 ׺ 4-1018
ԭĳĴѧѧ
ԭɶ
ԭںš200002
ԭҳš2132
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš200003
    θЧӦ
    θо
    鳣
߼顿鳣ĴѧѧԺ  Ĵɶ  610064
ҪθЧӦһйθηչ˥֮ϵҪ⣬һֱڲͬۡθ
оױйθЧӦȺ˴ͳθЧӦۡչ׶ΣͳθЧӦ۰θ
Ϊ˥ܣϸθЧӦ¶λΪθܿԵ·չйҵηչɶɵĹ۵
Ͳ䣬½θܿ˥ܣܽ˹θоףָԼ򵥻ķչ۲ЧθЧ
Ӧĸ⣬һۺԵ۷ܡ
  ʡθ/ηչ/˥/θЧӦ
    
    ±š10060766200002002112
    θЧӦEffects of political corruption ָθܶϵӰãһηչ˥
صҪ⡣ѧһֱֲͬĹ۵㣬һΪθ谭ηչȻ˥ܣһָЧӦ
Negative effectsһΪʱҲܴٽηչһΪأҲһЧӦPositiv
e effects
    йĸθ뾭θٶȳ񾭼ٶȵעйڽʮĸĸУ
ʮ໥ìܵķչ״һĸٽ˾Ѹٷչ19791995ֵGNPƽΪ9ң
һĸתθܴѹͳƣ19851995̰ܻۡ߾÷ﰸƽ
Ϊ2819861996йȫ˴Ժе˵ĸθηչ˥
ܵĹϵĳָӹһķչжϡһ棬йءǷչ󻬼Ǹĸ
ֹ۵ĸʵϣΪصθܵȷܵβȶһ棬ƺҲܱ۶ϵؽθ˥ܻ
ţΪģθʱ뾭ø͸ĸ˳άƽзչθ˥ܼϵֲȫͬ
ӹϵдڽһ̽֡
    ͢٣Huntingtonָƶ˥ܵ⣬ڴִһֱΪ[1]8687ҳ] ˵Ϊֹ
Ը䶯˥ȻȱоθЧӦ֮һθȻһϵһзչ׶Σ
ڸϵĸ׶֮ų̶ȡʽúȴͬնͬһϮڽͲ
˵ǲһģһУرתУθܶһͶһӦĳҲһ
ҳθϵ໥֮ȫ涯̬ϵǳһƫȫȷ˽θЧӦ
    ڴ˽ԹθоһĻϣ̽θηչ˥ܵĹϵ
һ۱䶯ĳ¼θЧӦ⡣θܣPolitical corruptionĸΪֹѧ粢һ
ձ鹲ʶĶ壬ֶ嶼䳤ͬʱִһȱ[2]θڲͬĹвͬ壬ͬĻ
ͲһͬһĻµĲͬſܶĿҲͬ˲ṩһձܹûܵĶ[3]63ҳΪ˻
ȡһɲĸĲNyeĶ壬 θܿǣΪ˻ȡ˽ˣ˽ϵĽǮλƫ빫
ɫְΪǹɫΥĳ˽ӰΪ¸ȹϵ̰۵[4] һҲǴѧǶ
θܱձܵĸ
            һͳθЧӦ
    θΪһʷȻ˼ۼйθЧӦȴ20֮ǰֻܴһЩ
˼ҵֻƬѰһټǶθЧӦĻ̬ȡ簢˶٣Lord ActonйءȨ¸ܣȨ
ܡԣʵϷӳ˴ͳ˼ձ鿴θһɲµʷ޹ţ  Rogow   ˹άLassw
ellָ˶ٵġȨܡһжϣ˵ЩռȨ˽ȨøֱֵθУ
ȨȨλΪ䲻Ϊ绤˼ϵԴǻ̵ԭ˵Ϊڱǻġ[5]2ҳȻ˶˵
ġܡ̶ܴǹϵθܣȻԺӰ켫ΪԶγɸٹ̴ӵθЧӦһֵ
Ӱ£൱ʱͳ˼ΪθֻһЧӦЧӦȻ˥ܡ
    20ͳ60֮ǰйθܵ״࣬ʱ漰θܵӢ״¿ԷΪࣺһйظθΪ
ʷойعҵθܵ鱨йθܵѧо[6]Щ״ע δϷθ
ЧӦĳЩ治ӳͳθЧӦ۵Ŀ粼³˹BrooksڡеĸܡһΪɹ
ĸ̰ܵᣬͳڶԹɴܵʧ򻵵ĵ°ĶӰ죬ԶڽЧʲߡ[7]4154 ҳ⣬
һЩ漰θܵ鼮硶ѧĵȣҲθΪһֲµΪ
[8]
    ͳθЧӦص㣺һֻθиЧӦ˽θܿ˥ܣֱ۵Ĺ۲죬ӵµĽǶȳ
θЧӦжϡǵµжϱϾܴѧоֱ۵Ĺ۲಻ܸԵķʵϰ˶ٵġȨܡ
Ҳм򵥻֮ӣΪȨԵ¸ܣҲʹ˸[5]130131ҳ⣬ȨԷܣ ûȨ޷Լ
ܡͳθЧӦȻθܱעĿĻ󣬵һƬԣнθܵĸЧӦԻδܶ
չȫۣȱо֧šҲڵʱûбҪȥͣڴͳθЧӦ۵֧£θֻиЧ
Ӧ̵ͬġһͨˡ
    ֵһǣʱᲢһ顣籾ͳһЩ־·ӳʵ֧Ϊ˵ľ
ǰ徫ʹҵ¡ģǺõģ谭ıǻģ¸ǲãҵǱĻͲô
̰Υ񡣡[9]48 ҳЩȻܵͳ˼뷽ķ侭֤
ܸ洦ǻ[10]501509ҳɼθЧӦĲͬʹˡ
            ɡθЧӦ
    ʵ50ĩһЩѧ߷෢չйҵθѴںܳʱ䣬ЩоճһȻѧ
θЧӦоĹע60ڣṹѧɵηչ۷һʱʹʱѧߣǵв˶ǽṹ
ߣͳθЧӦ۵ĵжϳɷݹ࣬Ƿ׷γɵνɡ
        1.г뾭÷չ
    г뾭÷չɵҪзLeffڡͨŸܷչáһŶθЧӦۣθ
ĳЩھ÷չ۾Ҫǣ
    һеķչйܶԷչúģҵҿԶҪԱܶҵһ⣬
ǳΪµȨģʱ¸ҵҽӽӰйؾߡ
    ڶչйȿǵ飨緢չ£¸һʹԱԾ÷չָĿһֿ
ṩֱӵļԶԱԱشҵҵ棬ҵ˵õȨŴȵȰ
    չйΪԤϣͶͻĸԤܿԼٲȷԣͶʰȫϵ߲
ʱҵҿͨлʹԱִһף˱һ
    ģڷյƷʱڻ¸˾ƣʹչйҴ¢Եг˾ɷݣ˷Ч[
11]
    з֮⣬϶ţTilmanҲƵΪչйҷԴʱƽ⡢ڹθʹ
һԴʱָͨ۸г۸񣬴Ӷʹ֮Чشﵽƽ[12]
        2.
    з֮󣬹ɶθܵЧӦΪΪϸ֤ҪΪףBayleyNye ʷأScott
ͰߣAbueva ֱڡչйҵĸЧӦ͡ηչ֮ۡƪо˶
θܴкЧӦҪɹ£
    1θܿܲЧӦ
    һʱγɡչй£ʱϡһۻȱչõʽθܻȡ󣬿γͶ

    ڶʹгչ˿лߵĳɱгرΪģôͨķг۸ԴͿܻ¸Ӱ
ҪĵطﵽԴгĺá
    ɨʽٽЧʡڷչй󣬰ЧʲθܿͨؽڣʹĮĹŻ
ζ߰Чʡ
    ģ㲻ͬἯŵҪȶءڹְԱ˵ܴθлмвŸɵˣ
޷ξߵ˺壬ҲθṩһĹͨ;ڲùֶΡ
    壬ڸϣٽͳһθܳϵֶΣŷչڣǸɱۺϵճϼ
ڹϹУȹϵ¸Ҳ塢֮ϵķ
    2θܿܲкЧӦ
    һ谭õķչܷӻȡʽδͶʣڻӻѣ⣬ʹԭȱʽΪѷ
    ڶ˷ѹԴΣгӶ𡢻ؿ۵ȷʽζԴɹĿתΪ˽ĿģйعͶʵľԴ
θӰƫȷ򣬱ȻԴ˷ѣгҡ
    θʹִȡĹְԱУǱְֻۣͬͬʱ߼ƻб
룬ƫԭĿ꣬λٻЧʵ¡
    ģƻṫܻǮ˿ڰʱٷѡûǮ˼ʹнҲѸٽ⡣ͬʱθʹ
ƸķƫȨǮˣΥṫξӢڸܣЧȣܻѭ
    壬ʹɥʧϷԣβȶθʹʧȥ֧֣ͬţƻĺϷԣΪ
û䡢ȨĽڣֶ[13]
    ⣬ʷڡθܹܡһУ֤θܾάϵȶĹܡΪӰͨѹ
ʩӵģչйûγЧΣӰִͨʩӵġθʽϵȱ
Ṧܵһָ꣬ԼϵʹϵԼҪĵ߸Ŭθʹ޷ͨʽҪõ
ɣֹ˿ܵµα˵ηչϵӦͨʽʽ;ԼǱڱĻ
ôθܾͲηչһµ[14]ͬڡȹϵ¸ηչĹסһУҲ϶θ
ڷչйڽ׶ϣдٽͳһȶ㷺롢ƶγɡɹŽƶȵãηչġԤԵ
ЧӦ[15]534539ҳ
        3.ƶ
    ˵ϵѧֻǸۡһȱڣôŶƶɴ͢һġں͢
θܶڽִĹ˵ں̶ܴϲ˥ܵηչҪ۵ǣ
    һ뱩ִĴ̼£߶ƶ֮£ʢбȸʢжϵи
вΪȻ߶ϵҪķǷֶΣҪΪ㣬ȴҪΪĿġ
    ڶһάϵĹܡǸǸ;÷չԣǽ
͹ڼȨģôһ縯һáһûиܵᣨ紫ͳ淶ǿĴͳᣩ˵һ̶ȵĸܻ
Ϊһܻӭ󻬼ɼִ·ϵ
    ŵĸĳɳôηչܵ谭ִĲʶβ뷢
չĲԸڴٽͬʱҲƻڵ[11]6469ҳ
    ˣ͢ʵϽչйҵθִܿıȻִڣθܱڴٽηչ
˥ܣΪķչƶȻĳ֣θܽˡƶָθܵĲͬЧӦϵĲͬչ׶
йأһ׷θܵۺۿܣǷǳдԵġȻ͢Ϊִθܻ˵Ŀֹ
ˣʵ֤Ǵģһ潫漰
        4.ɵθЧӦ֮
    ɵҪֲ˳ͳθЧӦ۵ļ򵥻ƬԵĲ㣬ָθܶηչиЧӦЧӦ
ԸֿܴڵЧӦķϵͳɣھ˸ַӶϸθЧӦ¶λθܵ
оһδչͬʱɶθһıĲԷʽ˽׼ȷĽ綨ָǽڱ͸֮һֺƽ
߸ִƶȵķǷֶΣͱйϵǣɵ۴Ҫȱݣһһ㻯⡣θʮָ
ӵ⣬ĳһθضϵչ׶ϵЧӦΪձڵһԴϵ©ڶ
֤ƫ߼۱ȱо֧ţӰ쵽۵ĿŶȡθЧӦǿн
ûȷشθܵЧӦ˭ǵһԵģҶθЧӦתΪЧӦƲ㣬̸
пЧӦ
    ֮ҲǺܵҪԭ򡣱ϾθܵЧӦȣЧӦΪԣɢʧأһ
ϵĴݻκθܵĸЧӦθܸЧӦЧƵ£ЧӦʵû
ж壬ĳֲкδЧ֮ǰԶǷǳΣյһ
            ɶθЧӦ۵벹
    70֮θԽԽΪȫԵвչйҵθܼʢУҷҵθҲƵƵڴ˱
һЩѧ߷׷׳ɵġۡΪθβĹߣʹңθҲ֤
ҹܵЧӦϵ[16]ЩθЧӦ۵ˣе׳֮ΪɡΪ֮
Ϊɡ׼ȷΪмѳ˹ɵķ롣
    һʱڵҪҪࣨBen-dorġܡ ƶȻηչ˼£GeraldͿ٣Caiden
ܡκɣWernerġоơޣCarinoġ޵ĹŸܣԭ򡢺ơ
Robin TheobaldġܡչͶȷչLienġЧʡϣҷңShleiferάVishnyġܡ
ðޣMauroġ뾭ȡ
        1.θ澭÷չ֮
    ɹθ澭÷չ⣬Ҫ۵㣺һҵҿͨ¸Ӱľߣʹ֧Լƫã
ԴЧʣʱۡ70йо⼸۵ʵ
    θǷٽ÷չΪҪôͱ֤뾭йܻߴھ֮ǰߴ
ھڼ䣬ܴٽھ÷չ֮󣬸ܾӦ١Ǵձ¡ɫеȹִչǡǡ෴
Ǿ֮ʢеģڴ֮ǰžչ[17]ϣҷҺάָܸܳΪ÷չĴۣ
һΪʹź͹Ա˽˻ߣɾ÷չߣǸܵԣʹһҵͶ
ɸ߼ֵתʩάĳһ¢ϣֹ谭Ͷʺ;
[18]˵ƪҪǴָɵĲ֮۾ȱݣð޵ġ뾭ֲⷽ
Ĳ㣬67Ҵ19601985Ĵݣ֤˸ͶԼһָ[19]
    ҵǷӰԱ֧ԼƫãºͿΪ֮ԷθйЧӦΪҪܿ
˵ƫΪ֯ƫΪʵںһ£ƫΪѳΪ̬ΪǷǷģͶԸʹ¾
֮³ΪߣԼԼƫ[20]
    ۵һ׶θЧӦоһ½չϿˣBeckգMaherò֤ йͨ
¸ﵽЧԴļһܶϣ⣺
    һȡĿĹУÿ˾ֻ֪Լɱ֪л߹˾ĳɱ롰棬ɱ
Ĺ˾ϢжϣֻСʻ߽ȥȡĿ˾ȴΪӮĻʻ߽ղһɱ
͵Ĺ˾Ŀͬ
    ڶʵУܹԱĿ˭ǽƾ߽ѹϵȿǡô£ɱĹ˾
ҲһͻĿͬ˵ʹû¸ֶʱЧʷĿʼǴڵ[21]ʻ¸һԴЧ

    ھоͲ۷ʹθЧӦ۷͸Ǻоֶϵ·չȻҲк
ɵͣһ㻯ĶжϣΪθܷʽȡĽǮǻʿкڻӻͶ[
17]δʵں̶ܴҲ޷֤θһָ߶ػκα¶ĲֻǱɽ֮һǣʼ
жϺнǿ˵
        2.θܾάϵ֮
    йθܾάϵܵĻ۵ҲҳҪ۵㣺һθܿЧʣθ
ϣθܿԴٽƶȻչԴ˺ѧͬ˼
    θܿЧʣHopeΪʵϲˣΪµĴۣⲻʹ֧󡢻
գս˰ҪչĿ룬ʹܵĹҸʧ[22]ˣʵ
Чʣᡢúηչ谭áΪ߹ְԱʿЧʵĿ©ģһֻ
йְԱܻߵ²ֻܳһ˵棬һδʿ䣻ʹЩܸǮܾ
Ǯ˲ܵõЧʵķĴۣνٷѡԳΪԱߵĹ[23]178179ҳ
    θϣκWerlinӼɵľָθܲãսʧȥΣ
ƻĺϷԣ̨[24]ָϵҪһСˣˡ͡ز̡ȣ²Ǻ
漰еģƽиǡǡ޴ڵ[17]⣬ŵ£Gould³Xiaobo LUҲֱ
йľо֤θܻκϷԶβȶ[25]
    θܷٽƶȻչ޷һԣָڶڿΪİʹ
ڵĲֻƶ[23]193ҳ ҲΪϷһӰҪʽ
ôֻи̺йϵ˲ӰǸȨԶǻȨ΢СȨͬʱӾ᲻ƽȣӾѺ
ɱĳͻս뱩ֹѭȥ[26]130131ҳʹԣθܶƶȻչġ
͢ԤԣִչĺڣչƶȻĳ֣θܽһٻƻʹԼˡһԤԿ
κڡθܵķչɫиоһָθܵĻʹܹƶȻƽзչʢв˥[27]Խ
ԽʵҲ֤һЩŷ޷صθȻ[28]
    θ澭÷չȣɶθάϵܵԵñһȱµ۷һ
Ҳھо㷺رǶִչڣûоһйصҲָܴ
ڸָڲͬıвͬıַʽ˲бֶвɼԼĹͬ[29]ɼθĸҪ
оʱҪԲͬ͵θڲͬϵĲͬչ׶ϵЧӦķȻûһ㡣
        3.θЧӦ۵Ĳ
    ѧɵҪ۴ͬʱָокԵһЩ棬Ҫûע⵽θܵɢʽ
ڲƽȺĻθЧӦ֮о
    ڷθܵЧӦʱǹֹضԴδܿһЩΪӵı仯ϵʵθе
ɢʽСģĸЧӦģĸЧӦתЧӦʱҲᵼЧӦתκɽɢʽ֮Ϊ
ЧӦThe spillover effectΪֻҪɣܾͻᡰӰȶ֯ĸಿ֣ɵ⡢
ĮЧӦθܵġЧӦҪ;һ׷ߵĸܻӰ׷ߵΡҳϺ˼
һָָܵһ͵ĸܺϷʹ͸ܺϷǸܻһƶһƶҪ
бҪԣҪڿޱҪڿԳΪɹֶ[30]£SyedһЩθܵ
ɢʽ硰ЧӦMetastatic effect ͡ЧӦClustering effect СЧӦָܾаתʱϸ
ֲܿޱһйؼűּǿӰ칫ڣʱЧӦͷˣЧӦָ໥
ʹһָһָܴһ𣬵¸[31]138142ҳɴ˿θܵɢʽʹ֮
һӿθЧӦͣԭзΧڣЧӦתΪЧӦСģĸЧӦᵼ´ģĸЧӦκ
θ֮ܵĿȻǷǳΣյġ
    θЧӦʱ漰ĻͲƽȷ棬Ҳ䲻ط֮һָܶ˵ЧӦʮָ
ͶģӰǵľӰ쵽ǵķչ˵ܵͷףͬʱ
ٽ[31]125ҳҲΪ ܵʢм벡̬ʽأ벻ΡˣСıƵʱϢйأһ
ʱϢ򣬶չ򣬶һĺʴãάֹĵ¡ּ˵ĸ
ȶƽȵݵ[26]130ҳ ڸܶԲƽȵЧӦ棬Լ˹٣Johnstonڡܣƽһָ
ӰвƸȨʵʷ䣬ԴάִеĲƽȣһǴٽ˲ƽȡƸȨΪֹ
вִı[32]1337ҳˣθйִ̺᲻ƽȵЧӦ˵θھη滹Ѱ
ҵЧӦôĻ벻ƽȷȴκЧӦԡ
        4.θЧӦ֮
    ںɶɵͲ䣬θоֻһδķչѧϵĹ׿ԹΪĵ㣺һҳ
ϵĲ㣬ʹеθЧӦܵһμ飻ڶȷθܵĸЧӦǵһԵġձڵģɿ
θЧӦ򣻵µоھоɼģθЧӦĳЩڲ仯ϵ
һЩµо
    ǺɱҪּҳϵȱݣڴһۣ˾һЩµоֶΣڽۺ
۷ܷȴûʲôȻɴ෽֤θܵĸЧӦձڵģȻȴûжθ
ܵЧӦǷشעޱʾɵļ裬ζǵļ費ȷ  Ledivina  V. Cari
no1986⣬ ҲʾܼʹЧӦҲǲܻӭģӦܵؿRobin Theobald1990ⶼ
ɲδȫϸܵЧӦûжԿܴڵθЧӦηչĹϵһʵ½θܵĸ
ЧӦԻˡһ˵ɵ70ܵʵҪȴδеȫѧؿθ

            ġ
    θḴӵ֮һθηչ˥ܵĹϵҲͬǸӵġͨعθЧӦۣۺϸ
ɸҵĹ۵㣬ڴ˶θηչ˥ܵĹϵһۺԵ۷ܣ
    θĸԣü򵥻ķȥθηչ˥ܵĹϵҪ෽桢η֮
ڹ
    ܵ˵θܡǸı״󣬵ܴ֮θ뱩ͬϵǷҪֶ
ͬǰ߲ȡƽķʽ߲ȡķʽǰ߽ϺߴСΪϵɣθͬǺƽı
ʽͬǰ߲ȡǷֶζ߲ȡϷֶΣǰ߽Ϻߴ۴״֢θ뱩ֻ߽⡢ƻеƶ
ͬʱƶȴ£ȴڳɵͬʱһƶȡݴ˿θ뱩ΪǷֶΣڴϸ
սֲʲ۴ӵ¡ƽǶȻǴӷչʵǶȿǣһ¸ʵηչѷʽθ
뱩ǲȡģ֮±Ϊȡ
    ܵ˵θܵĸЧӦǵһԵģձڵģǲܾԻΪκθܶЧӦȻһ£
θܵЧӦԣڲݷϣʱûҵθЧӦЧ籩ʱ
ھдݿࡢɨϵһθִں͸ĸʱҲʹ̵ľɹ淶ʧЧٽĴ߻á
ĳЩⷢչ׶ϣʷʱͨΪԼٵ·ġˣθһ˵谭ηչģᴦһ·չ
ϣɹ淶ᷢչĸδʱӳᷢչҪĳЩſܲθΪ߽ɹ淶ͨȲøߴ۵ı
ֲȴңңڵĸм·Ϊηչص·ȻθܵЧӦӦ׷Ŀ꣬θܸЧӦ
ӦĶ
    óθһҪǸЧӦֻ²žЧӦĽۣһ򵥵ĻԶԶܸ
ЧӦĸԣ¼εĽһ
    һ͵θܶиЧӦ͵θͬʱһἯŵҪ˸ЧӦҲһЧӦ[
33]ȻθЧӦʵǲתŵģЧӦЧӦתСģЧӦģЧӦţθЧӦͣ
ԭзΧ͹ģ֮ڡθܵЧӦҲתΪЧӦΪչйǰ󻬼òǹ̶ġ
    ڶθЧӦתǵϵأ͸߶̬ԡ۽θܿܶϵЧӦ
ϵһΪԾء仰˵ֻע˻Ӱ죨θܣΪ壨ϵĵãδעΪķ
ӦʵϵθܵķӦ൱ҪģᵼЧӦתθܵЧӦʱϵиĬϺ
ᵼԷչתΪЧӦθܵĸЧӦʱϵѹȡʩǿƣᵼƶȻչתΪ
ЧӦȻתҲǾԵģϵθܸЧӦѹʵƶȻķչпܵΣ
    ڲͬϵչ׶ϣθܷܿӵЧӦ಻ͬһϵٽȫȱӦʱθܱΪ
Ĵ߻𵽡֮ҲãȻ˥ܣܵηչһִչе
ϵθ·չʼ׶οĳ޵󻬼ãµĹ̼ͻƻ÷չִļٽ׶ΣԱ
¶ת͹ξʵƶ֮Ĳ࣬ʹϵǿƶȻʱϵ㹻Ӧθܶͣ
ηչƱᵼ˥ܡˣһθܶȻ˥ܣһִеθܶȻ
ηչ
    ϿԽθηչ˥ܵĹϵӻˣ֮䲻бȽϹ̶ĹϵθһЩ±Ȼ
˥ܣĳЩضȴʾ෴չĿԣյĽηչ˥ܣθܿܶ
ϵЧӦжϣȡ֮໥á໥ΪؼϵӦˣθܵĴ
жηչ˥ǹڼ򵥻ˣҪѰҴΨͨи뷴ܵҪùǷ
ƸܲȶᡣΪеĹθеĹȴܾθηչ˽͡
һµļ裬дڽһľо֤
οס
    [1] Samuel P. Huntington,   Political  Order  in  ChangingSocieties M.New Haven: Yale University Press, 1968.
    [2]Ting Gong, First Charpt, The Politics of Corruption  in Contemporary ChinaM. Praeger ublishers (U.S.A), 1995.
    [3]Leslie   Holmes,     The  End  of  Communist     Power:Anti   -  Corruption Campaigns and Legitimation Crisis M.Ca
mbridge: Policy Press, 1993.
    [4]J.S.Nye, "Corruption and Political Development: A Cost- Benefit Analysis"J.The American Political Science Review,L
XI,2(June 1967).
    [5]Arnold A.Rogow & Harold D.Lasswell,  Power,  Corruption and Rectitude M.New Jerser: Prentice-Hall,Inc,1963.
    [6]Colin Leys, "What is the Problem about Corruption"J.Journal of Modern African Studies, 3:2(1965).
    [7]Robert C.Brooks, Corruption in American   politics  and LifeM.New York:Dodd,Mead, 1910.
    [8]See Paul H. Douglas, Ethics in GovernmentM. Harvard University Press(U.S.A),1953; Paul H. Appleby, Morality   and 
Administration  in  Democratic  Government M. New    Yord:Greenwood Pres, Publishers, Reprinting in 1969.
    [9]Lincoln Steffens,The Shame of the CitiesM. New York:Hill and Wang,1957.
      [ 10] Robert  C.   Brooks,   "Apologies  for   Political Corruption"A. in  Arnold  J.    Heidenheimer,   Political 
Corruption:   Readings in Comparative Analysis C.U.S. A.:Holt,Rinehart and Winston, Inc,1970.
    [ 11] Nathaniel  H  leff, "Economic   Development  Through Bureaucratic Corruption" J.American Behavioral  Scientist 
8:3(November 1964).
    [12]Robert O.Tilman, "The  Effects  of  Corruption  in   a  Developing  nation"J.  Public   Administration    Review,
September/October 1968.
    [13]David H. Bayley, "The  Effects  of  Corruption  in   a Developing nation"J. Western Political Quarterly, XIX,  4(
December 1966); J.S.Nye,"Corruption and Political Development: A Cost-Benefit Analysis".
    [14]Scott, James C," An Essay on the  Political  Functions of Corruption"J.Asian Studies, 5:3(December 1967).
    [15]Jose Veloso Abueva,  "The  Contribution   of  Nepotism,Spoils, and Graft to Political Development "A.in Arnold J.
 Heidenheimer, Political Corruption: Readings in   Comparative Analysis C.
    [16]Simcha B.  Werner,   "The  Development  of   political corruption: A Case Study of Israel" J.Political   Studies(
1983), XXXI. Another see D. Gould,  Bureaucratic   Corruption and Underdevelopment in  the  Third  World M  . New  York:P
ergamon Press, 1980; J. Dobel, "The Corruption of a State"J. The American Political Science Review, 72(1978).
    [17]Gabriel Ben-dor,   "Corruption,   Institutionalization,and Political Development: The Revisionist Theses  Revisited" 
J. Comparative Political Studies, Vol.7 No.1, April 1974.
    [18]Andrei Shleifer and Robert W. Vishny, "Corruption" J. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,August 1993.
    [19]Paolo Mauro,"Corruption and Growth"J.The Quarterly Journal of Economics August 1995.
    [20]Gerald E. Caiden and Naomi J. Caiden,  "Administrative Corruption" J.Public Administration Review, May/June,1977.
    [21]Beck, P.J.and M. W.Maher, "A Comparision  of   Bribery and Bidding in thin Markets "J.Economics Letters 20(1986);
Da- Hsiang    Donald    Lien,   "Corruption   and   AllocationEffieciency" J.Journal of Development Economics, 33(1990).
    [22]Kempe Ronald Hope,   "Administrative  corruption   and administrative reform in developing states" J .Corruption 
and Reform, No.2, 1987.
    [23]Ledivina   V.Carino(edited),  Bureaucratic  Corruption in Asia: Causes, Consequences and Controls C.Manila:  JMC 
Press Inc, 1986.
    [24]Herbert H. Werlin, "The  Consequences   of  Corruption:The Ghanaian Experience" J.Political   Science  Quarterly,
March 1973.
        [ 25] David  J.   Gould,    Bureaucratic   Corruption Underdevelopment in the Third World:The Case of  Zaire M.Ne
w York: Pergamon Press, 1980; Xiaobo   Lu,   Organizational Involution and Official Deviance: A Study of Cadre Corruptionin C
hina. 19491993 M. Doctoral Dissertation,  University of California at Berkeley, 1994.
      [ 26] Robin  Theobald,   Corruption,   Development   and Underdevelopment M.U.S.A.:Duke University Press, 1990.
    [27]Simcha B.  Werner,   "The  Development   of  political corruption: A Vase Study of Israel" J. Political  Studies(
1983), XXXI.
    [28]Davld Nelken,"The Judges and Political Corruption   in Italy"J.Journal of Law and Society, Vol.23, No. 1,  March 
1996.
    [29]"Corruption and Reform:   An  editorial  essay"  J.Corruption and Reform, 1:3,11(1986).
    [30]Simcha B. Werner, "New  Direction  in  the   Study  of Administrative Corruption" J.Public Administration Review,
 March/April 1983.
    [31]Syed Hussein Alatas, Corruption:its Nature, Causes,and Functions M.England: Athenaeum Press Ltd.,1990.
    [32]Michael  Johnston,   "Corruption,   Inequality,    and Change" A. In Peter M. Ward ed., Corruption,  Development,
and Inequality: Soft Touch  or  Hard  Graft? C .   London:Routledge,1989.
    [33]կƽ.ԸܵһֹܷJ.ᣬϺ1994 12.
    
    
    
 
