 ׺ 2-759
ԭĳѧս
ԭ
ԭںš199805
ԭҳš102110
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš199901
    ѧ䣺¸嵽¼
    ƽ
߼顿ߵλйֵо
    
    ˡŮ˺ͺȺĳԱͥԡڽԡԡְҵŵĳԱ屾
ҲһȺ뿪໥ͽĸȺĴڻǸ˵ɶάֺܾáԱΪ˹ͬĿ
ܡȤԴȺܳ־áԵ׷ȻԴڵỷƻǹͬʵ顣
ΪЩԭΪûһȺۣ˵ȨͲܳõԱ档Ⱥȳϸ˵ϣֳڵԡ
עȺ٣ȨΡThe Responsive,Communitarian Platform Rights and Responsibilities,Ⱥ
־Responsive Community1991궬š
    λһѧһԡǩԵ50ѧߺμңݳ14ҳԵʽǡ
Ⱥ٣ȨΡ1991궬ŵġȺ־־90רȺĹ۵㣬
ȺիĲԵĺ˼ǣִռͳελĸ壬
Ⱥ塣еóǣȺĹ۵㴦һʱش⡢ͷ⡱
עȺ٣ȨΡThe Responsive,Communitarian Platform Rights and Responsibilities,Ⱥ
־Responsive Community1991궬š
    һٵۻǱĽҪĵѧ·չȺ塣עȺӢΪCommunitarianismĴʸ
communityԴϣ koinoniaCommunity ͨΪͬ塱ҲCommunitarianismΪ塱
ͬ塱ΪCommunitarianismCommunism 壩ĴʸcommunitycommuneƵĺ壬żҲ˰ѴΪ
塱˰Ϊ塱塱ȡΪЩ뷨Ƿ׵ΪʵӦǡȺ塱Ⱥ
Լ޶˹John RawlsΪĹзչģγ˵ѧŵľ档
˿µĸ崫ͳֳΪ¿¸塣ȺӺڸȡӪֱΪ¼塣
            һ
    1971ѧԼ޶˹ˡۡһķѧѧѧ˹㷺ԶӰ졣ѧ
ΪսѧҪףѧھΪٶ˵Ҫ־֮һ޶˹˵ʱռͳ
ελĹ崫ͳԼۺͿµѧ
    ޶˹ڡۡԭһΪƽԭthe principle of justice  as  fairness ǲԭthed
ifference principle  ǰǿ ÿڡԭ״̬theoriginal positionжǡɶƽȵĵˡ Ƕӵ
޶ȵĻɣֻҪеͬȵĻɲͻڡ֪֮Ļveil of ignorance£ ѡһ
Թ淶ԭ򡣺ǿǣֻлٵǲֳԱ뾭õĲƽȡ֮
Ĳƽȷʵɱ⣬ôЩҪġòʵʩĲƽӦ1 Щƽ
ߵ棻2ڻṫƽ£ ְֵ͵λӦɿš
    ޶˹ԭĺ˼ǣֵ棬ɺͻᡢͲƸԼб֤͸ԷչĿ͹
ƽȵط䣬ǶֻЩֵĲƽÿһ˵档ɴ˿ɼ޶˹Ҫ漰ķ䣬һ
ڷ壨A Justice of Distribution or  DistributiveJusticeڹڼֵԭУ һԭڵڶԭ

    ޶˹ӡԭ״̬֪֮͡ĻݳΪ乫ԭ򡣡ԭ״̬޶˹һּٶ״̬һִ״
̬ȫɵĸһ״̬нзѡ໥ԭʼԼڶЩԼʱ֪֮ܵĻԼҲ
˵ڡԭ״̬еǣȻ֪ǵȻ츳λ֪ǵƶ֪ᱳ޶˹
ԭ״̬һּ߼״̬ԣɴ徭ָΪζѧ塱Դˣ޶˹1985רдһƪ
Ա⡣޶˹ΪȻǴӼٶġԭ״̬ݳģζѧһ֡ε
Ҳ˵Ϊƽ壬ֻһѧ˼磬һεơִƶȵĻṹ
ṹУҪᡢκ;ƶһĺơʵϣȵġۡУѾԷΪʵ
ʵԭ˳ԵĽ͡ע޶˹Ϊƽ壺εĶζѧġJustice   as   Fairmess:Political N
ot Metaphysicalѧ빫񡷣1985ļš˵ӡԭ״̬ԭʵƶȣҪĸ׶
һ׶Ǵڡ֪֮Ļµĸڡԭ״̬ѡԭ򣻵ڶ׶Ǹԭƶܷ׶Ǹܷƶ־
ķɣĽ׶αʵʵӦԭ޶˹ΪԭʵеչӦụ̀ͬʱҲ
֪֮ĻĹ̡
    ѧĽǶȿ޶˹ΪĺĹ۵ǣ塢ƽ͸Ȩȵĵλһ᲻
ŬٽκضĿģڲ˵ͻʹ乫׷ԼĿġ֮Ϊʹһ
ṫĶҪﵽĿģǡǡԤڸֶĿ֮ѡȡȨܷͷУŬṩ
һֿܣֿ׷ԼļֵĿ꣬˵ͻ
    ޶˹ġۡһѧĸ̡ۡһڸȨ֮ϵ¿ѧ޲
ءŵ˵ġҺаɵ¡ֽġԴȨȵȡ
    ЩھĹ۵ϲͬһȫһµģǿȨѹһеԣѸȨǹΪ
ĳ㡣ԣ˰޶˹ΪȨۡthe primacy-of-right theory Ȩۡ
rights-based theory ޶˹͵ֽ𳫵ŵԵĸȨǶǿȨΪȨڸ˵ĵ¼ֵ˵ıܡ
ֽΪģξ߱κŵ˺͹Ү˷޶˹ֵ֧ٷߣǶ
ܾյ¼ֵ˼롣޶˹Ȩڵ֮ϾͻὫȨ֮ǰŵ˵Ȩ¼ֵͻ
ѡɡ
    ЩȨѧڹʲôȨǸԵģʲôΰҪĵϵĹ۵Ҳ
һ¡һЩָ֧ңֽ֧һᾭȨϵ縣ȨȨȨȣЩ˳Ϊƽ
ߡһЩгãΪٷַǵȨֽ֧ϸ˽вƲȨϵ
Щ˳Ϊߡƽ壬Ȩȶţ໥ĸˣÿ˶
ԵĿġͶƵĸ֪ѰһȨܣʹʵԼΪɵĵ˵ֻҪ˵ͬɡ
    70޶˹Ϊ¿ѧһֱռ޿ɶҡλȴ⵽Ͼս
ºڸԿµĹУȺִ˼ҵȨƵţԼ⺬ѡĸ˲
̵ĻɡΪǲ漰ĿģǾ޷֤ƶȵĺû漰Ϊ͹ߵĽɫǾ
ʲôĸˡ80Ⱥӷۺ͹淶巢ȫķΪΨһ޶˹Ϊ
࿹ѧɡ
            
    Ⱥ嶼ӸȺĹϵϵȺҪˡɣ¶ָ޶˹ԭ״̬
õģ֪ǽΪ֮ǰ֪ԼĿƵĸ֮ǰʹǽҪѡͳ
ԭЩԭԭ趨һ˵ͼ趨Ǳõķʽͼһ֪ҡ
ڲҶĿġ֪ʲôӵʲôҪʲôķʽζӵеļֵһʲ
ô֮ʼմŲ𡣶ضҵĿġͼȵͬʼζĳ塰ҡǵıһ֮⣬ҡ
ʽضκӵеĿ̬ȡһĺ֮һǽұ侭֮⡣֮ǳΪĿĵĿ
ԡ֪ңԵ壬ѡĿģѡĿĵ
    ɣ¶ָ޶˹۵ߵ˸ȺĹϵκθ˶Ⱥ˵ͬڵǸȺ
ˣĲ˵޶˹˼ٶֵĿģɣ¶ΪҲֵĿģЩ
ֵĿľҡЩֵĿĲγɵģʷĻγɵġκ˶ɵѡЩֵĿģ
ڸ˵ЩֵĿǹԵģ涨֮Ϊˡԣɣ¶˵˲ԷѡңֻܷҡȺ
˭ѡˡ˭˭Ǳ뿼˵ĿĺͼֵҪ˵Ŀĺͼֱֵ뿼
ȺʷĻעˡɣ¶ľޡ棺Ŵѧ磬1982棬150155ҳȡ
    ȺһҪ˹̫̫ƵĹ۵㡣̫Ϊǵĵ¼ֵʷģֻ
ȺʷͳĻܽ͸ӵеļֵĿġ޶˹ȴѸȺ뿪Ѹ˴˼
ĻỷгĸˡȺϵٵġ̫Ļ˵ֻͨĳֳĳ
narrativeеΪ ˵ͬʱģ˵һɲ֡ˣ
ֻȺĹϵвˣȺ涨Щʽͱ̫ΪЩȺʽڼͥ䡢
ǹҡͽ׼չʾһϵлҵļֵȱһµļֵۡ˵ִӵκιͬĵ
һȺ˵Ǳزٵĺʵģע̫׷Ѱ¡ӡڰǣʥǴѧ磬1973棬115ҳ

    ȺҪ֮һ˹̩հ17лԼ֮ϵʹӸĹ嶼֮Ϊԭ塱
atomism޶˹ŵ˵˵塣Ϊ ԭҪǼ˵ĸ壬ǿ˼Ȩ
ԣֻʵָĿĵĹߡָ̩Ϊһ壬ֻȺвܷչ̩յĽͣȺ
һֹͬĻĻǵǰ߼̩յó˵ڸȺĹ۵㲻԰
ˡע˹̩գѧĿѧļ  Philosophy and the Human Sciences:Philosophical Papers棺Ŵ
ѧ磬1985棬187210ҳ
    ȺǿȺҺ͸˵ԣȺ˸һѹһеҪԡ߼˵
ҪشȺĹϵȱ綨Ⱥĸ֮κȺڶ϶ȺڸʱͬʱشʲôȺ
ԼȺкԵ⡣
    һ˵Ⱥ߰Ⱥһӵĳֹͬļֵ淶Ŀʵ壬ÿԱѹͬĿ굱ԼĿꡣ
ȺУȺָһȺˣһ壬˶ĳԱӵһֳԱʸ񡣵ǣڶȺľ綨
Ⱥ֮䲢ȫһ¡
    ɣ¶رǿȺߵҵĹʡ˵νȺЩй֪ͬĲɵģͨƶʽ
ԾֵĳְţҪǲӵһֹͬͬͥ׼ȡȻֲͬʵȺ
ϵȺϵȺ͹ϵȺǿĹϵȺ򹹳ԵȺνԵȺָ
Ⱥһ̶Ϲɸ˵ͬνϵȺ˵ĿĲܶʵ֣
׷ͬвʵ֡Щ˹ͬ׷ҲΪҲɷָġұĻҪءһ
ɵȺͬʱҲΪҵĻҪءעˡɣ¶ľޡ Philosophy  and   the   Human Scienc
es:Philosophical Papers  棺Ŵѧ磬1985棬150ҳȡ
    ˡǿȺߵĳԱʸָȺĲԼ໥ֹͽ档ȺУ
໥ǳԱʸǹڳԱʸһйǵѡѡ˭Ҫ˭ķӡ˭
˰˭ʲôطûгԱʸŮһЩ޿ˡ仰˵κθ˵ȨǷյģûַ
յȨ͸ȺΪֻΪԱŮпϣе桪ȫԣְλȨЩʹ
ȺΪܣעˡɣķΧͼ鹫˾Basic Books,lnc.1983棬55ҳȡ
    Ⱥ۶ǵĴάرעȺԱȺӵйͬĸ
ģֹͬÿ˶˵ÿȺԱȺȺÿԱЧڵ
ȺԸ˵ĿٽȺ档ȺϵԣȺʽ͹ҡԣȺ롰ʸ
Ƿֲġ˵ȺǰǣԱԼǰԼ־Ļ塣ԣΪҪȺ빫
ʸศɵġûһֹͬͬͲܰѹۼһҲûʹЩͬĹ䵱ͬĽɫûйʸ
ͲʵԼǰ;Ļ룻ͻһΣգͳʽȺеһлԹͬ
ͬӶʹпȥһıʵ硣ʸԸıʵֶΡ϶ΪȺߵĻĹʸ񣬲
һռȨҲһΪֻӵйʸȺԱܸоԼھǰ;Ҫãż
ߵΣΪȺһԱͶڹͬ档עάգгȺţѧ磬1992棬23850ҳ

    ѷ֣Ⱥ綨Ⱥкܴİԣ֮ĸ顢ιȹϵеѧ߰ʵȺ
֮ΪȫȺΪĸ1 ʽΪ˷ϵģ2 ȺĲߵĹϵ
һĹϵ3ȺԱ˴˵ 빲4ȺԱͬĺģȺĹϵϰס 淶ʹͳ
ԳԱžԵ壨עܿˡصǣJack  CrittendenԽ壺ؽɵҡBeyond  lndividualism Rec
onstituting the Liberal Selfţѧ磬1992 棬132133ҳʵϣȺĿеȺʿ
˵ģΪ˴ﵽߵƶɵϵȺһϣȺߵǶԵģȺʵ
ûаȺȺֿ˵ȺԱͬҲٴһκ塣
    Ⱥ˶ȺΧĽ綨⣬ҪڶȺʵĿϡڴ߿Ⱥ
˵ȲǱģҲƵģֻǹԵġ෴Ⱥ˵ȺǱҪģƵġ
    ȺΪȺ˵ǿп޵ģǱزٵġǴ֤ȺıҪԡȣκθ˱
һȺ֮УɵѡȺ˵һʷĻϵУκҲѲ
ʷĻͳԼΣȺڸ˵һҪ绪˵ῴһԼǺģֻеǵҪõ
ʱԼ壬еҪ֮һȺ磬ĹͬǸ˵һҪֻȺ˹ͬ
ҪȺǸ˵ҵĹҪءʵеκθ˶ӵһĿġ롢ֵЩҵĶǡǡȺ
ˣȺ˸˶ҵͬ綨˭
    ȺУȺһƣֻͨȺ壬мֵȺ˵Ⱥ£簮
סŽᡢʵֱݡŵ£ͨȺγɵġ˵߽
ĸȨƽȣҲֻȺвʵ֣˵Ⱥ֮ҪȺ֮ʵ֡ɴ˵ó˵
ΪһƵȺĻ֮һûȺ϶һõᡣ磬ٶһᣬ
ÿһ˶޶ȵӵȨɵжûѵŦμš̻ᡢ͸ֹ
塣Щ˵ʮʿһᣬ϶õᡣ
    Ⱥ¶ˡҡȺ໥ϵҪĿĺʵ岻ڷۣڽصĹ淶ۣȺ
μֵۺȨۡ
            
    ΪĿġҵͬӵеĿ޹ϵʱҲܰԼɵġĺ
ѡġֻ֮ҪĿģҲֻеĿʱȨơ෴ȺΪҲ
ĿĺͼֵĿĺͼֵҲ涨ҡˣͲƣ塣ԭԹ淶ƽѡȨ
ģȨķ롣ԣ壬ҲȨȺߴȺҺ͸һóĵһ
Ҫۡ
    ɣ¶һ߼£ѧ϶ȨԣѰЩԤ趨κضƵĸԭ
ǿµĵϣҲ޶˹˵ƶҪµ˼ֵṩһܣ涨໥ļֵĿġ
ˣӵһֶЩĿĵۣһ᲻ŬٽκضĿģʹ乫׷
Ŀģ˵ͻضЩԤȹ涨κƵĹԼ֤ЩĶȲʹһ
󻯣ٽƣ֤ʵȨĸһƲƵĸߵ˼ά߼Ȩ
ƣһȨζŲձƶȨڶ綨ЩȨԭܽκض֮ϡ
    ɣ¶ָȨƵŴӸ˵ǴġȷĹ۵ӦǣȨԼ綨Ȩԭ򶼱뽨ձ֮
ȨԭΪ1 νȨ֮ζǵĿģ     ǶƵĸ֪ourcon
ception of the goodӦоԵԡ2 ǶƵĸ֪ζǵͬƶȷ
ǶƵĸ֪Ƕĸ֪3 ǵͬǶƵĸ֪ɵģ岻ܾԡݴˣǱ㲻
Ȩѧעɣ¶򹲺֪ҡThe Procedural Republic and the Unencumbered Self 
־Political Theory198412ڵ8196ҳ
    Ⱥ˵ձƣuniversal goodʵеﻯʽǹ棬ƹ档ǣȨȺ
ڶҪۣڸȨһкĽۣȺԼڵѧ
ѴΪȺķֽߣѧ֮ΪȨѧȺѧѧɣ
ԼҲ˵ߵһϵдζѧĳĹ۵֮ϣû»ԭ򣬼Ϊձ
ȨΪԭǾԵĺձģ໥֮䲢˽ԷγɹͬĿꣻǿ
Ŀ֮涨ԼĿꡣЩ۾ݱȻǴģɣ¶ӦȨѧѧ
עɣ¶ɵ롱Morality  and  theLiberal ldeal¹͹־The New Republic 198457գ
1617ҳ
    ȺŬȨѧת򡰹ѧмΪḻ塣ȣķΧ
ᳫķΧȺߵ⣬һȺйΪεģṩĹķΧԽ󣬻
ͬһ˻ҲԽ࣬ԽҪ󡣷֮һȺṩĹ٣߹ȣ
ʹҲһᡣ߹ܵ¼ȨָȺ߻ش˵Ȩ
ĸԴڴˣǡǡڶơ
    ΣȺ߳˻ĹչβҪݡһΪֻͨβ룬
Ȩܵõֵʵ֡ǴʵϰȨ綨Ϊ˲ξߵȨѸ˹㷺β뵱εĻ
ɺնǿָĸȨǱģǸ˵ĳԱʸ͹ʸûлβ룬ֳԱʸʸ
ʵ֣Ӷ˵ȨҲͲܳʵ֡Ϊ˻βǷֹרƼȨĸ;һҲ
߽Ȼ෴ΪǷǸ˵ѡ񣬻ԱβĽǶԸɵơȺΪ
ʹ빫ۺ͹Ϊרƶô˻ûй㷺β룬̸Ρ
    Ⱥ߳󹫹ΧһҪǣǴ󵨵ŰڸȺӦڱʹٽĹ
ΪΪȺձԲϧ˵档ԽֹɫΪȺΪɫ˷绯кά
ȺüֵԱ߸Žֹɫꡣߵ߻Ⱥ׼¿̵ȺӡԴˣ
ǵĻشǣǡǡطЩʽȷȹ̺ʹͳδγɵĵطˣǶشٻָЩڴͳе
ʱʧĹĹעİסȺѧ빫־1985ļţ3
20322ҳ
    ҵʵУӰҪȺӰö࣬ҪƶȺβʵǰԭ
ƵġȺ߷ǳѵؿһ㣬ǳġ¸塱תȺġ¼塱ʱҲӦغ
ʵδӡȨΡת򡰹Ρݴ˶ʵ
    ̫˵ִкͷ񶨲ͬΪǱҪġΪִǲϷģΪִ
ƶбǶԴͳȫ濹ܡִĵȺǴһϵȱĵ¹ʶĹŻ壬
ʴӸģġͳִгĺ塢̰Ͱгֵ
ĵλ״һ¡ִƣġģǼġģǻڴͳ֮ϣ
Ӵͳı׼ǶǲֵȰģȻȥҲһ¡Ϊ밮ȫ
£ֲκ͵ȺβֲȺʵı仯ȱ¹ʶӶȺ
ϵΣʱͺӵһĺ͸нİʱҳϺȺҳϱͳη뿪
ע̫׷Ѱ¡ӡڰǣʥǴѧ磬1973棬244255ҳȡ
    ΪֹǼҪؿΪֵȺҪ֪ۡȺ˼ʿͲˣ
˺˼ʷϾһֱûжϹ19ĩ20ͳʼγ˱ȽϵͳȺѧ˵˱80ʵѾ
Ϊѧ֮һȺ˼ԴԶȺһҲ19ĩͳ֡Ⱥ˼뼰
֮ڱбҪ˵һʼճ顣ȻȺһƵڵѧУ
˼Ǳۼˡɣ¶˹̫̫˹̩աˡɵȺԼȴʹһ
˵ȺԾӡάտǸ⣬еǲܻʹȺʹˣҲڰԼ˵һλ
ߣһλȺߡ
    ܶȺĸŷ磬ܹʲôȺûһµĽ綨ܷϵʵǣȷʵΪһڲͬģ
岻ͬѧšȺ徿ЩʵʲôĹϵЩ⻹ѧ
ǽһȥۡ
α༭Ŷ
    
    
    
 
