 ׺ 2-1193
ԭĳƾо
ԭ
ԭںš200005
ԭҳš312
  šF10
  񾭼ù
ӡںš200008
    йõķ
Ӣı⡿On the Prosperity and Depression of China's Economy
    CHEN le-yi
    (Economic Research Center, Hunan Institute of Finance  and Economics, Hunan, Changsha, 410079,China)
    һ
߼顿һϲƾѧԺ  о  ɳ  410079
    һ1967Уˣѧʿڣ˶ʿоʦо򣺺۾ѧ
Ҫойηй̣ǷٵγɣԼ١Ϊ
ηѭʼͶʲͼ໥ãγɷĽ֣˫
Լۡٵš
ӢժҪThis paper made a study on the prosprity and  depression  ofeconomic operation since the founding of the People'
s Republic, especially the formation of  prosperity, from  prosperity todepression and from  depression  to  prosperity.   T
he  authorbelieves the material and technical basis  of  circulation  ofprosperity and depression is the  flutuation  of   i
nvestment,the interaction of multipliers and accelerators gives rise  tothe formation of prosperity and depression, and  pro
posed  theidea of double constraint from prosperity to depression.   Thepaper finally  made  a  policy  proposal  on  gettin
g  out  ofdepression toward prosperity.
  ʡ/ͼ໥/˫Լ/ƽ˹/ߵ
    Prosperity and  depression/Interaction  of Multipliers andAcceleraors/Double  Constraint/Science   and   Education   for
Prosperity/The Coordination of Fiscal and Monetary Policies.
    
    ͼţF015    ױʶ룺A    ±ţ1000 176X200005000310
            һ
    ѧһ㽫ڷΪ׶Σ׶κŽ׶Σ壨peak Ͳȣtrough ڵת۵㣨עμPaul    A.
Samuelson and William D. Nordhaus, 1998. οס1 433ҳҲԻΪĸ׶Σ٣prosperity˥ˣ
recession Σ crisis   depression  գrecoveryrevival עĸ׶ε˳γɾʱ
׶ʮԣǶսòôˡзٺǾڵҪ׶Σ˥˺͸ɽ׶Ρٵ
ߵΪ򶥷壬ǷٵļʢʱڣҲɷת˥˵Ŀʼ͵ΪȻȵףʱڣҲ
תյĿʼϵķǱĽҪоķ
     ýӢѧϣ˹Hicks,   JohnRichard ľģͣעϣ˹о֮ɡ
ľҪ1950ġԾ۵Ĺס A  Contribution to  the  Theory  of  the  Trade  Cycle.
Oxford:Clarendon Press.һС˵ͼ1Уϣ˹ÿڷֳĸ׶Σעϣ˹Ծȫ̵μ
[2]Chapter 19һ׶׶Σս׶Σ ӵabҲǴӾÿʼյﵽ־ҵˮƽΪֹһ
Ρڶ׶ǳ־ҵķٽ׶Σǲų־ҵCCעϣ˹Ϊ־ҵ߾Ǿڵޣ߶Դɣ
ĳ־ҵ߾ͼ2Ǳڲ߻ܹAS[,L] ǿͻƵģֱﵽܹAS[,S]Ĵֱ֡
ˣ־ҵ߲ǾڵޣӦǶܹAS[,S]Ĵֱ֡˶ʱڣCCϵĵbc׶
½׶Σ˥˽׶ΣӵcdҲɳ־ҵ߿ʼ½FFΪֹһ׶ΡĽ׶׶Σǲ
FFеʱڣFFϵĵdeעڵĸ׶εĳȣϣ˹Ĺ۵㣬ԡ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ1  ϣ˹ģ
    ǣʵҪڵĸ׶Σ˵ԤڵĲͲЩת۵㣬ȻǼѵģܾѧѾø
ͳģͼԤδ»δһĲҵֻע˥˺˥˰˼ѧ˼Σ
˥ˣΣҪǳ̶ϵĲ졣˹ٸģJoseph E.StiglitzڡѧϲΪ٣µĲ
Ϊ˥ˣصĲ½Ϊ2030ʱ䳤ͷȴΪThe Great Depression
Ϊ˥˵ı־GDP½Ҳ˵GDP½ʱ˵˥ѾˣΪͳĿģ걻ֽ
ΪȣGDPÿȽʱһΣעμ Stiglitz,1993οס3658ҳ
    ӡᾭüάRavi BatraĹ۵㣬˥ͨ13꣬ڴڼ䣬ʧҵȻһ12
˥˳3ϣңʧҵʽ1220֮ʱ ñ˵һʧҵӸ߲£˥˳6ʱ 
ɳΪˣس̶ʱ䣬ڵ½׶οɶΪ˥ˡעμά
.1990[M].Ϻ꣬1988 ĽѧߵĹ۵㣬ϸ˥˺ڲӰȫǰ£
ʱҲʹ
    òȱڵĸҲжڵĲͬ׶ΡҪȱڣǱڲPotential outputһȽϾȷ塣Ǳ
ĸɰɫ¿ϣOkun,Arthur M.ǿǱڲֱΪ־ҵĲFull- employment out-putָڳ־
ҵ¾ܹʵGDPˮƽ ˵ȻʧҵӦʵGDPˮƽ һڲͨά
ֵߵʵGDPˮƽ עǱڲעǱڲͼ2˵Y[*]AS[,s]ĴֱĲ 
Ǳڲһ򾭼õֻڲͨ
ǱڲĹֵʵٶĻϣھдĥʧҵͬʱʹھ൱ʱҲһЩûб
ȫáˣǱڲĹֵȷ
    ȱǱڲʵʲ֮
    ȱڡǱڵĲʵʵĲ                     1
    ȱڿԺʵʲǱڲ֮ƫĹģҲԺõʵоߣPPC ע
PPCμͼ5жԶ
    ȱǱȽСֵʱʵʲǱڲʱ˥˵ļҲǸյףٶΪ˥ˣŲȱ
ĲʵʲԽԽǱڲǣ˥أһʱȱС
ζ˥˳̶ȲϼͻͣʵʲǱڵĲˮƽ븴ս׶ΡԽǱڲߣǱڵĲ
ˮƽʱȱձɸֵһȱζŹȾҵ˳ʱĹͻĳʹʡʱóַپ档
    ܹͨADASģ˵ͼ2еAS[,s]ʾܹߣAS[,L]Ǳڲغϡ AS
[,L]ͬAS[,S]Ĵֱ֣AS[,s]ĴֱλAS[,L]ұߡAS[,s]ĴֱܵõơAS[, L] 
AS[,S]ĴֱֺͶͲ֮򣬼ͼӰ֣ʾ١AS[,S]ȫƽ̹൱ƽֱ̹ʾ֮Ĺ
׶м򣬱ʾ˥˻ա
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ2  ٷ״̬
         ٵ¾½
    жڲͬ׶εҪָһЩ۾ñʧҵʡͨ͡ʡ磬ڷʱڣʧҵ½ͨ
ʱڣ෴
    ͨϵķԽ綨뾭ڵͬͬǣǾڵҪ׶Σ뿪˷
Ͳھ֮˵ǣоصǷΪʲôԼ٣ǿѭ
ԡڲˮƽƫ룬ѭԭ
    ϸ綨˷ݷĺ壬50ҹ˶ηעݹ͹ʷΪ
ķֻ˥ˣССļ11ΣǷֱΪ1953ġð19541955˥ˡ 1956 ġð
1957˥ˡ1958꿪ʼꡰԾ19601962Ĵѡ19651966ķٺ19671968Ĵ19691970ķ
1972˥ˡ1973Ļ1974ȫ˥ˡ 1975 ķٺ19761978ķٺ19791981˥ˡ19841985
ķٺ1986Ļ¡1988ķٺ19891991Ĵ£гƣ19921994ķٺ1998ҷ
Ķĵ͹ܴ֮󣬳ִ
    50ηй̿ܽΪͼ3
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ3  й
    ͼ3ηѭʼͶʲڳͼ໥ãMultiplieraccelerator interaction 
ѡͶʺ͹໥Ӱ죬໥ڣγɾڡעͼ໥ε¾õԲϸ
Paul A. Samuelson."Interactions Between  the  Multi- plierAnalysis  and  the  Principle  of  Acceleration",   Review  ofEc
onomics Statistics, 1939,21,7578ҳ. ڳͼ໥ãͶʹγɾõķپ档ڷٵĺڣ
ܵԴԼѲԼͶʲ㣻ͬڳͼ໥£Ͷʲγɾõ档
    ĵойηй̣ǷٵγɣԼ١ĵоĿ
оС͹֮⾭õĴ䣬Ӷʵ־õĳڳٺ
            ͶʹȺͷ
    ͸ηԷйԲҪص㣺1ҵУعҵԴṤҵȣ عҵ
У칤ҵ󡣣2һ˵ Ͷŵ¾øʱȻũᡢرṹʧعҵ
ƫũҵƫСƺѳΪҹòеһԱ仯صͶʹۣOverinvestment theory עͶ
ʹ۾ǹգGottfride Haberler1937 Prosperity and DepressionܽһҪۡ
۴ͶʵĽǶȷڵγɣ۵ǣϻʱƷҵƷҵ£˹ȵķչ
Ͷԭ͵ĲͬͶʹֿԷΪɣֱǣһͶʹۣThe monetary overinvestment theory
ǹҮˣF. A. HayekڶǻͶʹۣ  The nonmonetary overinvestment theoryǵ¹ѧ˹
Spiethoff, arthur august, 18731957꣩侭ѧҿCassel, Gustav, 18661957꣩ƳƷ䶯
Ͷʹȡԭ     ԭTheacceleration principleԭҲɷѧҰ
̣Aftalion, Albert, 1909꣩ѧJ. M. ˣJ.M. Clark, 1917꣩ʮơһ
Ͷʹ۵۵㣬ϻʱƷҵƷҵ£˹ȵķչҲ˵ʱƷĲճ
ƷҵöࡣڶǹҮˣF.A. HayekͶʹۣThe monetary overinvestmtnt theory˵ġṹ
ʧˣйķбҪͶʹۡ
    ͲӣǣַپͶʹȴġͶʹȵԭиֲͬĽ͡ͶʹΪǻ
Ͷʹȣ    ǻͶʹۣThe      nonmonetaryoverinvestment theoryΪ··֡ гٵȷǻ
ͶʹȡйͶʹȣлأзǻأǱΪйͶʹȵҪԭ
ԵģƻƵ͵طҵŵͶͳ嶯Ȩҳ֮ΪͶʹȣעͶʹ
ȵϸμο[5]ڰ¡ ԴͶʹۡǻͶʹӦ
    80ͶʹֳһأƸ߶ȼдͶͶʵӡעƸ߶ȼͶͶʵ۷μ
ο[4]9798ҳ
    Ͷڳ£ͲӡͲӣڼ£ֵͶʵĽһӡڳͼ
໥£ͶʴͲַӣͬʱǡͲ־ҵߣòޣγɷپ
档ڳ־ҵϽһʱڡϣ˹ģдӵabcμͼ1
            ԴȱԼ
        һ
    ѭ˶УҪǷΪʲôʲô˥˺Ϊ˻ش⣬
ѧ߲̽ɫɫмЩۣеȷʵֻǽͷΪеһչ
Ϊۡ
    ۵ķչУλѧߴԼͬһʱĹ ʵ˻о׶εá ǹգ
Gottfried HaberlerͿ˹John Maynard Keynes յĹҪڡ1937 Prosperity and Depressionһ
У20ʮǰĸ־һϵͳܽᡣ ˹ġҵϢͻͨۡ1936   The    General
Theory of Employment Interest and Money ȻûṩһϵͳľۣĹȴΪԺľ
۵춨˻ṩµķ򡣴ӴԺ󣬾۲һµĽ׶Ρϣ˹֮ɡ80¹ŵ۾ѧ
New     classical     macroeconomicsʵʾۣRealbusiness cycle theoriesִƽ˾۵о
    ܵ˵Դ2030Ĵ۾ѧҶţı䶯ġֱӵ˥
עʱܹŶҲȷʵܵ¾˥ˣ2070ʯͼ۸ļǣһ㲻Ϊܹ
ġϣ˹ģ͵ĳ־ҵߣܵԴҪƣҲܵԼ˵ܹǾ
ڳֵҪԭ˵ı䶯ģʱ徭öԣƻ򲻳ģμĵ
עֹ۵μPaul A.Samuelson and William D.Nordhaus, 1998.ο[1]436ҳ
    ѧߵĹ۵㣬Ϊг£˥˺ʼɵģܹŶʱƲ
һ㲻Ҫԭ򡣷ADASģ͡ͼ2УʱADAD ɴǱڲ
ķٽ׶ΣעСǱڲӽǱڲʱҲѾڷ״̬ɵλǱڲ·׶Ρ
תҪɵġ
        йķ
    йͬѲ˷ͼ3Уڷ״̬˵ڳ־ҵϣͼ1 һʱ䣬
кܾãȻ˥ˣйķгùҸΪӡƻʱԼ80ڵ
ҪܵԴԼעҲϣ˹bѴڳ־ҵ״̬ һܵԴҪ
˵ƶΣJanos Kornai˵ġ޶ȡ޶ȡμο[7]3.29.1010.6ڡܵԴԼΪڷ
ʱѾ˵ڶṹʧʱԴӦţʱƷ۸һǣƿԽԽխֽ
޷ά֣ǣʵʩߣעͶʹ۲ͬǣʵʩߣǸԶͶʡ
ѹͶʣͶʲ㡣
    80ĩ90˺ܴ仯ڼ䣬ͳ徭гùɣг̶Ȳߡ
ݲ㣬г̶Ȳߡݲ㣬г̶ѾӸĸ֮5199560 ңĳЩгùҵг
Ϊ80855608085 Ϊձ׼עɲμʤ.йго[
M].Ϻ磬1999ǰг£˥˺ʼɵġۣ80ĩ
йʼܵԼԼǿ֮ơҲ˵ʱķܵԴȱ
˫Լע˫Լϸμο[5]μͼ4
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ4  ԴԼԼ֮滻
    ͳҵľҪԴԼλͼеĵAʱҵľҪԼλͼеĵC[,0] й
ԼԴԼԼɣͼдACƶʾֽ׶Լռλʱ
ңˣӦͼеĵB
    㣨עҹĿԺͱҪԣרĴ˼ʣΣѧ˵Լơѵ
ìϵķμο[8] ȱΪѲ㡣עҹѲҪԭһǳ
Ǿӣռ˴ѡⲻҹҪһ۾ֵоĴԡѲ
㽫ƷгήƷļ١ʱҵֲƷ½ˣӵͶʻҲˡͬʱҲǵ
ߵĻԸҵǣҵͶʣͶʲ㡣עѲͶʲ㣬ǼԭõĽ
ѵļٱضƷƷֱضʱƷҲ˵ѵļٱضͶʵļ١
µͶʲּӾߵµͶʲ㡣Ҳ˵ͶʲǽߺѲ˫õĽע˫
ֻڷĩں˥˽׶Σ׶κ󣬽һתΪߡ
    Ͷʲڳ£Ͳ½Ͳ½ڼ£Ͷʵļ١ͼ໥ã
Ͳһ½ֱߣͬʱ۵Ĳµʱ׶νһʱ䡣ϣ˹
ģдӵcdeμͼ1
        С
    ͨϵķԴϵó˽ۣ80ĩηܵԴȱ˫Լ
г̶ȵĲߣԼӾƣӰԽԽͱˡʵϣҹֽ׶ε
ѾΪҪԭ
            ġ
    ой÷ĿģҪѰʵ־õĳڳٺ;˫ԼԴȱ
㡣ӦپҪ˫ԼĻ͡ԴȱҪǼƻõĲͶʹȴġˣ
ԴȱԼҪǽһĸ״ƼƻõĿܣΪƵгƣͶʹȣעҹֽ׶
ڵͶʲ㣬Ͷ͵ĻȻڡ⣬ף徭ƶȵıơԼҪ
ò
        һ徭ƶȵı
    һĸ徭ƶȣж෽ݣְܵıĸĽ
    1.Чƶƽ˹
    ԴȱЧ,(PPC)ͼ,徭λڴߵĵط,ͼ5A
E㡣ǿ˷ԴȱЧʵϰ,ӶЧʵԴɷΪ:һ,Ч
ԼеԴ,ʹôEƶF,ƶϡڶھǱʹƶͼ5Bʾ

    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ5  Ч
    ʵ񣬴ʹôEƶF㣬ƶƶ䶯ԴȪǾСڼз
ԴȪǸԵҪԣóԿƽΪ֮Ľۡ
    ѧѾооԴȪǷ֣ԴȪҪأʱƷۣͶʣӡͶ
ߡעѶɭڡѧ16ΪĸԴHuman resources  ȻԴ  Natural
resourcesʱۣCapital formationͼTechnologyʾΪQAFK,L, RʽQKLʱ
ͶͶ룬RʾȻԴͶ룬AˮƽF μο[1]519520ҳԴȪ ͨ
Aggregate production function, or APFõ 2ʾ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʽKLֱʱͶͶ룬Aˮƽ2ʾҪͶKLˮƽA ҪͶӺͼĸ
²ӡ
    ѧǽҪͶͼеҪԡⷽľоʡѧԺŵ޲  壨
Solow, R.M.ġ19091949ݣ óĽǣʱÿͶСʱĳ80Ĳɼ
ġ   עμġTechnical Change    and theAggregate Production  Function,   Review  of  Economics  and
StatisticsAugust 1957.֮ȫоɹ֮һɰ»ɭEdward F. Denisonġ ɭоɹ֧
ĹƣɭóĽǣʱҪģ֧áעԾԴȪҪԵľ
ȷƼѣоɹҲóһЩͬĽۡ磬ѧĴǸɭƣĴ󲿷ؿԹ鹦ʱƷӣ
μDale Jorgenson Frank  Gollop  Barbara  Fraumeni Productivity  and U. S. Economic  Growth  Cambridge,   Mass. :
 Harvard University Press, 1987 뱾ĵ룬ÿѧ磬1989ˣ
ɡģSimon. KuznetsJ.W.ϵˣKendrick,  J. W.Ҳͻ˼ھеá
    ͨϵķǿԷ֣оΪҪԴȪǼעҪԻԴӶǶ
֤й÷еη٣18861903꣬19151931꣩˶͵ձӦΪ־˾
áʼ1991 2 µľҪԭǸ߿Ƽ ɲֻԴȪоѵʵ
 ʱΪǿѵԾǱڹף ҲʱHumancapitalעʱǸϵĸֱ60
רҵлù㷺ʹáʱķչѧڹеѧϰԼʱڸĸڽǮʱ
ͶʡһЩѧҹƣȫʱе2334ʱΪһֵͶдʱʾΪ
        YAFKHL                          3
    ʽHʱ
    ʽ3У ѵʱ뼼ﲢеĵλʵͽศɵģǼĻ
ڽ֧˶о뿪Ͷо뿪ĿѧҺ͹ʦھԴȪķ
ΪΪͻѵѽҲΪ뼼еһԴȪˣҪԴȪǼͽ
ᷨڲӽչõĹңкҪ壬ǶйˣҪʵЧʣ
ٽй뽫ͽΪҪԴȪԿƽΪ֮ǱĵĽۡעƽ˹սԵʵ֤
μԾ׵ļ[J].о19992.ϲǣйȷƽ˹սԡ199812
24հ䲼21ͽжƻ˿ͽĸͷչʩͼؼʵˣ˽ĿԴ
    2.徭ег
    徭УЪMarshall, Alfred߶Walras, LonǾⲢļ£ Ͷ
гʱгƷгڳ״̬۸񣨰ʡʺƷ۸񣩾ܾгȶģͣһ
ֹ㣬Ӷͣ͡һ˵徭УԶĹʻᡢԶʻơԶļ۸ƣȡ֮
ǾܾȫƻƶĹʻơʻƺͼ۸ƣֻ޷ͶгʱгƷгĹǣЩ
гڴڲͷǾ״̬ͳ徭ег״£ע徭егеͼηɲ
Stiglitz1993ο[3]еChapter 40Ĵԡ
    1ͶгҪͶȱĽǣ һְȶĹϣһ棬徭õЧʺ
͡˵徭ƶ£ϷԾЧʵʧΪ۵ġ
    2ʱгҪӵȫʱ ͨѹեũѹѣʹʵϽиߴʵعҵ

    3Ʒгƶļƻ۸ ͨг۸࣬һ۸ˮƽ£ڳ󡣽
ֶȱΪ˹޵ƷòųӵȺ
    ге໥ԣһгļ۸湩Զ˳УʵҲʹг˳гΪ

    ľڽбٻгùɡйڹڣг״˺ܴ
仯Ʒг۸Ѿ󲿷ַſгۡݲ㣬Ʒгļ۸г̶Ѿ19792.2590ڵ85
£ȽϽӽĳЩгùҵˮƽʤȣ1999꣩ǣͶгʱггҪͺܶ࣬ٵҪ
ϰ֮һˣٹУҪͻͶгʱгıͬʱһƷгʵ徭г˳С
        ߵ
    ھôʱڣλͼ6еĵEʱ ΪY[,0]ڳ־ҵˮƽY[*]λڳ־ҵߡE 
־ҵٹУѡ񣬼ʵԲ߻Իߵѡ⡣ƶISƣ
ƶE[,1]ʱˣʵ˳־ҵ ˡƶLMƣƶE[,2] ʱҲ
ˣʵ˳־ҵ½µĽϵζڵE[,2]ͶʸڵE[,1]ͶʣISߵƶ
ͶʲµģͲͬˡ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ6  
    ھӦòȡԲߣԻߣֻӦѡźͻϵĳϴӶһмλã
ΪˣбҪһ߳Чǿ⡣
    ISLMģͣעISLMģܵУȻ۾õȹߣǲ߳Сۻ
߳ĴСעЧǿμο[8]߳ ߵĽϵ
ѡһµġ
    ߳ɱΪƵ̴ԣ
    dy        a[,G]
  
    dg                  b                              4
         1ka[,G]
            h
    
    ʽ4еdydgǿʵصĲ߳ ʽa[,G]Ϊ򵥵֧
            1
      a[,G]
             1c1t
    
    c Ϊ߼tΪ˰ʣbͶ֧ʵķӦ̶ȣkhֱӳʵˮƽʱ仯ķӦ
г̶ȡ
    ʽ4ɿ߳dydgĴСȡa[,G]kbhĸءΪ˷ķ㣬 ＯͶ֧
̶bʵʻʵг̶ha[,G]kҼٶΪ䣨עֻǼѡѧ߶ּ˹μһۣ
̩յĺ۾Ч[J].ѧѧ1997 1ʵa[,G]kҲΪȽȶʽ4bԽ
ISбԽСISԽƽ̹߳ԽСb ԽСISбԽISԽͣ߳Խh Խ
LMбԽСLMԽƽ̹߳ԽhԽСLM бԽLMԽͣ߳ԽСע
߳СĸֿԻRobert E. Hall  and John  B.  TaylorMacroeconomics-Theory, Performance, and Policy (1991. W.
  W. Norton & Company, Inc.175ҳеͼʾͼʾ4 ϸ˵˸ֿԡ
    ߳ɱΪƵ̴ԣ
    dy            a[,G]
                        5
    dm        h
         ka[,G]
          b
    
    ʽ5߳ĴСȡa[,c]kbh ĸءͬ߳ķһҼٶa[,G]k䡣ˣb Խ
󣨼ISбԽСISԽƽ̹߳Խb ԽСISбԽISԽͣ߳ԽСh Խ
LMбԽСLMԽƽ̹߳ԽСh ԽСLMбԽСLMԽͣ߳Խ󡣣ע
߳СĸֿԻRobert E. Hall  and  John   B. TaylorMacroeconomics-Theory, Performance, and Policy (1991.
W. W.Norton & Company, Inc.174ҳеͼʾͼʾ 4ϸ˵˸ֿԡ
    ݲ߳ͻ߳ķʱڵĲ߳ȻߴעΪʱڵbȽСIS бʱȽϴ
IS߱Ƚ϶ͣhȽϴ󣬼LMбʱȽСLM ߱Ƚƽ̹ЧȻǿˣٹͻ
ǣͬʱߵĸáߵĸҪǴڡЧӦCrowding outͺThe inside lagϳ
пͨ͡
            塢
    ͨȫйηй̣ɵó˽ۣ1.ηѭʼͶʲڳ
ͼ໥£ѡͶʺ໥Ӱ죬໥ڣ·Ľ֡2.80ĩη
ܵԴȱ˫Լرг̶ȵĲߣ֡2.80ĩη
ܵԴȱ˫Լرг̶ȵĲߣԼӾƣӰԽԽ
ͱˡʵϣҹֽ׶εѾΪҪԭ򡣱˫ԼĻͣٵ
š
    ҪǣѭйõҲй2 000ķ⽨ᾭС й
һشصǣᾭõķչͣͲǰҶ߱ʾ嵽֮ǳ޴󡣴غʱ
2000ʷУҹδССľõĶмβǳ޴󣬸ᾭô˻ԵѣǷ
ǣսĩغ֮ľòĩçʱľòĩľòʱᾭ
õķδᾭõľֲԪй⽨ᾭ÷޴󲨶ĸԭСũƾõĳڴڣֱԭ
˻ϸμο[12]
    ոڣ20000208
α༭Ȫ
οס
    [1]Paul  A. Samuelson  and  William  D. Nordhaus,   1998.Economics.The McGrawHill Companies, Inc.
    [2]Edward Shapiro, 1978. Macroeconomic Analysis,  HarcourtBrace Jovanovich, Inc.
    [3]Stiglitz, Joseph E. 1993. Economics.   W. W.   Norton &Company, Inc.
    [4]ά . йͶʹ˾о룬1990M.ϺϺ꣬1988.
    [5]һ.˫ԼйƷгķM.ӡݣ1999.
    [6]ݹ.˶۷M.ӡݣ1963.
    [7]ŵʲƶ.ȱѧ¾M.ÿѧ磬1986.
    [8]һ.ЧȡJ.ƾо19995.
        [ 9] Rudiger  Dornbusch  and  Stanley  Fischer.   1998Macroeconomics, McGrawHill, Inc.
    [10]ղķ˹KӶ˹Сᣬ 賨.۾ѧM.ÿѧ磬1997.
    [11]Rober E. Hall and John B. Taylor, 1991. Macroeconomics, W.W. Norton & Company,Inc.
    [12].й⽨ᾭʷ25M. 磬1982198419861989.
    [13]׷򾭼ѧ14M.ÿѧ磬1996.
    [14]Douglas  Greenwald  Edited,   1982.   Encyclopedia  ofEconomics, McGraw-Hill Book Company.
    [15]David W.Pearce Edited, 1982. Macmillan  Dictionary  ofModern Economics, The Macmillan Press Ltd.
    
    
    
 
