Ϣ
INFORMATION AND CONTROL
1999 28 3 Vol.28 No.3 1999



μϵͳ*
ɶ̿
ժҪϵͳƻһδģʽĶۺо״˽ܺͷǹϵͳһģ飬Լԣϵͳ׷Ӧ仯ϵͳһɳڵĶ̬ݽ׿ƽṹĿǰϵͳȻڶԡһģʽо׶ΣʵӦûһľ룮
ؼʣΣϵͳ
ͼţTP11ױʶ룺A
HOLONIC MANUFACTURING SYSTEMS BASED
ON AUTONOMY AND COOPERATION
WANG ChengenCHENG Kai
(Shenyang Institute of Automation, Chinese Acadeny of Scinoe, Shenyang 110015)
AbstractThis paper introduces and analyzes the related concepts and current development status of Holonic Manufacturing Systems, which are proposed by the IMS Programme as a kind of future manufacturing paradigms. Holons with characteristics of autonomy and cooperation are considered as the basic components of manufacturing systems, allowing Holonic Manufacturing Systems capability to adapt to fast environmental changes. It is concluded that Holonic Manufacturing Systems adopt a slacked dynamic hierarchy and that Holonic Manufacturing Systems are still in a phase of research and far from wide application in industries.
Key wordsautonomy, cooperation, holonic manufacturing systems
1
ȫͳһгγɣҵļӾ磬ûĶгĿٱ仯ͳĽģʽѾҵҵֻʽͻƻص[1]̽һӦδҪĶгЧӦµģʽȹIMSƻУHolonic Manufacturing System(HMS)ǱȽӰһ˼룬ĳͬģǰ߸ƫ˹ܼоµδģʽ߸мǿҵϵͳеܶЭãʵԴļɣҪͬǹϵͳǶ߶ʮϵͳеãǿΰѻڹܵϵͳǨƵڹ̡֪ʶķHMSĵЧγҵЭĻ̩յĹϸֵķӶʹҵӡ-ӵġģʽѳת򡰺¡ģʽ
2HMSĻ
2.1HMSԪ
HMSĻԪسΪholonKoestlerڡ"һģHolonϣСholos()Ϻ׺onӻ򲿷֣ɵģKoestlerΪȶм̬ϵͳԿݱͷչɾеݽ׽ṹĸϵͳΣڷлＰ֯ĵݽ׽ṹȶм̬ʱKoestlerȻױʶֲ򡰲֡Ǿϵġ塱֡͡ǲڵģˣHolonԷӳʵͬʱС塱֡͡ʵص㣻Holonɲֶ壬ϼǲ[2]HolonĿǰûͳһ˽ΪŪ HMSΪŪϵͳҲרҽ߽HMSΪϵͳǣĲáӡʾ䡰-֡ĺ壬HMSΪϵͳÿӾһԣͬʱֽϼĿƣϵͳholarchyӾص㣺ԡԡԣ1ָÿӿԹ滮Զ¼ӦΪɿأ2ָÿӿӵķҲԸṩйϵ࣬˵ҪʱӼԻȿӵģҲǶԵȵ[3]֮໥ĳЩ̶ȵԴ3ָholonܹʹʽ㷨[4]еоûаԵΪӵıص[5]ǿǵǰʱΪǰģ
оԱKoestlerĹ֯л֯ĸǡתΪһҵĸϵҵʿϵͳһֶģʽ׷󣬷ӳһĿҵл֯л֯ŵ㣺ŶȶԡԱ仯ӦԡԣԼЧԴоԱҵӸӦý˶壮
(1)ӣǹϵͳһģ飬Լԣת͡洢/ϢӰһϢֺһ֣һӿ԰ӣЧϢصı֤Ϣ֧ŻҲ磨ԵӻⲿбҪʡϢ壮
(2)ϵͳһͨӵĺﵽĳЩĿϵͳϵͳӼĻҲԣ
(3)ϵͳHMSһʵҵϵͳȫӶᴩơԼۣ
һϵͳܹбʵ𣬺ִֻܱϼԴͻԼʱֻܵȴԴͷŻָ ͻ¼ʱвϼֱӴ¼[5]ͻĻ仯1ԴҪı仯2HMSеĹ̹ϼ豸ĹϣӾִбܾߣѡ򲹷ͬһֱЭ̡ίִе
2.2ӵķڲṹ
ӦӿԻֳɲͬ磬һֳĹϵͳУӱֳ¾ͣͼ1ʾ[6]1 ̴ӣִһ㷨ơƻҪʱģͼ͸㣮κιܵӹܶڴУ2 ̸ӸӼĺΪȫֲżƽ⣮ÿӽõһȫĿֲ꣬Ŀɷֲʽ̸Ż3 ڸµӻHMSȫĿ꣮4 ݿӸʷݺϢĴ洢ͷʣ״̬ء̸кϵͳڵṩ֧֣5 ӽϵͳϼغϣųܣ6 ӰҪϵͳعܹӵɾӵļ룬ҪʵӺʹ룮7 ָӶϵͳйвֲйƣ8 / ΪÿṩϢݵ9 ӶÿӲ˳ԼĻͬЭ


ͼ1ӷ
ͻַϢͼĹ۵㣮⣬ҲԸϵͳĹҪؽл֣磬һϵͳУӱֳ[7]1ȫи𹤼صڵȽ׶豸̸Ун׶ζԼӹмغЭ2쵥Ԫ ӿһ豸滮췽3߹ӹ߿Ļҽе߷䣮4AGV ӸAGVСԶƺ͵ȣ5·ͨƷַAGVAGVʱ¼ϻ̬AGVλãڱʱĻװʵϵͳУӰӦùֳܱࣺӡӹӡװӡӺϵͳŻ[2]
ӵڲṹֽ˷ֲʽ˹жagentĽṹagentȫͬģģͰģ飺ģ飺ϼͬзӹģ͹۵еĻ飮ƻģ飺ݽģ룬ƻִܹеĻУǣƻģ鲻Դ䣮ģ飺¼ͬͻڻ÷һ¼ִִͬģ飺ִ¼ʵʱ¼źš/ʼźźж¼źŵȣģ飺۲״̬ϵͳǷԼ/ģ飺һ¼ߣӵڲΪִмƻЭͼصȹܣ
3HMSĽṹл
3.1ϵͳHMSṹ
ĿǰΪֹϵͳֿƽṹпƽṹݽ׿ƽṹͱ̬ƽṹ(Heterarchical Architecture)ڵϵͳһȡ̬пƽṹصǾиԡȶԵȱұ仯пƽṹһ̨ȫϢ;߿ƣϵͳȫݴ洢һȫݿĿǰϵͳõݽ׿ƽṹݡƲ㡱˼йģиģгɽʽݽ׿ƽṹֽһϵм򵥵γɿƲض񣮱̬ƽṹϵͳֽɽƶʵ壬ʵͨԤȶͨŽӿڽкʵ֮ӹϵоֲԣϵͳζʵ͸ģ ʵҪʵڱ̬ƽṹϵͳʵи߶ԣԿӦ仯Ҳ׵»״̬
HMSĽṹص㣮һϵͳȫԭ϶ƽȵģϸ¼ϵÿӾнϸߵԣԶоߣִкͿľߣڶϵͳдȷĹӵɶȣ֤֮໥һӿԾĳͨЭ̣ƶ໥ԽܵķҺִЩϵͳ֮šϵӿѭݹ鶨壮縺AGVӿ԰й̴ӣI/Oӣݿӵȣ֧ͨ幦֮ڰϵҾ幦ڲҲڰϵһ幦ӣɹҲǹӣǰ߽ӵߵϢ󣬼ԼݿӿûзҪĲƷ򽻸ƷϢɹӣûоͼƷӣʱݿӾ͡ڿУΪ֮İ뱻ϵĳһȶʱӼ¼ϵ򡰰ṩ
HMSӵļγϵͳṹϵͳĿΪָЭΪֶι淶Ϊ(ͼ2)


ͼ2ϵͳṹʾ
HMSṹǻһЭԵȵĽṹܵĿεԪ֮ƽȺЭĹϵHMSһŷֻҪԴͻͿԷڶӣңԴͻʱ̸֮ͨЭ̴һ£ӾܣԶѡԼֽתȣ֮ҲܹͨЭ顢̸Ϊͬ루ĳһϵͳΪŻţȡʵĻͬʱϢʡڱεӲͬڴͳṹдλģ飬ϵʱģⲿ仯ϵͳڲ仯ʱǰӿܱΪƽȵ˵ĵλҲܴж̬ṹʧӵļ룮Щص㶼ģʽҵعԣֶ̬عּ̬صHMSڴͳģʽ֮֮ڲáϢԼԼӵϵͳеĶ̬λ̬ȶ㷴ӳ˲ƷӦгڻȶ֤³ԣҲЧල̣ලģӵĽṹʾͼ2УԲǾκԲαʾĳһʱ¸ϵӣ˫ͷʾԵȺȰϢҲͷʾӹϵ߼ڵָ˵ǿԿӴڰ뱻ĹϵΪ˴ȫĿ֮꣬໥ͬʱҲϼĽ飬ֹܵԼ
Ȼϵͳṹһ޶ȵģϵͳζŹУʹ³ԽͣƽĻ״̬͹ҲҵȫֻԼӵӻֲ֮۸ӵԼϵڳ伶װУܻӵļӹװ˳ƻȱѭܡϵƣ
3.2ϵͳHMSл
֯ϸһвչḶ́HMSӼεĸ壬ڸӵĻвϢʵĽagentϵͳƣ֮ͨſԷֱֳࣺͨźͼͨţֱͨŰ㲥ʽ͵㵽ͨţͨͨרŸͨŵнӽתHMSлҪϵͳ̸֮ЭЭ̺ԣ̸ЭϢͺշϢĴȣһ㣬HMSӼ̸ЭúͬЭ飨Contract Net ProtocolͬһӰϴĹڷֲʽͨѶЭ[8]ַУͬĹֽ߽Ȼͨ㲥ʽб꣮ĳԱյϢͶ꾺߸ȫĿзѡѵĺ飮HMSжԵӼɱӵĴϢǽƿ֮һͨѶķչʵϢ㷨ҲΪҪϢAgent˼·Ϣӵ࣬ǽ鼼˼·ѾϳһЩ飬ÿһҪʱֻҪϢ ɴɨϽӵ򣬴ӶжϺͽһϢŸеĳЩӣͱϢäĿݴϢ
HMSŵ֮໥ϵͳȫĿ꣮Э̺Թ淶ϵͳ֮ĽжŻHMSϵͳĿ꣮ӾԺ࣬ӼԴͻЭ̺ṩӦĹԴͷHMSйУӵľֲĿ꣨棩ϵͳȫĿ꣨棩ìܣʱHMSԲȡ²ԾǷ
(1)ȫǵڶλģ
(2)ȫ棬ǵڶλģ
(3)ȫ棬ûеڶλĺ
(4)ȫûеڶλ棻
(5).
һ£HMSвȡ4ԣȫҲԸȡЭ̺ԣHMSЭƱ֤ϵͳܿٽʵʩڿٱ仯ҪпٵӦԣӼĸ߶ЭڲƷƱ仯仯п֯ӦHMSԶµŶг仯綩ı仯ԵϵŶ豸ϡϢнϺõĿHMSЭ̺Ʊ֤ٱ仯ǰ±ϵͳз仯ϵͳƽHMSЭ̺ƵоʼΧһģ׷̬١Ч֯ʵҵṹع
4HMSӦʵ
HMSCIMSһһµۡ뵽ԼϵȥĿǰڹHMSûʵʵϵͳ̽׶ΣѾ˼ֵ͵HMSӦʵϵͳаװߡϵͳȣ봫ͳϵͳ˷ԱȣһЩݣó˿Խۣ
оԱʵʵĻ˼ӹԪΪϵͳϵͳ̨վ[3]һ̨SGIվģ˼ӹԪⵥԪ̨Aitec ARS10ˣгֹߣһ̨עģͻһ̨ӻһ鴫Ƥһ̨AGVһ̨SUNվڽϵͳ֤HMSͨš̸кЭƣӼͨԺ̸ͬЭΪκֻ׼ִУӼͨ-Ӧʽͬͬǩƻѽб֮УͿִͨˣHMSԱ֤쳣нǿӦĳӳֹϲɸʱƻ·Ϣǩͬ
һӰǱʱоԱĻװʵϵͳ[9,10]ϵͳ̨װ˺һϵͳϵͳһĻÿվFIFOͻϵͳǷ롢ͨ뿪ĳվ㣮ϵͳͬʱװֲͬ͵ĲƷֲͬоԱHMSݽ׿ƽṹͱ̬ƽṹ˱Ƚϣʵ£HMSЧҪϵͳЧڻϵͳڲ仯ʱHMSЧѣ
5
ͨ죨IMSƻϵͳۺʵǿԵó½ۣ1ӵĸϷӳֲı֤۵㣬ϵͳӳ˿Ӧ仯󣮣2ϵͳ׷صԼԣھʵַʽֲʽ˹agentʮƣңĿǰϵͳʵϵͳȫǽڶagentϵͳʵֵģˣϵͳԼڷֲʽ˹ܼ֧֣3HMSûȫ֮ԼϵֻǽԼɳڣHMSƽṹʵǵݽ׿ƽṹͱ̬ƽṹУһɳڵĶ̬ݽ׿ƽṹɳڡʾϼָǷǿƣֻһֽ飮̬ӼӹϵǱ仯ĺͲ̶ģԣHMSӳܺԵĻϵͳ̬ع˼룮4Լϵͳ̸ͨоѶȣHMSϵͳ԰ιHMSоʼ׶ΣĿǰ޷ڴϵͳʵӦãˣHMSϵṹ̸лơƷģ͡Ʋԡ׼淶Ϳ湤ߵдڽһо
*йѧԺ¹ĿƼ863CIMS
߼飺ɶУ35꣬ʿоΣоΪCIMSۼȽ۵ȼ
̿У25꣬˶ʿооΪعϵͳۣ
ߵλйѧԺԶо110015
ο
1 Tomiyama T. A Manufacturing Paradigm Toward the 21st Century. Integrated Computer Aided Engineering, 1997,4(3):159178
2 Hopf M. Holonic Manufacturing Systems(HMS)-The basic Concept and a Report of IMS Test Case5. Sharing CIM Solutions J.K.H Knudsen et al.(Eds.) IOS Press, 1994
3 Tapio Heikkila. Holonic Control for Manufacturing Systems: Functional Design of a Manufacturing Robot Cell. Integrated Computer Aided Engineering, 1997,4(5):202218
4 Deen S M. Cooperation Issues in Holonic Manufacturing Systems. Information Infrastructure Systems for Manufacturing(B-14) H.Yoshikawa and J.Goossenaerts(Editors) Elsevier Science B.V.(North-Holland), 1993: 401402
5 Tonshoff H K. Product Modelling for Holonic Manufacturing Systems.Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Computer Integrated Manufacturing and Automation Technology, 1994
6 McFarlane. Holonic Manufacturing in Continuous Processing: Concepts and Control Requirements. Proc. ASI'95, Portugal, 1995
7 Amos H C Ng. HSCS-the Design of a Holonic Shopfloor Control System.Proceedings of Confernece on Emerging Technologies and Factory Automation (EFTA'96), France, 1996
8 Smith R G. The Contract Net Protocol: High-Level Communication and Control in a Distributed Problem Solver. IEEE Trans. Computer, 1980, C-29(12):11041113
9 Valckenaers P, Brussel H V et al. IMS TEST CASE 5: Holonic Manufacturing Systems. IFAC Intelligent Manufacturing Systems, Vienna, Austria, 1994
10Valckenarers P. Holonic Manufacturing Systems. Integrated Computer-Aided Engineering, 1997,4(5):191201
1998-06-08ո
