 ׺ 2-642
ԭĳÿѧ
ԭ
ԭںš200004
ԭҳš8188
  šF13
  徭ʵ
ӡںš200011
    ԤԼҵľת
    ԤԼ۶ʮ귢չ
    ޵/־
߼顿޵־ɣɽѧѧԺ  510275
    
    ԤԼ80ڵйѧܴķӦӰһЩйѧˡԤԼԭָƻ
£ҵɱʱŻԮ񣬸ѳԽԭи漰ƻõо
룬ھоĶõ˹㷺Ӧá
    90ѧƺѾԸÿʧȥȤǣʱȴǸȡҪչĹؼʮꡣѧһ
ڶྭѧǰ֧̽һ֧йѧɵмЪѧڡ˹̹
ѧǮӱһڡ׶ؾѧԺɸֽڡմѧһڵȣǽܳоԤԼ۵ķչҪ
ס
            һԤԼƶεĵԹ
    ƶΣKornai1980ڡȱѧһо˴ͳƻģʽ״ԵԤԼĸ
ڼ۸ϵеĶȱ󣬷˶ȱԭͺ
    ԤԼӲԤԼһϺ߼ķӲԤԼ˽ҵϸصҪ룬ҲǴͳ΢۾ѧ
۾ѧ۵ĻٶЩۺؼ裬ߺ߶ȷӲԼлƶΣ1980꣩Ҫ
ΪֻҪЩȫõ㣬Ա֤ҵԤԼġȫӲԡ
    1ҵͶƷͲƷļ۸ߣ
    2ҵӰ˰ ˰Ӧڿɹ۲ӲԱ׼ϣҾ˰ڶԣҵһû⣻
    3 ҵڲֲճ֧õĹһ޳
    4ҵȫʽ нױֽУ
    5ҵͶʲⲿʽԴ
    ƶָ2ͣ3Ѿõ㣬еɸδܵõ㣬ҵһСķΧ
ڶܹۡմͳԭȡʽ𡢻ܹӲⲿȡͶĿĵʽʱԤԼǽӲԵġ
    ͬʱͨɣ15еһɸǻоٳԤԼҵǶߡ
ּͨۻʹ˰ҵܹõ޳ʱҵٵľԤԼ
            ԤԼĳ
    һЩѧУͨµľѧۺͷ룬һ̽ԤԼĳԤԼ
ΪڲͬľϵµЧʵҪԴ㷺ãתʱڵ徭ϵˡ
    һǶԿƶεҳ˼ļ̳кͷչƶΪԤԼֵԭġҳ硱
һƲҵԮ֣֮ΪԸҵƲʧҵһϵвһȼ
ΪԡԤԼΪļҳҵĲƵڽڵС
    ·ѶºͿأGoldfeld and Quant19881990һϵеԤԼģ͡ΪҵȡĲģ
ȡҵԺԴͶЩģԤԼεҪӣε徭жȱ
ĳ֡
    ϣˣHillman et al.1987Ҳ̽ԮҪĺǵģУҵһȷĲ۸񣬽
͵Ŀ۸ʹоԮĻҵòپҵҲòеʧҵӵĲ
    ¶Gomulka1985ˡԤ㵯ԡĸ ΪԤԼյ˳ڵĶȱôԤͲҪģ
ȼ۸еԣΪ۸ĳ߿Եȵ󣬲Ͷȱĳ̶ȡ
    ˹Schaffer1989һģͣΪԤԼԴڼҳ磬޷ЧؽԱ
ҵʵоǿӲ󡣴⣬ҵǡġҳʽģǡǿӲġĲȫϢҲʹҵнһ
ǿӲĻǺпܶҵʵо
    ˣBoycko et al.1996 ΪμòֶιΪʹҵά־ҵʣԹԼĵλͬʱҲ
ͨ˽Ӫ۽ģͻˡΪȻֲμǵġҳ塱ƫãȫţͨԤԼ
ķҵŲġ
    ڶΪԤԼμҶҵΪӰġлѶºκ˹ᣨSheifer and Vishny1994Ϊμ
Ϊ˵оĿģ˵ĿģΪμҿͨӾҵͲʹԼλΪ̺ۺ
ˣμҿԶҵֱӹܿػ߿Чҵ̸ʱҵԭеӯͿҪӦμǵķǾĿĵ
ҪۿˡΪرμǻͨԤԼƩЩҵṩʽҵʧֹ۵ĵһ
۽Ϊƣڸ۸ǿμҵĿġ
    ΪԤԼڽߺʹ֮ϢԳƶֱӵµġԺͷʶĴ߻ΪһЩӼĿ
ʽͨ˼ǵͶʾ˹Dewatripon and Maskin1995ΪǹģϴŴ 
ǶԽҵڲϢգҲҵյҪٵö࣬ˣͬҵ룬ǿǿԵġʶ
ڵͶʵʧԺС͵ĴȱʽԵԵʶֹЩĿͶʣȻЩģϴĴ
˵ȼԸĿעµͶʣԵȴת
    ڶϢԳУմѧһˣ1995ΪΪ˱֤ͶĿİȫԣܻҵĿʽ
ˣҵΣҪĿʱ˱ҲҪܶеһַ߽֡ͨĿĿ
ת޸ˣѡĿʱҲСġ
    ǿڲ˵ĿȨǲԤԼԭڲӵҵȨĺ壺һ棬ڲ˿ͨ
ȨΪԼıȡ˽һ棬ҵʱڲڶҵȨӣ뾡ְ취ͨԺ
ֶΣѰ֧Ԯͨ˽˹ϵʵֶȴΣҵЪѧ1997Ϊڲ˶ҵ
ȨӣʹҵʱγԤԼ
    ˣ1998йĸ￪ź19801994ĹҵݣԤԼĺֳ۽ʵ֤飬̽
ЩἰĲͬضҵĲͬúӰ졣ʹҵзԹ˵ľҵƽµĵͻ
ͶԼ涨ҵֱֵֺΪԤԼͬ۵ĲָꡣͳƼʾڿҵ˵
Թ˵ľҵͻرͶԼҵĹȷֺ죬ǵ¿ĹؼԭǵĽ֧μӰ졢˫
ϢԳԼڲ˿ƵԤԼĳۡ
            ԤԼ
    ڽڵогֵԤԼӦãƶΣ1980ĶܲͬǶǶԤԼԭжչ
    һչ˹ٸΪԤԼĳֲΪһЩŻµκʧնоԮͲ
ΪǡѺϸעļStiglitz1994ָĽڻðյļԴͽʷ飬
ծѷͼͨʹø߷սķ԰εĽھ档
    ˹ٸĵи߷ͶģУծѷпܻעһضһЩ߷յĿͶʣȥӦĿ
ֵϵͣΪĲ״ðͶɹͿں̶ܴϼծ񸺵ʧˣҲʹծ̶ȸΪ
һЩˡһӦýжЩͶǰѾֳ߿Եĸ߷ĿͶʵȥˣˣǶԭ
ԤԼ۵һչ
    һֶԤԼչɵ˹1991ġ˹ΪеĻʵ϶ԤԼ
أͨϢԳƵĶ̬ģԤԼĸѧˡǵģ֤һȨΪɢԤԼӲƶ
£Ŀһ㽫òʣõĿҲԵõе֧֣Ŀȴ׵õʽڸģУԤԼԴ
ѡֿɳΪѡģ͡ǶԭԤԼ۵һҪչ
    и߷ͶģͺѡģͶ׽ס˾еҪʡȻƶԼչڼҳµĶ
ߵºԮģȣǵģǺܲͬġΪºԮģУԿҵעʽǲκλر
ֻǸҵرյԸġи߷Ͷģͺѡģڽ߶ԣǻ
ԭģǰߵģУԸͶЩֻкСܹȡĸ߷ĿεĲʹ
ĿԤΪҲϧںߵģУڲͬ׶ǷضĿľԭȫ֡
    ԴڼҳºԮģԼģ͵Ч׼ǣҵپϢչŴǰʱͬŴ˻
ͬķӦи߷ͶģͺѡģУŴȷҵڸΣҵǿ϶䷢Ŵ
ҳºԮģ;ͲͬˣҵǷϢ˿ӰҵĿԣˣҵг
ԤԼ
    ӲԤԼѾΪת쾭иĸҪսˡΪ˶Ըһ⣬ת쾭ùѾʼԹҵĲ
ͬʱҵеáЩʩѾյ˻ЧȻڹҵĴ˴תеĽɫתУ
ԤԼȻǺͻ⣬ڲͬҵıʽͳ̶ͬ
     ˵ǣ ޵ٺͿPerotti  andCarare1997иĸоҵ֮Ĳ
ծϵԵʱƶڲϵǿɭͿAnderson and Kegels1997оҲʾ һЩת
ùУݿ˺ͱǣеԤԼлʵӶ⣬˹1998ΪһЩת쾭ù
Ӷҵ˰ǷޣҲ˵һ̶ϼʵԤԼߡ
    ޷£Berglof and Roland1998عԤԼеһЩҪչͨصģͽµ
ͷ࣬ǹɳҵ֮γԤԼԭ
    1עʵºԤ⣻2ҵڼǿ໥ʱǣ浽ϵ۸ӣʹԤӲĻ
ɱ쳣Ӵ󣻣3ҲõͶѡ񣻣4ڴԼҵܹյĽĴڣʹ˶ĿǰĻ״
ļ5ѰʵʩԤѰΪ
    γԤԼԭͬӦģʹõȴͬһнṹͬʱЩģ͵һ֮ǣԤ
ԼγɶȱʵĿĿвµġˣ޷ΪЩ۽չǶԤԼģ
͵ܱͷࡣڴ˻ϣԤԼĳԼӲԤԼĻƣ̽еϵͲ
    ˹1995ΪԤԼ˻ԵĹסǵҪ۵ǣͶ߶ҵͶĳʽ
ǳԵģ˶Ͷ߶ԣԿҵͶʶǶƲǷͶߵºŻԭģ£
Ͷߺҵ֮ԤԼ㷺أ˹ģͰԤԼһΪһ㻯Ķ̬ŵ⡣
ԤԼ£ҵȱʵʩЧӪļڽеЧʵΪ֪ԼԻöĲ֧Ԯ
ԤԼӲζŴУٶҵж֧Ԯһֿŵŵźš
    ˹ģͺֱǮӱһ1994޷£1997һ1998˽һչо
ԳΪһ׶ģͣһ׶ΣлһĿûгʶĿĺûʵǰ
ʽͨĽУĿһĿбȻȻΪṩʡȻʶ
һĿʱڵһ׶εĽǳɱǼֹĿľѵöˡĿڶ׶εǰ
ģҲʶеڶ׶εͶʻܻõĻرҪʱڵһ׶κֹҪõö࣬н
ԤԼĲ
    ЩģУӰ˹̹ѧǮӱһ1994ڡۡϷġͨᲩģ͵ĽǮӱһ֤
ԤԼԳƵ£۸ƺͶȱڼϢɼ۸񷴵ʹ߳ԿɴˣǮӱһóĽǣ
תУӪҵԤԼҪȼ۸ɻΪҪ
            ġԤԼ
    һѧԤԼΪۿܣֱ̽˽Σۺ۵Ⱦѧǰо⣬ԤԼ
Ƕۡ
        1ԤԼΣ
    ׶شѧĻƺ޺׶ؾѧԺɸ֣1999ԤԼƶȿо˽ΣĳΪ޽ΣӸ
˵ڵؽڻҵԤԼɵģԤԼӰ˽гЧʣŤгϢ
سϢԳƣҲɱмгѡ⡣ˣԳʱʹӪȽ
Ҳ״ⲿôԽʽԵĶȱпܵмҷ糱ͬʱһѡ⣬мгı
ʹͶڿֻŵĲأտܵ¾Σı
    ෴ӲԤԼ£йϢϵ֤мгܹʱг
ԽϲṩԷֹƲΣɢղЧرΣı
    ǵۣԤԼУֹΣǾȱԵУڽƸĸͽΣ
߷棬ϵ͸ҪȻܲЧﵽǿ͸ȵĿֻ꣬ͨĸƶȣӲ΢۵
λԤԼпʹ֮õʵ֡
        2ԤԼ볧
    ԤԼǶ³ۼзҵرǸ߿ƼҵR&DĿΪشR&DĿʽ𾿾Ӧڲ
֧ⲿ⡣
    ͳΪҵR&DһҪСҵӵиƣԭڣҵṩڲʽSchumpeter1950ҵ
Ͷ֮ϢԳƣ·պѡӦ˶ˣˣձΪڲ֧ȣR&D ĿʽⲿЧ
ʻԵһЩArrow1962Stiglitz and Weiss1981 رR&DĿһҳӴĳɱ Ŀʽ
ܵͣʽⲿģR&D Ŀĵ·պѡļغ͸ӣBernanke and Gertler1989Ca
lomiris and Hulbard1990Щۣ ֻҪҵûʽԼǽԤҵͨڲ֧ķʽҵR&D 
ȻɻǣʵľҵR&D Ŀȫʵڲʵ
    ƺ޺ɸ֣1998ͨԤԼһ󣬶Դͳ۽˲ͷչΪ͵R&D Ŀһ
ҪǸ߶ȵĲȷԣֲȷֻĿִ֮ſܾõˣºѡR&D ĿɸѡΪЧ;
ȻºɸѡҪһֳŵƣǾǼעʽº֤ǾӯԵģĿԽֹ
    ƺ޺ɸֵоһֳŵֻھ߱˲ͬϢͶ֮ͻʱֻⲿʵ²Ż
һĿʽҵڲṩʱͬͶ֮ͻϢԳƵɱ⣬ȻʱԤԼͿҵ
ڲ֣յR&DĿЧʵ¡ˣ ҵԸѡⲿʡ
        3ԤԼ뾭
    ھ۷棬ƺ޺ɸ֣1999ԤԼۿڣۣ̽˽ƶȶԾӰ
˵ͨձ̨ͺڲͬչʱڵľ״Ĺ۲ͷ֤˽ƶӰ켼
Ӱ쾭ġ
    ǵоʾձͺĸϳʱڣҲڼȽģ½׶ΣĿĲȷԱֵòԣʱԤԼõ
ЧʲӲԤԼõЧʵ͡Ȼһ˼ģ½׶ΣرǵҪдʱ90Ŀ
ĲȷԾѸԤԼĲؽãʱƶȵȱݾͱ¶ˡԷΣǰ󺫹̨߿
ڲƷʵ֤ݷںʵеЭдռλĽƶȣصԤԼνΣ
бܳȽ϶ԣ̨ܵӰҪСö࣬ԭ̨ĸ߿ƼҵʵеǷǳĽƶȣҵٵӲԤ
ԼɴˣǵóĽǣͬĽƶȵԤԼӲ̶ȵĲͬγ˲ͬļնԾ
˲ͬӰ졣
    ԤԼӦĲչԤԼѾΪһ㷺Ӧڸصľǰоȡ˾޴
ĽչȻøԶֹˡԤԼӲ̶ȡʹԼӲķͼɵӦáǶԾߵӰ켰
Ҿ÷չʵָȷоԤԼ۵Ҫɲ֡ˣйԤԼĸΪоչ
ڶоԱǰ
οס
    (1)Bai, C. and Wang, Y. (1998)  Bureaucratic  Control  andthe Soft Budget Constraint, Journal of Comparative Economics,2
6 (1), 41-61.
    (2)Berglof, E.  and  Roland,   G.   ( 1997)   Soft  BudgetConstraints and  Credit  Crunches  in  Financial  Transition,E
uropean Economic Review, 41 (3), 807-817.
    (3)Berglof, E.  and  Roland,   G.   ( 1998)   Soft  BudgetConstraints and Banking in Transition Economies,   Journal  of
Comparative Economics, 26(1), 18-40.
    (4)Dewatripont, M. and Maskin,  E.   ( 1995)   Credit  andEfficiency in Centralized and Decentralized Economies,  Review
of Economic Studies, 62(4), 541-55.
    (5)Goldfeld, S. and Quandt, R., Budget Constraints, (1988) Bailouts, and the Firm under Central Planning,   Journal  ofC
omparative Economics, 12(4), 502-20.
    (6)Goldfeld, S. and Quandt, R., (1990)   Output  Targets,the Soft Budget Constraints,   Bailouts  and  the  Firm  underC
entral Planning, Journal of Economic Behavior  Organization,14(2), 205-222.
    (7)Gomulka, S. (1985) Kornai's Soft Budget Constraint  andthe  Shortage  Phenomenent:   A  Criticism  and  Restatement,E
conomic Planning, 19(1), 1-11.
    (8)Huang, H. and Xu, C. (1998) Soft Budget Constraint  andthe Optimal  Choices  of  Research  and  Development  Projects
Financing, Journal of Comparative Economics, 26(1), 62-79.
    (9)Huang, H. and Xu, C. (1999) Institutions, Innovations,and Growth, American Economic Review, 89(2), 438-43.
    (10)Kornai, J. (1979) Resource-Constrained versus  Demand-Constrained Systems, Econometrica, 47(4), 801-819.
    (11)Kornai, J. Economics of Shortage,  Amsterdam:   North-Holland, 1980.
    (12)Kornai, J. (1986) The Soft Budget Constraint, Kyklos,39(1),3-30.
    (13)Kornai,   J.   ( 1993)   The  Evolution  of  FinancialDiscipline under the Postsocialist System, Kyklos, 46(3), 315-
336.
    (14)Kornai, J. ( 1998)   The  Place  of  the  Soft  BudgetConstraint  Syndrome  in  Economic   Theory,     Journal   ofC
omparative Economics, 26(1), 11-17.
    (15)Lane,  R.   and  Wolf,   H. ,   ( 1993)   Large  ScalePrivatization  in  Transition  Economics,   American  Economic
Review, 83(5), 1199-1210.
    (16)Li, D. (1998) Insider  Control  and  the  Soft  BudgetConstraint: A Simple Theory, Economics letters, 61(4), 307-11.
    (17)Li, D. and Liang M. (1998) Causes of the  Soft  BudgetConstraint:   Evidence  on  Three  Explanation,   Journal   of
Comparative Economics, 26(1), 101-116.
    (18)Maskin, E.   ( 1996)   Theories  of  the  Soft  BudgetConstraint, Japan and the World Economy, 8(2), 125-33.
    (19)Maskin, E. (1999) Recent Theoretical Work on the  SoftBudget Constraint, American Economic Review, 89(2), 421-25.
    (20)Qian, Y. (1994) A  Theory  of  Shortage  in  SocialistEconomies Based  on  the  Soft  Budget  Constraint,   American
Economic Review, 84(1), 145-56.
    (21)Qian, Y. and Roland, G., (1998)   Federalism  and  theSoft Budget Constraint, American Economic Review, 88(5), 1143-
62.
    (22)Qian, Y. and Xu C., (1998) Innovation and  Bureaucracyunder Soft Budget Constraint, Review of Economic Studies,  66(
1), 156-64.
    (23)Rawski, T. (1997) Who  Has  Soft  Budget  Constraint,Global Economic Review, 26(1), 29-49.
    ( 24) Schaffer,   M.   ( 1989)   The  Credible- EnterpriseRelationship, Journal of Comparative Economics, 13(3), 359-82.
    (25)Schaffer, M. (1998) Do Firms in  Transition  EconomiesHave Soft Budget Constraints? A  Reconsideration  of  Concepts
and Evidence, Journal of Comparative Economics, 26(1), 80-103.
    (26)Segal, I. (1998) Monopoly and Soft Budget Constraint,Rand Journal of Economics, 29(3), 596-609.
    (27)Stiglitz, J.  ( 1994)   Whither  Socialism?   WicksellLectures, Cambrige, MA: MIT Press.
                                                          (ZH)
    
    
    
 
