 ׺ 2-637
ԭĳѧѧ
ԭںš200004
ԭҳš517
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200010
    йĲȨ뾭
Ӣı⡿China's Fiscal Decentralization  and  Economic Growth
    LIN  Yifu and LIU Zhiqiang
    (Research Center  of  Chinese  Economy, Peking University,Beijing 100871,China)
ע͡ǸлHans BinswanferJack HouաSuzanne Piriou SallAnwar Shah޺㸦Աĳ
ۺͽ顣ǵоõкۿƼѧֺ֧19981 1318գ̩Royal orohid Sheraton ٿˡ
컷̫ƽϾ֯顱ûύģĻǶԸĵ޶塣пܵĴ߸
    /־ǿ
߼顿־ǿѧ  йоģ  100871
    1952У̨ˣѧйоΣڣʿʦ
Ҫʡй80ʼĲȨھáǷ֣ڿͬʱĸ
ʩӰ󣬲Ȩʡ˾GDPʡ Ȩ߾Чʵļ˵һ¡⣬ǻũĸǹв
ŵķչԼʱҲƶйڹȥ20ѸĹؼء
ӢժҪWith    an    analysis    on   the  contribution  of  fiscaldecentralization  initiated  in  the  1980s  to  the
  economicgrowth   in   China,  this   paper    argues    that    fiscaldecentralization has  raised  the  growth  rate  of 
 real  percapita GDP at the province level.To have a positive effect  oneconomic growth, fiscal resources and decisionmaki
ng  powersshould  be  decentralized  to the lowest feasible level of thegovernment.Besides, the  rural  reform, nonstate s
ectors andcapital accumulation are the key  driving     forces   of  theimpressive growth in China in the past two decades o
r so.
  ʡй/Ȩ//ĸ
    China; fiscal  decentralization/  economic reform/economicgrowth
    
    ͼţF812.2    ױʶ룺A  ±ţ1000 5919200004000513
            1.
    2070ĩʼøĸйӽ10Ƽ¼ٶһУضҪá
ʹͥΪλũҵĸҵʼҵĸּ۸ĸó׺Ͷʵг
ԼǹвŵȵȡڶĸĸʩУһҪĵȴûбоķʼ80ĲĸҪ
ֲ̽ȨǷйõŻá
    ӹϽйĲȨطĲȨûв𣬶ָ·ŸطЩȨӵ
УȨطת߾ЧʣΪȣطԴϾϢƣOates
1972עЧʸƵĹ۵ΪѧܣBahlLinn1992Bird1993֮طԸõṩֹ
Ʒķ㱾ҪңطĹԱеṩƷʱҲʹڵؾܵļල֮£ӶҲ
жȥʹǵĲְΪı棨   Shah Qureshi1994⣬йĵطŴĵطҵ 
ȨӲ˵طҵlocalenterprisesԤԼQianRoland1996ӶߵطҵЧʣ¸ٵġɳ
ľȨҲܻ̬Ч档йԾָƶȰŻӰ쾭עBarro 
1990kinRebelo1990ԼJorgensonTun1990 ԤƲƶȴӼȨȨת䣬    ߾õĳʣ
Oates 1993Liu1997
    Щ˶ԲȨʹЧߵ˵ɡȣΪطʵϲûԵϢơطǲ
Եƫӵ㹻ϢĹԱʹڼеĲƶ£ҲԴùзáΣľҲ
¼ĹԱĲ룻ڴչйңطĹԱѡٲǷõȥϤ
ֵûɵģʹǶʮ˽⣬Ҳδ㹻ļȥ¡ עȻ ޷ȥ϶ȨǷᵼЧ
ʵߣ 뾭ϸʵ֤½ۡ Щ˴ӶԺ۾õĿƺ͸̰۵ĿǶԲȨн̬ȡ
Puod'homme1995Դ꾡ңйĵطһ㶼ֱӵоصҵǿܻøóױ
ԱҵӶгķָѰΪЧʵʧ
    80йĲƶȾҪı仯һֵһȫ뼯еԤƶȱΪһԷȨ
ƶȰš͵طӵԼĲ롣ƶȰ£󲿷ʡһ뽫ʡһֲϽ
һЩʡݵĲ֧룬ܻЩʡṩһЩһʡڲĸҲƵĲ
š
    ĸΪֹľöйδĸĸΪҪӵԣƶȵı仯ھ
ôĸĸӦڽһ̷Ȩĸĳɹʹ֮ƶȻ෴ȨԾûʲôãйӦ
ʵиΪеĲƶȣӦĸĸʹȨĲƶȵĺôܹȫӳ
    о岻Ƕйľøĸۡк֯ڻоҡйͰ
͢ʵʩĸֲĸ﷽ϣпΪ׼вĸĹṩľѵǶȿозǳ
Ҫʵüֵͬʱ۲˵ĶԲȨǷ߾Чʵʵ֤ҲǶԾѧ׵һס
    йøĸоţ䶰кĸԾ׵סZhangZou1996ԼMa1997о
⡣עдǶ¶йĸĸ涼ۣwong19911992Ǯweingast1995ȡǰΪ
Ȩھó෴ĽۡȻѧߵоԴΪǵķУҪôʹõķȨָп
֮ҪôûаͬʱĸĸʩҲǽȥ
    ڶԾолعǱ㷺ܵķڱоҲʹһȨ
ԾӰ졣19701993ʡһݡǵĹƽȨԾáǻ֣
˲ĸ⣬ũĸǹвŵķչʱҲйڹȥʮĿ˹ؼԵƶá
    о㴴¡һʵ֤У˼з˲ƶȵı仯ԾʵӰ⣬ͬʱòͬı
ҪĸĸʩһҲǸΪҪһǣǰѧ߲ͬʹ˱߼ʷֳʡʡһӲӶ
ıһָȨĳ̶ȡ
    ְ£ڵ2ڣ ͸ʡϵı仯Ϊص㣬й80Ĳĸ3 ڹ
һģͣ4ڶݽ˼Ҫۣ5ڸ˹ƽһڸ˱оĽۡ
            2.йĲȨ
    ڸĸǰйĲƶǸ߶ȼеġעԸĸǰƶȵϸۣLardy1975KsensergTong1991wong 
1995Լ֣Lin1997λ߻8090 Ĳĸϸ͸ط֮Ĺϵ
Ϊͳͳ֧طûԼԤ㣬ȫĲ벢ƶһȫ¼ͳһԤ㡣ֲ
ҲҵҵϽеʣ࣬ͨҵĸ֧ʵϣ
ҵʽҲҲŵһ֡
    еĲƶйڸĸǰȡļеԴģʽһµģ1979ʼгĸﲻݡҪ
ƶйƶȵı仯һǷǹҵҵӪҵ˽ӪҵĿӶı˹ҵһͳµ
档ĹҵԽԽ࣬˹ҲĳظòȥѰԴڶǾøĸʹطֵ
ȨõǿȻʹøطڲӦľȨҪ󡣵򴿴Եھϵԭ򡣾ἫӰ
ΪΪʹطжȥŬ߲ƶͱı伯еĲƶȡ
    ĸƣĸһʼҲԵġ1977꣬ڽʡһʡŵְţʡ
ҪͬĹ涨ÿϽһָϽɷݶʡȥĲ֧
    1980ʵΪ֧ԷĲİšţ밴ԴΪ̶
˰ֱӵеĹҵϽɵĲ룩ط̶루˰ũҵ˰˰ɵطӵеĹ
ҵϽɵĲ롢˰Լطز˰ط루͵طͬ쵼Ĵҵ󡢹˰Ӫ
ҵ˰
    1980İм⣺㶫ʡ͸ʡÿϽһ̶룬µȫʡ֧䡣
ء½ɹšġд۾ӵƶƫԶʡຣϡԴò
ÿ10ٶӡ
    ȻȻŵһ겻䣬ʵϷȴƵı䣬19821983ˡ1980Ȩ
ŵЧڷǳݡ
    1983꣬˰Ʒش仯ҵʵ˰ܲԱֳࡪ̶롢ط̶͹
룬ֵȴ˸ı䡣ǰҪǸݶԹҵȨ룬µĻֱ׼˰ϵ
    Ϊʹ˰ܹ͸ͬطᡢӦ̯취14ʡݣ3ֱϽУ ǩ
Э飬ÿϽһݶĵط̶͹롣㶫ʡͺʡΪŻݣֻϽһ̶롣
5ʡݴһ̶ת롣ʣµ7ʡõÿ10ٶӵĲ
    1985ĲУ̶͵ط̶ֻռԤԽСıռҪλζ
Ҫط룬ṩԴڵطԱһֹ룬ΪƣطҲŬȥЩ롣
    1988ٶȷ仯һ1г˸ʡʵеĲͬķ
            3.ģ
    ڶԾʵ֤Уһ㷺ʹõĻƿܣMankiwȣ1992Ҳһ
ȨԾӰ졣ǲ˿²һ˹͵ʵtڵɱΪ
    ytAtkt[][1-]              1
    
    yΪ˾kΪ˾ʱAΪˮƽ ΪͶռ˿ڵıΪԱʽ1 ͬʱȡ
ʱһ΢֣͵õ˾ʣΪ
    gt٣tڣtaۣt         2
    
    ʽ2пԿ ˾ȡأ˾ʱʺͼʡҪעǣAtӳ˼ı仯
ӳ˲ͬԴƶȵĲͿʱı仯Լضĵɹ۲⵽ǼٶAtȡ

    һֱӵغڸĸڼʵʩҪĸĸʩȨFDͼͥаƣHRS Ȩ
ӰǱоĺݡȻȨֻйȫλĸʩеһɲ֣ĸʩعϵ
ųĸʩӰ׼ȷȨԾֱЧӦĹؼǰоǡúһ㣬ЩоĽۿ²
ʮ׼ȷͥаƸĸǸĸڼũҵҪԭLin1992 ĸũȨ
ҵҵĳɳйÿǻũƷũƷFPMP֮Լ۸˼۸
ſӰ죬Ϊ۸ſũƷԼ۸ҵĸ⿪ߵ߸ĸЧӦȱϺʵָ
ֱӺȻڻعģмȴԼЩЧӦ
    ڶЩܹӳؼԴıFISCAPΪ˾ʵGDPƶƽֵ ָ귴ӳһ
Ĳʵũ˿ڱأPOPSHR˿TPOPֱлԼ˿ڹģԾӰ졣ǹҵ
ҪͨǹҵĲռҵܲNSOESHıġͨǹҵҪԿ˽ǹҵھ
𵽵á
    ǻ˾̶ʲͶʶɱȼ۸㣩һָΪ˾ʱʵĽ
    عģͿͨһ˫ģעڻع鷽ȡٷֱȵıˮƽPOPTFISCAPȡ
ʽֻΪ˷ԹƽĽͣԱĵĽ۲ûʲôӰ졣
    GGDP[,it][,1]FPMP[,it][,2]HRS[,it][,3]NSOESH
[,it][,4]GI[,it][,5]lnFISCAP[,it][,6]FPMPIT[,i
t][,7]POPSHR[,it][,8]lnTPOP[,it][,i][,t]
[,it]i1Nt1T                3
    
    У±iΪʡݣtΪʱ䣬GGDPΪ˾GDPʣGI Ϊ˾Ͷʣ[,i]Ϊɹ۲ĵЧӦ[,t]Ϊɹ۲ʱ
ЧӦ[,it]ΪӶҪעǣ[,t] һʡݲͬ仯ıûбڻعģжʱ
йصЧӦһǵķرҪΪйõģʽں̶ܴĺ۾ģԵĺ
ߵ˸͸ͨʣֽŵٺͽϵ͵ľЩۻʱȨ
ЧӦͿܻƫ
    عģ͵Уһд⡣[,i] ͦ[,t]ǹ̶ĴҲвӶӦ[,it]
IID0[2][,v] ʽһ˫̶ЧӦģ͡вӶģʽ3 ൱
һ˫ЧӦģ͡ϲû̫ǿ֧ѡһģͽйƸΪʣȫHausman ģ
趨ĽģͶѡ˹̶ЧӦģͣV֣
    ȨһҪṩطָԴӶǵͶʺ֧ˣȨܻͨͶʶӰ쵽
ʲȨԾĲӰ̣ͨ3 еGI͡ȨҲͨߵطԴõЧԾ
סȨͨٶԵʲŵͶʺӶԸʲŵͶʶӰ쵽õĳʡȨĺЧӦ
ͨFDϵӳģЧӦҲǽʵ֤ҪĿĺݡ
            4.
    ռй½30ʡλ28Ϻ19701993ĽԽʵ֤עݲȫ
Ϻزûбڡ2г˸Ķ;ֵ ˾ʵGDPǸй19521995ĹֵGDPģ
֧ȡԡʡ ֱϽʷͳƻࣺ1949 1989Լġйͳ̶ʲͶʵȡԸ
ʡͳЩݶǸݵ۵ݣ19701993ļ۸ָɰ1970ĲۼݡǹҵĲ
빤ҵܲıء˿ںũ˿ȡġйͳũƷԷũƷԼ۸꡶й
ͳϵϢָͥũһƶȵӵİٷֱȣһȡ1992귢һƪ
ģLin1992
    κȨٵһؼԵսڽпоУһ㶼ݿ֧֧ıֵΪȨĽ
Ȼйڸʡ֧޴ӻã޷ʡ֧ڸʡ֧ıֵ辶ڶй
ʵ֤оƪУֱ˺ȨĲͬķУMa1997ķʡԤбƽݶ
Ȩȡ÷֮ԭȴ޷ֳ80롪طϵľ޴仯ȣ
ڸĸǰһЩʡݾһֱԤף˵ЩʡݵĲǵ֧ˣMaķȨ
֮ͳͳ֧Ĳƶ£ʡһκο֧׼ΣMaķʹõƽֳʶǱ߼ʷֳʣ
Ӱʡʡ¸ΪȴǱ߼ʷֳʡ
    һйȨʵ֤оZhangZou1996ġͨһʡĿ֧ռ֧ܿıʣǸñʵı仯
ȨһҲ⡣ǵָУĸͬġ֧ԲȨȾȫȡһʡ֧
ˮƽǵķطϵ֧ԽȨȾԽԣط֧ߵǸʡߵĲɶȡʵ
ȴˣΪĳʡݵ֧СֻǷӳ˸ʡ˿ں;ùģǸʡڲӵеɿռ䡣ĴʡĲ֧
ߵģⲢĴʡȽСĹ׳ӵиĲȨͬϺеĲ֧ҪУϺӵе
ɶȲиࡣ
    ǰоУһԵҪйȨʵʿʼʱ䡣ָйĲĸ80
ʼġʡȽС ң 19801984䣬ʡĲϵı仯ں̶ܴ
ԺʱԵģ̯Ĺ򲢷һ꣬ǣʡ̸СЩѧߣWong1991Ѿָݵ
滮ĲϵʵЧڷǳݡʡĲ̫߳ĲȷԡˣʡѲ
Ǳ״֮γɶԱȵǣ1985꿪ʼĲĸķȽȷ̯겻䣬Ȼһʱ
ЭЧڼ䣬ĳЩԭʡ̶̯ͬб仯ǻϻǱѭġ
    ڱУΪȨ1985꿪ʼʡڱʡԤеı߼ʷֳһָȨڶѾָ
19851987䣬һʡͣ19881993֡ʡ˶ٲӶ
ȨĳʡԴбһݶFDķݶ1985198714ʡ198819935 ʡԹ
һࡣ༸͵Ĳζ100ı߼ʷֳʡ ע̯£1ڻϽɵһ ڽ
ļ Ͻɶǰ̶ıӣ2Ͻһ̶3ڻϽһ̶ ڽ
ļϽɶǰ̶ıӣ4 һ̶Ĳ5ڻһ ڽļ
ܲǰ̶ıӡʡı߼ʷֳڱ1мΪFD һг1985ǰʡݵĲȨȶ
Ϊ0עڶ֣
            5.
    3˾GDPʵĻع4 ˶ȨõĽԼ¼Ҫע⣺
һͳƼĽڱ3ĵײһмΪHN и˹̶ЧӦģͺЧӦģͽHausmanͳֵx[2] ͳ
ֵԿHausman趨ܾЧӦģ͡ΪLR һ˼費ڹ̶ЧӦĿԱʼ飨    Likelihood
ration testĽx[2]ͳֵ1ˮƽϵٽֵܾûй̶ЧӦĹŵع˫̶ЧӦģ͡
еĻع鶼ǰ˫̶ЧӦģġΪ˼ʡĹƽûڱгȤ
ȡBreuschPaganճܾ˴ͬ裬    и˺췽һµı׼µt ͳֵ
White,1980ע⣬DurbinWatsonҲû֤ʾлģ͵Ĳвֲء
    A.  3еģ1˶Է̣3 ֱӹƵĽ пԿȨ˾GDPġӰ졣
ֵΪ0.0362ζŲȨȡҲǶԤı߼ʷֳʡ0ߵ100˾GDPʾͻӦ3.62ٷֵ㡣 ũ
ĸԾҲĺӰ졣Ԥϵ̶ʱ뾭ĺءFISCAPϵǸ
ͳζŽϸԣʡʸ͡˵йʡݵˮƽ֮ơӳ
ͬʼıͳϲ
    ǹģ2 ԼȨĻعǷ԰Щıڻع鷽൱Сƽûжı䡣
    ڲȨԸʡԲӶı߼ʷֳģܲʡݺֻҪһ̶
Ͻɸʡ߼ʷֳʶΪ100 ߿ܻỳһЧԡģ3У ͨԽܵĲʡ
ʡ֣Լģ1ĹƽǷȻֲ䡣 ΪЩ19851993˲
ʡݶԣȡֵΪ1ʡȡֵΪ0ʱεڣͬȡֵΪ0Ȩȴ0.036
20.02651ˮƽ¼ϵΪͬ£ܲʡݵľ
ٶȸ졣Ĺƽģ1ͬ һְ취еһģ1 Щ
ܲʡݵݡģ4У ܼһЩƽģ3Ĺƽͬģ1Ľһ
¡ˣЩܲʡݵı߼ʷֳ趨Ϊ100 ûʲô֮
    һпܻƫĵطڸĸǰĲֵܻĸڼĲֵ֮ͬĸǰݵҲܻ
ԹƽӰ졣ģ5Уǽ19791993 һθĸڼݶԾ˻ع顣עһַǶڸ
ǰ͸ĸڼеĸȶԽм顣ȻΪFDHRSڸĸǰȡֵΪOϼﲢС F
Dϵģ3ģ4ͬͳ עĿı仯Ƕ˿ϵĹơģͲͬϵΪͳ
˵˿ڹģʡ侭ٶȸ졣ϵĹƽ仯ˣû㹻֤ݱǵĽΪ
а˸ĸǰõġ
    B.ԲȨ趨ǿȼ  ӸĸĴʩԾӰ֮൱һμڡΪֿ
ԣ辭ΪͺһĲȨĺͿ˾ʶԸĸʩı仯ķӦʱ䡣ڱ4 
ģ1УԲȨһͺ󣬽ϵĹֵرǲȨĹֵ3ģ1ϵֵǳơڱ4
ģ2УԲȨͺ󣬽ٶʾȨԾӰ졣Ωһı仯ǲȨϵֵĴС
ģȱøˡȥѰҸñͺṹ뷨ȻڲȨ߶أʹ޷Էֲͺ
ķǰͺһFDҲǽʱĹֵȫΪֶع
ֵı׼ҲӦúܴ󡣣עǶԺHRS ͺʽķ̽лعԽӰ첻󡣣
    ΪֹͨԱ߼ʷֳʵתȨȡȻȨ뾭֮ĹϵȴпǷԵġΪ
齫FD趨ΪʽԻعӰ죬¶Ա3ģ1еĸñ˶תlogisticת½˻عƣע
һLogisticУFD1expۣXa/kݣ[-1]ֵΪa׼ΪkУ3[0.5]  ú۵Ϊ߼ʷֳʵ
50 a0.5׼0.25 ߼ʷֳʱֵ׼֮ڡֱڱ4ģ3ģ4 и
 FD ĹϵȻΪͳñʽĹƽΪ0.0217ζŴ뼯пƵĲƶȫȨĲ
ƶȵתὫ10ٷֵ㡣ӶԸñlogisticתĹƽҲܵõƵĽ͡Ĺƻ䡣
עԭܣHRSҲʽ趨⡣ǹעFD 趨ʽ仯ԹƽӰΪȨǱоĺݡ  
HRS ͬȡʽʱϵֵFDϵƾΪͳ
    ǽһֺȨõĽǿȽм飬Ȼַʹõķϵڱ4ģ5
ʹõƽֳʡעǰĶƽֳʵǰعģ͵Ĺƽһ¡Ωһϴı仯ڸģ
УFDϵֵҪЩԶԲı߼ʷֳΪȨָģеӦϵĹֵҪСöࡣ
ʶԱ߼ʷֳʱ仯ķӦҪȶƽʱ仯ķӦΪС֮ʡݿԴͬķݶǵ
߼ʷֳʲͬʡ˾GDPʾͻֲ죬 ʱ߼ʷֳʽϵ͵ʡȱ߼ʷֳʸߵʡ˾GDP ʻ
ߡʵϣڱ4ģ6ͬʱʹֺ߼ʷֳʺƽֳʣʹñ߼ʷֳʵıϵ
ֵΪ10ˮƽʹƽֳʵıϵĹֵΪͳϲ˵߼ʷֳǺ
ȨһϺõķңǰߵĹֵ0.0254ҪںߵĹֵ0.0082ֽģзֱʹַʱ
һµġ
    C.Ȩʩ  ǵĻعȨ˾GDPźǿأ еϵҲп
ǵùģʡľʽϵͣ˸пܴȡϸԣʡʽϸߣӶɶпܸ
£ǰеĹƽƫƲһ¡ȻȨġ
ȣǷ FDǳȶ1985ǰʡñȡֵΪ0䣬ʡñȡֵҲʱı仯ֶ
仯1985꣬ʡĲűȷ䶯һΣ䶯1988ִ꣬е1993ꡣ1993ڵ
һꡣΣǻͲȨǱڵ˼顣ĽûоܾԤı߼ʷֳģ͵ļ衣עǻ
HRSFDͬʱԵļ˵ Hausman Ľû֤HRSFDӦ
    D.Ͷʺ  ڵָȨͨ;߾ʡһȨܹʡһʱͶʵ
ӶʡԣһȨĲƶµͶʶҪһеĲƶµͶʶǿΪڷȨ
ƶ£ʡԴӶеͶĻرлȡһķݶȨʡͶ֮ȷʵ
عϵô3ͱ4ĲȨϵĹƽͿܵ͹˲ȨԾЧӦͨһĻع
Ƿֹϵ˾ͶʵʣGIFDԱлع顣ʾȨͶ֮عϵȻֹ
ϵͳϲעعģͣʡʱûгΪGI0.002450.0038*FD0.02470.317*
HRS0.0834-0.875*FISCAP-0.0451-0.242*NSOESH 0.003690.091*FPMP-0.0388-0.148*POPSHR-0.580-1.768*LPOPT
еΪtͳֵбĶ2R[2]0.41⣬ıģ趨ʽGIFD֮ĹϵûʲôӰ졣
磬GIFDеعУFDĹϵȻΪҲˣûԵ֤˵ȨͨʱͶƶ
˾
    ڶȨͨԴЧʶƶ˾ڵһָģȣʡ㵱
ϢƣܹõṩƷͷ񣬶ЩƷͷԵصľûнϴӰ졣磬ĳʡݿͨ
ԴܲҲͨԴӵʵõʵָܲǣڲȨ
ЧߵãͬǨƣ Զ˾GDPʴõӰ졣ʹõļģʹܹЧ
ӦеĿ졣ƽȷȨйʡľá
    Ȼȱݣ޷ϸطȨδйЧʵߡʡһĺͳȻ
ȨԵʣطĸͶ˸磬ǷڻͶռԤ֧ıȨ֮
صĹϵעعģͣʡ˺ʱûгƽΪBESHINF0.04863. 033 *  FD- 0
.0569-0.3401*HRS0.02492.694*FISCAP0.1383.794*NSOESH0.003440.398*FPMP0.1321.981* POPSHR0.
4190.510*TPOPBESHINFǻʩͶռԤ֧ıеΪTͳֵͱĶ2BESHINF FD
ļ򵥻عFDϵֵΪ0.0655tͳֵΪ3.986ԸýһܵĽ;ʡͼͨʩͶʣ
ٵ򡪡ũҵšͶԴЧʣΪʩͶʿʱʡעũҵ
صĸʽռԤ֧ıȨ֮ĹϵΪͳϲ  ˵Ӿǵطҵ
TVESķչݵĽɫȨ롪ʡ֮Ĳϵʡʡ¸ҲƵķȨʽĲ
ϵĿǰʡµĸܹӵزбıѾıЩͶΪǲиǿҵĶ
ȥиͶʣһͶڸʵũ幤ҵţҵһýгַѳ˱
оΧעһЩ֤ݱҵķչȨϵʡ˾ҵͶʶԲȨ
ƱعʱFDϵֵΪ
    Ա߼ʷֳȨǶԹȥоʹõһĽ߼ʷֳҲһָꡣȨ
Ȼȡڶ̶ͨ;ԤطĲ磬ܻĳʡݼŻߣ
쾭Ȩ׼ͶĿȵȡЩں̶ܴ϶ʡͨڻعʡѾǵЧӦ
˽ȥ
            6.
    ڱУ̽йʼ80ڵĲȨĸ˾GDPʵӰ졣 ǷֲȨԾ
Ȩܹ߾ЧʵļһµġͬʱǻũĸͷǹвŵķչڹȥʮƶйĹ
ء
    ЩʹǵóۣһƶȰźҪȨ⣬ߣũ岿мͥаƸĸ
ҵͨչǹҵʵӪйľáڶݶݵķȨҪͨԴ
Чʶ¸Ͷйľʡ
    Ӧָǣ80ʡĲϵı仯۸ӡھоԱ߼ʷֳΪӳȨȵָ
⻹Գֳϵ仯ĸԡõ롪ʡ̸йؼõغͻƷǳҪԭ
ĵоֻһ׶ԵĳɹодС
         1  롪ʡƶȰźͱ߼ʷֳ
    1985-1987                   1988-1993
ʡ     ䷽*     FD           ䷽**       FD
        a         49.55            b           100.00
        a         39.45            a            46.55
Ϻ        a         23.54            c           100.00
ӱ        a         69.00            b           100.00
ɽ        a         97.50            a            87.55
        a         51.08            b           100.00
      c        100.00            c           100.00
        a         40.00            b           100.00
㽭        a         55.00            b           100.00
        a         80.10            a            77.50
ɽ        a         59.00            c           100.00
        a         80.00            b           100.00
        a         88.00            d           100.00
        a        100.00            a           100.00
Ĵ        a        100.00            a           100.00
        e        100.00            e           100.00
        e        100.00            e           100.00
        e        100.00            e           100.00
        e        100.00            e           100.00
ɹ      f        100.00            e           100.00
½        f        100.00            e           100.00
        f        100.00            e           100.00
        f        100.00            e           100.00
        f        100.00            e           100.00
        f        100.00            e           100.00
ຣ        f        100.00            e           100.00
㶫        e        100.00            e           100.00
        e        100.00            e           100.00
    
    Դ*йίᣬ1988pp376377Zhu1993pp294296
    **̯
    a.Ͻɵһݶ
    b.ڻϽɵһݶڽļϽܶ̶һ
    c.Ͻһ̶룻
    d.ڻϽһ̶룬Ͻܶ̶һ
    e.һ̶Ĳ
    f.ڻһ̶Ĳܲ̶һ
    ͼ{ͼ}
             3  ˾GDPʻع
        (1)        (2)      (3)     (4)*        (5)**
FD         0.0362     0.0349   0.0265   0.0259     0.0271
           (2.703)    (2.595)  (2.049)  (1.659)    (2.039)
HRS        0.0372     0.0408   0.0448   0.0565     0.0336
           (1.768)    (1.951)  (2.163)  (2.304)    (1.685)
GI         0.0478     0.0493   0.0459   0.0538     0.0237
           (3.819)    (3.897)  (3.692)  (2.879)    (1.919)
FISCAP     -0.144     -0.126    -0.157   -0.138    -0.125
           (-5.308)   (-4.509) (-5.664) (-3.810)   (-3.804)
NSOESH      0.142      0.145     0.203    0.259     0.173
           (3.163)    (3.288)  (4.116)  (3.811)    (4.052)
FPMP        0.0107           0.00522  -0.0172    0.00575
           (1.158)           (0.575)  (-1.149)   (0.576)
POPSHR      0.0446           0.0353   -0.0746    -0.0545
           (0.630)           (0.509)  (-0.422)   (-0.782)
TPOP       -0.209           -0.310    -0.405     0.137
          (-1.612)          (-2.366) (-2.634)   (3.960)
Subsidy                    0.0275             
Dummy                          (3.648)
Hna:     36.31[8]   34.13[5]   35.20[9]  20.24[9]   37.98[9]
LRa:    289.29[47] 285.14[47] 286.40[47] 181.34[35] 215.71[42]
R2 0.52    0.52      0.53      0.56       0.51
ģ     534      534       534       294       406
    
    עеģоʡ  ֵ White1980췽˵Ϊtͳֵ
    aеֵΪx[2]ͳֵɶȡ
    * ڰѴܲʡɾݵĻϵĹƽ
    **19791993ڼݽйƵĽ
            4  ˾GDPʻع
      (1)*     (2)**    (3)***    (4)****  (5)     (6)
FD     0.0372    0.0503    0.0217    0.0315         0.0254
      (2.750)   (3.633)   (2.422)   (2.422)  (0.0119) ( 1.607)
FDAVG[a]*****
                                  2.358   0.0082
HRS     0.0387    0.0411    0.0374    0.0379  0.0397  1.392
   (1.831)   (1.938)   (1.774)   (1.788) (1.863) (0.0389)
GI      0.0489    0.0484    0.0478    0.0479  0.0483  1.839
    (3.865)  (3.858)   (3.822)   (3.829) (3.854) (0.0481)
FISCAP  -0.144   -0.147   -0.143     -0.143   -0.142   3.848
       (-5.298) (-5.398)  (-5.266)  (-5.267) (-5.206) (-0.145)
NSOESH  0.145    0.159     0.138      0.138    0.155   -5.338
       (3.216)  (3.433)   (3.097)   (3.087)  (3.313)   (0.157)
FPMP  0.00974   0.00948  0.0105    0.0106    0.0103    3.386
      (1.049)  (1.019)   (1.136)   (1.147)   (1.149)   (1.117)
POPSHR 0.0417    0.0376  0.0426    0.0416    0.0390    0.0438
      (0.593)  (0.541)   (0.601)   (0.587)   (0.551)   (0.618)
TPOP  -0.206   -0.208    -0.207    -0.206    -0.253    -0.243
      (-1.593) (-1.611)  (-1.599)  (-1.859) (-1.915)  (-1.819)
    0.52    0.52       0.52       0.52      0.52    0.52

R2
   534    534        534         534        534     534
ģ
    
    עеģоʡ   ֵWhite1980췽˵Ϊtͳֵ
    *FDΪһͺ
    **FDΪͺ
    ***FDȡʽ
    ****FDȡlogisticʽ
    *****FDAVG[a]Ϊʡƽֳʡ
    ոڣ20000531
    ֿδעͣ
        ԭΪyϼһ
        ԭΪAϼһ
        ԭΪkϼһ
    
    
    
 
