 ׺ 2-233
ԭĳݴѧѧư
ԭںš199904
ԭҳš4249
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš200001
    ̸ۣѧĺ
Ӣı⡿Negotiation Theory:the Core of Legal EconomicsWei JianWei Jian College of Economics and Management,NorthwestUniv
ersity,Xi'an,710069,China
    κ
߼顿κ  κ(1972-)Уɽˣѧʿо²Ȩѧо  ѧ  ùѧԺ     
 710069
ҪԸʵЧʵ;Ը谭صĿ˷̸۵ɡ̸Ҳ˽Էɲŵľ÷
ͳһڴٽʵЧʵּ֮£Ϊѧĺ̸ۡڲƲԼȨеӦøֵ˵һ㡣
ӢժҪThe paper holds that voluntary cooperation is the mosteffective approach to efficiency,and the removal of obstac
lesin the way of voluntary cooperation is the mainstay ofnegotiation theory.Because it has the principle of efficiencyas its
 guideline and the economic study of legal institutionsas a major task,the negotiation theory has gained a coreposition in l
egal economics,which is further confirmed by itsapplications in such cases as property law,contract law,andinfringement law.
  ʡѧ/̸//谭/Чlegal cconomics/negotiation/cooperation/obstacles/efficiency
    
    ͼţF019  ױʶ룺A  ±ţ1000-2804(1999)04-0042-08
    ѧǽЩѧʮֻԾһоҹĿǰԷѧܺоཫѧʾо
Էɽоѧڶҹ˾ΪСӾѧǶΪѧĲࡣӾ
ѧĽǶȣֶ̽ԷɽоѧĺۺͷΪЧʻϵ̸ۣ˾ѧԷɽз
ۡ
            һ̸ۣ
    1.̸ʵЧʵ;
    ̸Դͳ۸ΪΪԸʹһԴӹ۵͵תƵ۸ߵУӶԴʹЧ
ŻԴãͬʱҲ˺˫ĸˮƽ̸йУ̸иĿĶϣһ£кˣ̸ͨ
ڽкĹһֺġ̸йУ˫ԸضԽ׶󡢼۸ԼշȽЭ̣Ǵ
һ½кԴһ޷㽻׳ɱǰ£ֺֽȡںֵĴСηʣࡣν
ķֵǺкĻɱҲ˫кܹõ档һûߵ£ķ
ֵǸԴ״ߵߵĳۡʣԴںӶ۵͵ĵط뵽۸
ĵطĸˮƽӡ̸ΪɹҲľÿ̸еúʣһȷݶ
    ̸еĹ̿ԷΪ׶Σ(1)ȷֵҪȷԴ״Ҫȷ˫ľȷۡ(2)Ԥ
ʣ࣬ҳ˫۲죬Ԥ˫ˮƽߵĿ̶ܳȡ(3)ʣ࣬ԤĻϣȷõķݶ
еķգЭʣࡣڲѹ˫жʵȵ£˿̸ͨҵ⣬ԴЧ
ʺḣˮƽ
    Ȼ谭ԸĽУгɱġʧʹԴ޷ܷõĵطγ
ѵԴø֣Ҳ޷帣ˮƽȡֶν͵ԽɸЧʺ͸ʧҪ˷
ϰŬʧܴĸʧʹ˽ЭʧɵСΪĻԭ޲ءغ
˹νġ淶Ļ˹
    2.谭̸˳еڲؼ˷
    ôЩ谭̸е˳أ̸йÿһ׶ζ谭س֣ǽЩسΪڲ谭ء
    (1)̸зֵȷȣȨ彫ʹ̸иȷ˴˵״Ҳ޷ȷķֵȨһ̸и
ȨΧ壬޷жȨ磻Ȩ߽صԻޣȨʲ壬ԶۣǲǷȨ
޷סָǣȨǹģָȨ
    ο˷ȨϰأƲԼƶ÷ɽ̸иȨʡ߽Ϣ͹̶ȷ
˸̸еȨλԲȡĲȨ÷ʽԤڵĲȨ綨ܣӶʹ̸еķֵȷﵽ
ϰĿġ
    Σ׵гṹӰ̸зֵȷҪӰֵĴСں¢϶ԺӰʱ
    (2)ԤʣࡣԤʣ࣬ҪѰҺ⡣ѰҺҪѰɱΪʣݶѡǰ£̸
һֻݶԼϢһֵķҪֶԲ߳ɱѰɱͶԲ߳ɱʹʣ׼ȷԤ
⡣ѰɱͶԲ߳ɱԴϢĲȫԲ߳ɱԴϢȫϵĻ塣
    ԽѰɱͶԲ߳ɱҪйϢİţҪзƶȡЩɱûнΪɹƶȰţ
Ϣȫͻ嶼󣬷ֻܽǣܳ׸ƲԼԼйϢ¶ֹթƶȣ
һã볹ȴ൱Զľ롣һϣʵһߵƶȵǰ棬ϢԳƳֵϢɸѡͼ
ʵϢѾЧؽϢԳɵѰɱԲ߳ɱĳԼʵҲáЩԶ
ûﵽƶȻˮƽ
    (3)ʣķ䡣ʣ಻Ҫиһͬ⣬ҪиЭСҪЭнмලȷЭ
ȷȫ桢ʵУලɱɴɡලһǶٸһǷԼгֵĸַգҪ
ΥԼպ¼գͨԼյķһԼලɱӱҲԴڶԽеĻķ
ϢȫʱԴڣԼලɱͬϢȫĲȰþϢĳɱҲʵʩලĳɱ
    ͼලɱķɰҪԼƶȡԼһǹģͬϵҲΪԼϵҵ֯ϵ
ɹϵԼƶҪͨԼգģͼලɱͬƶ̶̸ͨиɲȡĽ
׷ʽͷշʽγй˽Э̸пܡÿݴ˿ܿԺԤڱ˼˲̸кЭĽ
δĲȷԡҵ֯ƶͨȷϺ֧֡һ廯ҵԼٵĲȷԴвߵϼеض
ϣﵽͲȷԵĿġƶĺʹձ㹻ĶδͶʣ˺Ӧ
ʣࡣ
    谭أ̸йУǽ׹бԵĽ׳ɱǻʹԸԴɣʹԸĺ
ԸķǺġҲǲ̸йУǵĿ˷ҪΧԼƶչϢȫķսз
Լƶȵ⡣
    3.谭̸˳еⲿؼ˷
    һЩز̸й֮⣬ǵĴʹϰʹкԸЩصµĸ߰׳ɱʹ
֣ܳʹʣķֲƽǽЩسΪ谭̸еⲿءǰ˵̸۵ĻǴͳ
۸ۡͳ۸гȫΪǰģڡгʧ顱֤ʹгʧ飬ǵĴʹԸ
г޷УΪӰ
    гʧĵһԴǸʽ¢ϡ¢ϸı˽зֵĴСΪȫ̸У׵κһгֵѡ
أֵ෴Ӱ»ᱣֲ䣬ڸԴ״¢ϴһ֣ʹ¢ߵķֵ˫
໥ֵʹ˫ȫʱӦõһֺʣתƸ¢ߣʣཱུͣͼ
ԸĶʹ¢геĽڳ־геĽӶЧʿܴﵽĸ߶ȡҪ¢ϵµĽ
ǿԣƻ̸еԸʹֻ¢߸ˮƽķչ˫ĸˮƽߺٻûߣᱻȽ
Ҫڽ׸ָƽ⣬ͨǱҪ
    ¢϶Ҫάʹ־гҲǷ¢ϷƶȵҪĿġ¢ϷƶͨȡƳ
̼ĲˡԼ۸йƼֲֹΪֶΣάгþ¢ϡǣһ
ΪڴٽЧʵͬʱЧʣ¡һЩþ¢ǲЧԭģ繫ҵе¢
ϿԻȡģ档Ϊͱڹģ¢ʧҳƽ㣬Իȡḣ֪ʶȨ¢ϱΪ
֪ʶȨֶΣԶ¢ϵòҪʶ谭Ըһ棬ҪʶĳЩдٽЧʵáؼ
СЧʧͬʱŬ¢ϴ档
    гʧĵڶԴǡⲿԡĴڡνⲿԡһ˵ԷΪδͬǿӸǵķûǿи
ǵ档ⲿʹһֺʣ౻޳ã˶ԸļⲿɱǿӸԶɱ
ⲿɱӵеĲȨ۸߶ȣӶⲿɱߵķֵʹõĺʣݶ͡ˣⲿص
ԸĽУⲿγɵĵ˼Ĺϵȫһºǿƽ׹ϵ̸ͬγɵԸϵζⲿ
еٽԸǷѧ;ѧٵĹͬ⡣
    ϣ˷ⲿԵ;ⲿڲָⲿԵصͬⲿҪѧ
Ʒɵȶǵ͵ⲿԲƷҪͨƽ⹩ߵĹɱ棬ͬʱҪֹ
Ͷʡⲿǹ㷺еһʵòĳɱȫǶķ
ˣⲿڲ;ǰҪѰɱѽϵ㣬ѡ׳ɱСķƶȡʹⲿɱ
ͬʱֲ谭ԻȾȲȾֲʹԸɱ޷
Ҳǿ˹Ĺ۵㡣ںߣȫҪģڲҪ;ƲãĿļʹȫе
ɱʹûжⲿԡԹȨĳͷ
    ⲿγɵǿƽ׹ϵ˶Ŀ˷ҪγԸⲿʹÿ嶼һΪȶĲȨ
УȨ¼ţδȷԣӶҲͽ˺ɵķաⲿԵĿ˷漰෨ɲţһ
ϣѧ;ѧĽϲŸոտʼŹķչǰ
    гʧĵԴϢȫϢȫɷΪһϢԳƣϢȷϢԳƻʹڽʱ
·պѡ⡣ӵϢƵһƵλڻջ£ֻݶԼϢ󼺷ںʣ
еķݶ·գΪ£գϢһ߽׼۸߶ԺʣռзݶΪϢյıշá
׼۸ʹ׵ѡΧе˸߷յĽ׶ϡʧܵĸ׶ĸ߷նӶƽˮƽϽ
˺ʣʹ߽׼۸ý϶ʣࡢյĳգѡ񣩡ҽ׼۸ҲʹԴŻ
ŤΪ߷յʹ߲һǸЧʵʹߡϢȷֱʹɥʧ˲ӸʹʣĲټ
ѡ
    ϢȫʹԸıⲿ谭ԸǰָģʹеѰɱԲ߳ɱͼ
ɱĳЩϢԳƿͨԸõԸΪṩҪͨǿϢ
һ¶Ϣͬʱȡ衰Ϣ𡱼ʵϢĴʩϢԳƴķЧʺͲƽϢȷķͨ
ƶȰԷҵ֯ƶнӪչ̶Ͷ߻ӪߵϢȫձ󣬹㷺
УɵԷķաʵǴӾѧǶȶϢȫȫķȻ߷ƶȵ
Чԡ
    ǿԽ̸۹Ϊĸ棺(1)ԸʵЧʵ;(2)ʵϴ谭Ը
(3)˷谭̸неأָЧʡ(4)ڻָЧʵ;Уܹٽ˽ԸİΪѡ
    ̸۾˵˺洦谭ԸĽ׳ɱԴΪƶȣ˷谭ٽṩۻͬʱҲṩ
۱׼̸ʵϽʾڽ׳ɱΪУʵЧʵ⡣Ը谭صĿ˷漰˶෽ľۣ˷
ƶȰҲ漰˼еķƶȣ̸۽Ƕͳһͽ׳ɱٽԸּ֮£γһΪ
ϵʹɢҵĶԲŷƶȽеľѧһͳһۺġ̸˳Ϊѧĺۡ
            ̸ھ巨ƶеӦ
    1.Ʋƶ
    ƲӰԸ׵״̸˵˶Ҫ󣺽ȶĲȨϵƲƶȻ˽ǧ
ķչȴδγһ׽ΪķϵƲƶʼĽйءƲƶ漰¿
ΪȨν綨αʵʩ⡣ȨʵʩڲƲеĵλҪΪ󲿷ֱϸع涨ƶ
СڲƲϵҪǲȨν綨ͱ̸۶˻شΪҸӵĲƲϵṩһ
ŬڼС
    Ȩ綨Ҫ˵Ȩ綨Ҫ塣޲ءغ˹̸ͨһ˼ʵ˵⣬
Ȩ綨ЧԴԴ˷ѡ
    ڲȨν綨ϣѧǾûг׽һ⣬Ҳ˳ĻشԸǴٽЧʵѷʽҪ˷
谭Ըϰͽ׳ɱ˹ָʹ׳ɱСĲȨ綨ƶѵĲȨ綨ƶȡ˹ֽһָΪʹ׳
С뽫Ȩ塣Ȩ綨ƫûȷ裬˹ΪӦ˾ͲȨתý̸УʹȨͨ
ı䲻Ľ綨״̬ҲȨṹıǨҲӦԴٽԴʹЧʵΪĿꡣ
    ȨıͬԴٽ֮ԸΪĿ꣬ѧĵúַܴﵽЧȨĿġ̸Ϊ
ѡṩݡΪȨṩֱһ⳥ȨΪɵ𺦽⳥һǽֹ
Ϊķֱʩǣ⳥󿴵ģǶҵɵʧвȡǰģֹȨ߽ٸ
ʧַף⳥ڱܺЧˮƽԻָͬʱСǮΪΪɡЧܺ
˵ͬʱȨ˿ܹϸʹѾеͶȫЧˣȨٵĸѰһֲȨʩ
˫ЧĽȨµ𺦽СܹЧԤԲȨֺҸҪɴ˽һ
Ȩƣʹʱı仯ȳֵĲȨ綨ƫõ
    ѧԴ˳شȨΪ˽ָڹУ漰϶࣬Ȩ˺֮ܺž޴̸
ɱγЧĺرܺһڵֲɢ͡㳵صӰ죬ԴɹʶмжҪ˷
ĸ߰׳ɱȡ⳥ķɷԺͨСгⶨ̸гɱΪ㡢ʱ̸м۸񣨼
⣩ȻѸü۸ΪȨ⳥ܺʧĻҶǿ֧ԻָЧʡ˽У漰٣˾𺦽
̸С̸еĽһԸһӷԺлõȨɴ˴ٽЧʽĳ֡
    ȨǷɴõĻȻȨı綨ݹڲƲƶ£ʵϵóĽ۾ձԡܷ
ѧǵŬв⣬ٱȨȷ̸иķֵڲȨĽ綨ͱϣ̸۲˵˽綨뱣
ԭ򣬸Ҫ˵˽綨ͱȨĸĿģڽһȶĲȨܺʹȨƶȿܣγ˴ٽԸ
òȨ
    2.ͬƶ
    ȨĽ綨ֻȷ̸еǰ̸еĴһȶƶȻУ˿ԺԤںʣ࣬ٺ
աͬƶȼṩһƶȻ
    ͬӽӴһǩͬٵִкͬһǹʱĹ̡дർºͬԤĿ겻ܴɵķգ
Ҫľǻ¼ǰ֮ѰɱԲ߳ɱͼලɱɿΪĳɱͬĺļ
򽵵ЩɱԤաݣһʲôĳŵγɺͬζΥԼսԤͲȡͬ
ƶȿԱȫԱͬĸʽͬ涨ˣٱΪЧʵģͬĳСΥԼ߱ķ
һ̸мԼеѰɱԲ߳ɱͼලɱ¼ƶȻ
    ͬЧǺͬҪ⡣̸ΪͬĴͳҪṩµĽͣųǩԼеķաȣ
˵ı׼һʸ̸еԵ壬жϺͱƫõ岻ܳΪ̸壬ɴγɵĺͬҲòɵĳ
δ˺;񲡻ǩĺͬӶһǩԼųȥ
    Σͺͬݶԣ̸ΪԷսЧĺͬЧĺͬΪյķ̾ǿ˷谭Ĺ
CalabresiΪ̸ѰҺĹУӦ˽ֵֿܳķգӦؽ֮Сɱͳеյ
һˡмȰԶԷ˻ԤҲ¼Ԥ
    ǩԼʱ˵ĻҪǿȡвթȡ£λƽȵһڶԷṩĴϢܵǷв
ȣûӰ²̸бɴĽǷԸģȻûЧʵġǩԼлԤ
ϵжƶȰţӢԼƶȣ½ǳԭǶ涨γɵĺͬЧģǿɳģҪӦһе
յһ˱ǳɱСķշߡǩԼе¼Ҫʧ󣬵˻ǶԽ׶дʶǶԼ۸
ȽдʶЩԴһ˵յʾȫɵԼɵģԸԭûЩʧ
£ͬʧɵĺͬһ㱻ΪЧġʧ׳Ϊ巺ĵͨʧ
գԶԵʧγɵĺͬҪʧ⳥ԷҵѽеͶʧԼǿġ
    ΥԼսԤͲǺͬһݡͬǩ󣬽˫ŶԺʣĺԤڣչԽ׵רͶʡ
רͶʹͬԼ˫һ˫¢Ϲϵ˴˼ֻ໥ͬʹԵͶʵõرͶרԵ
ǿͬϢԳƳ̶ȲͬĻΪ¼ƽ˫ƽϵʹ˫ɺĽ׶ν뵽Ǻ
׶Ρ˫ԺδԤ̫ԶºŸ߰Ľ׳ɱյºʧܡԣʱɰҪǵľ
ͨζԼмʧܼʧɵԭǱŷʧСԭաԼеĻ
գҪ߳еǳɱСķߡɶԷ˹ɵʧڻ߳еΧ֮УΪ
Сɱǹߣǻߡ¼µķգҪ˭ǳɱСĳеߡȷ
˫ͬеաͨͬԼշܣʹγɶԶԷԼҲγΥԼĻɱӶ
ԼΪҪǣԼʱ˿԰պͬγɵΥԼշ̸ֽУºָЧʡ
    ͬǩлΥԼĲȣʵϾ̸й̡ͬصоľǵ˽Ը״̬֮ʹԸ˳
ɵ⡣гֵ谭Ը˳ɵϰԷΪࣺϢԳµĻպϢȷ
¼˷ϰͷյĻԭɳɱС߳еաԤվԼľѧ塣һ㲻гԼҲ
ҵԼԼ
    3.Ȩƶ
    ÿ˶ӵȨʹȨɣȨʹԲַ˵ȨΪǰᡣȨǶ˺ϷȨַɴɵʵ
ϾһָⲿԡȨͨԼΪܺ˴˶ɱ˫˼ĹϵȨΪԺԸؽġ
ȨΪʹеȨòң谭ŶԺʣĺԤڣһֹ㷺ڵ谭Ը˳еء
    ˣȨƶȵĸ㼴ͨȷȨ⳥ƶȣʹȨ˽ɵⲿɱڲʹ˽˱߼ʳɱ߼
ɱһ£άеȨ֡ı׼ǽܺߵЧˮƽָûʱܴﵽˮƽ׼
Ϊ𺦵ֲҿԿǸԤˮƽĲͬ۸
    ȨɵⲿɱȨʱ״̬ⲿɱǷΪĲͬͬȨǹȨɵ
ɱӦܺЧˮƽĽΪݣһӦΪԤֺҪĳɱԹȨЧԤǲ
ܵģȨⲿɱߡɴɵⲿɱȫҪģû˿ã˶ƲҲ
ʹȨԤˮƽǱڵȨˡ
    ʧȨⲿɱȷڷ׼ȷ׼Ϊⲿԣûйʧ׼ⲿԣڹʧ
Ϊʧ޷رܵʵɱȫɹʧ˳еǽΣĺɴ˻Ӱ򣬷
˹ʧһֳɱееݾǷ׼ɴҲԿ׼Ҫԣ˼
ʧɱΡĺ¹ʽΪ׼ȷṩһѧ˵Ԥ𺦵ĳɱСԤɵʧʱ˲ȡԤ
ʩʹڹʧ֮ûйʧʵڱȽ˹ʧ𺦵ԤɱԤжϡ
    ϸǶ𺦻ΣΪⲿɱжۣǵ˵״̬ϸµⲿɱܺ˵Ԥ
ͽܵģȨ˵ǱȽԤͱġϸ淶ΪģΣճ̶Ⱥһ
ʧʮ־޴ĿǽΣΪķҪʹȨ㹻ĶԤͱɵⲿɱĶˮƽ
ʹβԵ˵״̬ΪתƣֻҪֻǹʧҲҪеΡʹΣΪ˵ԤˮƽҪ丶
Ŭֹֺķ
    ȨΪ˵̸вʹ˫ⲿɱĶ۴һ£޷ȷʧĳеͨȨһԼ۸
ϵܱܿ˽ֱӽ׵߳ɱùģƽͳɱҹֺһ˾ⲿɱк㣬ȷ˸
̸еԴ״ⲻ󻯵ؽȨʧҽ˲ȨתƣʹԭеĿѲõĲȨϵ
Ҿһش
    Ȩһֵ͵ĸⲿԣʹ˼Ըؽ׹ϵȫԸԭŤЧʡˣȨĿ
ƽ˽˳ɱɱֵĹϵָЧʡⲿԵĿ˷䲻ֱӴٽԸףͨƷԸΪӵ
γɴٽԸⲿңͨȨȨΪԼ۸ϵγԸԤͼȨʧ
ȻȨּ
    ƲͬȨֱ漰ȨĽ綨תͱ棬ΪǷϵɡ̸۶
ĽͣЧʹ۶¼顣̸ӦãΪ˵̸۵ĽԤΪ̸
Ƿѧ۵۵ṩǿ֧֡
            
    1.ѧķǽƶȾѧΧڵģƶȾѧķܣԴͳ۸۵衪
ˡȶƫú;ΪȨϢ׳ɱطƶȶԴõӰ졣ԸʵЧʵ;Ƿ
ѧڽ׳ɱΪУο˷Щ谭Ը˳ʵֵأȻسΪѧҪоݡ
    2.ѧǴӸгһзġʶɹγɵֻǲͬġԼ۸񡱣֮ķɹ
ϵֻһʽĽסɵüʹǽкĽ׳ɱСͺɴʧ
    3.̸۱ѧо˵ЧʶڷɵҪԡƶӰԴõҪأǾвݺӵء
ΪЧʣԷɰЧʵҪй졣ⲻָɵƶִҪЧԭ򣬸ҪǷɵҪΪʵЧ
Ļ෴һԵǰڽеҹгϵżΪش塣
α༭ʯ
οס
    [1]޲ءأ˹ס;ѧ[M].ϺꡣϺ磬1994.
    [2]κٰⲿ뷨[J].й⣬1998(4).
    [3]˹ҵгͷ[M].Ϻ꣬1990.
    [4]˹ɡɵľ÷[M].йٿȫ磬1997.
    [5]κѧľۻ[D].ϣɽѧѧԺ1998.
    [6]Calabresi.Costs of Accidents [M]. New Haven:YaleUniversity Press,1970.
    
    
    
 
