 ׺ 3-1595
ԭĳѧư
ԭ
ԭںš200103
ԭҳš107113
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš200105
    ƶѧ
ע͡ڱ׫дĹУŲѧԼ¶ɭ(Johan P.Olsen)ڡѧ˹ƿ˲(Theda Skocpol)ں͸
˵˹(B.Guy Peters)ṩйƶѧĲϣл
    
߼顿(1972- )Уˣѧʹϵ빫ѧԺѧʿݴѧϵʦҪѧ
оѧʹϵ빫ѧԺϺ200433
ҪƶΪϷչġǷ԰ѸΪΪѧоģƶеá
ƶڲֻʷƶ塢ѡƶѧƶ塣
  ʡƶ/ƶ/Ϊ/ѧ
    
    ʲ׼θĿǽһӦгúηչƶȣԵʱѧע塣˵ϵ˹
ٵпάѹҵƶΪо⡣ʲ׼ɣʱ̴ƶȵܹƶȲ
ȶķչʱڣѧעĿʼƶתƵеìܺͶѲǼڽƶϣǲ
ʲôĹߡ̵ʱ205060Ϊ𽥳ΪѧۡǶʽƶȡɹ淶
ӣûйעʵΪоȥΪͳѧһҪȱݡΪ峫οѧоΪΪģ
עضԸоעضĶоƶȿʼųѧо֮⡣
    2080Ϊڽ˽30Ծ޷ʵΰѧܵѧͬǶƶоȡ
õľ޴ɾ͵Ĺ裬ѧҿʼٶȹעƶȣƶ˵ѧҰʼʿµĴƶоĴͳ
ڴʱ۸߶ȣγһɡƶ(neoinstitutionalism,new institutionalism)հķ˹(James G.
March)Լ¶ɭ(Johan P.Olsen)1984ġοѧۡϷƶ壺е֯ءһģҿƶ
ѧоĻپ20ķչΪһɵƶ졣еѧ߰ƶڵѧչΪһ
ƿ˵ġʽеѧ˵ڶƶˡ
    ƶڵ𣬲ѧߴӲͬӽǶƶȽȫλоƶȵĺ塢ɡԴǨΪƶȵĹ
ϵƶĻĹϵ⣩һƶõ߷ȽѧʹϵԼŷһ廯
Сӵοѧ־ǵѧƶѾΪοѧһȵ㡣
    һƶ֪ʶ
    ƶΪҪ档ǶΪƫü跢ʡΪ߶ԣġƫòֱ
ӡͨһ˵ΪܽʾƶΪġƫú͡ġƫֵ֮ġΣΪ
ΪǸΪľۼƫþЧۼܴЧƶ߶ԾۼıʣΪ
߲ǽڸƫü۵ĻϣǾ߹ֱӰ쵽κ߲ܻͬԭΪƫáָѡƫ
͹֮Ĺϵϣߵγɲѡƫõľۼͨƶġ
    Ϊʹ뵽Ϊ۵ġںˡͰ¶ɭ˶ΪӰµοѧ۽С㡱ڡƶ
壺е֯ءһУָͬг̡иɫ֯һʽ֯
ƶȵҲ򡣵Ϊ¡лص֯ȴˡΪοѧҪУ
龰壨忴һ֣ҾֿܾԼ壨ѺǸΪĻ㼯
壨ӶԴľߵӽΣΧƷšʽ巢չϵã壨ΪԴ
ƣԴκ񣩣ǹ壨ʷһΪΨһĺʾЧʷЧʵ
һ棩
    Ͱ¶ɭڰΪӰµοѧ۵ġںˡı׶˽ʾĻϣáƶ塱۵
ǿƶȾǿʷ̵ĸԺʷЧص㣻ǿжΪλ
һҪļжߣֻļ򵥵ķӳֱӰ쵽λĽ֡
    ƶ߾ܾΪۣԼΪӰµĶԪۣıۣ塢ṹ壬70
չκۡ硰عѧɡ(bringing thestate back in)֯(group theory)ѧϰ(learningtheory)
Ż(symbolic interaction theory)ͱȽѧеηչۡ
    ƶѧ߹עһԭǾѧѧѧ2070߶ƶоΪͻƶ
徭ѧȡõĳɹǲŵѧ٣ҳΪѧ֮һЩɹοѧо߰ƶ
ҰСѧооע⵽ž޴Ĳ죬ڽۿʱǴƶȾѧн
ͷۣƶȵĺ塢ƶȱǨ·巽۵ȡѧƼ佻ǵѧչ֮һ
ƶȷʽҲŬǹƶѧһԴ
    ƶ֣ѧвһµôΪֱԼǡƶ塱أƶкϵأƶ
Ϊս֮ǰƶоҪ̫νṹɿܺͳȣעԣþ̬۹⿴ƶȶƶȵ
̡̬ѧ櫡(Julia Black)ΪƶͼƶעƶеúΪעΪ
߽ƶġ¡ڼȹעƶеãΪĶ̡̬оƶ
ѧĻص㡣
    ƶҪɼ·չ
    ΪƶЩԴڲҲɡֻڶѧ߶ʶһ֡ƶ塱Ƕ֡
ΪѧߴõķǱ˵á(Peter A.Hall)˹C.R̩(Rosemary C.R.Taylor)1996Ӣо
Ϸġοѧƶ塷һѡƶ塱Ϊʷƶ塱(historical institutionalism)ѡ
塱(rational choice institutionalism)͡ѧƶ塱(sociological institutionalism)޴⻹еİƶ򵥵ط
Ϊࣺѡƶѧƶ塣
    ʷƶҪе˽ṹһЩ۵㣬˱Ƚѧйηչ֮ۡԡʷΪһѧΪ
ʷǿ˷ԣԣֶΡĿĵƣԵһҪ;֮ǡƶ塱ΪעƶΪ
ʷԹҡƶΪʷ˹ƿ˲ġҺ䷶ʷƶΪƶ֯ṹ
ξеʽʽĳ򡢹淶ȣǰܷ򡢹ű׼ִгȣƶȱһж塣˼ڡ
عҡһΪұһжߣҾԺ(the autonomy and capacity of states)ʷƶ
ҪǷԶԪۣжԪֵĸƫþתƿͨ塢ʽ뵽ιеĹ
㡣ΪжߡƶȶԼʷıܷƶȡҽṹȹι̡ǹע
ǲͬڲͬʱڣҡκ֮Ĺϵ(corporatism)ͻعѧҪ۴ʷƶķչ
Ҫв˹(CharlesTilly)ѧʷչǡѧʷ˹ƿ˲ѧоΪ
תΪģУʷѧеͷ͡
    ѡƶҪ¹ŵ侭ѧйءˡļƶ徭ѧйƶھõۣҪ
вȨѰͽ׳ɱۡѡƶرӰУɭ(williamson)ض֯ʽŬٽ׳
Ľŵ˼ƶȷչۣ׶ķ(paul milgrom)(Pratt)˵ίСۢ⡣ҪԴڶ
ȵоעĹӰ쵽ߵΪҪD.󿨱˹(mathew D.McCubinns)ɳ(TerrySullivean
)ġ᣺ṹߡ˹(Gray Cox)󿨱˹ġά̹ѡƶ߹עУò
ת͡ŷһ廯еƶȸĸʹϵеĹҼ֯˥
    ѧƶ֯۵һ֧ɴϿ׷ݵ2070ͳۣ֯ΤĹۣΪ֯Ϊʵ
ضĿĶģЧ֯һҪԭֶΡĿ߼Ļ֯ȫͬģ߼ض
һ淶ѧƶս֣Ϊִ֯ʹõĹ򡢹淶ضĻһʵ̬ƶȱһ
ƶĻһͬʡѧƶ͵صΪʲô֯һضƶʽţЩ
֯ڴġҪУͰ¶ɭġ·ƶȣε֯J.(Paul J.DiMaggio)ֶW.
(Walter W.Powell)ġ֯еƶ塷ԼW.Ү(John W.Merye)W.R.˹(W.R.Scott)ġ֯ʽ
ȡѧƶעУıȽϡŷ޹ߵĲȡ
    ܣƶ߶ڲֻеѧΪ类ˡΪȻͳһƶ塱Ŀ
£ڲķֻǷӳ˴ӲͬӽоƶȣǷӳƶȱĸԡ¹˹̹δѧѧ߰M.׹(Ellen M.Im
mergut)ƶΪʷƶһ֣ѡۺ֯ǹ۵Ļ[11]ƥȱѧɡ(Simon
 Reich)ڡƶĸףߺһֶԪ۵㡷һУӲͬڲͬĹ߳Ϊƶڲķ
ֻǷӳ˲ͬĹ߶ƶȵ󣬲ֻǷӳƶõͬ[12]ЩͬĹ۵ʶƶ
۵ĸԡ
    ƶ۵
    νƶȡ˽ƶ۵һ㡣ƶѧƶȵѧƶ徭ѧȣȽ
͵ĿУ
    ݡE.S.͸(Sue E.S.Crawford)Ͱŵ˹ķ(Elior Ostrom)ڡƶȵ﷨һаѶƶȵĿΪ֣(1)
һ־⡣ƶԸ໥ƫúѡΪĻϵһֳֽȶ״̬ȶΪʽƶȡ(2)ƶһֹ
Ϊ۲쵽Ļʽǽض£һԡˡ͡ˡͬʶϵġʶֶΡ
Ŀĵķ̶ܴһֹ淶Ե(3)ƶһֹֹ۵㽨Ϊ۲쵽Ļһֹͬ
ѭЩƶȽܵʹЧʡ[13]
    򡪰ˡ(Jan-Erlk Lane)˹ء˹ɣ(SvanteErsson)ڡƶѧЧͽһϸƶȵĺ
ΪӸ忴ƶǹ򣬹ָΪƶԼжʵ󻯣˵ƶǻ֮Լ׳ɱһ
ã˵ƶһѰ(rent--seekingmechanism)˵ȵȡ忴ƶ֯Ȼ֯ΪжĽɫô
ƶȽǹж߻Ĺ淶һжɫΪָĹУֵÿһ
ƶȣڶֵһ塣ԼֶսԵѡ񣬶ֵΪɻһˣǽΪ͹
ƶȻˡҲһ֯ɾԵĶֵɡ
    ƶȸΪȫԱ˵á˹C.R.̩յġοѧƶ塷һģͨѧɵıȽָʷ
ƶƶΪ֯ṹξеʽʽ򡢹淶ͷס䷶ΧǴƲִ
ı׼Ӱ칤Ϊϰߺͷסһԣʷƶƶ֯ʽ֯ڰ䲼Ĺ֯ڴķϵһ
ѡƶƶΪӰ쵽ĹĳΪ˽롰򡰹õر硱֮ļж⡣
ѧƶġƶȡοѧĸΪƶȲʽĹ򡢳淶һϵͳ֪涨͵
ģ壨Щָܹжǰ֯Ļ߼ķںĻΪ֯ӵеһֵֹͬۺ̬ȣ
ΪŻ֪磬Ϊжṩģ壬ṩһܡָΪƷ˴ͳƶȺĻϵķѣ
ĻҲΪһƶȡ
    ½йƶ϶ΪƶȡĺǶֵģڶԡƶȡһĿʶ۵ĽǶȿƶ
ĿҪУ壨ԭۣ塣Ӹ壨ԭۣƶΪƶ֮࣬ԴӸ
Ϊֻ͡иˣĿ׷ϵͳǨԴڸΪƶǸ廥һֽǳս
󻯣ΪƶȡѡƶһֶƶȵʶΪ䲿֮
ӰԼŸΪΪӦôΪһл壨ƶȣֻͣзв塣עԸΪ
õ淶ֵãпƶȡȣӰ쵽Ϊƶڸ壬Ӱ쵽ƫ
õγɺ档忴ƶȵķʽ͵ѧƶ塣
    ӱ۵ĽǶȿƶȿɷΪƶȺƶȡƶȺ澭ݻĹƶƳʽģ
֯ĻʵʩƶȰʷƶѧƶеϰߡϰסĻγɵ֪磬ڻڸ֯жУ
ʵʩɣҪǿִСƶȰѡƶԼʷƶеĸʽ򡢸ָͳԹ
ȣصȨ϶µƳҪʵʩ
    ƶȵԴͷչƶоһҪ⡣
    ԡƶȴӺζ⣬ƶṩִ𰸡һ(functionalism)͡ƶȵҪ֧
ԼŸΪԼŸֻߡΪ˽ƶȵĴƶеĹ֣ƶXĴΪ
Yѡƶ[14]ƶԵж֮ĽһƵĲƶȹ̾
߶ȵĿԺ͹ƶȴĹȻ״̬£ƽȺͶĸ֮ԸеԼǩ
    ·(path dependence)͡տϵͳǨۺƶȾѧйƶȱǨۼ˵ѧѧ߱ޡ
Ƥѷ(Paul Pierson)Ϊ˶ԹƶƽУ׫дˡƵľޣƶȵԵͱǨһģ[15]Ϊ
ֻ˵ǰƶΪʲôܴںͳȥûжƶлش޷ΪʲôдڴЧ
ȡĽҪ¼㲻㡣ƶڹƶȹвǶչжģʱƶ߻Ҫ淶
Ļʶ̬ˡ֯һµƶʽĿƶ֯ĺϷԶЧʡ֮ƶʽض
Ļ¸мֵǷܵģǵЧġͰ¶ɭĻ˵ǡ߼(logic of socialappropriate
ness)ԡ߼(logic of instrumentality)[16]ִ£ƶȵһ޵ƣܹע
ƶȵĳЧʱƣ޷Ԥ⵽ƶڳʱеȫܣҲ޷ʵԤĿġƶȵЧǳ
Ԥ֮ġ߱ԾԼҲܻ᷸ɵġ
    ڴ˻ϣƤѷڡرʵ·ѧоһУ·ƶȵԴͱǨ[17]ڿϵͳ
˶Уϵͳķֲٽϵ΢С䶼ܶϵͳɾ޴仯ۣƶ徭ѧʾƶȱǨ
γһǿ·Ĺ۵㡣Ϊ뾭ͬιȱгǿľƣƶȱǨ
ĶƲѧϰƶȵԸǿҡУԵشŵƶȱƶǱϣѡ
ƶȣ仯ķֲ㡢ٽ㣩ڻرʵ£γǿ·ټƶܼȨȨ
зǶԳԺͲ͸Ժƶά״ĻƶȵıǨȾƶŸǿ·Ƥѷ
仯еķֲ㡢ٽϵƶѡǳӡΪǾƶĹؼ빦Ŀⶨ²ͬ·Ľ
ͰעʷϣΪƶȵıǨһݽĹ̶ƵĲ
    ͨǿԿĽƫڵƶȶ̬УΪƶѰҵݡʵУһ㶼
Ա򡢻ϲְתΪĸһֶΣԵΪǽڹƶȱǨĽͻϵģ·
ƫڶƶʷĽѰҸƶȲͬԭ򡣵Ƚѧƶ֣͸ηչ·ĲͬҲǽ
ֽ˵ϵġ
    ġ
    ƶѧʢгΪοѧһ۵ͷǶΪֵУԭ
ι̣ƶȰеãƶΪͻĳɾܿ͡ɹӰ
µĹ塢Ϊʱʮƶȡʵ塣ǴпάѵطƶΪԿרһ鱤ݡΤ
ԿרϵƶϺ޶˹ѡ֪֮ĻΪĳȡ֡Ϊѧ;

    ǣƶڷչҲһЩ⡣һڲֻɣڶĽ϶Ų㡣ѡƶ
ڸ嶯ϣע⵽жսԻھκеãᾭ÷չȽṹϵĽƶ
һµ򡣵ȴ޷һЩڻĹһں̵ǰΧ˵£ȻؽͨЩԼ޷
дЧʵƶȴڵʵʷƶѹΪһжߺͷĵλΪҾԣԹҺ֮Ĺϵ
ʮҪ壨ȸ̫עغ۹̣޷ʾƶȴͱдڵ֮
Ȩ֮ѧƶдЧʵƶȵĴںнǰĻҲΪһƶȣʹڽʱ
ѽжо൱ģԣѧķչ档ˣƶҪȡ÷չЩɴڵȱݡ
ѧڲһЩϻûдɹʶƶȵĺ塢ƶȵıǨȣ˵ڲϻҪһ̡Ϊһ
ҪһЩϴɹʶΪʧܾ֤
    ƶҪȡ÷չעƶȵƶȡƶڵĲ졣ѧƵĸۺܿܺ
ƶȱѧƵںǽѧƷֻ͸ѧƸ߶ȳϵġѧѧв죬ƶȷʽо
ʱһѧת̡Ƥѷڡرʵ·ѧоһĽһɹתͬʱеƶ
߶ܼƶȹɵĸԺƶȼϵԶƶоһս
    ԵйηչԣƶȽǸĸ￪йηչһҪص㡣Сƽͬ־ͨԡĸķ˼ǿƶȽ
ѧ80ķչһµġνƶۣνйηչʵںϣоƶ
йѧٵ
οס
    [1]Sue E.S.Crawford,Elinor Ostrom,A Grammar Institutions.American Political Science Review.1995,Vol.89,No.3,pp582-596.
    [2]Jan-Erik Lane,Svante Ersson,The New InstitutionalPolitics:Performance and Outcomes,London:Routeledge,2000.
    [3]Chareles Tilly,As Sociology Meets History,New York:Academic Press,1981.
    [4]Theda Skocpol(ed.),Vision and Method in HistoricalSociology,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1984.Statesand Soci
al Revolutions,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1979.
    [5]Peter B.Evans(eds.),Bringing the State Back InCambridge:Cambridge university press,United Kingdom 1985.
    [6]Mathew D.McCubinns,Terry Sullivan(eds),Congress:Structure and Policy(New York NY,Cambridge University Press,1987).
    [7]Gray Cox,Mathew D.McCubinns,Legislative Leviathan (Berkeley CA,University of California Press,1987).
    [8]Paul J.DiMaggio,Walter W.Powell,The NewInstitutionalism in Organizational Analysis Chicogo IL.University of Chicago 
Press(1991).
    [9]B.Guy Peters,Institutional Theory in PoliticalScience:the New Institutionalism,New York:Pinter,1999.
    ١James G.March and Johan P.Olsen,The NewInstitutionalism:Organizational Factors In Political Life.American Political S
cience Review,1984,vol.78,pp734-749.ҲɲμƱȽϡ19955ڣ37-40ҳѡ˲ݡ
    ڡJan-Erik Lane and Svante Ersson (2000),The NewInstitutional Politics,London:Routeledge,pp23.
    ۡMark D.Aspinwall & Cerald Schneider,Same menu,separatetables:The institutionalist turn in political science and thest
udy of European integration.European Journal  of PoliticalResearch 33:1-36,2000.
    ܡѧ־硶οѧۡӢġоŷо־ȿйƶо
ࡣԾѧУհķ˹桢Լ¶ɭ·ƶȣε֯ŦԼɳ1989
˹ķ(Olstrom,E)Ƥ(Scharpf,F.)ѧı˵á(Peter A.Hall)ͱޡƤѷ(Paul Pierson)ҪƶԴ
ͱǨоعѧɡĴء˼(Peter Evans)˹ƿ˲(Theda Skocpol)Լ˵˹B.Guy Pet
ers,οѧеƶۣƶ塷ŦԼƽس磬1999ȡ
    ݡJulia Black,New Institutionalism and Naturalism inSocio-Legal analysis,Law & policy,Vol.19,No.1,January,1997,pp52-93.
    ޡPeter A.Hall,Rosemarcy C.R.Taylor,Political Scienceand the Three NewInstitutionalisms,Political studies,(1996),XLIV,9
36-957.
    ߡASBJ RN SONNE N RGAARD,Rediscovering ReasonableRationality in Institutional Analysis,European Journal ofPolitical Res
earch,29:31-57(January,1996).
    ࡡPeter B.Evans(eds.),Bringing the State Back InCambridge:Cambridge university press,United Kingdom 1985.
    ᡡOliver Williamson,Market and Hierarchies (New Your NY,Free,1975);The Economic Institutions of Capitalism (New YorkNY,
Free,1985)
    ⡡Paul Milgrom and John Roberts,Economics,Organizationand Management(NewYork NY,Prentice-Hall,1992);John Pratt andRicha
rd Zeckhauser,Principals and Agents (Boston MA,HarvardBusiness School Press,1991)
    [11]Ellen M.Immergut,The Normative Roots of theNew Institutionalism;Historical--Institutionalism andComparative Policy 
Studies,ժ
    [12]Simon Reich,The Four Faces of Institutionalism:Public Policyand a Pluralistic Perspective,Governance:AInternational
 Journal of Policy and Administration,Vol.13,No.4,October 2000,pp.501-522.
    [13]Sue E.S.Crawford,Elinor Ostrom,A Grammar ofInstitutions,American Political Science Review,Vol.89,No.3September 1995
,pp582-599.
    [14]Robert Bates,Contra contractarianism:somereflections on the new institutionalism,Politics and society,16(1987),pp38
7-401.
    [15]Paul Pierson,The Limits of Design:ExplainingInstitutional Origins and Change,Governance:An InternationalJournal of 
Policy and Administration,Vol.13,No.4,October2000,pp475-499.
    [16]James G.March and Johan P.Olsen,RediscoveringInstitutions:The Organizational Basis of Politics,New York:The Free Pr
ess,1989.
    [17]Paul Pierson,Increasing Retum,Path Dependence,andthe Study of Politics,American Political Science Review,Vol.94,No.
2,June 2000,pp251-267.
 
