 ׺ 3-1031
ԭĳѧ
ԭ
ԭںš199904
ԭҳš129135
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš200001
    ηչоеĻع
    
߼顿ѧϵ˶ʿо
ҪͼѧƽǶȶԵηչеĻعзȲνĻع顱ں;ʽ
ȻͨηչоʷȡֻıȽϣʾĻع顱򱳺ѧݱ߼ӰȱݵĻ
ϣѧѧƽҪԵηչоܽͽ顣
  ʡĻع/ֵж/ηչ
    
    ηչоѾа͡ڴڼ䣬ֹѧɲţ䶰ķپȻ־ܿͱ
ƣηչоһϢˡǣηչоһĻعηչ
롰ĻҪأսֵ̬ġٶ񡱣һֱĿǰڹκͶ֮ϵĴ̵ۣطӳ
ξõĸֱ䶯ѧоشӰ죬Ҳڸ˵ηչоѧʷչĹ켣
            һ
    ڱ80ηչоͳ롰ĻҪչо༴עеļֵصоȡ

    ѧѶP ͢پоȡĴסΤɺϱġ˽ηչһоص
ˡڷչĻ⡱ôͳλ򾭼ģʽԽ͸ִеش֮󣬺͢ٿʼΪؼԵĶ
ĻעѶ͢٣չĿ꡷1987꣨תࡶִʷ̽֡Ϻĳ磬1
993꣬352ҳָ Ļһ״ġ۸ӵĸĳϻһοѧеĺ󱸸
residual categoryʹȽס һʱǾͻעƵҲйѧ硣
90йִоУһĻȳ޷ȷ͵ȫͳΪĻǣϷơĻ
Ϊѧоġ䡱ָʲôӡ͢оٳҪľŸĻȺٵÿһĻȺǷ
صξ÷չĿģʽһ⣨ע5 㷺ġĳͻһеķͬΪĸ
ӦýʺϸĻִģʽָϵķչĿֻĲĻСܵòʲô֧
û壬ҲȫķչĿꡣʺϸĻִ˹ģʽִģʽִӡ
ȽģʽʱѾˡڼƽִͬʱҲһ벢һĽ̡עѶ
͢٣չĿ꡷1987꣨תࡶִʷ̽֡ Ϻĳ磬1993꣬350357ҳ
͢Ļ۶ڡۡηչо˵ȷһġԡǣܵʹ˺ݱʵ
ȻĻδͳͬȵҪԡ
    ˣʱηչоƲûеõܺõ͢ٵġĻȡоҲ˸ȻֹΪʱĹξþ
Ȼʶ̬ͻΪҪѧоδܵϾսҲûʶĻصҪ
ԣעˡĻΪоȡڵʱηչѧֻ꼻һ֡
    սԺΪṩͳһ滮ıƺֻеˡǣΪǽδʧ塢Ա
塢ҡʱڴýȫ򻯵ȸܼķʽӿֳܿΪĹעġǻŶ
Ϊձֵάٽ侭ŬǴ𡣣ע Huntington,   Samuel  P. : "The  Clash  of Civ
ilization?" Foreign Affairs, 72(1993):31ΧЩֵĻκ;صسΪĵ
ͼֵȫΧڼԡѰԡΪ־塢˶˶ִƶȺ
ʹϵɡոΪʵʧܶ磬òڡĻԪ塱µһս
    ͬʱԭеѧ˵Ѿɥʧ˽µϵںսʱʱӪ˼άѸٱ
ģʽԵģʽۡʣѷģʽģʽۿҲԽ͵ĸԡĻԪ
塢ԼֳŲĶ˵⡣һǸҵľúĻȫ򻯣һǸ
ѰԵ˶ù˹Ļ˵Щ˶ļĿꡰҪǴĻǶȷģȻв᲻ƽȡòƽ
ԼԵ⡣  ע  Jurgen   Habermas:"Struggles for Recognition in the Democratic  Constitutional State",Mul
ticulturalism:Examining the Politics of Recognition, edited and introduced by  Amy  Gutmann,   Princeton,   N. J.:Princeton U
niversity Press, 1994,pp.116117 ǰ忴ֳĵЩ˶Ǽ򵥵طĻȨ
ԱĻΪĿꡣˣ˵죬ȫ򻥶ĻͬʻʻĽŹϵעA
rjun Appadurai:"Disjuncture and  Difference  in the Global Cultural Economy", Public Culture,  Vol. 2, Spring 1990,p.5.
    ʷʹηչоĻعĳֳΪܺʵĻԪͼηչѧߵĹ۵
ѸٷֻࡣһʵΪݣĴͳĽ壬սʱѸٵǵĿܿ˶
¹ĴۡӰǰԺԱ ¹˾ְġ˹ɽFrancisFukuy
amaġʷսۡThe end of History  עFrancis Fukuyama: The end of History? The National   Interest,1989.
1992꣬ ɽһ۵һʱġʷսἰһˡThe end of History and the Last Man,   New  York1992
ΪսĽƶȡʶ̬ϵӮ˳ʤͬʱҲ־ʶ̬ϵʧܣ
ʽƿγɡʶ̬յ㡱͡ͳε̬ʷٻᷢչµ̬һʵϹ˵ǰ
ӵġĻȨʶ̬1990ԺĹʹϵչ֤صڸʱֻǸɽĿ롣
    ǣһ۵ϣǺ͢1993귢ġĳͻһ³ͻ   ע  Huntington, 
Samuel P.:"The Clash of Civilization? "Foreign  Affairs,   72(1993):2249ƪ͢ڼĻϣһ
ĳͻȡʶ̬ĺʽĳͻΪδȫεҪĳͻͬʱָͻӦͬ
ڲĽϡʹϵ֮óۣսγˡԿľ棬δͻʵϽ
˹һ֮ͬĳͻĳͻ⵽ڵѧߵԴˣ͢ٷʣ粻
ʲôעHuntington,  Samuel  P. : "If  not civilization, then what?"Foreign Affairs,  November/ Devember1993, pp.18
6194ҸԼԡʽPARADIGMSĺ塣ĻͻķʽʽȨģʽģʽ
ģʽ硪弯ģʽȵȣܹʵʾʵͽҪʵ
    ˲ıϵǣ۵Ҳ׷ĻоװԼĹʹϵۼԼɪĻΪȨ
Soft PowerΪȨĻֵȡڵʹϵҪ        ķֱֿˡĻͬCul
turalsynchronizationĸ ʵǡĻ۹塱Culturalimperialismһʽ Ļͬǰʱ
徭úгȫΧڵձ黯ҪĻķչܵչ๵ͨصᴴԺĻԽ̽״̬
ݻ١ղķ˹˹ŵڡң仯ͼ̳еۡԾڴ˻νġȫĻGlobal Cultureĺ
ľĻͼֵĻʵϵġȨʴErosion of Sovereigntyͷչڡ
ĻȨ͡ĻȨĶԻ1996꣬͢ٳˡĳͻؽһ飬ڡ⽻ơǶ
صģձġŽеĻͳԿִķԹŷˡעHuntington,
 Samuel P:The  West:   Unique,   not  Universal, Foreign Affairs, November/December 1996. һ۵ٴȫΧ
ʹĻعоµķ粨
            
    ηչоеĻعĳ֣ѧƷչʷȻ
    ηչоΧƷ۽ϷоȡķֱַֻֻԴڶִоСۡĲͬ˼
γɡһѧɣżֵʵ룬ѧһΪѧɣֵܼ
    ִۼҶִΪŷͱƶȺͼֵʮԺŷĴ̣ʮʮ
Ĵ̡עɣִѧٿȫ顷6ŦԼ1965꣬324ҳʵǰִ
򵥵Ϊֹ۵ʮһֱռͳελҲʼ50ִоĵη
չۡʱηչڰηչ̽綨Ϊʽķչ
    ǲã־ƫӸͬڲĻͳļֵۣ⵽ԽԽбȽ粼˼й
ΪִǴͳƶȺͼֵڹ϶ִԺʹͳԻϵоɴˣִоҪתۣһΪֻ
հȫƶȺ͹ʵִĹ۵㱻ִ̬оʼִ̬ϵо
չ͹ֳչйصִжϣBreakdown of Modernizationȱαϵľ
Һѣͳִ۶ԴѾ޷ṩĽͣģѧ˼ʹηչоĴ󲿷ѧͼ
Ѽֵж϶ԿѧоӰ죬ʼֻʵжϵĺûҲ˵ϵӦóʲôչɵºͿƶ
չеΡת۵ı־ɵáġ롰ġ򡰷չеġִʹͳᣨעA
lmond,  Gabriel  and  James  S.   Coleman:   The Politics of the Developing Areas, Princeton University Press, 1960.P2324
󣬰ɵC ķСġȽѧչоһƺǿ۵㡣עAlmond, G
abriel and G.   Bingham  Powell:  Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach, Boston:    Little  Brown, 1966.P13
    1995Ѷ͢ڡΡ־Ϸˡηչ˥ܡһģʽִηչΪߵ̫ͬ
ηչġʱͿռ䡱ƱС侭ںעHuntington, Samuel P. : Political  Development  and Pol
itical Decay, WorldPolitics, 17(1965):P389393 ڵʱоηչѧ߿ͬϵ֮䣬ڡһϵ
ڡ塱ֻǴſáԵĲ졣Եֵжȡ򣬼ڰɵºC ķ
СġȽѧϵ̺ߡһСעİɵ¡СȽѧϵ̺ߡϺ
磬1987һʱִִ֧չоѧ߶ΪΪҪļֵоҪǿһۿܣ
һ׸롢ͷȣʶеõַչϵ簢ɵ˵ĳһλĳЩһ
λһЩ⣬Ȿζļֵѡ񡣡עɵ¡СȽѧϵ̺ߡϺĳ磬
1987꣬27ҳˣ·չоѧ߱ȻżֵʵȻеƿơ
    ˣѶ͢1971귢ġ±仯ı仯ִչΡһΪηչоʵȻĿԵģ
ԵģȻŰƶȿļֵжϡעѶ͢٣±仯ı仯ִչΡ
ִ˱࣬Ϻĳ磬19966667ҳŰоתʮĩͳֵġǨоοѧ
ΪѧңŬȥ¼αǨԭʼʵʱãδ仯ȡһһһЩڷû򻵵
Ŀ귢չı仯ϸáעѶ͢٣±仯ı仯ִչΡȽִ˱࣬
ĳ磬199679ҳѧҾͿûκоչйҴαǨʵˡ
    ˣηչоŬһԸߵһˣͼֵжϣȻҲǡǡµ
սԺ˶ž÷չηչķ񣬶йطչ֪ʶž޴ѧִ
ƶΪΪչйҵηչıߣƶȲδЩѿȶδʵ֣һֱ
ڶͻ֮С÷չȱλͱϣһֱƶͼĥֵжֻǻرʵ⣬Υ
ηչоĳԣҲʹȱɥʧӰ
    ѧΪֵо˥ʱһȻͬѧɷչˡԼѧɣ
ϵۣΪ70ηչов˾޴Ӱ졣ȫʽҵ͹ҿչйηչ
Ŀꡣʵͼشηչоеһؼ⣬һۣڶ̶Ͽչڷᡣ
    ѧȣҪþѧηչʶǿҺͷչй֮ľùϵԷչйη
չֱӰ졣ȣ۶ԡ뷢չйĲࡱһͳ壬ע뷢չй
ĲࡱԮ197451աϹԡһΡΪֹһ趨ֻһַչģʽֻһͨձ鸣
·ҵзչˮƽӦ̬ӦչйΪģʽΪһĿԽܡΣٷչй
Ǻͷ֮Ĳ࣬ҪԮ˾ţʵҪǸ
    ӦóϣΪչоҪסӴˣѧҲܺѧѧѧҲӱܾѧ
ѧˡҲʹչоһעⷢҵԮóסͶԼ˾Ρ;úһ濪ʼھ
֮漰ľ÷⡣ǣҲصȱݡͼڷչоаۣѧƼֵȻ
ļֵжȴԴʶ̬ƫϿ۲ûнγɸȻϵͳؼоûи
չһȷĶ塣۱׼ȱʧͻң۶ʵȷƬķʵϿ©ٳʹ
ۿۡѧ߶19461973Ԯµξýп죬۵Ԥìܵ80
ҵרη׷׿̨ƶȵԽͬʱ෢չй綫СȶѸٷչˡЩǡǡ
ҵͶʣ˾Ĺҡ۵ȱݺʵìܣܿͼŬηչֵܼжϵԸʹ
۵80˥ȥ
    ɼηչоĻعͼʾΪѧоĿֻ֮ΪصֵģԱ
ΪηչѧΪѡȡĵ·
    ͼ{ͼ}
            
    Ȼ͢Ϊ׵ѧηչ͹оڶĻҪصĲڼ̳ȵǰ˼ĻϣΪ
ִηչѧоһµĹ۲άȣһĿԺͲݺӵѧֵϵǰĻȫеĴƣҲΪ
жսĹξṩµӽǡźǣΪĻعоȡʹηչоص
Ϊǰ˵Ļ塢ĻȨṩۻΪֹתĻоηչʵѾٹעչ
ˣ۵̶ȱݺǷǳԵġ
    ġʷսۡĸɽʵϲõĲʷѧϵ֤ѧ֤ġ
֤ǰ£Ļͼֵ̬ǰǷڵǰѧдʡ֥Ӹѧʷѧ
HWilliam H.McNeilֱԣɽʹˡעWilliam H.McNeill."History Over, World Goes  On. "   TheNew 
York Times Book Review, Jan. 26 1992, p.14, Col.1.Ϊ֧Լ۵νʷѵȻ󲿷վסŵġɽ½
ΡTRUST ͨòƹʵıȽ϶ĻԵʽóһֻۣġΡĻźִ
֮бȻϵӶڸ㷺Ϸ˷Ļִ߱ԵĿܡȻ̵֤ǰ͡ʷսۡһޣ
һ¶˸ɽ˶ԶĻ̬֪¡ȻûֱšĻȨսԣǼȻ϶ʶ̬ѾΪʷ
չյ㣬ô۱Ȼˡ塱endism͢ٶ֮ΪΣյġƻԡۣΪṩһƽ
󡣣עHuntington, Samuel P."No  Exit:  TheErrors of Endism", The National Interest, Fall 1989,p.10.
    ں͢ٿ1989ԺֵС塱Ĺ۵㣬Ȼ֪ƼһҪġĵءע
Huntington, Samuel  P. : "The  Clash  of  Civilization? " Foreign Affairs, 72(1993):22 һؾǺ͢ԼȾ
νͻǣơĻʵǴ£ǴˣMagna Carta, not the Magna Mac ʱ עHunti
ngton, Samuel P.: The  West:   Unique,   not   Universal, Foreign Affairs, November/ December 1996.p.29. һĸ
ǣǲܺʹ˽ȻġȣĻж˼ά̬ȻΪĻγṩʻ
Ļһʷۡע¡³˺ȣĻˡ㽭1986棬67ҳǱȻ
ġͳҪػҪءаһĽӴ͢ȫ׿Ļγɵʷ
ΪһϵбĨʱԵĸĻҲͬ󡪡м򵥺ͿշıȽϡֺӡ
о⵽ŷ˼άƵעάƣ¿ѧѧ磬1987꣬134135ҳ
γɱһͬĻ֮䲻ϽӴںϡķչ̣ʵϰ˶ĻҪءѧ߾ָھĻ
֮ȷڲ죬ֲǡ̶ȵĲĲ족ŷĻ׼ΪȽϱ׼Ϊֵձ߶Ǻ
ġ ע  Frederick   M.   Barnard: Culture and Civilization in Modern  Times, in Phili P. Wiener,ed. Dictionary of 
the History of Ideas, New York 1968, P.618.Σ   ͻƵ   ǽϸġۡhypothetical corolla
ry֮ϵġ͢ʷԼõĶȻԳġעܺ롢͢ٵġĳͻؽ
ŷޡ19975ڣ8081ҳĻһ䶯ŵĻʵ̣ʷԼļ򼸸ص
ܷ嶨ġκձ棬ȻǳͻġͬʱͷĻʷҲ˵֮ںϺԻ
Ǳ֮ҡͻĸԴȪ͢һϼ̳ȵ˼룬ԶδﵽȿšԶ̬ѧ磬
Լ趨ġڷǰлÿ־岢Եġ
    ͻ۵ʵʹһȰѹ۵ηչ۵Ӱں̶ܴΪսʱ
Һͷչй֮ĳͻṩΪݡĻԪʵ£ǡ塱ǡͻۡǴ
۵ǰԲͬǶȺԺͷ񶨷Ļ壬ܽϵʱȫ򻯵ķչƣͼĻǶ
ٶΪ˳νѧƼֵĻع顱ηչоηأ
    һѧΪһѧƶԡ
    οѧΪѧڱǷܹСֵжϡһ⣬ѧһֱѾءӿѧĽǶ˵οѧĿ
ʵԵز󣬰һֿ͹۴ΪѧңΪΪǷԵģеж϶
ģѧоҪǲܵġˣΪѧοѧңҲӦоֵ⡣Ȼı
Ȼ漰ԡԼһϵлͻĵҪˣΪоεοѧңòоЩҪֽɫì
ηչоֵȡֻڻ
    Ϊû֤ѧǲӦҲֵȡģͻɥʧΪѧƵηչо
ҪľΪηչоѰѧΪηչоṩļֵͷۣʹηչʵ֤оϵ
ʵʵļִֵƫļֵȡȻѧľԭǣֵĸ
۵ʵϾֵձ͵ձԣضʵҲǿԻɵġͻصִѧıԴ
ζҪм˵ϣͨƷͨǿȨУڷչйʵƶȡͽ
ѧӦÿΪηչоṩлۻʹ֮߳磬ҮĻĽ۱磬
ǼȷԽ۵Ψ壬ַԡɡעϣ롤Үˣԭ1997꣬Ͼ38ҳ
    ڶηչΪʵԡ
    ηչӸϽ۵ͬʱҲʵִһȫϺʷ߼Ḷ́γ
ΡáʷĻڽ̵صۺúͻЭȻǽɡȻչγɵģʽͬ
ᾭñѿäĿظһʱʵͱԤˡͬķչ߼ȻͬĿꡣս
Ȼչйھͬ羭ϵΡʷĻľ޴죬·չй
ҵִߵǲͬʷĵ··ϣΪִδʵǲɱġΪαȻѸ
ľ÷չϵìܡηչоǡǡ߼ķѺͳͻһԸͼĿǿڷչ
ҶһɡȥʷѾ֤һ㡣νĻع򣬱ȻΪ緶ΧĻԪ
ⲻΪλƽ·ʹٿܽΣաΪغ˷Ļִ
ﾳеں壬Ҳʹ屾ʱ徭̬һ֮ìܸӶ񻯡עμࣺͣ
Ļ빫ԡ1998꣬۲֡
    ɼĻعӰ죬ԤʾŵηչоѾһĽ׶ΡµηչоؼǻشִҪ
ʲôλʲôβܴﵽִҲǻشʲôضֵĻΪƶȾԽԺձԣӦ
شضºʷ׶УͨĵϵͳЭγϵӶʵķչͬʱ
ƽ塢гķչһ㣬ڵչйҡҶǺġˣڵηչои
ĻصоؽʾҪԶ塣
    
    
    
 
