 ׺ 1-104
ԭĳʷѧо
ԭ
ԭںš199602
ԭҳš18-27
  šK1
  ʷѧ
    챾Դ
ӡںš199610
    ʷѧ΢
    
      ϵһ˼ʷѧϵ
    ѧ۵óġ֮ǿӵѧϵڱв漰ӵȫѧۣ̽йʷѧ
֣Ҳ̽֡ڱĵһָġӵʷѧۡʷչۺʷ۵ľԱ׼ۡۡ
۵۵⣬áѧеס롰סǡסۺ͡סıۡ
    ס۵ҪڡȻۣ͡˵ҪΪ¹ۡιۡʷ۵ȵȣͳһӶΪʷչ
۵ĸݡνġסı۵ġۡһúڸ˵ζѧо˼סĿѧ
˼ܹıԵġζѧĵһǱۣڱʵĳ涨ѧ˵˼벻ʵ
substanceҹɾԵĶձʵ塱ۢ٣ݿӵıǰ˵ͳһһζѧġòסľԵ
ձʵ塪ӳΪ֮Уһ棬ǽڣ
    Ӹۺͱ۽˼ʷϵһϵͳʷѧѧ۳ض˼ʷѧӢ
ʷѧоרֶʲW.H.WalshʷѧΪࣺһΪڣĩġ˼ģζѧʷ
ѧоҪʷ̵ʣΪʷΪԻķչ̺֣Ϊܾ÷չ֧ģȵȣ
ĿģʷʲôУڶΪʼڣĩڣġеģʷѧҪоʷʶ
⡣ӢһʷѧҰؽɭR.F.AtkinsonĵһʷѧΪʵģSubstantiveʷѧǿо
ʷġʵ塱substanceʻʷʱеģʽȵȡ֮˼ʷѧڷǶʷ˼
ĴµġʷζѧۡӵʷѧҲ£ǷΪΣӵʷѧҪ塣
            һʷչ۵۸ݣס
    Ŀѧֱۡ۵˼ά۱Ȼǡġvitalistic翴
һ壨organismݻĹ̡ԿӰز֮Դƣ֮»ϵ¡
ҰΪڵĻأtheground of existenceƣӯ֮ߣΨԴرӺδ
ΪȻȻŵģԡ״ûд񻰣족Ҳû˸Ϊϵۡ˵գʱɣɣ
ա
    һ׵Ĺ̡ڸԣǱףWerdenۢ٣ݿӸ衰סĶǡ֮νס
ϵǴϡ塷˵ǰν֮סҲǰ֮仯סɴȷ
ı׵ۣǬУסӣǬ٣ԼססɼǬ򼸺Ϣӡϵϡ
˵Ǵı׺˶СӵǣӴֱ׵ݳȻۺĹۡ
    ڡ贫ʾµ⣺ۺԲʱ䣬ۺԻ¡˶Ȼֱʱе
µʱҹı仯ƣĪأͨĪʱ裺νʱԱͨǱߣ
ƶɣƶɡϵϣ¡ʱֱǴ䣬ԡ״߹ۺģ
Ȼ󣩾͵óʱ䡱Ĺ硶ԥ贫ƣ˳²עʧʱ߯ע߯
˵尴ʱ򣨡˳˶ºʱжᷢɼɱ׵۵ó䡱Ȼۡñ
۲磨ἰʷ͵óɡĹۡɡҲָʱеĽУ硶㡤贫ƣ
ʥ˾»ɡӱΪʥӦʱ䳤֮ܡʹӻҲ˵
УֵͨƶȺΪ淶õضʩн̻Դﵽ׵ĿġҸƶȺ͹淶񡱣һɲ䣨
ΪҪӦΨʡǡɡĹۡóֻɹأ״Ϊȡڱ׵ۡ硶ϵ
¡ƣס֮ΪҲԶΪҲǨ˲ӣ飬޳ףΪҪע׼ҲΨ
ʡӶʥԼ֮ͨ񡱣ϵϡɡǵĻ˵ָ
ᷢչһʷḶ́Ҳǡʷɹ۾ǿӵʷۡ¹ʮ͵ʷҲ׺E.Bernheimʷ
һĶ壺ʷǹ෢չEntwicklungder Menschenһֿѧۢڣ
            ʷʶԭʷչ׶
    ȻΪʱ䡱Ȼۺ͡ɡĹͬڱ׵ۣͳһвġʱȻȻ˶硶ϵ
ϡƣƶ仯仯߽֮󣬸ҹ֮󡱡ǣ磬ɡΪģʷˣ
ʷĿ˵£¡res gestaeӸĹۣ¡һոµĶ壺֮ͨν¡Ӧ
ʷ˼ʷϵһβʷ¼ΪƵĲԡsituational immobilityΪʷ̵һɲ֡ʲô
ǡͨ䡱ڡ״ѧУͨ䡱롰ͨͬĸνָͨȻ籾˶νʱԱͨ
νͨ䡱ġϵǡе仰ʥԼ֮ͨ񡱡νͨȻָʶ
һʶʶĿġӾݴʷʶԭΪҪͨ롰Լ
֮Ϊǰ⡣˵ƶµĵƶʱҪйصġ¡һʱΡdure longueʷ˶УԱ
ʷĹȥ£ȥԤʷδ£ǹͨӶƶкʷչĵʶ̡ϵ¡
Ϊʮ֣ס΢ԲġѧҺעƣסã죬΢֮ԣ֮
ӱ塷עƣ±أҲԤռǲҲʷıȻԣѳɶ޿ɸףʷĿ
ԣֻһ̶Լ¡ֻǿʷչ׶ԵƲ⡣׿ӳΪ
΢Ԥռ£ӳ֮Ϊ֪ӲΪһּʶ˵סʥԼСҲ
֪ߣ֮΢Ҳν񡱼˵ġ㡱˼ȫһʶ۵ĸ˵ġ
֪ӵĻԡϵǴƪ֪֪΢ν΢ԡǡ΢󿯣ġ
ӱڡ΢ġĽ˵ȷУ˵֮΢Ҳ֮ƲģһҲʱ֮ν
ġ塱ʷ̣νʷչĽ׶ԣԣregularityʷʶ˵ֻ
ʷʾķչ׶ԲſʷԤԤռ£˼ָνʷչǽĻϵģ
ʽǰѹȥʽԼչĸ׶Ρۢ٣ݻߣö˹Ļ˵ʷθһƶȶֻ
ɵͼ߼չеһЩʱ׶Ρۢڣ
    ӸʷʶۣĻʷġҰʷչ׶ۡݡϵ¡ʷ׶Ϊ
ʱ˵еķʱΪΪԵ桱̶Ϊԭʼũҵũҵʱ˵еũʱΪ
ľΪ꣬ľΪ硱ٽһΪũҵֹҵֹԼֱӽʱˡΪУ֮񣬾֮
ˣˮ½ͨƷˮС֮Լòͨ½򡰷ţԶ
ҪǷд֣ϹŽΣʥ֮ѧĦֵʹΪʱʼıġ
һö˹Ļ˵ߵʱżˡƷƶ£ѪԵΪŦԭʼ幫𽥱ԵԵϵֵ
к͹档ҵĹʱڣƹڽ׼Կֵװ硶ϵ¡ƣŻݣԴ͡
ľΪľΪʸ¡
    ڴҰɵľ״״û˵֮ڿдġˡƪСǰһƪģʷѧ۵
ڹ͡ʷѧоڣڣУѾˡˡƪйС֮ıģʾ˴Ӳ
ᵽ֯ҰĹɡǽԵظҪ档ΪĴʼйʷʱ
ġ̡ʵСΪ͡ΣʵԡΪרͳĸټʹ󷨣紺ʱѧ˵񣬾
ң𢣬ˣҲ꡷񡱵ĻԭǡΪ񡱣Ȩ͹ĳЩҳƼ
ͥеϮѳΪƶȡΪάƶȣıɴ𡱡Ϊڴ֮ͬԭʼУıղˣ
ĴԺı𡣴˵νҪָ³еġỤ̡֮̋ʦ
ҡο顤̷ơȨϮǿ˥΢Ҷȡ֮ʷͻ⡣
ʱΨʵα˵ظʱɣ˳Ӧˣ֮ʱա˴
νġ족ȻָۺԲʱ䡱ġ족νˡָۺԻ¡ġˡԿ˵֮ʱ塳
աǰı׵۹Ϊͨ䣬ʹ񲻾룬֮ʹ֮ס䣬ͨͨáϵ¡
ɴ˶Ƶʷչ۾ǣʷ̿᲻ϻɵḶ́䶯Ŀľʹõأʹ񲻾롱
أΨʵأʹ֮أšǡϵϡ˵ġסע֮ͨ־֮񣩣ð֮
˹Ҳ
    ӵʷѧ۽˵ʷ¼ṹָ֮ĽṹıǷڡʱˡԭģӼʹ
ҪʷʵʱΪƶҲʱ׵ģΪʱĲVirtue filia temporisô
ı׵ۼ̺Ļɵʷ۾˿ӵʷѧ
    ǣӵʷ۵߱׼塱ձĵԵĵ¼ֵԣӻҪΪʷѧζѧ
ıۣڱ׵ҳסձľʵ壬ȿΪһдֿ֮Ϊֵʵ֮ߵ
ѧ룬ӳ֮Ϊ֮ǽУϸ
            ζѧ̽ΪеĲ䡱ġ֮
    ʿָ׷󡰱еĲ䡱ϣѧһѧɵġʼarcheصġ߸˹log
osѧɵġ̫һta henͼġeidosʿµġʵ塱substantiaȵȣǱٶΪ
һб仯ĸʼı塣ѧȻ׷󡰱еĲ䡱˹ŵɯ˵ǡ
Ĺ۵¡sub specie aeterni˵Ŵ˼ֱ̽ϵʵԣsubstantialityԣindivi
dualityĹϵ˼ʶ۷ֱ̽ʣessenceĹϵָΪ֪ĸʡָ
˼άǵĳöóġԡࡱԡࡱspecieձԣȵȡڽ
Ϊһ㲻ʽǹɡԴӴĵĽ۳Ժġࡱ֣Ҳ֤Ϊݱţټ淢
ſѧγɣۣ˹ָΪ仯š˶ŵԼһ˶ͱ仯ݵĹ
ûʲôĶۢ٣ݻ˵ֵò˵ʵ壬˵Ǳ仯Ḷ́г
͸ĺ֮⣬ûʲôǳġۢڣݡǽŴ۵һ졣
    ѧӵġ֮ŴϣĺصѧϵʵĲϵΪڱ
ĵһָġغͿһһж˶仯ʧı۵ѧңҺ
Ҳ̽ˡסʵ塣صѧڹŴ䡰ɬڸӦǺصõĲߣΪ
֤ġչ۷棬ڸǺصļ̳кͷչߡ£Ǹһºڸ͵ĺصġסġ߸˹
ѧе塣
    µĶϼƪд߸˹logosȻشţȻﶼ߸˹Ȼ
˹еģȴţһԼƵġDiels,1,2ҿڸԺصĽ˵ʿ
µ¼أֻСһǳסģˡһ⣬һбĶתţȹ̵ġժ
ѧ߰˹AetiusϾ䡲˹ȫΪضԣһж˶˾ǱȻԡ˵ı
ǹᴩʵġ߸˹߸˹̫ether壬б仯ӡڸʿ˵ġһΪ
˹˵ġ߸˹ڸ˵˶Ĺͳһġһձ顢ࡢǣVerstand,logos
ذձ顢ڶеͳһˡȻԡǡᴩȫĴеľԹϵ߸˹Թϵ
̫壬б仯ӡںؿձ鱾ǱʣǾֹĶڸָ˺
߸˹˵ԣlogos,Vernunfeʶ۷Ĺϵ˵ţһԼ
ǣVerstand,logosǣԣVernunft,logosǱģֻǶİţṹķʽתۡ仯֮ʶ
ԣֻҪǷ֪ʶǾСۢ٣
    ڸԺصԼѧ˼֮ʾѧһҪͳһΪ߸˹
ԣеıԣϣʶ֮ʿΪ֮޵ĵطڡԵĶһΪ߸˹ԣ
бԵģ˹ָȻ粻ԵģϣѾǲԶġۢڣݡѧ׷
Եһ¡ͳһϡԺ˵ԲǱģֻǶĽṹʽĲڸ˵ѧĿ
ȷ˼뾭һ£ﵽԾеԵĺͽ⣬༴ﵽʵڵĺͽ⡱ۣۢνԾָ
ʶĸ߼ʶνеϣζѧָʵֵġ仯Ĺԣںڸѧ
ָڵġеġıԡĹԡ̽Եһµѧڵ¹Ϊ߸˹ѧlogos philos
ophieԿѧVernunftwissenchaft
    ǿԴ߸˹ԣѧӵġ֮ѧıȽӵġ֮ıۡ
    ʲôǡ֮ӵĸǣ
        ʥ֮סҲ˳֮֮Ի
    ֮Իգ֮Ի塣Ŷ֮˵⴫
    ɼ֮졢ءŶڵζϵĶڡ״͵رΪʱȵģأȻ
Ǿȵġԣ֮ȻΪ֮Լ֮գν
Ѿ˵ģΪ桢ԭһһ֮νġνաﲻӦ
ɵעΪˮͻ羴˵ڵĪˮ𡱣ɽ壩Һ壩ȵȣӦӡϵϡ˵ġ
ƶ仯͡ϵ¡˵ġгӡȥ⡣ɴ˿ɼΪ֮ԭָߺ㶯ߺ㾲
ϵ˶ɡɴ˿ɼ֮Ȼ˶Ķ͹ɵʼarcheζţ͸
Ķ͹ɣߵġձľʵġ֮ߡӾͺ׵Ƶ塱㲻
֮Ϊ֮졢֮һǡֳ֮ԭʿµ˵֮졢ء
֮ġԭǡȵĲƶߡthe first unmoved mover
    Ψ˵ߣûа֮󿴳졢ءˡһ塱ϵۣǿԡѧ
Ĺϡ磬˵ͬȻߣҲνҲϡ˵ߣ֮ȻҲ֮Ҳ
ͬȻߡǡ֮ȻߡδĳɵѧҸ˵ˣһΪǡ֮߼˼ά
һΪȻߣҲ
    پ֮͡ġ޶ʶԣڡ״еġһʵıָһеıԻʡ硶ǡּǡ
ϵǴеġۣȺָ֡߼Ļķࣩ󣬼һ䡮ͬӡɼָһﹲеʣ
ԣ߼ϵġࡱuniversalscharacteristic of speciesڸΪǹһĶġض
ʡʡessenceѧԴڰͼġߡousiaһʡҾٸٵӣ˵ľһ
ʱǰ«ǰߡеķֱγ֯ɲƥܣͼ֮Ϊӵġ
ʵӵġࡱҲǺѧνġԡͼѧΪڴڵġνġҲ
ڴڵıʡ塷ע͡һʱ˵ߣ֮ʣˡܡ˵úã֮һ
֮Ϊ죬ص֮Ϊأ֮ߣָ֮Ϊԡļ
    ״еġһʻСɡ򡰱Ȼԡ塣Ϊһʻԣԡǡǡԡ
ǡӹ˵֮νԡ嶭˵֮ν顤洫ڿǰܴʫ˾Ͱѡ
Ϊ˶ɣ硶ʫšά֮ƣά֮²ѡ¡Ϊ̾ʡעʹ˶Ϊת
޼ֹʱҲ͡㡤贫˵ġ֮òѡһ£ָ֮͡˶ĹԺͱȻ

    ġ֮ļֺԣ߸˹ĺһµġǽһ֣̽ͷ֮֡ġ
Ŵѧġ߸˹оһĲ죬һζŶѧһʼ;вͬȡγֲͬ˼άģʽ
ֲͬҪڣϣ߸˹ѧоĿ桱ӵġ֮оĿơҲ˵ǰʶ۵
֮۵Եģѧģ֮ʵԵġ
    ϣѧҪеĲסʵ壬ǰΪʶĿ壬ҲΪ桱磬Ӱѧɣͼֱ
ʿ¶Ϊ֪ʶepistemeĶǲģΪǿ֪ģǾͱȷģ
ȷģԶڲϱ仯еĸͲȷв׵ʶΪ˵ʲôʱѱΪ
ǵġԶʶֻСdoxaϣϸˡ֪ʶ͡ϣ֪ʶһ
ǡѧscientiaҲǡveritasν桱úصĻ˵Լԣlogosһ
¡Ҳʿµۣ͵İǣThomas Aquinas棬ʵǵķϡadaequatio rei et 
intellectus veritasest
    ϣѧ߸˹Ϊ˵Ծԡԡеԡʶʱȫ漰ơ⡣ϣҲŷ
ԵΪǵµΪѧĵո׵ǡ֪ʶ¡ϣѧļʿ°ġ
ԡΪ֣һΪ۵ԡtheoretikos logosһΪʵԡpractikos logosΪǰʹѧ֪ʶΪ
ʹΪܡ˵˼ġ۵ԣǣʵģֻ٣γ񡱣ǰһƪϸ
ο֮ϣѧ춨߸˹ѧģʽ߸˹Ϊ۵ʵԷֿģǰ桱롰١
жϣ߲ơ롰񡱵жϣǶ߷ֵǰߵϣ߼ѧ͡ϣHellenisticʱȻѧγɺ
չҼӵ˽Ȼѧʢγѧһɱ𡪡ΨѧԿΪߡ
    ӵѧȻ֮֮֮׳֮֮һߵı۷롪֮У
ΪĹԡȫѧϵͳʱǳġڸġԡ߷룬ڸ
ΪϹȥһкڷһСֻǹе˳򡱣˼ԺڸҲ˵ΪĹ
ԡԹΪı֤߼ѧ˳򡣶ѡ֮Ϊѧ硶ǡּǡ˵֮Ҳ
ӵı۵Ŀơ桱˵ӵı۹ǵµζѧǿ԰ѿӵġ֮
ıϵڡ״еµαУ
    ֮䣨ע仯ý֮ƶ֮ͨעƶ仯߰Ͼ֮Ի
֮Ինԣ¾֮Իԡ֮ˣĬ֮ԶСϵϡ
    㣬Ҳ֮öҲµܾգʱ仯ܾóɡ߰Ͼ֮ԣپ
֮ԡʥ˾»ɡ߰ʶԡ㣬֮ɼ㡤贫
    һһ֮ν֮Ҳ֮ҲλסкӡԴ棨עԣ֮ԣ棬ν
    ִ棬֮壩֮šϵϡۺΣͿɿ㡱֮㡱ָ֮ǡòס
ԡϵ¡˵һ¡塷עʼղףǴһҲ˵㣬֮Ҳһ¡֮
úڸ˵ֻ˼ɵġձԵľʵ塱Ȼ磬Ϊ˶Ķ͹ɣ
š֮䡱͡ƶ֮ͨáΪ֮ǡһ¡ģԡµ졲աʱ
仯ܾóɡپԣ֮Ϊ֮壬ǡ塱ͳΪһ¡ζѧ£ֻҪ
ʥ˾Ϳɡ»ɡܵ˵׵Ȼ㲻׵֮Ϊ䱾ġǣ㣬
֮ɼ
    ֮ȻĽʵͳһвġصĺòѵ˶ͱ仯ȻȻġǰġԵ
˵˳²ʱ֮߯ԣͲͬˣҪΪʵֵġʹ츳Թеı
ԣ־ɵģҿܻıġӵԭǡҲϰԶҲϰָѧϰ
Ϊƣѧʱϰָ֮ϰס硶ӡЧƣϰ־ʡˣ֮Ҫ֮ˣĬ
֮С˴νġһʶ۸ѽ˵֪񡱵˼ӱעƣߣȥ
Уδ֮ʱ֪빲ӪҲ˵ֻвϵ˵ԾԣȥʶġδΡ
µı塪Ϊ֮壬̻ͨԼС֪ءĬ֮ذʵֳӵ
˵ǡУ塱ӡ¦¡ӵ仰ǧδȷ⡣ν塱ζŰΪ
ҵĵʶСΪζϵ
    νˡ˵ҪʵС֮ġоӡϣѧΪֻ˲ƾʶȥʶȻ
ԡԿ˵ԳɵΪУԻɼ֮СǬԴ塷˵Ϊ֮ˣԳɾ͵ΪУ
ʹտɼ֮¡硶ʫš֡ƣΩˣ˳֮СӣرΪӵ߲εġʥˡ˵
µĵ䷶޼԰աʱ»ɡ
    󣬴ĿԿӵıĿ۵ģΪһ˶ͱףλסкСԡ
Դ桱ΪĿġġԡָ֮һдĹеıԣ˵ġ֮ԡ༴ڴڵıʡ
ĳһһ޵ġڡDasein϶ԣԡǱġԣԾġǱġ
塱뾭׵Ĺԣҡִ桱׹ǵе̡һ˵ĳһ
ԳɵΪСľϣҲܳʵ츳֮ԡġΪ츳Եĳַչֻȫ
϶ڸϡΪֻһ޵ĴڡǣȻԣǰصıΪȻɶţ
ôֱһɲģν䱾֮Ե⡣ǣӵģΪ֮Իϵ¶
ˣضһС֡ԣҲšԴ桱áǡԴڡͳΪ֮šνһһ֮ν
֮Ҳ֮Ҳı塣һı׶ơġ֮ӵġ˺һѧоΪ׷
ʶϵġ桱ѧϵġơǿӵѧµĽָۣʼڡƷ֮
֮ԡڡ˵֮ȡءҲ˵ӵʼڵ¹ۣڵ¹ۡԿȻ۷治Ϊо
еĹɶоȻ󣬶Ϊȡ˵ĵʶǿһ͵Ը࣬ǴǧŵĿ
ӵĵ¸ԡнǿϢǬ󴫡塷Խ͵úܺãߣ˶֮ƣнߣν
֮ҹ˼ܶʼµУԾ֮ˡǿֹϢµǿϢģµı壨Ϊ
֮壩㲻׵ġǡеĲסͼΪ£arete㲻ġΪǾ
Ե񡣿ӵı֤塱ζϵĲı塣ǣӵ˺һѧйʷϲȻѧ
߼ѧķǵµѧ֮ѧʷѧķ
            
    ӵʷѧʷѧ۵ҪʷչҪһֱ׵Ϊ۵ȷϣcorroboration
ʷ۵ľԱ׼Ҫһֲ׵ıȷϾԵĵ¼ֵֶʲµʷѧʱ˵µǽԵģ
һȷķʽ˼ĵ±˵ʷѧǵѧһƷۢ٣ݾͿ˵Ҳ
˵֮ԣ֮֮ҲγݡʷעͣԡνǷҲ
ͽԣᣬ總ڵʱ֮¡ζţʷѧǵѧġʵѧobject-lessonԿ׹涨
ӶʶǰУ¡󴫡˵ʷѧǰ˵ĵʶǣӵʷѧΪ
ߣһֵµġʷζѧ
                                             ꣩
                            챾Դʦѧʷϵڣ
    α༭עʷѧ΢ƪר⣱ڣڣҳ
    ٣  ڸС߼룬񣱣ڣҳڣҳڣҳ
    ٣  ڸС߼ڣҳ
    ڣ  ׺ʷۺʷѧ̡̳꣬ڣҳ
    ٣  ˼˹ѡڶڣҳ
    ڣ  ˼˹ѡľڣҳ
    ٣  ˼˹ѡڣڣҳ
    ڣ  裺ѧѧ磱棬ڣҳ
    ٣  ںڸۺѧ۶Ϻľڸġѧʷ¼һ̫룬񣱣꣬ڣ
ҳ
    ڣ  ˼˹ѡڣڣҳ
    ۣ  ڸС߼ڣҳ
    ٣  ֶʲʷѧۡ䡢Ľ룬ѧ׳磬ڣҳ
    
    
    
 
