 ׺ 6-246
ԭĳѧư
ԭ
ԭںš199904
ԭҳš122128
  šD0
  ѧ
ӡںš199906
    ΪηչоԵ
    
߼顿ѧϵ
ҪηչоԵѧظﱳ߷˴ͳѧΣΪѧƱ
Ĺ׺壬ָɴ˲Ŀѧо۷ģʽոı˱ȽѧоּȤӶΪηչоṩ
ʵѧԴ۴µ
  ʡͳѧ/Ϊ/Ƚѧ/ηչо
    
            1.
    ηչоȷĶͷΧǹڵɴͳִҵαǨоǵ
ѧбȽѧһҪ䶦ʢʱڣȽѧĿγáݰšܹоص㼸Χηչ
չκαȽо̸ηչ۶Ϊһֲԭµȱݡ
    ȻηչоƾղģΪһֶԵо㷺ӰۣҪйѧ߽϶عע
սԵε¸ֶڴƱȽѧߵĵޣ̶Ȳͬظı䵱оȤζ壬ָξ߼ų
ȫΡáηչоĳϣηչоĶηչоķΧĿꡢ
Ⱥ⡣Ǻȷġǣ۱ķչһЩѧƵġԪۡ۵ۣıηչо
ĹϵƺעûʵϣǰҶѧһʱıΪηչоһΪҪ
ûΪڿѧԭ֮ϵĿѧо۷ģʽ޴̸𡪡Ϊηչ۵ṩ˼ʵ
ѧԴ۴µˣѧķչһԵĻعˣڴݱηչ۵ĹǱҪ
ǱĵĿġ˳ҪָǣΪȱҲηչоʢת˥һԭԲкΪͼﲹ
            2.ͳѧΣΪĵ
    ѧУ淶оNormativeʵ֤оEmpirical⺯⡢۷ѧʷĽǶȿ淶о
ԴԶʵ֤оΪһѧɣ20ͳ¡淶оǹŵѧûй淶оѧ˵ʷϵ
˼ϵΪԶѻԶԹ淶۵Ϊʵ֤оҲʧȥѧϵĺϷԡ
    ѧ淶оĴͳɿʿ¼ͬʱۡеĹ淶ۣͼͬŵʿµ
ȡϵע[]˹롤ķۡӡݣ1990꣬14ҳΪ淶оĵߣ
ʿʮӻĵб׼ΪԹԭϣչ˵ĸͶڵ壻Щ
ֻչͳǵͶǴı̬ƫ룩עʿ£ѧӡݣ19951棬
32ҳ ֹ۵ԴңǰռԭΪ˵ȻԵĿۣΪκ˺ƶȶһԱֵ
͹ĿģĿĿΪ淶жṩһιͬĿǴٽĳҵɾҵĹͬǺϺµġ
ʿʵϸ˹淶оķһѧҴµĻǹ淶ĻЩ¡ͼֵжϣ˵ҪĲ
ǻشʲôǡӦʲô֡Ӧáܲ⣬ǶԱϵĴ򡪡ν͹Ľʾ
    ִͳѧϾ
    о󿴣ԼԹΪĵȨͷƶǴͳѧעĻݡ˹ΤΪǣ׿гЧأҪ
ԼһΧںϷ¢αΨһԴȪ˶˵ڹ֮һ֮ڵȺȨ
ӰȨķ䡣עMax Weber,Essays in  Sociology,  H.Gerth and C.Wright eds.,N.Y.:Oxford University Press,1946,  P.28
Ȩͳһԡ ͳһԺͳһڴͳѧعɹҵҪءǰ߱ΪҪĵλΪҵĸ
ԡһָڸ˲ʹ˸ľԵõȨԺѧҰΪȨȨߡѧɡȻ
ѧԼĲҲԼļ໤ΪձķҪʶңܲоķƶȡˣ19ǰ
ѧΪ֮ѧȨ֮ѧ֮ѧ
    о;ͳѧʹõҪѧġʷġɵĺƶȵġ͹ŵѧķһеġͳѧѧߺ
ŵѧѧ߶һЩͼùձ֪ʶ͡йﱾʵġѧҡǵĽ
ѧƫȲѧѧѧǸʱ֪ʶϵڣѧѧĿܷԭ򣬹滮
ʵĸƷ        ѧҰˡ֣EricVoegelin˵һҪѧԭ򣬼Ϊѧ
ͬʱҲһʷۡעEric Voegelin,The New Science of Politics,Chicago:University  of  Chicago     Press,1957P.1
ά˹˵пάѧʷεĽͳѾԽһ㷽۵壬Ϊѧ֮
ԴȪ19ѧеĸԾ˵ģʷǹȥΣڵʷˡʷѧҺѧʵϲͬ
оע[]סC.ˣѧΧ뷽㽭磬1987꣬41ҳڷɵĺƶȵķ
ڴͳѧĻоݵĹ淶£ѧԭΪƶȺͷɷоҲ˳µ¡
    һоӳһʱѧ򣬷ӳһʱѧѧ֮ҪϵԼΪԼ̶ֻȣ
ֶѧƵķչ̬ʩ޴Ӱ졣ͳѧĵѧƱ߽ģ19ǰʢеѧġʷġɵ
ƶȵоġͼġѧһѧѧĹΪӢλǣӵĴ
磬ѧҿɢģѧҿߵĳ˼ѧҰΪ¼֪ʶ֤ʷѧǳǰ
ʷϵ͡ͳѧһݶѧƶģѧɫϵչ´ֶȡĿģоķ
ѧƵ·ꡣ磬ʷĴʹþʹ19͵ѧҡϰοѧΪһʷѧơע[]סC.
ˣѧΧ뷽㽭磬1987꣬40ҳ˹̹׻Цͼھѧѧ֮仮һ
˷ѡע[]÷ķ˼롷ӡݣ1988꣬243ҳ
    ͳѧѧƷ൱ʱﱻΪȻ淶ооġ淶Գɹ԰Ȼ̬
ۡѧԴصŷȥѧѧ˵ѧ롣˵ѧŷⷽˮųģ
¶ŷ޵һЩصǺȻġȻѧǡǡ߼ͳѧԶʱĵѾʼ
һΣĲôͳѧΣʲôطأ
    һӦѧս19ҶҵͿѧͻԷչˡѧ͡ĵйȻ֪ʶѸ
ʶΧһ̣ͬ۲졢ɡĿѧӦڴѧ
ҼӦ˼жз棬ֶԿѧĳ˿ѧ˼˼ƶ£ѧγһ
Ĺ۵㣺һ۶Ҫھ飬ֱӻӵ֤֤ʵƷѧоҪĿ͹ʵоʵĻ
γɿ֤ľֹۡ۵ֱԵǴͳѧĹ淶ھ߿淶оķڿѧʱѾԵ׽⣬
ʱˡѧжʵж϶Ǽֵжϣѧǡֵġע[]סC.ˣѧΧ뷽㽭
磬1987꣬32ҳɴ˶ۣѧҪΪѧֻͨѵжϵĹ̻ͨӵжвϳѳĹ
ﵽע[]ղķ˹A.Ŷ¡ɭءV.ɪ˹ȣִ˼롷ӡݣ1985꣬63ҳͳѧġصľ
ԡǡǡܰѻܳѼֵĹƣоѡۺͼֵ۵ͬӶʾѧ
ʡоķʽ˹ΪѶɡʷ塱Ǵŷ޴ͳŴǵģѾʹɥʧȵĻ
áע[]ά˹٣ϵӡݣ1993꣬219220ҳҪָ˹ڵһЩѧ
ͳѧĹ淶ʱ򵥵ط񶨼ֵ淶ѧоеĺλΪŵѧ춨Ĺ淶о򱻼ڴ˵ĺ
ۼҷӵ£оĿѧҲûнμֵ뵱ǰʵĹϵѧġƶ

    ڶܽ͹֮ķʽ֯ĴںãܽͿƶԭ㣵ι̡ŶԹ淶Уͳѧ
оҲȫļ֮СҡΪѧʼյ⡱ܵԸɡ˹Ϊ
2500һԵķ磬úӵĸһѧ˵һֿµȱݡšӦȫ
ơע[]ά˹٣ϵӡݣ1993꣬103ҳǣ⻹ ͳѧϾ
Թһͨ˵ġҪ˵Ȼֻһ壬ֱӶ塣ȻáҵҪءͳһ
˿ںȨң˹طԼǩ17ǰʷڣֻܵóκιҴڡĽۡ
ע[]ά˹٣ϵӡݣ1993꣬104108ҳͳѧѹΪĺоݣҵ
ȴҪȡͳѧоΧǴͳѧһۡѧΪ20ͳ𣬹ԽԽܺεļΪ
ḻݣڹ֮⣬ķʽ֯塢ڽ塢ߵƶִеаҪĽɫԴͳѧҲ
һϾս⣬ͳѧעشƶȺͷʶͷûпʽΡͼʽε
һƶԭ㣵Ĺ̡ʵϣ塢Ȩ⡢ЭġӢѡߡ̼뷴Ӧȵද̬
ҪȾ̬ļܹεķоԵӰ졣֮ܶͳѧԹҡȨƶࡰ¾ɡѧʷ
ķ޷αӿȵĳʽ΢һԭ
    μֵ䡣һЩѧԣ۽жʶ̬ռ֧λʶֻ̬һ
壬ҪĳɹͼԼķʽʵԭҲж
ڴͳѧУһֹڸҹϵѧ˵˼¿ԱΪһмֵռʵ˵ĸԣ
ʵ˵ĸԵʽڴͳѧУһִƶȡľձĵ
ѧ淶оѹϵⲻżȻġȻһսıҡǶμֵġۼһ
ɭ˵˵ҾĵģȨΨһߣǴӱȵ˻Ů˸ʵöϽĺϺµĶ
֯ôΪʲôûڶϵнһֵءע[Ӣ]L.T.˹ζѧĹۡӡݣ1996꣬ 107ҳ
Ƚִų׷ɵİ֮໥ɱԼǶɫֵĲпūʹͳѧʾΪһַ̡
ֵԤ뵱ʱضʵ౳ʧȥѧϵĺϷԣǴͳѧ̵Σڡ
    ǣѧʱڵһרʣΪ
            3.Ϊ󼰹
    紫ͳѧΣɿѧΪҲǿѧѧĽѧҪԭ
ڷʵĻϸĳۻ˵ܹձõķԼ֤ʵһԭΪо
ּȤλھ⣬ǹ淶⡣Ծ֤Ϊģǿ֤ģжһǼ٣
Ǽֵжϡƫã޷֤ġ֮ѧΪѧͲѧĴͳѧ֮ǰ
ֵسֵּϡˣΪΪдͳѧγɵµӦǷģǱģǽ͵
ģΪȷηͽ۵Ŀ͹뾫ȷǿѧҪҲǿѧıʶѧ㲻ȫֵҲӦö
ֱֵ̬ȣٲܰѼֵѧҪ¹оĲ֡ע[]˹롤ķۡӡ
1990꣬78ҳ
    ֹ۵ΪԼоĻλΪΪƶȡΪ忴ƶѧһ
Ҫ棬ѧҪأѧӦعעλĻԼΧΪʹһǿҪʹ
ʷϣоϵķɷ棬ҲƶȵҪԣǱʶʷ˵ΪɵģƶغΥɵ
ƶȲΪģʽϡע[]סC.ˣѧΧ뷽㽭磬1987꣬4647ҳΪ
оƫڸΪΪΪѧγνۺֹ۵㡣ѱòôҪˣ󲿷ѧ
߼ȳϸΪģ͵ЧԣҲ۰ѸṹмԿĺԡʵϣΪΪѱΪ΢
Σ壩ͺ۲Σ壩ϵͳһηģ
    ΪоĿѧϽԵ׷оʽҪǶǶԷɴ˷չѼʵϵ
ʽ۲졢ģʵ顢̸绰̸ʼʾʴȵȣҲദʵϵֶΣݺȺͼ
طⶨ;ԪعԷͼȵȡЩУѧΪڡѧáο
ķѧ˵ûʲôܱܿͳľģҲûʲôܱܱ
ϵٵľ޴ѡ˵ΪصǲȷԡԺȨԣ˵ѧԶȻѧȷ
Ԥ⡰ε˶ѧֱܹȷԤεıǨΪѧ֧ͳѧһ̶
ѧѧһֺΪΪѧ
    ȻǾģΪģģôϺ߼ҲͱȻǶ̬ģǾ̬ġΪó
һҪķԭһ̡һ̣ζεʵʲƷǼ򵥵ϵ涨õˮ߳ģ
ϵʽתıⲿʽƶȹ淶ιʾһϵʵʡˣΪѧȤ
Ĳεʽεʵáι̡һ߸ԵĹѧоĴģתƣͳ
ѧоƶȡܷȨ˾ҡƺȿ⣻ι̹ѧעоβ롢Ļữ
ιͨ⡢桢ͶƱΪ漯šƶΪ˸񡢴ڴͻȵȡһµ
˵ѧעȽηϺ磬1987꣬93ҳ
    Ϊӷչռλʮʱ䡣֮ѧ粻˻ΪһƫۣȷҲ
Щ⡣磬ǿоеġֵ¶ĳЩĽͲ԰ǰֵ˹ٺҲϣоʵ
޷رֵܼҪ˽ʵܵҪһߣǶʵĳЩѡĳذ˵ļֵͳɼ
ǹһʶϣŽԵһиоӡʹַֻܷԼʵΪһƫΪΪ
˷ߡ磬ֶεжӣһ淴ӳʱѧĿ͹ҪһҲʹĳЩضĲͶƱ
ѡоΪЩűȽʺܵоǿѧʣϾ粻磩ƣºѰѿ
ѧձƹ㡣עμHeinz Eulau ѧΪо֮šJames C. Charlesworth η
֣1981꣬45ҳˣѧڴѧѧʷѧȴͳѧƵӰѳʼԼѧƱ߽ͬʱȻһ
ѧѧѧ;ѧз˶ɹѧнøͿԼ񣬶ǡǡֻƾΪ
뷢չɡ˹˵ѧڷһµĸսںҪжѧơ
רҵʹѧעת[]ɵ¡H.أȽѧۡѧ׳磬1998꣬25ҳ50
Ϊĳ£еĴѧοѧϵ˴ΪΪоѧΪĺо
㱻ãŴźʵΪѧռѧ֧λΪڱ鼰о򡣣ע
[]˹̹˹ȣѧֲᾫѡϾӡݣ1996꣬һ£
    ΪԶģѧƽ۽ĽǶȿΪףһʵоĿѧϣⲻ
Ǽ򵥵ػظȥƼʻڵĴͳ̬ά³1951귢ġΪоеĸҪءΪʽ
ΪܶձΪ֮⣬ΪҪѺصϵԼķ룬Ҫι۲Ұչ
Ϊڽѧƽ㷺еϵע[]ղķ˹A.Ŷ¡ɭءV.ɪ˹ȣִ˼롷
ӡݣ1985꣬154156ҳѧ໥оԼѧƵĸ۵㡢ϺоɹΪ֤
ص㣬һЩо⡢оĿоעµڶǹڶ۷ģʽɫۡۡӢۡ
β۵ȵȡЩ۷ģʽͼΪṩһֶΪȷΪ㷺ͬʱҲͼͺԤεʺͷչ
ѿǴһонͨ򡱵Ŭ˹ٵĹ۵㣬Ϊ忪۷ģʽУϡһ
ۡҪصͨʵϵͳۡϵͳ۵΢ǶΪ뻷ϵ
ʶ⣬ͬʱҲںΪȽоṩͨȫֵķ͸ݽ겵ӽǡ
            4.Ƚѧ
    ѧо͵ڴ˵۴ֱӵ˱Ƚѧ
    ҪָȽϷһµķԶڰͼʿµʱѾ㷺ӦڵʱоУͬȽҲ
һµάġۡӸֲͬĽǶ̽ȨĻȡúά֣˹ġά̹ɸձ
Ϊձ鷨ѧ˵ʷ϶ΪȽоķǣԣܴͳѧоӰ죬Ƚо
һֱȽоComparative Governmentصʽɽṹ档 Ƚѧ£Howard  J.Wiarda
˵ȽѧҪоĵɹҵܷͷɡǹעϵͳеģԺԺȨ
Ĺϵط˾Уѡٷ˵ȵȡǺ˻繫ۡ漯ŻǨ̡ߡΪ򹫹
ද̬⡣ ע Howard   J. Wiarda,Introduction to Comparative Politics, Wadsworth    Publishing Company,1993
,P.40.⣬ ȽоȤĵŷ޺ͱһֶӢ¹ͶЩνҪĹҡ
ЩѧġŷۡɵġȽϷȻʷԶҪһ־̬ԸƶȽṹж
ȣֶԱ漰Ҳƶȵһһ֣ܽƶͬǨԭ֮ڴͳѧĿ£Ƚоʵ
ֻһ֡Ƚѧעɵ¡H.˵ЩԲңΪоָоȽ
ѧڶһʽλĺͷġֱ̽ȽоˣȽѧרѱȽѧΪһ
оκνСıȽѧģоݵı׼ɵ¡H.أȽѧۡѧ׳
1998꣬4ҳ ϵıȽѧΪԺųֵġ
    ΪȻоԼӾ顢֤ѧ̵Ӱ˱Ƚѧоƫãʹεı
ϷȡΪʵģپʽƶȵоͽͷΪϽ;ȷ˹÷Lawrence Mayer˵Ϊ
ǰȽ౳Ӱ챾һֱһЩԽ͵ĶԺ󣬱ȽѧΪһñȽϷ
֤Ľ۵ѧƣȽѧϵһתʹԸӵ¼Ľͻ˿ԣ±Ƚѧ
ǰᡣ  ע  Lawrence   C.  Mayer,   Redefining Comparative Politics,SagePublications,Inc.,1989,P. 25仰˵
Ϊĸ죬ѧľҲȽϵأڡȽϷѾЩذԼѧѧĿѧ
˵ͬȻѧȽѧҲԼġʵҡϵͳеʵңȽѧʱ
Ե÷Щϵͳɽпѧʵ顣ڱȽѧУͬʵѧһʹü衢֤͡ݡΪʲô
̲סҪѱȽѧͬȻѧ עHoward  J. Wiarda, Introduction  to  Comparative      Politics,Wadsworth Publish
ing Company,1993,P.17
    ȻڵһЩȽѧ߲ڼΪ򵥵ذѱȽѧΪϸȻѧ˵
ѧУǲܺѵعʹЩҲڿѧʵظ֤ܵõͬĽʹʵķҲ
ʹڹ᳹ռ߼֤ͽ֮ĲԵķˣǲȽѧķͨһ֡
ǡֵĳ򡱣ǡģʽȻֱܻΪĿѧо˹ڻع˱Ƚѧ
չʱһ˸߶ȵָۡȽѧȥıȽоͳԨԴϵҲǶԸôͳķȽ
ѧΪĳЩʽĽṹǾԵġϽ̬ĻķӳƶֻĻʷϵ
⡣Ƚѧ˷ΧĻصоʹ뵱ѽоΪ˽ĳЩضĿѧ
˶ϡоȽͳǰ߶ѧƵأѧĵѧѧλѧͽ
ʷȵȡעHoward  J. Wiarda, Introduction   to Comparative Politics ,Wadsworth Publishing Company,1993,P.385387
    ѧƺ͸۷ģʽ뼫طḻ˱Ƚѧ̬ΪȽѧı仯
ѧѧѧѧ̬ѧѧԼǺѧγɵһЩԵѧ½߽ȽѧɱȽо¸
    ͬʱо⿪ʼΪȽѧ춨˼ʵϻֱƶˡоѧ뷢չ
2050𣬴ѧ߷׷ܵޡ޺ޣԵعҺ͵ṹϵϵͳĿ죬Ѽ˴ĵ
һϣʹȽоصԭխŷתƵĵ硣ȽѧоȤζתʵԵɣڶ
սķͽζȫ򻯵ʷڴͨ˶ĵ飬ΪȽоսȷİλҪ
زͬĻʷڽ̡ΡõĹ˽⣬ԱЧߡڣȽѧоҰͳ
ѧ֯ƶȽṹضĵΧڣչеϵͳall the world's political systems Լϵͳ
档ֱ£ԱȽоѧڿһµļԵηչӴˣηչ۷
һʱ60ĩ70ȫʢ
            5.
    ͢˵60ԴоԴΪɳһ𣬽ʶذעеηչϡЩ
ηչרҵѧҵҵУԺؿһϵĺۼǿʼʱΪչеĳһһרң׫
дйǵѧģȻ͡ǵġεĳһдһ飬̶ηչΪ㷺бȽʵоô
Ϊȡĸͷ൱Ȼͼ״оһʱֵĹϵйصĹϵȥ
ע[]˹̹˹ȣѧֲᾫѡ¾ӡݣ1996꣬149ҳǲġǣ ݱ
оΪĸƷΪʹȽѧҴѧѧյṹܡ롢
ϵһЩͱȽϲͬҺ͵Σо˿õϵͳĿܣӶо
ΪҪ۾ȷͳƼĸĽᡢ˿ڡúϵۻΪӵѧֶεƣ
෱ı֮Ĺϵ˿ܡԺ͢ע⵽ڡͳšоηչʱһγõǱ
ڡᶯԱηչעĿʹöݵķʽΪĽ
    ֮ܶηչΪĲΪΪηչоṩ˸ԵѧԴܡʵ֤
ϡģʽΪηչоṩһʱͿѧ¾ηչ۳ֺ۱Ǣʵںܴ
ΪƫģӶΪص淶оһĿռ䣬˹˵ηչоһؼԵ⣬
вƷϣܿΪȽεļΪооṩҲΪҪǣɹؼ
ۿ⣬Ҳʹۼֵѧʵ֤ѧеĿⷢеĹϵΪηչоԿ̲ݻ
ʽٶ԰ͼʿ˹˼ҵԿ⡣עFred W.Riggs,:ηչ
James C.Charlesworthη֣1981꣬390ҳ
α༭ƽ
    
    
    
 
