뻷
SOIL AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES
1999ꡡ4ڡ8Vol.8No.41999



MetaMetaWin
롡֣Ӣ
ժҪMetaMetaWinMetaWinǵһרΪ̬ѧƵĶMetaṩּģֿ͡ѡĽͳ򵥣һµķǲ鷨ȡ顣
ؼʣMetaMetaWin
ͼţQ141 ױʶ룺A
Introduction of MetaWin Software
PENG Shao-linZHENG Feng-ying
South China Institute of BotanyChinese Academy of SciencesGuangzhou 510650, China
Abstract:MetaWin is the first software of quantitative meta-analysis for ecologists, which includes two hypothesis models and at least two cumulative statistics. It can be performed easily and proves a new non-parametric test, and resampling test.
Key words:meta-analysis; MetaWin; review
̬ѧķչѾɶԹ۲оʵоӱͳľʳȽϴַŵʵȵģCO2ȽΪϸʵ顣
Scheiner1993һ⣺̬ѧʵĿĺڣͨʵĿ֤һһضļ˵ʵϣһʵĽĳһضʱ䡢ص֣Ȼʵ޷һ˵֤[1]Gauseľų۵˵Ĳĳʵ޷֤ġӦ̬ѧ̬ѧԸʵӦͬǰߣһµʵֻҪ̬ϵͳĹΪãںߣӶʵۺݱ޶ôôһʵܶԴȻʾأһʵƶأǶǰоֻ֧ǷأʲôЩʵܹóͬĻ໥ìܵĽأλشЩ⣬̬ѧǳвͬļ⡣
Ȼ̬ѧоظʵǲܵģۺһʵԱҳһԽҲͬҪҲǷǳҪġͳֻԶʵһУ͹˹ûۺϡáżȴΪʧѧԶ⵽̬ѧΪҳһϺõķʱMetaǵǰ
1 Meta
MetaһֶͬһµĶʵ飨оۺϵͳƷѿڱͳ[2]1976ѧҶΪMetaҿڽѧѧҽѧеӦõƪ[3]MetaЩѧƵӦȡ˼ĳɹչ˶ַMannΪҽѧѧоеһθ[4]
ֱ90˷ű̬ѧҷ֣ȻĿǰ̬ѧеӦʵ٣̬ѧĸ߶ӡGurevitch1993˵һ̬ѧеMetaר[5]˺1997귢MetaWin
ҹ루1988״ν˷ҹ̬ѧ[6]ô˷̬ѧ[7]
MetaĿǰҪӦڶʵۺоУĿΪжʵеĴʵЧӦЧӦǴСͬһ²ͬʵĽǷһ£̶ж⡣
Metaһѧ̣ҲһоҪơҪ
ҪⲢƶѼѡ׵ı׼ѼףһǳҹؼĹΪѼȫףͨ;ܵռѷĺδףʽڿеġġժҪԼ˽˽ϵȣ
궨оص㣬зࡣоصĲͬоΪclassȽϡ
оص㡣Ϊ˱ʱȵоͬĽϱ׼·Ĳ׼ȷ˶Metaƶ׼оصдۺооصҲ˳һΪMetaڶMeta
оԷоĻооȵͷѧЧӦֵ֮Эϵ
ĿǰзչֶMetaǵĻ˼һµģǾ裬һͳȻоĽͳڶMeta÷ȥȨĽͳоеļȨƽͳƽУҪͳķȨأоͳԼ顣
MetaĲͬҪڽͳͳƼĲͬ
2 MetaWinص
MetaWinһҪΪ̬ѧƵĶMetaҪص
2.1 ṩּģ
ּģΪ̶ЧӦģͺͻЧӦģ̼ͣ[6]ߵҪǰ߼ۺϵоһʵЧӦСʵʲЧӦСͬȡ£ȴовͬʵЧӦСЧӦСĲͬɣʵЧӦĲͬȡ߸кʵʣƽϱأMetaǻӭ
2.2 ṩֿѡĽͳ
̬ѧڵMetaõĽͳΪHedgesdЧӦֵd =Xe -Xc/S JУXeXcֱΪʵͶĲƽֵSΪ鹲ͬ׼JΪСֵMetaWinṩ˷Ӧȣresponse ratiolnXe /XcXeXcͬϣǴҽѧMetaһֽͳ⣬MetaWinΪMetaΪϤķṩ˸ѡᣬϵcorrelation coefficientȡ
2.3 ṩ뷽ʽ
оķ߿ֱЧӦֵݣʽЧӦݸʽ뷨ĺôڷ߿ɸռ׵ʵԼͳҲMetaWinΪṩ˽ϴɡǰֽͳ£߿ԭеͳݣƽֵСм㣬ȽϷ㣬ԭʼݸʽ
2.4 ṩһǲ顪ȡ
ģͼڼоеʵͶ۲ֵѭֲ̬½еģMetaڴԭʵͶСС10ʱЧӦֲֵ̬̫СʵͶС̫ЧӦֵ̫ʱԭͱò׼ȷ[8]ʵϣ̬ѧ۲ֵȴΥ[9]⣬ֻе豻ʱڼоЧӦԵQֵнƵX 2ֲ[7]ȡ鷨ȡͳͷǲһֺ÷
ȡһּǿcomputer intensiveǲ鷽[10]MetaWinṩ鷨randomization testѥᷨbootstrapǰ߳һͳˮƽڸͳ䡣
MetaWinоЧӦֵÿһȨƽЧӦֵ䣬ΪiÿһǾԷŻʽȡѡȡiоȨЧӦֵȻظȡΣС˳ЧӦֵȡ2.5%ֵΪ5%ޣڵļΪû㡣̫Сʱƹͣʱƫ[9]
MetaWinжϼЧӦСĲǷԭʼQBȻjоһǷֳj𣬼ԭͬQBֵظ˹̶ΣóһQBֵķֲQBˮƽΪQBֵڵʵQBֵռظȡİٷֱȡ
3 MetaWinʹ÷
3.1 MetaWin
MetaWinֻһ̨װWindows95Windows3.1WindowsNTIBMݻй8ļ1MetaWin.exeWindows95WindowsNTµĿִļ2MetaWin.hlpWindows95WindowsNTµİļ3MetaWin.cntWindows95WindowsNTµİļݡ4MetaW16.exeWindows3.1µĿִļ5Meta16.hlpWindows3.1µİļ6Raw.dtaԭͳݵĸʽʾļ7Effect.dtaЧӦСݵĸʽʾļ8Gur-hed.dtaߵʾݸʽļ
Windows95Windows3.1汾Ĳ֮ͬҪоÿһмÿһļоǲеظֵĲͬWindows95Windows3.1Χ㡣
3.2 MetaWinʹ÷
3.2.1 
MetaWinļfile˵edit data file״ֱ̬ڵĴݣҲɴfile˵еload a fileеļԭʼʽ£
sex tree state +/- Nc Ne Xc Xe Sc Se Label
m oak pa + 7 7 78.14 79.71 40.650 40.650 study1
m maple ny + 7 7 18.86 26.00 9.170 9.170 study2
f maple ny - 6 6 -1.80 -2.10 0.490 0.490 study3
УһΪУǰ3Ϊ׼ʵϣWindows95汾10׼Windows3.1Ϊ5+/-ΪڴЧӦֵΪֵʱʵеĴʵЧӦڰڴӦóЧӦֵом+ЧӦֵом-飬ʱʶļймּ׼NeNcֱΪʵͶXeXcֱΪʵͶĲƽֵSeScֱΪʵͶı׼LabelΪоıǡÿһΪһоЧӦݡЧӦʽΪ
sex tree state +/- Nc Ne effect var Label
m oak pa + 7 7 78.0.036 0.286 study1
m maple ny + 7 7 0.565 0.347 study2
f maple ny - 6 6 1.533 0.517 study3
УeffectһΪЧӦֵvarΪЧӦͬԭʼݸʽ
3.2.2 ݷ
ڴMetaWinļͬʱԶһMeta-Analysisڡڴ˴ϲType of Inputһеraw effectȷΪԭʼЧӦʽԭɫData fileͻӵġ򿪡ѡҪļ
Meta-Analysisвѡ̶ЧӦЧӦģͣͳҲظ飻²gourp byпѡ񻮷ּı׼Refine AnalysisпڲıļȥһЩо
Щѡѡú󣬼ɵstart㡣󣬻ԶһMeta-Analysis outputڣʾ
3.2.3 ʾ
ڷУɿʱ䣬Դ·ԼΪParametric methods Meta-Analysis results for groupsǰΪоЧӦֵÿһдһоơСУֵJպʵĹб׼spoolЧӦֵd95%䣨95%CIоķVȨأW
һȼойͬdֵзʱڵڶпɿоƽЧӦֵd++95%䡢ͬԣQwiɶȣdfX 2pֵ伶ԾX 2˵費ȷʱһı׼оΪٽзʱĵڶлʾоļȨƽЧӦֵdi+95%䡢ͬԣQwiɶȣdfX 2pֵԼͬԣQbͬԣQwܵͬԣQtotalͬԣQb˵ĳһͬԣQwi˵һڸоЧӦֵϴӦýһִ˼ٷֱQwi鲻
ʳϵMetaз֣ʳߵ±ʳȺͣd++=-0.3855̶ЧӦģͣd++=-0.4589ЧӦģͣͬ׼ֵļЧӦСв죬ʳЧӦشԶ仯ȴЧӦֵȴ´ҲЧӦȴС̬ϵͳּʱ½̬ϵͳΪЧӦˮ̬ϵͳΪСЧӦ[10]
MetaWinһҹܽȫMetaWindows֧֣ûֱͨӶԻ̼ѧˡźMetaWinûпǶMetaóоֵԭʼֱ뷨ܶЧӦֵоȨءͬʱֵעMetaWinֻṩ˶MetaMetaһоǰҪƣҲԽоһõMetaҪѡõĶҷǰƺͷǳҪΪͳƵĿΪṩѧݡ
ĿȻѧشĿ39899370йѧԺشĿKZ951-B1-110㶫ʡȻѧĿ980952
߼飺루1956Уʿоʿʦ̬ѧңȻѧشĿϯѧңȫһͶ»ߡ
ߵλйѧԺֲо 510650
ο
[1] Scheiner S M. Introduction: Theories, hypotheses and statistics. New York: Chapman and Hall, 1993
[2] Kay D, Jesse A B. Meta-analysis: state of the science. Epidemiological reviews, 1992(14): 154176
[3] ˳. Meta-analysisһµĶۺϷ. йԲԤƣ1993, 1(6):277281
[4] Mann C. Meta-analysis in the breech. Science, 1990, 249: 476480
[5] Gurevitch J, Hedges V. Meta-analysis: combining the results of independent experiments. New York: Chapman & Hall. 1993
[6] 룬С. Meta̬ѧӦ. ̬ѧ־1998, 17(5): 7479
[7] ֣Ӣ. ʳϵMeta. ̬ѧ1999, 9(4): 448452
[8] Hedges L V, Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Orlando: FL Academic Press, 1985
[9] Gurevitch J, Morrow L L, Wallace A, et al. A meta-analysis of field experiments on competition. American Naturalist, 1992(140): 539572
[10] Dean C, Gurevitch J, Michael S R. Resampling tests for meta-analysis of ecological data. Ecology, 1997, 78(5): 12771283
ոڣ1999-01-22
