йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999 2 No.2 1999



ͬӻѧ㷨ڶ໷Ϊṹ-ʹϵ(QSPR)еӦ
¾ġ˧ܡΰȫơѦ֥
ժҪԲMINDO/3MNDOAM1㷨17ֶ໷(PAHs)ǰ߷ӹΪӽṹ,ЩPAHsʳĶṹ-(QSPR)о,PM3㷨õQSPRģͽ˱Ƚ.о,ӦPM3㷨õǰ߷ӹܽЩPAHsʳQSPRϵĽ,AM1㷨,MINDO/3MNDO㷨õĽϲ.
ؼʣӻѧ໷ʳṹ-
ͼţX13 ױʶ룺A ±ţ1000-6923(1999)02-0102-04
The application of different quantum chemical hamiltonians in developing quantitative structure-property relationship (QSPR) for photolysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.
CHEN Jing-wenWANG Shuai-jieZOU Shan-weiQUAN XieXUE Da-mingZHAO Ya-zhi 
(Department of Environmental Science and Technology, School of Chemical Engineering, State Key Laboratory of Dye and Surfactant Fine Chemicals, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116012, China). China Environmental Science.1999,19(2)102105
AbstractMINDO/3, MNDO and AM1 algorithms were used to compute frontier molecular orbital energies of 17 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which were then used as molecular structure descriptors to obtain Quantitative Structure-Properties Relationships for photolysis of the PAHs. The comparison of the obtained models in this study with the QSPR model based on the descriptors derived from PM3 algorithm obtained in our previous study showed that the QSPR results in which the frontier molecular orbital energies derived from PM3 hamiltonian were used, was the best, and the next was the result based on AM1 hamiltonian. The results based on MINDO/3 and MNDO hamiltonians were relatively poor.
Key wordsquantum chemistrypolycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)photolysis rate constantsquantitative structure-property relationships (QSPR)
໷(PAHs)һ͵ĻȾ,PAHs°[1],ˮкѱｵ[1].ǰо,ֽPAHsˮеһҪǨơת;[1,2].Ȼ,ʵⶨPAHsĹҪʵװ,ȷʱ,ӦPAHsлȾΣ۵Ҫ,,չPAHsΪĶṹ-ʹϵ(QSPR)ǳҪ.
ӻѧȷ塢Խ׵ͨáʡʱ;ѡڶԻֵ̽ŵ,ʹ֮ΪĿǰQSPRоһȵ[3].
,ѧоMINDO/3MNDOAM1PM3HFR[3]İ뾭ӹ㷨,ı׼ʹȫʵ(ӵĳɼ).Щӻѧ㷨ȱ,ǶԲͬͻʺϳ̶Ȳͬ[4,5].оMINDO/3MNDOAM1㷨17PAHsǰ߷ӹ,ԻЩ㷨óǰ߷ӹΪӽṹ,չPAHsʳQSPRģ,õQSPRģPM3㷨óQSPRģ[6]Ƚ,ӶɸѡʺϽPAHsʳQSPRоӻѧ㷨.
1 뷽
о17PAHsʳ(kexp)ʵֵ[6]1.ӦALCHEMY۲ӽṹдӽṹļ.ӦMOPAC(6.0)е MINDO/3MNDOAM1㷨[3],Pentium 150MHz (16ڴ)΢Ͻм.MOPACĹؼΪ:MINDO/3(MNDOAM1)PRECISEESPDIPOLEPOLARNOINTERBONDS.MOPAC(6.0 )ڶԷӽṹŻ,õPAHsǰ߷ӹ(2).
1 PAHsʳ
Table 1 PAHs and their photolysis rate constants

logkexp
(ʵֵ)
(100min)-1в=ʵֵֵ
PM3
㷨MINDO/3 㷨MNDO 㷨AM1 㷨
-1.2920.227-0.716-0.727-0.333
-1.222-0.0120.6100.4620.686
0.362-0.1120.2200.243-0.019
-0.1850.5530.1730.2050.368
1-׻-0.785-0.199-0.514-0.441-0.365
2-׻-1.189-0.432-0.821-0.793-0.619
3-׻-0.775-0.213-0.511-0.431-0.370
9-׻1.2120.6771.0001.0440.787
9,10-׻0.8010.2220.5270.5610.347
9-0.5930.07950.3890.4370.167
ʡ0.7080.1580.3150.2290.339
[a]0.4000.01020.2940.3270.076
-0.151-0.210-0.119-0.066-0.241
-0.441-0.024-0.920-1.077-0.476
[a]0.508-0.111-0.1860.1490.049
Ƕ0.182-0.427-0.169-0.216-0.255
[a,h]0.146-0.1880.0550.094-0.143

2 PAHsǰ߷ӹ
Table 2 Frontier molecular orbital energies of PAH s

MINDO/3 (eV)MNDO (eV)AM1 (eV)
Ehomo ElumoEhomo ElumoEhomo Elumo
-8.8841.085-9.3320.253-8.956-0.064
-8.2130.477-8.574-0.332-8.710-0.265
-7.606-0.074-8.049-0.842-8.123-0.840
-8.0500.348-8.480-0.481-8.617-0.409
1-׻-7.9970.275-8.455-0.522-8.518-0.398
2-׻-8.0670.346-8.484-0.477-8.595-0.376
3-׻-7.9960.265-8.4580.525-8.510-0.400
9-׻-7.539-0.172-8.024-0.902-8.007-0.840
9,10-   -7.475-0.273-7.978-0.984-7.890-0.848
9--7.524-0.139-8.024-0.880-8.048-0.884
ʡ-7.226-0.440-7.721-1.185-7.747-1.234
[a]-7.642-0.032-8.114-0.830-8.206-0.813
-7.7830.097-8.261-0.719-8.372-0.674
-7.408-1.293-7.932-1.736-7.879-1.182
[a]-7.344-0.290-7.861-1.088-7.922-1.111
Ƕ-7.272-0.316-7.816-1.118-7.856-1.158
[a,h]-7.647-0.006-8.149-0.829-8.255-0.805


STATGRAPHICS(4.0)лع.øϵ(R)ɶУĸϵ(Radj.)ֵı׼(SE)ķ(F)tֵ(t)ˮƽ(p)ģ͵.
2 
ӻѧԭ,ǰ߷ӹ,ռݹ (Ehomo)δռݹ(Elumo)ǳҪķʲ[3],,Ehomoʾĳ໥ʱӵ,Elumoʾĳ໥ʱܵӵ.ǰ߷ӹ(Elumo-Ehomo)ӳһӵӴռݹԾǨͿչʱĴС.
1996,¾ĵ[6]ԲӻѧPM3㷨óPAHsδռݹ(Elumo)ռݹ (Ehomo)ĲΪӽṹ,״αһ17PAHsʳQSPR.÷̵ʽ,ģϽ3.
logkexp =-32.734+9.769(Elumo-Ehomo)-
0.715(Elumo-Ehomo)2(1)
n =17R2=0.848R2adj.=0.826
SE =0.322F=38.926p =0.0000
3 ģϽ
Table 3 Model fitting results

㷨(Ա)ϵSEtp
PM3㷨
-32.7345.728-5.7140.0001
(Elumo-Ehomo)9.7691.5876.1570.0000
(ElumoEhomo)2-0.7150.109-6.5550.0000
MINDO/3㷨
-4.9077.960-0.6170.5475
(ElumoEhomo)1.7891.9960.8960.3852
(ElumoEhomo)2-0.1490.124-1.1950.2519
MNDO㷨
0.5599.5670.0580.9542
(ElumoEhomo)0.4632.4630.1880.8535
(ElumoEhomo)2-0.0730.157-0.4620.6510
AM1㷨
-28.3899.778-2.9030.0116
(ElumoEhomo)8.3512.6223.1840.0066
(ElumoEhomo)2-0.6040.175-3.4600.0038


(1)عϵ,÷̾нϴϵͽСֵ׼,Ҹ÷̵ֵʵֵӽ(1),˷(1)ӦPAHsʵͬԴµĹʳԤ.Ҿڱ׼֮,(1)Ա֮ϵС,÷̿˷ԱĹ,˸÷ڶPAHsĽ,ʵ,ܺõؽPAHsĹ[6].
ԲMINDO/3MNDOAM1㷨õǰ߷ӹΪӽṹ,ڷ(1)ʽ,ֱоPAHsĹʳлع,õµQSPR,ģϽڱ3.
MINDO/3㷨: 
logkexp =-4.907+1.789(Elumo-Ehomo)
-0.149(Elumo-Ehomo)2 (2)
n=17R2=0.507R2adj.=0.436
SE=0.580F =7.195p =0.0071
MNDO㷨: 
logkexp=0.559+0.463(Elumo-Ehomo)
-0.073(Elumo-Ehomo)2(3)
n=17R2=0.491R2adj.=0.419
SE=0.589F=6.766p =0.0088
AM1㷨: 
logkexp=-28.389+8.351(Elumo-Ehomo) 
-0.604(Elumo-Ehomo)2(4)
n =17R2=0.724R2adj.=0.685 
SE=0.434F=18.363p=0.0001
ɱ3(1)(2)(3)(4),ԵóµĽ:ˮƽ,(1)ˮƽֵС,Ƿ(4)ˮƽֵӷFֵ,(1)Fֵ,(4)Fֵ֮,Щ˵ڵõ4QSPR,(1),Ƿ(4).ӷ̵ĸϵ,(1)ĸϵ,Ƿ(4)ӷ̵ֵ׼ƫSEĴС,(1)SEС,Ƿ(4)SE,Щ˵ڵõ4QSPR,(1)Ԥ,Ƿ(4),ǵʵֵֵ֮ĲвС(1),˵ӦԤPAHsĹʳ.Կ,ӦPM3㷨óӻѧвPAHsʳQSPRоĽ,AM1㷨,MINDO/3MNDO㷨õĽϲ,˵PM3AM1㷨ԸõرPAHsķ.ΪMINDO/3MNDOAM1PM3㷨ʱȺ˳չ[3],㷨˷ǰ㷨Ĳ,ǰ㷨ŵ.
3 
ӦMINDO/3MNDOAM1㷨17PAHsӵǰ߷ӹ,Ϊӽṹ,о17PAHsĹʳлع,õһϵPAHsʳQSPR,PM3㷨õQSPR˱Ƚ.о,ӦPM3㷨óǰ߷ӹܲЩPAHsʳQSPRоĽ,AM1㷨,MINDO/3MNDO㷨õĽϲ.Ϊ,PM3AM1㷨ԸõرPAHsķ.
ĿȻѧ(29807001)ȾԴصʵҿſĿ(Ͼѧ)
ߵλ¾ġ˧ܡΰȫ ơѦ֥ѧѧԺѧ빤ϵ,ȾԼϸϳɹصʵ, 116012
߼飺¾(1969-),,,ѧѧԺѧ빤ϵ,ʿ,ҪлȾĻΪ̬ṹ--ԹϵȾԤȾơȾȷĿѧ.μӹشȻѧĿͻѧȾڻеı仯̬ЧӦо.ҪеȻѧĿлȾΪĶṹ-ʹϵоо.Եһ,ڹSCI﷢10ƪ,ڹںڿϷ8ƪ,μӱдר1.
ոڣ1998-07-08
ο:
[1]Grimmer G.Environmental carcinogens:polycyclic aromatic hyd-rocarbons, chemistry, occurrence, biochemistry, carcinogenicity[M].Boca Raton. Florida: CRC Press,Inc.,1983.
[2]Miller T, Mabey W R, Lan B Y, et al. Photolysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in water[J].Chemosphere,1981,10:1281-1290.
[3],˷.ӽṹ[M].:ѧҵ, 1997.
[4]Baj S, Dawid M. Correlation between the chemical structures of dialkyl peroxides and their retention in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography[J]. Journal of Liquid Chromatography, 1994, 17(18): 3933-3949.
[5]Kass S R.Hydrocarbon acidities calculated with MINDO/3, MNDO and AM1[J]. J. Comp. Chem., 1990, 11(1): 94-104.
[6]Chen J W, Kong L R, Zhu C M, et al. Correlation between photolysis rate constants of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and frontier molecular orbital energy[J]. Chemosphere, 1996, 33(6): 1143-1150.
