 ׺ 1-85
ԭĳʷ
ԭ
ԭںš199603
ԭҳš55-60,97
  šK1
  ʷѧ
    ˺
ӡںš199608
    ʷѧȻѧ
    
    ҪʷѧҹʷѧȻѧû漰еı𣬲ȷشʷѧǷȻ
ѧ⡣ʵߵĸڣȻѧоĹԲоߵӰ죬ظԣʷѧоĿˣ
ͨʶ߶ıԼΪʽʹĹԲϱ仯ʷֳظԡ;˶оϵĲͬ
ʷѧĿ͹ԲͬȻѧĿ͹ԣʹõĹҲԵĲˣʷѧӦäĿ׷ȻѧӦ
߳Լо֮·
                                  
    ʷѧȻѧĹϵһϵ⣬һʵ⣬ڿѧ߶ȷչĽ죬ԵΪҪ
ˣ̸һҵĿʷѧͬۡ
            һ
    ʷѧȻѧĹϵѧƵͲˡڹŴϣȻѧں̶ܴһ֪ʶڵʱ
ˮƽԼӦļˮƽޣȻѧûгΪһʵѧ۽Ʋ߼ĽҪȻѧ֪ʶ
ϵͳģйɵģͨԭƼ͵Ӿŷµļѧһ˵ϣΪ˲ϢĶܳΪѧ
оĶ󣬱ʷʿ°Ȼѧձ֪ʶʷǹ֪ʶûձõĹɿԣ
ΪʷѧǿѧΪʫʷѧѧͼΪ֪ʶ֪ʶֻǹ۵㡲1
    ͣѧʷѧѧŮϣʷѧȷģˡʷѧȻѧĿĶΪ֤
ϵ۵ӢΰʱʷѾһϵ˲Ϣĺûйɵ¼Ƕ˵־֮ϵͼı֣ʷ
־תơĳ˵ʷѧԹϣʷһֽʷҲͬȻһΪһйɵ˶
    ͽѧʵ鼼ֶ˽ĵȴʵڵķչŸĸʵѧĵѧ֪ʶ̽
ͳҲˣͬʱʷѧһ˫صսһȻѧҪһ͹۵ϵϵǽ
ʵ֤֮ϵģʷѧڰѧ֮ͬʱҲʧȥѧϵڶʷѧ޷ʵķȥһ͹
ϵֻٴν˼棬ϣȻѧһһԵʷϵͲòʷ֮ϵͳԺʷѧԡ
Ժʷѧķչǡǡͱֳ
    ѧϷӳһĵʹǺڸͨ߼ϵһʷϵʷںڸ
йɵģ޷ʵ֤ʵġڶĴصˡΪʷϵĶ㷺
˵ֽһεġǸġھ鷶ΧʵȴֱԣִԣȻѧɸĽ
2 ΪʷѧȻѧڣͳޱȷḻһȻѧĿġʷ෴Ϊ
ܹѧؽ˼άжϣȻҲһĶȻһĶʷ˵ֶΣʷͨ·»صΪ
ĸȥ3ʷһۿѧ һֵϵĿѧ4
    19ĩ20ͳѧҪǰѿѧΪһα֪ʶʽΪ֪ʶʽʷ֮ڣǰʷ֪ʶ
ĵλдԵѧաɭղķʿȡΪѧ֪ʶΪģõġΪ
κʶǾģʷǲȻѧļֵΪȻѧõģǽԡ5
    ѧҵ̬ΣְҵʷѧȻѧΰɾ͵ļ£˵Ȼѧоѧƶ£
19ҶʼʹʷȻѧ⡣ʷѧţʷѧҲȻѧķʹΪһšѧô
ʷѧļֵѧĵλǣʷѧͳѰձõĿѧɺȻѧĳ
     磬 19 Ҷ Ӣʷѧ˹ͿգThomasBucklerȻƣ ͨʷһձûĹ
ԵĹԷ⡱Ȼ򣬶ʷһſѧĿ׵£August Comteʷڵһαϵͳؼо
ұֺһܲĹ֧ġ 19 ĩ20ͳŴѧڣ˶ѫLord ActonͰ
BuryΪʷǿѧҲһΪѧ6
    ִʷѧûֹˡͳ֮Էࡣһ࣬ʷ塣ΪʷȻѧȫͬ۶
Եģ˵ĿǣʷоһΪпˡȶµˡڶ࣬ʷ࣬еһֹΪ
ѧΪѧѧࡣ磬ؾΪʷԷΪԿѧΪĺΪ֡ΪʷĿ
ѧɲʱΪôҪҪʷͨʷѧҵѧƷϡ7ɭ LeeB
ensonʷΪ4ࣺ1Ϊѧǲõʷ2Ϊʶʷ3Ϊѧʷѧ˼ϣ4Ϊ
ѧʷṩҸ棬кѡ֪ʶ8࣬ΪʷȻѧһͬǿѧ͵Ĵ绳أMot
on WhiteʷоΪ֣1.ʷʵ2. Ϊʷ͡Ϊ͵һԣʷѧܵͬص
Ӱ죬ǵڶ㣬ʷѧҺȻѧһӦܹԡ۵ȸصӰ졲9
    ʷѧʵеʷѧв̶ͬȵӰ죬ȻĿǰְҵʷѧҶ̬ȣʷйɵģ
ֹ̽ɵʱ죬ʷѧҪо⣬Ūʵ̽ҪȺܾԺʱ
ֽСԣʷое˶Ծо棬ԹоСĵػرˡʷѧĻ״
            
    ΪȥֹʷѧȻѧû漰ʷѧȻѧıԶȷشʷѧǷ
ȻѧʷѧǷܳΪȻѧһĿѧ⡣
    κοѧоĹԣͨԹɵʶָʵһϣʷѧȻѧһġʷѧȻѧ
ڣȻѧоˣ˵Ȼ磬ΪһڵĹ۲ߣʶо屾
ص˶ɡ;ȻѧоǿͨʵԤ֤ʵģÿնĻ˵ǿ֤αģɡ
ʷѧоͿ嶼˱һ˶Լµʶ˾ѾԭΪоˣɳˣΪȻ
Ҳ仯Ӱ쵽ԭеԺԤڵʵ֡ĹԼʶ߲ϱ仯ŵģҲ˵ʷ
оĿǲϱ仯ģûһͬģǲظģ;оĹ޷ͨʵԤ֤ʵ֤αġȻ
ѧʷѧ𣬾֪ʶϵڷϵĸͬ
    ȻѧĽ۶ͨʵģЩʵ鶼ͬ²ͬĽҲ˵ǿֵġʷ
ڲϵطչģڵ͹ȥԶҲȫͬ;ʷ¼пԡʷпԣȥ
¼֣ǾûбҪоʷˣֻоʵͿˡʷֲֵʾʷоĽ޷ͨʵ
֤ġʷѧҿ˵ڻ¬ʧһûԤϵĴսƻȴʵ֤ʵһۡ
ʷѧҪ˵Űȷʵ˫ּ򵥵Ĺ߽˽ִʵԵؽһС֤һ㡣ʵ鰴Ȼ
ѧı׼վסŵģΪʵһŽǲͬģŰִŲͬ;顣һʵΥ
ͬ²ͬĽһѧʵѭĹ
    Ⲣ˵ʷѧоóĽǲʵġʷоĽۺܿʵģֻʵ޷ͨʵ֤ʵġ
ʹʷоĽۣЩȷʵĽۣл񹲺͹1949ꣻʢһͳȵȣ⣬Ȼ
ѧĽձܡʷѧıʾģʷѧȥЧȻѧҲ޷ıȻѧֱ
    Ϊ˼֪ʷѧͼ֣߸ȷе˵ǹ룩ʷĹɡ19ҶʼʷѧҶ
ѰʷɵĹһʷѧҺǵ˹19ĩд֮ĵѧΪԼĹѾӽ
ҵһΰĸʹʷһĹһķǵ˹Լҵһ򣬼ضɣݼɡ
1020ᣨCheyney1923 ʷѧϯ´ҲҪѰʷɵԼ6ɣ3Ϊ
1.ʷ¼һһģмûмϡ2.仯һжڱ仯֮С3.11ʷϸض
໥ġЩƹɲ˵ʵģȱȻѧɵ׼ȷԤȻѧĹ۵㿴ֻ޷֤
Ĳ²⣬ͬȻѧеĹɺͶᲢۡ
            
    ʷѧȻѧѧֵһҪ۾ݾǣȻѧǿ͹۵ģ۱ձܡʷѧоɹҪ뱻ձ
ܣʷѧӦǿ͹۵ġʷѧһ㣬ʷѧͻΪȻѧĿѧˡֹҪʷоѭ
ԭһǿ͹۵̬ȣʲôͻһʲô˵ۺöƫ˽ǶʷϺʷʵĸ߶أǿݣΪʷ
Ǽʵÿ仰Ҫвϸݡ߱һ˵ʷѧž߱˿ѧǰᡣ12
    ȻѧĳɾͺеĵλΪĿ͹ԣʵǶȻѧ⣬ͳʷѧȻѧ֮ҰҲڴˡȻ
ѧоǵܡ˵ۺöƫ˽Ǳи۵ĺö񡣻仰˵Ȼѧڴ¿ѧобʹü
ֵжϣⲻȻѧһпѧо㡣
    ʵϣȻѧΪһ壬ǰҪΪоĳ㣬ǳڸķ淢չѧ
ŴѧǾѧͻѧִѧѧѧѧӳһʵΪʲôûпѧȥ
ŵĴСĹϵأһΪŵĴСʲôϵΪʹȷֹϵҲûжֵȻ
һ۵жϡ۵жڿѧȷоʱžԵáʹڿȷ֮󣬿ѧڴоʱҲǲ
۳ɼƫġ1888״֤ߵ粨ڵʵʱͼٶʵҵĴСҪ˹ΤĵǡȻ޹صġ
һƫӰʵĽʹóߵ粨ٶٲһµĽۡ13
    ôȻѧĿ͹ԵںʲôأΪĿ͹ԵĺǣܿѧҵʶΣֻͬ»ͬĽ
ʵ۲ŻõѧĹϡȻѧĿ͹ԡѧֻϿԵõظ֤ĽֽۣԼԸ
ôزͬȻѧֿ͹ʷоǲڵġôʷоеνĿ͹ʲô߻һ仰˵ʷопɲ
п͹ԣһʷѧ糤۵⡣ΪʷоеĿ͹ָܸ˸ƫӰͻʵϣ
̬ȡǷٺͲеĿ͹ԣνĲƫе̬ȣȻѧеĿ͹Ǹͬġ˭֪аͲдȻӦ
ȴȫ̬ȵӰ죬һֵּжϣûһձܵı׼οԷɺ͹
飬Ҵڲϱ仯֮УȥķڿܶǲġͬһʷĹ۵һʱڱΪǡ͹ۡģһʱ
ܱΪƫ
    ˣʷѧȻѧʹá͹ۡѧŲͬں
    ﲻһӡ1880굽1917ڼ䣬͹ԱʷѧΪʷоı׼Ҽû顣
һʱڵġ͹ۡʷУʷֳûĺʷսؽɸĸ
ɵı磬ȵȡ14ʷо򣬱ձܵĿ͹۱׼ǲڵģҲƫСͨﵽ͹ۡʹԼȻѧ
·߲ͨġ
            
    ʷȻѧѧһҪžǰȻѧеķʷоӶʹʷѧȻѧһĿѧ
Ȼ⣺һʷоʹȻѧ޶ȡڶʷоʹȻѧǷͿʹʷѧΪȻ
ѧһĿѧΪĻشǷ񶨵ġ
    Ȼѧõ֮һԵؽԭԱΪAڸָ±۲쵽 
Щ۲쵽AؾBʣôеABʡȻѧʷожʹùɡڵǣʹ
Ĺ֮ʲôΪʷѧȻѧʷʵ̫٣޷Чĸɡ15Ϊ
ڴˡﲻһ·ֹ׻ǵӡ1682귢˺Ļǣִҵ1607꼰1351
Ļͬ۲쵽ĻƵĹͬһŻǣҼŻÿ766³һΡ16Ϊֹ 
ֻι۲ݣ˵ٵòˣʷоеĹʹõԶҪöࡣڣ1758꣬ڹȥ15
ŻԤƵճ֣ʱֻԤƵ죬Ҳ˵Ĺɵõ֤ʷоеĹȴ޷֤ġ
˹׵Ĺ1758õ˹ϣʷоеĹɴֻ۲ݵ⡣ɵĽǷ񱻽Ϊ
ݵĶ٣Ƿõ֤ﲢ˵ʷовʹù˵ʷѧʹùʱҪסʹõĹ
ͬȻѧеĹɣҪǵĹɽ۵ͬȻѧеĹɽۣϣõ˵ĹϡʷĹɸߺ˵һ
ʷԵѡѡõģмֵģȴܵͬȻѧе
    ȻѧкʷѧҲԵĲͬǴһ㵽͸Ǹһﶼеһԡϵ
ƶϸеĸеԡϵʵʽʷоУʹʱǰһϵΪʷ
оеĸȫжϡ磬ǿԸūһ壺Ҫūūᡣһ
ôսǰϷҪūӦūᣬǼûλʷѧһۡϷū
һе̬ʹ޷һձĸȥ˵κһʷĸų⡣˵һƶȴ
һƶһҪθҪʹһһʣ˵⡣ʵҲҵƶȵĸûоθ
ԣʹֲȫĸΪǰеȻѧʹõڱǲͬġʷѧҿʹһȫƵĲ
ҲձܵжΪǰᣬȻѧȴ
    ѧȻѧõķҲʷѧȻѧеһҪӵķӱʮŷʷѧ
磬γ˼ʷѧɡĸ￪ҹʷѧҲкܴӰ죬Ϊʾ21ʷѧǰ17
    ˲ڷпܵĵطʹüķǣķʹʷѧȻѧΪȻѧʷѧʹü
űϵĲͬڴ˽ԼʷѧʹõͳƷΪ˵һ㡣
    ʹͳƷóȷĽҪҪһҪ㹻壬óĽ۾̫ܲûʲô
ˡй˿г1000˵ϽͳóĽۣķְֲҵķֲȣй˿ڵʵ״кܴĲ
ȱŶȡڶģԱΪصĸŶӰͳƵ׼ȷԡ
    ǣʷĲϣرǽǰϣѷʷľԣʷԣǶļ¼
ѡģʵȣܹ¼ģֻռСһ֣ܹˣвӵ鹹Բ
ԡȻʷѧҿԶЩϽп֤ܹ֤ʵıϾһЩϽмõĽǲͳƷ
ȻѧͳѧõĽᲢ۵ġ
    ͳѧĻǸۡһСʵʵʲԭСһĳ̶ȣ0.01¼һ㱻Ϊǲܷġ
18һͳƶԣȷġǶʷһ¼ĸСҲܱ֤ʷûзݷǰ
ͼߪΪͳ˧ĸйһص¼ͳ˧ǻƣʷϵżȻԶԶ
ͳѧܹƵķΧ;˼ʷоеľԼý۵Ĳȷԡһ¼ʷѧҲǳ
ϵġ19ʷѧСʩΪеҪ֮ҪǡǡΪǲüķԻش𡱡20
ʷѧɵҪRobert William FogelҲϣĿǰʷѧҷĶԲʩĶԡ
˵ͨʹʷѧѧ⣬ǳּķ̬ȡΪʹʷѧõ˴ӦãʷѧӱϽһ
ѧƣѧҪ˵Ȼѧˡ21
    ʷѧȻѧڱǲͬģѧҲкܴĲͬȻѧĵľһԵ
ʷѧһɸȤҹĸǲȻѧĮӸĲȻѧʷѧֲ̬ͬȵĸ
Դڸоļֵ㲻ͬȻѧоĶȻ磬ȻֻоձԵĶ˵ġ
ϸؽȻѧоĶÿһҲǱ˴˲ͬģȻѧҲעֲͬΪֲͬǵоû塣
磬һѧעһһƥһƥĲֲͬͬȻǴڵģֲ
ͬȺԼ˵ǷǳҪģѡ˵ҲԿѧ˵ȴûʲô塲22ʷоĶ
ᣬеľ¼һһ඼ġʷѧҲԷʱڵķ˵һԸȤҶԾ
ˣҲȤκξʷ¼ʷѧҲǵĹͬȤҶǵĲͬȤκʷ¼
ʷѧ˵ǲͬģ仰˵ʷ¼ǲظģ;ǲʵԤķ֤ʷоеĸԽۡ
    ΪʷѧȻѧֱ֮ʲʷѧȻѧɽķ޵ģӦõķΧҲ޵ġ
ǽȻѧֱʵĲʷѧҲΪȻѧһ֣߳ΪȻѧĿѧ100 
ʷѧһҲ˴ĳɹȻЩɹڶ̶ƽԼʷʶȴֵûɵġ
˲ϣΪŪһЩʷ⣬ȻѧļԷʱǺҪģǱزٵġʷѧҰѴ󲿷־
ھϸϣΪԽԽ֪ԽԽˣôʷѧҵ˿Լʷѧʷ»صҵ
ȥ100ǰʷѧȻѧ˳ʼӿ֮ǰҪ˽ʷȥʷǡͨɭ
֥ա˵100Ľ죬 ȴҪС˵͵ӰӾ˽ʷǶʷȤûм٣ֻǶʷѧ
дʷٸȤˡʷѧΣ֮ʱʷС˵ʷӰƷͼʵѧȴһƷмʮڵĹ
ڡְҵʷѧѵӦܵһʾȻѧֱӳɹҲ٣ЩɹͨӦöʹ
棬ʹǸܵȻѧáЩѧȻҲܵǵľܲûжǵоɹȻʷѧ
ɹٿͨӦöʹǧ˽⣬ֱֻ߼ĳɹʹ˽ʷоʷѧӦ˽Ȼѧ
ֲͬҪȥʩЧ򭣬ûɰʷѧѧεŮλϽųȻȥ䵱ȻѧŮȻѧ׼ȷԡ
ϸԺͿԤԹȻĽģģԡԺͻȻԳԸǻۺϡԼ·ñ˵ȥɣ
ʷѧӦֵԭ򡣣
    ע
    1R.G.Collingwood:Essays in the Philosophy of History,Austin,1965,2425ҳ
    2347Ľܵȱ룺ִʷѧļϺĳ1984棬67824131ҳ
    5£ʷĹйѧ1986 棬212232ҳ
    61011Henry Steele Commager: The  Nature  andStudy of History,Columbus,Ohio,1965,128484ҳ
    8American Historical Review,Vol.80,No.2,199ҳ
    9Hans Meyerhoff,ed:The Philosophy of History in  OurTime,Garden City,New York,1959,188ҳ
    12ѧ䣺ʷоԢ֮Сڡʷܡ19933ڡ
    13Ĭ˹ѧʲôӡ1982棬4243ҳ
    14American Historical ReviewVol.94,No.4,198710£10221013ҳ
    15Amold J.Toynbee:A Study of HistoryתԣHansMeyerhoff,ed.ǰ101ҳ
    16James F.Maurer:Concise  Dictionary  of  ScientificBiography,1984,N.Y,331ҳ
    17˳ʷѧҰ1987棬153ҳ
    18ٹͳơߵȽ1963棬20ҳ
     19Charlotte Erickson:"Quantitative History", TheAmerican Historical Review,Vol.80,No.2,April,1975,361362ҳ
    20Arthur Schlesinger,Jr:"The Humanist Looks at EmpiricalSocial Research",American Socialogical Review,Vol.27,7
70ҳ
    21Robert William Fogel:"The Limits of Quatitative Methodsin History",The American Historical ReviewVol.80,No.2
,April,1975,333341346ҳ
    22ΪĶ󣬵ǿͨ־һ㣬һҪϼ
                              ߣൺѧѧԺ
                                          α༭ƽ
    
    
    
 
