йѧ
CHINA ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE
1999 2 No.2 1999



пɳչۼ
СТ졡 
ժҪڳзչݱķ,ȷʵΪпɳչۺָľѧ壻ڵʵ㷽ϵĲ,ص̽ʵοǳпԡԴ۾ɡȾʧĽ綨.л̨ΪԵ,ʵָ˸вͬչʱڵĿɳչˮƽ.
ؼʣУɳչۣʵ
ͼţX196ױʶ룺A±ţ1000-6923(1999)02-0127-06
Environmental and economic appraisal of urban sustainable development.
MA Xiao-mingGUO Xiao-minTIAN Da-qingGAO Li
(1.Center for Environmental Sciences, Peking University ,Beijing 100871,China2.Planning and Financial Department,State Environmental Protection Administration, Beijing 100035,China). China Environmental Science. 1999,19(2)127132
AbstractBased on the analysis of urban development measuring methods at different time,the economic meaning and policy signification of genuine saving was expatiated on as an integrated appraisal indicator for monitoring urban sustainable development. The paper discussed the relative issues about impact of urban openness , time and space range determination on calculation of resource economic depreciation and environment pollution loss within genuine saving,and also appraised the sustainable development level of Yantai City for different years using genuine saving and interrelated indicator .
Key wordsurbansustainable developmentenvironmental and economic appraisalgenuine saving 
10,ҹлļӿ,б¶ҲԽԽ,رԴĽߺͻȾ,ԼųеĽչ.ʶ,Ҫֳзչٶ,Ӧע߳зչ,߿ɳչ·.۳еĿɳչˮƽ,ȳлúᷢչЭ̶,ѳΪйߺоԱעҪ.
1 зչȵݱ
60ǰ,ͨѾõķչչȫ,ԾǷչ, ׷ֵ˾Ѹ, ˾ֵ˾ΪȷչΨһָ.60Ժ,˿ӵͨзȱһϵ,зչۿʼת򡰷չĿữ.õũҵõصìܡ񻯴ʹʼ̽оúЭչĶԲ,ʼʶGNPֻܷӳ,ܷӳƸĹƽ״ĸˮƽ.Ϊȫһľᷢչˮƽ,ϹᷢչоȽһȫָϵ,صоOECDձȹҺ͹֯㷺չ[1].ȽUNDPġķչָ.
80,õѸȫ򻷾Σ,вδķչ,ʹǶԷչ۽з˼.1992Ϲ뷢չԺ,ɳչΪµķչģʽƳ,ɳչСʼΪоߵ׷Ŀ,ɳչ۳Ϊзչָϵ۵ָ˼.
Ϲеȹ֯ƶĸ߶,ɳչָоӦõõ㷺չ.ָصϿ,Ҫͺչ.ָ˵͡ͺۺָ깹ָҺ͵.пʵΪĿǰΪѧĿڿɳչ۵ۺָ֮һ.
2 ɳչĲָꡪʵ
2.1 ʵľѧ
ͳGNPGDPȻ˸ֲͬòŵͷ漰ʱ۾,˾ûĻⲿЧӦȻʱ۾.Դ,Ϊʲľ,ֻǱԴŵľӪӯӵؼʻ.ΪԴľ۾ûھƸļ,ǸõĳȻԴڲϵĺĽ,õľƸȴӰ,ڲ.ԴͳGDPָ겻ܷӳûⲿ,ܹܿߵعʵ,ڿɳչ.
1972,ѧW. NordhausTobinø߶ȡ,ͼͨGNPõøָ.Ӣ׶شѧѧD.W.Pearceͬ¶ɳչΪ:ʱ,ร[2,3].Ӹö,γ˿ɳչо:ʱķǵݼǿɳԵıҪǰ,ֻеȫʱĴʱ䱣һʱ,ַչ;ſǿɳġ.Pearceʱ·Ϊ3:ʱ:,,·ȣʱ:֪ʶ,ܵȣȻʱ:ط,ɭ,ҵԴ,,ʯ,ú,ѧѭ.
1995һ˺ҲƸ·.и𻷾ɳչĸгSerageldinָ:ɳԾǸһ˾Ƹ[4,5].÷ɫ񾭼ú㷶,ͨԺ۾ָһЩ,ûҶһһʱ(˾ʱ)ı仯,ͼӾѧĽǶȥ뷢չĹϵ,ԴжһһķչǷпɳ.
оѧһȻԴͻʲĶʲ۾,ҲӦ뵽񾭼úһɫ񾭼ú˼,һʵĸ[6]
ʵ=ܴ-ʱ۾-ȻԴĽ-Ⱦʧ 
ʵΪһڼҵĿɳչ仯ָ,ߺ:ձؽ¹Ƹļ. Hamiltonʿˡ׼:ʵʱı仯ʴڵ,пֹܱĿɳˮƽ[6-8].
ʵص˵ǻ뾭õ໥ϵ,رǸʱ䶯,ǿǻɳľ÷չ,Ǿ÷չͻ(Դ)ɳ.ʵĴС˿ɳչǱ,ӳ˿δĳ.ʱı䶯,ȻԴı仯ͻı仯ӰȻʲı䶯,ΪпɳչĻۺָ.
2.2 ʵָ
ʵһɳԵĳ߶,ʱͶʴڿ,Ⲣʵḻߺ.ɳԱ׼ǿɳ(ÿʱ)ıҪ.ʵѾ÷չԴϵһ,Ϊɳչߵƶṩ.
2.2.1 ʵͨ¶ʲĸ,ָΪ˱֤Ƹ,ͱԴͻûɱͶ.
2.2.2 ڴתʱ,ʱͶʲӲΨһʽ.ȾԴĿŻȶ¿ɳ.
2.2.3 ʵǿ˶ʱͶ.ͳ񾭼úѾԽѰѴ,ʵѸΪʱͶ.
2.2.4 ʵΪṩ˽ģͷֶ.ҵṹĵӰȾŷˮƽ,Ӱ쵽ʵ,ֵΪҵĵṩ.
3 пϵͳʵ
Ǹ߶ȿŵϵͳ,ҪⲿʣƷҪгķҪڲ͵ϵͳ,̬ϵͳԾ䲻Ӱ.еĿų̶һ뾭ˮƽԴӵϵ, ÷չˮƽԽ,ų̶Խ,ԴӵԽȱ,ҪĿų̶ҲԽ.
ʵĹؼԴûɱͻʲֵ䶯.ԴĽԴʹȫ(Ϊ:ӪӯȥƷʲġ桱)ֵ[9,10],ȾʧȾɱ.
3.1 Դ
еľˮƽԽ,ԴԽ,Խ,ԴǿȺ͹ģԽ.ͬʱ,бӵеԴԽ,бĹӦԽ,ҪԴԽ.
ʵԴĽߵĺӦԳеΪ׼,ֻҪԼпɵԴ,侭۾ɱԼе.ú򽫴ʹԴĳмǿԼԴŻ,ԼǵĿΪ.ŻЧֶպˮƽԴ˰,˰չ,ܴ̼,봢ıʽСſɵı,ʹԴɴﲻˮƽ.˰ƫ,̼߹ؿ,óľ,ԴĲɳ.
3.2 ȾԽת
ȾԽձ,磺Ⱦĳ,תƵ.ͬȾɵӰ̶ȺͷΧ᲻ͬ.
ӰⲿӦ뱾еʵ,ֻҪԼɵȾ,ӰھڻǾ,Ӧ뱾еɫ񾭼ú.ͬ,綨ʱάϵⲿҲӦ뱾,ֻҪǵھûɵĻȾ,Ӱ췢ڵ,ǶδĳӰ,Ӧ뱾ڵʵ.
4 о
4.1 ̨иſ
̨ҹ˵еȳ,شɽ뵺в,ȫΪ13506km2,Ϊ834km2.
̨1995ȾŨˮƽӽҶ׼,г,1990кת.ȾﰴȾϵС,ΪTSPSO2NOx.
ˮȾҪΪʯȾˮȾ.ȻʯȾ𲽺ת,1995ݺ̫ƽ壩ں壩ƽŨȳ.ˮҪȾΪӲȺε,Ӳȳձ,ƽֵ1991Ϊ.
ԹҵΪ,1990ꡢ1995ֱΪ325324t,,β󡢷úռҵ80%. ҵȡ񡢷պͶѻβӼúҳȴʹôʩ,1995,Ϊ15.5%,Ϊ23.98%,ۺΪ50.05%.
4.2 ̨лȾʧ
ѡȡ19901995ݽͱȽϷ.ķΧΪȫΧ,51غ7ؼ.̨ͳ̨лͳ,Ҫ̨Ⱦʧ̨Դ㡢йȾʧ[11].ɱĻȾʧ1.ȾӰֻCO2ЧӦ,Ҫʡ. 
1    Ⱦ  ʧ   (Ԫ/a)
Table 1 Environmental pollution losses

 ĿȾʧֵռʧı**(%)ռGDP (%)
1990 1995
199019951995*19901995
ȾʧAD19381.349953.5534969.4134.6138.121.300.87
彡Ӱ죨ADH8551.5113611.659528.15844.1227.250.580.24
ũҵӰ죨ADA2466.1915542.4810879.7412.7231.110.170.27
ϵӰ죨ADM3788.346002.5624201.79319.5512.020.260.10
Ӱ죨ADY3244.678591.2136013.84916.7417.200.220.15
ϴӰ죨ADC608.5732698.8751889.2133.145.400.040.05
ͻ¹ʵӰ죨ADT21.422.8215.9740.110.050.000.00
CO2ЧӦADB700.6383483.9382438.7563.626.970.050.06
ˮȾʧWD33641.175718.7153003.160.0857.792.301.41
ˮֳӰ죨WDC27254.358991.4241293.9981.0277.911.831.02
ҵӰ죨WDI6365.8416694.4411686.1118.9222.050.430.29
ʧWDS568.7775246.9843672.8891.696.930.040.09
ͻ¹ʵӰ죨WDT20.932.8522.9950.060.040.000.00
ʧSD2974.475355.5323748.8725.314.090.200.09
ռأSD12974.475308.633716.04110099.120.200.09
ͻ¹ʵӰ죨SD246.9016132.831130.000.880.000.00
ȾʧD355996.9131027.891719.45100 100 3.77 2.28 

ע:*ʾ1990ΪĲ۸ **ADWDSDָռʧD3İٷֱ,Ϊ,ռӦʧADWDSDİٷֱ
ɱ1ɼ,19951990,Ⱦʧֵ,ռGDP½,дˮ͹ʧռGDPı½.˵ȻȾʧ,СGDP.
4.3 Դ۾ɵĲ
Դ۾ɵĲҪ˸ء԰غˮԴĻɱ. ûֹľ۸񷨼Դ۾ɼ2.
2 ̨ʵָĲԪ/a
Table 2 Genuine saving and relevant index of Yantai City

 Ƶ۸ֵռGDP(%)
199019951995*仯(%)19901995仯(%)
GDP (Y)148.53575.70402.99171.321001000.00
(C)73.00243.76170.63133.7449.1542.34-6.81
Ͷ(I)49.70250.95175.67253.4533.4643.5910.13
ͷ񾻳(X-M)25.8380.9956.69119.5017.3914.07-3.32
̶ʲ۾(D1)5.8761.9043.33638.393.9510.756.80
Դ۾(D21)29.5843.9432.058.3519.917.63-12.3
ȱˮľʧ(D22)1.394.092.86106.220.940.71-0.22
Ⱦʧ(D3)6.9917.2012.0472.234.712.99-1.72
Խ֧(E)1.644.242.9780.871.110.74-0.37
ֵ(NDP)142.66513.80359.66152.1196.0589.25-6.80
ɫֵ(gNDP)106.09452.66315.57197.4671.4378.637.20
ܴ(GDS)75.53331.94232.36207.6450.8557.666.81
(NDS)69.66270.04189.03171.3646.9046.910.01
ʵ1(ESg)64.06256.94179.86180.7643.1344.631.50
ʵ2(RSg)38.69222.01154.12298.3226.0538.5612.51
ʵ3(Sg)33.09208.90144.94338.0122.2836.2914.01
Ͷ(EDI)51.34255.19178.64247.9334.5744.339.76
ʵ(EGS)34.73213.15149.20329.5623.3937.0213.64

ע:* 1995ΪĲ۸
4.4 ̨ʵʵĲ
ΪͻȾԴĽ߶ʵӰ,GDPΪ̨ʵ,ʵ1ָ۳Ⱦʧ(D3)ʵʵ2ָ۳Դ۾ɺȱˮʧ(D21+D22)ʵʵ3ָ۳D21+D22D3ʵ.仯ʰղ۸.2ʾ. ӱ2ɼ,̨еʵ3(Sg)ϸ,19951990д,199033.09Ԫ1995144.94Ԫ.ռGDPıҲ22.28%36.29%,14.01ٷֵ.ǵʱͶ,ʵ(EGS)13.64ٷֵ.
SgESgRSgٶȶϿ,GDPٶ,ΪD3D21D22ռGDP½,رD21½12.3ٷֵ.RSgESgֵҪС,˵Դ۾ɵôڻȾ.
19951990SgΪ338.01%,ֻ171.36%,SgռGDPı14.01ٷֵ,ռGDPıȴ0.01ٷֵ.ҪΪ̶ʲ۾ɵıܿ,Ϊ638.39%,D21+D22D3ռGDPı½,˵̨ھ÷չͬʱע˱,ʹ񻯵ٶԶԶСھ÷չĳ̶.Ҳ˵SgȾʵطӳԴı仯.
ܴΪ207.64%,СSg,Ǵھ.ҪΪֻܴӳGDPѵĹϵ,ûпǹ̶ʲ۾ɺͻ.
gNDPʽΪ197.46%,ԶСSg338.01%,ٴ˵gNDP,SgܽطӳԴֵı仯,һܽϺõĿɳչۺָ.
4.5 ۺ
ʵ3 (Sg)Ϊۺָ,̨ʵ199033.09Ԫ1995144.94Ԫ.ռGDPıҲ22.28%36.29%.,gNDP˾GDPͶʵȺ۾ָ궼нϴ.˵̨еĻᾭ÷չˮƽ,˵,ǿɳ,ھáᷢչͬʱʹȾԴĵõʶȵĿ,֤δչǱ.
̨зˮԪֵŷ,ԭúˮȵԪֵ,̨еԴЧʺȾʶкܴ.,ӾֵϿ,̨зˮ͹ŷԴ۾ɺͻȾʧ,˵̨еľ÷չһʱ,Ҳ˵,һ̶ϴԾòĸֲԴĴ۵.,̨бҪǿȾԴͶ,ԼȾŷԴЧ,̨֤еĿɳչ.
5 
5.1 лָϵ񾭼úָԶԶɳչҪ,ֻ뾭໥õйϵ,Ϊƶṩ򵥡ȷĿɳչȵϢ.
5.2 ʵһڼҿɳչȵۺָ,ߺǳձؽ¹Ƹļ,Ҫֿɳ,ʵҪ.
5.3 ȾʧԴ۾ɵʵеҪ. һľϵͳ,ڳʵĲҪǳеĿ.Դĵļ㷶ΧڳзΧڿɵԴ,ȾʧָзΧڲȾںɵӰ.
5.4 ̨1995ʵռGDPı
199022.28%36.29%,˵̨еĻᾭ÷չˮƽ,˵,ǿɳ,ھáᷢչͬʱʹȾԴĵõʶȵĿ,֤δչǱ.
ߵλС졡 򱱾ѧѧ, 100871
߼飺С(1962-),,,ѧѧĸڡ˶ʿ,Ҫ»滮GISңӦо.Ⱥɹ֡ϲϵȳл滮ȫɭֲ溦ϢϵͳĿ.ʡƼ3.20ƪ.
Т񡡹һֹܾ滮˾, 100035
ոڣ1998-08-31
οף
[1]ν.йָʵ [M].:йͳƳ,1989.
[2]Pearce D W, Atkinson G.Capital theory and the measurement of sustainable development: an indicator of weaksustainability [J]. Ecological Economics,1993,(8):103~ 108.
[3]Pearce D W, Warford J J. World without end: economics, environment and sustainable development [M]. Oxford University Press, 1993.
[4]World Bank.Monitoring environmental progress: a report on work in progress [M].Washington D.C., 1995.
[5]Serageldin I. Sustainability and the wealth of nations: first steps in an on going journey [M].Environmentally sustainable development studies and monographs series No.5.World Bank.1996.
[6]John Dixon,et al.Expanding the measure of wealth: indicators of environmentally sustainable development [M]. Environmentally sustainable development studies and monographs series No.17.World Bank,1997.
[7]Hamilton K. Green adjustments to GDP [J].Resources Policy, 1994,3:155- 168.
[8]Hamilton K, Atkinson G. Air pollution and green accounts [J]. Energy Policy, 1996,24(7):675- 684.
[9]Hamilton K. Unpalatable choices: valuing subsoil assets [R]. World Bank, 1996.
[10]Hamilton K. Greening the national accounts: valuation issues and policy uses [R].World Bank, 1996.
[11]Т,Ż.Ԫ2000йԤԲо [M].:廪ѧ,1990.
