 ׺ 1-1206
ԭĳ羭Ρ
ԭ
ԭںš200011
ԭҳš5156
  šD7
  
ӡںš200102
    Ͷǵķչģʽ뾭õĹϵ
    ʱѧ
߼顿ʱѧйѧԺооԱʱࣺ100007
ҪͼӷȨ塱֣ҪͶǵġȨ塱侭÷չеã̽
뾭õ໥ϵĵĽǣܷȡøһΩһľءף뾭õĹϵĺģһ
ȷȨԣάϵȶΪý贴Ҫ
  ʡ뾭/Ͷ/Ȩ塱
    
    ڱȽͶǵķչģʽʱ׷һʵһЩͶǹңõĸھȨĸ
ѹȡõġʶһͶǷչзӹҪõġȨ塱Ȩ뾭໥ü
ʲô߽ʹԳ¹ܼ
    νȨ塱
    ʷϣ19ͳĶսνޡľ˶˾ռߡ2060˵ٴη
͢ѧҰη֣60̨ʷϵġޡͬ(1)ʷϵġޡͳһ̶һָ
ϵΪµľȨϵơ(2)ޡȨ֪ãµľȨھù
רңֲⷽľǷȱˣȨרҵ֪ʶ̶Ƚϸߡ(3)ޡĵֻ
ԼȨͲƲµľȨȻҲΪߵȨԶʵиѹͳΣǳעطչãǿԼ
ͳελĺϷԡ
    2060ֵľȨͬʷϵġޡͳΣνǰ֮߳ΪȨ塱ȨעȨ(bu
reaucratic authoritarianism)롰Ȩ塱ѧ糣֮ΪB-A70ġִȨ壺
εоһУ60ھȨͳ֮µİͰ͢ηչ;÷չۺʵ֤עGuillermo A.O
' Donnell: Modernization and Bureaucratic-Authoritarianism: Studies in South American Politics,Institute of International Stu
dies, University of CaliforniaPress, 1973.ڰоĻϣѧ߶԰Ͱ͢޹ҵΡ״˸Ϊ
ķ֤ӶʹȨ塱۱øΪƺעĿ
    ڡȨ塱Ȩ쵼˵Уͳθǵ¹ҶҪԴ֮һЩʵȨľһֵӵ۹
μңΪμҶܡܺ˽ʹһֻȨ塱ȨĵȨ߻Ϊ
ҰȫٵķղⲿԹڵ淢չ׳ڹȱΡúȫ淢չ
ˣ˼רҵİ£˶Ρƽ˴ȵĵΪԼͳڵİšͬʱЩȨ
Ƶľ˻λȡ֯еνֶҵĸԴ
    ɼһԣȨ塱Ȩص㣺һŵְλмרˡڶųڡ
ƻȫȡλģıʾûк͹ʻһ֯ԼŷкͿ˾ƹϵ
˹񾭼ãԼĺϷԵλעT.Skidmore and P.Smith: Modern Latin America, fourth edition, OxfordUniversity Press,
 1997,p.57.
    ͶǵġȨ塱Ȩ
    Ϊ͵ġȨ塱ҡ˹Īָ19641985ڼ䣬ͳΰһһר
Ȩ쵼˶ǽܸȨĽṹԱͬɾ١һ֮Աʸμɵ˹
ɡעT. Skidmore and P.Smith: Modern Latin America, third edition, Oxford University Press, 1992,pp.180181.һ棬
ľȨǿȶøѹֶѹһ棬Ȩȶáͨͺ͸ƹ֧ΪԼҪ񣬲Ϊ
һЩ˵ξòŵҪְ磬ڲƽʱڣѧҺ⽻޲ء˹ΪƻΪ
þеĹؼ̨ϵ˸飬޸͹˳ó׵йع򣬲ʹƱгծȯгýһ
ƻ
    ƤŵͳʱڵԱΪһСȨ塱صҡ19739Ƥŵ̨󣬡ǿ
йȨ塱עT.E.˹Īִޡİ棩֪ʶ磬1996棬166ҳƤŵؽ
ɢ˹ᣬϳܷʵʩͼǿýĿƣ˽ӹܴѧȨʹѹֶηӲԥ
͹ҺڿκͷˡעT.E.˹Īִޡİ棩֪ʶ磬1996棬
168ҳȨΥȨѹ˴ʿаþˣ19981016գӢӦ
󣬽ӢβƤŵؾһɡ粨ֱ20003²ŵԽ
    ȻƤŵؾȨǿרͳεʱһ֥Ӹѧܹļרң֥Ӹӣھʵʩ
̶ĸĸΪÿĴǣٹҸԤ⿪šƤŵ˵øĸĿʹΪһ޲
ߵĹңǳΪһҵҵĹҡעT.E.˹Īִޡİ棩֪ʶ磬1996棬167ҳ

    Ӧָ80صľΣǣܵ˵Ƥŵصڼ䣬ľĿġ
Ϊøĸġȷ桱
    ڶǣȨҲСȨ塱ص㡣һ˵Ȩ70ʼ򡰹Ȩ塱ɡ
ڵҪѹ1972СάơƹֹֹչСտ
УǿŹߵĿơǣھ򣬺ȨѼپΪ׷ҪĿꡣΪ˼ǿԾ
Ĺ͵أ60˾Ժ(EconomicPlanning Board)ɸֱ乤˵ĻУ20%ĳ
ԱǾѧңԱΡ̹ͽȷרҡԣʱ巽ʽµľ÷չҪǮľ
ͶʣһҪȶλĹߡΪʵȶ¸ʱֹ˴ѧᡢ֯λ
ЩͳʱΣ᲻ͬʱ֯һɽںרɵľίԱᣬԱרҲμ
;ߡԼǵۺͲʡעPark Chung-Hee: To Build A Nation, Acropolis Books, 1971, pp.102107.ת
ƣִ磬1995棬114ҳ
    ⣬һЩǹңҲֹȨеġ漣һȷ7չС漣壬
սʷбֳר(authoritarian)򡰰רơ(semi-authoritarian)ص㡣磬̩70ڵġšǰй
һνϳʱľͳΡ80ˡйơ(controlled)ɻ1991ֱ˾䣬ܲԺͻӡ
ǵһͳ£ݱΪƶȻ¼ºңԶȨһֱ¢һ
¼µжһЩɹɵߣǵĹߣСעTun-jen Cheng, Stephan Haggard and Da
vid Kang:Institutions, Economic Policy and Growth in the Republic of Korea and Taiwan Province of China, UNCTAD. 1996,p.4.
    ֵעǣһЩǹңȨߵͳηʽȴˡȨ塱(soft authoritarianism)ıǩǷе
˵ǡɫ(Asian-Style Democracy)
    Ȩ塱ɫ¼ص㣺һӵԼѧ˵ΪĻͳͼֵۣˣ
ŷʺ϶ǡڶ(community)ȡ˵νɡȶȸ˵
ȨΪҪΪάϵ͸ƾø񡣵ģμ֮ɵĹʶΪһʶ
ǽһĸǽ±͹ȶ壬ܡȨ塱ͬΪ
ھ÷չעڡȨ塱ɫĺ壬Yung-Myung Kim:"`Asian-Style Democracy?: A Cr
itique from East Asia", Challenge, No. 34,1998.
    뾭õ໥
    κһᣬչκ;仯ĸӶḶ֮́һֻĹϵ༴ı仯Ӱ
쾭ı仯֮ȻȨ塱͡Ȩ塱ԱȨĲͬʽȨǽκͼȨ
֮һֹ̬Ӳ뷽跨ķչעƽִе塷ءս
19971ڣ91ҳ
    ǡȨ塱ǡȨ塱⣺뾭֮便ʲôϵʲôƶ
ʺھ÷չηչηھ÷չ
    Щ⣬μһѧߣƺвͬĿһֿΪֻȡýĹңܸƶ÷չ
עѧ̽뾭֮ĹϵʱҲʹáơ(political regimes)һ˵ġơ(regimes)Ҫ
ָμȡͿƹȨġ(methods)(J.Benson Durham:"Economic Growth and Political Regimes", Journal of E
conomic Growth, March 1999,p.81.֮ʵרƵĹʵ־õȲģΪ
ڱ˽˲ƲҲ޷ͶߵĻԡ磬˹ΪȨܸõӮùڶԸĸ֧֣Ȩͬ˳
ؿչøĸҲܼӿ쾭÷չ͢Ϊ谭÷չϰ谭ϰעתLarry Diamond and Marc Plattn
er: The Global Resurgence of Democracy, The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993.һǶָ뾭÷
չءζţԣĻࡣעSeymour Martin Lipset:"Some Social Requisites of Democr
acy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy", The American Political Science Review, March 1959.
    ۵㲻ͬǣҲΪȨȨھ÷չ磬˹ָȨȣȨȨƶøĸ﷽
ΪɹΪȨ쵼˲صԼǷѡʧȥѡ֧֣Щѡܵ˸ĸӰĴʧҵˮ
ƽ͡עJeffrey D. Sachs: Social Conflict and Populist Policies in Latin America, International Center for Economic Gro
wth, Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research, 1989.˹ΪȨ쵼иʱϵȨ
ܵ漯ŵġ⡱רƵѹƹͽ͹ˮƽܿߵܴٽͶʺ
ƶõЩʩܲġ෴Ϊ޶ȵӳλʱ䣬ǧټƵѡĸҪ
аϵҪ֧ѣȵȡǣʱܴܵӰ죬õĿҲԳΪʵ
    ˹ӸĲϷηչ뾭÷չĹϵΪŷҵľ÷չϾ׶Σ(1)򵥵ķ
Ʒ(2)ʱ(3)Ʒڵһ׶ΣһЩŷ޹ҽƣڶ׶˷˹רĵ¹
׶³ʮȶƹҡעJ.Kurth:"Industrial Change and Political Change:A European Perspective," 
in David Collier: The New Authoritarianism in Latin America, Princeton University Press, 1979.ƺ˵÷չηչ
Ĺ켣ȫһ£ǳʽ׶ԵķȻ÷չﵽһ̶ȺĵһֱȻˡעɣ
չйҵڷչеáءս19965ڣ81ҳɵΪξõչִ
ͽγƺ4֧Ļǰչ˶42P2W2PαȨ(
power)ԼĲ(participation)2WǾñƸ(wealth)͸(welfare)ܷʹ4õͬٶȵ
ܷͬʱǿȨͬʱĲ̶ȣͬʱӿ쾭÷չͬʱƸɵµĻشǷ񶨵ġעG.
ɵ£չеξáѶ͢ٵִʷ̽֡İ棩Ϻĳ磬1993棬3
61363ҳ
    ʮΪеִ۸ΪȷָƶȵĹŷǳеĹϵΪӢȷҶ
ȶҡʷϿӢŷҺձĹҵ϶רȨ½еġעYung-Myung Kim:"`As
ian-Style Democracy': A Critique from East Asia", Challenge, No.34,1998.
    ָǣͺ˹ҵҹȻͣͲǰһʱȡ˾øļѼȻͬݷ
ϣȱĵңȴûȡþ漣ɼܷȡøһΩһľء
˵Ȩ뾭÷չ֮ϵԶڣʺڴũҵҵתеһʱڡ֮Ӱ
쾭÷չĲأȨʽĶѣһһϵҪıľߺⲿȵȡ
ͶǵķչƺҲÿһַչģʽĳһضʱڵķչģʽӦƶ֮ƥ䡣ƶ
ھ÷չôӦñΪǺġ⣬ƣȨʽЧƺҲȡڰҵķչˮƽڵض
;
    Ȩȷʵһʱڡһ£еȨΪش÷չȶͳҲ
ʹìܲϻۡˣӱϿȶģȶǴġʵϣڶʮȨͳ£͹˶
˶ûֹͣʱʹᶯڿһ֤ע򼪣ִʷİ棩ѧ
׳磬1997棬267ҳ
    ⣬Ȩʹҵ֮Ĺϵʣصĸܡ2090عĺһЩƷҵĳţ˵
һ㡣
    뾭õĹϵĺ
    ʵϣ뾭֮Ĺϵĺǣ(1)ȷȨԣ(2)άϵȶΪý贴Ҫ
    1955꣬˹ָάԼڵ򡣡עW.ɪ˹ۡ꣬1990
516ҳߵ⵽һЩ漯ŵķԶ޷ʵʩʱһЩǿӲֶȫġҲΪ
ûһǿľ޷ʵʩЩѵľߵģ罵͹ˮƽȷʵһǸ
Ԥġɵľƣɼ۸гĹгԴôźȡ侭ϵĳɹҲʵ־
עYung-Chul Park:"Korea", in R.Dornbusch and F.L.C.H.Helmers (eds.): The Open Economy: Tools for Policymakers in 
Developing Countries,Oxford University Press,1988,p.404.ΪһصСȨ(the centralize
d nature)һƶеͨķʽΡȶߵʹ͹֯Ӷʹ
ʴڵµˮƽ60ⲿ߾ÿΪͶṩ60%ʽ70ֱӻӵؿ
˹񾭼м2/3Ͷʽ𡣳һЩ⣬ûһҵ֧˶ĿͶʵʽ𡣴⣬
ԽڲŵŴʵйơȻ˵ԴòǸЧʵġڶԱڲⲿʽ𲢽Щʽ
֧־õĸ棬ȴǳɹġעYung-Chul Park:"Korea", in R.Dornbusch and F.L.C.H.Helmers(eds.):The Open Econo
my: Tools for Policymakers in Developing Countries,Oxford University Press, 1988,p.340.
    Ȩйصһʶչ(developmentalist state)չصǣδľһǰ
һµĹ룬ԷչΪҪĿ꣬ǿӵ㹻Զԣ漯ŵӰ͸漯֮
ͻӶﵽٽϵĿġˣĺϷӿʱۺʹٽ񾭼óչעJames L.Dietz:"Ov
ercoming Underdevelopment:What Has Been Learned from the East Asian and Latin American Experiences?" in James L. Dietz(ed.): 
Latin Americas Economic Development: Confronting Crisis, Lynne Rienner Publisher, 1995, p. 192; M. Castells:"Four Asian Tiger
s with a Dragon Head: A ComparativeAnalysis of the State, Economy and Society in the Asian Pacific Rim", in R.Henderson and J
.Applebaum(eds): State and Development in the Asian Pacific Rim, Sage Publications, 1992.ԼѷΪչܽص
(1)÷չ׷ҪĿ꣬ʱΪ˴ﵽһĿϧһдۡ(2)˽˲Ʋг򣬵ľ߳Ϊ
ӿ췢չƶиԤԵĲҵߡ(3)ľ߹УͨһҪõĲšòŵĴԱнΪḻ
רҵ֪ʶҹЧʸߡעChalmers Johnson: "The Interplay of State, Social Class, and World System in East Asian Dev
elopment", in Frederic C.Deyo(ed.): The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism, Cornell University Press, 1987.
    ѧΪණǹңǵ͵ġչЩ봫ͳ뼯Ȩͬʵ֤չ
ԶԶʱִķչٶȣȷʵȡĿľá漣
    뷢չƵһνǿ(strong state)͡(weak state)һԣǿص㣺߲
쵼ͨרƵͳֶΣҵϵĵλƶüƻʵʩߵȷר϶Ȩ
רʹ˽˲ź͹ڸѹڹҵĳڷչ滮ҲʹĿƲһؼɡЧͿɿĹߡעDav
id Felix:"Import Substitution and Large Industrialization: Latin America and Asia Compared", World Development No.9,1989,p.14
59.ܹ֮ڲͬ漯ŵĺƶʵʩȫ᳤ڷչƻǡǿעTed C.Lewellen: Depe
ndency and Development: An Introduction to the Third World, Bergin & Garvey, 1995,p.135.ʣȱصǡ
ѶĶ壬ʵʩչߵԸעG.Myrdal: Asian Drama: An Inquiry i
nto the Poverty of Nations, Pantheon, 1968.˹Ϊܻ֮þáɡҪΪʵ˴ġ
ġǿתĹɡעLeroy Jones and Sakong I1: Government, Business and Entrepreneurship in Economic De
velopment: The Korean Case, Harvard University Press, 1980.
    80ڶǣһЩڽоøĸͬʱʼۻʵʩ̶ͬȵθĸǿĹӦ
øĸҪЩҵľȷθĸ뾭øĸ֮Ⱥ˳ʮҪġīǰͳ˹ָ
ɾɻǰϷɡ˵᷸Ƿִ󡣣עתEconomist, August
 26, 1995,p.19.̸ܿʱ˹ȷرʾһЩңǿԿھñ仯ʧˣѾ
ûгΪʵָĸĲͬйأǵ֮עEsther Wilson Hannon:"The Politics of Mexic
an Free Trade and the North American Free Trade Agreement", in Lowell S.Gustafson:Economic Development under Democratic Regim
es: Neoliberalism in Latin America, Praeger,1994,pp.162163.ǣ19958³һӢѧҡ־Ϊθĸ
ʮֱҪġθĸԸĸûаžøĸôøĸĿǰ˵ֻζ΢Խ˵Զڴ
ĵزΪͶ˾ƶȵȵȱǺöȻܵ˵īʹȥڶǾϵʹ࣬ʵ
ʹĸԴϵ⡣ԵĵƶȵͳīѾ66ˡֻԸⲻͳīʱҲû
ҪȥŵķúעEconomist, August 26,1995,p.12.
    ӹɣ˹θĸıҪԵĿǲȡģѧҡĴֻиƶȵȨ
ĸ۵ӻ⣬ӦָīһЩչйҶԣΪøĸﴴ˵λڴ
øĸθĸϵʱҪشҪ⡣īΣֱԭȻǹͶԽǿĶʱЩԼ
֮ī磬Ϊ1994īξƳעĿĶǡ˹ũԪҸͶֽ֮λ
ƶȵҪԱܼ쳤ְһλмұܵ¼һЩؽ֯һڴʹʱī
磬ӶȫıΣ
    ̽뾭õĹϵʱҪشһάϵӿ쾭ýȶǰīĸƶȵλ70
꣬Ϊɹر˹ڵȶ60ĩ1994ֱ𱬷ѧ˶ũ˶īƶȵ֮άϵ
ҪΪһƶȵʶ̬ڶҵȨԺƽķʽӡܽĺεء
עҫȶִīģʽʷ졷磬1996档
    ͨȽͶǷչģʽ뾭õĹϵԷҪ󣺵һһЩͶǹңִ
ĵλݺӡӵòֻǿֶԼִʽӺܿȫļơ
ЭͿϳΪΪؼעάִĺҴߡİ棩֪ʶ磬1990档תԳ
»ᡱ¹ʽìܡءս19971ڣ101ҳӵЧʡһԡ֯
ԺִʹΪչйпܽϺ͹һ廯ϵע»ᡱ¹
ʽìܡءս19971ڣ101ҳ⣬ӻԹĺԾӣάȶͷչΪ
ڹҵ̨Ϻ;̨ϰһʮҪĽɫڶһЩҺ͵īӡǣڴһͳ
ľ棬־ЩάϵȶĻī磬ƶȵ1929ִλ70꣬Ϊִʱ
עƶȵǰǳ1929Ĺ19461¹ٴθ飬Ϊƶ.Ȼſ
ԣһīӡǡʮáġ80ī磬Ϊ˼ᾭøĸĴۣƶȵڹ֧֯
£ʵʩ˵ķƶƻ(PRONASOL)˽˲һ𣬴˶ԸѵġŽЭӡǣչû
ڵǿҷȻһάϵ͵ҵ֮Ĺϵ
 
