 ׺ 2-606
ԭĳϺƾѧѧ
ԭںš200004
ԭҳš311
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš200012
    ͬ˵
Ӣı⡿Economic Growth and Convergence HypothesisZHU Bao-hua, XU Li-tianSchool of  Economics,   Shanghai  University  o
f  Finance  andEconomics, Shanghai, China,200433
    챣/
߼顿Ϻƾѧ  ѧԺϺ  200433챣1963У㽭ˣϺƾѧѧԺڣʿʦ
죨1972ŮϾˣϺƾѧо
ҪҪ뾭صͬ˵Դصľú壬1990ͬ˵о򣬽
֤ͬ˵ҪҪʵ֤оͨ˵¾ɾۼĲһЩ̽֡
ӢժҪThis  paper  discusses  the  origin  and   implications   ofconvergence hypothesis in the growth theory. It  als
o  reviewshow to test the convergence hypothesis by  regression analysisand  some  related  positive  results  about  the  c
onvergencehypothesis.
  ʡ/ͬ/عgrowth/convergence/regression
    
            һǰ
    1960ĸľʵٶ֮źܴĲ죬һЩҵƽʴﵽ2 
òҵľʼӽ㣻ڸ÷չУȻֹҵƶõƣҲڲֹҵƶû
Сơν1960֮ĸʵѳΪҪһҪ⡣1990ռݾ
λҪSolowSwan صĴͳۺΪ¾֡ڸĲ
죬߸˲ͬĽ͡ͳΪ˾˾ʱĲ쵼˸֮Ĳ죬ʱƣ
ʼĲпʧһأͳ˾ϵ͵Ĺһнϸߵľʵͬ˵  
convergence hypothesisȻ¾ΪҪǸĲ쵼˸ʵĸߵͣ˾ûб
ȻϵʵĲ첻һʱƶʧǣͬ˵ĳͲΪж¾ۺԵҪ
׼ҶƶʵٽҲҪĲο塣1990ͬ˵ľΪʵ֤оҪ
ɲ֣ӿ˴йͬ˵оףóһЩڷչйҽ߽ۡҪͬ˵о򣬼򵥶Ҫ
̽ͬ˵ĺ弰侭ȷ⴫ͳۺ¾۵ĲṩһЩο
            ͬ˵ĸ
    ͳҪǿҪͶھеã侭ĳҲȻѡΪҪͶ뾭
໥ϵSolow1957 ͨʷֽɸҪͶʵĺҪضԾӰ̶ȣ
˵ҪͶͼھáھйģ治ʵͼg[,A]Ļϣ ʱķ
ΪӦͶͶg[,L]ʱͶg[,K]򾭼g[,Y]ɷֽʽ
    g[,Y]g[,A]g[,K]1g[,L]             1
    ʽ1ȷļǴӾʿ۳ʱͶͶͶ빱ʵʣ࣬Ҳͨʽ1ļʳΪSolowв
Solow's residualsSolow1957о19191949֮䣬GNPƽΪ2.9ʱͶĹ׳
Ϊ0.32ͶͶĹ׳̶Ϊ1.09Ĺ׳̶ȴΪ1.49ԼռGNPʵ87 
ҪԴȪSolow1957 оȷ˼ھеҪԣûо漰ܷͨϾ
ԣҵͬ˵⡣ˣͬ˵뼼ûбȻϵͬ˵Ӧͨ漰Solow-SwanģͶ
˵
    ٶ漰йģ治ʣ˾ʱkӦΪfkʱͶΪg[,L]Ӧ
sʱ۾ʦģɵõµSolow-Swan ģ͵Ļ̡
            k[,t]sfk[,t]ģg[,L]k[,t]    2
    ˾ʱg[,k]Ϊkkʽ2Ϳɵʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                3
    fkʿ֪kf'kfkΪ ˾ʱg[,k]˾ʱkļ˾ʱ˾ʱ
ĸؾͳΪͳ۵ͬ˵ԭ㡣һص˾yͨʽ2ɽ˾g[,y]ʾʽ

    ͼ{ͼ}                               4
    ʽ2g[,k]Ļϣ˾g[,y]˾ʱ kĵͿɱʾʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                 5
    ʽ5֪˾g[,y]˾ʱkĵݼ˾ʱʼֵСˮƽʱ˾˾ʱ
˾ȴ˾ʱļҪָǣ˾ʱΪ˾ʲһ˾ʱļ
ˣ˾ʱǰ£˾˾ʱĸؾ͹ͬ˵Ļ͡һþ״̬˾ʱ
k[*]봢s໥ϵɽ˾ʱg[,k]ʾʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                  6
    ʽ6֪˾ʱk½ζʱƽfkk˾ʱg[,k]ߡ ֻ˾ʱĳʼֵС
ֵʱſֽܳϵ͵˾ʱӦϸߵ˾ʱʵΡرأʱƽfkkԶԶֵfk[*]
 k[*]ʱϵ˾ʱӦϸ˾ʱʵЧΪԡ ˣֻҪ˾ʱʼֵֵĲ첻ʱͲܳ˾
ʱϵ͵ӵнϸߵľʵ
    Ϊͬ˵ĻǾ˾ʱg[,k]ĺkf壨kfkΪԲǴͳۻ¾ֻۣ
ҪһȡֵΧڣ˾ʱ˾ʱļͱȻͬ˵һΪ¾봫ͳ۵ı
𲢲Ƿͬ˵ͬ˵ʡݴͳ۵Ľ֮ͣĲҪ
ʱӰ첢ʱԣöԽϿ⡣¾Ϊ˾ʱ첢Ǿ
ĸԭ򣬳ڸʵּȷĲʹø֮ԵĲ졣ǣȻͬ˵ľ
ֲֻܾͳ¾۵ԺԣⲢųͨͬ˵ľԽһȷͳ
¾֮ıʲĿԡ
    ͬ˵ֻ֪Ҫ˾ʱʼֵƫֵڸ˾ʱĶ̬У˾ʱʼֵСĹҪ
ʱʼֵĹҾиߵľʡˣͬ˵Ҹ˾ʱֵ໥ӽʱӦôھķչй
ϾøԣķҵĿԡȻʷ˾֮ڲ죬Ҹ˾ˮƽ֮Ĳ
ҲһС򣬻ƣֱӵõͬ˵ĽۡΪ˵ʲͬ˵໥ϵ
Barro and Sala-i-Martin1992 ݾͬ˵ΪڲǾǰ£
ؽұȾøԣҾиߵ˾ʵļ˵Ϊͬ˵ľھ忼Ǹͬľʱ
ʵĸߵƫ״̬ĳ̶ȳȵļ˵Ϊͬ˵ͬ˵ľ֤ͬ
˵ľ˾ȫݶìܵġ
    ּٶNɵȺ徭ôͬ˵ľbȡֵΧ01֮䣬Ӧit˾y[,it]u[,i
t]ͬ˵ľɱʾʽ
    lny[,it]1blny[,it1]u[,it]            7
    ʽ7˾lny[,it]y[,it1]˾lny[,it1]ʸζͬ˵ľĳSolow-Swa
nģͲܳԾЧӦּģͿ漰ԾЧӦΪԾ    leapfroggingЧӦ͹ȷӦ      
overshootingЧӦбҪ޶bȡֵС1ʽ7ĲbҲӳ˾ʱʼֵֵʡٶ˾
u[,it]ľֵΪ0ͦ[2][,u]tڸ˾lny[,it] ƽֵΪ[,t]˾lny[,it]
D[,t] Ϳɱʾʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                      8
    ڹɹȺԱNʱôʽ7ɽ˾lny[,it]ķD[,t]ı仯̱ʾʽ
    D[,t]֣1bD[,t1][2][,u]                9
    ͨһײַ̣9֪˾ķֵD[*]ڦ[2][,u][11b[2]] Ҹ˾ķ
ֵD[*]ͬ˵ľЧӦǿС[2][,u]Ӷӡڸ˾ķֵD[*] 
ʼֵD[,0]ϣ˾ķD[,t]ı仯̾Ϳͨʽʾ
    D[,t]D[*]1b[2]D[,t1]D[*]D[*]1b[2t]D[,0]D[*]                                10
    ʽ10֪ڲbȡֵС1˾D[,t]ȻֵD[*]ֵD[*]ķʽ
Բͬġڸ˾ķʼֵD[,0]СֵD[*]ʱ˾ķԵʽֵD[* ]֮
˾ķʼֵD[,0]ֵD[*]˾ķԵݼʽֵD[*]
    ֤ͨͬ˵ʹõݻǺݿɽͬ˵Ϊͦһ£ʱ
صͬ˵ұȾøԣҾи߾ʣҾ˾˾Ͼøԣ
Ϊϵͬ˵˾˾ķʱƶݼ
ΪܴòͬݵĽǶȶͬ˵Ħ֮ͦ仹Ǿһ໥ϵʵϣi 
t˾y[,it]u[,it]ľֵͷΪ0ͦ[2][,u[,t]]ͬ˵ɽit˾ʽƵرʾ
ʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                       11
    ٶtڸ˾lny[,it]ĺ򷽲Ϊ[2][,t]ʽ11Խ˾ĺ򷽲仯ķʽʾ
¡
    ͼ{ͼ}                                        12
    u[,it]ķ[2][,u[,t]]Ϊ[2][,u]ʱҸ˾ĺ򷽲ĳʼֵΪ[2][,0] ͨһײ
ַ̣12Ϳɽ˾ĺ򷽲[2][,t] ʾʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                        13
    ͬ˵ĦζŲΪͬ˵ĦҲͬڸ˾ĺ򷽲[2][,t] Ҫעǣ
ͬ˵Ħͬ˵ĦıҪͬ˵Ħͬ˵Ħĳ
    ͬ˵Ħͦ⣬ͬ˵ľĻϣDurlauf and Johnson1995Quah1996 
Ⱥͬclub convergenceĸGalor1996ĽͣȺָͬƾýṹȺԱֻҪƵľʼ
ȺԱ˾;гͬʡʵϣȺͬĿҪǿҪԸĺݽʵ
ϲչͬ˵֤ıҪԡ
            ͬ˵֤
    ͬ˵˵ʼ˾˾ʱʸضûоָ֤ȷͬ˵֤ͳΪһ
Ҫ⡣Mankiw, Romer and Weil1992עشͳۺԵĻϣ  ͨ²赼֤ͬ˵Ļع鷽̡Ma
nkiw, Romer and WeilоڼٶHarrodͼĻϣþйģ治ʵCobb-DouglasҪΪʱK
ͶL״̬ΪAղY¡
    Y[,t]K[][,t]A[,t]L[,t][1]          14
    һؽЧ˾ʱ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ֱΪKAL YALͶg[,L] ͼg[,A]ĻϣӦsʱ۾ʦģʱ
۷̿ɽΪYL ˾yʾʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                   15
    ͨʽ15ȷ˵ķţҲܴƶϳ1ĴСݸĹ񾭼ͳݿ֪ ʱ
ʦȡֵΧһ13ңʽ15ȷ˾ĴʵҲӦ12ǰMankiw, Romer and Weil  Summers    and
Heston1988ݽзĽϿΪͳƷϴͳ۵ļٶʱʦԼ0.6ǰ 
ͳݡΪˣMankiw, Romer and WeilֽʱղƵ֤ͬ˵Ļع鷽̡ڵʱH 
ٶС1ĻϣMankiw, Romer and Weil ղY̵Cobb-Douglasʾʽ
    Y[,t]K[][,t]H[][,t]A[,t]L[,t][1]  16
    ʱͶʺʱͶʵĴʷֱΪs[,k]s[,h]ʱʱ۾ʾΪʱЧ˾ʱ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    Ļ۷̾Ϳɵʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                     17
    ʽ15ʽ17ȿ֪ʱھеҪãʱЧӦֻͨع鷽̣15
ֳΪʺͶʽԲͬķʽӰЧʱľֵ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ڳʱʱʽ15ʽ17лعܿͶʶ˾Ӱ졣    
Summers and Heston1988ݵMankiw,Romer and Weil ķʾʱSolow-SwanģͶؾͳ
˵̶ȵõ̶ܴȸƣʱʵĲĹֵҲϹ񾭼ͳݡ
    ΪԴڴͳ۵ͬ˵ص̵ĸ˾ʵĲ죬  ˾ͬ  Ի
Solow- Swan ģ͵ͬ˵ϸ  ͨMankiw, Romer and Weil1992Ļع鷽̵ϵȷͬ
˵ʡͨɽʽ17ȷĶЧ˾ֵ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʾʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}            18
    ڶЧ˾ĳʼֵΪ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ʱʽ18Ϊ΢ַɵʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                          19
    ٴζӦʱs[,k]ʱs[,h ] Cobb-Douglas16ӦЧ˾
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ɽʽ19дʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                              20
    ʽ20Ч˾Ч˾ʼֵĺͨñҪͳƶϲ˵ĹֵͿ֤ͬ˵
Mankiw, Romer and Weil1992ͨоָʱSolow-SwanģܽϺõ˵ʷ
ͬ˵ڰʱʱȻܸݾʼ˾Ƿʸض򵥵غͳ¾۵
ӡ
    Mankiw, Romer and Weil1992Barro and Sala-i- Martin1992оĻϣBernard and Durlauf1996 һؽ
ڻع֤ͬ˵оΪࡣһ֤ͬ˵оҪ۳ʼ˾뾭ʵ໥ϵ
ͼͨʼ˾뾭֮ĸ˵ҵľʸھøԣҵľʡڶ֤ͬ˵о
ظ֮˾ĳڲ죬Ŀ˵ڵ˾ʱģ˾Ĳ콫ʱƶʧ
ͬʱBernard and Durlauf Ϊͨع֤ͬ˵ҲԴʱзĽǶ֤ͬ˵
ͬϢϵδ˾ͬԤֵƶΪʱԤͬtime-series  forecast convergenceԣڵi
͵jt˾ֱΪy[,it]y[,it]ʱʱԤͬt ϢϦ[,t]ĻϿԵõʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                       21
    ʽ21Ļϣ֤ͨ˾ͳ֮Ƿڵλunit rootͬʱƣcommon time trendͿ
ȷʱԤͬĳ񡣽һأ Bernard  and  Durlauf1996ʱԤͬΪǿʽʽʱԤͬǿ
ʽζ˾ʱ֮ڵλͬʱƣʱԤͬʽζŸ˾ʱ֮
co-integration̡  ʱԤͬ Bernard   andDurlauf1995оȷOECD Ⱦ÷ҵľ
дʱԤͬ
    Durlauf and Quah1999ΪȻ19601990֮䣬˾ƽֻ2.25ңʵĲ
ǵ¸һ־ҵľõõܴķչеҵСӸֲͬǶȶ
ͬ˵ֲı仯ӦóֳһĹģԡˣͬ˵оֲĶ̬仯̾ͳΪ
۵ľоҪɲ֡ٶӦt ڸ˾ĺֲF[,t]ĸʲΪ[,t]ͨʲȦ[,t] ļ޷
ֲĳڱ仯ơӳֲ仯ĸʲȦ[,t]ļ޷ֲΪһʱΪڸ˾
ȵơӳ˾ĺֲĸʲȦ[,t]ļ޷ֲΪֲֲ̬˵ܵ¸
ȻӳֲĸʲȦ[,t]ļ޷ֲԲֲͬĸʲȦ[,t]ȻһĹԡ
ʲȦu[,t]Cartesian˻ӳ䵽ΪT[*]ӳֲĸʲȦ[,t]ı仯ɾͿ
ͨʽ
    [,t]T[*][,t]u[,t]T[*][,u][,t1]22
    ʽ22ڰu[,t]T[*][,u]Ļϣ øʲȦ[,t]һײֲַĶ̬仯
ֲ仯תƸʾΪMʱ ˾仯ҪϢתƸʾMбԡǣ ӳ˾
ĺֲĸʲȦ[,t]ı仯̾Ϳͨʽ
    [,t1]M[,t]                              23
    һʽ23ɽӳtsڸ˾ĺֲĸʲȦ[,ts]дɣM[s][,t]ʽ תƸʾ
MΨһΪ1תƸʾM[s]תƸʾM[,]ͱȻʽ
    [,]M[,]                                24
    ˣʽ24[,]бԣ ҲǸ˾ĺֲĳڼޡQuah1996о
˾ĺֲĳڼ޾˫ԣ÷չĽ¸
            ġͬ˵ʵ֤о
    ͬ˵ϵ¾۵ۣ漰뾭صĹƶʿ͹ȷ֤ͬ˵ͳ
Ϊоص֮һȻͬ˵ԭ˵ʸߵʼ˾ˮƽɸأûųҲ
ñĿԡˣΪõ֤ͬ˵˾yĻٵñX˵ƽ
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ĸߵ֤ͣͬ˵Ļع鷽̶ʽ
    ͼ{ͼ}                                      25
    һ£ñXļϰӳ˿ ʱŴһʡͶʻʱ桢۱仯䡢ó
Ϊεȷıʽ25Ļϣ֤ͬ˵ͱ֤bȡֵǷΪ⡣Barro1997ȵ
оԽͬ˵ľ۵ʵ֤оҪ۴¿ɹɳ¼㡣
    һͨعõͬʻȶ2ң ͬȶԭҪʱʱıʵĵݼԡ
ݵĹʺ쳣ֵ⣬2 ͬʲһʮֿšһЩݸݵоΪͬʵȡֵ
ΧԼ030֮䲻ȡ
    ڶͬصļãڿ͹ȱڣObjectGapsȱڣIdeal Gaps˹۵㡣͹ȱڹ۵Ϊ
ڼǹƷҸɻȡȫҪʣTFP ֲ䡣ʱرʵݼTFPͳΪھʡ
ľջڸķչ׶ΡƶȡͶʻƺصȲͬʵʾʲһܹ
ȫͬ½ϵ͵Ĺǳлʩȿ͹ء۵оΪˮƽ仯80ֿ˿ʡ
ʱʡʱʵؽͣӵüСչѧеȱڹ۵Ϊר
ĲҪʵܻȡʱǴҪأȱٱҪļΪԼҪأȫҪҲȻͬ
Temple1999ΪܼȡõģҵļδʺƶңֻʺϱʵʵȽʱ
ŻЧڿǼغͬ˵ͲͨʱݼнͣҼռתҲӰͬ˵ͬ

    оڷҵľҪáʵ֤о19501960оͶʻر30
50֮䡣þоͳݵOECDеоȻоͶ뾭ʵϵȷо
Ͷʻ뾭ʸ߶صġ
    ģƽھͬ˵ʵ֤о벻ƽ뾭أƽԵȽ
ԡAghionCaroli and Garcia-Penalosa1999оΪ벻ƽȶԾĸҪԭǲƽ
Ͷʻ᣻ǲƽȷͶʵĻԣ벻ƽɺ۾õĲȶ
    壬ų̶뾭໥ϵָϵжϿų̶뾭໥ϵҪóƶȵӦ
ϵ⡣ڴͳóױ̶ȵָѼ㲢Ի㹻ݣͬ˵ʵ֤ҪʹóGDPıʡ л
ʵĿų̶ȡһоڿžõĸھͬƣܴٽóһЩо
վÿҲѭȽԭ򿪷ŵľþиõľüЧ
    ʱҲӰ쾭Ҫ֮һԵõչйҵйعʩݣַͨչ
ҵĵ绰͵ָܵ귢뾭ԣʩ֧ʱͶʵᱨʣٽ
    ߣȶ뾭أԽ÷չ̶ȵ谭
    ͬ˵ʵ֤о漰ᾭأҲֻϵͬ˵̽һЩΪ˼йóƵݡ
йͬ˵оһЩɲDurlauf and Quah1999Mc Grattan and Schmitz1998ġ
οס
    1Aghion, Philippe, Eve  Caroli  and   Cecilia   Garcia-Penalosa.Inequality and Economic Growth: The  Perspective  of
the New Growth TheoriesJ.Journal of  Economic   Literature,Vol.37,pp.16151660,1999.
    2Barro,Robert J.and Xavier Sala-i-Martin.ConvergenceJ.Journal of Political Economy,Vol.100,pp.223251,1992.
    3Barro Robert J. Determinants  of  Economic  Growth: ACross-Country Empirical StudyM . Cambridge  Mass, The  MIT
Press,1997.
    4Durlauf,Steven N.and Paul A.Johnson. Multiple Regimesand Cross-Country Growth Be-haviourJ. Journal  of  Applied
Econometrics,Vol.10,pp.365384,1995.
    5Durlauf,Steven N.and Danny T.Quah. The  New  Empiricsof Economic Growth in Jphn B.Taylor and Michael  Woodford  eds
.Handbook of Macroeconomics,pp.231304,North-Holland,1999.
    6Galor,Oded.Convergence? Inferences  from  TheoreticalModelsJ.Economic Journal,Vol.106,pp.10561069,1996.
    7Jones,Charles I.Convergence revisited J . Journalof Economic Growth,Vol.2,pp.131153,1997.
    8Kaldor,Nicholas. Capital  Accumulation  and  EconomicGrowthN.in Friedrich A. Lutz  and  Douglas  C. Hague , eds
. Proceedings  of  a  Conference  Held  by  the  InternationalEconomics Association,London,Macmillar.,1963.
    9Mankiw,N.Gregory,Romer, David  and  Weil, David  N. AContribution  to  the  Empirics  of  Economic   Growth J .
Quarterly Journal of Economics,Vol.107,pp.407437,1992.
    10 Mc  Grattan, Ellen  R. and  James  A. Schmitz, Jr.Explaining Cross-Country Income Differ- ences R . FederalRe
serve Bank Of Minneapolis,Research Department Staff  Report,No.250,1998.
    11Quah,Danny T.Twin Peaks:Growth  and  Convergence  inModels of Distribution DynamicsJ.Economic Journal,Vol.106,
pp.10451055,1996.
    12Solow,Robert M.Technical Change  and  the  AggregateProduction FunctionJ.Review of Economics  and  Statistics,
Vol.39,pp.312320,1957.
    13 Summers, Robert  and  Heston, Alan. A  New  Set  ofInternational Comparisons of Real  Product  and  Price  Levels
Estimates for 130 Countries,19501985J. Review  of Incomeand Wealth,Vol.34,pp.125,1988.
    14Temple,Jonathan R.W.The New Growth  Evidence J .Journal of Economic Literature,Vol.37,pp.112156,1999.
    ոڣ20000612
    
    
    
 
