 ׺ 2-1590
ԭĳƾо
ԭںš200004
  šF63
  Ͷ֤ȯ
ӡںš200005
    ʱ뾭ĭγ
Ӣı⡿The Operation of Fictitious Capital and the Formation of Economic BubblesLIU Li-fengMacroeconomic Research Insti
tute,Beijing 100037,China
    
߼顿  ۾оԺ  Ͷо  100037
Ҫʱ䲻ͬʵʱص˶켣̶ӣ۸䶯ԽԽʵʱ
ڼֵȡ֤ȯгϵĽ״ȡ֤ȯгͶߵԤġֶʱԤںԶȶʵͶʵ
ԤںôȷԸǿʱʵʱöࡢö࣬ʱĭʽڵġҹƺ
ƶڽϴ̶Ͼʱ򾭼ĭĴ̡ĭֵֵĹͣĭԾõӰǶ෽Ͷ
ġ
ӢժҪFictitious capital is different from tangible capital in both operational character and movement trails.Along wi
th the increase of the extent of fiction,its values are quite different from the inner values of tangible capital which it r
epresents,but mainly depends on exchanges in the stock market,and depends on the expectations and confidences of investors.F
ictitious capital exists in the shape of bubbles.The nature of economic bubbles is the over -inflation of fictitious values,
and economic bubbles have various kinds of effect on the economy.
  ʡFictitious capital/Economic Bubbles/Financial Crises
    
    ʱָʵʱġûмֵġȡһȨƾ֤ƱծȯҵƱݺת֤ȯ
ʵʱԭģмֵڶʱļ۸ʵʲֵҲ
ԴʵʲֵһǮֵʱ˶ɾ˾Сĭγ벻ڴٽ
ûԾͬʱҲ˽뾭ȶԵѹһĽ뾭ÿϾս
    һʱ˶
    Ҫʱ˶Ҫȷ⡣һʱǷʵʱ룬Զ˶켣
Ƿʵʱö࣬öࡣ
    ʱ԰̶Ȳͬз࣬ͬʱʵʾûĹϵͬ˶Ҳв졣˼ʹù
ʱһʡָʱĵһʵʱ֤ȯ֤ȯֻʵʱĴûмֵȴмֵġƷ
ָһʱ˫شڡڶָԭ֤ȯٴ֤ȯκмֵĶָһʱ˫
ϵĴڣءصȵȵĴڡ
    ˾ƱծȯǴͳϵʱʵʲϵΪеʱڹ˾йƱĳϣʱ˫شڣһ
еʵʱĸ̬ϣʱʱƷʱһ棬ִڹƱ̬ϡǰ
ʵʷֵֵõʵʱǰģûмֵģһŵĶԹɷʱԤڿɵùϢȨ֤顣
⣬ƱùϢ⣬ܵõ۸񲨶ļ۲棬Ϊļֵֵ̡˾ծȯƱơ˼ծ
ȯҲʱһʽǿҵƱծȯҷеծȯＯʽ⣩ԭеʵʲ
ûϵңɹծＯʽҪĹѣĽ̷õȣΪѵһĵˣ
ֵֵ̡ծȻ԰涨ƾеĹծӹһһϢ߰һ۸֤ȯгϽծۡɼ
ծǰۺͬʵʱûκϵģҲûмֵģǿɻһϢȨ֤飨һ
ֵֵʱȨ֤飩ʱԸԲˡ
    ˵԰ѽʱΪʱע˼˼˹ȫ[M].磬1975.25526-533.
ΪڽʱĳϣᷢʱĶشڡԣһֽҴڵ£ʵʱġûмֵһ
ڣһⶼʱʹʵңңڵ£ͬһҷʱҲֻڵһΪмֵ
ҴڵģڶĸҲ˼ֵš£ʱĴ󲿷Ҳʱ
    ߼ʱʽָʲ֤ȯҵ񣬼һЩõȼ֤ȯһ飬ϸõȼ֤ȯΪѺеծ
ȯ·е֤ȯԭ֤ȯĻϷеģʱʱʲѺ֤ȯﻯʲǼӴһʴ
ʽﻯʲļֵ٣ݴ˷еծȯȴżֵֵ£һֵͬʵʲ޹أΪʵʻ
ֻ˵򻹿йءƷʱʱĻԶԶʵʱĻۣĽ׾СܸЧӦ
ֽױȽٵı֤渶ܽо޶ˣƷγɺͽĽĭԶʱԭʼ̬öࡣ
    ʱĻҪԶԶʵʱĻۡһΪֶͨεһԪֽܹýһԪƷӶʵֶԪƷ
һһԪʱҲԶִнʱְܣӶΪԪʱע˼˼˹ȫ[M].棬
1975.25530-531.ڶΪʱ֤ȯ۸ͬϢʵĸߵͳɷȵġƽʵ½ֱȻʹϢ½
һҲʹʱԭĻϽһΪƷʱļ۸мͶԣ¶˹϶
Ĺ۵㣺֤ȯӪҵͶںܶ½ܽһ𣬺˵ӪҵĵֹͶһ㿪ʼע˼˼˹
ȫ[M].磬1975.25458.Ͷϵʱļ۸о˵˼ּ۸Ϊ
õġݡʱ˶Ȼʵʱ˶ģȻԺΪġˣʱĹͣȻ¾
ĭѡȻʵʱļֵȴǻΣıʱƷʵΣͼ۸Σծȯ
Ʊȥͼ۸񱩵ⷽĵӡ
    ҪָʱĹͣȻĹͣٽʣΣıʣľΣҲǴٽ
ΣĻ
    ʱ˶;ĭγ
    ʱγɾĭأʱͱʵʱöࡢö࣬ʱĭγɴڵġ
ʱļֵֵеһ֡ϢϢʵʾùԼģһ֡۸񲨶롪ȡǷ㹻Ļҹ֧
֡ʱγĭʱҹ֧־͸Ҫҹƺƶڽϴ̶Ͼʱ򾭼
ĭĴ̡
    һҹ
    Ϊ׵ĻȡʵʹˮƽͶĻˮƽġ˹ͶĻ
ϵ˹ǵĲƲʽծȯ֮ѡģծȯ۸(V)ծȯ(R)(i)֮
Ĺϵйʽ
          V=R/i
    ծȯ۸ծȯͬ䶯ʷ䶯ͶĲծȯ۸ʵֹϵ˹ǿԤڵã
ͶıҪǡǶ֮ǰ;òȷע˹ҵϢͻͨ[M].꣬1957.1444.
˵Ʋ߶δʵĸߵһȫˮƽĸһԤڡʵڰȫˮƽƲ߾ͻԤδ
ʽȫˮƽˮƽɵͱʱծȯ۸µծȯҪծȯ۸µծȯֵٶʲʧ
ҪծȯлҡˣʵʱͶĻʹ󡣷֮ʸʱͶĻС
ҹӣ벻䣬Ʒû䣬гϻҹڻĻ
֤ȯгʱһҹ½֤ȯ۸һ棬ڻ֧֣ſ
֤ȯ۸ʱ㹻Ļȥ򡣻ҹ֧ļ۸ֵʹԶԶʵʼֵֵӶĭע
񣮴ʱ⾭[M].ϣɽ磬1998.70-79.ҹһ֧ʵʼֵֵһҲ֧
ֵֵӵĻҹΪ֣һֽƷгʹ۸ˮƽϢ½ˮƽߣܲԼʵʹ
ߣһֽ֤ȯгʹ֤ȯ֤ȯгĻ֧һģͶ߹֤ȯͶ߲
õϢϢ룬Ҳܻ֤ȯ۸ǵĲ룻˵Ѿʵļֵֵڼ۸
ӵ޹أ֤ȯ۸Ժ󣬾Ͳ˼۸ֵĭڻҹʱ۵ǣҲ֤ȯ۸ǡ
ͬ˵֤ȯͶ߱סʲֵӸ֤ȯгչ֤ȯرǹƱ۸ǳˮƽ
    ƶ
    ƶйûʽûùߵܳơƶȵķչΪĭγɺͷչṩʵһ
ûģṹı仯ٽʱѸ͡80֤ȯкͽҵϵеĽڻͶС֤ȯ˾
ֻ𲻶׳󡣸ڻķֹ𲽱ƣ໥侺ңٽ˽ʲģѸ󡣵ڶƶȵķչ
ùߵѸٷչΪ־ġҵеƱͻƱеƱ֡ѺͳͶʣӹȨծȨڲƷ
Ȩ͵ڽ׵ڲƷڹߴ²ϳ֡ЩڹԲӣģ޴ǿͻƹҵ
ƣγͶ񳱺͹Ⱦĭʷʽ໥͸໥ãΪͶṩ˷㣬ٽ˽ʱͺ
ĭγɡҪľлֱӲ֤ȯͶʣΪ֤ȯṩʱʽ֤ȯгΪĳЩͶ
гȡ¢Ҫ
    ĭ
    һһ
    ݡ׷ڴǵ䡷(1992)ᷨĭָһУһֻһϵʲ۸ͻȻļ۸
Զڼ۸ԤڣӶµߣܵͶ߸Ȥʲõ棬ʲ;ӯ
ʲ۸ͨԤڵķ仯۸Ѹ½յ½ΣԼɪ˹ٸ(Joseph E. Stiglitz,19
90)ڡĭۡעJournal of Economic Perspectives,Volume4,Number2,Spring 1990.13-18.һΪͶߵԤ
ڰһַʽ仯δĳʲԸļ۸ʱʲʵ۸ͽˣܶĭ
ֲͬĿֱĽǣ۸ԭΪͶ۳۸ߣȴƺ
Լ۸䶯Ӱ죬ôĭʹˡ
    60۵ķʱڣһЩѧֹ̽гܷȷĭԼÿһĭǷնѡڱΪȫ
Ԥģ͡(Perfect foresight models)У(F.H.Hahn,1966)Ѷɭ(Paul.A.Samuelson,1967)֤ȱϵеڻг
ܹչ޵Ľ£ûκһгܹ֤òĭѡģУЧʵġġ(L
ong lived)Ͷ߿лʱ£Ӷ̴ĭÿһĭնѡעJoseph E.Stiglitz,Symposium on Bubbl
es,Journal of Economic Perspectives,Volume 4,Number2,Spring 1990.ģУʲ۸䶯ǳҪʲ۸ٶ
ӵı仯ôʵĽǶȿռ۸ĸߵѾòҪˡ£ʲֵضպõʲֵ
ʱĭҲͲڡͶ߲޵ģгϵҲṩһʹĭ־ôڵʵϣͶ˽⵽֤
ȯгĭ2000ѣĭһ1999ѾˣΪû֪һ۸񽫴»߼۹֤ȯ
ǵĻôĭͲܴˡ
    ĭΪѧǰۣдۣѾĭһֽھʵ徭õƫ룬Ԥغ
ΪϢؾ˾ĭγɣȴõѧҵĹ㷺Ͽɡ
    ĭĲ
    йĭУѧǷּĭʵڲסѵڵݿԽʱʱڼ۸ܷܺõյ
۸ڼرһ£ȱԶδݵ£ѧʹȷ۸ֵʵĻûֵԭģ
һֻĭʵʹɼ۵Ĺ۲¼ɼƫ۸ĳ̶ȣԴΪĭԤָꡣڹƱгϣӯ
ʣP-EֵǷӳĭγɵҪָ꣬ӯԽߣĭԽпγɡP-EֵʵǹƱԼ۸񣬿ֱ۵طӳƱмӯ
ˮƽѽڵжϹƱ۸ԵҪָ꣬ҲǶԽĭжҪָꡣӰгӯʵغܶ࣬Ҫ
гľ÷չǱгˮƽгƱձнϺõķչǱʸߣˣгȳг
ӯʸߣǣггϵгƣҵƶȱԣгӯʾ쳣仯ӶӰ
гĭжϡ
    ָƱгĭ״"Q"ֵָ˾ʲĹмֵͬüֵ֮ȡQֵԽζڹϹһ˾
Ͷʽһ˾ԳɱԽߣ½϶ͶʣĭγɿԽ󣻺(Dividend yield)ǺԹƱ۸֮
ʹ˵Ʊ۸ߣծ(Bond yield)֮ҲǺƱ۸Ƿߵһָꡣ⣬۾
ĭĴҲýر(FIR)ͽʲ۸GDPıʵָӳĭĺ
    ƱгĭҲԿһʱڣƱֵʴGDPʲˣʵ֤УùƱֵ
GDPʵıֵĭϵĭϵ1ʱ˵Ʊгĭɷ֣ĭϵС1ʱƱгͬĭ
ֻʱĭǸġѧڶԶҹƱгĭϵķΪڳгĭϵ2-4֮Ϊ
˵ķչй˵ʵߣһԴﵽгעĿȣƱгĭΧѡ[J].Ͷ
1999(6).֮ͻߵĭϵھõĽչĭҲҪһ޶ȡһĭûУ
׵ĻԾĭؾеķء
    ĭѵ
    ʲôĭŻأĭõγɺͷչ̾һֻҪݹеκһڳⶼʹ
ĭѡ
    һӳԶʹûκ¹ʷеĻԽԽΪ׷󣬱Ȼȡʽ
ֿܣһгʹ׼㣬нṹ񻯡һ׳ϵͳΣ
ʽԴݽߣʽҲͶͶȻʹ˥ˣʧҵڽóϳͶ
ĸ߶Ȼʽǿžãⲿʽ룬ڶʹĭ÷٣һ紵ݶʽ
ӣᵼϵͳıڶǶδԤֵ仯Ͼͻжĭ÷չĴݹ̡ʹԤֵ
仯ԭпھϵͳڲҲϵͳⲿĭóʱ䳤ǶͶĳرʵԤֵԽߡ
ԤֵԶԶľûʶѾﵽʱҲһС¼ͻʹǵԤڷشı䡣
ĿʵﾭûãĭѵĿԽСΪĭĸԤɺ򻵵תĺ۾û
ͶܹڻԤڣ֤תᷢĭھôӾתۡ
    ġĭԾõӰ
    ȣĭ͵ʱ򣬽ͶʵʻԶԶʵͶʵʣʽʵʾгͷز
гȾĭǣʱһ棬ɶʹӣÿʼţʵʾǵ
ӣһ棬ƱгʼԾǶԹƱͶʵԤߣɼ۲ĭ֡ʵʾ⾭
УʵĲᵼʽı仯ʱԤڵԤڵķһͬЩĭͲӰʵʾá෴
ԤڵԤڵķʱͻ֤ȯ뷿زгĭʽ⾭ò
ʵﾭòͶʽ𹩸㣬ծǷΥԼ֣ҵƲƵ
    ΣҵĲֽһӰϵͳʹڻƲڽڻͬҵ֮临ӵծծȨϵ
ڻʡʱڻӳ𼶷Ŵ󣬴ӶʹϵԷռӾ磬ֲԻȫԵĽΣ
ĭʹڻʲ֮ӶӰڻŴͶʻʹľӪʲ
ʱڸǣĭʱźرڹƱʲռҪλõĽڻˡ
    ٴΣͨĭñ֮ڻγɴʣΪ˽ȫڻľӪڼܲžȡƴʩٽڻ
ݹйʱʵĹ涨ѹʲΪָķʲҪ󣬽ڻܵѡǾܵؼŴռ
شѹģ˲ɱػнְܵ˥½һŴή⽫ʹҵɺ۾õ

    Žȫ򻯵ķչĭйʴЧӦĳľĭѽͨϵԤڵȷʽӰ
ҵľȶ磬һĭѣùҵڻͶӰùĽó׵ķչӶ
عҵͶ˥;½ڿֻĹʴݣܱ߹ҽгɹʽϵеıڳֽ
Σı
α༭Թ
 
