 ׺ 2-581
ԭĳʦѧѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200003
ԭҳš9299
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš200011
    Ƹĸʵϵ
    ˼Ľʽ
Ӣı⡿Practice of the Economic  System  reform  and  theTheory of Productive Relation
    A Re-interpretation of Marx's Theory of  TransactionalForms
                          WU Tian-lin
          ( Political  Economics  College  of  ShAAnxi  NormalUniversity, Xi'an 710062, China)
    
߼顿֣1949УɽˣʦѧξѧԺڡʦѧ  ξѧԺ    710062
ҪϵԴ˼ĽʽۡڱƶȵĸǲڴָǶϵ
ҹƸĸʵб¶ԵʷԣӦݸĸʵľ˼ĽʽۣϵȫΪ
ɵķָϵͺϵͳһ
ӢժҪThe concept of productive relation is derived  fromMarx's   theory   of   transactional   forms.  In   time    o
frevolutionizing  the  social  system, the   understanding   ofproductive relation was emphatically affected by the  view  o
fdistribution of material interests.The understanding  of  thissort has exposed its obvious  historical  limitations  in  th
epractice  of  the  economic  system  reform   in our country.Therefore, it is  necessary to re-interpret Marx's theory oftr
ansactional forms based on our experience drawn from thepractice of reform. According to Marx, productive relationshould be 
comprehensively  understood as a unity of thedistributive and  the  cooperative  relation of materialinterests among people 
formed in  the  process  of production.
  ʡƸĸ/ϵ/ʽ
    economic system  reform, the  theory  of  productiverelation,transactional forms
    
    ͼţF121  ױʶ룺A  ±ţ10005293 200003009208
    Ƹĸʵͳϵ⣺1 Ͷе֯ʽڲϵݣ2 
ᾭûеĲƷʽ˵гƷӳǲ֮һϵ3֯ʽ Ʒʽ
ϵռͶƷķʽ֮ϵεģлϳͳһϵϵȻҪشĸʵ
Щ⣬ȱԴͳϵ۵ʷԽз
            1
    ͳϵҪָ˹ֶϵݵķΪγɵĹ۵㡣ͨѧ̿ϵͳѧߵĹ㷺
ѱΪҹʶ̬ҲΪѧĹͬ۵Ҫ۵ǣϵ綨Ϊзһġ
ȻĲ־ΪתƵʹϵڷϵݹʱˡĻ˵͡˵ԼѶۺġ
˵Ļ˵ǰ˼תдڵ䡢ĸڵϵĸڡ
ʵӦϵĸ֮УڴڸеϵݵʲôǡǡҪʾ˵
ġ˵˹Ľʾ˵ϵΪ棺һϵʽɴ˲ĸֲ
ͬἯеĵλԼǵ໥ϵ˼˵ģཻȫΪתƵĲƷʽ[1] 
P594ѧ̿ϵͳ۵ʱ˼̵ġĻ˵˹ֹϵġ˵ۺһ𣬰
ϵݹɱΪΣϵƹϵеĵλͽϵƷϵԼֱӾѹϵ
ϵĸϵУϵġķ棬ϵĻ
    Ĺ۵Կͳϵ۴ԣһ۰ϵΪһָϵ
ų˶ϵĿǣǺɵԵʹϵӦ˵Խ׼Ϊ٣ΪҪ
ʷ׶ΣϵΪָϵʮȻģǷǳҪġΪģԽг
ΪĿĸĸʵУȴ˽¶Եʷԡ磬ũ˼ͥаƣɢ
ˡһ֯鴫ͳϵ۵ĽǣͥаʹũʹصȨѷ
ɹͬԼͶֱӹҹһ仰ϵĵũԡֻĽͣ㿴ԼͥΪλ
֯ʽʺֹΪũҵ״Ҳʺʱйũ˵ĻˣϵһҪʺ״
ָָϵҪʺϣһ֯ʽҲҪʺϡ
    ڶͳϵ۰ƹϵϵĻֹ۵ֻ²ȷģ1 ϵ
ΪָϵǴϵʱȻǻ2 ֻͬϲ㽨ϵ
ռͳελϵΪûʱϵеָϵű͹Գƹϵܱ
ƶȵʡֻҪıһ֯ʽƷϵָϵϵ֮Уͬ
ϵϵϵδؾϵĻҹľƸĸʵڸıҪΧ
չ˼ϵϵĹɼڹϵ
            2
    ϵɽʽݱ˼Ͷ˹ǺΨʷ۵ĵ֮־ʶ̬һУ״ʹ
˽ʽʽʽӦԭⲿУΨʷ۵Ļ˼Ѿγɣ
Щ˼ʱʹõﻹкܴĲȷԣȽϿʽˡˣǺһоо
ʹýʽڱǵʽϵʱȷϵʹϵʱͻ
ϵԺĽ͹бԽԽ򵥻ֱǰϵָͬϵŲ˴ͳϵ
۶ԾƸĸʵ͵ѡ
    ˼ʷ֤һ˼롢һһױ򵥻˼ֻγʱڲž޷չγʱڵ˼
ȻвȷԣΪˣžйĽͿռ䡣˼ĽʽγеϵۣҪشҹ
ĸʵ⣬бҪ˼ĽʽۣԨԴϵӦеݡڡ־ʶ̬У
˼Ͷ˹ʼհѽʽֹͽܵϵп죬ΪκµֻҪ
翪µأֹĽһķչ[4]P25ֹһʹǴ״̬һʹ֮Ľ
ΪҪĶͽǴһĽʽУֲϲֽʽ֡ڹȥһʷ׶Լ
ͬʱԼĽʽᡣչһ׶ϵһʽ[4]P41Щ
ǣʽʵָ֮ʽϵҲԳΪϵùϵϵʲôӳ
Ķᣨᣩʵֻǡչһ׶ϵһʽôչַֹԺ
ʷ׶ϣ֮һʽЩأзн԰Ѹ˵һʽ
ݾ廮ΪΣھͶߣߣΪнͶͶ
ͶƷͶƷΪнҪᾭҪأҪأΪнͶ

            3
    Ϊн֮ͶֽϵУΪߵʹߺֵ֧߳ģ֮
ܹʹú֧乤ߣֻΪͶ˵ܺܡˣֽУ˽ʽʵ
ʹú֧乤Ͷ֮ĽֽķΧڡͶ򡰸ͶУֱḶ́ͬ
ֱ֮еĹϵȻֽΪýģķչ˵µߵĳ֣
֮ͶĽͽʽҲȻᷢı䡣
    СΪչ׶ϣҪֹߣ˼ΪȻߡ[4]P71Ͷھ
ͶǡΪ߶е߲һ[4] P71˴˻ȫûзֿ[4]P72 
ĸˡֻҪͨʶܹ֧ʹùɾͶÿһͶ߼һʹùߵĹͶߣһ
֧乤ߣʹߣߣߣЭĹͶߡˣʷ׶ϣھͶ
ڲÿͶ߶Ϥȫ򣬷ĹܹһӦ[4]P58ֹߵľ鼼ص㻹ûв
ķֹڲ֮ͬһЩ򵥵ЭֳֻҪͿЭҵĻûбֻ
ΪרŵĶͶʷ׶ϵľͶǶĻߵ֧䣬ΪȨĸռ
ϵͳߴ̵ⲿϲԾͶ̺Ͷ߽ͳΣˣˡھ
Ͷ̵ⲿγɶȨԾͶ̵ͳδ˹
    ԴΪչ׶ϣ߳Ϊ˼Ϊߡ[4]P71ֹʹ
˱ۼһ[4]P71ͬһʱ໥ˣھͶڲӦʹͶߺͶ֮
ʵѾɷֹ[4]P72ͶߵĽϡ[4]P71һҪѲ˱Ϊлɲ֣
Ĺɰѹ˷ֽΪ²ͬλͲֵͬļ򵥲ߣΪߣһҪѰܺת֯Э
ͬ򡢲ͬλͲֵͬͶ֮以ĹͶߡΪһйģϴֱͶͬͶ
ٵҪָӣЭ˵Ļִ˶ͬĶٵ˶ĸһְܣһ
ԼָԼһֶӾҪһֶָӡ[2]P367 ֹУͶԼԼڻУͶ
ڲֻרŴ¹ְܡְ߼ΣˣʱУ;жʣ
ʱҵĹһͶ̵ʲͶ̵ְܣͬʱҲǰͶ̵ְܡ[2] P368
20֮չʹԶ͸ӻӶʹеļӣʹ𽥳ΪһҪѧͷ
ָӵרְҵеȨȨ룬ϵȨתΪɶ͹ɶıȨӪȨ
˶þӪǡ»;ײ㡣ΪִУҪҪУҪͨһҪִ߶ȵ
ҪһĿѧ[3]P394 ֻ߶ȷչĽ׶ϣǲܿͶ̳ΪĻΪ
һԶľûֱ̣Ḷ́ϵԼݡ
    Ͷ̵ΪͶЧʣҪȡߵܺ͹Ͷߵļܣֹ߷ʱǳ
ֻܵаѶлγʵʵֶ߽ϵ֮⣬ҪĻ
֯ʽ⡣ⲿڽоͶ֮ǰͱȷǰ֯ʽڲͶ
ʼձܰѶͳһˣھͶУ˵ϵͱΪ֯ʽ
Ͷ֮Ĳ֮ĽʽͶ߸˽ʵԼʽͬʱϵ
֯ʽǹͶ߽ԽйֶΣá̡άͲֹϵά̵ʹܹ˳
СˣͶеϵìܾߺ֯ʽìܡ֯ʽһҪʺߵ
˵߰ʹùߵͶߣھͶִеǻߵְܡˣͽʽĹϵǽ
ʽΪĹϵ[4]P78֯ʽͶ߸˵ͶӦڷӸ˵Ĵܡ
    εϣСƽͬ־˵èèֻҪ׽סǺè͵ϵʲôʽ
ΪãҪȡһ̬ȣʽĸطܹȽױȽϿػָͷչũҵͲȡʽ60
ũһĸ￪Ժũȫ˼ͥаơʵ֤֯ʽȽʺҹũҵ
״ֹߵܺũͶڳиĸУǰֳаʽᵽҵȴ⵽ձʧܣԭ
֯ʽʺϴҵ뽨ִҵƶȡ˾ơǰϵΪָϵ
ͱȻСƽͬ־ĽΪʱϵϵֻҪܰȥСΪͶ
еϵͬΪƶݵϵξϵȴݻͬᾭƶ£Щҵú
ЩҵòãؼǹݾǴʺܺߵͶʹЭ
֯ʽ
            4
    ͶƷΪн֮ҪֽϵУΪͶƷߺͽֵ߳ġΪ
ͶƷߣȨԼͶƷн֮ԳΪߣΪֹͶƷΪͶĲƷչ
ʹҪΪҪΪȫ淢չҪֻͨͶƷĽԼҪֽ
ͶƷȨ˽ʵռкͽͶƷҪ֮ĽֽķΧ
ͶУоͶ̡ͬľͶͨͶƷϵͶͶƷϵʵͶƷ
Ϊн˵ҪֽͶƷĴ̬ı仯仯
    С׶ΣͶڲûвķֹͶ֮Ҳֹ֮ȱϵԶ
ԼıƷԸȻãͶƷʱʵ̬šڲȴѷͶ;Ͷķ
¾Ͷ˳Ϊͳ߲뿪Ͷ̣ǰͶصȫת޸ͶߡͶǾͶ
ͶͶƷҪάͶߵ棬һҪͶͳߡͳߺ;Ͷ֮ͶƷΪ
ý뷢ֽͶƷĽΪΪͶܷɱĶĻռ
֧ĻͶ߻ΪԼΪߡΪͳߡΪԼ˶ǵͶƷȫ
ԼǻȨнͳ߸ͲͶûʲôͶƷԽڲҲҪͶƷ
ֱȨͳȨаᣬѾͶߵľ󲿷ͶƷΪСԶͶƷӶΪĽ
ʵֻҪһͳҪͶƷǵҪһǾͶҪȨǵ
ͽоͶİȫҪҲͶһоͶͬͳȨнͶĲƷȡ
ͶȨͳԼȨȡһоͶߵͶƷܣԴ̡άֺͼǿ
ͳȨˣֽͳ߶ԾͶߵֱͳκͰϵϵȨãҲȻ
ãȨԾûֱͳΡ
    ԻΪ׶ΣͶڲķֹھͶ֮ҲֹͶΪרҵ
ữƷǵͶƷҲƷ̬ڡͶ֮вƷܽҾͶ֮Ҳܹ
вƷΪʷ׶ϵľͶѳΪܷɱĶĻ߲ھͶ֮⣬ͳ
Ȩ֧ͶھͶڲþ̡֧ҲͶƷߣƷҲƷ
֮еĽƽȵĽʵ֮ҪҪữɵĸḻȫҪ
ҪҪͶĲƷͬһͶĲƷ֮䷢һͬзԵĻƷ֮
䷢һձԵĽձԵĽͶϵĲΪͬ
һͶһоͶֻͬĽתΪңתΪһͶܳΪͶлɲ֣
ЧͶѸͶͶѲڵȨڵľҵȡ
ͳ߳ΪµȨ
    ͨϷǿͶƷΪн֮ҪͶǡֹܷԼĲͬ˵Ĺ
ͬѸͶγɵͶƷʵ̬ʱѸͶ
ȨֽڵĽϣֽʵķԾһСʽľͶ
ȻСͶƷΪƷʱѸͶͳΪľҵҴӾ˶ڲ
ʲͬľͶֽͳΪữĴǴͶΧ
ϵͻᷢΧʵָͶϵָǰѸͶΪͶķ
ʽͶƷ֮Ľʽڴ׶ΣͶƷƷ̬ʱͶƷ֮ȻĽʽƷ
ϵ
    ҲεϣСƽͬ־ǿƻò壬ʱҲмƻгòʱ壬Ҳ
гƻгǾֶΡ֤ȯЩƷ÷ĶҪԡΪڻҵʱͶƷ
ֻƷ̬ڵ£ҪչữֻͨƷϵʹͶΪרҵữƷ
ҵüֵֻڸͶ֮ĹϵлؽͶгƷ
ϵĹ淶ƶȻȷձ黯ͶΧڣͶƷΪнһϵƷ֮
ҪʽָͬϵϵڲͬĲΡ
            5
    ҪΪн֮ͶҪָϺͶߣǾûеأ
ͶĽ̻̬˵Ͷ˼ΪͶͶǴʵͶˣ˼Ϊ
ͶۡͶǡͶͶҪΪý˵ĽʵݾͶĽ
˵ǡͶ͡ͶĽͶ֮ĽֽΪͶеͶ
ͶеҪʷǰ߼ǰᡣΪʽΣͶߺʼءǣڱ˴˷
ֻڿءҪͱǽ[5]P44
    ԭʼ£ϺͶߵĽֱӵĽϡֻ˽£ϺͶߵĽϲǵķΪǰᣬ
ַչرɷֹµģֹͰͶͶߺͲϵķ䣬ҲŻ
ڸ˽֣֮ӶҲʱͶ֮ķԼƱĸֲͬʽ[4]P73С׶Σڷֹ
ϺͶ߻ûг׷룬ռϵͬʱҲռͶߣūƣռͶߣ⽨ƣͶ
ĽûзչռϵͳǿԵذͶֻ߽Сڴҵ;У
˵һһԼԡһƬԶںΪ򵥵ʽ˽ƺͶʱ[4]P72Ͷ롰Ͷ
ϺͶ߲ų׷벢ͶĽųΪȻȱһͻֹͣ[4]P73ֻռ
ϵʱҺ;ɵĹӶͶ֮ĽֽΪʱе
    ϺͶߵĽʽϵƹϵֹϵ֮ͶġϺͶΪҪ
ķչϸıԼ̬Ϊн˵ͶʽҲȻ仯ʽ
ݱ䡣Ͷ߱Ϊ˵ĹߣҪūʱͲūƣͶأسΪҪʱ
صĵȼռв˷⽨ȼƣͶ߳ΪһеˣʱΪҪʱʱռвʱ
ơڲͬ£ϵеĵλͽϵȻǲͬģɴĶͶƷķϵѹϵҲȻ
ͬˣǿ˽ūūũʱҺ͹Ӷˣͳߺͱͳߣߺͱߣ
Ÿ˺ˣͶʳߺͶʳߵìЩǴͳϵӳʵݡ
    ɴˣǲѿͳϵҪΪнͶʽ⣬ֽʽУ˵ϵԶ
ϵռйϵͶͶƷķϵֳʵϷӳ˵ķָϵǣڷָ֮ǰȱ
ʵֳߴҪǵ棬Ҫ˵ĺεĺҪرǿֱĺھ
ͶеĺֺΪΪнͶĽֽͨʹͶЭʹùͶƷ
ȽϼӺ͸ӵĺͶеĺֺΪͶƷΪнҪֽͨʹͬͶƷ
ڽתΪͶлɲ֣ΪҪЧͶ߳Ϊʵ֡ˣǱѾͶ
е֯ʽͶеĲƷʽҲϵֽʽУ˵ϵͶ
ϵҪϵֳģʵʷӳ˵ϵ
    ǰϵ綨ΪɵϵһĲ˵־ΪתƵ
ϵϵ˵ϵָϵҲ˵ϵҲе
ìܹϵͳһָĶֻкΪȥȻ磬ǵ
档ָֻͨʵͬἯţճΪ˵Ʒϵдεĺϵ
ͶеͶϵͶеҪϵָϵд׶εķָϵ
֮ǰϵռйϵ֮ͶƷķϵķָϵͺϵ֮䣬Ӧǿָϵᴩ
ںϵ֮СΪھͶ֮ǰƹϵֹϵᴩھͶ̵ʼգͶγ֮ǰȷ
ͶƷȨȨᴩڲƷ̵ʼգԲƷķϵʵķָһµռС
ķָϵΪᾭƶȵĻݣϵƹϵֳΪƶʵı־ˣΪ˱ƶ
ҪȷͬƶȵʱǰϵΪָϵϵƹϵԵĹϵǱҪ
ģҲȷġǽоƸĸʱǱעϵϵڲıƶȵǰ
½оƵĸĸָĸĸĿǴٽչʵ֡ĸִˣ֯ʽͲƷʽıｫ
иͻá
    ոڣ20000323
οס
    [1]˹ѡ¾M.磬1979.
    [2]˼˹ȫ23M.磬1972.
    [3]ȫ30M.磬1957.
    [4]˼˹ѡ1M.磬1972.
    [5]˼˹ȫ24M.磬1972.
    
    
    
 
