 ׺ 2-933
ԭĳ̶ѧѧѧ
ԭںš20005
ԭҳš3035
  šB5
  йѧ
ӡںš200105
    ӹѧ
Ӣı⡿The  Dilemma  of  Confucious  Political  Ethic  in  GongyangDoctrine
    QI Liang
    College of Philosophy  and  History  and  Culture,   Xiangtan,University, Xiangtan, Hunan 411105,China
    
߼顿̶ѧ  ѧʷĻѧԺ  ̶  411105
    1955УϺˣ̶ѧѧʷĻѧԺڣҪʷĻıȽо
ҪҶ𡶴ԽΪġ½ҡԹѧΪ󣬾ѧ˼Դѧʵǵ
ִεĽ裬רͳεĸԴѧѧͽӷΪԵѹƵͼ
ͳͳĸӹϵȴֻΪεŮ
ӢժҪGongyang school exclusively revered The  Spring  and  AutumnAnnals. New Confucianists of  Mainland  with   Mr.   
Jiangqingbeing one of its  representatives,   are  eulogizing  GongyangDoctrine and managing to explore its  thought  resourc
es.   Infact, Gongyang Doctrine was  the  root  of  autocracy  throughages more than  helpful  in  the  course  of  construct
ion  ofmodern  democratic  politics.    Gongyang   Doctrine   deifiedpolitics and esteemed Confucius  Untitled  King  intendi
ng  toprevail Force with Principle, but only to be  reduced  to  thestatus  of  a  slave  girl  of  dynastic   politics   in 
  thecomplicated relations between the  principle  system  and  thepolitics system.
  ʡѧ/ѧ/
    Confucianism/Gongyang Doctrine/political ethic
    
    ͼţB2  ױʶ룺A   ±ţ1001 5981 200005003006
    ǰЩй½ѧ˼ΪУĳЩѧԡ½ҡԳƣԽӴнΪΡУǺѧ
ڴ½Ӧߣ˵ǳ½һϵѧҲѧߵǰǰΪ˵Ľľѧ֮һ·ԹѧΪ
ľߴԵһλۣѧ˼ԴΪѧδʱڽмֵ˽
۲ɻȱ֮ḻ˼ԴǿյйϽȫӹѧȡǻۡ
    ִᣬѧ˼ĶԪģԸϵ޿ɷ飬ͳ˵ĶģʽǷǵʧ
Ĺ۵ֵ֮ӣΪѧľҲڿݷʧһЩᷨĲףЩҲֵȶ
ԹѧߣķǸѧߵĸںһЩӰ죬̨
塶¿ġй½ѧʵ弰ٵ⡷һģΪ½ԡĸ˹ѧţõһЩ
Ϊ½ѧߵĿ϶һ˼ĻţѧǲӦĮӵġΪҪǣͬйŴִ֮ͬ
ϵֻοѧ⣬ǹ浽ǧйͳ˼Ľۣ֮ǶԹѧķҲǶ
йͳķ˼
            һ  ѧѧ
    ѧѧ˼ѧԼѧΪѧͬʱֽѧͬλѧ
ǰΪľѧΪľѧΪѧΪĹľѧ컯˵ѧ˵ʶ̬˵ѧ
λ˵ѧѧִƶȲԭĽܣǾкͷġ[1]P9 ǹҲ۹ľѧǷΪ
λ˵ѧ಻ۡѧͬλ˵ѧʵԵ𣬽͹ѧԣ俴ԡ˼ɱ𣬾
ܲǡģ˵ܶԹѧоķȴδð¡ΪĹѧ˵ѧ˵
ѧԻѧѧһ㣬ѧжۣ˵ǳʶ۵ıҪڳʶǽ۵Ļ㣬
ıȶһʶЩѧǽġѧʶ̬˵ѧȷҪ

    һѧ˸Ӧ˵ѧ˵ʵʾǹλѧϵڶѧ˵ֵΪ֡ڿѧ
Եѧʣڽ̻īһڻѧ֮УӶϵͳ˸Ӧ˼롣ѧ˵
Ϊ֮Ȼ֮죬֮죬֮졣족ĳݣܳ˵ġġ
Ҫָ죬ڶȨԵ˵֮ңԡӹΪ˵ġֻǴ
Եģ֮νԡ˺˼ѧɵġ۾һҵ˼롣һǿ죬
ƶ֮ԡһǿ֮֮ҲȻҵĶⲢ޶Ȥָ
ȷ˵ͨһػΪϵľȨ绤ӷ֮壬ȡ֮ƶ֮
ȡ족֮٣족ﷱ¶塷
    ӦҶԡ족ǿȷнѹ˼붯˸Ӧ˵Ҳǰһġ֮Ϊ
ҲΪҲ԰ߣ֮ߣ֮ﷱ¶Ң˴䲻רɱӱϿ
Ļǵ͵壬ΪԾȨĳƣͬʱרͳε۸ݡΪ˸Ӧѧ˵ӵϵȨ
ԾȨľԷ쾭ģӦа㻳ɡԣѧ䵽ʵǶԾȨάѹ˼붯ת
ΪΪ
    ѧʼ˵ŨʷɫʡϹѧʼ˵Ϊɹѧѧĸ
αġʼ˵ʼٸߡ֪ԵóĽۡʼ˵սʱˣܴ˾Ǩ
дƣܡתƣθˣӦȡĽľѧ̶ܴϱѧѧ
϶ɡġͳʷѭۣԼӴƺţ˷׷ɫţֱԴʼ˼
롣ͳĴѭֹڡȻҵʼ˵ͬϵ˼ѷ˼ìܡʼ
˵ͳ˵ǵصʷۣͬ޹ءͳе»޵£ʰǱŰͬͳεİΣûйϵĻ
ô족Ҳʧȥڵ壬ƾȨڵáҲ˵ҵʼ˵ֵг
νġ־Ǵᡱ衱ȵȣֵҳܶìܣĿһµģǶר
ͳά
    γ֮ѧǽѧγ֮ѧͬѧȻһ£֮Ųɷָϵԣϵ
Ҫĸ棺1.γľ˵ȡԽľ˵2.ľѧͬʱҲγѧң3.γ֮ѧԶġﷱ¶Ϊ
ݣ4.γܴܿڹߺͶλѧʦĺѧ֮֡γ£ĿȫĿ˵ߣԤ
סγߣ֧м塱ʱ˵γرУγǺеģͬѧء
Ϊ۴ӡﷱ¶˸Ӧ۵˼룬Ƕԡ΢ԵĲơѵڬԼƪĿԿ
γȵγǶ˼ļ̳кͷչ[2]P127 γ֮ѧǿҵĹɫʣһּȹضֲִڵλѧ
Ŀ֤ڵĺԣֱΪרȨ񡣵һ棬һֲڵѧͬʱĲءΪȿΪڳ
ͳ߱绤ֿΪ˷ҵ۹ߡһ㣬ʵǽľѧʼδġָǣγ֮ѧΪĳ
ߣζĹеģ෴ǶΪһƶȵרάΪγѧ񶨵Ĳרƶֻ֮ĳĳ
֮¡
              ʷʷ
    ѧһŽ͡ѧʡȻǰҵ伮ʮҪ¼͸¶Ϣ1.
ᵽʫ顷סȴδᵽ2.⣬Ӻټ֣3.ػҪǡʫ
˵ʱ˶鲢ӡʼʱ͡˹ǲʿְ¸вءʫ顷ټߣϤξ֮иż
ʫ顷С˹ջԹŷǽڵʱӣôȱٵӦǡӦǡʫ
͡顷
    Ǻе飬ȷ˵ǹӪѧաҲΪȺ֮ףҷΪ̫֮ڡ
νΪǱӣִԴ¡ʣ֮ͽһǡƣǳڹҵĿš
    Ĺ֮رӡһԵڵʱʷǰйǹᣬƽѼȨȦӡ
һƽ˻ʵ۵ıӴ˽ҿйʷƽεĻɹιɵƽΣ濴ƺͬǾƵ
£ʵȴǴΪͬġǽʽĵȼᣬƽǡձūơ˼ᡣƽߵ
ͳȨȫῪŵģ˭пܹΪӡǣλֻһ˭Ϊʲôµģ⣬
и˵ȻĻ´ҡѾϻλ˵ΪҪΪ˵ķǷ֮룬ΪԼͳ
ѰҺԣѰҷǼĪĸݡһ棬һǣƽӣڹӣ׵¼˵ĸܣ
ȫѣͳߵΪΪͬһֵ⡣ʷѧֳеʵü
ֵΪڡȿΪĺԶ绤ͬʱһ̶϶ͳơ˵ġһ
³ȵ˵ƾȨã˷׷ɫͨͨͳǶ
֮ͳε˵
    һʷ飬ΪάȨƾȨűӳ˺ʿײһּìܵɷ⣬
ΪʿһεľأžرӡʵüֵݲۡʷԾȨǷ罯Ծ
оȿֱΪרηġ
    ˾Ǩ˵Ƿǣʳˡ̫ʷ򡷣˵´ܣԡ
¶ġ˵øΪףȷʵֶ֮顢飬ܷ֮٣ϵȨ
˶һѭ[1]P99֮ԱҷΪ󾭴󷨣ǡһֶᡱıʷֱʷ֮ʵ
ʷʷǺҵķ֮ǰˡСͳΪ˵ͳεĺԣ۹߾
ʷѧʱ޼ʹֻСʷԣʷ¡ʷ书ȴͬġ顤־˵֮
ߣҲʷ٣ٱ飬УѷʽҲ顷еƪĿоУıȻʵ
ʷʷ֤ĺԡǶԹϵĽʷԡѷʽ֮ͳļ̳С
    ʷԡѷʽԻԡɱҪʷΪۡ顷ƪо֮У񼫣һ
ȻͬʵȻȡĲǡ顷ƶͬԵġǷǺöڸ
ļֵĿϣҲͺѱԼ̬ȶʵʷرǣġʷΪЧ£ʷ
ʵӰĽչľѧΪȺ֮ףȾǿʷġʷΪѰ
۸ݡ
    ԭǿģ½֡ϵ֮֮ľ֮󣬲Ÿı̬ȣҪ½֡Ϊ
ʧ£ԵߺΡƽڿ˵ġСˡ͡ޡ֮Уպǰģʽǲܹµġ
˵Ȩ˳Ӧˣͳ뿼ǵ⡣½ܲ¶˼ʮƪÿһƪδ
ơ½ֵġ顷䲻ʷȴʷԭдɵġͳ˵һڣӶóۣλ޵
ڲƶ̣õƶ𡣡СġʷһνΪɹؼ֮ڴͷʷ
˾Ǩġʷǡ˾Ǩʷּǡ֮ʣͨŽ֮䣬һ֮ԡо˾Ǩѧ߶⼸仰Ǻ
ƽ⡣ʵ⼸仰˾ǨΪѧʷѧʦѧԣԼҪչѧĹ׫дʷνһ֮ԡ
ɹ֮ԣǳ˾Ǩ˵ġһ֮ԡ֮ҡָѧɣָĳһˡ
    ʷ̧ĸ߶ȣȨ֮ԵݣͬʱҲζʷѧȻر߻ʶ̬˵Ϊ֤
Լεĵ˳ģҪʷѧʷ֮󣬴Ϊձ顣õʷǾܵرǰͷα
ϧʷʵĸʷ׫޷棬ҪǶŤרγԭ
֮һΪʷġʷоʹǺѻԡ˭£˭ͿָʷѧҰ
Լͼ׫дʷһЩͼĳΪҲͺǵµģҲҪ¡ΪĿһﵽʳ֮
»ʷǲҲԼΪʥ֮
              ͳͳ
    Ҷ𡶴ӿΪǰȷȨĿǡݴΪѧΪѧ
ǡС롰ƶСѧѧͳоǿйܵѧп˵ǹѧеʡ
ʵʾǡִƶȾ޵ĺԵȨԣԽĳһضƶʥ㻯ͨȥ¶ִı
ͨȥ׷δ룬ӶֹὩٽá[1]P16
    ӹɣѧȷоġԿΪͼԼΪ֮ΪѹԡΪ
󷨣༴ͼԹŷԼ񷨡ȻֻһЩ󣬻˵ǹҵԸʵǲġǡǡǣ
ѧġС֮ͺҷ񶨵ʣǶʵУǶרƶʥ㻯ά
    йʷϣԾȨľԻʶģֻйѧܹԽֱ죬ǧ꣬һֱһͳܹѹ
ǿΩλڵԪǳεǻʶӴʶΪУΪĻк͵Сǿ
ʿ־ڵļֵ淶֮󣬡йǻķ룬ΪеľԴĹѧǽܳġ족
ͬսʱڵġƴһ𣬼ѹԵѹǰҪ˸Ӧ˵Ҫڿ˵
ɷֵġ桰첻಻䡱֮˵ͺ˵֮ϵ
    й˵ĿУгߵĵλ˵ʿ־ڵܶ¶ʳߣδҲ˵ııʳǵ
ƶĵ˵ʿɲضԶ˵øΪ׳еԵѳ޵ѳΪ
һֹй˵˼봫ͳж෽ĺ塣ҶԣҪָ֮ʥ֮Ϊݡ֮
ıԣҪƶԵġơȨȨԼơơΪʷķӦ
֮ΪͳơΪͳ
    ʿײ֮֮رԵͳֵԭйȨģʽֻʿܹΪ֪
оͬʱͳĹϵͣȨ͵Ҫạ̊́ȨѹȨйûڻ̵
ȨȨʹҲȻ䵽ʿļϡرԺƽᣬרȨʿеԼʹش
ǵֻǶһ족롰ҷΪʵʾԵѹƣԵͳ淶ͳΪ
Ŀ಻ǸԵĴѣǹԼ֮һϿ˵ҶרȨоҲ
˵ùȥġǣ룬رǽͳͳԼйŴȨϵͳһṹԵķѷ֣ͳǵԼ
ͳ䱾רε֮塣ߣڵͳͳ֮䣬ʿڼελáǷǵܳܵͳͳ
ҲɱͳȫͳԻʹͳΪͳ񣬴ӶʹϵоתΪ͹϶רεĻ֡ڴˣ
ǿɴ˵
    һսʱڣʿɽϵ͵һȼԾʷ̨λãΪʿũ̡֮ףǵΣ
ʶ˼Ļ·ˡǿҵʶԡĵԾΪһʷ̨ϣ
ߵĽɫƷʱ˵ġʿ顱༴˾Ǩ˵ġζۣۡʵϾҪΪ
Եͳ淶ͳĹҲĴ΢ԣʵɿءʿ顱
    ȻʿɫìܵģҴбԵζǼȴʷ̨ģͬʱִڱԵλáһֻ֮ر
غԺʿһȼλȡڳ͢ǷáڶʿΪ֮ףȴ޹̶ְҵԼľû
·Ȩ󣬱ֻһʿʵȻԡζۡȴֻǡʿͳʱɽ֮֮
ȥģǵġۡǷ񱻲ɣȫͳߵԸܲɣΪġΪѿĻڣԵʿ
ΪԼڱԵλãΪ˲ãƷףιΪʦǺίԼʱ̲絣
ʹʱѳҲ͵ڰԼüڭʽЦλ
    ʿͼõͳ淶ͳĿʹͳܹʵеΡרģʽȨûԼͳ佾ݶ
ֺǱȻ飬κѼʵľͬʱζڵķҲɱ⡣ǣھ֮䣬ʿֻܴ
һּελáǼҪҪȷ˵ھǼҪάȨͳҪ
ĹֺڣǼҪڵ棬ҪգԾͳγвɣشʹ
ʿûиġȻʿ־ڵļֵԼͳͳĶģʽ־йʿҪи
⸱صӶԼϳصʮּܣһ޷ѵԭСһ棬޵ʱʿеԼûо
ʦΣԵͳΪ˳һ棬Ŀ֮ʱͬеھΣеԼûоιƽ¡

    ǺĹңػڵͳͳ֮䣬Ըѵͳͳ֮ϡ׷ǵͳ
ͳ˭еǷͳϡǣֺһʿԵͳı׼ͳͬʱŲϧѪķʽˢ
ͳʹ֮ͳϣӶʽıΪʿԵͳĵΪȻҲͰԼελáһ棬
ʳ֮»ûж˸񣬲ܲͳܷͳȫȡͳǷṩŵĻͿܡһ棬ͳֻ
һֹ̬֯ʽƶȱ֤ƾǵĸΪά֣ӶǿͳǰԵĶţӢʱ
ƣڡȱʽ֪ʶֻͨ˵԰زġ޿ɿı֤[3]107
ڰѵͳάͬϵͬϵʶʿֺ״ӵͳϿ˵Ӷͳͳһ忴
Ҳ;ǺܿӵͳһͳɥʧԼԵͳĵʶر˵пܽڡеΩ
ڸλĹΪԼͳĿͳ߻ʹԵͳΪʿΪԼ蹦̵¡ߣڡе
ǵͳҪ˼룬ʿҲڸ˵
    ģѧľΪʥιۣԿӸΪȵȣʥ˵ĸʵεı׶
ôͳִͬӹ졣첻ʥ˳йʷок壬ĵغֻҪִ˵İ
ܿӵĸԭִ֮θĸʵǽľɴµҵһóɹ[1]P185ʵϣ ʥ˳Ҫֲ
ġڸ˵ռ䣬ʥ˳ǵ¾ĳڹռ䣬ʥ˳ֻᵼ¼ȨΡ
    ڹҿʥûжġ׻ͨƣʥߺΣʥߣͨҲҲҲͨգ֪飬
غϵ£ºʱ򣬹ϼסġﷱ¶˵֮ߣν֮ߣ졢Ҳ
ߣͨҲ졢֮Ϊ֮ͨܵǣ߿ͨ졢ءߣֻʵζǡ족
Ĵˣǡ塣ұԵͳ淶ͳʥޱ˼ֽߺΪһ塣ͳʵڵģͳֻһֹ̬
ֹϵʵǽͳͳ֮Уʹڹ淶ͳĵͳú塣һ棬ھʥ˵λΪ壬
ֺ׵Ψ־ͣΪ֮£ֻǾӵߣܿܿԡʦΪʿ򣩶
ǻ֮֮¡һʥ⻯¹ҲͱȻ˼ĻרͳΡ
    ոڣ20000901
οס
    [1].ѧۣM.磬1995.
    [2].γۣM.磬1991.
    [3]Ӣʱ.ʿйĻM.ϺϺ磬1987.
    
    
    
 
