 ׺ 3-3139
ԭĳѧо
ԭ
ԭںš199601
ԭҳš12-19
  šD0
  ѧ
    ΰ
ӡںš199603
    Ϸоѧоӽ
    
    κϷһϵڡȶͷչĻǰᡣηչĽǶȿϵǨĹд󶼲̶ͬȵ
źϷΣ⣬Σܼ𽥼Ӿ磬ͻᵼϵı֮һϵȨ֮Чȡ
άϵϷԣ򽫴ֵȶˣκϷԵںͳоάκϷԵȷ;ͷ
ʽѧһҪ⣬ִȷչĵǰйҲһʵ塣
            ϷԵں
    ȻϷԡ1һʹ㷺Ϊʹã ʹһʱҲ֮ͨѧ˵Ǵż򵥻һĿ
ҼʼǣҾĹ۵淶Ĺ۵̷֮磬ҲϷһķḻں
    ԺϷԽϵͳ綨Ϊ۵ѧ˹ΤΤϷǴʹһЩ˷ĳĶκȺ
ͳĿҪǶͳϵͳĺϷǷţˣҪһʵض£ԺϷԵŴﵽԵ
̶ȣһжͱΪǡġһʵȷӵȨߵĵλ2ζţ ϷԲǼȶ
ϵȶԣ༴ǶȨߵλȷϺͶķӡɼΤǴӾоĽǶȶԼȶʵ϶ʵ
УκγɹġȶͳΣԺʽ֣ȻǺϷģϷͳαûдڵء
    ΤشӾʵĽǶȶԺϷԼԷķԵѧҪӰ졣ڶսԺѧSM
ٴη˶ԺϷԵоɴ˹㷺֣̽д󲿷ѧ߶ԺϷԵĽ綨Τʽġ˵κϵͳ
γɲάһʹԱȷƶȶڸΪʵͳεĺϷԡ3ѧGAɵҲ
ΪĳһеĹԸصȨƶʵʩķ棬һΪؾͻܵʹΪȷӦ
õģôȨǺϷġΪ;ӢﶼȨĺϷʱҪʹط׵ö࣬ʵе
ҰרƵͼùţӦη棬ҵȨ߿ԺϷǿֶʵʩЩ桱4
    ϿɼϷζڶȨͬͷӣȻͳֽͺ˵̵Ŭ޹ϵͬӲͳ
ߵõĽǿвܴɣͳڵ˫򻥶£벻ԾʶD ˹ض
ԺϷӦͬʱ۲죺棬䱾ԾӵͳȨӵеȨʩȡִʩӦ
仯棬ͬȨͳȨ֮ʹϵͳͳεĺϷҪ߱ʱӵС5J˼ж
ΪϵͳͳεĺϷԣ漰ϵͳԱ֪ϵͳԱϵͳģϵͳĽṹƼڼȶķΧ
ȨʹȨ6Ļ˵ ǺϷԡȫȡϵͳļֵԱļֵǷһ¶ˣϷһ
ȡĻȨΪǿԼͳελʶ̬ġɵĺ͵Ϊ֤һ
ΪʵʵǹȨڴڵӮ˹㷺κҳϣӶʹԾذѶķӵԼ
    ԺϷԹ۵㲻ͬJ ˹һֹ淶Եۡ˹ΪڹŴᣬΪ֤ͳεĺϷ
ԶԼΪĻãڴͳУͳڽΪԼĺϷԽ֤Щ߶רƵͳ߼
ȨͺϷԽȨһϷԽͻ֤ȫֻǳͳߵҪֵһֹߣӮôڵҳϡʹڶȨ
ҳϺҲζžһںϷԣΪ޷ڶԹȨҳʢһʱķ˹ңĺϷ
Իʲôˣ˹ϺϷϵͳΪͳ֤֤ҲϰѺϷԵΪڶڹȨҳϺ
ڹ˹ϷΪһֹƶȻܾеԣֻһġĻУڹƶϵͳ֮
⣬ĻõȫķչҵĺϷĻܹõԾ֤ӶϵͳӮ˴ڵĹ㷺ֺ֧ҳϡ
κҳ֮ܲҲȫΪϷԽйۡˣ˹϶ϷԢڶȷ
빫жϴŽ֮УϷζһֵϿɵ򡣡7Ȼ ġֵϿɡڱϿɣؼ
ⲻڡǲǡڡӦòӦáɼ˹ǰѺϷԹڵľͬϣǿϵͳϷ
Եļֵжϡ
    ˹ĺϷּڶԵʵУ̵˼ںΪһҪԵᣬ
ձ޵ġһϷԱ׼ʷ⣬ϵкϷԣʹЩϵڵʱ
ĺͱҳϵġֵּϵľȱʷĺͶԪĻҰԺϷԼֵǿ壬
ΪһĺϷԵķеѧȫŷʽļֵ淶ΪϷԵΨһ׼͸ΪѵˡηչĽǶȿ
ϷԵҪǱһӦִϵͳĺϷԱһ̬Ḷ́һ̶ļֵ淶
ԺֻܴӦ̵ִȼԷ˵κϷԸӦӾʵĲԷǲͬĻ
ԡˣκϷҪָȨõĹ㷺ͬҳϺͷӣͨضʱʵľ߼ʵʩ
Ӧ仯ϵͳЧԺȶԡ
    ôϷԵĻʲôأ˵ϵͳĺϷԴӺζϣ˹ΤӰ졣Τ
ӾֺϷԵĻ81ͳĻͳκϷԽڶϰߺ͹ϴͳʥַԵҪ֮ϣ
ͳ߿ƾϮλ˷ӵȨ2˹ͳεĺϷԽĳӢʡǷƷʺͳ
ʥ֮ϣＴ˹䣬䳬ǵ׷ͷӣ3ĻͳκϷԽڶʽƶĹͷ
ΪҪ֮ϣǷշռĳְλʹȨͳߣͨѡְԱΤǿֺϷͳεĻ
ڴͣǴûʷԴֹ̬оʵеͳʽִ͵Ļϣͬ
صıغϷʽв죬ĳʵͳκϷԿԷǳӽĳһ͡ȻΤκϷԿܵĶֻ

    ѧҴά˹ٶԺϷԵĻ˽һ֣̽ѺϷԵԴʶ̬ṹ͸Ʒ档9 ʶ
̬ΪϵͳĺϷṩϵڹͣϵͳԱȨƵĺϷУṹΪϷԵԴȪζͨһ
ƶȺ͹淶ϵͳȨ߼ɻͳεĺϷԣ༴ϷνṹִܸߺϷĵλϷԵĸ˻ִָ
߸ӮϵͳгԱκָͬ˺ϷҪڿ˹ķ룬Ϊеִ߶г
ֳͨһٵҲܹݴ׷ߣĻƭģֳȷ˺Ϸвһ
Ҫء10ֺϷԴȪ໥Ӱ졢໥ãͬΪϵͳ춨ϷԵĻͬΤһ˹ҲǾվڼֵ
ϷԴ۵ģȻȫļֵǲܵģ˹ٵ۲Τķ࣬ͬʱҲʺڵ
ڷʵϷԵĻһʾá
            ϷΣһΪձηչ
    ΪϷ۵Ŀߣ˹ΤϷԵĸͳʱغ˵ͳߵٱϵ
Ϊ˷ӵʱ򽫻ֵΡΤϵУͳεĺϷԵĻƺǲģû֡Ϸͳεķ룬
ʶھǿܵġ11ѧرηչ۸Ϊעͳδнκҳϵ״
ǺϷѻõɥʧΣǡϷΣĸǹ淶ۻǾۣȻҰͷ
ͬϵͳġϷΣеĹע
    ͹淶۶ԣ˹ġϷΣѧ˵дԡ˹ΪϷΣִеģǿһ
ڹŴзֺϷԳͻĴڡ 12ڹȥѺϷͬͳεͳ߱ӵкϷ
ȨҿӵкϷԲʹܣŹһĲǿɥʧ㷺Ⱥڻȱ
ϷʹҵԨ޷԰Ρ񷴿һ£ЩͳΪϷǡǡΪǷģ
ȨĳͻʵǺϷԳͻ˹ΪֺϷΣĸԴʱĵŵԸı䡣ʱг
һֶڹ˽򣬹ַͨչȷĺϷԵĻңеĹĻ
ǰ¡ԾΪṩĺϷ֤
    Ȼ˹ָʱķչرǹҸԤһ棬ϵͳ;ϵͳнڣΣֱ
ʽڲǰѿ˷ϣھϵͳǼϣһҲ޵°ʱ徭ù̹ʧ
ЧӦάѡԽܵķΧڣôϷԵĳ־Ͳɱ⡣13һ棬ҲǸΪҪģȨ͸
Ļ֮УͬʱĻҲϵҵˡĻƶ˵ľ컯£Щǰϵ
ͳ߽ñϵĻ滮򡱣ˡ˺ϷҪ󲻳ɱһЧ14ǣ˹
ѡϷΣʱҪΣԷбڿ˼ڶʱġΣ˹Τʱƶ
ṹġΣķ15ֻǣʵֺϷΣδҵ
    ˵˹Ǵеļֵ϶ԵʱҵĺϷΣϵĻôڵ෢չ
˵ϷΣͲһϵ⣬ǾʵЩңҡ塢սŷβȶ
;õķչ³ڶԷչйβȶзʱġΣ˵һΣϷΣϷΣ
ͬΣΣ᳹ΣΣΣΪġ16չй֮ԽձźϷΣ
ЩҴӴͳִתֲġִһұ䶯Ḷ́״Ϸ⣬SP͢
˵ἰִƻӰʽ;õı仯Ȼʹͳμ߽⣬ԴͳȨ
ҳϡ17ӸΪҰ۲쵽ϷΣǱת۵㡣ˣִȥѰĸԴ
Σṹɵʱڣ1ṹʱҪƶȵĵλܵв2ʱҪȺûв
ϵͳĻᣬҪ֮ṹƶ㹻ʱڲҪȺԱ»
ϷԣͻµΣ18չйִźϷΣ⣬ʷִķչҲ
β롢Ļȷ˲ϼӾĳͻҲǺϷΣĳֱ֡
    ɴ˿ɼϷΣǵٵһձ⣬ңǴ̵ִķչйңѺϷ
Σţͨѧߵѷ֣ĺϷΣɻΪΣһεĺϷΣֳΪ㷺γͻ
ͲȶֱΣȨĴڣڶεĺϷΣǱִ֮Уھϲڹ㷺γͻβȶ
ڶϵͳҲϺͷӣͨ۵ķԶϤϷΣĴڣΣȨǱڿԡѵڶε
ϷΣΪǱڵĺϷΣ˹ͨ淶ʾĵʱƶȵĺϷΣࣻһεĺϷ
ΣǡʵڵĺϷΣ³ͺ͢ٵѧо⡣ηչĽǶȿʵڵĺϷΣ
ǸΪҪ⣬ֱӹϵϵͳİΣһҵִ̺ȻҲǾͲ
ʵڵΣΣǷչйҵһ󡣷չйִУϷԵĴͳ⵽ƻĻµĽ
Դ޴ӽҲȱԱǿʶ̬Ϸϵ쵼˸ϣһ쵼˵ĸȨܵսϷΣ㲻
ɱ⣬ֱвϵͳִ
    ʵڵĺϷΣķԴӲͬĲչȻͳؽϷζŹϵͳ֧֣D ˹ٵĿ
ܣֵ֧ľɷΪιͬ塢ƺ͵档ιͬǽͬһιеɵȺ壬ηչ
ʾιֳ֧ͬΪҵͬʶ⣻ָϵͳжλһϵԼɼֵ淶Ȩṹ
ֹɣּȨɫĳеߣҲǾȨߡ19ԺϷΣ⣬ɴ͸ӡ
    ෢չйιͬϾȱٺϷԣͬʶʶĮرһЩ˹ңԱͳͬǼ塢
䡢硢ԡԼţִϵĹȱͬУеϵԭеĹͬıǨ½ɥʧ
ڶԴͳʽʶľͬ£Ҳܲڶµʽʶľͬ£Ҳܲڶµ
ʽʶǿҵλɸСιͼֵĿȵȶ谭γͬأ°³˵ġͬΣ
һιͬĺϷԳ⣬󰢶ɵ˵֮ľǷ˶ʹѾõĹ⣬ر
Щ漰ԺĻͬһĳ֣ιͬѽ˵ı߽Ҳٴα20Ӣոʿ壬
ô˵ķĽͬΣһҪԽǷǳѵġЩѾйͬʶĹң
ҪǲҪЩͬΣسֻЩص̳
    ЩιͬʶĹңڿܰѶϵͳ֧תһ˹䡣ͬ˹һöʱ˶
˻õ֧ǶƵ֧֡Щ˵ؼΰѺϷԴȨ߸תƺ͹ͬ
ЩʷƾõĹңͬʶǿⲢζƺ͵־ͬĺϷԣ編ʶһֱǿңڵ
͹ǰǶƺ͵ֵ֧ȴһֱͬһϵͳĹĳһȨ߻߷Уȴͬеơ
оضϵͳĺϷΣʱҪע⵽ιͬ塢ƺ͵໥ϵӰķ棬ҲҪԶķ
һ˵ֲĺϷΣ׽ǳĺϷΣƲĺϷΣͬ
ҪҪϷΣǳӦһΣɵֿʼ뵽꼰ͬ壬ζϵͳıڵ
رǴ̵ִĹңⲻһΣ񻰣ǾԿϿʵ
            ϷԲάֵ;
    ĺϷΣᵼιͬķֱصβȶǳĺϷΣȻػңҲӰ
ϵʵΪ෴ǿĺϷԻʩɵϷԶϵҪʱ˵
ȷȨĺϷԣɾܱȽ׵غЧʵʩΪʵʩķҲ١ңĳֺϷԵĻ
ĻȨѵĴ֮Ҳʱ;⡣21ˣƲάͳεıĿĲ̸ھú
ᷢչĽǶ˵ֺͼǿκϷҲҪǰ֮һ
    άϵĺϷԣϲͼǿֺϷԣһֵо⡣ΪֻҪܹʵҪ
ܹάĺϷԣʵⲢô򵥡ΪϷԵԴʶ̬ͳṹ͸Ʒ棬һ
ŬǲġרŶϵЧϷԼ֣νЧָʵʵϵڴ
ܵĳ̶ȣкϷ̺ԺϷЧԽط˺ϷЧͬʱںͬ
ʱȱʧ⣬һЧԸߵϷԵͻЧԵ͵ϷԸߵ˵ЧԲһϷԣϷҲȻ
ҪЧԣӶ۹ЧʺܸߵȱϷԵᣬõֳأҪЧԵ͵ϷԸߵȨȶ22
ȻһϵڱЧԣرǲϵľ÷չԻúϷԡ˹ж¶ϵĺϷЧ
Ĺϵ˸ΪϸµĿ죬ָϵĳԱͬϵͳεĺϷԣͿֲڵĲ߼Чͬʱϵȡ
㣵ΪʾϿɣͬϵܳԱҪ棬ҲӮͳεĺϷԣ󣬼ʹһͳϵȫӵ
ͳεĺϷԣ䳤ֵûӹܣʴͳεĺϷԡ23ɼϵĺϷЧԻ߼Ч֮
ֳ໥Ӱִ۸ӵĹϵ
    ϣ˹ٶ辶ֶϵֵ֧ĲͬʵĽǶ˽һϷζŹڶϵ֧֣˹
Ϊֿ֧ɴӡض֧֡͡ɢ֧֡͸ӡض֧ϵߣϵԱĳЩ
γɣض߼Чܻߵ֧֣ɢ֧ͬضֵ֧ĹԣھǶϵġ
Уһ֧⽫ʹڳϻЩ㣵Ϸ֮ʶ̬ġṹĺ͸˵ԴҪ
ɢ֧أ˹ٿϵĺϷԸҪɢֶ֧ض֧֣òҪָ
ضĺͿɼĻرֵ֧ĻôûκһܹͬձͬҲûκһ鵱԰Ȩ
24ѿϵЧԻμЧӮֵ֧ĻҲֻһض֧֣֧ǲõģ˺ϷԲܽ
ض֧֮ϡ
    ȻⲢζϵض֧֣ϵԱҪضֶ֧κϷҲҪġһ
ʼղҪпɿĺϷԣC˵ڵۻ ȨʩõĺϷ
ΧԼҳķȣȡܷҪ25ֻǣضֵ֧ĹԽǿһ߼Чѣ
ϵͻɥʧ֧֣ǡǡκʼһرõļЧⲻΪʩʧ󣬶ھ
ı仯Ҳʹ߼Чʱʹʼܱһ߼ЧȺҲĳ̶ֳȵĲȣʹԱ㡣
һϵעɢ֧֣Բ߼Чʱض֧⡣
    ɢ֧ض֧ศɵģض֧ЧΪɢ֧Ҫữãγһַض
ʶ̬ĻRMĪ׶ΪͳεĹУӦѧϰʲô벻ģӦ
ѵõԵĹŻḳϵͳԺϷԣҪͨڵѧϰɡ26˹
ͨữĹ̲Ӯɢֱֲ֧֣ʱꡢǿӵ֧֣ͨ
ӦһŬڳԱйƼְߵһι̵ĺϷУڶͬͼǿԱ
ι̶ͬͬȡ27֮ϷԵĲάͨ߼Чữ;ڻϵض
ɢԵ֧֡ںϷԸػڵữֶξԵøΪҪˡ
    ֵһǣĻ㷺ںʹʹͨữɢ֧Żļֵȡ⡣Ȼÿһ
ϵضʷĻҲȫرɵһЩֵʶ³˵ͳεĺϷһΪϵͳһ
ԣرṹļЧйأȡϵͳҪأһ棬ͳεĺϷΪ裬Ȩƽȵԭ򣬲
ɫ塢֮ͬвͬĴʱȡĳϡܺͬ28ˣܰɢ֧ΪȨġ
ҡữͬڸߡһϣ˹Ĺ淶ɾĳʵ塣RҲΪÿһͬ
ĻԼһ׽綨ϷԵķ׼һŶۣΪڵı£һõĺϷӦ߱
ϵһȷһµͳӵһ׹㷺ļֵʶżȶɹͬļֵʶ29
Щѧ߶ԺϷԵձֵľʶǷȷһԿ϶ǣڵξһ廯ʱһϵҪ뽨ά
־õκϷԣϵӦ˳Ӧʷչĳ
    ѧоеĺϷȻԴҸѧ˵硣вƫ󣬵Ϊ˼һ֣ڷ
оʵġ
    עͣ
    1ϷԡӢLegitimacy壬 Ӧ˵ĴʻĿǰҳһlegitimacyĶӦʣʶԡȡ
һɲáϷԡ뷨Ҫѵǣ˴ϷϺɡ⣻˵ô뷨ɱޱȻϵ̽
⡣
    2M.Weber,Economy and Society,ed.Guenther Roth  and  C.Wittich,Berkeley:University of California Press,1968,p.214.
    3S.M.Lipset,"Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy",American  PoliticalS
cience Review,V.53(March 1959),P.86.
    4GAɵµȣȽѧϵ̺ߡϺĳ磬1987꣬3536ҳ
    5D.Sternberger,"Legitimacy",International  Encyclopediaof the Social Science,V.9,N.Y.:Macmillan Co.The Free  Press,P.
244.
    6J.Rothschild,"Political Legitimacy  in  ContemporaryEurope",in B.Benitch (ed.) Legitimation  of  Regimes, BeverlyHil
ls:Sage Publications Inc,1979,P.38.
    7Jurgen Harbermas,Communication and the Evolution ofSociety, Boston:Beacon Press,1979,P.178.
    8From Max Weber:Essays in Sociology,trans,and ed.,H. H.Gerth & C.Wright Mills,New York:Oxford University,pp.7879,p.
245.
    9D˹٣ϵͳĳ磬1989꣬317318ҳ
    10ͬϣ334335ҳ
    11ˡ𣺡˹ΤĴ磬 1987꣬114ҳ
    12J.Harbermas,op.cit.,P.181.
    13Ibid.,P.197.
    14J.Harbermas,Legitimation Crisis,Heinemann,1976,P. 71.
    15ԣʱҵĺϷԡءйѧۣ19938£34ҳ
    16L.Pye, Aspects  of  Political  Development, Boston Little Brown&Company,1966,P.6367.
    17Ѷ͢٣䶯򡷣Ϻĳ磬1989꣬40ҳ
    18ˡӡݣ1993꣬5354ҳ
    19˹٣ǰ飬ʮһʮ¡ƣregimeԭ롰򡱡
    20ɵµȣǰ飬39ҳ
    21ͬ飬36ҳ
    22ˡ5657ҳ
    23J.Rothschild,op.cit.,pp.3839.
    24˹٣ǰ飬298ҳ
    25C.Bay,"Needs,Wants and Political Legitimacy",Canadian Journal of Political Science, V.1 No.3(sept,1968),P.241.
    26R.M.Merelman,"Learning and Legitimacy",American Political Science Review, V.60.(Sept,1966),P.552.
    27˹٣ǰ飬306ҳ
    28L.Pye,"The Legitimacy Crisis",in L.Binder etal.(eds),Crisis and Sequences in Political Development, Princeton:Princ
eton University Press,1971,P.135.
    29 R. Lowenthal, "Political  Legitimacy  and  Cultural Change in West and East",Social Reseach,V.46 No.3(1979),P.402.
                                      α༭ǿ
    
    
    
 
