 ׺ 7-365
ԭĳϾʦѧư
ԭںš200005
ԭҳš310
  šD4
  й
ӡںš200012
    Ƹĸʵѧʵֵ
Ӣı⡿A  Theoretic  Logical  Analysis  of  the  Nature  of  thePolitical System ReformJIN Tai-junSchool of Economics,La
w and Politics,Nanjing Normal  Univ.,Nanjing 210097,China
    ̫
߼顿Ͼʦѧ  ÷ѧԺ  Ͼ  210097  ̫1963УϾʦ󾭼÷ѧԺڣϾѧѧϵ
ʿ
ҪѧϷƸĸȲθҲθвͬںߵʺص㡣ȷʶƸĸġ
ĸʣڼǿҹƸĸԺͿɿԣƸĸԾԺԣҪķָ塣
ӢժҪIn this paper,the author holds,analyzing  from the viewpointof theoretic logic,that political system reform is  n
either  apolitical revolution nor  a  political  improvement. Correctlyrecognizing the  "reforming"nature  of  the  political
  systemreform is methodologicaly significant to both the  enhance  ofthe orderliness and controllability of  the  political 
 systemreform  and  to  the  increase  of   the   consciousness   andinitiative of the political system reform in China.
  ʡƸĸ/θ/θpolitical   system    reform/political    revolution/politicalimprovement
    
    йţD62    ױʶ룺A
    ±ţ10014608200005000308
    һ͹ȵĹƸĸۣʮٿֽ¡йƸĸΪ۽עһȵ㣬
γμɹ۵㡣һƣƸĸһµΰ[1]p.32 Ӧƽ֮һ
ǿĸġʣŻԢθĸھøĸ֮С[2]p.26 ൱ʱڼάֺǿȨ
߶ȼеνȨơΪֹ۵˶Ԫŵ˼άѧǲѧģʵкġ
ƸĸȷǡǡӦҲֻһ֡ĸѧȷƸĸġĸʣǶ
ƸĸʶʵжڼǿҹƸĸĿɿԡԣƸĸԾԺԣҪ
ָ塣
            һ
    ƸĸֳθĸθθǱηչͬһϵе̶ֳȲͬ[3]p.398Ƹ
θηչֻʽ;ͱ̬ߵĲ֮ͬڣθǡһȫλĸݻپɵƶȺ
ϷģʽԱἯŲΣ½綨ιͬ壬ӽµμֵ׼ϷԵ¸µġлξӢ
ȨԼµġǿƶȡ[4]p.317θĸιϵƶȵڲƣͳν׼е
ΪάͳελеԾΪ˵Ƹĸ¼ֳθԡ
        1.θԸ׼Ϊ壬θĸ쵼Ϊ
    θһ׼Ʒһ׼ζɱȺ֮Ϊ׼֮Ĵģ
֯νڸĹУԱֳɽĸ׼͸ͳν׼Ӫθǽĸ׼Ʒͳ
׼µƶȵĻΪڸ쵼ĹĶٺ֯µһִģȺ˶ͳ˵к
ͻԡԤԺͲɿԡ
    θĸ쵼емƻвıе쵼ʼθĸ塣ⶩĸƻ֯
ԱиĸߣƶĸʩĸĹУ˷𡢲߻֯쵼áˣθĸĽһ㶼ڽ
Ϊܵļƻ֮֯¡
        2.θҪ־ǶȡȨθĸά͹ȨΪĿ
    Ȩεĺ⣬ȨĹϵıθΪζ߱ʽҪȨ
⣬Ҫı־ǶȡȨʵȨתƺͳ뱻ͳߵλıȡȨθĸĿģҲǹθ
ɹƶθ뷢չĸ
    θĸǶϵȨṹķչƣͳν׼쵼ͨƺлԼȨ
ǿԼȨЧܣһάԼͳΡ
        3.θϵƶȵĸΪָ򣬶θĸԲƻͳΪ޶
    θζͳȨı;ɵķɷıζеϵһ֯λƶ
ṹֵԼ쵼Ѹ١סҵת䡣
    θȽϣθĸ޶ȵģеϵĻϣͨеԴеġԣԲƻ
ͳΪͳͳν׼ĸ֮ڡͳν׼һ̶ͨṹƺߵĵ
ìܣҪ˳ӦʷķչǴҲ漰ͳò
        4.θһּҵıθĸһĹ
    θηչеʵķԾᷢչľ𵴣ˣһֶݶıʷϣеθڸ
뷴ԱȺͽʮ꣬йĶԹ񵳵θ1927꿪ʼ1949ʱ22ꡣǣ
ʷηչֻһֶݵݵĹУηչĹȡȺٶȶǳġ
    θĸﲻθڶʱڣͨߡһĸΪɡ츲ءı仯θĸηչ
ĻۣԣĿʵֲһͣҪһڶĹ̡⣬θĸ쵼Žеһмƻĳ
Ҫڲϵ͵ʵĹнУУĸϣڲΣԼͳεǰ£ѭ򽥽ɸĸ
        5.θ뱩ϵθĸԺƽķʽ
    θĻʽθıʺͳν׼ıԷֲġθǶ׼Ĵ󲫶˫
ȻҪ޶ȵضԱ͵װڵһԴзУȻǽ˫ҪҪѡֶΡ
ͬʱһͳν׼Ҫ׺Զ˳ʷ̨ҪԼյװв
ѹԣҪƷװͳߣ߱֯øıֱͳν׼ʧΪֹ
    θͬθĸǰͳߵļƻвֽ׶εؽУԾĺ;ֲĸĸΪԼչĽݣεġϷ
ԴͨΡɵ;𲽵ʵơƶȵĿġˣӸųģαʷ
һЩҵθĸгĳЩΪ¼ЩΪ¼ǾֲģҲǸĸͼġ
        6.θͨϵȫʱıᾭýṹθĸԾýṹΪȵ
    θһζԱβ룬Ȼɹ㷺ζԱβγɵȥٳξýṹı
    θ죬θĸﳣᾭúı仯ͷչģľúı仯ͷչھ;
ϵֳӶľøĸøĸ𾭼ϵṹʵַʽĵ͸ĸԱ
ᾭ÷չµҪʵֵιϵı͵[3]p.401ԴƶƵıʹߴﵽ⣬
ϣٽ
            
    θĸﲻбθҲͬθѧУθĸθûϸͬһ
political reformôߵĲأӦƶȺ֮Ľߡ֪ƶ
ϵһƶָͨͳν׼Ϊʵ׼ͳζȡͳηʽ̬ܺͣʵĹ涨
ԵȶԣƶȵıҪͨθ;ƶȵľġڵıʽʵʩʽ
ƶΪݣԹ˾Ȩü໥ϵΪݣɸ֯ʩӦκͷɹ淶
ᡪϵʵּȶҺĹΪְܣԹ̺ͷչĻáƶΪĿꡣƶȣʽ
ϵĶԺͿɱԡƵĵһȡθĸθķʽ
    ȻƶȲԣθĸθʵ𣬶߶ҪӸάִƶȺ򣬶ڼȶ
ƶȼܹڽеġƲ棬θĸĲǷǳԵġθǶдб׶˵ĻڣǺĵĺ
Ļڣĵεġϸ֦ĩڵֲ͸ƣ漰ƱתͻǨڵ͵䷶룬
Χ˾ŵȨϵеĳԼϵеĹܺ͵λı仯[5] ʵ϶
ΪЩάʲ׼ͳͻƶȵǰ½еģҲûбȨƺƿܡ 
    ӴϿ      θӽӢġPoliticalimprovementĺ塣
    θͬθĸǶԼȶƵı׶ĸЩ׶ƵĻڣѴﵽȽ
ĳ̶ȣˣЩ׶˵ĸζԭƵıȻƶȲ棬θĸάƶΪǰĿģ
ִϵеҵƣı仯ʹθĸбθƲ棬
θĸְ˲ʱ䣬˵һ̶ϵʱ䡪ԭƣʹθĸбθ
    ɼθĸθͳν׼ر쵼άּȶͳƶǰȡֵƵ
ԾΪھӦѡΪʽ͹ȡƱ׶˵ʡΧس̶ȣԼֱ׶˵̶̳ȣ
ȡͳν׼ֱ׶˵֪жϡǰһʱζͳμѡȷķʽƶȵ
ƺͳḶ́ǰ߲һ౳ʱζͳμŲȡ˴ķʽӦøʱ˸ĸ
Ӧøĸʱѡ˸ʽǵкִƶȵƺͷչرǵԭѴر׶ˣ
ʱٲȥƱϸ΢ں͸пθĸìܵĻۺͼ񻯣տ
θıͳıⷽ棬ն䲻ܲ˵һΪ̵Ľѵ
            
    θĸθθʺصѧҹľȻҹֽ׶εƸĸȲθ
Ҳθķ룬зǳġĸɴ˿ԵóҹƸĸʵҪָļʶ

        1.ҹƸĸƶȵ
    ΪйĻƶȣרƶȡ쵼Ķ൳ЭƶȣйᷢչıȻ
йʷѡǷйġΪӵƶȡһԽƶȵľʵʽ
ȴر׶ˡΪ̥ڸսʱڻȷڲǿ׼Ϊ١ͲǿָԼ
ƵĹγɺͷչģȻֲӦִ衢Ӧƶȵȱݺͱ׶ˣҪΪȨ
ּУأ⽨ӰԶδȵȡʮһȫǽеƸĸڼƶȵǰ
£дڵر׶ˣ׼ȷ˵ǸĸЩر׶˵ƣͽȫƶӦ
ƣݼȰںνṹаѵȨ֯ͬ֯ĹϵȨ֮֯ĹϵԼ롢طͻ֮Ĺϵ
ԭγȷƶȹ淶ְ΢νṹ;ʵУԭִͬ쵼ʽ֯ʽϵһͬ
ĸְܺ͹ϵһͬ쵼ɲѡϵһͬȺڵʵϵһùͨ顢Э̡ѡ١
ߡල⡢ȾġƶȻĳԹҵͳȨΡáĻеλѭƶȡ
淶ͳʹȨƾЩƶȡ淶ͳ֤򻯡ȶߵĿѧԡԣӶڸƶ
϶ھϡʱҵ߸ʵ[6]p.323ˣƸĸﲻǶƶȵĸ
Ƕƶȵķչơ
        2.ֺ͸Ƶ쵼Ƹĸĸ
    йƸĸй쵼ƶʵʩĸĸ￪սеһҪɲ֣ͼƿ쵼¯Ѱν
ͻơֻʹƸĸӸʧȥԡ緶ΧִҲв㣡ɻȱ
棬ȱһɸȽϳϵͳе쵼ãεĸĸͷչΪ̣һɹҺĻҺʧ
ΪҺ෢չйηչľͽѵһ֤ййΨһִ
йҵ쵼ļȨģйʷͳĻԡģʵ״ͺִҵʷ
Ⱦ飬йľáκҵķչؼڵƸĸȻҲ⡣йֻе쵼
ʵƽƸĸйǽʷ۶ջԴһǧԱĴ󵳣
䵳Ա鲼ȫظиҵҸ˵йڶܳ˲ţһ֧ӵӢнȫ绯֯
12ڹеĺȨλױȵġ
    ƸĸﱾҪ˵Ϊһϵͳ̣Ҫĸĸͬչ׽Сͻơ¾벻У
ͺĸĸҲСˣϵĸҲִֻ쵼вչĸĲ
͸ίܿǡͳһţĸĲʹʩҪֱػмƻСǱ֤Ƹĸȷǰ
óɹĻͨСһӡĸ﷽͡ݿƷļĸսԣױȴƣֻʹĸһʼ
¹ķԡΪĸȻᴥִߣȫļĸĸʹִصμŶе
вӶǱڷߡȫĸĸעĿġѸ͵ĺ͡ϲĸܳɹԭڴʱѴ
žʹ⼯ϵλˡ[4]p.317ʵİάĸİ¸ĸǰĸǷĸﶼǵ͵Ľѵ
    ֮Ƹĸ˳УҪֵ쵼һҪƵ쵼仰˵ͨĸƣҲ
ȷֹڹе쵼ĵλʵ˵쵼ⱾҹƸĸһҪݣȫ
ڼ쵼ԭرǸƵѡƶȣӸѡٹܣ˳ϵʵ֡ϵĹ淶[7]
ǿڼල͵Լƣȵȡ֮ ֻڵ쵼£Ըƺͼǿ쵼ΪҪĿĺ͸Ƹĸĸ
ȡóɹ
          3.ƸĸӦ뾭ƸĸﱣԻϵ
    ҹ20ĸĸʵκĸĸ벻ľøĸΪҪĻƸĸҲ벻
Ƹĸֺ֧ͱá
    1ƸĸΪƸĸѡʱ ΪԼǿƸĸʱѡǳҪθĸھøĸ
ԱδܴӸĸлȡʵʾ棬θĸͺѵõ֧֣ͬĸȻά裬;ϣĸʱѡ
øĸѾԵشĳЩ¾ɵƵʱ򣬵ԱѾƸĸкʱ򣬻ʱչ
ĸĩƸĸηϰԼпĳЩìܶᶯֽ׶ε
ҹгƽ̶ܴڵı׶ˣ󲻷ְ֡͡
صзִϡӵȵȡƸĸŹͻƵϾҪȡµͻƣͱƸĸϣ
ӦʧʱؼӿƸĸĽ̡
    2 ƸĸһľΪչľûƸĸľûأھƸĸﲻ
ɵģҲ˵ֻеƸĸѾƸĸĸҪصʱ򣬲Ƹĸʵʵƽ
ĸǰԽгΪĿľƸĸڸ̵ܲشĻķ
ҲܲҪƸĸϺ֧֡ڱ׶˵ԭƣԴͳļƻΪΪġƸĸ
Ҫʵ֮ӦĸĸսӦͷгõơ
    3ƸĸƸĸﻥΪ ھδ໥Ӱ졢໥ٽġѪԵϵΪᷢչ
ԱƸĸƸĸʵʽȮ˫򻥶˳ƽйȫĸȱٵҹͳƻ
ƣ󲻷ֱ֣ӹҵӪγȨ߶ȼеƵֱԭƸĸʵɴͳƻ
гת䣬ҪӪλȨزгͱȻԸ߶ȼȨƽ
ĸǿһ濴ƸĸÿǰһеƸĸıҪԣƸĸƸĸԹ᳹
ϣСƽͬ־ǳ̵ָеĸĸܲܳɹǾƸĸ[8]p.164
ĸҪϲ㽨 Ƴ谭չϰΪƸĸ￪ͨṩϡ
        4.ЭƸĸȶηչ߹ϵ
    ƸĸڱָĸչȶЭϵչεȶӦƸĸһⲿҲ
ǺĸɹҪ־ʮһȫҹƸĸʵֻһŽξỷУ
ƸĸܽΪ˳ؽУһЩش漰ĸĸʩ̨ܳʵʩв𵴡Ҫ
ƶƸĸĿꡢʹʩʱѵע㣺һֿǵصĴڣǵЩؿܴ
Ӱ졣磬й˿࣬شĻʺܵͣ⽨һɢɳϰڣɡɽͷĻϰд档Щ
ڽƸĸʱֿǵԼءֿǵײԸĸĳǵƱĳĸ
Ҫǵ棬̴ѾϰΪĴͳвͻΣȶĸٶ̫졢
Χ̫㡢䶯̫ңշζңֻٲⷽ̽ѵġƸĸĽУǵȷܵ
Ӱ졣ӰȱΪƸĸıҪԣѸĸΪƸĸӶƸĸͺ
ΪԽʵľƸĸĲʵʵҪ磬89η粨ǵûдٽӻθĸĽ
̡йʵ޷ܼθĸ
    ˵ȶƸĸĻԼĻôηչƸĸĿָ򡣻֮ƸĸﲻǷչ
εֶκͶʵϣƸĸﱾһϱơƺͷչƶȵḶ́Ҳһ
صĹֻ̡ͨĸʹֲطӰĿԽ͵㣬ӰЧӦ͵㡣ܵ
ԸԴؿر赼ɾøĸβ󣬽ȫලƵȵȡͬʱӦͨ
ʹƾмܹܵסسܹξĻơӶƸĸȡηչٶȺ
Գܵĳ̶ͳһȶƽƸĸηչƸĸηչʵȶ
    壬Ƹĸ߱дηġź͸߳ĸĸ＼
    θĸ漰Ȩ̵ֵعìͷָر׶˵ƣСƽ֮ΪƵĸ[6]
p.397 ʵְθĸͬһָΪĴ̬ʹáĸǷǳ淶ѧΪ
쵼ְơȨּСҳơƣǲͨķʽƵġңƵġĸ
ȻֱӴƵĵȨߵļȵ棬ǶԣĸȷС塣һ棬ƸĸƽҪԲ
ȨߵȨзֽԼҪԼṫͱ˵ĵȨߵȨаᡣһ棬ЩȨ߱
ĸִߣн֮һ㹫öҪǡԼԼѶȻܴѾɻʵġˡȻ
ϰӸĸĽСʹƸĸѶȺ͸ԣʱǿʹĳĸʩزۡ
ϣСƽΪƸĸҪݵĻĸΪһҪǿǣƸĸļԺ͸Բ
ɲ򻺸ƸĸɣرѷǵѵĽѷΪˣ쵼ر
߱߶ȵʷθԼ׳ʿľġͲεԸ̬ȶԴƸĸȥӸϴ
ر׶˵ƣǶϸ֦ĩڵɣȻʹƸĸԽԽͺھƸĸⲻֻܱϾƸĸĳɹ
ʹƸĸǰ[8]p.176Ҫ漰⡱[6]p.397
    ͬʱθĸδ˵ıθҪ׵ö࣬෴θӼѣһɹĸξ޽һ
ɹĸĸһμҡ[4]p.317ΪθĸսҪԱҪԹθǵ
սֻԷˣĸ߱ȸ߾߱μɡ⣬θĸǸ״θƻ״ĸ߱
ȸ߸ؼԦȷؿ仯ԱҵᶯңθĸҪƽΡõȸ
ı仯θƽ⣬ѡĸķΧٶȺȵȷ棬ĸ߱ȸҪѵöࡣҪҹ쵼
߱ζ߱ʷչ̡ƶᷢչһʶǰհʶԵҺĸԼʷ
λ̵⣬ξƵķչ仯ѵʶеϵ׶Ҳȷķڴ˻ϣƶʵ
еƸĸ﷽мƻѡĸʱȷĸĿ꣬ƶĸԣвƽĸ̣ʱظĸĹģٶ
κͻĺͲɿص¼ΪҹƸĸȲƽҪġ
    ոڣ20000601
οס
    [1]Ƿ.ߴθM.ձ磬1998.
    [2]ƽ.йƸĸݺ̸M.磬1998.
    [3]۾.ѧM.ѧ磬1995.
    [4]͢.仯еM.꣬1989.
    [5]̫.ƶȵƣJ. ѧо19973.
    [6]Сƽѡ2M.磬1994.
    [7]̫.ҹƸĸĽչ뷽˼J.ϺѧԺѧ19993.
    [8]Сƽѡ3M.磬1993.
    
    
    
 
