ѧ
JOURNAL OF ASTRONAUTICS
1999ꡡ1ڡNo.11999



ҺɿƵ·

ժҪԷϵͳɿо,ۺÿɿԿͼ
ģʽЧӦݷȿɿԷ,ͬƷĿ
ˮƽ,ĳͺŷķ֤˵ͷ
ʡҺɿơɿԼ
FRESH APPROACH TO LIQUID ROCKET ENGINE
RELIABILITY DESIGN
Kuang Wuyue
(Shanxi Engine Design Inst.Xi'an.710100)
AbstractAt present,high reliability and low cost are the major considerations in Liquid Rocket Engine
(LRE) development.This paper presents a synthetic approach for LRE reliability trade studies.It outlines a
rigorous yet practicable approach for evaluating engine reliability during different design phase.The approach
uses proven reliability methods of Reliability Modeling,Failure Modes and Effects Analysis,Failure Data
Analysis and Fault Tree Analysis to estimate the probability of different LRE design during the conceptual
design phase,and to find LRE weak point for design improvement during LRE Developing process.An example
is provided,in which the approach is used to evaluate the concept design of an upper stage engine.
Key wordsLiquid propellant rocket engine Reliability design Reliability calculation
1
ڴͳƽ,ɿԳͳΪ,
ơƸĽȽǶȳ,㷺˾ԼǿĴȫϵƷ
ƵȱڲܶѧܡպȸƫĽ
ɿȵı仯ƼĸͶ͸߷,ʹһҺĿɿԳ
עĿ⡣Ƚϵͳ(ALS)ԱΪȷﵽɿָ
(0.999),ڷƽ׶γԲһϵͳȽϷԸѡпɿԷ,˶
[1],÷ƼĻ,Ч߷ƿɿԡ
ĴӷɿƽǶȳ,ͼɿԿͼģʽЧӦ
ݷл,һϵͳҺɿ淽
,ͨۺϷпɿԤ,ȿڷƽ׶Ŀɿָܷﵽ,ȷ
ɿָķϵͳ;ҲҳƷеı,ԸĽ,Ϊ
顢֤鼰ɱȷĹṩ;ΪɿԷ춨ڿ
չоͬʱ,ӦĿɿƺͷʹø÷ضĳͺŷķ
֤˵ͷ
2ۺϷѧģ
ۺϷͼ1ʾ


ۺϷͼ
2.1ɿԿͼ
ɿԿͼÿɿԿͼԷɿԽз,ǽйģʽЧӦ,ɿԤƺͿɿԷĻɿԿͼͨͬ,ֱ۵طӳ涨ʱ,֮໥á໥߼ϵ
2.2ģʽЧӦ(FMEA)
FMEAۺϷнҪĻ,ǸݷɿԿͼ,һʽͻвطÿһ(һֹ)еĹģʽ,ÿһģʽԷӰ켰Ϻس̶ȣ2ݡ
ÿһȷĹģʽ,ܵΣ̶Ȼֹϵȼ,һΪ:
ࡡԹ,ϵͳƻ(ը޷ƵŻй©);
ࡡʧ(ػ);
ࡡδֹ(ܽ͡ºά)
2.3ݷ
ݷĿĿɿ,ΪɿԤṩҪϢɿֱӶԸ͵ʹݽֵͷ,صЩƵʽϸߡΣϴĵ͹ģʽԷΪձӦõǻĳֲַʽĸͳơֵڽʱΪݵķֲ֪ġһι(˲ʱ)Ĳ,籬ܡ籬,Ϊɰ͡,Ӧöֲ;Ļеಿ,Ϊֲָ;ֲ̬ܲƣӦǿݵĴĳЩϷֲȷ,Ȳֲд,Ȼ״ֵĴС,ҳƵķֲ
ڽṹ򵥵Ĳ,ҪҪģʽ,ѡ12ؼɿ;ڽṹӡɿԽϵ͵Ĺؼ,ÿһҪĹģʽֱȷؼ,пɿȼ㡣ѧģ͵ȷӰɿַ澫ȵĹؼءΪֲģʵʽṹĲ,֤ͨ,ѡʵϵ
2.4(FTA)
ͨFTAɽɿѧģ,Ŀɿ,һɷΪ졢Է׶ΡFMEAĹ̾,ͬͺŵƲƷԤƲƷĿɿȡԤƽȡڷӳɿԹϵķɿģ͵ȷԼݵ׼ȷԡĽ켰Էɸݹй,ͨϸµĹɣ2ݡ䶨Ҫѧ߽м㡣ԴͲ޸ϵͳ,ɿ߼ϵɿͼ,ɿȵЧС·3ݡ
3
3.1ϵͳ
ĳӼƽϵͳ,ҪӦֹ:һṩӼķж,ṩӼȶϵͳҪĿ;ҪŶr=0.7ʱ,ڹ涨ĹʱڽṹɿȲ0.9899
֤,ȷ˷ϵͳ:ƫƽ,˫ҡںͶ𶯵;ƽͷʽΪѹʽ,ȼѭ,ùҩ;Զ,ĸŷʵ,Դɼƿ
3.2ۺϷ
,ĳЩв,ɷĸǱ˴˶,ӰɵĽǶ,ɻͼ2ʾĿɿԿͼͼAii(i=1,2,15)


ͼ2ɿԿͼ
ݷɿԿͼ,ͬѹʽԳ,չϲԭ򼰶Ӧɹ10ֹģʽ,1ʾ
1Ϸ

ģʽؼ
ȼ
ģʽؼ
ȼ
й©ͷ,ƣҶƬ,ע,֧,ܢ
й©תܷ,̶ܷ,ܷĥ/ʴ,ҶƬ,ע
ҶƬ,ע,֧,,ҧϹ,Ţ
Т,ͨ,Сע
¶ȱ仯ҶƬ,ȼұ,,ȼܵעֱáע
Ա1ÿһֹģʽķʽͳƷ,õҪĿɿԤֵ,2ʾ
2ɿݿ
ƿɿƿɿƿɿ
ȼϸ뷧0.99988ȼ0.99988ȼ0.99990
뷧0.99987ŷ0.999890.99989
ȼϸ0.999890.99976籬0.99989
0.99989ȼϱ0.999850.99820
0.99989ܷװ0.99730ƽ0.99889
Ҫ,ѡ񷢶𶯹нṹʧЧΪ¼,ڽ̱ȽϷ,˴򻯺Ĺ,ͼ3ʾ,ͼE1E6Ϊ״̬ĵ¼ڸɿԤֵ֪,÷ɷĿɿԤֵΪ0.9886,ҪĿɿָꡣ


ͼ3򻯵Ĺ
ڿɿԤƵĻϽпɿԷ,ȷϵͳɿԵĶҪ,ΪԱɿƵݡһڸӳ̶ȸߡ졢ӵĲƷ,ĿɿָҪЩ,ЩҪȸߡĽǱĲƷӦϸߵĿɿָꡣͨһɿݷ֪,ֱáƽǸ÷ϵͳı,ڽƹӦȡЧʩ,⼸Ŀɿ,Դﵽϵͳ涨ĿɿָꡣֱõҪģʽǶܷʧЧ,ԭڶܷȱ,ӦṹͲ;ԶĤƬǰѵĹ,ӦĽ,ϸ,ӦǸĽ뷧,пɿ顣
ߵλ(ео..710100)
ο
[1]Cooper P A,Wolting D E.Reliability Comparison of ALS Engine Concepts:A Systematic Approach.AIAA 91-3373,June 1991
[2].ҺϵͳɿƵĹ.ƽ,1995(2):1-7
[3]Ң.ϵͳɿƵĹ.ƽ,1994,15(5):28-33
ոڣ19961021գ޻ڣ1998325
