 ׺ 2-601
ԭĳŴѧѧ
ԭںš199901
ԭҳš3339
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš199904
    Ծ˼ٶƶȹ淶Է
    
߼顿Ŵѧо
ҪԾ˵ΪٶȻ߼ǣǷữƷǷпɷԡԣڳ׵˽
вȨƶȻϵгᾭƶȡˣԾһȷƶȹ淶ķٶⲻһ
۳˵˵γɼ䷢չԼʷ֮Ļϵ⵼¹ŵ侭ѧΪһ侫ȴط
ϵ
  ʡԾ/Ȩ/ƶ/淶Է
    
    гĸ뷢չʹйѧؽΪѧעĽ㡣̽йгеۿʱµ
۷ĽҪ˴ͳξѧ۷㡪֮ʲôȡأЩ¹ŵ
ѧķȡ֮ЩоδʾпԿԾΪǰġĵĿ֤
˲һʵ֤⣬ƶȹ淶Ϊ衣
            һ
    Ծ¹ŵ侭ѧķǰᡣںҪ棺ռ塢󻯼ٶȫԼٶ
    ռԾ˼ٶоӺĵλǣҹѧֻ򵥵عΪ塣
ѧ¹ŵѧɵָ˼ͷۻû塣ǣҪһָ壨IndividualismΪۡ ʶ̬
򷽷ۣжֺ塣S.¬˹ָڸʿв11ֵĽ͡˵ϡ˽˻ҷ
չһֱʶ۵ĺͷ۵ĸ壬ȵȡȻڸֲԵĲ൱һʱδ
ʶˣڵľѧ۲ֲָ𣬣עC.B.˸ɭĿJ.S.ǵһռ
˷չ֮ľѧңǣʶǱȽϻҵġ˼ǵһָľѧңȻ
δøռ͸˷չJ.Τȱࣺ׷򾭼ѧǵ䡷2ÿѧ1992棬
853856ҳѧڵĶѧ綼ֻ˵ѧ¹ŵ侭ѧķۻǸ
壬Ǹʲô壬Ӧأ˼ѧĳ֮Ϊ壨collectivismķۡҹѧУ൱
ѧȻΪע⡣йط׾йɫִѧķǰᡷءй⡷19982 
Ҳĳ̶ֳˣˣҹһЩѧڷ񶨼巽۵ͬʱ¹ŵѧɵĸ巽۳̬ͬȡ
    ϸֲͬĸ塣ӸĹϵֽȻͬĸ塣һǸռ˵˾壬
һǸ˷չ˵塣ڸռ͸˷չ壬A.Үȷ֣Ϊĸִ
չʼԼˣʼڲɵ¡ϵάʹĮǡ˶ǵɭǵ˹ܣԼΰͬ˰
ɡ˵Уĸ״γϵ⣬пάͰ˶ѫҲĸߡ19͵ı
ߺѧߣԼŷ޴½ܵѿѧӰ編ġٿȫ顷ɡ¬ũȴٵĸ
ߡעA.Үˣ뾭򡷵1£ ѧԺ1989棬6ҳڹҮ˿ ĸ壨
ռ壩ָǡһۻʶ̬˱ȸԸߵĵ¼ֵᳫøȥ
Ϊ¡עC.B.˸ɭ塷J. Τȱࣺ׷򾭼ѧǵ䡷2
ѧ1992棬853ҳھѧϵҪǣ1ʱ˽вƲ֮ͼ̳еȨıҪԣɴ
޵תúͻۡ2 һָ֮ڻȡƸĶԿһΪõеĶעC.B.˸
ɭ塷J.Τȱࣺ׷򾭼ѧǵ䡷2ÿѧ1992棬853ҳJ.S.վѸ
ռУԭݳɣ˶ΪԼһˡͬ档¹ŵ侭ѧĸ
壬䱾ʶԣǸռ塣ϸĸռƵȫгģ͵Ϊٶע
Խʵеˣ¹ŵѧɽչΪЧ󻯣һչȴ˸ص⡣йط
׾йɫִѧķǰᡷ
    ռ巽۵һصǾܾĿġƫáγɹƶȻʷáΪ
ⲿԸΪӰڸƫ£֪ͨⲿı仯ʵĿ꺯ԼͻԷӦS.
¬˹ΪƶȺؿ˵ΪôͲһĸˣռУ巽ߡ
    Ծ˼ٶ棺󻯺ȫԼٶƪĲչ
            
    Ծ˼ٶΪ㣬¹ŵ侭ѧƳгᾭŵ֯ʽгõĲȨƶȻǳ׵˽
ơ
    ȻΪᾭĸȫģͬʱʵ󻯵Ը˵Ȼ״жߣ
ԾԼĿ꺯ʵڸ˾ԼѵȫƷƷѾпɷָԣʽо
ǰ£κữʽǲҪġΪԼѵĲƷǣѵᾭзʽȻ
ᾭзʽӦĲȨƶǸӵԼȫϣȫĸơڸ˲߱Լ
ȫƷԱвͬܣߣ˾ԼȫƷԼȫ
Ʒǲõ£ĸ׷󻯵ĹУȻ𽥵ԼбȽƲƷͬʱͨ
ȡԲĲƷˣרҵȫʽиЧ£ΪĸˣԱѡȻ
ֹгϡġ˼ӡThe  Edgeworth boxüͼĸڼ
ͨ˴˽ӵвƷʵָ˵ĸ󻯡עLee S. Friedman:Microeconomic Policy Analysis,McGRAW- HILL  BOOK C
OMPANY,1984,p.32ͼ1
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ1   ˼׺ͼ
    ͼ1˵ڼȶ£SJ ͨʵָԵĸ󻯡ͼУ½O[,s]SϽO[,j] 
JMTֱӵеƷMT ˣͼڵκһSJƷMTӵ״
ٶASJڽʼ֮ǰƷMTӵ״O[,s]M[,s] O[,s]T[,s]ΪSӵеƷMTO[,j]M[,m]O[,j]T[,j
]ΪJӵƷMT޲S[,i]J[,i]ʾSJڲͬеĸˮƽSS[,3]S[,2]S[,e] S[,1]
JJ[,3]J[,2]J[,e]J[,1]УAS[,e]J[,e]SJڳʼ״̬¸ˮƽ޲ߡ޲S[,i ]
J[,i]еĵCBHDԼߣcontract curve CF޲ߵĶ壬ͬһ޲S[,i]J[,i]ϵĲͬ
ʾƷMTĲͬϸO[,s]O[,j]Чüˮƽ޲ġ磬  A[,s]M[,e]T[,e]B[,s]M[,e]T
[,e]ƷMTȻͬǣS˵ ṩЧˮƽͬģ ӦأA[,i]H[,i]JṩЧˮƽ
Ҳͬġ ע⵽ʼAλԼϣڼȶ£SJӵеƷMTıǵƫò
ϣȶƷֲʹи÷µˮƽSJͨ໥ӵеƷMTʹӵе
ƷƫӦ磬ͨʹSӵеƷӵA[,s]S[,e]ƵB[,s]Sĸˮƽ䣬JĸˮƽȴܴJ[,e
]ᵽJ[,2]֮ ʹJӵƷӵA[,j]J[,e]ƵH ʹSĸˮƽJ ĸˮƽǰµߡA޲
S[,e]J[,e] ΧɵӰ֣ڼȶ£SJͨ˫״Ŀ򣬼ӵAӰڵһ
㣬SJ ĸõơˣΪԾ˵SJ ضͨӵеƷӵABHĳһϡ
    һأвɷʱҲ˵һֲƷϵԱʱŶTeam Production 
ͳΪҪǣԾ˼ٶŶʽıзᾭлƼȨƶȻĽۡA.A.氲
H.ķķڶ£˶ܲĹǺ׼ȷȷġΪһЭḶٰ́Ͷ룺
X[,i]X[,j]
    ͼ{ͼ}
    עƫΪ㣬
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͿԷֳӵĺZ ֽܷΪͶX[,i]X[,j] ң ĲһҪ
ԱԽĲ֮ͣ˶ǿܵĻˣܽZ ֺ֮ΪZ 
ڶԱзܴʹЧعأȻԾ˵Ϊٶ£ѶԱͶϵͶ
̿ʼǰͿȷͼͶͶ뼰̵ģǿԷֿʵͷϵĻǿɱģˣҪ
ÿԱͶͶ뼰Ľмͼලּලͼ޳ɱģû˻͵ļΪ˭Ҳ޷͵
ǿӸˣԱǵĺԸɵģڼලͼгɱ£ڴת޲ָϢɱԱ
Ӷʹδĸ˳ɱڶӵʵɱĿԣΪĸˣÿԱȻ͵ĶʱЧʵ½
ЭܴЧߡˣĳרΪලԱͶ뼨Чǣල߱ҲҪල˭ලලأ
A.A.氲H.ķָⲿг֮⣬ԼǡԼලʩӰ죬ڶӵľ뼰Ͷ֧
ȨͶͬල߿Իȡ涨ϵκβƷͶı߼ʼֵƷල߾
һΪල߲͵׷ӵļעA.A.氲H.ķģϢ뾭֯ƲȨƶ
ǨϺ1991棬67ҳȨ1һвȨˣ2۲ͶΪ 3Ȩ
ͶԼǹͬģ4ıӵĳԱʸ񣻣5Щŵҵʱҵƣ
ȨעA.A.氲H.ķģϢ뾭֯ƲȨƶȱǨϺ1991棬68
69ҳȻȨѾŶƽȵһԱǹԱǹԱ˿ԵóۣԾ
£ЧʵŶҲ뽨˽вȨƶȻϡ
    ڼලѶȴӶɱŶĹģԵģ֯ɱලɱֻеһ֣ڶ
Эʱҵı߽ͳˡҵ֮ĹϵȻǽгϵʽ룬ûиı¹ŵѧ۶
ᾭлƼȨƶȻнۡ
            
    ƷѵĿɷԣSeparabilityǲƷԵĻǲƷΪ˽˲Ʒprivate goodsǰᡣ ˽˲Ʒ
ӦǹƷPublic goodsƷ˽˲Ʒ෴ϵĲɷԼԡѵڼѡ
P.A.ѶɭĻ˵ǡÿ˶ԸòƷѲѵļ١
    ڹƷA.˹ܡJ.S.յA.C.ӹšP.A.ѶɭΪгʧõĶ󡣵ǣF.ء峣
ȴ෴Ŀ峣ָǮͻõĹӦĹӦһ˰֧֣ôô˻κг
أѵܳԵ˶ãע峣ԡĴ1988棬39ҳ峣ԡ˹ĵΪ
˵һΪӪĹƷҲǿ˽˾ӪġעR.˹1974귢ӢڵȨƶȵģѧ
ĵThe Lighthouse in EconomicsThe Journal of Law andEconomics,17,No. 2һʵΪݷһ㾭ѧձ
ܵΪ˽Ӫ޴շѻͼĹ۵㡣E.J.ָڹƷĲȨ˽лӵɹƷʹ
ЧʡJ.M.ˡֲۡӴͳĹƷлֲֳƷֲƷȺ˽˲Ʒֲȫͬڹ
Ʒ1ԡ һĳʸ񣬲ؾֲԱɵȺ干ͬѵģ2 Ƕ
ԡĳһֲԱԾֲƷѲӰųֲԱͬһƷѡJ.M.ΪþֲȨƶ
ĳЩоֲƷʵĹƷӵ⣬ңͨһĲȨƶȰţ൱ĹƷǿԱɾֲƷģĻ
˵ĹƷǺٵġԿ߼Ͽ˽˲ƷǹƷΪĳϵľֲƷ˽˲Ʒ
һ־ֲԱΪ1ľֲƷJ.M.ϵľֲƷ һɾֲԱΪN1NMM ΪòƷĹͬѲӵ
ٽľֲƷƷһȫԱΪֲԱľֲƷ˵ƷΪһȫԱΪ
ֲԱľֲƷӦֲԱN ʡȻԷ֣ʵУƷûҲǼٵ
ڴڹ£󲿷ּʹJ.M.ϵΪǡ⡱ĹƷΰȣҲֻ鱾ѡһ棬Ծ
˵Ϊٶ£J.M.ϵ۵Ʒġԡˮƽصģ֮ѾֲƷ
ԭǸòƷϵķǶԿԡֻǿʵоֲʽѵıҪǳΪѸòƷĳɱڸ
Чۣ˵ˮƽأʱòƷϵķǶԿԲʹǿԡǣԾ˵Ϊ
ǶԴ˲ԸȡֲѷʽӶʹѸòƷĳɱСڶЧۡμͼ2
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼ2  ֲƷĸѳɱЧԱĹϵ
    ͼ2˾ֲƷĸѳɱ ЧֲԱ֮ĹϵɱCžֲԱӣ ÿԱ
ĳɱ½ЧB1ζһĳԱڣ˶ԾֲƷЧǲģֲĳԱ
ӵһԺ󣬾ͷӵʹԱЧü½˳ɱ½һ棬˵Чصģ
ˮƽʱЧߵˮƽ߶βֻἱ̣ͼ2 еB2ΪˣֲƷģѶʱֲԱ
ʵˮƽ߻ʹֲС򣬼ϣٵһֲƷҲ˵ԭڽϵˮƽϳֳǿ
ԡĲƷˮƽʱڡ˽˻J.M.ָʮǰũҵе豸ũ
ģÿũԼ䱸ᵼ豸Ч½ԸˡˣԾ˵ļٶ¹ŵ侭ѧ
ĽǣϵشʹƷ˽˻ƶȰšע۵ϸѧɻֽǶȿ¹
ѧɣ磬A.Үˡ峣J.M.ϵȣǣڼԾ˼ٶ棬¹ŵѧȫһµģй֮޲
ǵĹ۵һ֮£A.Ъƺ漰Ծ˼ٶȨƶȰŵĹϵΪΪ
Ȼ֣̽A.Үˡ峣J.M.ϵΪ˻ָ¹ŵĴͳ԰˼徭ѧڵѧɵ
Щ¹ŵ߼Ľ͵Եʡ
            
    Ծ˵ΪٶȻ߼ǣǷữƷǷпɷԡԣڳ׵˽вȨ
ƶȻϵгᾭƶȡȻһȷƶȹ淶ķٶһ㣬¹ŵ侭ѧӲԡA.
Ү˾ȷָģıʲôأȣҪһּЩۣΣ
һԴ۵Ϊ淶עA.Үˣ뾭򡷵1£ѧԺ1989棬6ҳ
ҹһЩѧ֤ĳЩ÷Ի˵ǼֵȡԷż顣ˣǣ
۷չϵľ޼ɴǱ
    ѧоˣʵֵ֤֮䲢ڽȻĽޡעйط׾۾÷еЧ۱׼
ֵ۱׼ءо199612ڡѧоųļֵȡϣڿ͹۵ڣʵ
ǵطǷһ۳ȷطӳڱʡԾ˼ٶƶȹ淶壬ر޼
Ϊֻʹ۽ɳ֮ϡͬΪĳںļֵȡؾܾҲǿѧ̬ȡΪڸռ
ϵԾ˼ٶĸǣһ۳˵˵γɼ䷢չʷ֮Ļ
ϵĻȱݵ¹ŵ侭ѧΪһʮ־µȴطյϵڽгʱҲԿ˷
ìܣοڷгСˣΪйɫִѧ۵Ĵ¶Ȼ
ǷǳҪģδ治ǰߡǧ磬ڹ۴¿ռ䣬ȫҪϵ֮Ǵ˼ˡй
ɫִѧ뽨ԼĿѧ۷ϣҪҹѧĲиŬע߶Ըĳ̽
׾йɫִѧķǰᡷ
α༭С
    
    
    
 
