 ׺ 3-3106
ԭĳʦѧѧѧ
ԭɳ
ԭںš199506
ԭҳš46-51
  šD0
  ѧ
    ¬
ӡںš199601
    ˼ȽϴҪʾ
    
    ժҪ  йͳ˼ʥ֮˼ԨԴոʽǻۡǰΪ⽨רṩ˼
ΪȨƶṩݡʥ֮Ϊһѧѧܸ壬Ϊһѧѧȴȱʵ֧֡ǽ
Ƹĸﲽά裬ԭʥ֮ǧ˿Ƶϵȫ뷨ƣҪ˼ϸʥ֮
ȡһոʽǻۡ
    ؼ  ʥ  ֪֪  
                                                  
    ˼ǰʥ֮ԨԴոʽǻۡʥ֮ոʽǻ۸Ŷ
ĸͬϡĽͨԱȿŬʾԵξĶϣϵͳıȽо
            һ
    ˵ʥ֮һйѧ֮ȫ壬ּԾ˵йѧ֮񡱾
ʥ֮йѧУһһɣΪʥ֮1˼бֵΪͻ
    ˼ҽעظ֪ĳ⡢ҡιƽ£Ϊ֪֪ϣ϶
ޣ޶룬ΣζƽˣҼǽΪ2ԡѧĻ
ʥ֮Դͷ
    ӦΪΪ˳ΪʥˣΪʥ˻ѳΪʥ˵ľвιƽµʹɼʥ֮۵
ѧѧһ¯ѧʡʥ֮벻Եġ˵Ϊ˽ƶˣʥ˿ɽƶ֮ڡ
֮3ӿ֮˿Ϊ˿ΪҢҲ˵ʲôˣֻҪ¹򡢺¹
ܿԳΪʥˡһѧ˵Ҫ˵ʥ֮Ļʯ
    ߱ſɳ֮ΪʥˡһϺ覴áʥ˵ĵѴ֮Ȼ󹫣˳Ӧ
ִ˵ʥ˾˽֮ġ֪Ͼʧۿ˵ʥҲߣ֮ҲգνһĹģ
һһһɡνĴ⣬ڴԣɡνأ컯˹Ž񣬱
ɡ4ɼʥ˾ǻۣ ڷ֪ϵĴ
    ô˵ʥ˾ƾȫȫܣϵͬй˵ʥϵһͬ㣬ʥҲˣѪ
⣬ϲŭ֣ϵǳʵ塣ʥϲŭ֣ڸ£ʥ֮ϲ֮ϲʥ֮ŭ֮ŭ
5֮ʥˡϲϲ֮ŭŭ֮ϲŭ֮ճִţ಻ΪҲ6ʥ˵־
ȻɡɣѺгһˣˡ˺һ֮磬±ܡء
        
    ˼봫ͳиͬĹ˵ıԵĹԹϣոй˵ľԵϡ
    ո׵Ĺʽշһܵ¶͸û˱ո׸ǻۡŮ˾˵û˱ո׸ǻ
ո׵֪һ֮а룬仰ʲô˼أԼԼ֪ΪʲôҪ˵˼ǻ۵أ룬
ܷһλԼǻ۵ˣͿԵȥˡʿЩֻĳЩǻۣ
ʵǻۡԼȽϣΪԼǱЩ˺һ㣬ΪЩ˲ǻۣȴΪǻۣԼǻۣҲΪǻ
֪Լ֪ոʽǻۡոȷȷģƣֻǻ۵ģǸ͵ǣ˵ǻû
жټֵ˵ոǻֻۣո׵ӣ˼Լ˵ģոˣԼǻ
˵޼ֵǾмǻ۵ˡ7ոʽǻ۶˼Ӱ
    ͵ĻѧΪģ̷ֻϵۣܾԼ꣬ϵ۵Ķ衣׵˾ܾƾ
ȫȫܡ
    ߺѧߣһΪȡ˵ĽŶ֤˵ϣ֤˵Ը㣬һҲж˵ľԸȷı
⽨ȼƺѧʶ̬ʱǻıʵȥˣΪʵƶȡƶıʱж
ľԵʫȥȡ˵Ľţÿѧķȥ졢عƶȺ;ƶȡ
    ˼Ҵȼ̳ոʽǻۣվ׵ϳ˵ĵϵľԡ¬Ϊÿ˵˽
֧䡲8ϵ˹ΪֻǸʵ壬 ǻ֪ʹģһ޵ʵһе΢֪ʶҲҪɥ
ʧ9ǴΪ˵Щ޷˷ģ˵ģ޷ؾԼԶͼƫǲ
ıԼԡ10
    ѧͳոʼӣ¡ƤʿֱִĲգж˵ԵľԵԽԽָ֤
ճͿѧоɻȱĹɷǿɵõ绤ķ֤ܰյֻĶ֮
޷󼰵ģƤʿΪѧʶԽҲֻܲϽԼĴ󣺲˵ľԺ֪ʶĿɴԵ֪ʶ
ۡʷѧѧĳ㡣ڲտ˼׷󣬵ԵԲϵشӴѧϰѧͨϴӴѧϰ
ģѧͱΪһģʽѧض⣬ֱʽԼ˵Ȼȥ󣬼Ƴ
۲ʵȥ˵˵۲ʵ鲵ˣѧ⣬Ҫ¼˵ٽµļ˵Ŭѧ
֪ʶڲųŬеԽġԶֲֻųĹ޽ӽڿ͹11
    ɼͳ˵ıԵйͳʥ֮෴һ˼ҲΪ˿ԳΪϺ覴õˣˡ
ӡϵ˹姬ǵ˹ܵ˼ҶһǿΪ˼ҲΪ˿ԳΪȫȫܡˣո
ֱյȵ˼ҶΪǺ׷ģһ㲨ռֵΪǿңΪעĿ
            
    ӸͬĹԵϳ˼ƶȵݻҲΪͬĹ켣
    ѭйͳʥ֮˼·ﵽʥ˾Ӧȥιƽ¡һ棬֮λ֮¾֮
νӣʥ˿Ϊ֮12ʥ˳ΪΪʥʥڵϾ覴ã񲻱صȨı˽ϵѾ
ȫȫΪıʼղӡʥǻۣԾڷϵĴԳ
ʥִȻͨ˺̩͡񰲣ǲŶԾȨơʵпܲʥִй
κ̫ƽµϣڶԳʥϣټϴͳѧһš֮˿Ϊ ˿ͨΪʥ
ŲƣԼʹڴδֹʲôʥҲδ뵽ҪȨƺİ취ȥһֽΪƽƶȡɼʥ֮йǧ
ꡰΡ˼ĻԴ
    ˴ȫͬǰȫͬ˼ʵ˵ǼȻܸıκҪʣ
޶ֻǸıǵ״ʹ巨Ϊǵн棬ƻ巨ΪǵԶ
13˵ĵºǵĲԿƵĽۣȨΣյģΪȨĳĳЩ˵Ȩڵ
֪϶оԵģԼȨǣϵ˹˵һ˲Ƶľ飺ȨˣҪȨ
޶Ȳֹ14ôα򾡿ܼȨأˡӡϵ˹˿ΪʹǲȨ
ưţȨǣȨ15ִ˼رǿ˵֪ϵľԶ˼άҪԡ徭ѧ
ҹҮָģӶԸ֪ʶľԵʶԼκθ˻һСȺ˶޷֪ΪĳЩ֪һʵСɵó
һҪʵĽۣҪеǿȨרƸϸơ16Ȼκθʶȫκθ˶ȫӵ
е֪ʶôƶȨˣƶʹҵһʱƶΪȥǣ
ΪҷǳҪҪˡʹȨ˵Ϻ覴ãҲӦ޵ȨȨƵ˼ǰᡣ
            
    ѧʥ֮˵ءԲڣ̼ḻʾ˵Ǽߵľ񾳽磬ɾҪѧϵģ
ѧϵġڽ춫˼ĽͶԻУӦҲԶһݶصľʾͶֵ˼άģʽλ
˼άģʽԼ£ܰȻȻȻʹȫԵĻȾ̬ƽƻѡй
ͳʥ֮ں˺һ˵ľ߾磬˺һ磬˼άģʽ;׷˼Ͷ֡
ģʽ෴ԣԣʥ֮ΪһѧɶԾ˼еĳЩסȫ󲿷˽Լؾ
ھڳԽù򣬲׷˺һľ磬ôȻ֮ĽŶŵǲ¡Ȼ״
ֻǸаĿǰгڹҵ֮У˹˵Ͼ׷󣬸˵׷˺һˡ
ֱȻĿͷ֮󣬲ſȻʡʱңԼң˺һձӣʹ˶ѧ˵ȷ
ԣδĻڹŴ֮Ʒ17
    Ϊѧѧʥ֮ȴʧ϶ࡣ漰Ȩã˼άӦǿѧģð
ѧͬӿѧ˼άĽǶȿӦԸӵзűķо˼ڸ빫֮仮
һޣ£ɸѡ񣬵Թҵȴ¡̷֮Ųڽ̣ʲôڽ̣ȡʲô
ֵۣۡŷʲôѧ˵£һμǣֺṫ档Ӧ˼ѧѧ
ѧѧѧѧѧ뷨ѧ֮Իޡͳѧʥ֮˼ȣвԲ֮ųȴ
֮ȷΪѧѧѧѧ˵һ¯Ӷգȱ΢
˼άδﵽѧˮƽķϵԭ
    ֮˿ΪΪһ־ѧѧǰᣬΪ˼άĻʯʵж˿Դﵽʥ˾磬Ǹ
˵׼Ҳ˵飬ԹŴй˽ʥĳ֣ԸȡѹϵĿѧ˼ά봫ͳй
ѧϣ˼άͽΪ̤ʵءоԣܳҲ⣬κȨȨҪʵзȨ
ȣȨԼȨȽԸ˵йʥָ֮ŬڵľԽΪǿ
ˣҼǽΪʥִ£˳Ȼ紾ԡΪڡġΡ
ʽǻʾŬĻΪĿģ˵ģǼȻ޷ıκҪʣôֻ
Ǹıǵ״ҲǸıṹʹȨúͷܵƶȵƣԷΪ˵

    ֮λ֮¾֮Ҳܱ֤е߾֮λһҪȷһ
ƶȣѡƶȡѭһ˼·ģ˵ѡƶһܰееѡεߵ쵼λѡͨ
ҲֻѡγϺõģѡõġйͳȴ㣬мܴﵽʥ˾ͺ˵壬˾ɥǣ¸е
˼ܾӾ֮λܳΪĵܲһսթŪȨˡʹҶйεָмƭԡ
Ȩʵ϶ͨȷģ˭ǿ˭ʵϵͳߡͳ߶ҳġţʵʩȴ
꺫֮˼νڷȻйҵһȫͬ˼ΪȨΣյģ
վڱͳߵҪͳߵȨƣͳϼӷԷȨַܵʵʲ׼
ξƭԺαԣһ¡й˼ȷվͳν׼ϣҪͳ߶Աͳϼӷͼξð
˵ΣԼΣǿ18ǧϰúˣӦɵեȡǣ
ǷҾͺѹǡԣй˼˼ȫͬʵһΪ
ΪΡġйξⷨβжѭе߸޷ھ֮λԭʥ֮ڱ
ͳ˼˼άҰʹ޷ÿѧķƶϵ˼
    йͳѧִйϵԭҲзϵԭ򡣹ϵĸϰʥ֮רעʥ˸
ȱոʽǻۣ˵ĸԵϣڵľԽļѹĸŬϵĸϰ
ͳй˼άȱȱԾʵȥϵͳ֤۵Ŭȱѧѧ֣ڸÿѧ˼ȱѧķ
ʥ֮ڳԽ̫ɫΪһѧǺ̡ܾоģΪȴΪǷǿѧġǲ
ɲġ
            
    񼪶˵ʲôرõΣΪֹֹõʽǲذֻ񼪶Ŀе
൳ơȨʽжʽΡӦһκθӵ޵Ȩ
ȨκͶͳ
    йαĵ·쳣ۣΪй⽨רǧ꣬γɾ޴ʷԣʥֹ֮ͨι
ϵľ޴ϰйɷ⽨רεĵһ塤˶ǰ󣬳¶ԿѧȨء19
ӵĪDemocracy˹ScienceλΪֻλԾйϵѧ˼һ
еĺڰ20Ȼֻһһϵļµ񵳵ĵµת䣬־εȷй쵼
ʤĻȷйαΰҲ߹·ĸ￪֮ǰھáΡĻ
չˮƽƣڻŷ⽨Ӱ죬ҲĻƶȽԺδܽһʵξƶȺͳĽ
裬ӶӰĳʵ֣Ļʹƻ
    Сƽͬ־1980һξָΪִر˽ƵԺ󣬵
Ѿͬڹȥ彨ΪأȨּУԽԽӦҵķչ21ȨּУ
ƶȺ͵Ƶʵ֡22ָʷ϶ιǿļͳһǿԷɢ壬ֶԣ
ǿҪķȨȨٷԸ˹ּȨ23Ϊⳤû㹻ʶǵĻġһҪ
ԭ򡱡24Сƽͬ־ȫǽٲȫƶȣǾͻ˵ΪʲôʱƶܽһЩ⣬ƶ
ܽأֱȽϷȻȫ棬ǲ˶ӡ˹ƻ巨ƣëͬ־˵¼Ӣ
Ҳܷ25Сƽͬ־ץסĸǽȫ뷨ƣȫ
뷨ƵĹؼƶȻ򻯵ر֤ҪķȨ֤ȺڶȨļල
    ڵСƽͬ־йɫ۵ָ£ҹȡشͻƣýȡþĿĳɾ֮ͣ£
ƸĸȴԵòά裬ԭ൱ӵģϵԭƺ봫ͳʥʥ֮ǧ˿Ƶϵ
    һĻϵͳ쵼ӦȫȫΪ񡢺˽֮ĵͣӦһиҺۼҵƷʣ
Ⱦзḻʵʵʹ͸߳Ĺ־зǷ۶ӦǫãĹηǣ
26ЩƷʵˣ䲻˵Ǵͳѧ˵ʥˣҲǵϵˡ׻ȷ⣬ж
ӦáֵرӣǱʱѵʶǵĵ쵼ӦþЩƷʣζʵÿ쵼ѾЩƷ
δʥ˼άģʽӶѰѡҪķȨᵽճѧǶȳǲϣÿ쵼
ȫȫΪ񡢺ר˵ĸƷʣϣÿ񶼾оܸеĵƷʣ徫ĸ
ҪĿꡣѧǶȳ뷨ƽ費ԡ˿ΪҢ˴Ϊ㣬ӦԶ˵ľԵΪ
㡣㵳쵼ȫȫΪģҲԶȫȫߣԣǵȨƺͼලҲǱҪ
ʹ˶ԣؽոʽǻۡ
    ĸ￪ǽͳ˧һеֲĽгˣȷʵ˵»͸ܼӾ
Ķ˰̾£Ĳšּ˼Ϊʹ״Ψһ취׼֮٣ʵΨһĳ·Ǽᶨ
ƸĸĲӴƸĸȡԽĹʹƣǵĵ˼άеؼ̳ʥ֮еľ
ݣԷḻǵľ磬˼άȴʥ˼ά·ոʽǻۡ
    1תԶά򣬵2ҳйƽ磬1988
    2ѧ
    3612μйѧʷϲᣬл֣1961160ҳ163ҳ149ҳ
    4ۿڡƪ
    5򫡶顷
    7Plato, Euthyphro Apology Crito Phaedo Phaedrus,london,William Heinmann LTD, 1938, P.80.
    8μԪ롶ѧʷ¾ӡݣ1982240ҳ
    91415μϵ˹롶۷ľ񡷣ӡݣ19783ҳ154ҳ154ҳ
    1013David Hume,A Treatise of Human Nature,Oxford, Atthe Clarendon Press,M DCCC XCVI,P.537,P.537.
    11μնص롶뷴Ϻĳ1986
    16Ү˱տ롶뾭򡷱ѧԺ磬198916ҳ
    17ѧŹۡ磬198614ҳ
    18̾顤˵񡷡
    1920Ĵ桷磬19879ҳ242243ҳ
    2122232425Сƽѡһ塪Ű˶꣩1983289ҳ281ҳ289ҳ289ҳ
289ҳ293ҳ
    26μ֡ڡࡶ֤ΨʷΨ塷йѧ磬1982409410ҳ
    ոڣ19950725
    ߵλʦѧϵ
    ְƣ
    ֿδעͣ
    ԭΪͿ¼
    
    
    
