 ׺ 2-1341
ԭĳѧо
ԭ
ԭںš199903
ԭҳš711
  šF11
  ۾ѧ
ӡںš199906
    ۾ѧо߼
    ½
߼顿ߵλɽѧѧԺ
    
    ѧо߼һεĸϽṹɶ߼˼߼ͷչ߼ɡһھѧоУѧ
ָͨĳѧ˼ϵ˼߼漰ѧĶ߼չ߼ĺ塣һǰѾѧоӾ徭ѧ
תԾѧо򾭼ѧΪѧ֪ʶһԶȶԣΪʶʷĽ׶Գɹķչԣͱ
ɾѧĶ߼ͷչ߼֡ݾѧ߼ֽṹص㣬۾ѧо߼໥ϵ
            һѧоĶ߼
    ѧоĶͬѧʶʵ壬ľûɵĿ͹ʷ̡ھѧʶ̣
ѧоĶһ̬ⷢϵͳྭûԵоⶼ͹۵Ķ̬ϵͳ֮СѧΪ
ƣΪʶĶ󡱣ֻǲ⣬ǻش⡣
    ͹۵ľùһӵⷢϵͳʶȴֻѭض߼̣ѷ׳ڸľ徭˼ά
ļӹӶѿ͹۵Ķ̬ϵͳΪ۵ľѧ߼ͬ͹۵ľѧϵͳһ£۵ľѧ߼Ҳһϵͳ
ֻͼ໥ϵѭ˼άе߼ṹʵľǾġ䶯ӵģ˼άľѧǾ
̬ġϵͳĺʽġѧʶ֮Ա뽫͹۵ľѧת۵ľѧ߼ԭֻи۶
ľѧ⼰߼ṹǲܹγϵͳġȶľѧ֪ʶϵֻǽͿ͹۶̬ľ徭һЩ
µ
    ۵ľѧ߼ֻǴʽ߼ϵͳκεľѧ֪ʶΪͬ͹۾ѧǺϵⷢϵͳһ
ЩΪľѧļϡЩĲͬʣǿ԰Ѿѧֳࣺ淶ͷ⡣淶
һЩͬѧ˼ĻӦļֵжϻʹ淶⣻ͬѧĸ־ùϵ
ӦıҪص⡣߼ϣ淶Ľͺ϶ͨйԣڱܹ淶Լʾ
߼ԡͬ淶ϵľѧоҪǶԵ˼͹Եжϣͬصľѧ۵
;ʵ֤
    ݾѧķ࣬۾ѧԵبŲĹ淶ǡʲôǲƸ⣻ķ
ǡƸӡ⡣һʵĻҾϵԣ۾ѧĶ߼Ĺ淶ԻУ1.ùеľ
ƷļֵγɵģϵеļֵƸʲô⣻2.ھù侭ùܵĻңֵγɵģ
ֵʲô⣻3.ҵľùЩ⡣۾ѧĶ߼ķԻУ1.Ʒͷʵع
ʵʾñϵʵԴùϵͶϵԼƶ뾭ЧʵĹϵȣ2.ҷĹϵһ
ˮƽĹϵҹҼֵĹϵȣ3.ʵʱͬұ֮Ĺϵһ˵ù̵ʵ﷽
ͬù̵ĻҷĹϵҷ仯ǷӰʵʾõĲ⣬仰˵Ƿ֮Ĺϵ⡣
    ӦڻԵĹ淶⣬۾ѧӦγ˼ֵγۡұۺͻҹ۵о򡣶ӦھñϵӦ
ľѧ⣬۾ѧγ˾÷оִѧϵĺ۾ѧ΢۾ѧƶȾѧ۾ѧľ
򡣡ƸֵӡǾѧķ⣬˾÷ľѧǳɱ
    ϶Ծѧ淶ͷĶ壬ǿԸͬʵľѧļԼ֮ӹϵ ͼʾ1

    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼʾ1 ѧĶ߼۾ѧо⼯ϼ伯ϹϵɡֵĻǾѧ
ֵжϵ⣬ǹھû֪ʶϵͳʲôǡƸʲôǡֵĹжΪǰġڼֵͬ۵
ཻ֣۾ѧĻǻҼֵĹ淶⣬༴Ҽֵγۻұ۵⡣ڼֵͬ÷۵ӽ
沿֣ѧĻһ㾭Ʒļֵξ⡣еĻǽ綨ҹܵ⣬
۵⡣һ㾭÷⼯ɸ־ñ֮໥ϵɣڻļͬһ㾭÷
ļཻĲǻҷ⣬Ҽֵ⡢ұϵ⣬ԼұͬʵʱĹϵȡԶ
׼нһ㾭÷߼ӵⶼǷ⣬߼֮ľѧ⼯϶ڹ淶⡣
            ѧо˼߼
    ѧоĶ߼һʽϵͳӳֻǾѧļϼʽ߼ϵںκξѧ֪ʶ
ѧ֪ʶ򾭼ѧǶԾѧ߼ϵͳлشͽ͵߼ϵͳ߼ϵͳԳ֮Ϊѧо˼߼
    ͬѧ߼ľ̬Բͬѧ˼߼߼Ƕ̬ġġѭһ߼ιϵྭѧʶ
ʷʱϵͳݱ䷢չˣھѧо˼߼Ҫرǿ۵㣺1.κξѧ֪ʶۣϵ߼ϵͳ
صģ2.ѧ֪ʶۣϵ߼ṹϴԵĲιϵͬԽһͼʾ־ѧ˼߼뿴ͼʾ
2
    ͼ{ͼ}
    ͼʾ2Ľṹͬǰͼʾ1ĽṹӦģͼʾ1 ʾ۾ѧϵͳͼʾ2 ʾǸʷʱ
ľѧ֪ʶϵЩش߼̡ͼʾ2 Ľṹѧо˼߼ڽṹΣһͼʾ
Ȧʾļֵ۹۵㣬ɹھѧֵĻжϻɣӳضʷʱڵľѧ֪ʶϵļֵۡڶ
ͼʾмȦʾڽṹӳľѧ֪ʶһ㣩÷۹۵㣬ұ۹۵Լҹ۹
㣬ǸԶһЩ˼ɡ÷۵㷴ӳضѧ֪ʶϵľѧۺ;÷߼ܣұ
ͻҹ۹۵þѧ֪ʶϵĻҼֵγɹۺͻҵľùܹۡ߼ԲȦʾĻҷ۹۵
ھѧ֪ʶ߼ϵͳϵͽ׵߼Ρ
    ṹϿ쾭ѧо˼߼ӡ֤һҪʶԭ򣬼߼˶ͬʷķչһ¡̬ع۲ͼʾ˼߼
ǿ߼ϵڣɵһνݱġ˵κضʷʱڵľѧ֪ʶϵֵ
۹۵߼λģǾ÷۹ۺͻұ۹۹۵㣬ǾĻҷ۹۵㡣Ӷ̬ʷʱ
ĽǶ۲죬ǿѧ˼˶߼˳ͬѧ۷չʷһµġκξѧ֪ʶϵʷеγɺͷ
չڼֵ۵߼γĹ̶һ㾭÷ۺͻұۻҹ۵߼ιɱͷչ
һµĻҷۿܡ
    ھѧо˼߼һϵͳػش߼̣˾ĳضʷʱڵľѧ֪ʶϵԣ߼ε֪
ʶ۵㡢ԼԭȶЭһµĹϵ˵ضľѧ֪ʶϵ߼һµġ֮ѧ֪ʶ
ϵĸ߼֮䲢֪ʶ۵㡢ԼԭЭһ¹ϵ˵ضľѧ֪ʶϵ߼һµ
߼һһ־ѧ˼ϵչĽ߼һþѧ˼ϵϵͳչĹʷ׶Ρ
    ͨ£һ˵ľѧ֪ʶϵ˵һµľѧʽҪ൱ʷʱܹ߼һ״̬ݱ䵽
һµ״̬֮ˣ˵Ҫԭ򡣿͹۵ԭǣ˾ѧʽļֵ۹ھѧ˼߼Ľṹ
϶µ˶ʱڿ͹ʷʱʱͣ۵ԭǣ澭ѧʱڵľѧѧߴŬԼСأȱ
ѧ֪ʶϵݱ䷢չۺҰ߼ʹҰҲǡķֻеġ
ճɡˣеǣͳѧƾЩСջġľѧ˼
            ѧоķչ߼
    ʶʷУѧоĶ߼بŲ䣬ɾѧһ֪ʶϵͳרĹ涨ԣǲ̸ۺ
ѧͱȻԡʲôǲƸֵ͡Ƹֵӡ⣬ͱȻԾѧĶ߼ϵͳľ
ѧ⡣ԣѧоĶ߼ṩһ̬ϵͳѧо˼߼ӦЩγɻش֪ʶϵ
Ȼѧо˼߼ͬ߼ֶ֮ӦϵȫľѧʷչΪκضѧ֪ʶϵͬѧ
߼֮ĶӦϵྭѧʶʷжֻʱģھѧ˼߼ԣһĳѧʽʷ
ĳʱڱȷ߼ռͲٲµġѧ֪ʶ
    ¡ѧ֪ʶһµľѧ֪ʶϵȡɵľѧ֪ʶϵĹ֮УһµĻشϵͳȡɵĻش
ϵͳĹ֮С߸ϸ˵µġѧ֪ʶ¾ѧʽȡɾѧʽĹ֮Сʶѧ
ʷйɡµġѧ֪ʶġѧʽת¾ɾѧ֪ʶϵ̣ͿԶΪѧоķչ߼

    ݾѧо˼߼ͷչ߼Ĺ۵㣬ھ̬ľѧ߼ѧྭѧ֪ʶʷ̾ͱΪݱ
͡Էչ淢Ķ̡̬ڳݱʱڣһ֧λľѧ֪ʶϵѭѧо˼߼ʵ
߼ռ̺̣ɳľѧչʱڡʱڣ÷ļֶ澫£Ծѧõֵ
ͺоģΪȶѧʽ߼ռ̺ģѧ֪ʶʱγɻԵӡھѧĸԷչʱڣ
ѧĶ߼ٱľѧ֪ʶϵ¢ϣ֮˾Ե˼ϵŬؾŶھѧ߼Ĺ淶ͽȨ
ͼʹԼչΪµľ֧λشϵͳʱڣ淶ԾѧĻתƵǰ̨ۡкͶԹ淶ѧս
˳ʱڵľ÷ĽǾиӹ߼ռľѧʽʼ¢϶Ծѧ߼Ĺ淶ͽȨΪµ
ľѧ֪ʶϵɾѧо˼߼ͷչ߼Լľѧʱں͸ʱڵĽ淢չ͹˾ѧ򾭼ѧ֪ʶʷ
չĻ̬
    ѧо˼ھ̬ľѧ߼γɵľѧ֪ʶʷչõġƶھѧ
֪ʶԴڿ͹۵ʵʾù̵޷չͱ仯ʷʱзͷչľùྭʵĻҲྭ
ѧ۵߼Ϳ͹۾ùͬѧĶ߼֮Ĺϵ͹۵ľù۾ѧʵ
һ˾ѧΪ֪ʶɲֵıȻԺͺԣѧĶ߼˼άڿ͹۵Ķ̬ùγɵľ̬
ʽͿ͹۾ùͬѧ˼߼֮Ĺϵ͹۵ľùʷκʱڵľѧ֪ʶϵĺԵļ
һµľѧ֪ʶϵɸ߽׵߼ͽ׵߼﷢չʱھѧϵͳĻش;ͻԽԽ
ࡢԽԽľ顣Щʵʾùṩġʷʱвӵľʵͬȶشϣһ
ѧ֪ʶϵĺԾӡ֮͹۾ùͬش͵ݷìܣìʱ̶ӣѧ
֪ʶϵĺԾҪ½Ǿͻỳеľѧ֪ʶϵԣ͹۵ľùڸϹɾѧչĶ

    ھѧ淢չʷʱڣɾѧ˼ݽĶһǼȴľ¢ϵλľѧ˼ϵ߼ԣһ
ǿ͹۵ľù̶߼չľʵȷϡûкߵǣκξѧ˼ϵ߼̺޴ʵֵ
ءѧ˼߼ض޵ġһӦѧϵͳ˼߼ɣ򾭼ѧĳ淢չͽ˾ֹ
״̬Եľѧ֪ʶϵ򾭼ѧʽܹɾѧ֪ʶչʷ̬Ŀ͹۾ùһ߼ռе
ѧ֪ʶϵṩ϶ľȻһ֪ʶϵ߼ռĺԷΧ͹۾ù̾Ϳʼṩ֤ľۣӶ
ʹԭȵƶתΪֹоѧ֪ʶϵչʱѧչ߼ķʽת̾ͻᷢиӿ߼
ľѧ֪ʶϵͻȡϵӶγɾѧ֪ʶʷԷչԣֻп͹۵ʵʾù̵Ķ̬չܸѧʷ
չṩ־õĶ
α༭
οס
    Blaug,M.(1976) Kuhn versus  Lakatos  or  Paradigms  versusResearch Programmes in the History of Economics,in Method  and
Appraisal in Economics, ed. S. J. Latsis, Cambridge: CambridgeUniversity Press.
    1984ѧѧйѧ硣
    Klamer, A. ( 1984) The  New  Classical  Macro- economics:Conversations with  the  New  Classical  Economists  and  theOp
ponents,Brighton,Wheatsheaf Books.
    Kuhn,T.S.(1962)The Structure  of  Scientific  Revolutions,Chicago,University of Chicago Press.
    Popper,K.(1959)The Logic of Scientific Discovery,London.
    Russell,B.(1948)Human Knowledge:It Scope  and  Limits, NewYork,Simon and Schuster.
    
    
    
 
