײġһ۷ǳ󻯣һҲ֤
ԻƲʮδı״
    һҪ־ҲΪǶйϣԸı䡱ָۣȻͳ֤Ͼ֤
ͨ޳ɵġƵй˵ⲻǿͷϵģѿʼжԺȡļййصĽ
ȥйУ[44]
    ˹͸ڡܿϿٵרзΪйҪơ¡˵ֵ֤ᡰǶԼѷ
ͳʩѹӶʹĶԻ[45]
    (2)Ե
    ո˱38տһרⱨΪںɫйָ֤޶ȵز֤ʵ
ԺͼѰһڹǵĲ֤ὫǡкġԱءѡһΣյķʽı
Խս
    3.֤ķ
    ͬںܶ¼Ҫһ֤Ҳ˾ڵķӳ˵飬614յġʢʱ·˹
ɭ׫дй¡˵֤Ľⳡ֤Ϊ֤ʹǡ
޵˸õ˽⡣֤пе55%ΪԱصǶġ45%Ϊ
ǡкġ
    ֮г硢Լ֤ķʵԻ֤ĳԣù
ȷ˽⽻ߵ[46]ӰͳԻߵƶԱڣʹӶй˽⡣
            ġ֤ἰƵй
    ֯Ի֤ͬһ㡣ȣ֤1949л񹲺͹1950
УνĺɫֲԺίһЩ⵽ϴûڹǰ¶йͨǹ֤Լ
ԻߵĿĶԻߣԼ߽顣ǸҵΪҪΪйͨṩһ
̸ԻߡڲԺ۵Ľ̳ʹ̸ܹ۵⣬Ϊܡ
    Σ֤ʹԱܵ˹йʷ״йȨйá¡չϵԽϵȶ
ġ֪ʶԵĽ50ڵһл˽йΪ1949л񹲺͹³һֱ
ָΪʧйʱ˫ͨŻйıƬģӶ

    ٴΣ֤ΪԻһõġҪĿˡ[47]áԺίٿ֤
ԺҲٿƵ֤ᣬʹĶԻⲻʲôˡѧҲԹйϵ⣬йϵ
۲ר1966ййص޲ء¬ķġей޵¡ٵġ
еĹйͰ¡˹ٶдġй꣬ر˵ġȨİͷġй
Լġ֮䣺ϵеΡۡ뽭ѵġ̫ƽ붫ǹϵڲ
ʷԼ¡ФġԽ⣺ޡҲ׷׳棨ƪڴ˶ۡ
    ƵйµԻ߿ܵڣȣһµԽĲҪԱǹ䣬
йרңһѧߡ
    ΣЩרǴĻߵĻǰΪһ磺ϵίԱᣩйодԱ棬ڹϲ
ڲнĹ۵㡣籫ɾ60ϵίԱ֯ĶԻо쵼֤ϵ֤
µ飬µĶԻойءЩѧߵĹԣӳѧ˼ԾͶƶԻߵĲ

    ٴΣЩͬȡԻߵѧǲڿͷϣжΪٽ˽йٽıԻĽӲ
˾Ŭ֤ͬһ꣬йϵȫίԱѧ߽ίԱˡ196869ȫίԱϯ
֤֤һλйרɽ󡤰˹̹Ҳ1971θίԱϯμ֤˹ŵѧ߽ίԱ
ĳﱸίԱڰ˽йɷûǰ⽻ϵǰ佻൱
á[48]
    Ƶйһµ߽֤ɱɡ֮൱̶ȵķ졣ͳ֤
ٿĵڶԲɷһҵ̨ļ˵ԻӦǡƵعȻĽܴԼѷܵӲ
ӳڲԻһµ黹вͬģٸͳǽһ½ġ
    Ƶйµ1950һֱеġƲйʲô֮أµ飺1.
ϳл񹲺͹һڵ壬ʧ2.ϾϵĽǸʧܣйгսó
3.űйбȴʹ̸йߵĶԻ4.йþش5.㡰һһ̨ǰ
й֮⡣ע19622/3Ʊͨйӵϯλ[49]6.ȥйΣ
7.й⽻ϵ
    ȻԼѷûȡЩйͨĽ飬Ըͳı̬ҲûۣȡжıԻߣ̨
ıȷʵǶˡ֡ơšƵй½30ˡ30
ϵչʷʱڿʼͳһֱһֱͳֶ١ڵһĽ
йΪ׵ҪƵĶ󡣴⣬ʲͬĻͳͬʶ̬ϵĲ죬֡ơ롰
Ķڳȥ죬Ǽ⽻ϵ20֮ʣعһʷ塣
α༭
    עͣ
    [1]198723ڻʢٲɷøʱ̸
    [2]뽭ѱࣺԻߡʱ֤ʣ֤֤ѡ(U.S.Policy Toward China-Testimony of the Times:Selectionsf
rom Congressionel Hearings)ʿСʳ1968棬ڢҳ19863ڻʢٲɷñʱ̸Ҳᵽ
һͼ
    [3]M.J.C.άΡӡݣ1981꣬126ҳ
    [4]·˹.J.Ϊʷս(The ColdWar asHistory)޳湫˾1967棬286ҳ
    [5]õȱࣺϵ꡷»1984棬174177171ҳ
    [6]õȱࣺϵ꡷»1984棬174177171ҳ
    [7]õȱࣺϵ꡷»1984棬174177171ҳ
    [8]չϵ֪ʶ1984棬68ҳ2
    [9]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30(U.S.
Policywith Respect to Maniland China--HearingsbeforetheCommittee on Foreign Relations,United StatesSenate,Eighty-Ninte Congr
ess,Second Session)ʢ1966棬83444ҳ
    [10]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30(U.S
.Policy with Respect to Maniland China--Hearingsbefore theCommittee on Foreign Relations,United States Senate,Eighty-Ninte C
ongress,Second Session)ʢ1966棬83444ҳ
    [11]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30(U.S
.Policywith Respect to Maniland China--Hearingsbefore theCommittee on Foreign Relations,United States Senate,Eighty-Ninte Co
ngress,Second Session)ʢ1966棬83444ҳ
    [12]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30(U.S
.Policy with Respect to Maniland China--Hearings beforetheCommittee on Foreign Relations,United StatesSenate,Eighty-Ninte Co
ngress,Second Session)ʢ1966棬83444ҳ
    [13]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30(U.S
.Policy with Respect to Maniland China--Hearingsbefore theCommittee on Foreign Relations,United StatesSenate,Eighty-Ninte Co
ngress,Second Session)ʢ1966棬83444ҳ
    [14]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [15]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [16]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [17]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [18]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [19]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [20]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [21]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [22]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [23]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [24]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [25]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [26]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [27]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [28]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [29]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [30]½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ196638,10,16,18,21,28,30գʢ
1966棬415415172106177232232232232330331334337375376385386ҳ
    [31]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ395553553554555570ҳ
    [32]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ395553553554555570ҳ
    [33]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ395553553554555570ҳ
    [34]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ395553553554555570ҳ
    [35]Դ½йߡ89ڶλ飬ԺϵίԱ֤ᡷ395553553554555570ҳ
    [36]ݱ1987ù˾绰ĵ绰¼
    [37]1966322ͳдᡱԡͳļֵǡԼѷ196869꡷ʢ٣346ҳ
    [38]ղķ˹СķɭԻߵƶ196169꣺Թεой50ţ197246һڣ
239ҳ
    [39]ԺԺ򱨡ڣ̢1398ţʢ٣֣1966꣬566ҳ
    [40]ʢʱ1966324ա
    [41]ʲôɫйԺ⼯šʵȴһ̨֧ġԺԮš
    [42]Ժᵵ89ᣬڶλ飬112ڶ֣14583ҳ
    [43]ŦԼʱ1966318ա
    [44]1966321ա
    [45]ܿ196644ա
    [46]壺Դ1994棬502ҳ
    [47]֤ʱϣ֤Ϊ1949깲ӹйԻߵҪĿˡ
    [48]׾ģǰйϵȫίԱᡱʷо̬19899ڣѧоο
ϡ198911ں͡19721992Ļʷ19952ڡ
    [49]׾ġйطϹʼĩʷ19961ڡ
    
    
    
 
