 ׺ 4-452
ԭĳ羭Ρ
ԭ
ԭںš200106
ԭҳš3945
  šD7
  
ӡںš200110
    鶨顷ǰ;ʾúӰ
    ӭ/ׯ
߼顿ӭ19694йѧԺ羭оԱʿׯ19699йѧԺ羭
оԱʱࣺ100732
ҪΪ̸еҪ̱鶨顷ǰ;ܹĹעķ͹ˡ鶨顷һ׼Ч
ܴĹʾúӰ죬Ϻ̸е½չ䷢չǰչ
  ʡ仯/鶨顷/Ӱ/ιϵ
    
    
    199712£Ϲ仯ܹԼ(UNFCCC)εԼ(COP3)ͨˡ鶨顷״ΪIҹ涨˾зԼ
ľĿ꣬(JI)ŷó(ET)෢չ(CDM)ơھȫ򻯼ٷչĴ󱳾£
ҵļжӰ쵽ľ÷չұȻĿǰδеŻķչйңӰ쵽ʾθ
֮й鶨ǰ;ԹʾεӰѧļȤȻ仯ڿѧᾭӰ켰
ƶȰŵȷ涼ںܴĲȷԣ鶨漰ش̸֮УĿǰ̶ֻܴԤ²⣬
龰ˣйΪչд͹̸еҪԱ˽ͷ鶨йǱھúӰ죬ƶй仯ս
Լ⽻ԲһҪʵ¿⡣
    鶨顷ľӰ
    鶨顷һʻЭھȫ򻯼ٷչʱȫͳһĹʴгγɣʱΧĲ
չԼ˾羭аԽԽҪĽɫû֮ϵܡһ鶨׼Чõʵ
Ƶõ㷺Ӧãҵļжͨ羭ú͹ó״ѭĴã԰ҹδŵŻķչ
йҴļӾӰ졣
    1.ԾøӰ
    ѧΪIҵļжͨԴг䶯ӰøˮƽһǣIҵļжʹ
ûʯȼԴĳɱͶЩŷԴ󣬴ӶԴ۸½ȫԴó½ֱ仯ͨóϵĲ
Ӱ쵽δжķǸIңԴڹܵʧһöԴڵԽʧԽʯ
֯(OPEC)ңԴڹйӡȣʯͼ۸½档磬Mustafa Babiker & Henry JacobyEPPA-GTAPģ
͵ļ2010꡶鶨顷ԸIңŷ⣩ɵľøʧԼ0.52%֮䣬ǸIУʯͳڵ
жǵȵĹҵľøʧܴﵽ2.43.7%ĳЩԴڹԼ 0.3%ڡעMustafa Babiker and Henry J
acoby(1999),"Developing Country Effects of Kyoto-type Emission Restriction", in Proceedings of IPCC Expert Meeting on Economi
c Impact of Mitigation Measures, The Hague,The Netherlands,2728 May,1999
    ⣬Ҳѧ߽һӹó׷ֹĽǶָҼɲƷɱڼ۸ͽ٣ʹ
ڼ۸ҲӦ½ڴ󲿷ַչйڹó׷ֹдڳƷԭϳڵĽϵͲΣ䵱Ʒԭϳڹ񾭼
ռнϴʱչйҴľпܳصĴһøܵۺӰ죬ȡڳƷԭϳڵʧܷ
ʯͽԼ뷢ȾǿԴܼƷڵлƽ⡣Paul M. BernsteinȲMS-MRTģ͵о
ŷóʱIҶ̶ܲͬȵľʧڷǸIУīOPECҵľøʧﵽ1.39%йӡ
ľԼΪ0.34%עPaul M.Bernstein,W.David Montgomery,Thomas Rutherford and Gui-Fang Yang (1999),"Effects of Restricti
ons on International Permit Trading:the MS-MRT Model"ͬϡ̶ͬȵŷó׽ڻⲻӰ죬йӡû
ôIڲŷóʱŷǰĳ̶ֳϽ¢ŷȨгü档
    2̼й©
    ̼й©(Carbon Leakage)ָIҼŻǸIŷǡ鶨顷Ӱȫ򻷾ϵķӳ
̼й©ҪԭԴܶȵı仯ɱ仯𸽼IǸIԴܼƷԾı仯ʹI
ŽԴܶȷвҵṹԴܼ͹ҵˮࡢġȣǸIתơʵϣ
Žڷҵ߼ҵĲҵѿʼŲǼһ̵Ĳ
    ձ鵣ص̼й©ܼȫŷţ̼˷ǸIŷŵܵȫŷ
ȫ򻷾ɲӰ졣ǷҪչйҲȫжһҪɡĿǰչйδŵŻ
£ѧҲϣ鶨涨ƶԸIɼĿҪȶԣȻ̼й©⣬أ
عֵġעAlan S.Manne & Richard G. Richels(1999),"The Kyoto Protocol:A Cost-Effective Strategy for Meeting Environme
ntal Objectives?",Stanford University'sEnergy Modeling Forum 16 Study,1999磬CPBJohannes BollenȲWorldscanģ
IPCCŷ龰ر𱨸桷A1B1ŷ龰עϸߵľʣǷǸIңB1A1ԷԴЧʸĽ
ٶȽϿ죬ʹ鶨涨ѹСͬʱǰڼĿŷ龰(hot air)¼õ
̼й©ʾ20%ҡעJohannes, TonManders and Hans Timmer(1999),"Kyoto and Carbon leakage:Simulations with Worldscan"
,2728 May,1999ԴܶԼԴ̼̼ܶй©Ҫ;УԴܶȱ仯ҪӰء
ӾƷͷڵĽǶȷ󲿷ֵ̼й©򸽼IҵնѡҲ˵ǸIŷҪԭ򸽼I
ڸͬʱӸIҽڽٵԴܼͲƷֵעǣԴܼ͹ҵתƿܸչйҴһͳ
Ч棬Դܼ͹ҵתĹȾתƣпܸչйҵĿɳչӰ졣ͬʱӳԶĹ۵㿴չ
йҴչҪҲء𲽵ؽҵṹĵܺĵĸ¼͸߸ֵҵⱻ(lockin)ڹ
ʲҵӹײ㡣
    3.ԹʱӰ
    ʱĸıǡ鶨顷ӰһҪ档ѧΪ֮ͬڽϴļű߼ʳɱ죬ǽ
ŷгƶڸ߼ʼųɱ⣬ڸ߼ųɱĹңܵʽʱֵ̼ڣڵͼ
ɱĹңܵʽ롢ֵڿԽʵʡ̼гڿʱӶٽGDPڹ
ʱڿķΧѰɱԻߵͶʻرˣǷڹŷóףκθIҵļ߶
ɲŹԽϵ͵ĳɱмŵĹӹʱ档ģʱʻʲ
    Worwick J. McKibbinȲһG-Cubedģ͵оŷóʱȡOECDҡעģ
ͽҷΪձĴǺOECD4ӼšųɱϵͣŴGDPʧСͶϿ졣OEC
DҡڼųɱϸߣʱͶʻرʵͣʱΣա2010꣬ۼʱߴ3700Ԫ20204900
ԪЩʱ󲿷СչйҡǰͷǸIҴ۵ļŻᣬʵ
󲿷ֹʱȻOECD֮䡣עWorwick J. McKibbin,Martin T.Ross,Robert Shackleton and Peter J.Wilco
xen(1999),"Emission Trading,Capital Flows and the Kyoto Protocol",2728 May,1999
    4.˾
    ŶԴԴܼͲҵķչشӰ졣ˣ鶨顷֮ͨҵڶҵ
Ŀǣֻɺ͵̬ȣԾӪԴܼͲƷΪĴͿ˾ˡƾۺľʵӰͨ
ҵЭἫ˵ͨойڹ̸Ҳ൱Ծ1989ġȫˡ(GCC)һ
ҵҵΪҪԱĹ֯ߺIPCCһӰǼΪйů֤Բ֣δ
Ӱ첻ȷԺܴһ棬κξзЧӦļЭ鶼ʧҵͲƷ۸ǣӶӰ쾭ḣ
    һЩͿ˾ҵЭ̬ȿʼֱȽϻת䡣һڹڻʶĲǿҵѾʶ
Žʹҵɥʧܹں۵ǿѹһ棬ΪҪǣһ鶨ЧʵʩδΪ
׼ҵɱӶɥʧˣδٵսͨ˾ӪսԣӦߵ
Ҫˣ۹ҵ쵼ҲʶŹŷгĽ͹ԴгķչŽҵᣬҵ
ӦЩµгĻãΪҵͬʱҲΪȫ򻷾סҪŵѹΪչĶ
ҵ̬ȷתĸԭ磬ӢBPʯ͹˾ƶҵڲļĿǵ20101990ϼ10%൱
Ի׼ŷ(BAU)Ž40%ͬʱ˾ڲŷóƶȣʹӪͳɱɼĿꡣע
Rodney Chase(1998),"Climate Change-A Role for Business",Deputy Group Chief Executive and Chief Executive of BP Oil speaks at 
Chatham House,London,27th Nov.,1998
    ھȫʱ˾ΪֱͶʡȽ͹Ҫ壬淢ҪáڹʼжУ˾
ƾھáֲȷıпչйҵĹʱͼתƷҪɫҪעǣ
һЩͿ˾Ժܸߣ鶨涨ŵǹ˾ҪãҪƶȿ֧֣ܵҲҪ
йعҽӦĹڷƶȡ20004£ʯҵЭᡱ(IPIECA)ٿˡʵʩеĻϰ
ᣬڻйҵĲ룬ٶԻӦõĸƶϰԼȷԸҵķաע
International Petroleum Industry Environmental Conservation Association(IPIECA) (2000),"Summary of IPIECA Workshop on Opportu
nities,Issues and Barriers for Practical Application of the Kyoto Mechanisms",April,2000
    5.ó׹Э
    ó֯(WTO)ƶó׹Эó׹ϵҪʾ֯1994غ̸Уó׹ϵ
Ӳó뻷ίԱ(CTE)ѧۡ鶨顷˵һЭ˵һóЭ鶨ʵʩ
漰ó׹򣬲пWTOͻעJennifer Lee(2000),"The Kyoto Protocol Could Violate WTO TradeRule
s,Say Experts",Weathervane (Feature),April 26,2000磺
    (1)ơǡ鶨顷ҪĿǰWTOĶ壬漰ŷŶΪƷ(
goods)Ϊ֤ȯsecuritiesһֿתõĽڹߣԴΪƷнΥֹԲͬWTOԱͬ
Ʒݹ(MFN)ԭ򡣶Ϊתõ֤ȯóϵнΪһ֡񡱡غϡóЭ(GATS)
Դṩ߲Υԭ򡣴⣬ŷŶȵĳʼҲᷢ⡣ŷȨΪҵһֽ
WTOͲʩЭ(SCM)ķԭŷȨķ䲻ֻԲҵš
    (2)̼˰̼˰ŵҪߴʩҲпΥWTOҪƷûƷһ̼ͬ˰ҵ
ҵľнᴦơ߽˰ڡͨԽƷ˰ʹ֮ﵽƷͬˮƽԳƷ˰ǿ
гϾķԽ϶Ը˰յڷWTOµĺϷδɹʶ
    (3)ͨٽԴĿûȼתŵһҪߴʩǰ˹
гռݶSCMķԭֲҲΥWTOġ
    (4)Լ鶨ڹԼĿߴʩҲWTOͻһΪɼĿó
ߺʹʩ߽òЭĿóĿ¿⡣
    Ӱ֮⣬鶨顷ʵʩɻشٽԴҵũҵļɢ¼Ӧãƽ
չйڵȫɳչ̡
    鶨顷Ӱ
    鶨顷Ӱ֮⣬ԹʹϵӰҲݺӡ
    1.չйԽԽĹѹ
    鶨顷ҪӰǷҽһֶμӽҪйӡȡȷչдȫţŵŻ
ʹչйԽԽĹѹӢţԴоBenito MllerĹ۵㣬鶨顷پĿ꣬
עBenito Mller, "Does US Ratification Really Matter?",http://associnst.ox.ac.uk/energy/13.html
    (1)Ŀ꣺ͨ鶨׼ЧΪṩʷɻͱϣ
    (2)Ŀ꣺20082012꣬Iŷ19905.2%
    (3)Ŀ꣺ͨIȼʾã˵չйҼȫж
    Һ̶ܴϽĿȵλĿԵġڷӪڲܸ漯֮һ磬
ڷչйҲȫϵǻһµġΪˣѧһоνչйȫֵϵһ漫
ƳȫŷóƶȵԽԣչйȫŷгô磺ʿڵͳɱŻ᣻
Ŷȿɻÿɹ۵ľ룻ٽżתƣپֲȾũҵҵȾòź͹ڽ̼ͨ˰˰ѭ
̼˰Ͷʱ˰գִг˰ŤȵȡԤ⣬йļųɱͣǱ޴MIT-EPPAģԤ
2010׼ŷ龰(BAU)ϼ10%ձŷ˺ļųɱֱй166419999£ͳת
һùίԱ(CEA)ййоУռѧòͬԴģйδŵһϵо
ѧߵļ㣬2010йԵBAUļŷ1424%֮䣬һŵ20082012ԤƳŷȨ뽫414
ԪעU.S.Council of Economic Advisers,"The Economics of Greenhouse Gas Emissions Abatement in China,A Preliminary An
alysis",September 1999
    ˵ľ沢ŷΪЩ߹йĿ棬رܴܿĲӰ졣ԭ⣬
Դѡ񡢼ȼأԼģͱȱݡ磬ԼҵṹԴṹתȾóɱǲ㣬
ڼžóɱ֮ٿɱú̿ҵʧҵ⣩޷ӳ谭Чʱ׼ѡƺƶأԴϵͳĹ
ԺͶԣгʧĲʵԤʵȫгܴﵽģȫֽ׵״ȵȡ
    2.չйӪڲֻ
    1991̸1992ǩԼչйӪǿҵʷΣҪԼȷֹƽͬ͡Ρ
ԭشϱֳǰŽһ¡ԼͨԺ󣬾ܷչйӪڲһìܷ磬ЭڷΪ
չйĶУ77żйģʽȻȡüɹǣ֮鶨ơջ㣨
̼㣩ʽԮͼתƵشϾʵʩϸķԽԽʵͽȡ̸Ա
ϱսģչйӪڲֻϼӾ磬ŶƵõǿơĿǰչйӪٷΪ¼
Ӽţ
    (1)仯ӰŷСС(AOSIS)ԼԸŵŻĿĹң簢͢ͺ
ǶǼĿȫ򻯵ƽߡ
    (2)CDMּĹңЩҰCDMΪȡCDMʵʩܸ棬īͰԼ
ķ޹ҡ
    (3)ԳŵԴѴйӡȣǿΪ๲ԴԴõȨͷĹƽԣҪ󻷾չռ䡣
    (4)OPECΪԴԴ񾭼ռλǳȫȫԴгĽɴ˸
ô޴ĸӰ졣
    ̸ʱܲµӼš仯̸֮ѣ̶ܴΪйҶǡϷĲߣû
ϵȫͬġҺܿ÷չйӪڲ磬ʩѹͬʱԾòԷֻ߽⡣
δ̸УڲЭܱȶ⽻ΪӺͼޡ
    3.ѧġλ
    Χơ鶨顷кδֵϱϼӾ硣ڴ˱¿չ仯רί
Ա(IPCC)桷(TAR)׫д˸ĸ߶ӡرǸŵᾭӰ켰Բ߽ĵ飬ѧ
֮ζܽ֯ѧġλ൱ԡԼͷչйҲе⣬ѧ
мǿκ塣ҲҪڴˡйͳƽƾǿľʵϢƣṩ
϶࣬Ϊȫ桢ϵͳͼ磬Եһ¡չƽɳԡ仯ȷʾܽܣǿ
ָû¹ŵ侭ѧгۣڷչɳеĵλãûȨ÷չƽɳ֮Ĺϵ
ڷԼ⣬ֵԼҪɾ漰ʹƵۡԷչйҲ⣬ָд
չйҸŷŵ龰ΪҪӸŷŷҪԸŵʽɴ˿ɼ
Ĳݿѧʶ
    սԵѧλҲһʾ̸вڻ᳡Уս⽻ս벻ѧо֧šΡѧ
ǶԿѧλûӦ
    4.ŵŻٹҰȫս
    ĿǰйδŵŻ񣬵ӳԶйһĳʽе˾зԼŻ񣬲ֱӲȫ
гپðȫԴȫԼķһϵйϵҰȫϾս
    ȣηڲ߱£ееⲻҹľ棬ʹйʧ
ȥδķչռ䡣Ŀǰйҹŵĵȱϵͳо⽻ߴܴѶȡ
    ΣͨCDMETйһȫŷгͲɱǰŷԼչдľйܷڼҵ
нǱΪʵͳɱŻܷάȥʹʱйɳչĿֹ꣬ƻãȾ
תơԻʵĳȣֱӹϵйľðȫ
    ٴΣŻʹйòбҪԴṹȼú̿ʹöʯͺȻйϾ
Դȫսй뽨ԼࡢЧɳԴϵ㻷ĿͬʱԴȫ
    󣬵ԼȷезԼŻԼʹȨϾս磬빫Լ鶨صļල
ִС˲άȨǱڳͻʷ֯(NGO)λܹɶȨԼһ겻ɼĿ꣬
ԼеӦɺܾϵĳͷɹ𺦣ȵȡ
    鶨顷ǰ;
    ݹ涨鶨ҪЧҪ55ҵ׼иI1990ŷ֮Ҫﵽŷŵ55%鶨顷ǰ;ȡŷ
ˡΪ׵ɡ͹ҡչд漯ŵ̬ȣԼ֮临ӵĻϵ
    ŷ̸еķߺҪƶŷ˿ڡ÷չԴṹıȽƼǿĻʶŷ˶Դ۶
̸жɵġ鶨顷൱̬ȣϧ׼Լƽһ̡ŷʻ֯Ϻ
̸и׼鶨顷ʹ֮2002Ч2002ԼԼǩ10꣬ѡһݲϣ
Լ10ںʹȫ仯һĹ㷺עͬʱҲǿǹҾϵԴϵͳкܴԣ
ȡʵԵļжȻӰʵ鶨涨ĿĿԡ200038գŷˡŷ仯ƻ(ECCP)ǩ2
005꿪ʼŷڲʵʩŷó׵Ľ(Green Paper)ΪŷڵεԼ(COP6)׼鶨׼Ϊ2
008ʵʩȫŷó֮ǰȡñҪľ顣עJennifer Lee(2000),"European Commission Makes Plans to Launch Emission Tra
ding",Weathervane(Trading Post),March 15,2000
    ŷŹ1990ŷռȫŷԼ1/4ռIŷ֮͵36%ھ鶨顷
ǰ;Ĳ𵽹ؼáȻκ仯ĹЭ鶼Ӧǻгġĺȫģйӡȡȷչд
Ĳ롱Ϊ׼鶨Ⱦʲ̨ԼӰͷչйδеΪɱ˾ִܾ
ǿӲ⵽˹һµǿŷˣͬɡ͹Ҽŵձȶڻ˵¿⽻
ߡʵϣ80йعʻķѸٷչΪԴзӵʮޡڹȥ20ͨ5
ȫԻԼУ4δ׼Чġע1992ЧġʿΣշתƵİԼ1994Ч
ʺ󷨹Լ1983ЧġϡֵĲԼԼ1996ЧġλĮʹԼJohn Anderson(2000),"Coul
d the Kyoto Protocol Go Forward Without U.S.Ratification",Weathervane(at the Negotiating Table),March 9,2000仯
ȫԻԣЩ˵̬赲ʻ̸еĽ̡һֹ۵Ϊ
ǿҷԣγĳֻƶȹ淶ӰҲۿۡ
    Ȼڴٽ鶨顷׼ЧͬʱҲӦԤ鶨;Ŀԡˣ̸нһδ
ĵˡʹึߵĴۡ鶨顷ʷλɶҡܺҪԽδ̸еҪĿǰйء
鶨顷һʧܺǰ;ҲвͬĿעHenry D. Jacoby(2000),"COP-6,Kyoto and the Long Term",Arco Forum on Climate
 Change Economics and Policy,John F.Kennedy School of Government,March 15,2000һֹ۵ŴӳԶĿ̸УΪ199
0ϿĹ趨ϸΪеļĿʱԴΪ㣬һԶĿ꣬ǿŷóƶȲٽ
гϷԼչйҲ̵ȡһֹ۵ŴӶĿ鶨еĶڵʹй涨ɣ
̼㡢CO[2]ͳƿھԼCDMɹĶȡǰ߻¯ѶȺͷʱ֪Ȼ鶨
ԺԣȵҲȫ򻷾ɲӰ졣
    2000111325ںٿ˵εԼ顣ǰձϣλܾʵ鶨涨ļĿľϸȡ
ʵԽչٳ鶨2002׼ЧźǣִҪлֲջ㣬ڷչйʵʩ
CDMĿʵԵļж⵽ҵǿҷԣʹ޹աҪ缯ǷƵ
ơǷջĿΪCDMĿջĹ㷽ԼǿԺȹؼ⣬ŷΪ׵ɡ͹Ҽ
硣
    ŷǿšֻǹڼжһֲʽҪ50%޶Ƶüƣɡ͹ǿ
ԼͻгĻߣκʽջ㣬ŷΪʹɭĹ㷽CDMĿвӦð
ĿϣͨͺջĿŵľѹһڷչйҲȡһһЩֲǺ
ַƵңͨCDMʵĿǱʾͬйȶΪջڸݺ͹㷽ȷȱ
㹻ĿѧʶͬʱĿȣչйҽļתõĻ٣ԽջĿΪCDMĿձ
ؼϸ⣬ԷչйҪӹٷչԮ(ODA)ĺʹODAͶCDMĿѺ˵缼ҲΪCDMĿͬʱ
ǵŽϸߣձԼ̸мΥԼǿֶΣŲñȽº͵ĴٽԴʩձΪ
鶫ʱȽϻ̬ȥԶ⵽ǿָ𡣣עμInternational Institute for Sustainable D
evelopment(IISD),"Summary of The Sixth Conference of The Parties to The Framework Convention on Climate Change:1325 Novembe
r 2000","COP-6:Building Castles in The Sand or Air?"http://www.iisd.ca/vol12/enb12163e.html
    ܺ޹źʱݻᣬ20017ڲᣬԸʧһµϣ
ٿCOP6ڶ׶λһ쳣ѵļҽΪ˲ʹ鶨顷ĳɹ֮òߵܷ
һϵйؼȡЭ˽ĿԴ
 
