 ׺ 1-3097
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš199602
ԭҳš118-142
  šJ1
  
    
ӡںš199606
    ʷƷ֮
    
              
    ǰܡӦóΪ⹹һΪеƷҪ˼֧㡣δؽΪԵ÷ͬСɣҸ
ضضϵݿᡲ35ĳ˵޿ܼ޻滭ڡŵһֶǿƷûκ
ܹᶯ޸ģе˼Ҳˡ˵һҽ䴴˼άԾԾ쵽ƷܱߵĿϣô
ܵĴڵԭʵϣƤʷѧѾܾԶ׼ֵǣǵ
ʷѧ߻Ǵ಻ܵ壬ʹżἰҲǵһȤζԻ滭ʵ߽赭дɴӶ׷
ͬһ崫ͳйصġһͳУǷʻ˵Ĵڣ˲͹°ͼʽ˼롣Ȼ
ʻģ֮ΪԻ滭ƷӾһԿףȻ޼ζ36
    ǿ⹹߰ѿܣǻ棩⹹ʼ㣬Сձ˹ָȣĳЩضܱȷʵ
뻭иģ˹أMax Ernst1920 ġĿɪȡһõ°޿˷ѾͻΪһˡ
źԻǣĸƷȴǷǰ߷ֿɡ
    ΣʹұĿҲ൱ġ塱ɣڻ꡶ġޣΪһ
нɫı߿ĿľڼԦߵעӣʹ֮ڻ档
    ʷĲϣǻԵܵҪᴩ滭ʷȻ񿵵ѧڡжСʮ
ڣаѻ֮Ρѣȫνıǣֻܲ𵽱ɫ֮ãıҪԻζذѻ
뱻ġµʵ绮䡶滭һлһ϶ѿܽͼ͵ԶԶģΪ
Ȼͼ֮ĸӵĽáܴѧܵ⣬Ϊһֶصָ
ԵػعһʷڶԿܵʷԺ弰γɷʶڲͬʱڣԿܵҪǶֶġʷ仯
ĿܹʵϺγڷӳܵ15͵İ䡶ۻ滭дһᵽ˿ܵȻԡдȹ
һĳΣҿһȴ򿪵Ĵڣ͸һڣһҪͼռһƬ͸
ĲȻ細ڣȻдıҪʹζǣѿܵƶڣرԵڱڻ
ֻ汾ĴϡȷʵܳߵҪֶΣԿһǶģһ֡37һֽ
˵ܲӺ͸Եģ෴ϵֵĿռ֮УʹΪΪڵָϵͳڴˣܣر16
ļ̳ʵѱɻ滭ɻȱһ֡ѻġµʵֿȻǿܵҪΪ֮ںϵ
һ̶ʱҲͨܶʵֵġƩ磬ڰ޿˵Ʒеı߿ˡںϵַѡءһЩ춥
滭ֻ汾ϣĽֺڻǲв㣵ġҮ춥ϣܼȷԽģߵɱʹ
ֻǲֵصһ𣬶ԵĻʹҮܴķڽ˹ϣ˹Gijsbrechts͸أ
˹Fort BrasļͻǰҪظ˹ʽĴΪĶʵﱾ̲סȥŪأ˹
ӵһ÷һʹ뱳ΪһĻΪĳʵ˹ϣ˹һּͻı棬
֮ڽ侹ù߶ְһһʲôĻһı棡
Կܵϰ֮벻Ч  Ƶӻ̹նAbrams   van   denTempelͰͳжJean-Jacgue
s Bache-lierǰ1672ġ԰еĿΧס棬·ȴ˴̨װֻӣ
1753ʱСԻ۾ĿʾҲǰѿܱΪԵһ֡ɫʵƷӳĻδɵ
Ʒ⿪ŵƷȣڿͬŵŵĶԱ൱ԵġȷʵʱڲˡǸϣĻУ
˻滭֮н֮ͨġҹݺڿΡһΪǶԳǳġ⣨ͼ4 
ڸֵܵһ̸˲ֿܵľ⣺ڻĵײһЩ羰ïܵɭ֣һϪϪڱ
ǡĳ֮ǳϷٴγִٵİһǰٺϻ顭һõ廨顭ͬ
ڻгΣбڻеͼǾһֳ򡣡38Ҳ˵ǳĿͨԻͼ
˶ƷǼеȾǿŵĺС19ĩڣ滭ѧһ
̵ı仯Ϊٻҹעһ⡣Ʃ磬ε⣬֮Աزپڡûпܣ滭ɥʧ˰ٷ֮ٵ
39ûеһֿǶϲʧģһӡ廭ҵѡ˵һЩġǴ԰ɫɫĿȡ
ƽĿܡһ䶯ǶʱеһֺӦҲʽϵССǡǡǺӡ廭ǱµĻصϵġ
һʱ۹ҡ˹̺ˡĸ߶ӡľֵдǵ
չУЩĻúϺֲľ»ȡ˾ʽƽĿܣרҵѧԺɹõĹܡĿķ
СƻҫҷʮɫڵȣҪͬ͵ĿܣֻɻұṩŮ֪ôʲôʩʲô
͸ѡʲôǽֽԼĹ뷿һ40ҫĿܣʽмӣ֮ԱãֻΪ͸һɽ
һҫ۵Ľɫƻɹϸ΢仯γɵضɫ˵¼Ӿ̲˽ɫĿܣ˹ֻԼѡ
߿жĻУںܵĽṹЧˡ֮Ҳǳһ׷󣬼ʵɫʣѧ
ﵽһȫȫĿơڻÿһɫܵڽɫӰ죬ܵɫҪǽȥԾ߿Ļƻ
زЧȣǲӡ廭ƫİɫܵģеʷĿܡ1889ע
ڱ߿뻭֮һ壬ոܵġӰҲܹ߸̨µӰ죬𲽵ɫܴǳɫġΪ
ھԺеƹⰵΪʹƹ⼯е̨ΪΨһעģ滭ҲҪˡ1884뵺աͼ
ºӵıԵֺǸˣΪڱߵĻܵӰ졣һϷšĿܣԼٵĿܣѡɫһɫ
ʹƷձ֮ԲĿͬԼƷ֮Ľõעȷʵ˼ά
һл֡ͬʱҲӦĳϻһʷԵӡ֤˾˵Ļõİɫܱ
ٷɳչһɡʱöƽı߿ȲϹ淶Ҳš¼ӲһչԻ˵
ҪĿܡڻһ㣬ǻ滭ѵһݳƷ𣿡¼ӵĻشǣǵĿܻˣǣǵ
ȴ־ٵĿܡ41ǡвرҶض̬ܵȡ20ͣһȷ
ƷȶһУ滭Ķ塢滭ıʣȵȣȻҲ⡣Ʒܵĸ汻ɶĻ
ĵλĵ߸߿һȷҷȨһֱ־42ɣ粻ԭȴͳĶԿܵĹڴ
ǷܵΪǲʲôЧģ˵ˣԶĿʵԶԿܵᡢںΪǰ
ġɵﰲһд֪ǵһѻ滭ӿнųģǽ֮СҸеûпܵͼҪ
ܵĺãÿܻάռУһȵĴԣͨľͷɿܣȻûϣӶʵСͼ
ںγɵʵ滭ֵһ롣43ȥ߿õлά棨Kasmir  M
alevich  ֶٲ񣭼أFriedrich Vordemberge-Gildewartܶ˹Pieter EngelsͿStephen BuckleyͲ
£Pierre BuraglioȡǶƷĿܵһ־кζ⡣ҪԵǣձ˹
ѿܲһһּ󣬼ƷȻḻҪܵĵزˡΪȻǻװ͸֮ƶҪ
ʾص㡱ҡѧĿǷпܣһʱһأʵϣֻ
ʱʱ涨ܵΪ㡱44֮ܲһ̬ĺ΢Χ⣬ͬһδ͸ʷ4
5
    ͼ  {ͼ}
    ͼ4.  񣺡ҹݺڿΡֲغݡΪǳ
              ԭλλ
    ʷ˹̹дһƪʾԵģΪ˹еĹ۸С46֪ڲʥõ
˹ãӽʷϿǲô˸Ȥġ֮ԻҪȥǶֻΪ˹ۿеļǵƷ˹̹
Դ˻˺ζѣʵϣԿǵЩƷǽǰѿʼˡФ񻭰Сʮ͵Ŀռ
ʱϵǶͼ־ͬЩƷǡùϵȡĽǶȿǵġʥ޵͡ʥ˵õѳѡ
ͼϻԵ˷ֻеڹԴԻõԲʮֽԲʱпɨЩƷ⿨ǵЩƷΪʲ
ôҪһﲻɡһǵۿ縴ƷƷĳЩͼ־ʵԣЩ£ĳЩƷİ
ղҪ׶ԭһƷġﾳǽȥܽΪȫʶƷʷʡ47ЩƷ
ԭλϲǱģʷѧ߾عԭλԻԭʼġﾳ
    ٻźǣǶƷԭλƺһֱȱ㹻Ĺע䡶Ȼʷ롶־ṩй
˹Ͱ͹˹ıǶ꣺λŴҽ˹ʾһѵƷڻСʳ͹
˹óһĻƷͬǱФԭʹ˹ѿ˵ڸһĻ󻭵ʲôˡ
˹Ͽҵ͹˹䣬ԼֻƭС񣬶͹˹ȴƭһרҵҵ۾48ǣֹ£ֻϸһ
¾ͻȻʣ͹˹Ļȷʵƭ˹ôӦжĳ߷ںֳϣſ
Чͨ£ٻһСߴһֹǽϵĻһֿɽҵĲ˭Ҳѱ֮Ƭͬڱ
ԭһǲҲһֱԶĹؼ֮Դˣѷ˺˵ĲͣһΪдʵһԢԣ
ʷļбƵƵãͼʧȴҪһ¼صԡǿΧѹ·ֳӶһ
˿еСҲΪײ˻һƬڣıĴеһ壺
˳ɫС̨ǽϡʵϣ˹Ļϣ˳֮ΪSkenography 糡Ʒڶǰ
˹Ļľ棬Ƶ⡣ǻĻòģ18͵ղؼòѼϻ
һľϷԵĽĻʽϰ޲ֳ¼ֵǵĻò۵ĶĿϲⱾ
ϷԣʹϷԱǣһƺҪȥĻĻͼ䱾һ糡չʾġǡǡֹ糡
Ǵӷ˹˹ļлƻȵĵط˹Ͱ͹˹֮չһֵùעǣϷ
绯ĹµķԼԻ滭̨ϵǿ49Ȼ˹͹˹Ļʧ׶ãı
ʵҲܼ۵ܲɷ֡50Ǽ޷ƷԭʼλãͲкܶ಻Ҫʶ
    ʵϣҪԾʶƷԭλﾳ¡ΪġﾳĻʵѾԽԽٶ෴Ի
Ʒĸ಩ΪǾܲʧΪ˾ϺóȴδȫġƷԭġﾳڡͳӴ
ߡһѷرǿʷ׳ʵΪߵ˺Ϊҵ˻нȻķӦΪǰ߿
ȻӾʢж˼طĪѹ֣ܵͳҵʹԼʩչֽдĿռС
ˡ51ǿԼ죬ǻԿһز죺ΪߣڲѲӹȥӾĻ屦ʱܻԼ
ӾĽգĿϾΪʷѧߣȴӦһߵʣǰЩƷڵģ˵ԭʼġﾳ
ιɵģڴ󲿷ֲ֪ʵĻʱҵصĽͻӡȱŵ
¡й൱˵ҲΪĹĹУƷһֳġѾǵ
ɵʵϵǰĳʵƷ޹صԭ򱻷ڻڲʱʧ
ȥʵԭʼϵĳµģƷϵǲż񣬲ʽ󣬲дԵĻ滭ׯϵļ
򵥵ġʵüֵĹߣǳ˾ĳֹͬԵƷڣַ·йͬԵչƷʹ˶ԭʷò
ĴƫΪһݰѡʷǰżͽĹеĵܡӡװΡʱڵ鱦
ʥĲͼոʱڵƷ˻滭Ȼ壭ӡķ羰ɺͳ󣭱ʽṹȫһ
ʱṩһٵġͳһĸ52ڴˣ˵㣬ȷ˼һЩ
ҪйŴķ̱ڻĵܣӹϣĶǽԫŰľ޴ȣ˴ȵĻײ
ʷĴҸУҲ˵ƷʷԻΪĳϣݶƷԭλʵΪǿԵĳʹ
Ʒάԭеȫ嵺ά˹¬Ȼϳ˵ıȻƷԭλϵһ
ȴѲһԭ̸Ҫضռʱɺʸָ屾ƺΧĿռһԣ
岿ж󣬶Χռһ塣յĿռΧΧĿռΪʽ53
صƷЩǺΧضռ䴽ģ֮һַͬСɵϵԻ߸ıֹغϵʵ
ϱǶƷΪ޸ĺԴˣķĹ۸ǺģȫϲܵƶĶ
һǵӰͬʱҲǵĳϵһġĹ׿޵ġ
ѧԺյԲδһƷʧȥΪصƷԡڹȥΨһƷڴԭλԣ1504꣬
ˡԹ͹ҪƷʵ֣     CittadinoguerrieroĹ񣩡54Լ 
ƷǹġȫĴڣǡǡԭλмΪҪĹ
    Ҳûбʲô18͵ĵ¹J.  նƷԭλˡóϣĸ߹
ִĸжƷԭλԵϵζдվڹŴʦ֮ǰع۲ͺԢ幹
֮е˵ѧ;ѧЩʱԶнġϸϸĦЩƷĶԳƺЭʱ䵱
ϸϸĦЩ尴ԸĲͬھ붯״̬γɵĶյʱܵȤѽǿɰ
ƺһƮľ顣Щϣ˿ʶǵԲ߹ˣ֪һĻĻת˲ŵ˵
ʲôǰ˵οһЩʯϣ̵üȷʵִӶˡץס˵ÿһת˲ŵĳϵĻ䣬
֮ĸеĻʹ֮ʥһ쾹䵽ڵǵĴڵĳߵı־ϲ
ʱ򣬺ǣȻͰѾġ߹Ĵ۴˰ɣԼѷɣޱʥǰ
ֻиܵһֱռеҸǷȥռǣնƬ̵ǣǡǡռС޵
ıǵԭλԡпŭˣÿεҿ౦رô˵ӢȥʱܸеϧЩ
ǴϣӶıﻹԭˣɡֻҪ˲ֹ·;ÿܲĵؽӽ
ЩǵƷ͵ȥɡ55ȷʵϣһϢǺһʱ˺ڻһ
ģǾն˵ҰռǷռǴӶǵ;
    նɱһֶƷԭλԵҪ󡣲ʹǲף߲ܳףԭλԵعҲġ
˹ǿǼ粻ݵƷԭչʾʽʱ˼봴ԼʱĹȫ
һƷıԡҡʹƷǿƶģ续ϵƷԭĹ˳ԼΪһ黭γɵĸ֣ƺҲع
56ڽܳҵƷ˵һΪԡ쳶Ϊ˹͢ƵıڹƷһƷԵʱ16
кڵΪӰ죬Ҳ쳶ȥ֮ǰȫԸɵΨһĴƷԺٸԻط
ϵʪڻδȫ쳶ֻṩһЩ뷨ЩͼʵʵĻ֡ͽȳеٻ쳶
ȥɵģԵΪѵáǣʷѧ߷ѵǣƷвõıϵȴһ
С⣬ǰоԶѿ⡲5750λӢʷѧ߻أJohn  White ϣJohn Shearman
ͬ˽ϳʱڵо ΪǱȽȷذպ쳶ƷṩһֶⷽʽΪоĳʼ
Կǣڣ1 ܹʮƷһϵе壬ûпԣڣ2 ֵĹƬǺϡԼ
ʹͽд¼򣻵ڣ3 ʥ˵úʥйص´йػĦʪڻҲǴõļ̳
ʼģڣ4ΪҪǣ Ϊÿ鳡趨һĹôĹ߱ضͬÿϵ
ӦոʱڵУϵƷͨǹ˼ֹϵã粼еϵʪڻˣ
ţ쳶ҲѭƵ׼򡪡ʵϣ쳶ڴϵƷʱʮռյԼ
Ԥλõģڣ5 ӾߴϿƷضռôļֱ̳ԭλôǽ档ǻǰ
˵ʱع˳˱˵뱣޵ĹϵҲΪϵУǹڱ޵ϵУҵǡеĹնӦ
ϵ58Ȼвܴһعоеõ滭ƷƷһŲԭλԵĽۣȴʹʶԭʼչ
ʾʽƷǺҪƵľʹķ԰滭ԼڵƷʧȴ廷Ľ
¶źΪġ̬ƷӦרλã֮ڻЧɺϣ
Ӱ죬ҲԤ֮СԣƳռ͢ǽϵǶʽеĲɫʮȻ飬ΪЩ
Ʒвɻȱл֣ͬʱҲ价мȡص塣Ȼ ݡ еĿռƺǰ
ƷԭλԻˡ59
    ȻƷԭλԺλ֮䲢һžȻĶΪ嵽ĳЩƷȵġԭʼչʾصδѵ
ͬʱǱϾϤŵعһƷԭλԣ˵ΪձǣԭλԱҲҪʷı仯ضλ
ԭλԵĸı䣩ԳֵƷĹƷԣôпתΪͬԱϿɵġġ򡰶ġ
ȥģԭλԡ  ġȸҡPeacock  Room Ϊ ѳΪл˹գJames  MeNeill Whist
lerͻƷԴȵĹ18631864װƣ綫Ͻǵġɫͽɫĺг18761877μͼ
ԼйһַܳƵȻʵеչƷأСейŴȸҡ
ףȸҡԭ׶أΪFrederich R.Leyland1904꣨ȥʮ֮׶صһݡ
ͬ꣬£ȫɢװȥԺ󣬰Ըȸҡʢ٣ָװ
ڡ60ȸҡһرͻӣƵĸͳ£ŦԼĸղعݣFrick Collection׶صĻʿ
عݣWallace CollectionݵȡЩУ䶯еƷĿռصԭӦеͺ
⣻ȻЩƷѾԭʼģǴģռ涨ԣԭλȷʵȽǡеƷĸʡЩղ
ѳ֮ر˻߳ʷѧΪƳݣһҪԭǿ
ִԭλԵʷζûбҪԭλλԿȻŵķ룬ҲҪԭλԶ̫ͬҲܳ
ʷضƷõġλԡ
    ʵϣǿע⵽ǣЩղΪӴĲҲڳ̶Ȳͬ뻯Ļͬ໯ԭλԿ£ʼղ
ܾ߱ԭλԱȫ壬ԾӪ칹еԭλ˷ͬЧŦԼ󶼻еһͥ԰
йŴử͡ζ˼ʵвɶõ棬16ʽԺͶǷڳҲӦ˹
ĹͺͲ͹һֶضԭλԵĺӦǿͬӢάǲеְ黭ΪйŴеһл
ɲּչʾҲӪضԭλաܴӸ˵κζνԭλԵعŬֻ޶ġֲģ
ĳɷݣعȴӦԶȥΪʵǾ廯ΪһʵĻաȤ͸ȣֻʷ
ѧߵʵ֤оУرļֵһԭλλԵĶת岻ٳΪӦùעһάȣôƷ
ʷԹվɽʧҪһ
              ԭα
    ԭα֮ĸ칹ʷоһͳ⼴͡ȻƷűȷȨȵӹ㷺
⣬ƩܱųѧĻȷ̽ȻûӼ͵塲61ⲢǷҪҪ
ͣڴʲôǶȥڴˣѧҹŵNelson GoodmanرҪȡģЩѴʱ䡢
ȥȷĳЩƷǷƷղؼҡݳʷѧ˵Ʒһʹͷ۵ʵ⡣α
Ҫ񡣡62
    עԭġ֮α֮֮ͬġͬԭʱһ߶ϼԺⶨҲʷԵһ
ġġҪﵽĿ֮һɴ˴ﵽԭƷӡ󣬻ԭȱʧ³Ϊһڵԭ
ĸȡԭصԼʱļɡýϵȵ𡣵ǣġڱϻȫǶԭԽ
ٽ裬ġߵıǳϰȷҪֻǵġӰԭʱҲ˵ٱ
ԭʱαˡԣϣġαһֽ֮ѡȻναԼ
ġдʵɸΪӶ䡣ֵעʵǣġֵǡǡֻԭ໥Ƚϵ²
Գ֡һ仰˵ԭȻǰ֮£ġԶȶ֮ҸȫصġΪɫɫġ
ǿġĶԭʧںﵽĿĵλҲͿ˳ˡйʷΪ
ЩΪȽڵԭҲڵġ綫֮ġŮʷͼͼֲַ֣عʹ
ݺݵȣŮͼϳġְͼƴġͼ͡뽹δͼĺġʵϽ
ֲϸʤһΪЩġϾ൱ɫر˿ӵݡʷѧġعʷԵò޵ֻǲǿ
⣬ʲյҪԭٿֻ޼ԭġԭɼġ֮Իļֵ
죬˹1617ģɽˮ19ġпµƷʷ˿мֵģʹ
ԭʤһġƷҲԭһ߱ʷԵļֵƩײʶԼʦ˹Piete
r LastmanĸдƺԭҪһЩڣġ֮ȲײʵĴƷҲضʱֵüȡҵ
ʷĵӮһϯ֮ءڴˣʷ߼ֵüȼ򵥶ˣһҵƷΪĳһʦ
ġı䣬ġгɾ͵Ĵʦ֮Ҳܶȡԭߵʷλ
    ӦϣαƷġҪԵ˷öࡣѧAᣬ ǰαѧ
Ұ֮£Ϳܻ᷽Բ䣬ԽóĽۣԭ֮һǡƷα֮Ķϵжϵһַ׼һ
ƷαһϢͬϢҴʱ䣻Ĵʱ͵صλۼۣõĲ
ʾķӰ죻ʱ״ĿģȵȡЩϢɹ봫ǡʷѧѧ򡭡
һ仰Щ涼δǡƷıʣƷɵıʡΪαֵδþ͵Ŀ
ĵزڷ17ͺҸ׶ĺ׸ףHan van    Meegeren ġ˹͡Supper  atEmmaus
ʹͽ˹ʹͽ˹ȣμͼҲչʾ17͸׶ΰ󡱡63
ԭα֮Ĳ̽ʷչ
    ǲʷȻαѱƷ64ʵϣһӣһ棬ʷѧԼҲ̾
α²ʲôһĽǣȻŵֱҪ׷ʣ˭
϶ǹȥںͽ˰ƷƷֿأܹŵָֻA صϵ
죬ҲǺϵĲ죬ֻҪΪġģͲܲע⡣޸ΪȻԲǶƷԭαð
ּظӦеòǣ޸ǷǳΪģԭϵκıȾ֮ͿܻαıԵ
ʱһڻȻ΢޸ĽصҪǡ65ʥĽеġǵ͵ʳı
ϣ޾ͱ֪޸߲ŮϺ룬ȷʵµʴȫȫα컹Ҫ׾ӡʵϣ ־Ĳ
Ϊ֮ľ޴޸ͬҲܻرα⡣1980꿪ʼۼƺʱʮ˹͢ڻϴ޸̾һƽϢġ
ٷ粨ǻָԭԭʼòƻԭ߼ָ׿޵ıڻƷƺʧȴԭȳŵɫ
ͨ׻仯ϵĲҲǰ٣ʧȥ˷ḻУڣ׿ޱ˹˵ȵȣһ㡲66
Ҳ۸˭˭ȷһǣԭκһʮ΢΢ı䶯Ҳи޴۵Ŀܣ
ԶԭӦʷ״̬
    Ȼԭαȴں̶ܴǽһйԭʷԿȫƳĹϵġ׸ΪԼα츥׶
Ʒʱ˱ףҪôǾ͵óǻ᷸ҪôǾͱ븥׶һΰ󡣡67׶Ա
Ƶα޽ǲӹɵġȷ׸Ϊα졶˹͡·ǳٶǰĸ׶ֵ֮Ʒﵽһжи
ɻĵزһα֮רҵƤ£ײоᣩõϿɲ1937ö֮ں˹ݣBoysm
an Museum꣬ȫȻΪ׸׵α̫˼ˣȣռ׶ùϣɫʯɫ֬ɫ
֬棬ɫðǦȵȡͬʱո׶ֹĥʹ΢ȣеĥбɫʿʹպ΢
أΣмƻԱʣѸ׶гֹĶһΣԲͬϣ洦ļ׼
ΪʹαĻٶĹžĿ׸ײе翾¯ҳòͬϼӹ
ɫʹȷŻеϳɷȶԶģα졶˹͡ѡ17͵һ仭ͻܣ
ʯۼմĥϵԭͼ񣬵Ᵽ˵ɫͬҲΪӦպ֤Ժ濾װԭܣ
޷й֮󣬡͡Ĳ׵˹ʿȷΪ׶벩˹Ϊ
ҪƷС68׸Ƿ켫α֣ҪȻǣǷԭ˸׶شӦǷ񶨵ġȻ׸
׵α֮Ϊ׶Ľ׶Ʒı׼Ҳһ֮ı䣬֡һȡʷһʱ䳤ȶֻһ˲
ѡ˼ǣǲº׸׵αĸ׶ƷڷϵĲ죬ʵαճʱĿר
еŦԼ̶άʱյڰһ˷ȥĵ籨βǴдġʮƷֻδ
ע⡣ٺرȽ׸׵ҵʱ绯ױӰƵĿЧƷӰ졲69֮
Ǹ׵αҲȫʱ޹ء
    һ뻹ɰαķʷʽʾøΪһĿȻαṩαԭһģһƷô
ǷζŻ˽ʷʸأشǷ񶨵ġΪʷʹõġԭԡѧշġԭ
ԡԡԵȣͬġ˹͡ȻԺѾعеġԭԡ֮£磨1 
ƷκƷԣ2 ƷеĳֱĸԣָʹбƷɫʡͼĵȣ
3Ĳõı֣Ĵǰ޹˵Ϊ4ضƷ裬ȵȡǣ׸׵αѹ
ʷϷǳǿĳһ˻ĳһɵɾ͡Ը׶ΪΪ֮ǰҲֹͼСɫʵԼ
Թ߷ļԦǲ˵Ʒԭԣԭֻضʷ龳в͹ֳ֮ʷ
ԭԶʷؼ޶ġ֮ۡ͡ǾͿɺ˵׸׵α20͵ʷνԭģ
ΪʷʵԵĹ׻ͻơܹؿ͡·븥׶Ʒ޷˷ʷľ롲70ܶ
֮ʷĳ߶ǻԭαߵı׼ɴˣҲɼʷڱԡ
              
    ʷҰУƷһ־ĶۣҲһﻯ˵塣ǾȻۻǷ
ѧƺԹճʷԵƷԣǰǿĻϵʱƺֻ
ڡšͬʱʵַ˽綨ĿԡڵľдͳѧУƷʶҲĲ⣬
硰ۡۼơϰֻҵ򣬶ƺ˼ƷضƷԶۡʷо
˵ƷоӦǳշ֤һʼҪƷı塢ʷ龳ϵ԰ա
ڶÿһֲƷʷԵʱÿһأΪ΢СأпΪһлɷֶ
ֳζƷ廯ʷʷƷ۵ڡ
    עͣ
    1  һ꣬ͼ߸C.F.Waagen ƸΪһʷڣμ棺ѧĿѧ㽭
Ӱ磬1986ꣻҲţ¿˶ִʷĴߣ䡶̴ʡһۼʷ֮ʱᵽڸ
Dianne Sachko Macleod һƪָڰһ۵Ŀʷֶǵʲõġִ
ʷ֮   μִӢı֤   The Dialecties of Modernism and English Art, British Journal  of Aestheti
cs, p.2,Jan.1995
    2  ءM. ࣺѧ ձ磬1986ꡣ
    3   μ͢ҡܵʵ롰ʷʵ Quantin Bell:The Art  Critic Facts ofFee
lingvs.Facts of History, Artnews, May 1576
    4  Ȼ͹۵˵ аƷ޵ľҿռںһţղزͬƷڸı
Ʒԭλص㡣˸ȤǣѲͬƷпռĹϵһг͵ĶӦʱǷһֱԭλԶʹ
뷴˼
    5   μִԵһ棺ƭ۾ĲݡDonald Preziosi: Modernity Again: The Museum as Trompe Loeil,
in Deconstruction and the Visual Arts, ed. Peter Brunette and David Wills, Cambridge University Press, 1994
    6  μףݵĹܡDaniel  Buren: Functionof the Museum, in Theories of Contemporary Arts, ed.   RichardH
ertz, Prentico-Hall, Inc, Englewood cliffs, New Jersey, 1985
     744  μձ˹򣺡ӿܳJean  ClaudeLebensztejn: Starting Out From the Frame, ( Vignettes ),   inDe
construction and the Visual Arts
    8  μ׾ѧ107109ҳ 磬1994ꡣ
    9 14      μأոˣʫоWalter Pater: The Renaissance: Studies in Art and Poctry,  P. 1
14,P.121, Oxford University Press, 1986
    10  󾭷ǹԪǰ2ʱݹԪǰ350̼޿˹LlochaisһͭġƷܲǹϣ
ܵߣֲʧΪŴܣ¿˶ȼӡ
    1113  ԡڰ׻ѧѧļ56ҳѧ磬1982ꡣ
    12  ŵ˹ʥϵϣٺеһС˵ǰ񼣵ʥ
    15  μɳĬߵΣƽʱںĻĲ͡Simon Schama: The Embarrassment of Riches: An  Interpretation o
f Dutch Gnlture inthe Golden Age,P.401, London, 1987
    16  μ׵¶ͳ˼Max  J.  Friedlander: Reminiscences and Reflection, P.33,Greenwich, 1969
    17  һֶص͸Ӵӽǣ棩еͼΪΡǣѡǶȻӿף
ԭȻͼʹ֮ع鳣̬
    18  μŵǰԡJohn Varriano:   Foreword,Art  History's History, by Vernon Hyde Minor, Prentice  Hall,In
c. Englewood Gliffs,New Jersey,1994
    19   μͼ˵ִͣʷDavid Carrier:Ekphrasis and Interpretation: The  Creation  of Mode
rn Art History,   Principles  of  Art  History  Writing, Pennsylvania  State University Press, 1991
    20  ʵͨӰõľ̵ӡƷ֮Ĳ𣬺߲ԭ֮һ
    21  񣺡ӿķʽJohn Berger: Ways of Seeing.P. 19 London,1972
    222533     μά򣺡ͨӰBarbara E. Savedoff:  Looking  at  Art  Through  Photographs,Jou
rnal of Aestheties and Art Criticism, Summer 1993
    23  أɱͼ񡷣Susan Lambert:  The  ImageMultiplied, P. 16, New York, 1987
    24 µ£򡷣Edgar Wind: Art and Anarchy, 165f, London, 1963
    26  μͨArt Bulletin, P. 521, Dec.  1990
    2728  μ棺еɫʡJohn  Cage:Color in Western Art: An Issue? note 28, Art Bulletin,   Dec.199
0
    29  йر߿⣬ꡣ
    30  ǣ浽Ʒԭλԣꡣ
    3151  μѷͳӴߡNorman Bryson: Tradition and Desire: From David to Delacroi
x, PP. 106 109,3-6, Cambridge University press, 1984
    32   ŵ磺ѧEllen  Winner:Invented  Worlds:   Psychology  of  Arts,   P. 81,   HarvardUniv
ersity Press, 1982
    34  ȱࣺͼ̽E.  Bake  Wellet al: Object, Image, Inquiry: The Art Hitorian at Work.  P.11J
. Paul Getty Trust, 1988
    35  ͬĹϵδ壬Ļǣʹ񰲵УDe Andrea úƫ
ذɫĻҲǡ塱Ϊḻ壺壨壩ӦüǷҷׯصģǰִʥ໯
һʣոʱڵİBaccio Bandinelli ĵƷ硶ƵĬ˹֧ȥҮա1559꣩Ļϵ
ǲݺӵˡ
    36    μΪ֪һԿס Nyeole Paquin: The Frame as a Key to Visual Perception, in Emerging Vi
sions of the  Aesthetic  Process:   Psychology,   Semiology, and Philosophy, ed.  Gerald  C. Cupchik  et  al,   Cambridge Uni
versity Press, 1992
    37  йءܣڡۿΪһֺȵĿ⣺μеĴڡ Carla  Gottlieb:     TheWi
ndow in Art: From the Window of God to the Vanity of Man:  ASurvey of Window Symbolism in Western Painting, Abaris Books,New 
York,1981
    38  µ񡷣1802727գTo Daniel Runge,27 July 1802; Hinterlassene Schrifen 1840-1841, Vol. 1, p.223,
 New Edition, 1965
    39  μ³˹أ»Ρ¼Antonin Proust: Edouard ManetSouvenirs, p.  101,   Paris,19
13
    40     񣺡ѡ Jules  Laforgue:Selected Writings of Jules Laforgue .p. 178, New York, 1956
    41    С ¼ӡ ŵ Ambroise Vollard: En Ecoutant Cezanne, Degas, Renoir, p.107,   Paris, 19
38
    42  μ¡ơϣղϣأִ141ҳ144ҳϺճ磬1989ꡣζǣ
ЩоߵĿִҶԿܵķδǱѴͳΪǡǡЩʽǱڻУƷĹ˼뽨Ľṹ
ǶȡӦνġܡȻǽﱾˡ
    43   ղķ˹Լѷ˹ᡷ 1943 ꣨To  JamesJohnson Sweeny, 1943; The Museum of Modern Art Bulletin,  13,No
. 4-5, p.35-36, 1946
    45  йŵ滭ûĿ⣬ڶ̶Ʃװѵ⣬ʵڻ¡
    46˹̹񣺡˹еĹ۸СLeo  Steinberg: Observations in Cerasi Chapel,Art Bulletin,49, 1957
    47  ŵƷˣִĳ滭Ȼ ȣFernardLeger1952ΪŦԼϹܲĴͳƷΪ 
޴ƴ״Ķϣر˱˴ŽͺУ񰢶ķַǳضĺҲֻ
ϹһвܵõΪֵȷ֤μķRudolf Arnheim: To the Rescue of  Art:  Twenty-Six 
Essays, p.233, University of California Press, 1992
    48  μ᣺ȻʷPliny:  Natural  History,
У  ߡxv.p.65, London, 1961
    49     ѷעӱӵۡNormanBryson: Looking at Overlooked:   Four  Essays on  Still  LifePai
nting,PP. 30-31,Harvard University Press,1990
    50ͨڹϣ糡̨ǲʹνĻģΪʱûĻֶϯ֮Ĺǽֻǵ˹ʱĻ
ŵáϣʽľ糡νĻڸǺͱ任͵ߵȣǶ̨ԡԣ۰͹˹λ
ϣ󻭼ұµĻʱ˺ųֵϷþߣߣɴһŴμ˹ٷҡʵ
ѣӾֺͳStephen  Bann: The  TrueVine:Visual Representation and Western Tradition,Chapter 1, Zeuxisand Parrh
asius, Cambridge University Press,1989
    52١ŵ¡ѧ173174ҳѧֳ磬1987ꡣ
    53ɺʸ񣺡ʽ104ҳ йѧ磬1986ꡣ
    5459ķ
    55ն£ϣе񡪡ˡʫѡϺ֪ʶ磬1994ꡣ
    56˹νʷMark  Roskill: What  IsArt History?PP.105-106,University of Massachusetts Press,1989
    571527֮Ʒ˳ʧɢ˹һЩﰺ
ǲ˹ǲֱͻٸԡǣʱ׿лˡС黭λþ
ԭĹعԭڷʱչ¬֮⣬Ʒһֱٸԣżڽ̽չû㳡ֲٸ
ݡԴˣƷԭλԣ˳λõȣ⡣
    58Ȼͼ־˼·غΣоҲáΪҲǾĺ壬ʥ˵Ϊʹͽ֮ף
Ҳʵ˹νʷ
    60μ÷˹յĿȸҡLinda  Merrill:Whistler's Peacock Room,Smithsonian Institution,1993
    61ĳЩʷодһֿα͵Ϊǿȥ͵ʵã
ظ
    62N.ŵʵԡѧ
    6370A.Ʒѧ
    64˹ἰһʱ䡪Ϊֻʮ깤򡪡ʹαҲòôŷˡǿ
ҵķʽڸı䣬ακƷһɱػʾƵӡǡμνʷ 167ҳ
ƺ̫򵥺ɵĿ
    6567μѧ264ҳ276ҳ
     66 μɽʯ˹͢ڻٷ粨 硷 19945ڡ
    6869μ˹νʷ8¡
    
    
    
 
