 ׺ 2-965
ԭĳо
ԭ
ԭںš199904
ԭҳš5259
  šF62
  뱣
ӡںš199908
    ʽгȶԼ·
    ǽΣϢѧ
ע͡˶ʿҵĵһ֣деõϺƾѧѧԺѷڵָڴ˱ʾл
    
߼顿Ϻƾѧо  200083
    
    ǽΣһ࣬IMFΪ׵ľԮڼȻǸȻΣӰ֮¡IMF ڵ˶Щ
ҵĽϵýṹ÷չսԷ׷ʷΣʱһζָȻʵϣ
ÿһЭ鶼ڽ˫κδʧܻΥԼ˫Σһе
    ൱ΪǸھʧǲΣĹؼԭ򡣵ǵ˴ζΣص㣺1ΣͻȻԣ 
2ණǹҺ۾ûãKrugman1998Ϊͳ۾ԶԶΣĽͣ˹ٸģ
1998ĵǣǴ߼Ϊcollective  actionɵĹʽгڲȶԣ Σķ 
IMFȱݼʴߵĵ·ʹΣӾ硣
    ȫķ֣һֽ˹ڹʴ߼Ϊļģͣʾ˹ʽгȶԡ˵˼ʹһȽĽ
ϵߣδԻܵƶΣвڶ֣ΣIMF Ԯƻȱݼڻ
ڵĵ·գʹIMFľжӣӶΣ ֣ڽǰַĻϣԵ߽
˼
            һʽгڲȶ
    ʽгڲȶָʱг׷ʵ֡ʽĽڿֻš˼·ǡľԵģ
ǼжĽܻһгϴģʱӣһ򵥵ģͣעģSachs1998 Ϊ
ΣһԲ㵼µΣϼ˲ķ˽һ̽֡Sachs1998
    ȶԽ߽з࣬Ϊ峥ĽߺԲĽࡣǰָߵδֵ峥ծ񣻺
ָ峥ȱֽʹ䲻бڻծ񡣵ԲĽ߲ܴʱг´ծʱ
ΣͻᷢԭϣԲĽߣʱгӦṩµĴʹ䳥ڴ¾ɴõ
ˣʱгԸ߲ṩ´ͳΪĹؼ
    ʱгṩ´ԭǴߵļΪ룬һԲĽ´СṩЩ
Ϊһṩ´͵߶ԣ˲ṩ´Ҳṩ´Σͷˡһܵг
ûһԸԲĽṩ´ΪÿԵԤڵĴҲ׼ṩĴ
    ٶһڳڶСߴծܶΪD ԼʱڢڻծDʱڢ򳥻1r1ȣDrΪϢý߽
ծһͶĿĿԤʱڢQ[,2] ʱͶĿڳֵΪQ[,2]1rQ[,2]1r
ծڳֵDۣ1r1ȣDݣ1rDQ[,2]1rD ǽڳȱֽԳDΪͶ
ĿֻʱڢŻ档
    һ£峥ԲĽ߿Ի´LLʱڢծDʱڢծ1 ȣD
LȻLDʱڢծܶΪ1rL1r 1ȣD1rD1r1ȣD1rD ݼٶ
ֵ֪ȻСQ[,2] ÿֻṩ´ΪˣˡDֻһԸʱڢṩˣ ô
ͶĿֻܰ;ϣֵQ[,1]DôߵĦҲʧʱڢĴҪN[,1]ߣN[,1]Dˡ
    ȥķչǺģڶԾ⡪
    һNNN[,1]ṩ˴ ͶĿ˳У¾ɴõ˳
    ζ˽Σÿ߶ṩͶĿȻʧܣ侻ֵQ[,1]Q[,2]1rʱԲ
ݱϵ峥㡣ʱÿ߶Լľȷġ
    ģͿһ򵥵ĵN ߵĲıʾ֧1
            1  Ƿ
                                  
                                              
            (1+r)N,(1+r)   (1+r)N, 0
                    0,  -(1+r)        0,     0
    һȫϢ̬ģǷԸṩӵеĹͶĿû˽Ϣprivateinforma
tion ҸǷҲԸṩĴÿ߶Ե£ߵսѡ
˵սѡ˲ľʲ⣬ڸ£˵սͬĴ
ڱ֤ȫ»Ϣ룬1 rˡһʲ⣬һ 
ʹɥʧһĻᣬԣһʲ⣬ͬģڸ߲׼ṩ´£Σ
ζʱ˵սֻǲһ⡣෴ս
ֻʹΣʧ1rˣ޷ջأÿ߶Ե£ǲֵġ
    ȻÿڽԼĴʱ֪ߵľߣȴ֪˵ѡ־ֻʵ֣
гǷԵģΪгעؼر֪гڸʲô Keynes 
1936˳ΪѡΪѡ߶ڲ²˽ж˭ģȥ˼˭ȷʵгͿܻƫ뾭û
ΣһΪߵĶǸ10ĸٷչû൱οΪߴԤӯ֡ͨͼ
ԶԲծһЩҾĿֲֵ󡣾ˣڶʴȻöǸõľûڲˣʱ
ӡӱ2Կ5еĹʱ1996100 Ԫٶ룬1997ϰͬٶ
    2    ǹⲿ19941998
                                             λ10Ԫ
Ŀ               1994   1995  1996  1997    1998
Ŀ      -24.6  -41.3  -54.9 -26.0   17.6
ⲿ()    47.4    80.9   92.8  15.2   15.2
˽ʱ()40.5    77.4   93.0  12.1    9.4
ȨͶ          12.2    15.5   19.1  -4.5    7.9
ֱͶ           4.7     4.9    7.0   7.2    9.8
֤ȯͶ           7.6    10.6   12.1  -11.6  -1.9
˽˴          28.2    61.8   74.0  -7.6  -17.3
ҵ          24.0    49.5   55.5  -21.3 -14.1
нڻ     4.2    12.4   18.4   13.7  -3.2
ٷʱ() 7.0     3.6   -0.2   27.2  24.6
ʽڻ      -0.4    -0.6   -1.0   23.0  18.5
˫Ŵ           7.4     4.2    0.7    4.3   6.1
()-17.5 -25.9  -19.6  -11.9 -5.7
仯(ƽ) -5.4 -13.7  -18.3   22.7 -27.1

    ԴInstitute  of  International  Finance, "CaptitalFlows to Emerging Market Economies,"Jan,29,1998
    ٶָӡᡢǡ̩ͷɱ
    ڣ1998Ϊֵ
    ģչʾ˽гϴ߼ΪڲȶԡϢԳƽǶÿߵľ߲ǽ˽
ϢĻϣǽڱĴߵжźϣӶЧʡÿ߲Ǳ˵źţǵ;û
ߣôͻõиĽ
    ͨǰķԿֲȶгĴڣʹüʹǹҾȽϵߣΣȻпܷ
СͿžܵгͻȻĳ˹ٸģ1998ǾͬеһҶۣȻǲ
ȷ֪Сʱ㸲Сջᱻ˴򷭼Ǻʵģܼݴô߳ͬļʻټΣʱľ
ʧ룬ôʹǡ̩̹ˡľҲܻû
            IMFжʧ·
    Σ֮IMFʼ˴ģľжڽIMFһӸĸƻ̩֮ӡᡢֱIMF ǩ˴Э
3Ȼ3ڽIMFļƻ ûʵָֻгġȶʼھõĿ꣬෴ӾΣѧ
Krugman1998Stiglitz1998IMFҩǲҪʣΪʲôIMFľԮƻûмᣬ 
ⳡΣͼһǶȣͨIMF ݵĹһɫһϵĹȽϣָ
ͬʱΪ׼˵ĴڣΣǰ޴ĵ·ա
        1.˻
    ˻ƱԤڶмᵼ¡ʵ֡ĿֻšDiamond-Dybvig1983һмҵģ
ͣԹʴ߼ΪǳơDiamond-Dybvig̻һΣĴͬʱһȡֽ𣬽ʹ
峥ƲЩ߲ͷǮֻǵıʹƲӶʹԼĴΪСּ
ҵµΣִгùѾһƵĻƽзҪеˡ
    һڹڳеְ𣬻㣺
    1ṩ㹻Ŵ֧֡ǸܻҵķߣڴΪҼֵôԭϣпԲĽڻ
㹻Ŵ˷ΣΪ1974ṩ17.5Ԫ޶10½ŵ˹ṩߴ50
ԪжУṩĴ޴󣬴ӶɹرǱڵпֻš
    2бжѸ١Ҳ˵гֻֿͷʱеĴӦ֣һΣѸɢʹеȴ
ʧܡڱΪɫһ19871019գбУ˹ڶ1020գǰ
κθ֤ȯ˾ṩļʱжڶָ̻һֻŵԱ⡣
    ڶǽΣУͶ߾ȡʲͬʱЩҵе㴢޵ġӶ
ãֻתIMFIMFȻΪ׼ߡ
            3  IMFԶǵԮƻ  λ10Ԫ
Ԯṩ                          ӡ
                       ŵ            ô
                                        ֹ           ֹ
                                       97/12/31       98/3/31
ʻһ֯         10.0           3.0              3.0
                  4.5           0.0              0.0
޷չ              3.5           0.0              0.0
ձ                      5.0           0.0              0.0
                      3.0           0.0              0.0
¼                    5.0           0.0              0.0
Ĵ                  1.0           0.0              0.0
й½                  1.0           0.0              0.0
й                  1.0           0.0              0.0
                  1.0           0.0              0.0
ӡ                      5.0           0.0              0.0
                      0.0           0.0              0.0
                      0.0           0.0              0.0
ܼ                     40.0           3.0              3.0
Ԯṩ                          
                       ŵ            ô
                                        ֹ            ֹ
                                       97/12/31       98/3/31
ʻһ֯          21.0          8.2             13.7
                  10.0          3.0              5.0
޷չ               4.0          2.0              3.0
ձ                      10.0          0.0              0.0
                       5.0          0.0              0.0
¼                                               
Ĵ                                             
й½                                             
й                                             
                                             
ӡ                                                 
                                                 
                                                 
ܼ                      57.0          13.2             21.7
Ԯṩ                        ̩
                       ŵ            ô
                                        ֹ            ֹ
                                       97/12/31       98/3/31
ʻһ֯           4.0          2.4             2.7
                   1.5          0.0             0.5
޷չ               1.2          0.0             0.6
ձ                       4.0          1.7             2.7
                       0.0          0.0             0.0
¼                     1.0          0.6             0.7
Ĵ                   1.0          0.6             0.7
й½                   1.0          0.6             0.7
й                   1.0          0.6             0.7
                   1.0          0.6             0.7
ӡ                       0.5          0.0             0.0
                       0.5          0.2             0.2
                       0.5          0.0             0.0
ܼ                      17.2          7.3            10.2
    ԴSteven Radelet  Jeffrey D.Sachs ,1998,P50.
        2.Ϊ˵IMFѾ
    IMFԾĿΣĶǣ ȻòûмΣʵϣIMF ڴ˴ζΣеΪʾһ
ŵΪߵѾءIMF ûй˵ԴҲûһɫ
    1IMFṩ޶ȵŴֹʱӡڱ3 пģIMF ṩļƻɹʽ֯عһԸ
ṩĴɡҲ˵IMF ľԮһƷ˽ˣȨңԸġȻϢѧԭ֪
IMFԮһƷʲ⹩СѶѷSamuelson1954Ź֮ĲΣ
Ӱ죨ֱӺͼӰ죩ӶˣڶԸƶԵĽΣʱIMF һӴǲ
Ҳӳ˸ԴΣ̬ȣǿԿֻĮĵŷޡ˽ձԼԹ˲Ͼй
    ҵǣIMFƻŵ£ ЩڶҲûȫͶʹáЩʹIMF ׼Լ˫
̸СԺΪIMFŵܼ570 ԪĴУ 19983µʵʹöΪ217ڡIMF ֻǽһӴһ
ٲֱṩֹ
    2IMFжٻûг֮ǰԮΣ֮Ϊ漰ȨңIMF ֻܱƳ
ľ֯Σʱ ǳԸIMFζųʧشηպΡ
ղòIMFļƻȥ̸߳й̡гξжʱ˷ѱʱ䡣Ϊ˷ãI
MFӦһֻƣ ʹ֮ԶͶԳѿھͽֹȴԸΪʱӡ
        3.ڻIMF·
    ԿIMFڵȱݣ ֻܼ޵ط˵áзǣȻIMF ܳ䵱ŵ
ˣĴȴȻ˵·Ĵڣ˵Ĵĵ·գעڹĵ
ĸϸۣĲοף3ݵ9¼13¡Щơֵ·붫ƹͬӾ˶ǽΣ
    ֪ǹҵĽڻĵ¾Ӫ˺ЩƲֵ벻ȫļܹ̼ͬ
дҲ̼нִڷսϴĿΪԤһؿȡ
    ֵ·ҲӰṩĹʴߵΪΪţͬڴһЩծĻϢģ
ȻʽĵЭ顣ǻȷ֪ΪһȺԳɻΣвùŵʵϣڶΣʱ
ʴ߾ģҸɵ൱ɹֲĵʴΪûбҪԶǽڻϸ
Ȼʴӵõķչϵʱ֪ǵһЩڻĸ߷գȴȻ
    òᵽϢҪԡָǽϵȱ͸ȼϢ֣ƺֻҪϢȫгͻ
á뷨ɵġڶǣϢĻȡǷģⲢûбתΪг룬ΣеĴ󲿷ϢԳԴ
ڹʴߴΪеĵ·գûͼȥȡúͷЩֳɵϢϢľڴˣûǡƣ
ϢҲܱ֤гĸЧȶˣǰǿÿʴۺûܴ֮ϵһˡ
ʴ˵ΪӦָܵġ
    IMFĴֵһֵ·ա ʴʶǸܿ˷ǳĽΣʱЩʴ߿ʼ
йعʩѹʹIMFΪIMFļƻڴ˶ǽˣSoros1998IMFľԮƻͨŸ
ζŹʴ߲ܹ׵ȫˣԻöг֪оԮͲжԼԼ
ζΣʧɶǸ͹ٷĹԮеծȨ뺫ծչ̸ֳ
̬ȣӢܣ1998в׼еӦеǲΣʧǡǡ෴ҪΣı֪
ڵĹʴӵегԿģȽĴչڵг·ϣʹIMF 
òΪˣҲʹǽΣĽüѡ
            ԤͿδĽΣ
    ȥΪ˾ʾδKindleberger1996ʷǶȶԽڿֻŷԭصɢоʹȷţֻҪڹ
ͶͶߣΣݡ˱ʵѾʾڽͶΣȻ๤ͽ͵ġ˹ٸ
ģ1998ΣھûõĹҲᷢһʶȻָȥֹΣߣȴǱ
Ŭȥ̽ѰԼһΣĿԺΣʱʱ䡣һЩ˼
        1.ƹʽгĲȶ
    ڲ׶ɭϵ󣬹ʽгĲȶվ񲻴ڹ˻ƣߺδγɣ
ЩСͿžֻ˻صĳ̶ֳȵʱԱ֤ΣĴȾ
    1ȡʩԼʱֱ㽻˰ Զʱʩ׼ҪҼƼۻйصծ
ϢۼȵȡЩʩΪӹʱ׳ɱӶ١ĳ̶ֳϼʴ֮໥ģʹ
ؽ˽Ϣ֮ϣӶߴȶԡΪڽ׼ĽߵķչʹЩ
ʩЧ1995꼰1997ԵΣеı֤ʩȷʵЧؼʱ١
    2ʱĹɡԽԽľÿԿ ֱͶʲʱͼͬʱȷԸȶȻ˷չй
δӦعֱͶʡ
    3Դɻͬʱǿڼܡ ෢չйžʵǿ׷ɻ׷ȡгĹ
ƶȡھó졢ϵȫʱȡЩƶȷġǣһǣġƶҲȡɻ
ĽУӦƣӦǽһɱ֤ϵЧļܿܣԱ֤ег嶼ȷļơ
    4ʵǣһ˽Σ ӦѸٶϵʵơһԣֱ׶ˣгɻ
㣡 ڽΣһǳʱ̾ӦȡǳʩKrugman 1998עKrugmanIMFΣƴʩʵʱ
ơѸٸгʹڽڻԴϢĻᣬ鼰ָгĵȡ
        2.Σĵ·
    ǰķʴߵĵ·ռΣĳ̶ȡˣҪΣĽӦôӷֹߵĵ·

    1ȣ Ҫʹ߶мǿչǿҶһ㣬ҪʹΣҲҪеʧ
ϹȥνΣĽѾ˶ӵΣծǹծ˽˲ծ
ζΣҲ·ҲҪеʧĻƽôѹʴ˶ǷжӦ˽
Ϣ֮ϴӶټΪķΣʱʹɱӹתӦĵط˽˲ţ̶ǿ
ԹڻǵĽļôڶϾͻָĽڻ͸ٵ˰ʧ
    2˵ķչйҵĽڻƽʱʱ ҪʽгϵҪծȨṩŴӢܣ1998
ŴڹҳмʱԶȡŴһΣĿԣΪծȨв̫ڴҳʣ
һ棬ʹΣΣҲɴӱŴлٴӶΣĽ
    3ӺϿĻָпԿ ˫̸ֱΣĽҪΪ˫ծ⼰֤ȯ̸
УЧؿ˷дڵĴ㳵Ϊͬʱ˵·ա
            ġ
    ڶǽΣڼһ棬۲ڹʽϵؽοƽгȶԼIMFְܵȡ һ
棬Խй˵δӱ˵ĴȡǸΪҪģйҲŴĽƣҲŷҪ󿪷Źڽг
ľ޴ѹ԰ӿĹʽڻйƸĸĵ·ôߣһֵ˼⡣
α༭
У  ߡˮ
οס
    ܸ˼ա׶1992ȫӽǵĺ۾ѧѷ룬ϺϺ硣
    ʲ1995ҽѧ뱾йѧ硣
    Ӣܣ1998ӺΣʽϵĽѵĸƱȽϡ3ڡ
    Լɪ˹ٸģ1998Ƚ޵ĿɳչƱȽϡ3ڡ
    Diamond,Douglas W and Philip H, Dybvig. 1983,"Bank  runs,Deposit Insuranse, and Liquidity" Journal of Political Economy,
 91(3):40119
    IMF,1997,"KoreaReqest  for  Stand  By  Arrangement."Washington ( December  3) .   1998, World  Economic  Outlook.W
ashington.
    Kindleberger,Charles P.1996,Manias,Panics, and Crashes;  AHistory of Financial Crises, 3d.ed.John Wiley.
    Krugman, Paul. 1998, "Saving  Asia:   It's  Time  to  GetRadical" Fortune, September 7, 1998.
    Steven Redelet and  Jeffery  D. Sachs.   1998, "The  EastAsian Financial Crisis: Diagnosis, Remedies,       Prospects",B
rooking Papers on Economic Activity, No 1, 1998.
    
    
    
 
