 ׺ 2-576
ԭĳÿѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200002
ԭҳš1521
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200007
    ڹȨľ÷
    
߼顿ѧ⻪ѧԺ  100871
    
            һ
    κһᶼƷòƷβƷòƷ˽˲Ʒ빫Ʒֵ
һƸβƷбΪȨֵƸ
    ΪõĲƷй㷺ĺ塣εƷҲεΪβƷȨҲй㷺ĺ塣
ȨҲ˾ȷȨ磬ɡƶȨ߰䲼ȨȨȶβƷ֮ͨ
ͶƱ˾ι̶νβƷЩινĳЩϵǿԣ
ȨһʱʾβƷעȨpower ڲͬожǲһġѧȨںΪ
ضȨĶǣȨԤЧB.   Rusell,Power:  New Social Analysis,London:George Allen and Unwin,1938
,P.25 ֶʵǽȨȼȨȰԼȨ־Ŀƣѧо򣩣ְ
ȻȻѧо򣩣һˣһȺˣһˣһȺˣĿᡢѧо򣩡
ѧҶȨĶںҲǱȽϿġ磬ΤȨΪϵĳΪܹĳ־зҲҪ᳹Լ
־ĵλϵĿԣM. Weber,   Economy  and  Society,   threevolumes, G. Roth and C.Wittich, eds,  New  York:   Bedminister
Press, 1968, Vol. 1, P.53 Ӱѧ֮һصĶǣȨڲƽ䶯ϵ໥б෽
õĶȨ֮ԵڲΪΪ޴M.Foucault, The History of Sexuality, Volume 1:An 
Introduction, New Your: Vintange Books, 1980, PP.93,94.˵ѧȨָ˶ˡᡢȻ
緢ӰôѧȨָϵӰĸŮɷӡ쵼
ӰѧҶȨ֮СȻ,ЩĶڱķҪﵽĿĶǲҪġĶȨĶ
ӽѧɭ˹Ȩĸɭ˹,ȨһڴٽһּԴ(T.Parsons,Politics a
nd Social Structure,New York,The Free Press,1969,PP.185223ɭ˹صȨҲȨɭ
˹ķͬǱǴӾѧǶȶǴѧĽǶȶȨз
    ƷҪԴԴԴԴָʱءͶҪأԴָȨҪ
רͶ룬λ˾μҵȡԴҪͶ뾭ԴŵԱԴһ
ֻβƷȨòƷ
    ԴھòƷΪԴĲƷȨȴܳΪòƷһͶҪءǣ
òƷͶҪأءʱͶҵҲܵȣȨβƷͶ롣ȨΪòƷһ
ͶָȨֱӽƷֱֶ̣Ӷ֯ǶȽȨߵ
һֲƷQΪQfR[,e]R[,w]R[,e]ΪԴR[,e]ΪȨR[,w]һԱR[,w]ףR[,p]R[
,e]ݣR[,p]ΪԴȨֱӽ̣ȨɾòƷͶءעɼٶǿԶһ
б߼ʱڲͬĲƷͶĲͬ׶Σ߼ʱģֵǲͬġǲƪо
һԸֲͬƷı߼ʱģϸַֻһƪרŵչ
    ȨھûĸԤȨΪòƷͶġȨھûĸԤ京ǿġȰֱ
ĸԤֱȨԴƷְӸԤͨƶߡָ淶徭õλĻȨ
ΪòƷͶȨھûֱӸԤκһУгĳ̶Σһ־ûȫ
ȨԼҪܵ÷ԼǲͬᣬȨھøԤĳ̶ȲͬԤķʽҲͬǾȨھû
ֱӸԤԣͬĹұֳܴĲ졣
    ǿԴӷɡ뾭ߡԼֱֶ֯Ͻ綨ȨھõĸԤ̶ȡԳ̶ɸ
͵ΪԼ뾭ָ΢ֱֶ֯ӸԤһҪƷ
úܳ졢гûƺƵĹҶԣȨھõĽҪΪӵĸԤҪԤʽͨ淶
ΪھûԸԤ޶ȣȨֱֻ֯ڹƷ򡣶һгûƲƵĹҶ
ȨھûĽҪΪԤֱӸԤ㷺ڡҵ̶ͬȵָ֧ܵ䡣
    һھûⲿԡڹƷȫľöԣ˷⣬κʽȨ붼ή;ûЧ
ʡһгⲿ빫ƷȨ뾭ûΪĽԴЧʵһֶΡھûеⲿӰ췶ΧСӶ
ͨ˽˼Э鷽ʽⲿԵĽ׳ɱС£ȷȨĻͨ۸ƾⲿԡעοR. H.   Coase,
"The Problem of Social Cost", Journal of Law  and   Economics,October 1960,PP.144.߽١ģСĹƷҲͨ
۸Ƶ乩󡣣עοE.Berglas,"On the  Theory   ofClubs",American Economic Review,May 1976,PP.116121. ǵ
ûⲿӰ췶Χϴ󡢽׳ɱ̫ȷȨʱƷߺܶࡢģϴʱͨг۸
ⲿԡƷ£ԾûʵʩĳʽȨԤʹԴõЧʵõĽⲿҪȨ
ӸԤĹƷҪȨֱӸԤ
    гûƲƵľУȨ뾭ù̲ڳ˾ûⲿ빫ƷȨȡг۸
ԴáƵгûȣԴ÷ʽЧʵġΪȨҲҪķѾԴġͨһ
־ԴõλȨḶһʻɱʹȨֱӸԤûԴü۸Ƶ
ûȫͬ棬ȨԤͨҲǲֵõģΪȼ۸Ƶĵڶһ̣ȨḶ́
ķһɱֻȨֱӸԤûܴ治ͨ۸ƵĵڶʱȨֱ
뾭ûֵõġ԰ȨֱӽľûΪһػصľûȨһмƷΪһͶվ
ƷûȨֱӽľûΪһֱӵľûֻеػصľûľ棨ɱ
ֱӾûľʱػصľûֵõġ
            
    뾭òƷβƷƷӦггҪƷгԼггָȷ΢Ϊ
ȨĻϣͨƵԴƷơƷҪг漰ƷҪع⣻г
漰ȨĹ⣨עӾѧǶȷгʼڲˣJ.M.Buchanan and G.Tullock, The Calculus ofCon
sent. Ann Arbor:University of Michingan Pree 1962. һΪѡѧɵѧ̳뷢չǹѡѧɵľѧ
ҲûȷضȨ˲ȨĽǶȷгҪƷгϣڿȷ綨
ҪƷȨ˿ͨ۸ƵƷԴáʲô٣г۸ĵڡ
гϣԴƷȨͬƷҪءʲô٣ͨһ׻Ƶڡ
    гͶԴԴ⣩ĲƷǹеģȨ綨ȷλ˾
κθ˻СȨǹѡĽȨڲһѡĹСڸ˾ѡɵ£
֮Ҫһ־ԴͶȨȨµľûΪÿһ˻˶ʶ
ڷɢĸѡ£˵ĳЩƫòͨ˽˲Ʒ㡣ֻͨĹѡʹⲿƫõõ㡣ͨι
ȨǹѡĽͨȨĹƷʹֻ˽˲Ʒƫõõ㣬ȨΪ
в㹫ƫõʹµȨǲܽ׵ġһȨۣͲΪУǹڵȨˡ
    ȨĲɽԱԾƷȨβƷۡü۸ƵԴβƷ
䡣гĻƲͬڵҪƷгĻơڴٽгЧҪĻ棬г
ƷҪгͬģ˵ٽƷҪгЧ߱ĻȷȨ뱣־ô޷ȷԴ
βƷȨ£ڴٽгЧʾΪҪ
    гľָԴãλ쵼˵ĲβƷĲ編ĵİ䲼
ߵƶȶҪͨͶƱķʽһ޳ɻ޳ɵĹԸֱλ齨򳷲ĲþԸλѡ˽
ɸѡԸֱѡߡоʹԴõĽȨȫڵԸͨͶƱ
ԴβƷķʽͨͶƱþԴòƷķʽͬҵľƣʹȨĹﵽƽ

    гЧľÿһβƷܵȨӰ˶Ȩעŵ˹ϢƶȽṹ˴ﵽ
гЧ״̬ĸ1 гӰ˶ܵӰȷϢ2һϢԴˣ3
ԸݾѡƱмȨ߲4 ܹ㹻Ľ׳ɱ½У Douglass  C.    North,       Institution,
Institutional Change and  Economic  Performance,     CambridgeUniversity Press,1990,PP.107109.ŵ˹ͨг
Ч֤¹ŵģƶȷıҪԣûгľͬԸ
С߸ԼҪԲ˽˲Ʒ˽˲ƷäĿһɹڸҪͬѵȨҲ
ȨäĿԡȻλľ÷ÿһȨĲܵһȨӰе˲ͶƱ
׳ɱʮ־˵ġʵУκһңĳ̶жߣʹÿһȨͨȫ񹫾ķʽֽ
ΣܹλĽ׳ɱͬʱܱгЧгǴѡѡʽѡٺѡ
ѡͬƵηгľѡΪѡĴùȨ
    µһҪȨȨʹˡȫ幫ͬӵеȨֱͨáȨͨ
ѡߡμֱáִɷҵҵƶȡҵƶвƲȨƲӪȨǷġ
ƶϵԾ˴´ִɷҵڵƵίˡ˵⡣ѡ˻μǴˣڻ
ѡίˡί׷ĿĲ˲һί˵ͼ£гϵίСϵп
ص⣺ȨȨƷ
    ȨָڲȨȨӾ÷ĽǶȽȨָȨõı߼ɱڱ߼
гһֱӵǴȨɱȫ幫ÿĳɱۺϹ
ڽǹͬӵеȨֱھûʱʹȨõı߼ɱڱ߼棬ʹȨЧôﵽ
󻯡Ȩɴʱʽĳɱ棺ί˳ɱ桢˳ɱ桢Լί˳
湹ɵɱ档һί˽Ȩˣ˽Լ˵ĳɱǶȨڵѡ˻
μҲλһҪĿ׷ȨãЧúȨõԽܹ㷺Ȩõ
ЧˮƽԽߡȨı߼ΪֵǴȨı߼ǵݼģֱΪֵȨ
ҪķڹеԴԴɾԴתģһɱȨķѵĸܳɱΪ
ʱ䡢רλȨı߼ʸ˳ɱ㡣ڴȨ˱߼Ǵڸ˱߼ʳɱ
˴ȨõĶᵼ±߼ɱڱ߼״κιᵼʹøһ
ȨĹʹȨͬᱻá
    ȨƷָȨͨȨΪԼֱıȡƶȹ涨ľ档ƶȹ涨ľָѡ˻μҡ
ԱõĹġϷʲ롣ͨȨãǿܻóֺϷ롣ȨƷͬͨƷͨ
ƷгתȨΪȨƷ򲻷ȨȨתãȨǹеģȴõ˶ĺôȨҵ
ԾûĽʹȨƷΪܡܹ׸ȨҵԾû֮ĹϵͲܳȨƷ⡣ȨƷ
ĳ̶ȨҵԾûĳ̶ԼȨֱӲĲƷĿɽ׳̶ǳصġȨֱӽǲɽ׵Ĺ
Ʒ̣ȨͲᱻƷΪĹҰȫϵȣȨЩƷ̺Ȩ޷ͨ
Ȩȡö롣ȨɽƷ̣ȨбƷĿܡȶ£ȨҵԾû
ԽֱӣȨԽױƷ
    Ȩֱ֯ɽƷ£ֻҪƷ׵гȨͻᱻƷ£ҵ
˫ؽɫʹҵڲȨʹṫȨȨзõĳ̶Ǻ
ֵġκҪͶƷ̻Ҫлñһ˫ؽɫľӪҲԼҵȨ
ȨҪȡȨ롣ֻҪȨֱӽɽƷ̣ȨʵϾѾƷˡ
    ȨֱӽɽƷ£ȨƷ̶ȡȨҵԾû֮ĳ̶ȡţ˰ղ
ȨҵԾûϵΪܣˣ˰ղȨŸƷ˰յԱҵԱ
Ҳ׳ΪлߵĶ
    ȨȨƷĽһƵгƵгĽͬƵƷгĽг
Ҫһضлƺй
    ȣгҪȨƺලԷֹȨáͨƷУҲֹɷݹ˾ҵƶ´
ί˲ƲȨΪԼıȡ򣬵ҵĲƲȨȷƲ߿ͨ۹ƱķʽƲܵ
öķա⣬Ʋ߿ԴֵĲƲóһ˷Ա㼤ʵίҪʵֵĿꡣȨ
ʹгϵĴⲻͨȨܿȨõķաгҲڹɷݹ˾ĲƲĻֳ
Ҳ޷ȡķʽʵί˵ĿꡣڲЧļƵ£гֻжȨƺලܷ
ֹȨáִ˾໥һЧȨƺⷽʽȨκһŵöܵŵԼ
ȨõķΧʵзֲεȨලҲЧطֹȨáΪ˽ͼලȨõĽ׳ɱҪרԵȨල
ÿһȨòܵȨලļලҲܵڵļලලƺƵĽʹгȻ޷ͨԴʩ
ʹ˻ʵί˵Ŀ꣬ȴͨͷֶʹ˰ί˵Ը¡
    ΣгҪ綨Ȩھû÷ΧԷֹȨƷȨƷԭķֻڲɽ׵Ĺ
ƷȨȨͲܱƷȨҵԾûĸԤԽֱӾԽױƷˣֹȨƷЧʩ
ǱȨҵԾûֱӸԤȨԾûֱӸԤڹƷȨھûļӸԤҪ
ԣκ΢ҵʵӻŻߡȻ䲼ƽķɣƶȨԤõһõķʽ
    ٴΣгҪһ֮ЧĹ磬淶ϸ˾ƶȡѡ˻ԱƲ
ԱԼĿơλۼලƶȵµĽ뽡ȫȨȨ
Ʒ
            
    гƷҪгķ뾭üгҪһ֮ӦΡҪԭ
ΣȨԴ֯ƷļƻƹɵԼ۸ƷԴõгƣоƸĸ
Ƹĸǲģȫľг뽡ȫг໥ģκһȱһڡʵʩȷ΢Ϊ
Ȩȷ綨Ȩʵм۸񡢲˰աڵƸĸͬʱҲʵʩ˾Ƹĸֻע
ƸĸƸĸĸﲻ᳹ףпܳ־Ļҡڽ뽡ȫЧƷҪгͬ
ʱȫЧг۸ֶεھûĽޣؽȨȨƷ⡣
    ƸĸһȾƸĸѸӵϵͳ̡ĽҪһϵ;ƸĸƸĸ
ҪԣɼƻгùɵתڣƸĸҪϽйҸֻطȨƵȷĸĸ
Ƹĸ뾭ƸĸҪͬƸĸĿģʽҪһü۸ԴƷľƣô
ƸĸͲаһģʽĽβƷȨֱӽ빫Ʒ⣬û򶼲ҪȨֱӽ
롣ĸĲҪΧһĿСȷ΢ΪƲȨӪȨͬʱҪջҵƲ뾭Ӫ
ȨǮȨײܱ⡣ȨϸƵרҵԼڻתвŤΪһżҪ
ʵвȨ¹졢ӪԸӯľøĸҪʵθĸȨĹϵרҵ
ҵתḶ́ǲϵȨĹϵܿȨҵҵֱӸԤĹ̡ʲôʱڻʵ
ֲȨعȫƣʲôʱڻŤΪ
    뾭ƸĸϣƸĸĽҪԹõиĸֱӸԤûҪ
תְܣȨĴڽʹгҪЩȨȨýɱ⡣Ƹĸв
ƸĸĴڣӾ˲֧ѹԼලƲȫ£Ȩ
շѡ̯ɵֶά뷢չ
    Ϊ˱֤гЧʣҪطȨơЧʣгҲ⡣гľ˱Ϊͨ
ͶƱʽѡٺѡˣԼѡη⣬ΪľȨƷһҪͶ롣ƷǷű
ģеĹƷֻһȨṩ෴๫ƷǷṩġҵİȫϵȹƷ
Ҫṩ⣬ڽͨ๫ƷɵطṩչƷķΧȷƷΣ
ڹƷĹٶڹطԹƷṩϽżҵľ˰ͬ
ҪѡṩϺùƷסЧṩ㹫ҪĹƷĵطʱ˲ŵԴѹ
ʹطĹԱõذѹȨڹƷ
    طķȨָϵķȨǻֶ΢۾ĿȨھûֱ֧ȨӾѧ
ǶȽַȨҪڹƷṩһ˿ڶĴ˵طȨʵԴЧ
ڵ侭÷չˮƽĲ죬Ȼֹ˵ڹƷǲͬġͨȨķʽΪá
кܴĸṩҪĹƷ۴ӹ߳ɱ뽻׳ɱ濴Ǵ桢ԼƷ濴
ɷȨķʽɸطԼṩֻҪԼȨڹȫԵĹ
οס
    1Berglas, E.  "On  the  Theory  of  Clubs",   AmericanEconomic Review, May 1976, PP. 116121.
    2Buchanan,j.M.and G.Tullock, The Calculus of Consent.An Arbor: University of Michigan Press 1962.
    3Coase, R.H. "The Problem of Social Cost",  Jornal  ofLaw and Economics, Octother 1960, PP. 1-44.
    4Foucault, M. The History of Sexuality, Volume 1:   AnIntroduction, New York: Vintage Books, 1980, PP. 93, 94.
    5Laffont, J.-J. and D. Martimort, "Transaction,   costInstitutional design and the separation of powers",   European
Econmic Review, Volume 42, Nos. 3-5, May 1998.   ( Papers  andProceedings of the twelfth annual  congress  of  thd  European
Economic Association, August 31-September 2, 1997).
    6North, Douglass C. Institution, Institutional  Changeand Economic Performance, Cambrideg Unviersity Press, 1990
˹Cŵ˹ƶȡƶȱǨ뾭üЧ Ϻ棬1994ꡣ
    7Parsons, T. Politics and Social Structure, New  York,The Free Press, 1969, PP. 185-223.
    8Rusell, B.Power: New Social Analysis, London:  Georgeallen and Unwin, 1938, P.25.
    9Weberm,M. Economy and Society, three volumes, G. Rothand C.Wittich, eds, New York: Bedminister Press, 1968,  Vol. 1
, P.53.
    10˹Τƽά棺Ȩѧÿѧ磬1999档
    11˹ֵ²ķгΡƶȡϺ棬1992档
    12ղķ˹M.ϣеĲϺ棬1992档
    
    
    
 
