 ׺ 4-544
ԭĳʷ
ԭ
ԭںš199804
ԭҳš8896
  šK1
  ʷѧ
ӡںš199810
    ѧʷѧʷѧо
    ѧʷѧʷλ
    Ǯ
߼顿Ǯ𩣬ϾѧʷϵŷоĹ
    
    1880ƴѧԺУ̽ʷϵоγ̡ע²L˹ѧʷΪһֽѧ
γʱڡ(Deborah L. Haines,Scientific History as a Teaching Method:The Formative Years)ءʷ־(The Journal of
 American History)19774ڣ892ҳ1884ʷѧߴʷЭᡱ־ʷѧһ滯רҵ
ĵ·1895꡶ʷۡ־ʷоڱҵʷѧͳεľְҵʷѧʱĿʼ
ʷѧʷϣʱڵһЩʷѧ׷ʷѧһ׿ѧʷоͿѧѧ׼˳Ϊѧʷѧҡ(Scientifi
c historians)ӷѧʷѧγɵʷֿ̽ѧʷѧоʷĶѧֶΣλѧʷѧҵĽѧ
Ϊоĸɵʷλ꼻һֵԭָ֤ѧʷѧγ뷢չƶʷѧоרҵѧĽ̡
            һʷ
    սʤһЩʶ֮ʿʷѰǿԸμҺʷѧо÷ɭķ˹
ءֶ¡˹˹ֱ׫д˳ǿҵİɫʵʷ÷ɭġΡʢ١صġߺ˹˹
ġʢƽ25ġǴ顷ЩĹͬǡ춨ˡϵ۵񣬼縺ϵ۸
ȫʹЩʷơѧɡʷ׫˶ԡ³ѷʹۡǿʹʱڵʷǿҵİ
飬ͬʱҲӰǶʷп͹۵ȡʷоսԺڼŷȻѧķչᷢһϵ
е¼ں̶ܴϴٽ˿ѧʷѧγɡ
    ȣսıʹʵԡսڼ䣬ս֮໥ɱݻˡٿˡ
ʽİѧɱµͨ˿ʼһЩʷʾɡһЩܹڹѧѧ߹
ʾ԰ѧɼʷ۵ǿҲ
    ŷ˶Ȼѧķչѧ˶Ŀһ¡17ţٶɵķͱϿʹŷȻѧΪһķչ
йɿѭ19ͣŷѧѹ㷺ĺ˹Ŀѧ˼롣19ʹۺ͡桱
۱˹Ϊܡǿ˼ȻıҪǰᣬ˹˴ĵ
ᷢչɡעHSܣ񡷣ձ1988棬122-133ҳŷ˼Һλѧߵ˼
£һЩʷѧҿʼʷйɵģ˼άʷʵиֿԷЩɡע¡N޲
ȱࣺʷ(Gerald N. Grob and Athan Billias,Interpretations of American History:Patterns and Perspectives,Volume
  Since 1865)ŦԼ1982棬3ҳ
    սѧ塢̳֯ʹѧ淶Ϊһֳ1869ѧЭ70󣬽80ѧЭ֯
80121ѧ֯עķְҵʷѧʷ(John Higham,History:Professional Scholarship in Am
erica)Լ˹ս˹ѧ1989棬8ҳֹ淶רҵʵʩ̬ҲʷѧоΪѧʷѧɴʷЭ
ᡱ춨ۻ
    ģѧߵĻع˿ѧʷѧĽ̡19ִ͹ʷѧɵĴʼ˶ʷϿ֤Ļԭȷʷѧְ
ҵʷѧĿˡעˡգʷѧҵļɡ(Mark Bloch,The Historian's Craft)˹1954棬165ҳʱ
ʷЭҪʼ˺ղءͿ˹ءǵ˹¼ǵ˹ڵ¹ѧǱѧѧڼ䣬ܵ¹ʷо
Ͻ˿͹ʷѧ۵Ӱ졣ڶλǺ롤ն˹أһλ¹ܽںǱѧϸĵ¹ʽ
ѧѵְѧʷʱʮƳ¹Ŀѧʷѧоλǰءʲڶءڵ¹
ѧѧϰ1883ʿѧλڵΡʷۡ༭1909ʷЭϯʱΪʷΪһŶѧƲʹרҵ
ѧ˲ĥĹסעưࣺ2500ʷ˴ԡ1994棬240ҳλʷЭ
һϯ³Ͽɭءעưࣺ2500ʷ˴ԡ618ҳ1853ҵҮ³ѧ
Ͱ졣1857ʼЪѧʷڣıʹ1865Ъѧ˿ѧʷĿγ̡ע˹
ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ896ҳ
    壬19°ҶıʹʷѧоְҵΪܡѡƵĽƸĸһ档ע˹
ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ895ҳ1870ΪٵԺУڹĳ¿ʼҪѡ޿γ̡70ǵ˹
ȽоƶȡѧоƶȡƹʹʷѧսǰΪѧγ̵ĸεĵλ߳ʹʷѧ
רҵѧĹΪܡⳡѧĸʹһЩҪѧȫ˽ǵ˹Ϊ׵ĵһѧʷѧҵ׼
1884꣬İУƸԼ20רְʷʦʮԺרְʦѴ100עķְҵʷѧʷ4ҳ

            ѧʷѧ
    ѧʷѧΪʷоһʷϵḶ́ʷѧооʷʱӦѭѧ֤ʷϡʷѧ졣ע
˹ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ896ҳѧʷѧǿʷоζо߱ܵõмֵʷ
ϻϽжϣΪʷϻϽԼĹ۵㡣עءBأо(Albert B. Hart,S
tudies in American Education)ŦԼ1895棬76ҳΪѧʷۡѧʷѧɶʷѧʷоһϵ
еĸĸռʷоĽܹϵѧʷѧ˴ݡѧʷѧǵ˹ʷѧΪһ
ŶĿγרԺУո𲽣ʷдֻڼ﹤ߡ־˺͸츳ҵʷѧҡʷ޲
˹еϾ棬1876ڻս˹Уء֧£һȣԳγɵʷѧо
ֽսעԼķղءͿ˹ءǵ˹طʷо(John Higham,Herbert Baxter Adams and the Study 
of Local History)ʷۡ(The American Historical Review)19855ڣ1225ҳֿΣ¹
ѧáѧǵ˹ṩʷоŷҪѧȶԼؽо͵飬ЩоҪ
᷽˼ǵ˹Ҫѧѧ֯ʷϣʷϽзȽϡࡣǵ˹䴴Ļս˹ѧʷоڼ
ѧһЩɢ͵ĶоѧӦ໥ͨоɹɱ֣ۡͨѧѧʷ۵㣬
׼ȷرڱץסԷ©зסоһܹרҵѵ׷ʷоְҵ
ʷߣΪרҵʷоҵʷѧѹǵ˹Ϊɫҵ1884괴ˡʷЭᡱЭһλ
Ĳμߴ󲿷ǷְҵʷѧңƶЭ³̵ίԱԱʷѧְҵʷѧҡעķղءͿ˹ء
ǵ˹طʷо1232ҳЭּǣʷо򣬸ԺУӦòطʷѧЭᱣϵڴ
طʷѧ滯עķղءͿ˹ءǵ˹طʷо1232ҳЭĳЩڵط־о
ҵʷѧҹʷоĴ֮⡣һλܳҵʷѧ߰»˹1889걧ԹЭƺֻЩѧڵ
־ȤЩְҵʷѧͶۡעķղءͿ˹ءǵ˹طʷо1232ҳ
1895꣬ʷоѧȦڷش¼һЭӳڱҵʷѧҿƵĻʢѧУ԰ٿ
һѧרҵ־ʷۡʹ֮ϸְҵ༭ְҵʷѧСעķղءͿ
˹ءǵ˹طʷо1232ҳ1896ЭġίԱᡱԱȫΪڡעķְҵʷѧ
ʷ16ҳ1900Լ֡ղķѷǵ˹16֮õЭһְǵ˹ƽЭְҵְҵʷѧ
ġӹ״ˣʷЭᡱȫΪְҵʷѧߵıݣſѧʷѧרҽġעķ
ءͿ˹ءǵ˹طʷо1237ҳ
    ѧʷѧΪ⡣ֻͨڣһܵõ֤ע˹
ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ904ҳڵʳΪѧʷѧΪ֮ܶĿꡣ׫д˴ģ
߶ȶԾɵĽܽϸ΢ķĸƵĿںš˹ϴǵ˹ġʡʷ
ָϡѧҪĸĸ̾߸ĸԭʼϵı롢ѧУƶȵѧǵ˹Ҳ
ִ˲ƣΪдϵֲᣬѧ1887׫дˡͼѧ18977̳
ڷΪѧһ˽ĹϵʷѧһδΪһһΪ
һΪܴݻٹ͹ĳ֮ľע߶ءP޽˹³Dִѧ(Walter P. Rogers,Andrew D
. White and the Modern University)ŦԼ1942棬125ҳְѽδϵٽѧ̡
1900ǰӵڶĴѧѧԺÿ˶Խȥע˹͢ˣ̡1993
棬555ҳ
    ʷѧʷо򣬿ѧʷѧ԰ʷѧ鹹Ϳŵʷѧָ˼ˡѧ֤ʷϡ˿
ʷѧ۵Ӱ죬ΪʷоһʷϵḶ́ʷѧҵξռϣѧϡѧʷѧ»
غġʷоָϡʷϵǿʷѧоʹʷѧӴļתһȫµġĿѧʷѧʱ
Ȩ۵ķʣԸּսʷϵķΪýѧߡ1883갮Ĭڻعθĸʱ˵Щѧ߰
ȫͶ뽫ʷһſѧо˶Сǵõ˻رһԺУԺУĺ󳾣ûʷγ̵ԺУʷ
νˡע˹ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ897ҳΪѧɵȨĶԣ˹
Ϊѧѧһÿжĳֳɵľп͹ƷǡˡĽˡڶͷ
иɫʡעԼW˹ױǴѧʷѧоķ(John. W. Burgess,The Method of Historica
l Study and Research in Columbia College)ʿ1885棬218ҳΪˣʷѧУǷѧȨʿۺͽ
ۣΪִͳѧԿѧ׷к档ǽ̵ѧԼΣξ׷ʽۣѰ֤ݡΪﵽȥħ
ĿģȣͳĽ̿鱻ȡޣȡ֮ǻɲļͬһ¼ϣߵĹ۵۾ྶֽ̲ͥģѧ
ʦĹѵ£äĿĳһߵĹ۵㡣ѧ˶˼γԼ˼άʽӱתΪսΣѧ
ʷѧҿ˽ʽʷѧΡʦڽϱѧṩۼֵĹ۵㣬Ҵ˹۵ҪָĶϵĹ۵󡣽ʦ
ṩ̿ʷоϢѧоҰֽʽҪʦĶͷ׼ȫĵͶо
ڽУʦ˵ϽѧҲѧ˿ѧʷĻǿѧĸʶﵽȡһϵĿ
ģ˹˵ǽԭʼڵأԼɸѡʷϡͬһʵвֻһʷԴǾָǽЩʷϽ
𣬹۲ǵ ͬ㣬ƳһԲ˵Ĺ۵㡣ע˹ʷо(John W. Burgess,Methods of Historical Stu
dy)ʿ1885棬218-219ҳִѰʷϵʷϽбȽϡɸѡٵ۵Ŀѧʷѧ19ĩʷѧ
ģʽһѧϽڶ˼оȨսʷѧҡ߽ۡʼɣʷֱۡȶ
˱ʱ
    Ϊʷѧо֮һڰѧʢʱﵽʷĸ߷壬оȴǷǿ͹ۺͷǿѧġѧʷѧһİѧ
ɵġΨַ׷뻯ЧѡĵǿԵĿѧķڡʷָһָѴΪ
һʷѧֶʹʷԵøΪʵûκһַ󴫼ʹʷ¼ķչ硢̵ӡѧ
Ժע˹ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ906ҳѧʷѧʦԴǵƳʹǽѧǵĽѧ
ռ˺ҪһϯҪѧѧҪдһƪԴΪġѧʷѧĴǡμҡ
ⲿǴ¼ĲݺܴһǵĿýѧݡָϡڸԺУʷͼݵƼĿа״
Ŀλϡע˹ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ906ҳ
    Ϊдʱһ֡ʷϣʷϡǿʵʷʵѻӦý֮
ߵ壬ʹ֮ʷдһʷѧҪҡҡ̼ҡʦʹԼƷͬ
ҪʷѧҼҪһѧңҪһԤԼҺʫˡעأʷ(Albert Bushnell Hart,Imagination in H
istory)ءʷۡ19101ڣ246ҳصʷ׼ʶѧоʷıҪԡر1899׫
дһǡɡ˹עưࣺ2500ʷ˴ԡ240ҳѧʷѧҵĴǽѧо
һԾʷѧһҲִʷѧһʿʷıŲ
    ʷѧϵǿǿѧʷѧһشɫǵ˹ԣʷεĺעǵ˹ʷ
ǹȥ𣿡(Herbert Baxter Adams,Is History Past Politics?)ءԼ˹ս˹ѧĿѧѧ(JHUSHPS)18954
ڣ1ҳǶԡʷǹȥΣڵʷĹʽĤʹǰصʷӶʷѧо
ǴӴͳڽ̹תΪι۵ʷʹ˹ϴǵ˹˵ǹҵϣҪһЩ˲
ڴǰʱǾܶԴȷľȥʷ֤ϣȷġⲻ
ȷΪҲֻΪЩδܺܺõڴǰ̽֡ע˹ϴǵ˹ɵֿơ(Charles Ken
dall Adams,Irresistible Tendencies)ء¿(Atlantic Monthly)18999¿297ҳΪʷۣЪ
ѧѧԺˡѧҲʢĹϵĽѧʷѧҲ׫д˴ĺʷεĹϵҪ
Ϊصġɫصġζѧѧʷѧγָ˹ϴǵ˹ġɵֿơ
ǵ˹ġظеӰ졷ȡЩڶľʵ⣬¶Ƶĳź͵ط⣬˸
δֶεĹעơȻѧʷѧֻ۽ʷĹϵų͵úĻ
ᷢչĹϵ˽ѧȡѧʷѧɵШӣѧʷѧҰʷѧоιʷѧеã
ޡѷ¶ࡤ˹һϻۡ˼άݡζԨʷ֪ʶ羫Ӣ
    Ϊƶѧʷѧ1895ʷЭᴴһʷָίԱᡱǱ༭ռһʷойص
δʷϡļ¼ȡһίԱЭݽһݺȱ棬идмֵļĿעķ
ְҵʷѧʷ17ҳ1899ݳԼලݵݵĹʮڣ24ƶ˱δļͼ¼
עķְҵʷѧʷ17ҳڡʷָίԱᡱĹ£ѧȴѧ̽
ʷϵעķְҵʷѧʷ18ҳ1907ꡰʷѧ֯ǰȺʷЭᡱĳ
һЩҵʷѧѿʼְҵʷѧݵĽͷչ־ʷоרҵγѾѧʷѧ
ʷоרҵְҵʷʹ
            ʷλ
    ڿѧʷѧʷλʷѧδܴɹʶ2070ʷѧȨԼķԼԿѧʷѧƷеѧ
̽֡ʷѧĵλĻеĽɫ죬˿ѧʷѧġѧ֮˵ָ֤ѧʷѧġǿ͹ԡ͡
ǿѧԡעԼķʷ(John Higham,History)1965棬147-170ҳ1977꡶ʷ־ڿ
˴L˹һƪΪѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡġıܿ˺ķֻѧʷѧʷ׫
ӽתѧʷѧʷĳɾͣΪ͹۵ز˿ѧʷѧʷѧʷλݹۿѧʷѧ̣
ΪѧʷѧʷѧڼȰѧʷѧۡʵǡȡʷѧ춨ˡѧۣ
ʷѧһȫµʷʱڡѧʷѧʷ㡣
    һѧʷѧͨʷŷʷ͹ʷоָϡ1896ͨʷѵܽʷ
ʷбȽо˾ͲܳƵʷרҡע˹ѧʷΪһֽѧγʱڡ910ҳֿ
ʷоʷѧҵоҰһͨʷεѧߺμңͨŷ޼ĸ
ĺΪ˽ⲿṩ˴ĸԲϺ˼άģʽʷѧǶȴʹ19ĩʼѡ塱۵
롰ȫ塱ʱ
    ѧʷѧĿ͹ʷһѧˡǵ˹ǡۡŷߣԴѧ˵紫ߣѧ
ҪԡۡرĲ෴ѧͳʷоսϸʷ۵ѵ£׵ˡܿѷ
ӱġ߽ʷϵش塷ˡ߽ۡʷоӴͳۿн⹹Ϊʷо
һ̱
    μʷѧޡѷְҵʷѧԼ֡ղķѷʦǵ˹λĳɹѭǵ˹طʷ
о򣬶һǵ˹ȫͬо·ѷ1883ս˹ѧѧϰоγ̡˹ٴѧ
ѧϰڼԱȽβŨȤϣǵ˹ָ¼Ƚεоѷǵ˹ͬ
󣬶һѷĵһѧ߶ۡǵ˹˵ѷоһǳʷֵѧоע
ķղءͿ˹ءǵ˹طʷо1234ҳѷġ(1885)Ȼ䵼ʦо򣬵
ıȽоȫǴǵ˹ǶѧġעķղءͿ˹ءǵ˹طʷо1234ҳ
    Լ֡ղķѷʷѧԼ粩ʿ֮һ΢δѧǵ˹ݣ
ѧȫѭǵ˹о1882ڻս˹ѧʿѧλǵ˹֣ѷĶо뿪
ʼ˶εоȻǶԡطʷоı룬ǵ˹ԶԴ˾ٸ˼ĹעķղءͿ˹ءǵ
˹طʷо1235ҳǵ˹ҷ緶£ղķѷڵΡʷۡһʱʷѧְҵרҵ
·˺͡
    ѧʷѧƫСʷһ̶ӡԱӣìܣƶ̡ѧʷѧ
֮һءղķ˹ȵġ1850Эʷʷϵ̱עưࣺ2500ʷ˴ԡ
458ҳԺʷϡƫС֯߳עĿ֡ƫСʷƷһ֡ƽȡۣ19
ҶʢеİͰ³һкս
    ģѧʷѧԴڽĹעԴѧ׷ɼ̡ͬ1980ŷӿЩ
ƶڽȥԶرЩĲ԰׽ص谭´½ķչ
ѧ˲ҵѧСѧռûΧǽĽлĻܡµѵҵߣ
ֵ۵ͬȶͷ١
    壬ѧʷѧͼݵķչ͵Ľڵ棬Сʷļм
ֵʷȤͼݵĲҲûҪ󡣣ע׵ˡޡױǡ(Frederick Paul Keppel,Col
umbia)ŦԼ1914棬4-8ҳѧʷѧ𼰶ʷϵǿʹͼ͵ĽȫΪʵӶƶʷѧѧ
Ƶķչ
    Ȼý۹ѧʷѧҲԵʱԡ
    һԡѧʷѧ綨ģ1890ǰʷѧԺΪѧʷѧչ˱ۡһЩѧΪѧʷѧҪǿʷһ
ѰɵĿѧһЩΪѧʷѧÿѧȷʷϣκۻؽע»P
ʷķġ(Edward P. Cheyney,Law in History and Other Essays)ŦԼ1927档ⳡʼδܽѧʷѧҵ
˼ͳһһЩѧ߳СʷϣʷϡķζɬѶ޼ѧʷѧɵ
    ڶѧʷѧʷᷢչѧʷѧͷչҵܳڣɹҵ÷չһ
ǧ19ĩҵֵԾһλսĺгѸٷչڳһƬ÷پ
ùġʱѧʷѧɼιʷġ20ͳ˼ĳ£ʷѧʦʷ۵
˲˹ȶ䡶ܷľý͡þʷ۽ʷĻͬʱҲ˿ѧʷѧɡʷۡɥӡ
    ѧʷѧɵĸ˼ֵƷеȻ¶Ƴ硰ʵʷӰڸѧдԶ
³ѷϵڸԣУһ¼ڲ̶ͬϹԼǵ˼άʽֵۣʷ
УǲԾ¶Զ¼ֵ۵޴ʺͰ³ѷԽۡƫ˼ֵ۵ĺۼһʹѧʷѧɵġѧ
ԡۿۣ̣һҲһʵΪһˣκ˶ȫԽʱͼֵۡ
͸ʷѧߺͶҪΪһʷѧңӦʵ̬ȿ֤ʷϣܵرȥʷϡ׫д
ʷΪߣӦ߹۵۵㣬ԼĶ˼ͷóԼĽۡ
    ѧʷѧũҵᲽ빤ҵתڵ1980ǰ20ͳݵ
ʷѧıǨݻڡٷϴ١19ĩѧʷѧʱ˵Ļɫʷѧʷڲչѧ
֤ʷϣ˼άʹʷѧΪѧḻʷѧ˼롣ѧʷѧʷѧ淶ְҵı׼ָŸʱڵʷѧо
ͬʱҲΪΪƹҲ˼ӡʱķչѧʷѧĲƵձѧȡǸ
ضĹײݺԡ
α༭ĺ
    
    
    
 
