 ׺ 3-269
ԭĳʦרѧ
ԭںš200101
ԭҳš6165
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš200104
    Լ˼
    
߼顿(1963-)У̸ˣʦѧϵʿоҪѧĻо
300073
ҪԼȨɾдԵ˼ҡ벷ᷨ˹սУӽǵ֤˽̡ȨԪ
ܵĺԼҲʹڵıȻԣ˼϶˽оŷʶγʱڵ˼شļֵ
  ʡԼ/̡ս/Ȩ
    
    Լ(1241-1306)á(Jean Quidort)˽ŵѧңڰѧѧѧʿѧλΰѧ
ѧʦ漰ȻѧζѧѧѧΪһ˼ҡ13ڲμ˲ᷨ˹
Ϊĵڶν̡ս14ͳ׫дˡ۹̻ʵȨ(On Kingly and Papal Power)У
Ŭ֤ʱѱΪ˵ġʥ;ƵĽ塣ӦȥĽ壬
    Լд۹ͽ̻ʵȨΪ˻ػ϶˹ڡ۽̻ȨΪ̻ʵȨҪ֤ˣ˵Ϊ
ڽ̻ʺʥ۹ʵ۵Ȩı绤ʡ뵱ʱ˼һȻҲʱáʥеĲϺڽ̸Ĺ
㣬ǣòδڴˡ֤Ŀĳ÷ѧҵĹ۵㼰ʷϡҪǣʿ⵽̻ͳ
ɵĹ͵ʱȴ󵨵ʵ⡣֤׶
    ԪŷһιϵϾڽ̡ܽ׶ԪȨָۡ
ԣȨһȨȨڶȨͬʱҲȨķ
ΧҲǶġִȨÿߵģͬʱҪӵĸڽ̻ᴫ͵ԭ
ǸȨԻ֮ϵͳһ[1](P254-255)
    ǣ̻֮ȴûΪһͨԹĴڶల¡ʵϣԴӽ̻ʸ𣬽֮Ħϣͻ
ȨȨ֮໥ţʱȨȨԱʵ꣬սＸ͡Ļչķ
׳ʶǿȨȨɵĶڰȻһʷУԼγԼ˼롣
    һҺͽ̻ᡢȨͽȨвͬԴĿҲͬ
    ԼʿµĹ۵Ӱ졣ϵУȻ׷ĺϺ߼ĽڵĿΪ
ͬ档һ۵ԼΪһȺ֮УܹһĿĵĳл
һλΪԹͬΪĿĵͳ֮ǱҪģȻΪڱġεĺĶ[
2](P145-146)ȨΪһΪ˹ͬƶһƵȺͳΡԴˣϵ۽֮˵һ仰Ϊһ
ͳεȨѧ֤дֻһ˵ͳβǹҲϵ۽֮˵ģұһչǣ
ҵ˴飬34:23һǴȻȨǴȨġ֮˵Ϊ˾
ԶκĶ[3](P406)
    ԹҵԴڽṩѧ֤Ϊڻʳͱ涼޷ʵ㣬˵ҲΪ
˽ڵġԣӦȺӣֻһȺУ˵ܵõ㡣һȺ岢һͥͬһ
䣬ǳл߹ҡΪһͥУ޷ҵнʳ⣬Լһ˽ıҪ֮Щֻ
ڳлвҵ[3](P407)
    ȻԹԴĽں̶ܴͻ˴ͳģʽѹҿԴڸȻԵĶȺе֮Ҫһͳ
ߣΪǶ׷Լ˽ʱͬͻ˷ɢһԹͬ渺εǷ棬
һ˵壬ûһͬÿһֹͬĻͻһԤ˵ͳ
[3](P407)
    ڽ̻Դȫͬǿ˽̻ʵ˰֮뷽ĲԹܡҪǼס˲ȥͨ
䱾ԶһƣȥﵽһֳȻĿģȥһǰ
Ⱥ屻һǣͱһָȺȥʵһĿġƾԵﵽһĿģôָǵ
Ӧڹǣʹͽ˵ģΩĶͣǵҮ6:23޷ƾ
ֻܴﵽĿģˣָʵһĿĲ˵[3](P407)
    ǣΪܵεҮջáҮ顷еġӽҪһᣬȨ
ۣڵʩйƽ͹塱Ү23:5Ϊ֤֮һѧ̷ȨתΪʦУЩ
ʥ䣬ʥĵϵ֮н顣ԽְĶΪͽʥ¶ɻ̻ʦһ־Ȩ
    Զ׼ԼУҺͽ̻ԴͬԴ˵Ȼԣ̻Դϵ۵ȼƻˣȨͽ
ȨʺĿҲϽԵĲҵĿԼȨڵĸ׹ͬ棬̻
ĿԼ̻ʵȨ˳ͨݵġʥ֮áȥʵĿꡣ
    ڹҺͽ̻ԴĿμˣͽ̻ʵȨǲͬġҼȻȻĲôӦ
÷ȻĹɡȻǧе׷ҲͬˣͲǿǷһ¡ͳʦľ
Ϊ׵ĶιͬгֵĴɡԼҵ쳣̻ȨԴ̻ͳһҪ
Ժͽ̻ƲʹԽ̻Ϊ׵һ̻ͬҪ֮˲֮ԭģ
    ȣ塢ǴĽǶ֮Ų죬Ϊͳһԣ괦һͬˮƽȨ
ȻʵĲͬͻȾȨʾĲ죬ΪЩֳֻһЩٵı塣һȨ
ͲؾͬĹɷʽģʽ
    Σһ˲ͳξͳȫΪȨһԵָܹ׵شﵽеˣ
ԶȨ򲻿ô׵ԶˣΪǿֹġȷ˽Ҫס
    ΣڵײƲڹͬ壬ÿһ˶ԼƲˣΪЩƲԼáǣڵĲƲͲ
ҪһͬߣΪÿһ˶ΪʵķʽԼĲƲȻһ棬̻ĲƲѾתø˹ͬģǣ
ҪһˣΪͬĹߺвƲĴԹͬͳΡȫײƲĹûд˱Ҫ
    еͽͬһˣ޷õȡʱΣڲͬһЩغ
⣬ǣΪ˱ͳһͬ⵽ƻҪһھȨˣͨľЩˡ
ǣͨоͲҪһͳһˡԺĲ죬ܻвͬʽһ屻Ϊ
Ķһǣ˵Ҳˡ[3](P408)
    ԭóĽǣϼûпҲûбҪھһͳ硣ָ֮
ÿһлȻȻγɵģǵ۹Ĳð¹˹ڡϵ֮ǡĹ۵㣬ΪֻԼ
Ƶǰ£ܻͬøáƽͳΡȻڳֵ̻ͬʱΪȨͻȨĸԤһ
ҵṩһȽϳֵǰᡣ˿˵ԼӵĹңҪɵĶԪ硣ͬ
ʱҲһ涨ģʵдڵĽ̻ʾԣֻԵʽ֮еġ[
2](P146)
    ͳߵȨֱԴڵͬ⡣
    ѡϣԼΪһµƶԶʵʩͳΣҪ򼸸¸صʹͳȨƺ
ھ塣Ϊһṩԭǣ
    1.ȨĽǶȨһ֮ʱͳһҲ͸2.ȺӦ׷ͳһƽĽǶͳ
һ֮дźгͳһƽͲܴڡĳһ֮˵ԭ׷һߵĳ̶ȣôһ
½ͳε˾͸ֺƽĺƽҲͲ̫ƻ3.һ׷ͬĵһͳ߱ɼ
½ͳλῼǸΪձĶ4.Ȼ򣬶ͳҪʵͳһһ֮Уһؾͳελһͬ
ʵУһҪĳɷ֣꣬ɷŽȻԶ֮еİʶҲͻһ
[3](P407)
    ԼʿµȻҹۺͽ̻ᷨѧɵŷ۵Ӱ죬ͬʱҲǳϤǸʱŷĽ̻˶
УΪĹȻĲȻϵ۴ģ˹еԴϵۣȴֱ
ӵԴͷǿ̻֮ûʲôϵȨͨѡٴϵõģǸ־ִ̨
ˣԼΪ̵̻ȨҲǴѡͬȡõġˣ̻ʵͳȨҲȡΪ̻Ȩ
ʵԳɷڵͬ⣬ڽ̻ܡޱԼԭʱǿջͬġдȨԴ
ȨʹԴڽ̻ʣԴϵۺͨѡһ˻һѡһ񡣡̵Ȩ̻ͨʶԴϵ
ֱԴϵۡԴѡٺͬ[4](P208)
    ԼΪջͬ԰һа֮ͽȨͨͬѡһͬЧġһͬĹȨΪ
һǱڵȨֻ쳣²ܱáΪǽ̻ỹǹңõе˶ͨѡĴ
йز塣д
    ʿڡѧĵָһ˸ͳεҪκμ򵥵壬Ȼ
ƺƻһּ򵥵ҪáΪһֻϵУе˶ܲһĺƽ
õ֤ͬʱÿһ˶Ȱᱣ[4](P208)
    ѿƳɷϵľƣ׼ȷ˵һֻ塣ֻ岻׹ң
ڽ̻ᡣϣڽ̻֮һʡѡٲĴᣬڽ̴Ϊ̻ȨȨӦڽ̻֮
ϡ[5](P92)
    ڶָԼĹͳȨֻܸЩͳߵͬȡáһѡٵһ
ȨͬᣬһְȨ¡һǶ˹ľ޴ԽͬʱҲǶԴͳ϶µͳȨ۵
Ϊı롣[6]ȻԼֻһ룬һҲֻһûܹԾƻ̻ڲȨ
֣̽Ҳȫ˹̻֮ϵķ[7]ɼԼĻۻֻһĹ롣
    Һͽ̻ȨֱԴϵۣڸԵȨ޷ΧڶߵȨͬʱмලԼԷȨ
    ڽ̡׹ϵϣԼǳ϶߲ġȨСȨھиȨȨ
ԴϵۡͬʱҲܾȨȨ߹˵ǣͨԶ߽Ŀĵ֣ȨӽȨĴͳۡ
ΪȨֻϵرָӵľϷӽȨдʦȹΰλ߹󣬵ȴɴ˶۳ǰ
һз涼ΰ󡣡֮Ĺϵһ֮һͳ˧ӵĽУһ˵ȨһȨ
ͬһߵȨһʦһ½ʦְָͥԱȥﵽһ߹Ŀģ֪ʶһҽ
ĵֻһͼĿģĽ˭˵ҽ֢ҩӦ÷ʦأǲʵģΪӶ
ļҳûʹǸȨСһȨġ[3](P408)
    ̻Ȩϵ۵ֱͳߵļ۵㣬ǶԴͳĻһɲСĳ
ṩһϢΪ͵˼άߵʥ¢ϵλڵʱѾʼҡ
    ڽ̡˵ϣԼδȡǾԸ뿪ķȷ˶ߵȨʺзΧǰ£һ̡
ȨԼӵķʽ໥ԼģʽΪ̻ʿԼӵطͳߣͬʱʵҲԼӵط̻ʡ̻ʿͨ
Ľ̼䱻⣬ͬʵҲ̻ͨʣڹ󣬽̻ʲھ棬һ
ƹ̻ͬ淸д󣬻ʵҲԾ̻ʵĹʧǾģ̿
ҪʵɱǷϳ̻ʡдһһˣ֪ڸģԽָ̻ţ̻ʾͿͨ
ְùְȨ̻ǰǹڽ֮ǷдȨڽ̻ʡͨзһ
˵Ľ̼ʹȥͬʱҲϳһ̻ʡһ̻ʷУ̻ĻڣҲ
Ի̶֮ͨԾӵؿӶ½̻ʵķ̻ʾܲӣʵ۱ԶԱǿλ
ΪʵۿͨᰲȫȨԼʵʩ巣ֶֹǳĽ̻ʡ˵̻ʺͻʵ۶ܶԶԷȡжΪǶ
ĹϽȨеһǾϽȨһʹϽȨ[4](P210)
    ǿԼҰУһҪĸǣ񾿾ָ˭ȴ
    ġ̻ƲײƲвͬʣ̡ͳ߶ǲƲߡ
    ڽ̻ǷжײƲȨʱֶĹ۵㣺ֶʽĹ۵ϣʽĹ۵㡣ǰΪְԱ
ӦӵײƲΪʿǵڽȨʹԼӵķʽȫƲȨԼΪֹ۵㶼ʧ֮ƫģ
ִ֮䡣Ϊ̻ԺϷӵвƲȴΪͳ߾ͳײƲȨ˵̻Ϸ
˹ȨǵĲƲнڵľԼΪԽ̻ЩƲȨڡ̻ʲ
ڲƲߣֻǴ̹֮ͬйܹܼҡڣȨΪӵԼĲƲ̻ʲȨ
ֲƲ漰ڲƲʱ׹ְܲԷٵݴ׶ѡΪڵײƲڹͬ壬
ÿһ˶ԼƲˣΪǶͨԼƲġ[3](P411-412)ѲƲԴͶϵ
ѲƲȨĺϷͶϵǰѽ̻ĲƲϵ۵ֱѽ̻ĲƲڵĸ˲Ʋֿǿ
ƲĺϷȨдǱμǣڵڲƲû̻ĲƲ˹ͬ壬˵ЩƲͨ
ԼͶõģĸֲƲӵȨȨ֧Ȩÿһ˶԰Ϊʵķʽ
˵ǰ£šá䡢ռлԼĶΪЩˡ[3](P415)
    ȻҲδ˶Ը̶ָżΣΪڲƲĴڣ˴۶˵Ĳ
ʱǳڶԼĹְڹҵҪķʽȥ˷Ʋʱ򣬹ͬƽͻ⵽ƻˣ
ָһͳһٵЩͳΣжǷǣͷߣݹıͼȶĹͬҪ
ÿȡ[3](P415-416)
    ѿǲƲߣƲȨŴչ״̬ʱϵĲƲɹԿ
ᾭɹ۵ǣƲɲǾԵġһ˶ƲĴñԲ˵Ϊǰ᣻˶Ʋ
Ĵñ͹档ڽ̻ƲĹϵд̻ʲʦͷĿͽͷĿΪһ
ԭڼ֮ʱ£ͽһвƲӦùйʹǽ̻ʥ͵ĸƱΪһ͵µָܵߣ
̻ȨڵڽйĹͬҪ֮Ҫ󣬾ЩӦи̻飬ͻᱻͽɧ
[3](P416)
    Զ׼Լ̻ʶڵڲƲҲȨġѽ̻ʵȨ޶һķΧ֮ڡһֳڡ
֮ҪҪ󡱱ʮԣʮһ˰߲ÿλȡһĲ޷һҪձ밴
ıУڵĸ⣬̻̻ƲĹϵҲ֮Ĺϵһܼ֡ҡйܲƲ֮
Ĺϵ̻ƲȨ̻ᡣϽ̻Ǵڽ̻ڽ̻֮ϵġ
    塢ӦжȨ
    Լ׷ġ̡սĿľΪڵĺԽ֤һνʿµ
Ϊ׹Ҷڽ̻Ŀƽ˳ֵ֤һʷѧͷѧķͨԡʿ񡱽зˡȨ
ߵһҪ⡣Լָ̻ʴӻȡþ֮Ȩ֮Ȩ۵ʿձȨ˽̻ʵ۵㲻
ϣȻΪһ鹹ģǣȴΪһֱˡһ뷨޹ءѷ
һ񡱵ķΧڣӷϽЧġǾ˵ľʿ۹Լս˽̻˹(Sylvester)Ϊ
һ񡱣̻ʱľʵһķΪһ˵ʷѧҵһ񡱵
ϡʿƽ̻ʵĳһʿһЩʡݣвΪ̻ʶԷӵϵȨ
ṩɣһһָһûаڵʿշѧҵһΪԭЧ
ģʹһЧģ䷨Чܸ۹ǣδ۹ͳ֮£˼ʹһ
ʵϷҲ뷨޹ء[1](P432-433)
    ĪָԼΪһ˼ңһθ˼͡˵ԼԴڡʥıչ۵ĸᡣ
ƣΪ߼۵֤ݡ[5](P91)У˽̻˼ҹõġ˵˵ĳ´ĵʷѧͷ
ѧΪ˽̻ձȨţΪΪһӵжȨĹҵγ࿪
οס
    [1]Carlyle R W,Carlyle A J.A History of Medieval Political Theory in the West(6vols)[M].Edinburg and London:W.blackwood
 and Sons,1903.
    [2]Joseph Canning:A History of Medieval political Thought 300-1450[M].Routeledge,London,1996.
    [3]Ralph Lerner,Muhsin Mahdi.Medieval Political Philosophy:A Sourcebook[M].The Free Press of Clencoe Collier-Macmillan 
Limited,Canada,1963.
    [4]Brian Tiemey.The Crisis of Church & State 1050-1300[M].Prentice-Hall,NC Englewood Cliffs,N J.1964.
    [5]John B Morrall:Political Thought in Medieval Times [M].HarperTorchbooks,the Academy Library.Harper and Brothers,New 
York,1962.
    [6]Walter Ullmann.Medieval Political Thought[M].Penguinbooks,1979.
    [7]H Burns.The Cambridge History of Medieval Political Thought C350-1450[M].Cambridge University Press,1998.
 
