 ׺ 3-1585
ԭĳ㽭ѧѧư
ԭ
ԭںš200104
ԭҳš513
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš200105
    ˼˼ĺڸԴ
    
߼顿(1967-)У㽭ͩˡ㽭ѧѧԺϵڣѧʿҪѧѧȷĽ
ѧо㽭ѧϵ㽭ݡ310027
Ҫ˼˼ֱԴǺڸ塣ڸѧв˼˼뷢չת۵㣬ȫ˼뷢չ
ת۵㣬Уڸѧ˼˼γɾҪ塣
  ʡ˼/ڸ/˼
    
    ˼˹˵ǵĹѧ˵Ϊ̳˿˼ʥšҶŷĵѧ˵еһ
Ϊ̳˵¹ŵѧҿ¡ϣغͺڸѧ˵еʣ塢¹ŵѧԼɺڸѧϵ
Ӣŵξѧڹ˼˼оУӦԳֵӡ
    ǣ˼˹󣬵ڶʵҪۼǶ˼Ϊþۣеó˸νۡ
һȻܶ࣬ڶۼҶԵ¹ŵѧرǺڸ֤ĺӣҪһĻ˵Լӽ
ĶǺڸ˹̹˵˼Ͷ˹شףǽڸı֤ģڲġڴ
ϣ뾭þ۵ĶֻԵ塣˼ΪþۣǵĹֻ߽ͬΪ
˼Ҫԡ䡱ѣעԴ˸ΪϸĿ죬οˡġֵѧۡ㽭
1997棩3¡
    Ϊһ2020ֵġ˼塱âָǾþۡ벮˹̹Կµĵ֮ѧ˼
岻ͬ˼塱Ϊ˼ĺڸŲΪӱ֤˼롢˼롣ǣڡ˼塱
ڸ֤ڶʵ˼壬˼ڸ֮Ľޡ֤ǿ˶־ǿ˼
дһĹ˵ѧ塣2060ְ˼˵廯ﵽȫʢ׶ʱ
˼塱ڲ֮ġ˵塱򣬹ˡ˼塱еĿѧɱ𡣡ѧ˼塱ܾ
˼ڸ֮˼ϵĴﰢΪ˼ܺڸѧӰʱǡǰڰʱڡֶ塢
Ϊ˼ġѧ֤ʱ֤ڸı֤ġ˼˼ԣֶǿ¬
Դ˼¬֮仭˵Ⱥš
    ͬʱҲһЩѧ߿ʼעϣ۴ͳ֮˼˼塣ȡΪ˼Ĺ롰
ŵǰҵκ״κ״ǰͼʿµľģʽǵĴͳƾĻ
[1]Ϊڸ˼Ȼʿ۴ͳ[2]
    Ϊ˼оеĲϡ񶨡֮񶨡չ˼оƶ˼о
ǣ˼˼ʵԴȻһҪ濼ش⡣˼˼뷢չڸԴ˵˼
¬֮䡢ϣ۴ͳ֮Ĺϵרۡ
    һʶ˼ڸѶ͹֮˼ϵ
    ֪˼ѧڸѧ֮żΪҪĹϵǣֹϵʵںͬŲͬܲͬ
Ľ͡ҹ۽磬ռͳελĽģʽʼкŵΪڸ˼ӰҪͨ߼ѧҲ
ͨȻѧģڷѶ͹ý飬˼صһΨϣӶڸΨ廮˽ޣڴ˻ϣ
˼еظ˺ڸı֤Ӷ˱֤Ψ壬ѱ֤Ψƹ㵽ʷͲʷΨ塣
    ɴ˳˼ѧǱƬΪֻȻԵȻѧǱΪֻķ֤˶߼ѧֽģʽ
ڵ⣬20Ͷʮ˼ָ塢ͱʼǵ½棬ǶԺڸ˼˼о룬汩¶
ڡʶ˼ѧڸѧĹϵһУģʽγɼڵ꾡ķ·ֵ˼
ǶԺڸ˼оɹ϶˼ҪӰĺڸǡѧ͡ѧԭҲ
˼ʼչעʷʵ⣬ˣʷΨŹ˼ѧĻĺͳ㣨עο𣺡ʶ˼
ѧڸѧĹϵѧо19953ڡɲοġʷΨĸйѧ19956ڡ
˼˼뷢չУ18431844꣬ȷе˵Ǵӡ𱨡³ʿ⵽·ʱڣʮҪ
ĵλڴ֮ǰ˼˼ϿǴںڸӰ֮µġڵʱڸУ˼ӽڴѧлı
Ǻٴе¬ְֱ˼ıȡְһµ˼ŷſ⣬תʵġ
˵184212¼Ϊ¬ġ¹ִѧ۽ļдġ³ʿ鱨һ˵Ļ
ôúڡ𱨡ڼ䣬˼ѿʼֱӲμζ184235գ˼ڸ¬һ˵׼дһƪ¶ڸѧ
ìܵ£һеĶԺڸѧԭ𣬵ʱͼ¶ڸڷرھ巽
ķѧ˵֤֮ì[3]ڡ𱨡ڼ䣬˼ʶҲĳ˽˵ġȼ֮ϵ
ձĶ³ʿҽ͵˰˽Ƶжˮƽ˼ȻΪжûаԼж[4]
˼ʼӽʶΪڸͬײǵΪĳֿ͹أ˵һЩϵЩϵ˽˺͸Ȩ
ߵжҾһزΪתơ[5]˼δȷ˵Щϵʡϣ˼Ҳֻǽ
ʲ׼׼棬רƶ
    ǣ롶𱨡⣨18433£һ꣬˼һΨߡתΪһΨߺ͹ߡ
18442³ġ·Ϸƪ¡̫⡷͡ڸѧСԡѾ˹
޲׼ʷʹѧ˵
    Ͳ⣺ԾģرǣԾĺ徿ʲôһֳɵĽǣ˼ڡ𱨡Ĺ
ʹԭеΨѧ֧ҡʱѶ͹ˡ̵ıʡָΨȨܷѶ͹Ӱ죬
˼תΨߡڰֱӽӴ˶˼תΪߵĸݡ
    ֽڵԵġȷ𱨡ڼ䡰һҪν淢¡˼˼תһ
˼1859꡶ξѧСԡ˼뷢չʱ˵ġǣһУ˼ûᵽѶ͹
ᵽдĵһǶԺڸѧԷȻָĹϵҵʽһȲܴǱ⣬Ҳܴ
νྫһ㷢չ⣬෴ǸԴʵϵʵϵܺͣڸ18͵Ӣ˺ͷ˵
ΪᡯĽӦõξѧȥѰ󡣡[6]˼ʮعԼ˼뷢չҪ
ɺڸѧоתоͨξѧУﵽΨʷۡﲢһһΨΪνѶ͹
Ľ׶Ρʵϣ˼δصѶ͹ԳȻͳΪǰΨȥ
    ѧתˣתأǻû㹻Ĳϱ˼ԢӰ£˼184310
빤֯ϵǵ̫⡷͡ڸѧСԡƪдɵʱ䲻18441£ô
ڰֱӽӴ˶һ˼תǲֵġˣ˼˼ת۵㣬ȡڶԴӡ𱨡
⵽·һʱڵ˼˼ĸΪֵо
    18433£𱨡⣬˼̨˻鷿˼֮ԡǳ⡱˻鷿Ϊԭеĺڸѧ
ãҪŪҵıʼĹϵ⡣һ鷿Ľָ塶ڸѧСͷڡ·ϵ
¡
    ⲿָڣرӦ˼ⲿָеóĽۣео߶ǿ˼ָн
Ѷ͹ΨԺڸΨеĵߵֶΪ˼ĺڸѧУ٤Զԡ𡱣һ
λҮսͽѧʽѧңУ˼ﵽǡ֤ʵģ٤ʽģ[7]άΪ˼
ĺڸѧУǡͼѷѶ͹õķΨ巽עӦѧ[8](R.N.Hunt)
˼˹˼롷ظ˰άĹ۵[9]ͤ(K.-H.Ilting)Ϊ˼Уͨաѧ
ע֤ʵѶ͹ԺڸУ˼һֱ˺ڸԸ˼켣ңûڸıΪ
ҪЩֵ˼[10]
    ͤĿô˼УǽѶ͹Ψ˺ڸΨ壬˼Ѷ͹֮
ġͬڸ֮ġ족ǵĿ෴˼УֳѶ͹ġ족ֳ˼ĺڸ
Դʣ˼˻鷿еʱ򣬷Ѷ͹ӰǴڵġ18432£˼յڳġļ
ļ´ǹȥʱڵĶʱĶҪǷ³ʿҵķԱĵ·Щڴʱ
˼˵Ѻ塣ļΩзѶ͹ġѧʱҪһµġ˼Դ˲ǿҵĹյ
ļ¬Ļţ1843313գ˵Ѷ͹ľֻһ㲻ʹ⣬ǣǿȻٵǿ
[11]˹ΪѶ͹˼˼뷢չӰ죬Ǵ1841ͳ˵ķѶ͹̵ıʡһ鿪ʼ[12]÷
ȷָǶ˹ġд[13]𱨡ʱڵ˼ûгΪѶ͹ɣڡڽ̵һ㱾ʡϣ
ǡǡѶ͹żҵ[12]˼̵̡ıʡڶڶԵʱ򣬲Ѿ184310µˡ֮
Ѷ͹Ӱ˼еĿˡ
    ôѶ͹˼Ӱ쾿ʲô˼¬ţǸͼ{ͼ}ǵĽǣ˼ĲڣѶ
͹̸ԭҲ⣬ԷѶ͹ԭسϵġ[14]˼ĹǶԺڸѧ
ȫУôĽǿԳġڣ˼չǺڸѧУԺڸı֤ѧ
ҪڳһԺġָ塷вŽУһɣ־ʶ̬ǡǡԶ˼ѧѶ͹ѧĹͬΪ־
ġ֮˼˼뷢չת۵ǡǡ˼Ѷ͹ĵط˵ǷѶ͹ΨǸ򡣶˼
ûгΪʷΨǰΨߡ
    ˣԸǿ˼ԭеķѧʵ֮ĳͻǲ˼˼뷢չת۵߼Ѷ͹
ڣ˼Ժڸѧյʡʱ򣬷Ѷ͹ͨʾڽ̵ıʲ˵ıʵ컯ŴӽȻ֮ϲ
ʶ˳ѧһٴݻ˺ڸѧڸѧƲѶ͹컯˱ѧ˵ʹ˼˸
ϵĹԣ18431844꣬˼жν˷Ѷ͹νʵĵߵڡ컯˱ȵȡǣ
ڽЩʱ֮˼Ȼõ֡Ѷ͹˱ʼԳΪģ˼Ǵӷѧ
Ұмӹҡ̽˵⣻Ѷ͹ڽ̵ķΧ컯⣬˼ͨξѧУעе컯
ϣӶѧתʱԿ죻ȵȡɼ˼ԺڸѧнΪѶ͹Ψ
ġӦá֤ʵһֹڼ򵥻ʶѶ͹ѧ˼ӰһʼǷǱʵġʵϣ˼ԺڸΨ
ʷΨߵȿ˷ֱ˺ڸѧĽ֮Ժڸѧм̳У˼˼
ȫ˼뷢չת۵㡣
    ڸѧУ˼˼뷢չת۵
    ˼1843괺ڿ޴ɺվסڼдָ塶ڸѧСǶԺڸѧԭҡһе25731
3ڵоǰҳʧǽ쿴ָǴе261ڿʼġͨһУǰ˼óˡǹҺͷ
ᣬҺͷĽۡһָۣģ
    ˶壬ͥԹҵʵϵеڲʵϣͥǹҵǰ
ǲĻߣ˼˼άȴһͷ㵹á[15]
    Ͽ˼ʡ壩νʡߵԷѶ͹˼һУȫ
ͬˣ˼ͣڽʾںڸŵνʵĵߵѶ͹˼ͼһߵʵݣ
ϵʷʽȵȡָУдڱƲȵȣ͹ҵȫݣͬ³ʿȫһֻи
ѡԣĹͬľһֻһֹʽҵݶڹƶȵЩʽĽ⡣ԣʷ
Ҫʹιҷʵ硣[15]Ϊһʷ죬˼ָƶȱֻ˽ﵽڵĵطܷչ
ҵ͵زɡûдﵽڵĵطҲͲƶȡ[15]
    кڸѧռдʵʵʷϵҪ˼׫дָ塶ڸѧСͬʱشʷо
ڶ̶̵ʱУ˼д˺屾ʼǣайعҵۺʷйӢ¹
䡢ʷйطʷרժ¼˼һоǵӡڹ⣬ѧA
ֵǺAڴ30ͷ˵һרоս󣬷ѧ߿ƶŦġ˼Է޲˹Ӷ̬
18431845꣩һģҪӰ졣˼ʷѧJ1966귢ĳƪġ˼˼
ɡУ۶ϣ˼ܹо1789ʷ顪ΰʷ飬˼Դ֮һ[
16]ҹ֥ˡ˼뷨һ⡣Ϊ˼дڸѧСͬʱеĹ㷺
ʷо˼ɶԺڸѧе֤
    ˼ڶ˷ڡʷ־ϡ۷ĸ١һĺд·ʮͳʱǹ׼ܷնĹ£
·סִʱܷ׼ĹնȨ֮ǿԷ֣ʱɱʣʱʣȡߣ
ǹеĸҲӸ߷˵ˡ취ɣɵľµľܷҲȫ
ˡɵҲӼ̳ǹҵķɡϣгӼ̳ƵķɡˣڸѹҹҪرΪʣ
ҴڵľʽΪʣʷʵǡ෴ҹʼնǹҴڵЩ۾ɣʽıʡ[17]
    ֿڵĻǲѷ֣ʾڸѧνʵĵߵ˼ǡʷʵɼ˼÷Ѷ͹
ȴڿҷչʷĻϵó۵ġ
    ͬأ˼ʵ֤Ҳ׷ݵڿ޴ɺʱڵʷоͨʷ飬˼Ѿʶ
ڵÿһȼÿһ׼ֳǻʡũūԷ⽨ѹȵĶ˼ժ¼˲پϸڣ
ǶɺΤũ˶Ϊָ͵Ľ׼ڽɫʺа˵ʽȡó׵Ľšʲ׼Ľ
ԣ˼Ϊע⡣ڱʼУǿԷ˼Է1791ꡢ1793ꡢ1795ܷ1814ꡢ1830йĵϸժ¼
̫⡷дЩϡ˼˵Ȼǣҵһܷϡձ־Ľ׼˼һ
Ϊڡԡж޲׼ʷõ֤ṩһҪ޲׼Ҫ˽вƲҪ״
ձ黯
    ޲׼ΪֹƶȵĽ壬ֻǽʾԼĴڵܣΪƶȵʵʽ塣޲׼Ҫ
˽вƲֻǰѾΪ޲׼ԭĶδ޲׼ЭΪķ񶨽ϵĶΪ
ԭ[18]
    һ˼ͨʷΨĵ·سǵǰ·ǣ˼ͨڸѧУ
óˡǹҺͷᣬҺͷĽۣڶгоĻϣθ
ŵ޶ȣ˽вͣٵĸʵŵĿ꣬ҵ޲׼Ϊ˷˵컯״̬Ҳ
ŵĵߡ1845괺˼ڡڷѶ͹١дΨŵᣬΨŵ
ࡣ[19]νŵ˼ԡᡱΪΨŵ㣬ȷʵ
ΪʷΨ͹ѧ˵Ĺͬ⡣ڿ޴ĺʱںڰͨڸѧоȷ˵ġ
    һ˵˼ͨڸѧжʵֵ˼תۻڣһдʹ˼ʼоξѧӾõĽǶ
ᡣ˼ڷѧѧﵽĸ߶ȡȣĳ̶ֳҲζŷѧѧ޶ȡ֪ڸ
ȡõĳɾͣʱڼѿʼľѧоֲġΪˣάָڸԼȫ
ѧԽϽξѧҪԭѧϵ֮Ϊǰġ[20]¬Ҳ˵ڸǡΩһĵ¹˼ңоӢ
ҵ⣻Ωһĵ¹˼ңӢŵ侭ѧѧ⡢֤ϵ[21]ڣ˼Ѿó
ҺͷĽۣǣеľѧ֪ʶԶоѧķȻѾŻʵ˽вƲ
˵Ż˹ңʹҳά˽вƲĻִҵ˽вƲ˼δȷʶȻѾ
׼ŵĵߣ簢άָ޲׼ںڸձȼʹõģңڸԵ
ľõġεĹ涨˼ε屻ȫˡȻѾڡУιҾʧˡ[15]
һδķʽѧ֮ϣȡСˡеġѡȨֻһ
ѧǾѧѧˣҪʹ˵Ľž廯α޲׼ľù涨ľ
Ŀѧξѧʹ˼ʶĽӦõξѧȥѰ[6]ǣ˼
ڰʱڵһοʼξѧֱξѧǶȷἴʲ׼ᣬһֱ˼Ĺ
    ڸѧ˼
    ָ˼ͨʷΨĵ·ϣڸѧҪ塣˼кڸѧΪ־ʵֵ˼
תۣ뿪˺ڸѧضͳǲġ˼ĺڸѧУǡǡʾѧ˵ĺڸԴĳ
̶ϣ˼ͼʵֺڸѧеĻ롣ֻͨڸϵĳ׾Ѳϸ۷Ѷ͹һеӰ
İάϣһڸ崫ͳĳ׾ѣҲֻںڸ崫ͳﾳвܵõ⡱[8]
    ڡڸѧСԡУ˼߶˺ڸѧ˵¹ķѧ͹ѧΩһʽĵʵ
ͬˮƽϵĵ¹ʷ[18]¹Ĺѧͷѧںڸеõϵͳḻյı[18]Ժڸķѧ
УҪı˼ķѧġʵȻǱ˰硱״ѵ¹ߵӱ˰ִġʽˮ׼ҳԽ
һˮ׼ߵЩĽҪﵽ˵ĸ߶ȵĸ[18]ɼӵĸмͬӵɵķŭ
˶߹ͬķŭĺڸѧ˼˼Ŀ˷ǡеؿ˷ѧںڸѾﵽĸ߶
ļչͤ˼ûڸָǲܳġ
    ˼ڸķѧѧڹͬģʽģʽ19ͳڸͨӵȻȨΪʵԾ
ԼṩܺͳԽ͵ѧУԼͨʹѧõش¼
̷ȫ1718ŷѧŲʵһ׵ѧڴ˻ϣڸؽۣΪ
ļߣעμˡ۵ؽڸѧӰ졷ڶ£Ϻѧֳ2000档
һ˼Ϊʽĵʵͬˮƽı֡ڸĹ۵˷˳ȨµĹ۵㣬Ӷ
ΪۻѧҪд
    塱ԭԭ򣬼Ը˵־Ϊ飬Կָ֣֯עΪһӦôӸ
ȷȨӦȡøȷͬ⡣עμڸʷѧӡ1963棬498ҳиĶ
    ڸһУ˼ǿҵĹ˼һд˵ıʲǵеĳʵϣ
һϵܺ͡[19]Խǰ׷ʷˣӶҲǽĸˣԽΪһϴ塭ֻ
18ͣڡᡯУϵĸʽԸ˵űΪֻǴﵽ˽ĿֶΣűΪڵıȻԡǣ
ֹ˵Ĺ۵ʱǾΪֹϵֹ۵㿴һϵʱʵζһ
ֺȺĶֻвܶĶ[22]
    رֵһǣڸУڼͥҡ̶ܴ൱ʿµġͥ(oikos)͡ǰ(polis)
֮롰ᡱȱڸʵɸǶԹϣ˼ļ򵥻ظȻҪһط
ͶϵԼɵҪһ֮С[23]ֱ˺ڸۼΪԭġ
ᡱһԸ
    ᡱ(civil society)һƾʷͷḻ纭׷ݵϣʿ¡
ᡱ(koinnia politik )һָһ֡ǰ(polis)ڹԪ1ͽתΪsocietas civilisָһ
ңҲָҵѷﵽֳеιͬ״ЩͬԼķ䣨񷨣һ̶ȵǺͶԣҰ
ǰĻᣩԼ͡ҵ¡[24]ڽӢ
˼ǹ㷺ʹáᡱһʣ亭ָȻ״̬ԵңָԵʵᡣһֱ
¡˼ңر¬ӰĿ£ԣˣȨ͹ȨĹ˵Ȼ״̬״̬ĹɣȻ״̬
ǸȨ״̬״̬ɿǹȨ״̬˵ȨÿԼÿ˵֮ЭһΪ
ÿ˵ɣֻҪһձķǿܵģȨʹһֳ׵Эһ³Ϊܵⲿܺ͡[25]
һַɵ壬ǡͨҵĺеᡱɼڿȻͬڹң
ұ뻯ˡ
    ڸ˼ʷϵһζԹȷ֣ԹҵĹ۵ʾĳԡнԡͨһ֣
ʾ˽޶ȡѸҵĹϵΪԼϵĿһֶιϵںڸ
νĹҲᣬԶδҵʵڸָЩ۵㶼ǳģ԰ĸֹ涨ᵽ
ԽΪӶչ˶ȫ˼С
    ˼˼ԺڸʵֵĽ۵ȫתΪġȷ֣˼ڸ˼
Ĺͬ˼1843ָд
    ڸķ뿴һìܣ̵ĵطǣֻӱϽìܣֱ
ıʡ[15]
    ξиԵ˼ѳ׷ʵĽʾ˽вƲУڲͬں
˷ķȵȣںڸѧġﾳеձݡнеģע˼Թ
ۡкڸ壬ڹĿ꣬ĳ̶ֳǺڸձԵݡ
    ˣڵ¹ʷչڸѧӢʷΪģӢۡʷ¼
Ǵ̽¹ʵġʹ˶ԣ˼кڸѧͬʱеʷоԼϵʷ϶еĽ
оͬڸѧġﾳֵָǣ˼ʱ˼¹ʲ׼ոտʼͬԼĽ׼
壩жʱ;ͬԼĽ׼޲׼Ķ[18]֮£ڸ̷Ϊ¸
ڸѸΪѧԭΪһѧѧΪѧ˷[26]ˣ˼ģڸϣ͵
ȼƶȣҪִȨ壻ϣִȨҪ͵ȼƶȵ¡[15]ڸѧСץס
ġ˼ͨԷоڷθĽԺͻͬʱҲؾޣڷ
ľп˽һչıҪܡ˼ѧˡδȡʫ顱޲׼ǿѧ
Ӻڸ˼ķչ
    ɴˣǿԵóۡڸͨʵֵĶʷġʱۺϣ˽һȫµתۡǣ¹
ʷչųˡʲ׼ѧǰչĿԡ¹ʲ׼ų˿Եĺڸѧķչڵ¹
޲׼õʵ֡˹ָģ¹Ĺ˶ǵ¹ŵѧļ̳ߡ[27]Ҳдڸѧʷ̳
ﲢûбЩڸѧҡȲҲɣϮڸѧ˼ɲ̳зչȥ
[28]˼ͨкڸѧķʽ̳зչ
οס
    [1]Hannah Arendt.Between Past and Future[M].New York:Viking,1968.19.
    [2]David J.Depew.The Polis Transfigured:Aristotle's Politics and Marx's Critique of Hegel's "Philosophy of Right"[A].Marx
 and Aristotle,ed[C].GeorgeE.McCarthy.Rowman & Littlefield Publishers,1992.37-74.
    [3]¹˹ءƶŦ˼˹1[M]꣬1980509
    [4]˼ʡıۣƪ[A]˼˹˼˹ȫ1[C]磬1956155

    [5]˼Ħߵı绤[A]˼˹˼˹ȫ1[C]磬1956216
    [6]˼ξѧС[A]˼˹˼˹ѡ2[C]磬199532
    [7]ֶ壮¬˼[M]죺磬1993158-160
    [8]S.Avineri.The Hegelian Origins of Marx's Political Thought[J].in Karl Marx's Social and Political Thought:Critical Ass
essments,1990,(1):157.
    [9]R.N.Hunt.The Political Ideas of Marx and Engles:Vol.I[M].University of Pittsburgh Press,1974.56-59.
    [10]K.-H.Ilting.Hegel's Concept of the State and Marx's early Critique[A].The State and Civil Society:Studies in Hegel's 
Political Pliosophy(Z.A.Pelczynski ed.)[C].Cambridge University Press,1984.104.
    [11]˼˼˹ȫ27[Z]磬1972442-443,424
    [12]˹·άϣѶ͹͵¹ŵѧս[A]˼˹˼˹ѡ4[C]磬1995
222
    [13]÷֣˼Ͼ[M]磬197272
    [14]ǣٵǣ˼˼[M]ʵ磬198849
    [15]˼ڸѧ[A]˼˹˼˹ȫ1[C]磬1956250-251,283-284,282,
338,364
    [16]Ī1843-1844˼ʷоΨʷγɵԴ֮һ[A]ϣ15[C]磬
1981
    [17]˼޴ɺձʼǣ4[A]ϣ11[C]磬198036
    [18]˼ڸѧС[A]˼˹ѡ1[C]磬199515,7,8,9,14
    [19]˼ڷѶ͹[A]˼˹ѡ1[C]磬199557,60
    [20]Avineri.The Dialectics of Civil Society in Hegel's Thought[A].Hegel on Economics and Freedom[C].Mercer University Pre
ss,1987.95.
    [21]¬森ڸ[M]ӡݣ196323
    [22]˼1857-1858꾭ѧָ[A]˼˹ȫ30[C]磬199525
    [23]L.P.Hinchman.Hegel's Critique of the Enlightenment[M].Tampa:University of south Florida Press,1984.219.
    [24]άѧٿȫ[Z]йѧ磬1992125-126
    [25]£ʷļ[M]ӡݣ1990181-182
    [26]J.Habermas.Hegel's Critique of the French Revolution[J].in Theory and Practice.1973,121.
    [27]˹˼˹ѡ4[C]磬1995257-258
    [28][M]죺磬1993230
 
